This is acid, man. Hello and welcome to ACFM, the home of the weird left. I'm Nadia Idle and I'm joined as usual by my friends Jeremy Gilbert. Hello. And Kia Milburn. Hello. And on today's special microdose, we are talking about your party. So guys, why do we want to talk about your party at this moment in time?
Well, one reason for talking about this now is we just did a main episode about the whole concept of the party, although that in itself was partly inspired by current events. And it's obviously been a massive preoccupation for people on the British left in this autumn of 2025, this process that might or might not be leading up to the successful launch of a new socialist party happening at exactly the same time that an eco-socialist has become leader of the Green Party and started attracting lots of support. And at the same time, as it looks like the right wing control of the Labour Party is sort of breaking down in terms of moral legitimacy, if not... in terms yet of institutional control and it raises all kinds of issues about things that we talked about on the main episode about the party in very immediate concrete terms to do with like well what is a political party what do we want it to do like what do we want it to be like how what do we need it for etc and we're all likely to have different levels of relationship to this new this thing that's happening that are going to be worth thinking about not just not just because we're interested in this specific phenomenon of this new left party but because these issues around now how you organize a sense of collective identity how you organize a sense of collective agency have much
bigger implications for all of us. So, I mean, that's why I think it's important to talk about, even though it's quite a localised issue that might have stopped being relevant six months later. And what do you think, Nadia? Yeah, I mean, I think that question about agency and the site for organizing is really important and one that we wanted to pick up on by looking at all of the details of what this thing is and what's happened on your party, this organization. So I think it's interesting to reflect on where perhaps we are with this. I'm not as close to this in any way as I was, I would say, first time around. Maybe we shouldn't be relating them this way. And we'll talk about this a little bit, I'm sure. But when Jeremy Corbyn first came up and Momentum was formed, et cetera, I was very, very close to the whole.
process. But I do think that it's, you know, understanding, like, again, going back to the refrain that we always talk about in ACFM about knowing, you know, situating ourselves in history. And I think we talked about this a little bit on the party's main trip episode about where the sites for, like you said, Jeremy, organizing and activity and agency are. And we've had this, you know, spell of a few years where it didn't feel like the political party was that site at all. And now this might be changing, you know, again, because again, the terrain is changing due to all sorts of different factors, which I'm sure we're going to discuss. So it's interesting to look at, you know, the
the forensics of how and why we understand your party to be set up and who are the key actors there, but also to understand the affect around it. What are the expectations that people have? And what do people expect this kind of institution to do? And perhaps what are some of its shortcomings? But of course, we're going to be interested in it because acid communism slash acid Corbynism or whatever was part of the inspiration for this podcast in the first place. Us meeting each other came out of the world transformed and momentum, et cetera. So we're definitely interested in where certain characters and certain political tendencies from that era.
themselves, not when we started this project back in 2016, 17, 18, but now in 2025, and understanding all of those different tensions, like we said, but also what we think is going to happen if we can even predict something like that. And what is the role of an initiative like your party in collecting people together and also being some kind of a force for change? But also, as I said, what are some of the shortcomings and why perhaps some of those organisational mechanisms have not done what we would have liked them to do? So those are some of the reasons why it's interesting for me to unpack this phenomenon. organisation, tendency, whatever we're going to call it, your party at this moment in time. All right, great. Well, then I think in order for us to be able to get into all that, I think Keir Stratonic should give us a rundown of exactly what has happened in the past few months that has led to this point. There's been rumours that there's a new left party about to be formed. Going back, I think probably 18 months, perhaps two years, is an idea that there should have been a new left party going back to when Jeremy Corbyn, who was previously the leader of the Labour Party, when he was expelled from the Labour Party for nothing as part of a nefarious plot by the Labour right to evict everybody.
to the left of Genghis Khan, which they succeeded at doing. And at that point, there just seemed to be a huge political space, definitely a huge electoral space on the left in the UK. Then in July, I think it was, Zahra Sultana, who was a Labour MP, Labour MP for Coventry, one of the Coventry constituencies, announced that she was leaving a Labour party to form a new party with Jeremy Corbyn. And so she announced that they would be co-leading the foundation of this organisation. Now, that announcement was deeply disputed. Jeremy Corbyn didn't tweet to say, yes, that is what's happening. And it seems as though Zahra Sultana had basically decided to push the matter because there was a lot of dithering about the party and decided to make that announcement off her own. And that caused quite a bit of bad blood, I think. There's an organisation called Collective who are formed around Jeremy Corbyn. And they include people who were around Jeremy Corbyn when he was a leader of the Labour Party. So they call it Lotto, leader of the opposition. People such as Carrie Murphy, for instance, who's a figure.
featured prominently in the gossip around this. But like quite a wide range of people got drawn together around this into an organizing committee. We don't know who they are because it's all secrets. And that's been a really big problem. It's all secret. And so we've had to, basically gossip has been the currency of the last few months where people are trying to work out what's going on. Nobody's making many announcements. It's all going on behind closed doors. And, you know, you're basically doing criminology to try to work out what's going on. Really, it has been a really big problem. So that means that gossip is the currency of the time. And the medium through which that gossip is primarily dispersed is social media with all of the...
problems that that brings we'll get on to later so anyway quite a big broad organizing committee was drawn including people from social movements lots of people from the left were invited onto it you know you have to be invited there's no way you could democratically be elected onto it you get invited onto it and that organizing committee made a decision um a couple of months ago I can't quite remember what the decision is. I think they voted that there should be co-leaders of your party, at least up until the foundation of the founding conference. Jeremy Corbyn and people around him didn't like that. So they dissolved the organizing committee and formed a new one. So you can see there's been all sorts of tension and the gossip comes out about, oh, such and such has said this about this, such and such. A lot of bad feeling and like a collapse of trust, I think you put it that way. Nonetheless, there seemed to be a process in train towards a founding conference. Now, I've missed out the most important thing. When Zahra Sultana announced that this party was going to be formed,
a huge amount of people signed up. We think 800,000 people signed up to register their interest in this new party. And it was that number that really, really did open people's eyes and think, oh, hang on a minute, something could happen here. There was a couple of polls. One poll said that your party could be standing at something like 12% in the polls.
which is really significant, et cetera. Your party and the Greens together. At one point, there was one poll that showed them on 30%. People's eyes thought, oh, something really could happen here. And so there was a process where they were going to announce the membership. There were going to be a series of regional assemblies leading up to a conference. And the conference was going to be people organized by sortition, which is like a jury. If you're eligible, you go into a lottery system and your name gets drawn and then you can go to the conference. The idea of that would be that if there really were 800,000, or even if there were 500,000 people, you could not fit those people into a conference. That would be chaotic.
There are no official branches because there is no official membership. So there's no way you can have a delegate system. So it was an incredibly difficult process they're trying to do. Then a couple of weeks ago, perhaps three weeks ago, Zara Sultana announced and opened a membership portal. you know i saw that membership portal open i said oh that's great 20 000 people signed up in the first hour i was just in fact i think i was going to do a podcast interview but right i'll join that as soon as i come off this podcast interviewers had my 55 pounds for a year membership all lined up by the time i'd come off that podcast interview an hour and a half later it all collapsed basically the collective people around jeremy corbyn had denounced the announcement of this membership portal saying it's fraud and saying people should not sign up to it there was a huge back and forth zara sultana threatened legal action etc an absolute what's known colloquially in english as a shit show of unholy proportions that caused incredible confusion. And there's been no membership figures announced since that point. So 20,000 in the first hour, you would think that would head to some really, really large number, basically. My best guess is I think it's probably about 50,000 membership now. I actually did join a week and a half later. But whereas I was just about to join with incredible enthusiasm, I joined with real resentment and bitterness to both Jeremy Corbyn.
and Zahra Sultan and the people around both of them. And I think that may well be quite a common sort of affect. You start in this, not with this wave of enthusiasm, which is going to roll across the country and get 803,000 people signed up. Instead, much smaller numbers have signed up. Nonetheless, there was a political festival called The World Transformed, at which me and Jeremy did a very good ACFM workshop, actually. Nadia couldn't join us this year. And at that, Zahra Sultan and Jeremy Corbyn, and at a rally before, they sort of did a big public making up. They held hands across the ocean, that sort of thing.
They've announced these assemblies. The first assembly took place in Norwich on Sunday, as we record this on the 23rd of October. And there are more assemblies around the country. And that is leading up to a conference in Liverpool on November the 29th, 30th, or something around then. Have I missed bits of the story? I'm sure we can fill it in as we go through, because we need to examine lots of this based on what's going on. No, not really. I just say if people want the detailed accounts.
There are basically two articles that everyone on the British left is referring to in all these discussions. There was a relatively short article by Andrew Murray in the Morning Star on their website. And there's a very long article on a website called Prometheus by Archie Woodrow. And to the best of my knowledge, I mean, I know a few of the people involved and those are both completely accurate accounts. So I think, you know, Archie's been on podcasts and stuff. So you might find an interview with Archie Woodrow if you want an audio version of a more detailed account. But yeah, I don't think you've missed out anything. If people want more detail, other sources are available.
I was just going to say that we're going to try and be even-handed and not go on one side or the other of this dispute. But we need to set out the basic parameters of what's going on. And then we can perhaps grow back a bit and think about it in a little bit wider terms. Rather, we can move away from the political gossip, which, as I say, has been the currency of the moment. And when politics is done through political gossip, you basically miss the bigger picture, I think. And that's what we might try and provide today. What I'd like to get into a bit more, then, is what's been happening, not just at the level of these specific people relating to each other offline or online and everybody else standing around watching.
But in terms of how the kind of broader currents of feeling have been flowing around, the kind of amorphous thing, you might call the British left. I mean, really, it's the Anglo-Welsh left, because people in Scotland mostly don't care, I think. And we are really talking about a set of relationships, which I would say are sort of, you know, 30% at most face-to-face, like people talking to each other, and they are 70% like social media, including WhatsApp groups, people chatting about all this stuff from the moment it first started to emerge. And my account would be, indeed, there was a lot of anticipation, I would say a degree of impatience. really for several years, because really from the moment Jeremy Corbyn left, formally left the Labour Party, even I would say before Jeremy left the party, actually for quite a long time before he left the Labour Party, from the moment it became clear that Jeremy did not have any intention of trying to lead his supporters in a kind of assault against the right-wing bureaucrats who were expelling him within the Labour Party, lots of people started to say, well, if he's not going to do that, then what he ought to do is organise the people who are leaving the party supporting him and people who've already left.
in order to create a kind of potent collectivity, as I would call them, out of these people who are kind of being driven out of the party. So there's been a lot of anticipation for quite a long time. People are getting quite impatient. And then what happened, I mean, actually what happened was Zahra Sultana, who had had the whip withdrawn with a bunch of other Labour MPs for opposing party policy, party welfare policy, technically, although it was widely assumed it was really because of a militancy over Palestine. She made this announcement that actually it was going to happen, and she announced she was leaving Labour on the same day, in the same Twitter post, that she announced she would be coding a new party with Jeremy. So she kind of did these things all at the same time. People got very excited, and the fact that 800,000 people signed up to this email list was very exciting. Obviously, there was also a considerable amount of trepidation, because everybody knew that, well, 800,000 people on an email list doesn't necessarily mean 800,000 people are going to join a thing. I mean, anyone can join the email list. A lot of those people will have been in Brooklyn, DSA, and not eligible to join a British political party, etc., etc.
No, we didn't. But there was all this excitement. And then the spectacle of the kind of spat between Jeremy and Zara, the kind of evident disagreement really over who really was in charge of this project, who was really going to lead it, how it was all going to work. This caused an awful lot of anxiety. People have been really, really unhappy about it. And I think the situation right now is that broadly speaking, although there has been an attempted reconciliation.
I think my sense is, especially my sense is after the World Transform Festival a couple of weeks ago, broadly speaking, people are still quite disappointed by the whole process. There's a feeling that it looks like the process of founding the party is not proceeding in as democratic a way as people would have hoped, that mostly what is happening is that the group of people involved in the networks Keir was describing who mostly want this to be a sort of vehicle for Jeremy Corbyn's leadership rather than a vehicle for mass participatory democracy, those people seem to be really controlling the situation. And at the same time, as all this is happening, the Green Party, with Zach Palantzky as leader, has attracted, has doubled its membership, like, in the past few weeks. So what's definitely clearly happened is that quite a large number of other people, about 70,000 people, many of whom probably signed up for that email list a few months ago for your party, have decided just to join the Green Party. And also, nobody knows how many people have joined your party. The membership has been open for weeks now. The general consensus is that the membership figures must be quite disappointing, or they would have announced them. Because they were announcing how many people had signed up for the email list every 30 minutes, basically, while that was happening. You have a bit of context for that, though, is that...
that when the membership was opened, membership process was opened by Zahra Sultana, that data and the money went one way. And when they reopened it, when the collective, the other side reopened membership for your party, that data and money went to a different place under the control of different people. And that's part of the dispute. And so apparently that data has not even been merged yet. And so that's part of the reason why they're saying they can't announce membership figures. That's true. That's true. But the issue that really emerges for me out of this whole context, really, is there is a real tension between the different things that people want.
from a political party in this context. And the way I would put this is there are two quite different things that people want. Some people want both of these things, and some people really only want one of these things. And the two things are, on the one hand, an opportunity to get involved in a really democratic process with a load of other people who broadly share your worldview, to build solidarity, to build a kind of democratic community of agency, and go out into the wider community to try to win people over to a socialist programme and build a participatory mass movement. And then the other thing that people want is they want there to be a guy on the TV who says stuff they agree with a lot.
And that sounds dismissive, but I don't mean it to be dismissive. I mean, that is a really important thing that people want. It's a very important part of contemporary mass politics. In fact, it's always been an important part of mass politics. I keep hearing people talk about this, like this is only a thing that's happened now in the age of social media or TV. I mean, it's not. I mean, democratic politics in Republican Rome was mostly about some guy from the ruling class persuading the people of the city that he represented their interest and getting them to vote for him. So that is not a new thing, the idea that part of what people want is a guy who says stuff they agree with. Can I add a third?
So I think there might be a third thing that people want, actually, which is kind of related to your second and possibly related to the first, but it's a bit of a Venn diagram thing here, which is that I think there's a constituency of people that want someone who's going to get things done in the same cadence of... you know, take back control or whatever. It doesn't necessarily mean that it's in any way racist. But I think one of the things that people observe is that there is a democratic deficit under late capitalism. And whether they're necessarily conscious of it in this form or not, I definitely think there is a sizable number of people who think, and these might be the people who are, you know, controlling your party. Again, I don't know. It seems to be quite opaque, but who think that actually democracy...
and action at this moment in the political history are in tension. And actually, if you want to oppose, you know, all of the, or you want to take a contradictory position and contradictory actions and put yourself in conflict with late capitalism, what you actually need is more of a dictator. So I'm not saying that people think they want a dictator in the UK, not consciously on that level. But what I'm trying to allude to here is there's also this yearning for action, which is not stifled by late capitalism. And there's also this sense, I would say, is that by opening all of these democratic structures and doing things in participatory democracy, that might be great for the affect. It might be great to make people feel they belong and less atomized. But is it really going to make people's lives better? Or is it going to create any meaningful policy which can be enacted, which is going to kind of stop this train running down to even more crime?
crisis after crisis after crisis. Like what is the thing, what is the actor which is going to put a stop to some of the processes which are bringing about climate change and ever more kind of distraction, not of the planet, but also of society. So I'd say that that tendency also exists as well and might be coming into tension with this idea of open participatory, long-ended processes. Yeah, you're right. I mean, they're all democratic desires. They're different manifestations of a kind of democratic desire. To respond to Nadia's point, I mean, we should provide a little even more context, which people from the UK probably know, but listeners from outside the UK might not be fully aware.
There's a wider context here, which is there's an incredible anti-systemic feeling in the UK and most other places as well, basically. And that primary representation of that is a shift to the far right over the last 18 months. So Reform, who are a far-right party, are currently on 30% in the polls, but because of first-past-the-post, because of the political system, that would give them an incredible number of seats, probably a controlling number of seats. The last 15 years have just been incredibly, have just had incredible political volatility, basically. Like, you're just incredible. You know, with Jeremy Corbyn being leader of the Labour Party, you know, achieving 40% in an election and polling even higher than that after 2017, you know, figures that any political party in the UK could only imagine these days. The Labour Party got elected on something like 33% of the vote under Keir Starmer in the last election. They're incredibly like...
pretty much unprecedentedly unpopular. A really catastrophic government so far. So that's the sort of wider context. There is a huge anti-systemic feeling. The Labour Party is just, you know, we are the system sort of thing. But I would say, Nadia, in response, I don't think that we want a man of action. I don't think that's the attraction of Jeremy Corbyn. He is not a man of action, I'm afraid. No, I didn't say that.
I didn't say it's the attraction of Jeremy, but I might think that some people around Jeremy might be thinking that in order to be able to enact any kind of meaningful, different policy or opposition, then it needs to be organised in a particular way. I'm not saying I'm sympathetic to that, but that is my analysis. Yeah, yeah. I think the identification with Jeremy Corbyn has always been that he's a moral figure, basically. He represents a moral figure, morally upstanding, who will say things that people agree with, basically, rather than an astute analyst. Integrity. Integrity. I think Jeremy Corbyn is integrity.
which is attractive. I think this is important. And I think also this connects up actually with some of the Kremlinology around the pre-formation of your party. Because indeed, I mean, if you were to do a kind of proper analysis of the whole phenomenon of Corbynism from 2015, you would have to say, I mean, we have said on the show before, I think, that of course, like any mass phenomenon, it has various components and there are various groups of people with various kinds of relationships to the overall project. And, you know, there was a constituency of people that we all sort of belong to who understood Corbyn's leadership of the Labour Party basically as a political opportunity.
to build a sort of social majority for some radical reform program and probably and to try to occupy the Labour Party as an institutional vehicle for that you know Corbyn himself well exactly what the relationship of Corbyn himself as an individual to that was always complicated like at the most extreme it was incidental and there were lots of people who didn't even think he was really the best person for the job on the other hand there were a lot of people who felt that well only he could really sort of do the job of rallying the broad left partly because he was a figure he was very widely trusted like across different sections of the left and the peace movement etc because he was this very moral figure because he was very he is you know very decent guy who you know is famously not very ambitious or egotistical and then but there were also people who really their conception of things wasn't really at the level of you know even it's jeremy's moral personality is going to open up a possibility for a broad coalition it was simpler than that really it was like this guy says the stuff i agree with and i think that i've been thinking for years i haven't heard a main politician on the teddy say for decades and i like him and i trust him because he seems like a guy you can trust who's not full of shit and
That latter constituency, who were very much really sort of personally identified with Corbyn, I would say they made up a large portion of the number of people who joined the Labour Party, but they didn't join Momentum, and they didn't go to meetings, they might have gone to some rallies, and they were always a really important part of the overall mass of people who joined the Labour, and more importantly, they were an even bigger part of the mass of people who voted Labour in 2017 and didn't even join the Labour Party. So they are a really important constituency, but I would say... I would say there certainly is a group of people very close to Corbyn. They're a group of some of his closest advisors and some of the most influential people, both when he was leader of the Labour Party and people who now seem to have become very influential in determining outcomes around how a new party is going to be organised. And I think the most logical, they will never come out and say this explicitly because it would be really objectionable to most people on the left to say this.
But I think the most logical understanding of their behaviour and the things they've been for and against in terms of political strategy for the past 10 years is they really think that is the central element of the whole project. The central element of the whole project is the idea that if you put Jeremy Corbyn on the telly a lot, there's a whole bunch of people who will like him and will sort of flock to support him and will go to him and speak at rallies. And that is the nature of the mass movement that you want. And everything else that some people want, like they want participating in democracy, they want even Jeremy to be accountable to a mass membership, they want community organising in their communities, they want capacity building at the level of political branches, all that stuff is sort of bullshit, really. It might be nice to happen.
sometimes but it's not really very important the important thing is jeremy jeremy jeremy and making jeremy the center of everything and giving that large that fairly large constituency of people whose main relationship to politics is the fact of them liking jeremy corbyn an opportunity to express that through joining a thing giving it some money and having it stand in elections in a way that is obviously a manifestation of what paulo gabaldo calls the phenomenon of the hyper leader in the modern sphere of digital platform-enabled party politics. I think it's important to understand, as I've already said, it's not at all new. It's arguably the default form that popular politics has taken for thousands of years, actually. I want to reserve a complete judgment, mostly because I've not been very involved at all. Unlike last time, Corbyn was the centre of a thing. I don't even know if I'm going to call it a party or a movement. However, having read up some of the accounts that you guys mentioned at the beginning on...
kind of what's been going on and the very good rundown that Kia gave us, like knowing that information and contrasting that reality with the kind of language in the emails and the communication, it's hard to think that that's not true effectively. Like I'm holding back on saying that is definitely the thinking behind it, what you've just articulated, Jeremy, but it sounds like it is, you know, that basically... The two bits don't match up. The participatory democracy is not actually the end point of this project, although it says that it is. And I think that is the problem that I'm having, is that it effectively sounds like, for those of us who do know some things about the ins and outs of what is happening, as Keir gave that rundown, it does make you quite cynical. And that's unfortunate, and it might have quite a knock-on effect for the future if people think that this thing around Jeremy Corbyn is not what it says it is.
I mean, it's interesting because actually the publicity around your party coming out of official your party accounts, which has not been much and quite slender, but that really has lent very hard on the idea that, you know, we've got, we're using regional assemblies to feed into the constitution. We're forming a party out of nothing where, you know, we're using sortition and these innovative methods, et cetera. This is going to be the most democratic party ever. So they're really leaning heavily on that. Even if there's, you know, among some people, there's a little bit of, there is some cynicism about, well, perhaps actually sortition is the thing you need in order to keep a demobilized.
mass, basically, who are manipulable by the views of the hyper-leader. That's one of the things that Paolo Gabaldo sort of talks about when he, in his books about this, is that perhaps what's new or what's different between this, because we have seen these growth of very large parties very suddenly around the world, quite often got sort of populist parties on the left, right, and centre, and part of what distinguishes that from mass parties of the 20th century. is that you have a hyper-leader, then you have a mobilisable mass, but you don't have the sort of cadre, the interlinking layers, the cadre and the branches, et cetera, who feed into it in a sort of democratic manner. So you don't have the ability to have a democratic party, basically. No, and that tension, the tension around what should be the role of the activists in the party, I mean, that's not at all specific to this situation. I mean, it's something that's been an issue in the history of the Labour Party for the past hundred years. It's something that's always an issue because you have this complicated situation whereby...
on the one hand, you think spontaneously, like any socialist, any Democrat should say, yes, like the party leadership and the professional politicians, the elected politicians must be directly accountable to the membership. That's democracy. But then you get into this situation where the party leaders, the professional politicians, the people who've been elected to public office, they start saying to themselves, well, the thing is, the kind of people who are members of the party, they're not really typical of the public. They're not even typical of the section of the public who vote for us. And really, it's those people we should be representing. And then they start constructing these justifications for really just carving out the members, not really saying to the members, well, you shouldn't really have any saying or anything because...
the relationship that matters is the relationship between the leadership the legislative the elected legislators and the voters and the party membership should really just help those people get elected or shut up and go away and they think they have a democratic argument for saying that and sometimes you can say sometimes they might be right sometimes it might be true that the internal culture of the activists in the party has become so divergent from the culture of even the voter base that it becomes toxic for the party and this isn't just a problem on the left i mean this is what this is what's happened repeatedly to the conservative party in the 21st century they've they've tended to elect leaders who reflect the prejudices and concerns of their members and they're very divergent even from most Tory voters you know and they end up alienating loads of their voters so it's a very complicated dynamic and it's not unique it's not specific to the moment of social media platforms at all actually i think it's a it's a it's a problematic that's built into the whole nature of representative politics actually like the only way to get away from this is to move completely away from the whole notion of a sort of representative political system towards some more permanently participatory system which of course is something that radical socialists anarchists even some sort of radical democrats coming from a liberal tradition have wanted to do like for 120 years as long as you're within a basically representative political system you've got this problem that isn't going to go away
Yeah, and you have this issue of the mass and where people see themselves in relation to that. And I think that's an interesting question to think about, about whether if these assemblies... could be successful in allowing people, which is maybe one of the things that people are looking for, I mean, I feel like something we're all looking for, this kind of form of collectivity and solidarity, where people are able to see themselves as some part of something bigger so that they're able to identify and perhaps like join and get involved. Because if we're talking about participatory democracy on a kind of ground level, people have to have some kind of identification there, even to get to the point of some kind of agency, right? And I feel like we're living in an age of diversification of identity and thought, you know? And so I think that's interesting, like how, as late capitalism develops, like how it affects the terrain for that kind of even low-level organizing.
Just to go back to the example of the Conservative Party of being taken over by its members and going to the extremes, et cetera, et cetera. Because we could point to the Labour Party, the current leadership of the Labour Party is the opposite of that. That is where a political media elite, incredibly small, very isolated, have basically seized control of a political party and they are enacting the policies that seem common sense to this tiny, tiny political media elite. Yes, totally, yeah. And as it turns out...
they do not speak for the wider voters. Everybody utterly hates them, and their policies are completely at odds with the wider population. Yeah, totally. And we'll get into all the Labour Party stuff next to Microdose after this one, so we don't want to dwell on it too much. Yeah, you're totally right. And of course, I mean, the epistemological crisis from which the entire British political class, including, but not limited to, the Labour right, have still not recovered, was the discovery in 2017 that their long-held belief that what it meant to represent the public...
was to persist in the assertion that no form of meaningful social democratic reform would ever be possible again. That just wasn't true. It wasn't true that what the activists in the party wanted, which was basically a platform saying, look, we're going to start reversing the whole Factor Eye programme, was really unpopular. The fact that that turned out to be really popular was a complete shock to them. And they just became insane, really, and are still insane on that basis. I mean, right now at the time of recording, we're recording on 23 October 2025.
And there's a lot of ambivalence around the actual process of the formation of the party because the general consensus, I think for reasons we'll get into in more detail in a minute, is that people are not happy with the way in which the foundation process is going forward and they feel that it isn't democratic and it isn't being rolled out in a way which is actually going to facilitate participatory democracy. But as you said, the most recent publicity encouraging people to join has been like incredible. It's this fantastic animation by Andy Redwood, I think is the name of the guy who made it, which you can find if you search for your party, at least on Twitter, but presumably on Instagram, YouTube and TikTok as well. It's fantastic. It's a beautiful sort of animation, which basically tries to express visually the idea that this is going to be a completely collaborative process. And it's like, it's a visual expression of the whole idea of democracy is manifesting the inherent and beautiful complexity of the collective. Like it's just fantastic. Like if that was the only thing going on, I'd probably just join on principle.
just on the basis of that really fantastic bit of film. But it's true of acid communism. But the reality on the ground, of course, is that people generally feel that the process is not going forward in a way which actually reflects those ideals. Perhaps one place to go would be to look a little bit more into this idea of a hyper-leader and then a mobilisable mask. I know, Jeremy, you've been saying that that political identification of a leader has always been part of politics. It absolutely has. But perhaps one of the things that's changed is the reliance on digital platforms as the main medium through which this takes place. It's that that allows this really, really rapid mobilisation without any intermediate layers. And we should just think a little bit more about the central role that these social media platforms have played.
And not just in sort of like, you know, pulling these masks together, but also it is the medium through which the party has been discussed primarily at the moment. Like the role that social media platforms play, like their algorithms are set up to be antagonistic, to spread outrage, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Increasingly, you know, they're owned by far-right oligarchs who are putting the thumb on the scale all the time to try to push, you know, to try to eliminate certain voices and accelerate other voices. It's one of the really big problems that we face, the effects of social media, because there's no out to it. You know, there doesn't seem to be an out to that. It has to be a part of politics, you know. And I think part of the attraction of the idea that we could...
mass democratic mechanisms and then do things such as, you know, go out into the community and do community organizing and build up social infrastructure and these sorts of things would be a way in which you would do this thing where you move from one of these, what Gabaudo, Paulo Gabaudo calls a movement party or a network party, you know, formed to some degree through political identification and to some degree via the social media platform, a way to then shift that, go around the outside of that, try to build something else up, which doesn't rely so much on social media. Is that possible? I just don't know. We don't know if that is actually possible to do or to what extent that's possible to do. No, we don't know. And I think...
I think it's worth observing here that, to some extent, the tensions between the different groupings and factions within the new party, they have, I think, actually been, they're partly manifestations of different implicit assumptions about how you can use or should use new and old means of organisation and collective expression, etc., to do some sort of political organisation. I mean, I would say, I mean, maybe this is just me, maybe it's just in my sort of little bubble, my personal world, but the general impression and the initial stages of the process was that Zahra Soltana, the young woman of colour, kind of dynamic voice for a socialist anti-imperialism in the public sphere, was really desperately trying to get the notoriously slow, indecisive Jeremy Corbyn to actually do a thing and do the thing that people wanted and to launch this mass party. And that the idea of them campaigning together was very inspiring. I think it's not at all an accident. This was all happening like a few months after.
Bernie and AOC had done their very well publicised tour of rallies in the States. And the imagery was very, very similar. It was very similar. It's like a young woman who isn't white, touring with the boomer left hero of the left in that country. And it seemed like, I mean, I think Bernie is quite clearly trying to position AOC as his natural successor, because he knows he can't really do another presidential run, et cetera. And it's a very good way of doing politics. And everybody sort of assumed, I definitely did, of course, that's the strategy that Jeremy is borrowing. And it's a good strategy. And that should be what happens.
And then it all sort of fell apart. And it was quite disconcerting when this all started to fall apart. And you know, like, actually, that wasn't what was happening. And Jeremy really wasn't into anointing Zara as his successor, but wanted to be the actual leader of this thing. But then I started thinking to myself, well, is Zara really like an equivalent figure to AOC? Because, I mean, really, if you start asking yourself, like, where has Zara come from? Like, what is her actual public role? And I started to think, well, really, she's been an MP like since 2019. Before that, she wasn't even like a local councillor. She wasn't a union leader. She came out of student politics in the Labour youth wing, like very young.
And mostly what she's done is she got amassed a huge following on TikTok and Instagram, partly because she got a load of profile in women's magazines when she first got elected, because she's very young. It was novel to have such a very young woman MP elected, and she's quite photogenic. And she has used that platform, certainly, to take position, which everyone is really glad to have someone in public taking, especially around issues like Palestine. But for the most part, that position taking, well, what has it involved? It's mostly what it's involved is posting. It's mostly what it's involved is posting on her massive social media platform. And there is a certain sense in which...
Zahra Sultana's main role as a political figure in British public life has been as a poster, as a social media poster, a very successful one, one who gets lots of follows and likes, one who everyone is happy to be there. And you can understand why, from that point of view, people who are coming really out of the left wing of the British Labour movement, the trade union movement, like Jeremy Corbyn, like Carrie Murphy, he's sort of the key figure who is widely blamed by people on the broader left for being responsible for this kind of centralising and top-down tendency around Jeremy, both when he was leader of the opposition and now. You can see why people like that, who've been active in the British labour movement for decades, would not really have that much time for this. Because, you know, particularly in the trade union movement in Britain, there is a real historical culture of seniority. The idea that you earn authority on the basis of having been around for a long time and having learned a load of stuff and having done a load of stuff. That's true both at the level of the workplace, actually. It's a classic.
labor union trade union principle that people get paid more as they get older that's the basic principle of seniority and that was always seen as an important thing to win for trade unionists on the basis that well the alternative was people being rewarded for you know for you know being favorites of the boss and that wasn't the thing that you wanted seniority is not a bad principle it's not a bad rule of thumb you know, to have in any organisation, the idea that the people with the most experience are probably the people who know most of what's going on. It's not always true. And of course, the culture of seniority can shade into sort of gerontocracy. But I also think that the general feeling in the country now, which is completely justified, which is something Kir has obviously helped us understand a lot with his work on generational politics and political generations, not generational politics really, has, you know, the general feeling that part of the problem with this country and the United States is that we are, we have become this gerontocracy in which everything is done for and in the interest of retired people who own their homes and our pensions and against everybody else's interest.
that feeling, it can shade a bit too far into a complete ignorance and dismissal of that historical culture of seniority, and maybe taking a bit too seriously the idea that, well, because someone's got a massive following on TikTok, that makes them an important person and a political leader. So there's this real, there is this tension between those ideas of just what constitutes authority and legitimacy. I mean, to be clear, like my position is, yeah, it is, it may be actually a bit silly and regrettable that you become a big star these days because you get loads of followers on TikTok, but that is where we are. Pessimism of the intellect tells me that is where we are. And whether she's, whether we think she's earned it the old way or not, like Zara Soltana is a leading figure on the British left.
And that's why it really would have been better if everybody had just sort of accepted that and gone along with it, whatever the limitations of it. But I think it's also important to understand that there are reasons other than just sort of greed for power that might make some of the people around Corbyn, who are mostly we're talking about people in their 60s, who have been active on a daily basis since their teens, they might be looking at someone in their early 30s who's got a big Instagram following and saying, well, no, not really. You're not really as important. Could I use this opportunity just to renounce my work on critical generations? I think this idea of seniority is actually...
It's something to be embraced, I think, because I am a year older than Jeremy, so I'm the senior podcaster here. And I would like a little bit more respect, please. A little bit of genuflecting from my younger, less experienced colleagues. I defer to you, comrade. You can both defer to me, even though I'm considering myself Generation X, even though I'm just on the cusp of millennial, I suppose. But seriously, what we've just talked about is actually really interesting and really important. And I think, again, this would bring us back to, I wouldn't say, ACFM ruled the universe, but we are talking about democracy here, so let me phrase it a different way.
I think one of our ideal situations would be a kind of a happy medium where we understand that what older comrades or comrades who have given so much time in the movement, like you're saying, Jeremy, since they're teens, et cetera, what these people have is institutional memory, right? And that institutional memory either might live within organizations or networks, or it might exist within their own heads and ways of doing things, right? And that that is valuable because we come back to this over and over and over again. And this fact that there's a lot of very young, enthusiastic... people who are heavily involved in all sorts of stuff, of which I definitely have a lot to learn from and we have a lot to learn from. But there is a very much in this era of the last 15 years, we've seen several times the reinvention of the wheel, reinvention of the wheel in the way that as we've discussed several times before, there is an importance of understanding what came before us and why it was done and why it should or not be done differently. And I think this is something that I wanted to mention at the top of the show is that
one of the important concepts to think about here is trust and why there isn't necessarily trust between these two sets of stakeholders. I don't use that word. I'd quite like to find a different one, but constituencies rather, right? You've got to use it. You've got to use it. I've been using it. You can't avoid it. I hate it, but it's the best word for it. Thank you, Jeremy. I needed that provision. Right. So, you know, there are these two groups of people. There's, of course, many more. Okay. It's not that homogeneous.
But there is this suspicion between a culture of doing things, between very young activists and those that are with a trade union background, et cetera, that perhaps Jeremy has surrounded himself by. And I think it's that culture clash, in a way, that in many senses stops their being able to be a... I don't want to say culture of trust, but rather like an operational trust and being able to move forward through these kind of muddied waters and create functional institutions for us to be able to not just create participatory democracy, but be able to affect state, have some kind of relationship with state power, I think. So this is why a discussion around what is happening around your party now is really interesting. It forces us to unpack all of these different phenomenon and tendencies. I mean, just to push back a little bit on that, it's not really a pushback, I sort of agree with you, but just to push in the other direction for a moment, we might argue this, right? The Carrie Murphys of this world, perhaps they've learned a lesson.
they've learned like strong lessons but like they're in a different context or in a different arena and those lessons don't apply anymore and to be specific i mean people who come up to political consciousness inside the labour party in like incredible factional fights against the labour right and the labour right like are not just normal political actors they are the most factional the most immoral actors perhaps in world politics i don't know slightly big claim but i think i could probably stand that up and so that like this is this backroom maneuvering this obsession with secrecy the obsession with control to prevent other factions from having an influence etc And the obsession with disenfranchising the membership. They literally think, they will explicitly say this, that if you haven't basically got your membership to do something they didn't actually want to do, you've failed. You're not doing your job. Yeah, it's like that fear of the membership and distrust of the membership, basically. They hate the membership. They don't want to grow the party. They do not want to grow the party. This is the Labour right we're talking about. They've always been. This isn't just Corbyn. They were like this. When I first started to meet these people at the beginning of the 90s, and they really take the... We'll talk about this more next time. Yeah, yeah. Let's hold back from that. But I'm just saying that perhaps... That's one of the fears from the other side, is that like...
These people have learned their politics in an incredibly hostile environment. Now they're enacting those politics in an environment that doesn't have to be so hostile, in which you could actually build up trust from the membership. You know what I mean? And that is almost like you do learn lessons when you've been involved, when you're a veteran, a political veteran, but you might learn the wrong lessons and it might not be, you know, it's a bit like that. One of the nicest analogies of the role of a political veteran in new movements is taken from somebody I can't remember. Isabel Stengers has this metaphor of a movement or a party being a boat on the river.
And she says, look, the role of the veteran should not be driving. You shouldn't be driving the boat. Instead, you should be at the front of the boat saying, look, I've never been in this river before, but I've been in rivers before. So I know when there's an eddy over there, it's probably a rock. So let's see her this way.
But like, basically, you're not in charge of the boat because, you know, somebody else needs to be, basically. That's a great metaphor. Good old Isabel Payne. We should bring her in more. It's a great metaphor. And I agree with you, Kia. I don't think that contradicts what I said at all. I think it's just rather that we're coming at this from different angles of analysis, right? Because this is the state of play. Like, this is the situation we're in. And my question is, like, what is going to create that trust for us to be able to build that institutions? What is going to allow people to put a little bit of their guard down? And I think under the current conditions and what's happened to the country over the last 15 years, it's really difficult.
Basically, this is an incredible difficult task that they got faced with, everybody got faced with. This prospect of like 800,000 people signing up and then creating a party almost out of nothing. I don't think it was completely out of nothing, but basically there's no structures there, there's no branches. So, you know, there's nothing to hang it around apart from the attraction of these two, Zahra Sultan and Jeremy Corbyn, and this sort of pent up desire for some vehicle for political action. You know, that's incredibly hard thing to do. And so it's probably worth thinking about whether there's any precedence for this. I was having to think about that and I was thinking, well, there have been something that looks a little bit similar.
So the Spanish party Podemos was formed with a very small group of people who worked in a politics department in Madrid. And they had this idea, and they had a very clear idea of populism, basically. In fact, very influenced by Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe and their ideas of populism, trying to put them into practice. But what they did, they grew that party incredibly quickly, and they did it by forming, they called it circles, basically. So the context for that was on the back of a huge movement, the 15M movement in Spain.
in which huge amounts of the population, I can't remember what the proportion was, but an incredibly large number of population had been on demonstrations or they'd gone to one of these occupations of the squares or deliberated, et cetera, for days and days on end. So there was this participative feeling in the country. But they managed to grow this party very, very quickly. And at the same time or just after, there was the formation of what was known as the Citizens' Assembly. So these were to contest municipal elections. And they formed incredibly quickly. And actually, they formed in a couple of months. And then they took over six out of the seven largest cities in Spain.
with varying degrees of success. Barcelona on Comma were the most famous example, etc. Hello, this is Keir from the Future here, just time travelling back to correct myself. I keep talking about citizens' assemblies here, but what I really mean is citizens' platforms, which are a slightly different thing. So that was an example of, particularly the second example, a citizens assembly example, that was an example of huge participation because the idea was you'd get people to discuss what they wanted, they would form a political program, a political platform, and that platform would be the basis upon which people would be elected. All done over a couple of months, very successful at least at first, but eventually that wave was rolled back and even Barcelona and Coma were in charge of Barcelona for something like 12 years, I think, are out of office now. So there are some precedents when you look abroad.
but drawn on different sort of political histories and a different context, et cetera. I mean, the other ones we could talk about is momentum, which you two could talk about. And then there's the enough is enough. campaign if you remember that from 2002 and once again that 2022 don't you mean i do mean 2022 sorry 20 years what's 20 years when you get to my level of seniority 20 years means nothing but that was that was a similar sort of thing where very large numbers at five to six five to six seven hundred thousand people signed up to it really very like five demands basically but really just like wage rises lowering electricity bills and so forth but in a way that was another that was a previous failed attempt to perform a political force from this sort of dynamic of huge numbers of people signing up to something really quickly. And then enough is enough. In the end, all that happened was a series of rallies around the country and then nothing. It was a real dropping of the ball, basically. And as far as I understand it, the people who initiated that, some around the Magazine Tribune and then some leaders of the more radical unions, et cetera, there was just this inability to let go of the process and to allow local groups to form. And so it basically went to nothing, as far as I understand. But momentum as well might be something to discuss in terms of something, a process a little bit like this. Well, it feels to me like the process is very similar.
to the process of forming momentum, maybe more than Podemos. Podemos, as you say, really was ex nihilo. I mean, it was like an experiment by a bunch of guys in the political science department. And I don't think they made any use of prior existing organisations and networks, whereas that's not totally the case here for reasons we've explained. With Momentum, indeed, so Momentum was the organisation that was set up in order to support the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the Labour Party. So it was set up as an organisation for people in the Labour Party who wanted to support Corbyn's leadership. But the process by which it was initially set up was, well, it was quite complicated because basically, I mean, there was an organisation set up and it got an office and it got a little bit of money from a couple of unions and it was called Momentum and it was just...
a few guys in an office campaigning to support Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the party and it came out of his leadership campaign but of course there was a general sense that what was really needed was some sort of a mass organisation and they had this email list which had like 300,000 people in it who basically just at some point had got in touch expressing sympathy for Jeremy Corbyn's leadership of the party even before he became leader. And then in the months before Momentum was formally constituted, there were various kind of local groups sprung up, to some extent with official support and encouragement from this office, which had come out of his leadership campaign, and to some extent just sort of spontaneously. And naturally, they tended to form out of various existing networks, groups of local activists, some of whom were people in the Labour, the existing networks of the Labour left, especially people around the Labour Briefing magazine network.
Some of them, like far left and Trotskyist groups who weren't actually in the Labour Party, but were still active locally or had active relationships to communities of activists in the Labour Party. But then this was all happening before the organisation was formally constituted with the constitution, etc. And then you got to this moment when, OK, the organisation has to be actually created. People have to be given the chance to join it as members. So what happens is an email goes out to all 300,000 people on that email list. And the email is signed by Owen Jones. And it's saying, we are now launching Momentum. Click this link, join Momentum. And loads of people did. I mean, not as many as might have been hoped, frankly. I think the membership might have got up to...
close to 30,000 at some point. I can't remember now. It may never have got over 20,000. It was always a fraction of the people on that email list and the people who joined the party to support Corbyn, which is a real problem. There's a whole book to be written about why couldn't they get more people to join it and what would have happened if they did? Anyway, but then, okay, so then you have this huge aggregation of people who signed up to this thing. They've now joined this thing called Momentum, but this thing called Momentum still doesn't have an organisational structure or a constitution. So how are you going to actually make one come into existence? So an event was held, which was sort of the founding conference of Momentum.
But that founding conference of Momentum wasn't really something that was connected in any meaningful way to that mass membership of people who'd signed up online. It was basically people who were invited by the people working in the office who'd been working on the leadership campaign in an attempt to create some sort of a representative cross-section of people and groups who had been supporting Jeremy and his leadership. And, you know, I was at it because I was invited. I mean, really, I was invited because I had got to know most of the people in the Momentum office at that time and they were like me. But technically, I mean, in theory, I was there. I was there to represent the soft left. And if you don't know what the soft left means, we'll talk about that next time on the next Microdays.
And then that conference had a big set of debates about, well, what should happen now? What should the formal structure of momentum be? And one of the key areas of debate really was, well, how much should it be an online organisation which makes all its decisions online and which people join online? And how far should it be a federation of local branches which will form out of these existing informal groups that have already sprung up? At one end of that debate, you had people from Trotskyist organisations like the Alliance for Workers' Liberty, who, as well as calling for me to be expelled from the conference, were trying to argue very hard that these existing local groups that they were involved in should be the only sort of sovereign constituent body within the... Well, they should be the only elements of the sovereign constituent body of the organisation. And then you had people like me at the other end saying, look...
this is rubbish because the number of people in the total number of people represented by these informal networks of activists is probably a few hundred at very most a few thousand but you know we've got tens of thousands of people who join the organization by replying to an email from owen jones and those people need to be represented in some way and in the end you know what was worked out it was it was sort of a compromise but it was basically agreed that whatever organizational structure was set up would have to be ratified online like all of the people who had signed up for this you know it responded this email from owen would have to be given the chance to both the chance actually to put forward possible amendments to any proposed or constitution etc and to vote to finally have a vote At the end, what was established was actually more of a traditional federal structure based on local branches. I mean, I think they should have been more adventurous, allowing people to organise themselves online through interest groups if they wanted to.
but also with final say over key votes, especially the election of the people who would actually run the organisation from one month to the next, always happening online. So that all members get a chance to vote for things, which is like a reasonable outcome. It was a reasonably democratic outcome. I think there was always resentment from groups and networks who felt that they hadn't been properly represented, who accused the office of manipulating things and making it too undemocratic. Although my perception was always that there was some ground to those complaints, but mostly it was people who thought that they and their five friends who called themselves Momentum before Momentum existed, had somehow won the right to.
be permanently like the key the key group you know one of the key network part of the key network that would run the organization and i think you can say maybe similar things are happening now with your party so the real tension the real debate around your that's going on And I would say there are a couple of things going on. Lots of local groups have been set up, so pre-branches of this non-existent party, this party in formation. I would say at the most extreme end of the continuum of discontent with the centralised organisation are people who seem to think that those pre-branches have already earned for themselves some sort of democratic legitimacy that should in some way be represented in the constituent process, setting up the organisation. And I guess at the other end are people who think that the way things are actually working is totally fine. And I would probably put myself, I think, sort of in the middle. I would say,
as i said when momentum was first set up look the fact that you and a bunch of mates decided to hold a meeting and call yourself a branch of this non-existent organization means nothing i mean it's good well done well done for it's not a bad thing to do but it doesn't mean you've earned any democratic legitimacy because really that because that you haven't earned any privilege in response to people who don't happen to have a bunch of mates who hold a local meeting and who've just signed up online to join the organization they have as much democratic right as you do but on the other hand it is really really important that ultimately all of those people who signed up online should have a chance to properly participate in the democratic process to set up the organization and what and the thing that's happened is Very soon after the whole idea of your party was announced by ZARA, and then finally eventually confirmed by Jeremy, very soon after that, we were told that what the process would be, there would be some process leading up to a founding conference that would involve regional assemblies of members and or supporters that would then somehow feed up and build into a final authoritative founding conference. What exactly the relationship between those things would be was always quite unclear. There was a groundswell of support quite early for the idea that the founding conference, once it actually happens, should be chosen, as Keir said, by sortition, meaning it's basically chosen at random from members who say they want to go. And there's quite a lot of support for that. The reason for that is simply,
that well you know there's no way you could physically physically get the hundreds of thousands of people who were at that time were expected to be members like all in one room together for a founding conference and it wouldn't really be fair to have some sort of process of elections when really the organization hadn't had any chance to develop an internal culture so people would just be relying on prior fame and celebrity and networks of influence to get themselves elected and there was quite there was a lot of support for that idea and my understanding is that yeah that has been adopted as the idea But then the question then is, well, what's the relationship between the assemblies that are happening and the final conference? And what is going to be the role of the membership in relation to the wider membership of people who don't get to go to the constituency of a conference chosen by a solicitation? What is going to be their relationship to that conference and its final outcomes? The things that people are very worried about, I think are legitimate to be worried about are two things. One thing is, well, because it was declared months ago that this founding conference would definitely have to happen by the end of November this year, then those assemblies are happening.
with a very short time scale. So basically people who are members of the party or people who signed up to show interest in the party got an email like a couple of weeks ago saying, right, the regional assemblies are happening and your one is happening like probably next week or the week after. No, that's not true. It's not true? Much shorter than that. The first thing was announced, the first assembly was announced in Norwich.
It was held in Norwich last Sunday, and they had like three or four days. Yeah, that's true, but that wasn't outlier. I mean, the average was like people were given a week or two, like a couple of weeks notice, but it doesn't matter. So the one in Yorkshire has been held in Bradford. I can't go. And it's been held in November the 7th, 6th, and it was announced two days ago. So that's a little bit more time, isn't it? Yeah, but I would also say, I would say it's absurd. You can't, you don't, I mean, I've been event organising since I was 20, like on the left, and you don't organise anything with less than six weeks notice if you actually expect anyone to turn up, apart from your immediate mates who you told the day a couple of weeks before everyone else. So the suspicion that these assemblies are not being set up in a properly participatory way, and in fact, they resemble...
corporate consultation exercise in other words something designed to create the veneer of participation while actually having no effect at all that is an understandable suspicion that lots of people have and then there is an even bigger question really as to what exactly is going to be the relationship between the mass membership online the people who can go to these regional assemblies and the final conference and it's not clear at all as i understand it looks very unlikely that we are going to be in a situation in which Any member can make proposals for this founding conference, which the mass membership can then vote on if they're not at the conference. I mean, Keir, maybe you can elaborate a bit more on specifically what is being proposed now as this grows up. Yeah, so the bit that's left out there is that there have been four documents produced by the organizing committee. We are not allowed to know who they are or how they came together. But there are four documents that have been produced. One of them is like a constitution. One of them is a political platform or political statement, which is very short.
One of them is standing orders, these sorts of things, basically. And they were released like, I think they were released sort of 36 hours before the first assembly. So people were supposed to have read those, deliberated, and then thought about what they would like to change them. The form that the assemblies took, so the first one was in Norwich, it's only been one so far as we record this, was that people would be, you would go and you'd get put into a small group and you would discuss part of one of these documents. And then there'd be note takers who would take notes, et cetera. And then those notes would be fed back. They'd be put into a massive Google doc, apparently. And then there is some process which has not been revealed.
by people, undertaken by people we don't know who they are, it's not been revealed either, who will then take all of those things up and they will be used to, all of the feedback will be used to change the founding, for founding documents. And then those documents will go to this conference in Liverpool at the end of November. And once again, there'll be some sort of sortition. Each day, the thinking is there'll be 6,500 people chosen at random for the first day, a different 6,500 chosen at random for the second day. It might actually be that, in fact, there would be 6,500 chosen for the first day's morning and then 6,500 for the first day's afternoon. So it would be that sort of thing, basically. And they would also have some sort of process where they could feed into the alteration of these documents. And then there will be, after that conference, that feedback will somehow, through some sort of process which has not been announced, that will be turned into something that can be voted on. So we don't know if we'd be able to vote. Would you like option A or option B?
and you vote online for that, or whether it'll just be, do you accept or reject this constitution and political, everything altogether? We don't know whether it's going to be that. All of those have huge significance, basically. Once again, this is an incredible, difficult process to do, and there are timescales which is basically impossible to do well. That's sort of what's gone on. The other thing I would say is that there's this sort of like buildup of desire for something to happen. And so, you know, in the meantime, before this process is announced, you have the eruption of these proto-branches. There's lots of them around the country, and they're starting to be networked together. But they're just initiated, as you said, Gem, by...
But whoever initiates them shapes the initial shape of them, I think. So in some parts of the country, the Socialist Worker Party have initiated these, which is a Trotskyist group, a long-running Trotskyist group. And a well-known MI5 front organisation. Thank you, Conspiracy Gilbert. Thanks for popping in. Yeah, anyway, who have a particular way of doing things, which is very, very controlling, basically, in the history of second-up front groups, these sorts of things. And those have been very difficult processes where they're the ones who are initiating that. And it's been very difficult to get any initiative back from them because they initiated it. Other places, in Leeds, for instance, it was sort of like residual Corbynist networks, which were like remote re...
animated, basically, Facebook groups, WhatsApp groups, et cetera, to initiate a group. It's fairly well advanced, actually, you know, a steering committee has been elected, these sorts of things. I'm loosely involved in that. I've sort of joined that sort of proto-branch, et cetera. I thought the proto-branch's relationship would be to the membership when it's finally announced. We don't know, basically. We don't know how, whether they just get ignored or whether they get turned by some other process into actual branches of this party, which has not been formed yet. We don't know. But the other thing that's been formed, actually, is like...
quite a lot of sort of ecology of factions or tendencies, people are calling themselves. They've looked at this process or looked at the way the process is going and thought, there's very, very few people now, very, very few people, because lots of people walked away from the organizing committee. Lots and lots of people either walked away or basically were disinvited from that organization. It's a very small group of people doing all of this stuff. Very, very small. And lots of people are saying, well, look, we need an organized response to this. We need to do some thinking beforehand about what we want the party to look like. Otherwise, the party is just going to be a reflection of this handful of people who are at the center of this. And so an array of factions came together. I shall reveal that I'm loosely involved in one of those factions.
called Organising for Popular Power, which came together in a weekend in London with an emphasis on the idea that the party should not just have an electoral focus, but also should have like... capacity, base building, building up social infrastructure, these sorts of things. It should try to be active within local areas. It should try to have an immediate effect on what goes on in those areas without having to have an intermediation through electoral politics, through election councillors, et cetera, et cetera. I just want to be a little bit of a devil's advocate. This might be tanky nads coming in, but I'm just wondering about the whole, you know, we're talking about the whole membership being able to have the right to vote, right? But, you know, with clicktivism and stuff, isn't there the argument that if you've made no contribution to something whatsoever and you've not helped organise anything, why should people who can just like click a button have the same?
rights to vote about the future of a party or like put their idea forward compared to people who have been literally organizing people on the ground like i think there's a you know there's a fair argument there and perhaps you know especially after like in referendum gates other otherwise known as like brexit i guess i understand why there's some reticence of of of giving the same rights to a membership that perhaps have not been involved in anything ever my feeling about that is always i mean who i'm always bothered about is the people you know who do care about the issue but they've got you know they've got kids they've got jobs they're caring responsibilities they can't go to loads of meetings And I think, you know, you've got to give those people the opportunity to have a say over things to a certain extent. I mean, I would say, I mean, it is a real issue because I would say, historically, it's a potential danger for any democratic political organisation on the left or right, actually. And a century of bitter experience on the left surely shows this is a real danger quite often, that if you don't empower those people, you end up allowing the people who have the most time on their hands to take over any organisation. That is the strong argument, isn't it? That is the strong argument, yeah. Yeah, but there isn't an outside to that, though, is there? Because horizontalism didn't solve that problem.
In fact, it exacerbated that problem when it was like mass assemblies, et cetera. Whoever had the most time, whoever could last them out the most, they were the ones who had the most control. You know what I mean? It is just this huge tension. in politics and you know various political parties and organizations have tried to address it in different ways but it's like an unresolvable i mean my view is it's not it's not a massive problem really because look i mean those the people who do a lot of organizing on the ground who meet a lot of people you know they will establish relationships they will establish reputations and that will give them more weight with the membership it should do but ultimately it should be down to the membership like voting individually for things online to make final decisions and in the end if you haven't like if you're if you're like a local organizer who thinks that should give you your words more weight but you haven't managed to actually persuade enough actual members to agree with you like to win your position then then you haven't won. You haven't won the argument. I mean, that was one of the arguments around sortition actually was that so people were immediately against sortition. I thought it was an interesting idea, but it all depends on how it's done. But the argument for it would be, well, look, because it's just going to be random members of the party who signed up, who are going to be chosen, you've got to do a huge...
process of political discussion and political education. You've got to put your point across and try to persuade people of it. And so it would militate against that idea of, well, no, actually what we've got to do is join this committee and make sure all of our supporters are at this committee to pack this thing and get this past year, et cetera, et cetera. It would be an open process of deliberation of discussion. That's the sort of ideal. I don't know if it's going to work out that way. Who has access to the members? But I think that that's key because if you don't have that culture, this comes back to the cultural spaces of the left, whether it's formally, like it's assemblies or it's groups or whatever, which Jeremy rightly pointed out, a lot of people don't have time.
in this era that we're living in, you know, or capacity or headspace, you know, because of all of the fucking social reproduction and all of the other bullshit that capitalism is putting on us. Like people don't have the energy for it, like the mental energy for it. But without it, what you get is people being influenced by social media. And what is social media driven by? Algorithms, right? So in terms of forming people's opinions on things, like we have a huge, the democratic deficit is huge, but also like the debate deficit, like people being able to engage, whether cerebrally or practically in some kind of like...
considering of different opinions so i think that is part of the problem is that that is the terrain that we're working on and it makes processes like this incredibly hard to get right it does make it hard to get right and i remember these debates all going on in the early days momentum and i mean one of the one of the anxieties people had about doing too much stuff online was indeed it'll just be people with big social media profiles to get elected to stuff and at one point i sort of took the view it was it wasn't it wasn't like i definitely thought this but i thought this was a view worth entertaining that well was it really the worst thing if we ended up with like the the key people on the sort of central committee of the organization being like owen jones and asharker because at least we all know who they are like we all know how to reach them and they're sort of accountable to a public because instead what we actually did end up with momentum to be honest we ended up with these groups of local activists from various areas being elected to the national organization but mainly they were to be they were entirely groups of local activists handpicked by the people in the central office who then sort of recommended to the members that they vote for those people and they were all people like i'd never heard of you know so and most of us had never heard of so you ended up with a situation where in reality the whole you know
central coordinating group was it was really being handpicked by the people working in the office i sort of thought it would have been more democratic if like owen jones had actually been on the the central coordinating group and because you know i felt like owen was like i knew who he was and i knew i knew where he was to shout out if i disagreed with him about something or if they were doing something and i'm not saying that should be carried to its logical conclusion i'm not saying that rule by rule by social media following is the uh the form of a government we should be heading towards but there's something to that there's something to the idea that well people who already have a high level of public visibility potentially have a kind of accountability to the public as it actually constituted I don't know what you do with that observation. I don't know what you do with it. Like, I do think there is something you should do with it, which is, I think, and I think this should have happened with momentum and didn't. I think you shouldn't rule out.
the idea of the platform party, the network party, the thing that Paolo writes about, I think Keir was talking about. I think you have to find ways of making the platform online elements of organisation and party form, not the whole thing. And you have to make them work in tandem with the opportunity for people to meet each other in person and the opportunity for local branches to have both autonomy and authority. But I think on the British left, actually, we haven't been bold enough in experimenting with empowering people to use online mechanisms to coordinate themselves. I think that would be a more interesting way. Trying to find ways of doing that would be a more interesting way of dealing with this fact. It is a fact that we do all live online now. We're not going to...
stop and we maybe we should but we're not going to stop all living online so i think actually finding some way of institutionalizing actual democracy in the sphere of online you know the online where we live in there's a more interesting challenge than just sort of setting up party structures and organizational structures to pretend that isn't really happening because i think the effect of that is you just get those kind of forms of influence laid on top of these old structures in ways which end up actually being less accountable I mean, I do think you need to mitigate for both. And I do agree with the idea of having the one member, one vote. Ultimately, I do, of being able to enact democracy through online mechanisms. But I don't agree with that point about having, you know, internet left celebrities as being representatives. I'd way rather people that I've never heard of who are in like local groups somewhere than internet celebrities who have like tweets. That's my position on it. Well, I think it's a question of what's the least bad option. That probably ends up being a less bad option than just handing over control of the British left who we're in.
like you know i think he's there's where i mean part of me i'm also quite cynical i just think you look at the you look at the shit show of the your party process and you look at to be honest you look at how badly led the labour party was like from 2017 to 2019 i'd rather just let owen be the be the like benign dictator of the british left than that than that that was bad and i think this does this does speak to something actually we've danced around a little bit but we haven't really talked about yet that i know i'm sure listeners are going to want us to talk about because it's meaty stuff part of the context of the whole current perceived crisis around your party is the fact that the whole process does seem to have revealed very serious limitations and shortcomings in the capacity of either Zara or Jeremy to be these kind of leading figures on the left. To her credit, Zara has done quite well, I think, for example, publicly apologising for her part in four outs and also endorsing calls for maximal member-led democracy, things like this. None of this really alters the fact that she's 31 years old and in no sane organisation or mass movement would somebody who's 31 years old...
be like a top leading figure. It's just, that is, that is a symptom of a basically unhealthy movement. I mean, maybe that's just where we are. Maybe we're just stuck there. But to me, you know, she comes across and she comes across when she's speaking like someone who has very serious politics, is intelligent, is committed, but is really very inexperienced. And she doesn't come across, and this was always the problem with Jeremy, she doesn't come across like someone who's going to convince anyone who doesn't already agree with her. She comes across as someone who does a really good job of inspiring and firing up and making feel represented people who already agree with her. But this was always the problem with Jeremy. I remember people, I remember Owen himself actually saying at the start of the
Jeremy Corbyn leadership that one of the big risks was Jeremy had spent decades like talking to rooms full of people who already agreed with him and you saw that happen with the whole story of the Corbyn leadership was he was great at a rally and those rallies were full of people but they were all full of people who had always already agreed with Jeremy and part of the whole process of Corbynism was people realising oh actually there's like millions of people in Britain who agree with Jeremy Corbyn because we had spent the past 30 years being told by the media that there was like 10 people left in the whole country who agreed with Jeremy Corbyn so that was big but he didn't persuade people who didn't already agree with him he rallied together all the people who did And one of the things that's happening right now is people are looking at Jeremy, they're looking at Zara, they're looking at this whole process, and then they're looking at Zach Polanski, who we will talk about in a lot more detail in a couple of episodes, but he's doing a very, very good job of talking in what seemed to be a very reasonable and persuasive way in the mass media about a very radical programme and the need for a radical programme. He looks like someone who might actually win over some people who aren't already self-identified socialists, do support for a radical programme.
One doesn't want to accord too much importance to the personalities of individual leaders. On the other hand, part of the deal with being a leader rather than an organiser or a factionist or an influencer or anything else is personality does matter. And it doesn't look like your party has a convincing leadership. If we ask ourselves now, I think this is really important, especially given the situation right now when we're recording, which is an incredible situation, which is the Green Party has reached 15% in national opinion polls for the first time, apart from a weird freaky surge during the European elections in the late 80s. Zach Polanski is universally regarded as doing the thing that so many of us wanted Jeremy to do for the past 10 years and he was never really able to do, which is take on a kind of Bernie Sanders role of putting forward in public, on the telly, a basic socialist position on all issues in terms that are sort of antagonistic towards capital and are not just appealing to people's kind of sense of moral outrage at injustice. He's doing it really well and he seems to be working and he's attracted tens of thousands of people to join the party.
already he's doing he's doing all that they're going to get a few dozen seats they're going to get the low hanging fruit the 50 seats which are going to be easiest for a party to the left of labour to win in england they've already got and they are mostly they are they are quite affluent seats in cities with a lot of young professionals a lot of kind of downwindly mobile frustrated graduates and even a lot of their older colleagues who were still who were just politically quite politically sophisticated and sick of starmer them and university towns the greens have got those now you're they are not they are not available to your party now so where where might be available to your party where might your party actually be able to win some support it's going to have to go out into the posting areas. It's going to have to go out into the council estates. That is a much tougher terrain. And to win on that terrain, you have got to have a figure who is at least as good as that Polanski, a convincing, a kind of working class audience who are not really interested in ideology and they're not that interested in Palestine for the most part, that you are on their side and that you have got what it takes actually to pull together a political project which can deliver for them. And right now, as far as I can see, your party does not have a leadership and it's not even clear that it has networks that are going to be capable of bringing forward a leadership of that nature. But I don't know, what do you think about that?
It's a huge problem, the lack of development of leaders in the UK, basically. You know, Zach Lansley sort of came out of nowhere, you know, he was a Lib Dem back in 2018, I think, even still, you know. Well, he didn't come out of nowhere, did he? We'll talk about this when we talk about it. I'll give everybody my understanding of Zach as an organic intellectual when we talk about the Greens. But what I mean is that, like, there wasn't an organised process to develop leaders that he came out of. And if you want to look at what that looks like, you have to look to the US, in which both AOC and Zohan Mamdani, who's going to be the next mayor of New York, there are organisations which are looking for and developing...
leaders basically but the dsa and the justice democrats you know there are organizations which are trying to find the next leaders uh you know my worry about your party is the small group of people who currently have control of it they actively do not want to go out and find new leaders because their power their power comes from being from from their closeness to jeremy corbyn basically once jeremy corbyn goes there's no there's a reason the nearest we've got out of the whole experience of corbynism to a new political leader a new generation of political leaders was a 31 year old from coventry in coventry south historically one of the most left-wing constituencies in the country not very representative of the rest of even the rest of England. I mean, Zahra is great, but there should have been by now like 15 people, including some people older with more experience. There's a reason that didn't happen because, and this is the thing which the people, you know, people like Carrie Murphy have been being accused of by people around the Corbyn project for the past eight years. They shut down, shut out, actively prohibited and inhibited any process that could have realistically led to the emergence of a new generation of leaders properly.
We should just take a little assessment, I think, of where we're at with this. I do think it's true that there was this huge electoral space to the left of Labour. It was massive and it had huge potential. Has that been completely close by Zach Polanski and the Greens? I'm not sure. He's definitely doing left economic populism probably better than Jeremy Corbyn did. That's totally true. Is there a ceiling for the Greens? Are they unable to?
move to address the sort of constituencies that the Labour Party used to address and now seem to go into reform, etc. We don't know. One of the ideas that people have been sort of thinking about, I think, is to say, well, look, let's think of the left as an ecosystem and wonder what, and think about what, you know, perhaps, and we sort of mentioned this last time, perhaps everything doesn't happen for one party. In fact, perhaps different organisations fulfil different functions. One of the reasons I've considered joining the Greens, one of the reasons I haven't is I think it will be a more difficult arena to try to initiate some sort of process for extra parliamentary politics, i.e. for doing a sort of activity in which you're trying to change the composition.
of a constituency. I tried to mobilize people who aren't mobilized, tried to change the way people interpret the world by doing these sort of like base building activities, et cetera, trying to organize people around renters' rights, these sorts of things, trying to build up social infrastructure even to replace the sort of social infrastructure that's been withdrawn, trying to set up these sorts of projects which have a later effect on politics, if you know, on electoral politics, if you know what I mean. That seems to be still more possible through your party. We'll have to see how it pans out and whether it turns into anything that isn't remotely attractive after the conference. It seems much harder to think of the Greens doing that. I might be wrong about that, but that's my sense. And so perhaps you do have something, or you do have some sort of division of labour, and perhaps you do have Zach Palancey being quite efficient at doing the left populism through electoral politics and through media representation, et cetera. And then you have other people doing other stuff that needs to happen, but is less likely to happen through the Greens, et cetera, et cetera. I don't know. That could be one way in which all of this pans out. It's still a very volatile situation. The whole of British politics is very volatile.
in a very volatile state. We sort of don't know how it's going to pan out over the next six months to a year. And there's sort of like four years until the next general election. The reason there's been a massive rush to try to push the founding of your party through is that there are local elections next May, which would have been really, really quite significant. And there's some sort of idea, I presume, that in some sort of forms that there'd be candidates from that, from either your party or from smaller constituent parties or organisations which are going to lead into your party, such as Jeremy Driscoll's majority organisation up in the North East, et cetera. It's really quite...
It's a really difficult thing to think through. But I'll tell you this, it's a much nicer problem to have than the complete and utter demobilization of the left, which we've been living through for the last couple of years. Yeah, that's true. That's true. I mean, it is, you know, it is a remobilization of the left. It's a remobilization of the left across several fronts. But I mean, I think you're right. I mean, I think you're right in everything you're saying. Insofar as there is a role for your party, I mean, I think you're, I mean, if it's all going to be like base building and community organizing and not electoral politics, it's not going to be a party then, is it? Because, I mean, it's significant that you refer to DSA, Democratic States of America, which isn't a party.
And that one reason it's been able to do all that kind of work is because it's not a party. As a whole, that's one of the key reasons I would say why it hasn't, it has been able to do some of that work successfully. Yeah, it runs candidates through the democratic platform. Yeah, sure. Which it might be another argument for us needing some sort of equivalent of the DSA here. But then that does leave open the question of whether, if your party has a role to play in electoral ecology, like what is that role? The role is going to be, I mean, the role we would all like it to play is challenging reform. I mean, this is the thing, all the evidence right now is the Green Party is building up all this support. It's all coming from Labour. All the evidence suggests they haven't taken one vote from reform.
And that's what it looks like to me. It looks like to me they're going to function as a party which is going to put massive pressure on the Labour Party and possibly destroy it from the left by mobilising a big part of Labour's organic constituency, which is downwardly mobile graduates and their family and quite a lot of their parents, you know, frankly, basically. The question then is, well, who can challenge reform out in working class areas, especially in England? and that should be a role for your party i think i gotta say your party is going to be very lucky to be able to get itself into a position where it can fulfill that role before the labour party kind of you know has a kind of panic and moves to the left and starts trying to play that role itself in communities it's been embedded in for 100 years it seems quite hard to see actually what you know it's quite hard to actually see your party succeeding playing that role but i agree just because it's hard just because it's unlikely doesn't mean you shouldn't have a go you definitely should someone should have a go right now someone has to try it And it will be interesting to see, I don't know how we'd be able to measure this or even observe it, like in the Your Party kind of, you know, event structure coming up, like what kinds of people are showing up? Because I bet you, you know, 50,000 people from the 800,000 who've signed up are going to vote for reform. Like there will be a lot of people who are potential reform voters, if not, you know, members of the PLC or limited company or whatever it is that will have been really attracted by, you know, Jeremy Corbyn. There's like a definite populist crossover there. So it'll be interesting to see who actually show, who's mobilized, who you can mobilize, you know.
I'm not really sure about that, to be honest. I think by far the biggest majority of people who are going to reform are from a Conservative Party. And I think it's a hegemonisation of the... of the rights, basically. So there will be some people who are reformed voters who you can win back to a left politics from reform. But I think the battle is sort of around the outside, basically. That's not exactly what I'm saying. I'm not saying when it comes down to voting, you know, where they're getting the actual votes from. But I do think that there is a crossover between that anti-establishment language, which comes out of both reform and your party's initial comms. I think where I'm doubting is whether those people are actually going to show up to meetings. I think some of them might.
The Conservative Party, as with Labour, is a broad church and there's all different kinds of people in it. But I do think that the kind of anti-establishment vibe will cross all of Green Party, but also your party and reform, because that's what people are really sick of. I think, to close out, because it's ACFM, we should talk about how we feel about your party. i mean kia already has a bit because i've been mostly we've been sounding quite skeptical quite cynical but i mean i still feel like i said on the last episode actually i feel firstly i feel a sort of affinity with it i don't really feel the greens the reasons i'm still trying to work through and i think it's partly it is partly just habit like i've been not joining the green party for 30 years so like it's a habit for me to be really friendly to the greens and to be doing things like standing up saying to jeremy corbyn like in the early days of his leadership we shouldn't be running candidates against green mps this sort of thing so sort of it comes naturally to me to think of the greens as someone else's project totally sympathetic to cheering them on in their way in your party I do feel a bit like well I mean I feel that I completely feel the kind of pull towards wanting to be in an explicitly socialist party all the stuff here's talking about being the sort of thing that I've always thought like organically spontaneously that's what politics should be about I feel a bit of attachment to Jeremy although you know I think I think Zach is doing a fantastic job as well but also until quite recently I sort of was feeling quite sanguine about it like other people I was watching I was experiencing
especially sort of your younger comrades who got very excited about it then becoming very despondent very despondent and i was thinking well you know this is a bit naive really because this was always going to be like this it was always going to be a very difficult process there were always going to be teething difficulties there was always going to be this tension indeed between these different ideas of authority and it was going to take time for people to get used to this new thing and to work things out but then in the past few weeks i have i have started to share this kind of sinking feeling that you know it's not going to get half a million members it looked like it was going to get a few months ago that it does really look like despite my best efforts to be sort of generous and non-judgmental it does look like people like Murphy are just trying to sew things up in such a way that there isn't really a participatory constituent process. There's just the appearance of one. And it feels like I still have hopes for it and I really want it to succeed. But I share a bit of that sort of sinking feeling, although maybe not as much despair as some people. Yeah, I have to be honest about the backdrop for me, which is that I'm still very much burnt from 2019. So like my involvement in...
participative democracy and political party level has completely changed. I was working for momentum up till the last minute, and I just wanted to get out of politics. I wanted to get out of politics. And that's mostly what I've done in terms of my career. I've had a career shift, and that's a response to 2019. I still have the same values and ideas, and I hugely value the space that is this podcast. But if I'm completely honest, the reason why I've not thrown myself into your party is I do have that skepticism. And I haven't quite, like you, Jeremy, I think I'd agree with a lot of things that you said. I very much feel like...
an observer and I want it to succeed, but I'm skeptical. And I'm skeptical, I think, for all of the reasons that we discussed, but also I'm just quite sympathetic. I'm not coming at it from a kind of sneering perspective, where they should have done this and they should have done this. I think what they're trying to do is really hard. So I do want it to succeed. And I would love there to be a mass organization and it wouldn't be that I wouldn't get involved at some point. But at the moment, I still feel very much burned from 2019. And I think politically, my priorities are women's rights in Palestine. Those are my...
bottom lines. And I completely understand that as an organizing principle, Palestine, even though it is the biggest global issue. for me is not necessarily going to be an organizing principle for your party. And I kind of understand that because it's not the everyday life of people here in the UK and people might be influenced by all sorts of Zionist propaganda, which is all over the place. But I think women's rights and the rollback of feminism is quite central to me. And that's not necessarily a space that's been fronted by your party or any of the parties, actually. But coming back to Jeremy, your initial point, I think this also really does stand for me. And perhaps, again, this is my training and where I spent most of my political life since...
since I was 21. Apart from anti-war stuff, a workerist perspective is really central to my politics. And that makes it very difficult for me to join the Green Party. And I'm not saying the Green Party isn't going to be great. And I have a lot of friends who have very similar politics to me that have joined the Green Party, but I find it difficult too. Doesn't mean I'm not going to do it, but I find it difficult too. So I think for those reasons, I'm still very much both practically and psychologically and emotionally on the outside currently, even though I am watching with interest.
Like for me, I was more in the position of you two. I'd sort of signed up actually for the, you know, it was about that 800,000 wave. And then I thought, oh, there could be something interesting here, couldn't there? But like, you know, let's just see how it pans out. And then I got invited to go down to this weekend, this sort of like where people are trying to pull together, like little renters unions and, you know, various different sorts of like base building sort of organizations.
And I was asked to go and present a little bit from the Radical Abundance book, which has got a strategy which is to the side of that, but not totally unrelated. And it was at that weekend, there were lots of really good people there, and there was really good discussion. I was thinking, actually, yeah, there could be a real chance here. Something really interesting could happen here. Like, you know, if we do get like a large sign up of members, you could actually do something which could change the country to some degree. And I got really quite committed to that. And then two days later, Sarah and Jeremy did the whole, you know, the team around them did the whole membership fuck up.
And I've got to admit, I was angry. I was really viscerally angry at both Jeremy Corbyn and Zara Sultan and the people around them, like really, really angry at them. That's dissipated now a little bit. I've also got a little bit more sympathetic. This is an incredibly hard thing to do, et cetera. And so, you know, basically I've got involved to a certain degree. You know, I'm going to see how it pans out over the next few months. What would I do then? You know, I could imagine myself perhaps saying, all right, okay, this experiment is over. Now let's try and join the Greens. There's a few reasons why I find that difficult. The Green Party around me is very right wing, for instance, just in my local constituency.
don't like the people some of the people involved and so that's just a personal thing but like the situation is just incredibly volatile we just don't know how this is going to play out over the next few years so it's like that thing of like like try to get involved see if it's working out in this area if not then just then this attitude to take I think is pull back and see whatever opportunities are out there basically and that's the attitude I think we need to take