Skip to content
ACMI Conversations: Superheroes, Ethics and Justice episode artwork

Apr 27, 2018 1 hr 12 min

ACMI Conversations: Superheroes, Ethics and Justice

from ACMI Stories & Ideas Hosted by ACMI

From the Marvel and DC cinematic universes to small screen caped-crusaders and vigilantes, superheroes are more popular than ever. But how do superheroes reflect our place and power within society? Whether it’s symbolic representations of asylum seekers and First Nations people on Cleverman, Jessica Jones battling PTSD or The Watchmen exploring the moral ambiguity of individuals with tremendous power, superheroes have the power (dare we say great responsibility?) to tell nuanced, reflective and universal stories. Join us to discuss how our heroic representations hold a mirror up to contemporary views on ethics, justice and equality. About the panel Martyn Pedler Martyn Pedler is a writer and academic who focuses on superhero stories. He's published chapters and presented internationally on subjects like how the Flash runs in a medium without movement and why Doctor Doom cried after 9/11. He's also been a longtime pop culture critic for Bookslut, Time Out Melbourne, Triple J Magazine and more. He is the writer of the 2012 feature film EXIT, and has several other screenplays in development. Dr Liam Burke Dr Liam Burke is the Cinema and Screen Studies coordinator at Swinburne University of Technology. He has written and edited a number of books on comic books and cinema including Superhero Movies, Fan Phenomena Batman, and The Comic Book Film Adaptation: Exploring Modern Hollywood’s Leading Genre. Liam is a chief investigator on the Superheroes & Me research project with ACMI. He recently directed the documentary short film @HOME, which was screened at a number of international film festivals and was broadcast on Irish television. Brooke Maggs Brooke Maggs is a freelance narrative designer and writer for games, VR and other creative industries. She one of the women featured in ACMI's Code Breaker's exhibition where you can play one of her latest projects, The Gardens Between, an adventure puzzle game.Recently, she received the 2017 MCV Pacific XBOX Women in Games Creative Impact award for her work in the games industry. Brooke is writing a science fiction novel for which she was shortlisted for the Ray Koppe Writer’s Residency and awarded a residency at the Varuna House. Her other writing includes academic research in creative writing practice. Copyright Acknowledgments: Title: The Avengers (2012) Copyright: Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Production Company Title: Spiderman (2002) Copyright: Marvel Enterprises / Columbia Pictures Title: Superman (1978) Copyright: Warner Bros Title: Man of Steel (2013) Copyright: DC Entertainment / Warner Bros Pictures Title: Daredevil Season 1 Episode 2 Copyright: Marvel Television / Netflix Title: Cleverman Season 1 Episode 2 Copyright: Sundance Studios / ABC TV Title: Superman Returns (2006) Copyright: Legendary Pictures / DC Comics / Warner Bros Pictures

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

ACMI Conversations: Superheroes, Ethics and Justice

0:00 1:12:23
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Acme Conversations podcast, where we explore the world of the moving image and its connections to politics, society, culture, and art. This is a recording of a live event, and it may reference visual material. You can view this on our YouTube channel. Great, good evening everyone and welcome to ACMI Conversations. My name's Ari and I'm one of the public programs producers here at ACMI and I'm really, really pleased that you've all come along to hear about our awesome discussion tonight. Before we begin, I'd like to acknowledge the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nation, the traditional owners of the land that we're standing on here today and pay my respects to the elders past and present and also any elders who may be in attendance. So welcome to tonight's instalment in ACMI's conversation series that takes place every Tuesday at 6.30pm. ACMI Conversations celebrates bold experimental ideas, discussion and debate around the moving image and its connections to the world in which we live, from politics to society, culture and art.

Come in and join the conversation with us every Tuesday. So this week we explore how us superheroes and supervillains reflect our real world concepts of ethics, justice and morality. In coming weeks we look forward to discussing diverse topics including gender diversity on screen next week and finally to wrap up the series anime and feminism. So I'd like to begin by introducing you to our host and our moderator for this evening, Martin Pedler. Martin is a writer and academic who focuses on superhero stories. He's published chapters and presented internationally on subjects like how the Flash runs in a medium without movement and why Dr Doom cried after 9-11.

He's also been a long-time pop culture critic for Bookslite, Time Out Melbourne, Triple J Magazine and more. He's the writer of the 2012 feature film Exit and has several other screenplays in development. Now please give a round of applause for our moderator Martin. Hi everybody, thanks for coming out tonight. So we're all going to give short presentations on superheroes ethics and justice. Then we're going to have a quick bit of a conversation and we'll open up the questions for the audience. So first of all we wanted to start with a quote from Alan Moore.

There we go. This is an imaginary story, which may never happen, but then again may, about a perfect man who fell from the sky and did only good. That's Alan Moore describing Superman in Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow back in 1986. Tonight we're going to talk about what it means for a superhero to do only good. It's a beautiful idea, a utopian idea, and perhaps a childlike idea. But contrast that with this random tweet I found. Batman is a 1%er beating up the mentally ill. So who's doing good now as a superhero? As the recent Lego Batman movie, which was surprisingly sophisticated, pointed out, Batman can seem more like a villain than a hero. He's a brutal loner who uses fear and terror and menacing iconography.

In fact, the only thing that seems to stop Batman from becoming a villain is that he does not kill. Look at the five evil Batman from DC Comics' current batshit crazy storyline Metal. There's an Atlantean, a Green Lantern Batman, a Doomsday Batman, a Flash Batman, all evil. It's actually pretty spectacular. They're all different from the true Batman, as they've been corrupted by killing. First the killing of their enemies, and then the killing of their friends. Now, before someone in the audience calls me out on this, yes, Batman did kill in his earliest incarnations. You can see him with a smoking gun there on the left. But it didn't take long before the no-killing creed was in place, as you can see on the right.

One of my favourite quotes about it is from Superman in the series Kingdom Come, where he says when you scratch everything else away from Batman, you're left with someone who doesn't want to see anybody else die. But while most superheroes don't kill, they almost all fight. Action is baked into the bedrock of superhero stories, whether that's fistfights or heat vision or psychic battles. And that action usually takes the form of violence. This presents something of a moral quandary for some superhero fans. For example, Daredevil and the Punisher have a decades-long debate about whether it's okay to kill your enemies or not. We saw this play out most recently in season two of the Netflix series. Daredevil holds tight to the fact that killing is wrong. What's not wrong, though, is kicking the shit out of everyone in sight, as he does in this famous fight scene from season one. Here we go. Okay, so...

As you can see, killing bad, beating the shit out of people, totally fine. And as a friend of mine pointed out, those guys are not okay. It's not like everyone gets up after that and goes, well, I've learned my lesson Daredevil. Those people are permanently maimed and injured after a fight like that. So it's pretty easy to mount the argument that antiheroes who kill, like the Punisher, are there to convince you that anything less than killing is somehow morally justified. It's also why at the end of the recent Wonder Woman movie, Diana defeats Ares, the god of war, with more war. As Liam did point out earlier, she does do it with love, but love kind of is a blast of warlike energy at the end. It might have made more sense for her to defeat him with peace, but that kind of ending is resisted by superhero stories.

So superhero stories default to the good gunslinger motto, shoot last but shoot fastest. They're reactive, not proactive. In fact, proactive heroes always risk becoming villains. Every so often we'll get a story about Superman setting out to risk the world and he always becomes some kind of dictator in the process, like you can see here. Or whenever Batman's I have a plan for everything tactics come out, they're often used against him, his teammates, or the world. This is why superheroes are agents of the status quo and can never seem to change the world for the better.

There's a famous Superman story about this where aliens say that all he's doing by saving humanity over and over again is contributing to our cultural lag, again preserving the status quo. So as the Superman comic once asked, what's so funny about truth, justice and the American way? And what does the American way now mean for a global superhero? In a recent article, the academic Ian Gordon suggested that Superman's inability to change the world forces him to focus on smaller acts of good, and that stops him from becoming part of the interventionist American state. It keeps him a positive symbol of American power, and that lets him have a global appeal he might not otherwise have. In fact, Superman once gave up his US citizenship, saying truth, justice in the American way. It's just not enough anymore.

The world was more complicated than fighting for just American values. Yes, this caused all the outrage that you'd expect in conservative media at the time, and I believe it's been written out of continuity now anyway. So superhero stories often confuse complicated with adult, and adult with violent, and violent with kills people. So one of my favourite pieces on this is this story where the Riddler has a moral crisis about what's happened to the Batman story since the 1960s. The Joker's killing people for God's sake, he says. Did I miss something? Was I away when they changed the rules?

As Ben Saunders wrote in his book Do the Gods Wear Capes, superheroes can be seen as the wish that things were otherwise. I love that quote. Otherwise from the real world that's all around us. But of course social realism has been part of superheroes since their very beginnings. Superman originally took on crooked landlords and corrupt officials. The X-Men have always been free-floating metaphors for all kinds of discrimination.

And now Australia has Clever Man, which riffs on the X-Men through the lens of Indigenous culture, positing a race of so-called sub-humans known as Hairies, who are persecuted and exploited by the wealthy. There's a bit of Spider-Man in there too, with the lead character doing his bad behaviour that he then has to face when he gets the superhero qualities. With great power, great responsibility, you know the drill. Let's have a look.

Wari's gonna be mighty pissed off. Ever since you two were little, Wari's been dreaming of becoming the Clever Man. He's been waiting for this day all his life, and now his little brother steals his thunder. It's a big responsibility, Colin. Clever Man is more than just a title. Whatever reason Jimmy had, you got a chance to start over. Yeah. This belonged to your father. Kept his uni stuff in it. Where'd you get that? Found it. After the accident. Put other stuff in, photos, anything I could grab at the time, which wasn't much.

It's the past. You can't change it. All you can do is try to do better. Your father, he wasn't perfect. He was a man with all the faults of a man. And he was your father. I was thinking, though, that reality intersects with superheroes in other ways too.

I wanted to talk briefly about the Punisher. Now, there's a constant refrain in comics that Batman is the best superhero because anybody could be Batman. You know, he's just a normal man, except, as the new Justice League movie points out, his real superpower is being rich. But if anyone can be Batman, then anyone can be the Punisher. The superpower of Marvel's antihero is guns. Amazingly, back in the 90s, Marvel used to publish these Punisher armory comics. Does anyone remember these? Which were basically just pictures of weapons with loving narration about how useful they were. My favourite thing is, you can see in the tiny top of the cover, it says no ads, even though the whole thing is basically just an ad for real-life weaponry.

And as an aside, I know that Batman's no-guns policy has wavered throughout the years too. We have, this is the weapon of the enemy, we do not need it, we will not use it, compared to Zack Snyder's version of the Batmobile from the latest films there on the right, which has guns proudly mounted on the hood. In fact, movie heroes tend to be more bloodthirsty than their comic book counterparts. Even as back in Batman Begins, Batman tells Ra's al Ghul, I won't kill you, but I don't have to save you, and leaves him to die. Anyway, a few years ago, I found a Marvel editor in print stating that the Punisher had killed 48,502 people in comics since the piece character first appeared. All of them apparently deserved it, because that's the Punisher's true superpower. He never kills anybody who doesn't deserve it. The minute he does, the entire character falls apart. But moral reality hits the Punisher differently than it does most superheroes or even antiheroes. After the Las Vegas massacre, where 58 people were killed and over 500 injured, Marvel and Netflix pulled their Punisher panel from New York Comic Con.

As one article put it, the gun violence in the US means there'll never be a right time for a Punisher TV series. Of course, the Punisher TV series is about to drop in about two days' time. At first, though, Marvel didn't pull an even more alarming exhibition from that same Comic-Con. They teamed up with the defence contractor Northrop Grumman, even producing a comic to promote them. You can see the ad on the left. If you dream of working at Stark Enterprises, in reality, you should work for Northrop Grumman.

This happily ignores the fact that Tony Stark gave up being an arms manufacturer to become Iron Man, so even Marvel's own continuity knew this partnership was a terrible idea, morally speaking, but Marvel's corporate overlords seemingly didn't understand that. In conclusion, I guess I had two last examples of this no-killing moral policy at work. In one, Batman actually saves the Joker from death row, from a crime the Joker didn't commit. Just this one crime. He still committed all the other crimes, just not this one. Every breath you take, you owe to me, says Batman. But I wonder what would Batman think if he realised his moral code of never killing is perhaps just because the marketplace always demands the Joker be available for more stories.

And in the other, Superman gives my favorite explanation for why killing your enemies is a bad idea. Executions are walk in the park. These no-nonsense solutions of yours just don't hold water in a complex world of jet-powered apes and time travel. So the world of superheroes is regularly so insane that refusing to kill isn't just morality, it's a new kind of practicality. And on that note, I'm going to pass the microphone and the clicker over to Brooke Maggs. Now, Brooke Maggs is an award-winning narrative designer and writer for games, VR, and other creative industries. She's currently working on The Gardens Between, an adventure puzzle game, and Paperbark, a game about the Australian bush. Her personal projects include a science fiction novel for which she was shortlisted for the Ray Cobb Writer's Residency, and she's in the early stages of a superhero noir novel. Her interest in the superhero genre is moral ambiguity, and she's drawn to superheroes who are extraordinary and flawed people. Please welcome her.

Yeah, well, you basically just covered all this. I'm going to move to the next slide very quickly. I wanted to talk about Batwoman. So I loved superheroes when I was a kid. The one thing I asked for one birthday was a Batman costume. And then leading up to my birthday, my mom and my family would joke that I was actually getting a Barbie outfit. And I was like, no, I want a Batman one. And I got it and then never took it off for ages. And then I grew up, I think I just moved away from superheroes for a while. But I've definitely gotten back into them, you know, along with all the new Marvel movies and things happening on TV.

one of my favorites I was specifically looking for a female superhero that I could read and I found Batwoman and these are kind of old now these came out about 2013 but I recently reread them and I wanted to talk a little bit about Batwoman because I think she's amazing and also because of I guess the controversy around her being that She initially started out as Batwoman was added to the Bat family to give more variety but also to be, I guess, the woman counterpart to Batman. But early on she was Cathy Kane and she had a lot of, correct me if I'm wrong, but she had a lot of like equipment that was like in her lipstick and in her handbag and it was like these little, you know, kind of really, really girly things. And then when she was remade for this series or recreated...

for New 52, she was announced to be someone who was a lesbian and also to have more diversity. DC Comics Senior Vice President and Executive Director stated, it was from conversations we had expanding the DC universe, looking at levels of diversity. We wanted to have a cast that is much more reflective of today's society. So I think what we will eventually get into talking about is about how our heroes reflect our society and what our heroes say about us. But first I want to talk about origin stories and where Batwoman comes from.

Her mother and twin sister are kidnapped by terrorists as well as her. And her father works for NATO and he comes and rescues them. But he's only in time to rescue Kate. And unfortunately, her mother and her sister are killed by the time he arrives. So Kate follows in her father's footsteps and joins the army, but is dishonorably discharged when her sexuality is revealed. And so she goes on to train with her father to become Batwoman. So he's very much present throughout these comics and helping her out, which I find really interesting. But also more comes up, I guess, with one of the things I loved about this too was just how...

bold it was in terms of Kate meeting Maggie first of all so Maggie is a detective and she works on the force and naturally that starts to create problems with the things Batwoman does and the things that I guess the police would would rather do or rather her not do but throughout Kate also what's interesting is that I think we've only had our first female lead really this year being Wonder Woman just made in the movies but there are interesting characters in the comics who have you know whose personal lives are affected by you know by being a superhero one of the panels that I love here down the bottom is when Kate basically has a bit of a martyr complex and is quite can be quite selfish and Maggie calls her out on it and says you know you're going to climb down off your cross and you're going to let us help you or you're going to pack up all of your crap and move out and that kind of relationship is really great and here this is where Kate reveals to Maggie who she is by proposing to her saying that I'm Batwoman essentially and you know I'm Kate under the mask and will you marry me

So the best thing I guess about this is issue 17 was the milestone was where she proposed but in September 2013 co-authors J.H. Williams and W. Haddon Blackman announced that they would leave Batwoman after the December issue because conflicts over the storylines for Batwoman. They weren't allowed to expand to Killer Croc's backstory first of all but most importantly they weren't allowed to show Kate and Maggie getting married. The reason being eventually was superheroes shouldn't have happy personal lives but I wonder if there's more going on there if in terms of the politics and what they were and weren't willing to commit to in terms of following through with their diversity edict so I think the other thing too is that Where am I up to? In Volume 6, when the newer writers took over, Kate's personal life, or sorry, Kate's life as Batwoman started to create problems for Maggie's daughter. You know, she would bring the violence home, I suppose, and this is where her daughter discovers her in the bathroom, I guess, cleaning up, you know, blood and things like that, and she mentions how her life has consequences. They go on to eventually write Maggie out by the fact that she's in a custody battle with her daughter, and because her ex-husband resents Kate for whatever reason, Kate does her martyr thing and says, well, I'm going to break up with you and move out so that you can, you know...

um keep your daughter essentially um and it's kind of posed as a heroic thing to do but it also feels a little bit like um copping out in a way um you know because batwoman does you know many violent things throughout the comics one would think she might put on the mask and just angle the ex-husband over a building for a while i don't know but yeah it was really interesting decision i thought um and it kind of lost its uh i don't know it lost something i think when the writers left um and lastly i wanted to also um pose or I guess tell you about the fact that Beth survived but Beth became a super villain so being twins the comics and I think could have played more on the fact that there is a narrow line between superhero and super villain and it's played out between these sisters who love each other but are ultimately on completely different sides of the fence and is the line the fact that her father rescued her and you know not her sister and she constantly says you know it's not my sister's fault she was actually adopted by the religion of crime and after that you know the rest is history super villain status as you do yeah exactly

So, you know, I think the moral ambiguity in Kate for me is really interesting, but also that's posed between, I guess, being a superhero created for diversity, but then that storyline not actually being allowed to be carried through is, yeah, definitely worth chatting more about on the panel. So, yeah, thank you. Next up, we have Dr Liam Burke. He's the Cinema and Screen Studies Coordinator at the Swinburne University of Technology. He has written and edited a number of books on comic books and cinema, including superhero movies, fan phenomena Batman, and the comic book film adaptation, exploring modern Hollywood's leading genre. Liam is the chief investigator on the Superheroes and Me research project with ACMI. He recently directed the documentary short At Home, which was screened at a number of international film festivals and was broadcast on Irish television. So please welcome him tonight.

Yeah, I'm just going to give you a little prompt. Yeah, thanks, guys. So there's not really anything left for me to introduce myself. So I launched straight Intuit. I mean, this version of Batman is probably the most familiar version of Batman, but you're all superhero fans, or at least some interesting superheroes, so you know that Batman didn't always look like this. He wasn't always the Dark Knight. There have been times, in fact, across his almost 80-year career when he's been practically technicolor. And often these changes are in response to kind of wider trends and societal pressures. As the guys have already alluded to, in the kind of the late 1950s, during a pretty conservative period, Batman became the head of a larger Batman family. A media scholar, Andy Medhurst, notes of the hero's ever-changing identity that Batman serves as a cultural thermometer, taking the temperature of the times.

And I mean, this is certainly true of Batman, but it's kind of true of all superheroes. And it's one of the reasons why this panel is interesting and why they're interesting to media scholars generally, because unlike an Oscar-winning movie or a Pulitzer Prize-winning play, superhero stories, particular superhero stories in comics, are rarely self-consciously produced. And as a consequence, they're actually a much more accurate and honest reflection of changing interests and anxieties and interests down through the years. So for instance, we could talk about the emergence of superheroes on a comic book page in the late 1930s, in which they were kind of a welcome response to the Great Depression. And as Martin's already alluded to, far from the big blue boy scout, we're familiar with today when superman was introduced in action comics number one he was a social reformer he fought uh white beaters he uh captured crooked politicians an attitude at the time that an approach that would have chimed with readers move forward a couple of years though the rise of fascism in europe found many linking comic book superman with the nazis misuse of nietzsche's uh ubermensch uh concept and so there was a need to sort of diffuse that criticism and national publications which will become dc comics to diffuse that criticism

makes Superman the patriot that we're more familiar with today. He joins a cavalcade of costume heroes in the war effort. This reflective kind of quality of superheroes continues up to the emergence of the Marvel Universe in the 1960s where the heroes who populated this versioning Marvel Universe gained their abilities through disastrous space missions or science experiments gone awry. These irradiated icons were equally cursed and blessed by their newfound abilities and this of course articulated conflicting attitudes to the rapid technological innovations of the time. And you can continue forward to Punisher which we've already discussed how he was a response to increasing inner city violence or even the popularity of Disco which gave us this misguided character Dazzler.

She was misguided. So when the first feature-length adaptation of Spider-Man is released in the North American summer of 2002, and it breaks all sorts of box office records, cultural commentators are looking to the zeitgeist to furnish a reason for the unprecedented popularity of cinema superheroes, and they didn't have to look far. You can probably see from this image, this is a pre-production, early promotional still for Spider-Man. You can see in the reflective lenses, the World Trade Center. The film was in production at the time of the 9-11 terrorist attacks, and its success so soon after that terrorist attack found Minnie linking its success to the reassurance it provided to an American audience rocked by 9-11. And this makes sense, because superheroes were never more popular on the comic book page than when...

they were turning over Axis tanks or punching Hitler on the jaw. And so this kind of four-color rebuttal to a real-world trip found many going, oh, well, they provided reassurance in the 1940s. Well, surely they're doing it again now, but in cinema. But this doesn't quite make sense, because superheroes kind of chafed, or there was a tension between superheroes in their classical iteration and the kind of sentiment of post-911 media, where the mood was heroes among us rather than heroes above. It was about kind of celebration of community, first responders and the like. And you saw those in some of the comic book tributes like this one to those paramedics and first responders and so on. But superheroes, that doesn't really work for superheroes because superheroes are the latest iteration of a mythological tradition of exceptional individuals who seek revenge for injustices wrought upon themselves, their homes and society. Or as Tony Stark would put it to Loki in The Avengers. Because if we can't protect the Earth, you can be damn well sure we'll avenge it.

And many of these heroes are, of course, not sanctioned by the groups they seek to protect and could best be described as vigilantes. And probably one of the best early examples of this was Stanley and Steve Ditko's Spider-Man, who was an early example of this equally cursed and blessed approach to superheroes. The first Spider-Man film, the 2002 film, was in production at the time of the World Trade Center attacks. And if you look at the finished film, which was released about nine months later, you can discern a tension between the classical versions of the character, the character treated as a menace by the people in New York, and a need to kind of chime with... post 9-11 sentiment. So as one example, I'll show you a montage where Spider-Man is first established as a hero in New York and these kind of Vox Pops Man on the Street interviews are used to demonstrate the conflicting opinions of the people of New York to his appearance. I see the web and it's a signature and I know Spider-Man was here. The guy protects us, you know, he protects the people. Some kind of freaky little or something I could do. He stinks and I don't like him.

So you can see how there's this conflicting opinion. Some people think he's a saviour, some people think he's a menace, and this is typical of the characters you appear in the comic book page. However, across the film you can see that there are a lot of sequences that try to diminish this aspect of the character, this threatening individualistic vigilante aspect, no more so than the climax of the film, where the people of New York need to rally to Spider-Man's side and help him against the Green Goblin. And this sequence was described by the filmmakers as being added post 9-11 in response to the spirit of the time. So scenes such as this, where the hero's wings are clipped and he needs the help of ordinary people, sort of to emphasize a community where everyone is special and everyone can be a hero. But as the decade sort of progressed, this kind of first decade of comic book movies, the integration of the hero, which was at odds with the source material, in the case of Spider-Man, and at odds with the conventions of the superhero generally began to kind of chafe and that tension became more obvious and kind of reared its head more often. And you start to see the emergence of films.

in which the hero is treated as a threatening individual. They began to dominate the genre. And of course, while these didn't tally with the mood of post 9-11 entertainments, they did for the mythology and indeed an ideology that had much more resonance post 9-11. So following 9-11, U.S. President George Bush, he played a lot of Western tropes. Up until the first nine months or so, he was in the office, he went to work in a suit, and he was reasonably sensible, and everyone thought he was going to be a lame duck president. Post 9-11, suddenly these folkisms start to pepper his language. He starts to wear the cowboy hat more. And a key example of that was his response to the question about six days after 9-11, when he gave his first Pentagon briefing, which was, do you want me land and dead? And he responded like this. I just remember, all I'm doing is remember when I was a kid. I remember that they used to put out there in the Old West.

I wanted poster. It said wanted dead or alive. All I want in America wants him brought to justice. Media scholar Stacey Takas describes how this rhetoric, which was successful at home if not overseas, allowed the US government to portray its actions as those of a reluctant gunslinger, forced by circumstances to resort to violence. you know, these kind of Western tropes not withstanding, it didn't really lead to a reemergence of the superhero, the cowboy on screen. The Western, since its revisionist turn in the 1950s, has always struggled to kind of slip into the black and white morality that marked the genre's classical period. But fortunately, superheroes are part of that same mythological tradition. The cowboy is a kind of individualistic hero and was well placed in a country in a presidency that valorized the lone gunslinger and adopted preemptive, almost vigilante-like policies in its foreign policy. This became the preferred right-wing reading of The Dark Knight, with many conservative commentators like Andrew Klavan and others suggesting

that the superhero's use of extraordinary rendition and illegal surveillance to stop a terrorist threat validated the Bush era's war on terror tactics. And I mean, that is certainly the right wing reading of that movie. But what's also important about The Dark Knight is released in 2008 alongside Iron Man and alongside Hancock, it represented a shift in the superhero movie genre from the kind of classical conventions, the simple black and white morality, to more self-aware films that question the morality and the ethics of the hero. So for instance, released in 1978, Superman the movie, the Christopher Reeve version, concludes like this. This country is safe against Superman, thanks to you. No, sir. Don't thank me, Warden. We're all part of the same team. However, the more recent adaptation, Man of Steel, the U.S. military arrests and attempts to control Superman with his efforts to convince them that they're on the same side met with skepticism. And I'll ask the obvious question. How do we know you won't one day act against America's interests? I grew up in Kansas, General. About as American as it gets. Look, I'm here to help. But it has to be on my own terms. And you have to convince Washington of that.

Similarly, Spider-Man in the end of the original Spider-Man trilogy is given this parade. He's given the key to the city, the people in New York celebrate him. But by the time you get to the Amazing Spider-Man reboot in 2012, he is branded an outlaw by Captain George Stacey, who argues that Spider-Man's seemingly pro-social actions are actually the unintended consequence of a personal vendetta. And even just last year's two big superhero movies, Batman v Superman and Captain America Civil War, centered their premise around the collateral damage caused by these heroes' individualistic actions. So if superheroes are cultural thermometers, what do today's costume-clad characters say about our interests and our anxieties?

If nothing else, they seem to suggest that the audience has grown familiar, arguably tired with the conventions of the superhero movie genre, and demand a more thorough examination of the heroes, their place in the world, and also their ethics. We might talk about that a little bit more now. I guess let's start broad. Is there a difference between a superhero and a vigilante then? Yes. Superheroes are impossible to define. There is books and pieces written all about trying to define superheroes. Do you consider the origin of the superhero in 1938 with the arrival of Superman, which has the dual identity, the costume, the special powers, all of which are the key attributes people identify? Or do you go back to mythological antecedents? Or even more closely, do you think of characters like Zorro or Robin Hood? So superheroes are impossible to define.

they are often deputized in some cases so you know the 1960s Adam West Batman was deputized we were reminded he was deputized to sort of quite any parental concern and then of course there are vigilantes unfortunately in the real world who are not superhero anyway even if they don't have whatever about costumes and capes they don't need to have the sort of morality or the kind of the higher ideals that we associate with the best of the superheroes One of my favourite nods in the Batman comics was that they still have the bat signal on the roof of police headquarters, but that no policeman was allowed to turn it on. You had to get Commissioner Gordon's secretary to turn it on because she wasn't technically a cop, and thereby it wasn't a sanctioned activity. So they've always had to dance around this idea of, is Batman a vigilante? Is he a cop? Or is he in a liminal area between the two? That's really interesting, though, because it provides a lot of rich conversation to have about all of that. And I think when... So interesting that the secretary turns it on, that, like, when you have that discussion around the cops kind of...

Well, then the superheroes are the power fantasy for the cops, almost, if you know what I mean. And that's really interesting too, because what does that say about, yeah, war or justice? For superheroes to war, there has to be an absence of... proper point control measures. So in the Batman films, certainly in the post-minor era, that's positioned as the cops are corrupt, or largely corrupt, there's a few good cops, or they're incompetent, or the threats that are coming, like Thanos or whatever, are so far beyond their ability to work that there's no way to... And so it's this absence that creates the need for the superhero, but the kind of tragedy of the superhero, like a Western gunslinger, is they're defending a community that will not defend itself, but once they usher in that piece, they have no place in that community. So we saw that perhaps most prominently in The Dark Knight.

where Harry Dent is saying, you know, we've been happy to have Batman cleaned up our streets until now, and now suddenly you want to get rid of him because it's inconvenient. And that's a tragedy of the superhero, that they will depend on the community, but that they can never sublimate that desire for community themselves, constantly, you know, have to let love interest go, as you've kind of demonstrated, to answer a higher calling for justice. And then when they usher in that piece, they have to kind of die or quietly go off, or there's a reboot. They mark themselves as outsiders, first of all, but then they're marked as outsiders when they actually clean up the streets and pieces ushered, so they're twice othered in a way when that happens, which is interesting. I feel like we've seen a lot more state-sanctioned superheroes in the last, say, 20 years, both in comics and in film. You know, the Avengers basically work for S.H.I.E.L.D. at first. You had a lot of that in comics, where we had superheroes becoming soldiers, almost more so. Do you think that's a cultural shift we should have expected post-9-11? Definitely. Jim Lee, the X-Men and Batman artist, said the government is the modern version of radiation.

So radiation used to be the reason everyone got their superpowers, now it's the government. So you had, and it was even happening before 9-11, where there was, in order to justify or validate or even explain where these characters came from, they were state-sanctioned. So the Ultimates imprint or version of the Avengers are a state-sanctioned version of the Avengers. They work for S.H.I.E.L.D. That was obviously the kind of the basis of the movie. And you had this sort of militaristic inflection. So whereas Batman in 89 had wonderful toys, in 2005, Batman Begins, he's using the prototypes from Wayne Enterprises or indeed Divisions, particularly it's a militaristic division. And, you know, in an era in which people, I mean, particularly in the States, people drive SUVs.

that are meant for combat more than actually taking your kids to school and people wear a cabaret and people do all these sorts of things. It is again this reflection of wider anxieties, wider trends, wider interests that superheroes are noted for and celebrated for. Do you think this is part of the same tendency that means we've moved away from, say, secret identities, which now seem quite hokey in the movies? You know, Tony Stark at the end of the first Iron Man basically says, oh, well, I'm Iron Man, you know, fuck it, I'm Iron Man, doesn't matter, because we're not willing to accept the kind of Clark Kent putting his glasses on and, you know, no one knows who he is anymore. I don't know. I worry that... I worry. I don't lie awake at night worrying about it. But I do wonder, as more reality creeps into superhero stories, are we missing out on some of the things that made superhero stories special?

I mean, I don't know, when you were just talking about associating superheroes with the military and with government, I was thinking about, is that how they're getting away with just the mass destruction from beginning to end, you know, in Avengers or anything like that, by saying either the government, you have those characters that sort of say, and look what you're doing to the city, this is terrible, but you're getting rid of the aliens, so that's probably a good thing. But, yeah, is it a way of just, you know, kind of owning and trying to make up for these extra, you know, non-realistic things that happen as a way of kind of grounding it in reality, but also kind of trying to get away with that? I guess, cinematic, you know, sensation that comes along with the genre as well. Well, I mean, they have that veneer of sociopolitical relevance, which...

makes us read into things, but whenever the critical lens gets too focused, they go, oh, but it's just superheroes, so don't worry about it. So Christopher Nolan famously in interviews, particularly for The Dark Knight Rises, where it seems to sort of critique or even just outright criticise activist movements like Occupy Wall Street. Yeah, but he's not really right-wing because it's a superhero thing, so you're reading too much into it. So they can have the sort of gesture to or bleakly reference things that are happening in the real world. They go, oh, superheroes have grown up. But if the heat ever gets turned up too much, they go, yeah, but it's just a bunch of guys punching each other. But I mean, even in the case of things like...

Daredevil, I mean, they're so grounded, the Netflix shows. Do you find that, that the Netflix shows are so grounded? They're trying to be the street-level vigilantes. That's some of the joys falling out of it. Yeah, look, I will always go to bat for Daredevil Fighting Ninjas. Daredevil Fighting Ninjas is my happy place. But it definitely limits the kind of stories you can tell, certainly. I do notice that. In terms of, I don't know, you mentioned power fantasies. Are superhero stories always called out for being adolescent power fantasies? And in terms of morality, do you think that's true? And if it's true, is that a bad thing?

I mean, as a kid, I loved the idea of having powers and having more control. And, you know, it was my goal. I wanted to swoop in and do good. I wanted to have all the powers. I made up my own superheroes and things like that. So I can't deny that there is a power fantasy there. But I think there's something universal about, you know, that desire for control and uniqueness and purpose. But there's also bad when the power fantasies are from one particular group of people about their particular kind of power that gets reinforced.

So, for example, a cis white man's power fantasy will be different to my power fantasy, I suppose. You know, it's who is controlling what fantasies we proliferate, I think is interesting. I mean, there's a wonderful book all about this, which is Amazing Adventures of Cavalier and Clay, which is by the Jewish-American writer Michael Chabon. And it's set in the 1940s, kind of 1930s, 1940s golden age of the American comic book industry, which to European immigrants, kind of like most of the... key creators were, create the escapist. And at one point, one of the creators reflects that the criticism level against superheroes, that they're just escapism, is actually one of the best things about them. But as the book progresses, what's interesting is they're creating, because they're European immigrants, they're creating this sort of Nazi-smashing icon, paralleling Captain America, called the escapist. And it's sort of this kind of, this thrill for them to enact these kind of fantasies that can never happen in the real world, you know, punch it in the jaw and the like. But later in the book, when they have a bit of distance on the thing, they reflect that whether they were creating another generation of men who valorised only strength. And they worried that in kind of using this kind of power fantasy,

that they were kind of creating a whole another generation of that. And I think most audiences are smart, despite what we're led to believe. I've done a little bit of audience research in and around comic book adaptations, and most people go with their eyes open, recognizing that it's a power fantasy, and that the allusions to real world things can give it a bit of texture, but to confuse it with the real world is rare. Most people are pretty clued in, I think. I hope.

I don't know, we have seen in the States some SWAT teams actually using the Punisher logo. Yeah. Which I find very disquieting. Yes. So sometimes those lines between reality and fantasy do blur, even on an official kind of state logo. Oh, absolutely. I mean, you had, you know, World War II bombers that would have Wonder Woman and other superhero characters, combo characters and Betty Poop and all on the side of their jet planes and things like that. Or when they're used for propaganda. Yes.

when i was doing some research for this panel i found some war propaganda that was encouraging people to make victory gardens which are people growing their own food and vegetables and robin and batman were on the poster with you know arms of fruit and vegetables looking really happy with themselves so it is interesting then when you use those power fans or those people um to you know say things or encourage behaviour in reality. That's a really tame end of the World War II propaganda. You should have Googled it a little bit further until you get to some of the more... More disquieting things. Yeah, for sure. And I mean, it was funny because recently we had on Twitter following Charlottesville, a lot of people were posting about how comics hate Nazis. I think Gail Simone, the writer, had started that hashtag, which seemed to totally bypass, I mean, lots of pictures of, you know, Captain America and Ninja Turtles punching Hitler or whoever it might be, but seemed to ignore the kind of terrible racist caricatures and all this sort of, the worst part. And it's that sort of...

And that's what's interesting about superheroes is you have to take the bad with the good and you have to look back at the 80 plus years they've been on the comic book page and more recently movies, TV shows and everything else and to see how they are that sort of immediate reflection of the best and worst in society from time to time. Well, it's exactly that history that makes some of this discussion so difficult. So when characters have been around for 80 years, they've had stories by hundreds of writers, thousands of stories, and you can pick and choose almost any moral position you want. When Superman killed the enemy at the end of Man of Steel, and a lot of people were outraged, Superman doesn't kill, and immediately some people got in line and went, yes, he does, he's an example of him killing. And you're like, yeah, well, that was one time that was written out of continuity about three minutes later. It's kind of like the Bible. It's so conflicting and contradictory, and it's so long that you could probably find something to support any interpretation and any position, which is why, I mean, say, when Wonder Woman lost the UN ambassadorship, so last year, Wonder Woman...

before pre the movie was made an honorary ambassador and many people working at the UN felt that this was a poor choice because she was sexualized so often in the comics and she lost that position, the fictional character lost that position. And that's true, that's an accurate criticism. of Wonder Woman if you look at certain artists, like Frank Cho or whoever else. But then there's a whole other line of Wonder Woman comics written and drawn by great people like Nicholas Scott and James Simone, which is a totally wonderful version of Wonder Woman. And sometimes these two versions, or multiple versions, are at loggerheads with each other. And as you say, anyone can find any version to support any particular sense. I imagine them being vetted like politicians need to be with people going through all of the back issues trying to find the exact right examples. Which is funny because when we were talking earlier, I was asking if...

you know, why don't Marvel and DC create just completely new superheroes, like make them perhaps more relevant? Because a lot of these myths, like the myth of Wonder Woman and, you know, regardless of how we ground them and interpret them for the time, they've still been with us for a really long time and steeped in times where they were, well, you know, there's a lot of, you know, white, straight male superheroes and that's just a reality. So if we were going to go ahead and make a whole bunch of female-led superhero films... There's not a raft of them to draw from that necessarily resonate as well as the ones that we've been mentioning, like Wonder Woman and Batman and things like that. I mean, I loved Spider Woman. She was awesome. Huntress is great. She could come out of the comics and on screen. She has a little bit with Birds of Prey. Yeah, that's right. And that whole thing was great, and that's spun off a whole bunch of comics. But I think it was still perhaps not quite as successful as these franchises we've been talking about. It's interesting you mention...

kind of pre-existing intellectual property because i would i would add that to the conversation of why superheroes why now why are they so popular and i think also along with cultural reasons it was Technology caught up with superhero visuals. So superhero movies are now like the way to showcase new special effects, which used to be science fiction movies and is now superhero movies, I feel. And also it's just about pre-existing intellectual property. They worked out, hey, everyone knows Spider-Man. We should make more Spider-Man stuff. Well, superhero is a great spreadable content. I mean, you can get a film out of Oliver Twist, but you're not going to get a Teen Park ride, a mobile phone app. The Oliver Twist universe. Yeah, whereas Spider-Man, Batman, Wonder Woman, you can get a Teen Park ride, the interactive experience, and they spread across their ultimate transmedia icons along with Disney princesses. And so why it's really important for every conglomerate like Time Warner and the Walt Disney.

to own a comic book company. So Disney bought Marvel in 2009. Time Warner's owned DC for a long time. Netflix bought Miller World. But they create new Disney princesses. That's true. Well, I mean, they do and they don't because they're always based on, I mean, mythology or fairy tales. So they renovate them and they bring them back. They renovate them. But they do that with the superheroes too. And some stick. Like Miss Marvel's very popular. I imagine she'll stay around for a long time at Com. And some don't last, you know.

because of nostalgia. It wasn't a great back when Bruce Wayne was Batman. Let's go back to that. It wasn't a great back when Steve Rogers was... Well, I guess they did renovate Batwoman, didn't they? And they attempted to be really considerate or thoughtful of how they renovated her, for want of a better term. And then, yeah, I just... I'm so baffled why she didn't stick around in her incarnation, I suppose, but that's probably my personal thing that I need to get over. But, yeah, I think it's interesting that the way that we renovate them speaks to the time, but then what makes that interpretation stick or not is another question as well.

The word myth has come up a few times. And one thing I do think is interesting is, yeah, a lot of the time people do compare superheroes as modern mythology. But the big difference is that mythology wasn't owned by massive multinational corporations. So how do we balance our love of these characters with perhaps the fact that they are owned lock, stock and barrel by massive corporations who may have very different moral codes than the characters they own? I mean, we're in an era of...

participation. I mean, we have been for 15 plus years. So fans aren't happy with what they're saying on screen or on the comic book page. They take ownership of the character. They potentially have more say than ever. Oh, definitely more say than ever. I mean, comics, to be fair, have always tried to narrow the gap between producers and consumers, whether it was, you know, Stan Lee's soapbox in the 1960s or appearances at comic book conventions. And comic book fans, one of the reasons why they are so popular today is because they were the earliest adopters of the web because they've been part of virtual communities for decades. And so while the rest was working for emails, they were, you know, creating the web in their image and moving these characters to the central popular culture. And there has always kind of been that back and forth between the industry and the audience.

to use the example you pointed to where the weapons manufacturer, or whatever they want to call themselves, had a sponsorship deal with Marvel, the fans got on that, and true pressure that deal was dropped. So I do feel like if we're not happy with what we see, as you rightly point out, we have a bigger voice than we've ever had before, and so versions are thrown out, and so on. The problem is though, of course it's an echo chamber, so a finite audience, which might be the longstanding comic book fans who run into cool news or whatever else, can say, well we don't want the Falcon version of Captain America, we don't want Miss Marvel, we don't want the Asian American version of the Hulk, we want the classical ones. And then, you know, sometimes that voice is amplified beyond its actual, the size of the audience.

I'm certainly not the first person to point this out, but I do think there is a grand irony in Marvel training people to sit through the credits of their movies when they've been so bad at crediting the creators of the characters you're watching in those movies throughout the years. Compared to DC, I think. I think that's a pretty low bar. That is true. So we can love these characters, but at the same time we're enjoying the stories of these characters. Potentially the actual human beings working on the characters are not being treated very well throughout history. The comic book industry has so many stories of creators being treated terribly.

There is part of me that would actually love to see these characters fall into public domain. So they would become like Robin Hood or like Hercules. And then we would see anybody could write a Batman story. Anybody could write an Iron Man story. I feel like they've been around for long enough that that should be on the table. But that is a utopian thought that will never be. I was going to say. Which goes back to your point why we never see new superheroes. Because they're locked down and their movies are planned out for the next decade. It's not even that. If I was a comic book creator, you would not produce a character, a new hero from Marvel or DC because you would not own that. So you would wait until you work for a creator-owned publisher like Image.

no matter where there are some equivalent because you don't want to create the next Harley Quinn or Bane or any of those recent characters who've been added to the Batman mythos or similar that become the basis of movies and merchandise and you don't see anything from that. So I just use the Joker again, you know, because why would I waste, you know, my great character on something I'll get paid a pittance for. If superheroes were once stories for children and are now primarily consumed by adults, what do you think that's done to the morality of superhero stories? I definitely think it's complicated it. I mean, I think that...

I mean, I'm going out on a limb here and presuming that the morals are pretty relatively black and white, or at least the stories are simpler for children, whereas for adults, we're often looking for more from a story because we know, we get to a point where we're like, that's not true, you know, and we start to want to investigate these things. So I was really drawn to Jessica Jones, for example, and these ones where, you know, she's not a particularly nice person, but she's going through a lot of really complicated stuff and she's had a, you know, and then you start to look for characters that you can... learn things from and either to learn how to not be or how to be within that really complicated situation and whether it be you know alcoholism or you know she has a lot of PTSD and the control of Oh my goodness, his name has just completely escaped me. Who's her? Killgrave. Killgrave, yeah. And I think they walked that line relatively well, but I mean, it could have gone awry, but that complicated story was gripping for me because I felt like it was saying something that was quite relevant, I guess, for this time. So I think what it does to morals is complicate them. It makes them more compelling stories for me, personally. I find characters who are morally complex, who question themselves because of the powers that they get, and also...

made outside and made to give up a lot of things. It's certainly, basically what I love about stories is when they put people, give them superpowers and make that their crucible, like that's the thing that they have to deal with, as opposed to a supervillain, unless that supervillain is speaking directly to that morally complex problem. It's like, I have superpowers, but I'm really not good at this, or I'm not doing so well, or I have superpowers, but yeah, they're the kinds of stories that resonate with me as an adult. Yeah, I mean the great thing about superheroes is because they're a genre and now everybody knows superheroes, even if you've never read a comic, we've had 15 plus years of movies and TV shows. There is a familiarity there and there's a shorthand.

with the audience or the reader or whoever it might be. So when you do a show like Jessica Jones and someone who's suffering PTSD but she's also a superhero, the shorthand with the audience means that that's created instantly more complex and nuanced because the strongest amongst us is still wrestling with all these problems. I mean, that's what kind of Stan Lee innovated in the 1960s with equally cursed and blessed heroes. And we're seeing it again, whether it's something like Jessica Jones, whether it's something like Logan, that only, I mean, not only works, but if it was a quote unquote original film, wouldn't have the same resonance. But because these are superheroic figures, there is a sort of a...

kind of a tragedy there that would have been like others and their morality is more interesting because we expect them to be whiter than whiter and the best of us and when they fail to do that or they struggle to do that it's more compelling than if they were an otherwise average Joe. I do like that all of the Netflix shows were all about something. So about gentrification, about PTSD. And then you had Iron Fist, which was about... Punching? Punching, I think. Curly hair, cultural appropriation. I don't know. It didn't really have a theme. Yeah. I watched two episodes of it, and that was two episodes too many, so I'm really not qualified to comment on Iron Fist. What changes do you think, morally speaking, superheroes go through moving from comic books onto the big screen or the small screen?

What changes do they go through morally? Yeah, because I have noticed I think there's a lot more killing in superhero movies than there are in superhero comics. Even Captain America and Iron Man are just happily throwing people off the helicarrier in the Avengers. Do you think that's because of the change of medium? Apparently, I mean, the very similitude of a movie, because it's live-action actors, even if it's all CGI bells and whistles, demands consequences. So, you know, people fall off buildings, they're not likely to get up from that, and so on. So I think the change, I mean, the expectation of greater realism that comes with a live-action medium means that we don't have to think about the consequences.

even if a quip from Tony Stark seems to gloss over, you're sort of like, you're not going to get back up out of this. That's true, because of the fast pace of the movie, you're not actually considering the moral implications of everything that they're doing. You're just like, oh, Tony Stark's named Tony Stark, and that's funny, and then throwing people off buildings. Whereas, do you think in the TV series, then, because there is that extended format, there's more room to get into the moral complexity of these characters? There's more time to sort of...

build relationships with the people around them and have that go wrong over here and not necessarily just being about there's a supervillain or there's a drug deal or there's something I need to stop and we have time to talk about Daredevil's backstory with Stick and we have time to talk about Jessica Jones and her best friend. So I think potentially, yes, the format. allows for more investigation, which is really interesting. Pushed far enough, then you end up with Zack Snyder's Man of Steel, which is actually a fascinating mess of a movie where you have Superman kills at the end. You also have Superman kind of symbolically causing 9-11 rather than stopping 9-11, which struck me as a very strange decision for it to make.

Yeah, I mean superheroes have always toppled buildings and I mean the first superhero crossover ever was I think Marvel Comics 8, I think I know it's Marvel Comics 8, it was Human Torch, Submariner teaming up, having a slightly level New York, they dropped buildings like dominoes and that continued for 70 years and then 9-11 happened and people went, oh crap, this isn't carefree anymore, Archie Spiegelman wrote a great comic about it called In the Shadow of No Towers and every comic published since 9-11 has been in the shadow of those No Towers and what they'll often do is they'll find ways to gesture to the fact that that building was empty. or nobody was hurt, or it was nighttime, so everybody was off. And you'll have these sort of little sort of gestures, whether the captions or something a character says. So we didn't go back to the careless destruction. Or if you do have that careless destruction, it becomes the dramatic premises, as you did in the Civil War comic of 2006, which became the film of last year. And Zack Snyder seemed to miss that whole thing. And there was this sort of wild sort of abandon, just topple Metropolis.

And we haven't seen that in a long time. The response to it, I mean, Batman v Superman is partly an apology for that. And it becomes a dramatic premise of that. But I'm not going to credit them with the foresight that they had planted that. But rather they were like, oh, people seem really ticked off. We need to make it the premise of it. And that's why everyone's motivation doesn't make any sense. It doesn't quite make sense why the people of the world love Superman and hate Batman. It makes no sense in that context. But, you know, I'm sure Justice Lee will clear everything else. Slightly tangential question, but I'm just going to put it out there. Has anyone written about the relationship between superheroes and buildings? Not necessarily toppling them, but sitting on them, looking out from them, you know, sitting on...

uh the the stairwells and things that go outside a lot of epiphanies happen there a lot of spying happens there you know um standing next to the gargoyles on the building like though that imagery you know says so much about you know all of what we've been talking about already like surveillance and things like that but also being an outsider and places of repose and things like that so i was wondering in your academic research is that come up there's a whole book called comics in the city which is a really good edit collection and i mean What's great about superheroes is that they're part of this mythological tradition, but westerns are sort of outdated. Unless it's a Tarantino film, people don't care about the western. But the superheroes, basically the westerner, elevate it to near omnipotence and put in an urban environment. And comics lend themselves to the city because they are vertical. And even when, say, The Dark Knight was released in its sequel...

When you saw it in IMAX, it would have a vertical aspect ratio, because that's when they look cool, because they stand tall on tall buildings, and they're built for that. And of course, they emerged in the 1930s, which was a response to modernity. I mean, what was Superman? Superman was able to leave tall buildings in a single bound. Everything he was measured against was measured from the machine.

age, you know, so he was more powerful than a locomotive, whereas previously Tarzan or even Phantom and other characters were measured against the natural world. So superheroes are a response, and what they've done is they reposition that frontier between sort of community conformity and lawlessness and uncertainty that was the Old West to modern urban streets. And that's why they probably have a resonance in a way, one of the reasons why we tend not to slip back into the Western, or even the traditional action movie of the 80s and the 90s, because we don't need them. With the Punisher series about to drop, do you think it is true that there's no good time for a Punisher series? Is there a place for a brutal anti-hero murderer superhero?

It's always plays. It depends on how you do it, I suppose. It's always an audience. It's really... I don't know. I mean, I just finished reading The Punisher by the Garth Ennis tome, and, I mean, I loved it. I really enjoyed the comic, but he has a statement at the front talking about all of the, you know, controversy that goes around The Punisher, and he sort of says, you know, I'm not trying to make any political statements here. I'm just trying to entertain, and that's what I'm doing. It's essentially my very, you know, short version of what he said. It's worth reading, because it was like...

It's interesting that he put that in the front as almost like a justification or like just a, just so you know, like this is the Punisher and this is what he's going to do and da da da and Frank is back. And then, you know, we go over and it's pretty violent. It's a violent comic and I mean, I can't even describe what draws me to it, I suppose, but the TV series is going to be really interesting. I think I'm not sure where I stand on it. I think I would have to see how it's presented. And sometimes weird things get lost in translation, like in the Watchman movie. I felt like the point of Rorschach in the Watchman comic is he's a disgusting, brutal...

like, man. And then in the movie, he's being shot from below with lightning behind him, and you're like, Rorschach's rad. And I'm like, I'm not quite sure that's what Alan Moore was shooting for. No, yeah. I mean, they're all versions of Batman, with the exception of Doctor Man. Everyone, you know, the billionaire, the gadgets-obsessed character, Rorschach was the vigilante aspect, kind of gun seed, really. I think we're actually out of time. So thank you all for coming, and please join me in thanking our guests. You've been listening to an ACMI Conversations podcast. Visit acmi.net.au for information about upcoming events, exhibitions, and film screenings.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ACMI Stories & Ideas?

This episode is 1 hour and 12 minutes long.

When was this ACMI Stories & Ideas episode published?

This episode was published on April 27, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ACMI Stories & Ideas episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.