Skip to content
Additional vessels join search after more noises heard episode artwork

Jun 22, 2023 43 min

Additional vessels join search after more noises heard

from Anderson Cooper 360 Hosted by CNN Podcasts

The massive search operation continues for the submersible that went missing Sunday as officials fear there’s less than a day’s worth of oxygen for the five people onboard. The U.S. Coast Guard said this is still a “search and rescue mission” and they are unsure whether the banging noises picked up by sonar are from the missing sub. Josh Gates is the host of Expedition Unknown on Discovery and did a test dive on the same submersible that’s missing. He tells Anderson Cooper it’s “haunting” to know the same sub he spent time in, is still missing. Plus, the House voted to censure Democratic Rep. Adam Schiff, a key lawmaker in Democrats’ congressional investigations into former President Trump during his presidency. Rep. Schiff joins AC360 to respond to the censure vote. To learn more about how CNN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Additional vessels join search after more noises heard

0:00 43:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Good evening to 9-360, more sounds from under the sea as the race defined the Titan Submersible grows more urgent by the hour. I'll also show you what it's like inside the Titan and talks to someone who reads doubts about its safety. An exclusive CNN reporting from the front lines in Ukraine showing just how difficult the counter offensive underway has been. Good evening we begin tonight with the most urgent deadline there is.

For the five people you see here aboard the Ocean Gate Titan Submersible, missing somewhere in the North Atlantic on the way to the wreck of their Titanic. British businessman, Hamish Harding, British Pakistani businessman Shazada Dawood, and his teenage son, Suleman, French maritime explorer, Paul Henri, Norjele, and Ocean Gate founder Stockton Rush. They are now the subject of a multinational search involving military and civilian ships, aircraft, and expertise which grew larger in size and capability today. The question is, is it enough?

And do they have time? This is a new video from a Canadian Air Force plane normally used to hunt military subs. The entire effort is running on hope that underwater sounds, which were heard again today, are coming from the Titan. But it's also running up against the sub-limited oxygen supply and the possibility that locating a vessel the size of a large car in an area twice the size of Connecticut will simply take more time than they have.

As Jason Carroll is in Boston for us tonight where some of the Coast Guard searchers are based, Jason was the latest. Well, the U.S. Coast Guard says that they are in close contact with family members. As you can imagine, Anderson, the wait for them is agonizing.

Those sounds, those underwater sounds that have been detected have offered them some hope, but time is running very, very short. When you're in the middle of a search and rescue case, you always have hope. That's why we're doing what we do. With what could be less than 24 hours of oxygen left on board Titan, hope at this point may rest on noises detected by Sonar.

The Coast Guard revealed more noises were picked up this morning after a Canadian aircraft dropped a Sonar buoy. With respect to the noises specifically, we don't know what they are, to be frankly. The P3 detected noises, that's why they're up there, that's why they're doing what they're doing. That's why they put Sonar boos in the water.

The sounds are described as banging and first picked up by a Canadian plane yesterday and heard again today. All the acoustic information sent to the U.S. Navy for analysis. Additional resources sent to search the area where the sounds were detected.

The Coast Guard cautioned about drawing conclusions before experts can weigh in. We moved to ask that some research in there and we'll continue to do so. It is encouraging that there did seem to be a pattern to it. And, you know, we're going to continue to hold out hope.

Time is crucial. The rescue window continues to shrink. We are very aware of the time sensitivity around this mission. The vessel was headed to view the Titanic rack that sits nearly 13,000 feet deep but lost contact on Sunday just one hour and 45 minutes into its descent.

Five on board including Ocean Gate CEO and founder Stockton Rush. I'd like to be remembered as an innovator. I think it was General MacArthur said, you remember for the rules you break. And I broke in some rules to make this.

I think I broke in with logic and good engineering behind me. Now questions surrounding the safety of the vessel which was not inspected and classed by an independent group that set safety standards. Most started vessels are carefully inspected, reviewed, then classed. Ocean Gate argues the Titan is not due to the technology being so new that it's not incorporated into existing standards.

Two former employees of Ocean Gate separately brought up safety concerns about the vessel and the thickness of Titan's hull. There was additional testing since the time the employees left the company in 2017 and 2018 so it's unclear if their concerns were addressed. And Jason what more do you know about those banging sounds what they could need? Well Anderson that was one of the questions that I put to the captain at the US Coast Guard here earlier today specifically what more can they tell us what specifics can they tell us about those sounds because the reality is the ocean is a noisy place.

I mean these sounds could be anything from wreckage from the Titanic shifting. It could be sea life, it could be other vessels that are in the area. That is why the acoustic information all that data that they've gathered has been taken to the US Navy so their experts can look at that and try to determine exactly what it is. But again the time is running out that's the bottom line here.

Jason Carroll appreciated if the missing stub is trapped at the bottom of the ocean it could be in water many times deeper than any rescue ever successfully done before. As Tom Foreman joins us now with more on some of the challenges involved in Tom there are huge challenges obviously we don't know how deep this vessel was when contact was lost or where the currents may have taken it but just trying to put him to perspective for us just how deep down this vessel might have gone. Yeah this is an area that is just so incredibly forbidding and so terribly deep. Comparison there's Statue of Liberty, Eiffel Tower, Empire State Building, Saun Grand Canyon, Mount Fuji it's important to bear in mind before you get the Titanic here this is roughly where the deepest underwater rescue ever occurred in 1973 at that level.

This is roughly where nuclear subs operate so this gives you an idea of how forbidding it is and a three-dimensional environment Anderson you're right we have no idea where it might have gone since being up here on the surface. I mean it is incredible when you see when you put in perspective like that the different types of vessels that have been called into health obviously there's air assets there's CSS. Absolutely and right now those that are on the surface of the polar prints was the launching vessel for this these and many of the things in the air their best skill is going to be searching up above. Jason mentioned to go to the searching room or those that have been used to lurking for submarines well we showed you the regular submarines are way up higher up there really important at this point in the equation things like these probes that could drop down lower much lower and give a sense of what's happening on the bottom but you remember the search for the Malaysian airplane they were using things like this and it's a tremendous job to try to cover all that space down there if they can find something then they will turn to a robotic vehicle like this that would be able to go down and possibly attach a line to it to bring it back up but again huge huge job that absolutely takes hours and hours that's what they don't have much of left.

That robotic vehicle that you just circled I think that's from a friendship that's heading to the area but to your earlier point it only goes down to I mean it's 6,000 feet the limit on where it goes down. Right that's a problem with so much of this there are very difficult challenges to even get near this thing one engineer I'd spoken to at one point said that he thought the only way to raise it really would be to try to get some kind of buoyancy on it using robots that can go down lower and attach that way but all of this takes so much time and there's so many possible failures I mentioned that earlier deepest rescue ever they were on scene for many hours and the people were in the water at that much lower level for more than 80 hours before they were rescued and they had full communications the whole time and they knew where they were for most of the time that's very different than what we're dealing with here so even if they find what they're looking for here could be a huge challenge. What do we know about the interior of this immersible itself? The interior of this immersible is really interesting because I'm saving it this to come up here at this moment if you look at the inside of this sub here it's fairly large in a way if you include everything involved but not gigantic five people they're pretty close together they can't really move around a lot inside there and life support for 96 hours for the entire crew that's a give or take thing depending on how much they regulate their breathing how much they control things but the bottom line is you can see they're all fitted together in small space here Anderson no matter what's happening this is not comfortable it'd be a very anxious time and very difficult for these folks so close together.

Yeah I mean it's just a thing to think about this as the hours go by Tom I appreciate it. Once again tonight we have the perspective of a pair of wimmer who has himself involved with two missions attempting to reach the Titanic. How optimistic are you that these banging noises could have come from this missing submersible? I'm extremely confident not 100% sure of course but very confident that these banging noises come from the submersible for several reasons first and foremost because they're not that many banging noises like that out in the middle of the Atlantic it is in a very remote place 700 kilometers when you found them where the Titanic lies that's one number two the noises came as we understand it on the half hour and on the hour i.e.

with 30 minutes segments in between them signaling that they're clearly as a human watch behind it it's quite inconceivable that nature would be so perfectly attuned to to send banging noises on the half an hour and in fact it is common practice within naval distress situations that you bang on the hour and on the half an hour and the reason why you do that is because you allow three minutes of banging to make sure that people know you're there you're in distress and then another 27 minutes to be quiet so that the expedition looking to find you can identify you and it's quiet around you and then on the third minute again you bang again it's common practice within naval and you do have on board the French and navy person Pierre-Marie Nagerlet and he would know that it's interesting i had not considered that the idea that banging on at the top and at the half of each hour which is not a natural occurring cycle in nature would indicate that there there is an idea but i mean that there is a human behind that or an intention behind that banging that is not just some sort of ocean noise that would be occurring every 30 minutes no exactly i mean imagine i mean how unlikely is that the nature would precisely on the half an hour do that banging noise it i mean it's pretty much inconceivable so therefore i think we have a very high degree of confidence that those banging noises come from the submersible and that was actually the good news i learned today that you know they're there they're most likely alive and and we are in with a chance a fighting chance um so so that's a good news if the people on board have less than a day's worth of oxygen left are there things that they can do to try to stretch that supply out i mean obviously you're trying to remain calm um i guess sleeping in order to reduce the amount of you know breath you're taking but is that all that somebody can do absolutely i think that that is that is what you can do take it easy don't stress don't panic use as little energy as you can which is obviously easier said than done in this situation it would be hard not to be freaked out absolutely absolutely i mean anybody in that situation would be horrified and and panicking and and but the good news is i mean people like hamish uh harding who is on board who is a very experienced adventurer explorer he would he would be calm on distress he has been on the on distress before i know he went to the south pole with one of my friends uh and with buss aldering uh so he's he's been in the extreme situations before and there were some problems that happened on that expedition as well so he would he would have the calm and i would have full confidence that that that he's a good player to have on board Stockton uh as well um experienced uh um explorer as well but would also hopefully keep the calm but having said that one thing is the oxygen side of things and as also the co2 that that's being breathed that people are breathing out and that comes to point obviously will obviously be too much co2 and too little oxygen effectively so it is really a race against time and um something close to a i wouldn't say miracle or something but will have to happen pretty soon because we are really really running a tightrope here ideally the submersible will start to come up by itself so unless that vehicle can somehow surface on its own um i mean that that is where that's where the hope really still still lies and that is obviously the best case scenario for the vehicle to be able to surface on its own somehow even though it seems it has not been able to do that i mean because all of this the aerial searching all of which is important because not only placing some on our devices which is why we know about the the banging sounds um but also in case this vehicle has surfaced it's critical to get to that vehicle even though it's surfaced because the people inside can't get out until it's actually recovered yeah that's correct um however with with all the airplanes in the air they had the moment and provided that the the weather is okay or decent um one should be able to uh locate the submersible should have come up to the surface uh hopefully relatively quickly pair uh we're not we appreciate your your time tonight thank you thank you very much coming up next the safety issues surrounding the ocean gate titan and we'll talk with explore josh gay to head concerns of his own after a test dive on it and later we'll talk to congressman adam shift on his confrontations with c he goes about saying that any trip by humans to the bottom of the ocean carries considerable risk there are not many submersible vehicles that can even reach the depth of the titanic lies that said as jason carol touch on his report there are specific questions about this specific vehicle uh vessel in a moment someone who took a test dive on and came back with questions of his own to first see him escape code we are all in a position right now saying what could we have done will konin remembering back to 2018 when he says he penned a letter first obtained by the new york times to ocean gate ceo stocked in rush warning that what he called the company's experimental approach could have serious consequences this is a extremely difficult situation to be in konin who heads the submarine committee of the marine technology society was concerned that ocean gate wasn't following the same safety standards as other vessels because the titan hadn't gone through independent testing and wasn't certified by an industry group which he says isn't required to dive in international waters but is an industry standard there are 10 submarines in the world that can go 12 000 feet and deeper out of those 10 all of them are certified except the ocean gate some are so you believed this expedition would be too dangerous without being certified yes he says he spoke to stock and rush and voiced those concerns we agree to disagree many of us do feel that it may have been preventable if the vehicle had been certified in a 2019 blog post ocean gate defended the company's decision saying certifying titan could take years and stifle innovation and while they'd use those standards as a benchmark in the past quote by itself clashing is not sufficient to ensure safety what's the last rush who's one of the missing crew has touted his maverick approach to innovation you know i broken some rules to make this i think i've broken with with logic and good engineering by me the carbon fiber titanium there's a rule you don't do that well i did it's taking the rules that you break that are the ones that will add value to others and add value to society but that approach drew criticism from some of his own staff cnn has learned two former ocean gate employees neither of whom are engineers raised safety concerns when titan was built in a counter lawsuit one claimed ocean gate hadn't performed adequate testing on the titan's hole to check its structure and the other told cnn he was concerned when that carbon fiber hole arrived and was only five inches thick rather than seven inches as he says the company had assured both said their concerns were dismissed by rush and ocean gate management and the company face lawsuits in recent years seeking to recoup payments from those who had hoped to go on titanic excursions after several equipment or weather issues caused the trips to be delayed as the frantic search intensifies konin says there's one component he wishes were on the vessel a working beacon it would be making a huge difference if it had a beacon so that someone could direct themselves in that direction and anderson cnn has reached out to ocean gate about these various claims so far they've declined to comment anderson thank you so much so those are some of the safety concerns we're joined out by someone who had a chance to assess those risks themselves first hand after test i've with the ocean gate on the titan josh gates is the host of expedition unknown on our sister channel discovery josh thanks for being with us i want to talk about your experience on titan but first just i'm wondering what's been going through your mind of the past few days having been on this thing watching this it's been very surreal it's been haunting you know i spent quite a bit of time with sopton and quite a bit of time at the ocean gate headquarters up in ever washington and and so dive on on titan as they were putting it through its paces to get ready for the initial titanic missions in 2021 so having spent time in the sub um you know my mind reels to think about it i also know hamish harding uh who's aboard who's a fellow member of the explorers club and so it's obviously a really difficult challenging time what was it like being inside the titan back in 2021 you know i think the thing that people have to understand is how novel this vessel is you know there are as was just said in the previous piece there are very few submersibles that can reach titanic's deaths and all of them with the exception of titan are made in a much different way there is a person else fear which is made of um held together with titanium or with steel and titan's pressure hall is completely different it is made of carbon fiber and carbon fiber as you know is this you know kind of miracle polymer it's what's in the bone dream liner it's what's in the year bus a 350 and with it comes this lightweight machine and because it's more lightweight it could be made bigger so when you see titan up close one of the things that really strikes you is it's fairly large it can hold more people all of the other vehicles that go down to titanic and only hold two or three people but because of this carbon fiber design on titan it can be made larger and five people can go inside of it and so um but with that innovation with that novel design comes a really important trade-off which is how much do we know about how this carbon fiber can perform at depth and in terms of the pressure and the temperatures and in terms of fatigue and it just isn't a lot of data out there about that and so on one hand you have this incredibly innovative novel design on the other hand there are a lot of unknowns so i i mean i assume that's a business decision that this company made because they wanted to be able to bring paying passengers who are paying a lot of money to come down so you need a interior space that allows for you know several passengers um are there other i think i think that's true i also think it's true though that if you've ever been in any of these smaller submersibles they are extremely claustrophobic and you are really pinned in a trip down to the titanic is a fairly long expedition and i think that one of the things that titan was also offering is the ability to just have a little more room and not be in such a claustrophobic environment so i'm sure it was business driven but i also think that stopping really saw it as an innovation in terms of the design of these subs and and how roomy that could be i understand you were on titan because you wanted to perhaps do an episode of your show highlighting ocean gates technology ultimately decided not to go forward with it can you talk about why you made that decision not to try it yeah you know we were up there in 2021 so this was just before the season where they were going to bring the first passengers out to titanic this was really a shakedown dive to see how the sub would perform and we went up there really to see how we might film this you know we knew we'd only be able to put one camera operator inside the sub with me and so we were really interested in how we might mount cameras and make things work and of course though going out on titan and diving down inside of it it just became clear to us at that time that there was a lot that still needed to be worked out with the sub it just come back from the east coast where it had undergone some pressure testing it had just been rebuilt effectively and a lot of the systems worked but a lot of them really didn't we had issues with thrusters and issues with computer control and things like that and ultimately it was a challenging dive we were insight titan for two or three hours and there were a lot of things that weren't really ready for prime time it seems i think beyond that there were real questions about the support vessel that was going to be used with titan they hadn't really formalized that deal and we started to have real questions about the timetable you know making a television program you need to have some reliability of when this can happen in the window in which it might happen ultimately i just felt by the end of that trip that i just couldn't get comfortable with with titan at that time i felt that it needed time to go out and do missions and kind of get into a groove before we were going to go and film with it it just wasn't for me and just this is supposed to have the ability to drop weight so that if something happens it will naturally surface are you aware of what those systems were that were in place at the time that you were on it yeah you know lots been said about i think things that are not that important the video game controller and the simplicity of the cabin there were a lot of other systems on board titan that offered real redundancies in terms of safety and the weight system is one of them there were effectively at least my understanding in 2021 there were four different ways that titan could shed weight to come back to the surface there was first of all a computer controlled weight release system that could release weights there was also a manual valve system where you could turn a valve and actually inject air into you know exterior ballast containers and float it up to the surface there was also a hydraulically controlled system that could drop weights and finally if you look at titan it sits on a kind of sled that entire sled could be ditched manually which takes a ton of weight off the vehicle and can help it back to the surface so you know hypothetically if there is an emergency of board titan there are a lot of systems to shed weight and bring the vehicle back to the surface right the question is why why hasn't it come back to the surface and we simply don't know that judge case i really appreciate you being on thank you absolutely thank you and still had a look at other deep ocean search and rescue missions and what they tell us about the options ahead for saving those on board as rescuers race to get to the search site the question remains about what they can do when they actually get there even if they locate where the sub is underwater you heard earlier guess where we ever talk about that a rescue would be incredibly challenging complex but it is not unheard of here's Randy k a different ocean decades earlier and a frantic search more than a thousand feet beneath the surface it was 1973 and rescue teams were searching for a commercial submersible known as the Pisces 3 it had disappeared off the coast of Ireland two British sailors Roger Malinson and Roger Chapman spent three days trapped in the vessel which was about six feet in diameter they had been laying transatlantic telephone cable when the rope connecting their submersible to the main ship snapped they survived on a single sandwich and some extra oxygen they had on board Malinson spoke with sign news luckily before we started the dive i stole a bottle of oxygen and because we stole it i'm still here otherwise we certainly wouldn't have been here the Pisces 3 was trapped more than 1,500 feet below sea level around 150 miles off cork island the men inside avoided speaking to conserve air rescuers were reportedly able to locate the vessel using sonar by making one of the sailors sing high notes crews were finally able to bring the sub to the surface using a tow rope by the time the men were freed they had just 12 minutes of oxygen left according to the Guinness book of world records it was the deepest water rescue ever it took 84 hours to rescue us about a decade earlier officials lost contact with the USS thresher hundreds of miles off the coast of Cape Cod the nuclear attack submarine was doing deep diving tests when its communications became garbled no sooner had the tender skylock reported something a miss then maybe search teams went into action there was optimism at first maybe her communication equipment was faulty with the hours hope way 129 officers crewmen and civilian technicians perished when the USS thresher sunk what was left of the submarine was eventually located by other ships about 8,400 feet below the surface in 1939 the squalice submarine sank during a test dive off the coast of new hamsher 26 people on board died immediately but doesn't survive a marker was spotted and the navy put new rescue techniques in cooperation a bell was attached to the sub and 33 men of the 59 men crew were rescued more than 30 crew members reportedly survived using smoke bombs and Morse code to signal for help you couldn't see anything I'm sure we didn't do anything around we had we had battle damage what we just felt like a big flashlight say hand-manner they call them electric but they tried to conserve those because they didn't be down more recently in 2000 the kursk a russian nuclear submarine sank 350 feet below the surface during a training accident in the arctic circle rescue missions failed due to high waves and strong winds also the hull of the sub had trouble attaching to the rescue vessel there were very few chances for rescue but some exist in the end all 118 sailors on board perished it took months to pull the 18,000 ton vessel from the ocean floor and recover the bodies randy k cnn as we mentioned time and oxygen are both running low for more than that i want to bring in dr eileen marty who's a retired needy physician so knows well the challenges at hand here dr marty appreciate you being with us can you just explain the the impact of the dwindling oxygen supply and also carbon dioxide that's right and i'm glad you mentioned carbon dioxide because obviously as they lose oxygen the carbon dioxide builds up i don't know if the vessel has the capacity to extract that carbon dioxide whether that's the merciful was built with that in mind we also don't actually know what's going on right now they may not be alive right now there may have been a leak in that porthole it might have been a catastrophic leak in which case the individuals they may already have drowned which is horrible and if they're still alive and we're looking at dwindling oxygen that the the decrease in oxygen getting to the brain and that increase in carbon dioxide is is a very panicky situation you feel your world closing in it's like everything gets narrower like it's in a tunnel and it's a it's a horrific sensation that that people get they sense that they're dying they can't believe that they're losing their life in this horrific way it's just it's just hard i was wondering about that earlier today i mean not to you know go down i mean it does when knows you feel you feel like you feel like you know you're done you feel like you're done you can you sense that you become weaker you become disoriented you have lots of focus and you have a loss of the ability to see so you lose your peripheral vision it's it's a horrific way to die you then just pass out eventually they do pass out yes but before that they go through this and then again remember we don't know if there wasn't a fire on board that ship no doubt they have batteries the batteries can for a variety of reasons malfunction and if so there may be carbon monoxide in the atmosphere of that submersible that would already have made the individuals succumb so carbon monoxide that's something i had we hadn't considered that would come from batteries or having a fire any kind of other secondary problems that may have happened on board because right now we have no communication and so that's an indicator that something else may have led to the fact that we can't find the yes in person is there anything people can do to conserve their oxygen situation i mean obviously i've read you know sleeping which would seem hard to do in a situation like this with all the the fear involved and obviously not talking so much and not getting upset well it's also very cramped in there which makes everybody all five of them being able to sleep very challenging and the fear that you mentioned that's a huge factor because it leads to stress and the stress in turn is going to affect every organ in the body and anyone with a sensitive heart could then have a heart attack because of this situation of low oxygen and stress so there's a lot that's going on in that little tiny it's a nurse at the right now. Dr. Mardi, I appreciate being with us thank you. My pleasure.

Coming up Democratic Congressman Adam Schiff was censured today it's only the third time this century that a US congressman has been censured his fellow Democratic congressman loudly chanted shame at House Republicans in response. Congressman Schiff joins me next. Breaking news just over an hour ago for only the third time this century a member of congress was censured Democratic Congressman Adam Schiff in a deeply partisan vote led by the majority House Republicans. The A's are 213 and the A's are 209 with six answering president the resolution adopted without objection the motion to consider is laid on the table.

House be in order. In the background there you could hear Democrats in the chamber shouting shame and later disgrace we're joined out by Congressman Adam Schiff. Congressman I appreciate being with us. What's your response to this censure?

Well look it's a badge of honor as Roosevelt said in his time was sometimes a good judge of a person by the enemies they make and this was a mega resolution that Donald Trump threatened if any Republican voted against as many had last week that they would be subject to a primary challenge. So this is basically Trump and Maga world going after someone they think is effective in standing up to them and so I feel like I've earned their opposition and was proud to stand with all my Democratic colleagues and oppose this you know flagrant abuse of the House process. Do you have any regrets on how you handle the Russia issue obviously the former president was never criminally implicated for anything involving Russia? No not at all.

I think the investigation of his misconduct was very important. It ultimately led to his impeachment which I was proud to lead and it led to the first bipartisan vote to remove a president in US history. I was also proud to serve on the January 6th committee and I would do all of that again and I would do it the same way but what is really the the gravimant of the offense here is I feel it was effective at holding him to account and if the need were to rise again if God help us if it does I would do it all over again. The special counsel John Durham also testified today before the House Judiciary Committee which you were a big part of.

I want to play part of your exchange which with him where you were asking about a June 2016 meeting between Donald Trump Jr and a Russian lawyer to potentially get damaging information on that presidential candidate Hillary Clinton. And you think it's insignificant that he had a secret meeting with the Russian delegation for the purpose of getting dirt on Hillary Clinton and the only disappointment to express that meeting was that the dirt that got wasn't better. You don't think that significant? I don't think that that was a well advised thing to do.

Oh not well advised. Well that's that's the understatement of the year. So you think it's perfectly appropriate or or maybe just ill advised or a presidential campaign to secretly meet with a Russian delegation to get dirt on their opponent you would merely say that's inadvisable. If you're asking what I do and I hope I wouldn't do it but it was not illegal.

It was stupid foolish, ill advised. You clearly don't agree with Mr. Durham's description. Well you know what was fascinating about the hearing today was the degree to which it revealed both his ignorance of a lot of what was in the Mueller report but also the degree to which he is a biased actor.

There you saw him really trying to downplay the significance of the president, the former president's son, arranging a secret meeting in Trump Tower to receive what had been represented to him as derogatory information about Hillary Clinton. That was part of the Russian government's effort to elect Donald Trump. That's how it was represented to him. He was happy to accept it.

He was disappointed during the meeting as there were others in Trump's campaign that what they got wasn't more valuable. And to see this special counsel talk nothing about the danger of Russian interference on our elections and downplay seeking help from foreign power revealed a lot about his bias. It was interesting to see how during this hearing both Democrats and Republicans at time seemed equally unhappy with Durham for different reasons. Congressman Matt Gates was calling Durham quote part of the cover up.

I'm wondering what you made up the GOP response to his testimony. Well I mean you know the Matt Gates's and the Donald Trump's and others are deeply disappointed because this was a four-year investigation. It was supposed to uncover this deep state conspiracy. Biden was supposed to be indicted and Clinton was supposed to be indicted and got news who else.

Of course none of that materialized. The most he was able to come up with is he believed in his opinion. The FBI was justified in opening a preliminary investigation but not a full investigation. That was it.

Talk about a nothing burger. The two cases he brought to trial he both he lost. The defendants were acquitted in a matter of hours and and so yes I think the MAGA world was deeply upset with that. They tried to put the best ban on it they can but compared to the expectations they set and what was delivered they're deeply upset with him.

Congressman Adam Ship I appreciate your joining us. Thank you. Thank you. Just ahead as Ukraine claims more gains in its counter-offensive scene has been wedoment.

It takes a trip to recent liberated village in southern Ukraine what he saw next. In Ukraine tonight officials say a brutal and slow counter-offensive is pushing forward top military leaders today claimed advances in the south saying Russian forces are on the defensive around the Zapparisha and Hearsan regions. This comes as heavy fighting continues in eastern Ukraine. Ukraine's military said today that Russia conducted several what they called unsuccessful offensives around there.

Soon as bad wedoment went to a village in Ukraine that was recently liberated from the Russians and we want to warn you some of the images you're about to see or disturb. An unknown Russian soldier lost his life here on a dirt road in the small village of Neskuchinin. He was killed in Ukraine's counter-offensive which has at best so far put a small dent in Russian lines hardly the turning point so many had hoped for. This is one of the villages that was liberated by the Ukrainians this one on the 10th of June and clearly the Russians were in a hurry they left behind this blood-soaked stretcher.

It's still too dangerous for civilians to return to these once tranquil farming communities and there isn't much left for them to return to. The mortar crew of the 35th Ukrainian Marine Brigade has moved into a house recently vacated by Russian troops. This afternoon their busy piling up newly arrived American made shells. Far better than the old Soviet ammunition says, Andri.

Amazing they're just great he says. They hit the bullseye my favorite. Throughout the day shelling echoes around them the Russians may have left the village yet they're still nearby. Yuri's mortar training in Britain didn't prepare him for the front.

This is only his third day in the line of fire. There are moments when I want to hide his says but I have to stay put and wait. Unit commander Alex Sundor takes coordinates from headquarters. His men make the adjustments and prepare the rounds.

They're firing these rounds at Russian lines which are four kilometers or two miles away. It's going to be a long hot summer. Ben Wiedemann joins us now. Ben what are you creating authority saying about the progress of their counter-offensive so far?

Well what we heard today is actually President Zelensky saying that progress has been slower than expected. He said in an interview that this isn't a Hollywood movie and things don't happen just now. And what's clear is that things are difficult when we were up at the front today. What we heard from the soldiers is that even when they're able to force Russian troops to retreat they oftentimes come under intense artillery from the Russians and the Russians have throughout this war really used their superiority and just the sheer number of artillery pieces that they have to really unleash these punishing barrages.

So there were high expectations before this offensive began that it would be similar to what we saw last year in September in the Harkiv region where the Ukrainians in just about two weeks took an incredible amount of territory more than 4,600 square miles this time the going is much more difficult and much slower. Anderson Ben Wiedemann in Ukraine for us tonight thank you so much Ben. Still to come a forever honor for a deported American legend congressman John Lewis just ahead. John Lewis the man who was in an inshupist life on the Eman Pettus Bridge while leaving the Civil Rights March from Selma to Montgomery Alabama and later became a US congressman was honored today.

Congressional leaders and US postal officials revealed a new forever stand honoring the life of John Lewis who was a true American hero died almost three years ago. News continues in the end from time what Caitlin Collins starts now. From the descendants of history makers involved in the Louisiana purchase to the Lewis and Clark expedition discover the untold stories of American expansion in the CNN original series this land premiering June 7 on CNN. Hey I'm Anderson Cooper on my podcast all there is we explore grief and loss in all its complexities as Ken Burns said on an earlier podcast the half-life of grief is endless.

Riska Hargate knows that very well Jane Mansfield was killed in a car crash in 1967. Riska was in the car with her after decades spent coming to terms with her past and wanting to learn more about the mother she doesn't remember. Riska has made a remarkable documentary called My Mom Jane. Our vulnerability is our greatest strength and our greatest connector and so in telling the story I don't feel vulnerable I feel free we all have a story and you never know what somebody else carries.

Talking grief building community that's what the podcast is all about this is all there is listen and follow wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Anderson Cooper 360?

This episode is 43 minutes long.

When was this Anderson Cooper 360 episode published?

This episode was published on June 22, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Anderson Cooper 360 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.