this podcast is an audio recording of a live event it may reference visual material that cannot be represented in this recording it may also contain strong language and adult themes the opinions expressed in this podcast do not necessarily reflect those of acme Today's keynote speaker, Jennifer McArthur, founder and principal at Borderline Media from New York. Her background spans nearly 20 years working in radio, film and television, digital media and publishing. In 2008, she founded Borderline Media. It's a strategic design company aiming to bring impact production to the foreground. Alongside working on the campaigns of numerous films, such as Southern Rights, Out in the Night, Gideon's Army, Traces of the Trade, she's also worked as a consultant on Three and a Half Minutes, American Promise, Dirty Wars, Valentine Road, to name a few.
In my mind, she is one of the few people in the space who's working to construct a coherent understanding around what impact production can and should mean, publishing articles and consulting with institutions such as the Sundance Institute, BritDots, Tribeca Enterprises, aiming to carve out workable definitions and formalise the field. She started the Impact Producers Group in the USA to unite those in the field, an idea so genius that I, along with Alex Kelly, shamelessly ripped off here in Australia. So we now have an Australian and New Zealand Impact Producers Group, in case you want to join. Jen wrote once. And this is a quote, an impact producer is an executive director of a lean impact type startup. This is not your mother's outreach coordinator, end quote. She's pushed boundaries and in turn had her boundaries pushed. And if we can still use the term, she's a passionate advocate for justice, an intellectual, an activist and a real renaissance woman, a force of nature. It is my absolute pleasure to welcome Jennifer to the stage as our impact keynote to talk on what is sure to be a controversial topic on social impact film in an age of austerity. Please give her a round of applause. So good morning.
My name is Jennifer MacArthur. As I said, I came in from New York a couple of days ago to join you all. And I want to thank Britt and Alice and Alex Kelly and the whole team here at AIDC for welcoming me to Australia. It's my first time here, first time in this part of the world. And it's been a pretty amazing experience so far. And I hope it's not my last time coming. So I better get this keynote right or I'll never be asked back again. I want to begin by acknowledging the indigenous people.
here the traditional owners of this land and paying my respects to their elders past and present before i before i begin my my talk um And let people know how honored I am to kick off this day. I think, you know, clearly this word impact and the excitement around impact has become is a giant elephant in the room for many people working in documentaries. Some of us have been working in documentary for quite some time. And it might be exciting and thrilling that the field has taken this direction in terms of bringing the sort of social issue and social justice focus into our work. And for some people, it might be.
a little frightening and they're wondering, why has this beast sort of taken over what seems to be so much of the work that we do? I know that in the US, we've been probably a good 10 years into sort of having these conversations around what impact is and how to define it and why you would do it and how you do it. being a part of those conversations early and continuing to talk with people and see how the concept and the way of doing this work has been kind of spreading outward from the US and the UK and into other areas of the world has been exciting and challenging at the same time. So I want to speak a little bit about how I see some of the challenges and some of the things that I think our exciting possibilities and potential to do this work effectively and meaningfully, you know, as you all here in Australia seem to be really getting situated and sort of the last couple years now having good pitch and sort of all these other big films like Rackman and stuff like that.
So I started my work officially, started my company in 2008. I had been spending some time for a few years before that working as a sort of long-term consultant for different projects and doing much the same kind of work, but at the time it wasn't called impact producing. That phrase, you know, I don't know how much of the history I need to give, but I think it's good context so people can understand sort of where the stuff is coming from. That term, impact producer, was really coined by the Brick Dock Foundation. I applied to and was invited to participate in 2012, I think it was. The end of 2012, there were 12 of us that went out to the UK. Two of us were Americans, everybody else was from the UK. But 12 people that were sort of part of this initial group that got together with Brick Dock.
some other key industry leaders to talk about, you know, what we saw were the shifts and the changes in the way that the documentary film was being used for social change work and try to articulate and establish some best practices, right, for people because this work was growing and try to understand, you know, what does it mean? How do we talk about it? And when I when I joined that group of people. I had already spent a few years working in different parts of the media sector, not specifically in film, but having worked in public broadcasting in the U.S., advising the station community and independent producers and other system organizations on how to distribute content in the new media landscape that we're in, how to use digital effectively, how to engage people online and in communities. And also having spent some time in the public radio sector, thinking about journalism and how...
you know, how to incorporate some of the thinking around, you know, community engagement and social change into, you know, effectively and meaningfully, but still carefully in sort of the more, quote unquote, objective journalism space. And having spent some time working with a lot of interactive, you know, early interactive projects. So, and I kind of had this varied experience and working across multiple different areas of what I would call, you know, public media and non-profit social justice media, intertwined, not the same, when I came to get together with the BritDoc Foundation. and the 11 other folks. So they brought up this term, impact producer. This is what we think it is, an impact producer. And it was actually really a wonderful thing because it was the first time there was a term that seemed to kind of describe a little bit better than the other stuff what I do for a living, which people still, you know, I still cannot explain to a lot of people what this is that we do because it's so varied and multifaceted and requires so many different kinds of skill sets to be effective. I came out of that meeting, you know, excited about the possibilities because
Finally, somebody had acknowledged and recognized the role that myself, strategists like myself and other people that I knew of, the really critical, important role that people had been playing on many film projects, but kind of in the background and not being acknowledged as such. And kind of being, I don't know what the word is I'm looking for, but essentially being workers sometimes exploited because there was no acknowledgement of the role that we played. There was no terminology to explain to somebody what an impact producer is and what they do. So when I came back from this meeting in 2012, I was really excited to get together with the other strategists and the other outreach coordinators and distribution specialists and all these different people, interactive producers and outreach engagement coordinators that I knew who were doing sort of this high-level strategy work.
but really not getting the sort of significant, you know, acknowledgement of the work that they were doing. And even when I had attended that meeting with the crew at BrickDoc, I was the only person of the 12 that was a hired gun, right? Somebody who wasn't an actual filmmaker that wanted to then, after they produced their film, then take it out in the world and work with it, or somebody who didn't work at an NGO. essentially a political campaigner that wanted to use, you know, incorporate the use of media into what they did, like Greenpeace or something like that. You know, this this thing that is called impact producer, which I think for a lot of people, and I'm not sure how true this is here yet in Australia, but for a lot of people now in America and the UK, you know, sort of thought of as this, you know, consultant that comes on. That was not that was not sort of how originally was from from what I could tell originally perceived. Right. So it kind of became this thing as we as many of us started to organize, essentially, and to get together.
on forming what I call the Impact Producers Group, which two of my wonderful colleagues here who have been a part of those conversations in the U.S. have formed a chapter here. So I encourage any of you who are really interested in this work and developing skills and sharing resources and knowledge to learn more about the Impact Producers Group in Australia and get together with Alex or Alice who can help connect you to the network. So one of the things, one of the reasons why we formed the group It's not only because we, you know, yay, we're excited, we're a real thing, but also because many of us were finding that the trends we're taking, that the larger trends in the field were absent of some sort of critical sort of key parts of the work that we do, which is sort of a deep sociopolitical and economic analysis, okay? So we're going to go right here, right now. So much of the work, you know, that was being held up and sort of talked about was important, but much of it seemed to...
seem to not really understand or not really key in on sort of the deep social movements and networks and activists and organizers and scholars and all of the people that we were connected to in the way that we do our work as sort of part of the way of thinking about using media for social change and for social justice, right? That term social justice has really gotten out of favor, and now it's social impact. And so, you know, impact being devoid of this piece around justice, around this is sort of what I want to talk about today. And I think, you know, there are very intelligent and wonderful and smart people who have been critiquing this sort of issue, this challenge that we have around all of social change and social justice work, you know, writ large, that doesn't have anything to do with media. You know, people like Iron Daugherty Roy talking about the NGOization of resistance and other, you know.
socialist and left critics looking at, you know, social innovation and how, you know, that has become such a buzz and a thing that everybody from governments on down to, you know, corporations want to invest in and sort of the links between the divestment in the state and in. public resources and tax dollars going into shared, you know, common public resources in the West, you know, this move toward austerity to privatize everything, and how while that's been going on, there's been the simultaneous interest in the rise of social innovation and the NGO space and all of these groups that are essentially taking the place of what used to be our shared common, you know, investment in public infrastructure, in public education.
Just in public culture, in the production of culture, any one of us working in public podcasting clearly knows, at least in the UK and in the US, how the funding is being slowly drained out of those spaces. And we're all expected to now get funding from foundations or private investors or corporate foundations to fund this work. So all of those are true and all of those trends are real. And they are having an impact, I think, on our field. And while, oh my God, is that me? I hope that wasn't me. I'd be the worst person in the world to let my cell phone go off on my own keynote address. If that happens again, I'm sorry. But I think while all those things are true.
There also is people who generally really care about this work, that are wonderful people, that start incredible NGOs, that work in foundations, that care very much about social change and social justice, and are doing what they can inside of these structures that currently exist to address our social ills. And what I've observed is that our field tends to overestimate the salience of our strategies in this work while simultaneously underestimating the power of what's happening in the public discourse that we have no control over. That's just happening out in the world writ large among people. And as much lip service that we give toward how much the world has changed because of digital and because of social media, we still...
function as if we live in a 20th century world where we can control the message and we are the one individual that sends it out to the audience and the audience then receives our message in exactly the way that we want them to receive it and talk about it and think about it. And, you know, Facebook and Twitter and you can say what you want about how those things are structured and owned and all of that. But the opportunity that it's given for people to surface real dialogue coming directly from their perspectives and in conversation with each other is enormous. And it cannot be overstated how important this is to the work of impact producing. Now, when I say we tend to overestimate the salience of our strategies, part of what I mean is that, at least in America, documentary and public broadcasting is niche media culture, right?
And I know no one, we definitely don't like to hear that, but it is in fact true. And that's true for pretty much all other, all media, right? Everything is niche media at this point. The general audience, the concept of general audience is kind of gone out the window because we live in this very fragmented media landscape. So for at least in the US, unless you're at the Super Bowl or you're a presidential campaign, your film or media is not creating a shared general audience moment, right? It's not a shared moment. It's not something that 100 million people experience all at once and talk about all at once and think about all at once and receive and see all at once, right? Your film or media exists across time and space at different points in the public dialogue. So a good example of this is, and I don't know how far this has gotten here, but Beyonce.
her recent appearance at the Super Bowl, where she basically celebrated the Black Panthers and Malcolm X, gave a nod to Malcolm X in her performance at the Super Bowl, which was viewed by 112 million Americans. That is a shared media moment, a mass culture moment. And if you compare that to the show Breaking Bad, for example, which is a critical media darling considered extremely popular, for its grand series finale, it only drew 10.3 million viewers, right? But if you were to listen to the way that people talk about film and media critics and media scholars and media critics talk about the importance of Breaking Bad, you would think that it had 100 million viewers, but it didn't, right? This is a big fiction, huge success, one-tenth of what the Super Bowl did.
So if you look at documentary broadcasts, and I'm talking mostly about television here for the purposes of this conversation, you know, they're all obviously there are other ways to get your film seen and public screenings are incredibly important. And we'll sort of play with that a little bit. But documentary broadcast premieres in the US are a smash hit if they get 20 percent of the audience that Breaking Bad does. Right. So when I say niche media culture, that's what I mean in the sense of it is not a shared moment, a mass shared moment. So while that's happening.
While we know this for a fact to be true, we can look at the numbers and we understand this. The trend in the now being called impact filmmaking, which I'm not sure I know what that means exactly, but I guess I have to use that term. The trend in impact filmmaking in our space is to create documentaries with mainstream audience appeal in order to position them in such a way that we can drive or affect the national and even international public dialogue, right? And we're mainstreaming documentary storytelling. And that seems to sort of go hand in hand with this sort of impact strategy that's very simplified and sort of lowest common denominator that can reach anybody by appealing to a general audience aesthetic. So even though we know for a fact that the biggest moment in time when a film is going to be seen with the most eyeballs is still maybe only 2 million people, if we're lucky, we're still pushing the field toward attempting to ape sort of the mainstream media pop culture kind of presentations of somebody like a Beyoncé.
who's going to get 112 million viewers when she goes on television, right? So that's a problem. And it's a problem because we're facing really, really critical social problems. Police brutality, equal access to education, contaminated water, the worldwide refugee crisis, because it is worldwide, essentially, right? Just a few things to name.
And they're caused by really complex sets of variables. These are not things that you can do one thing and fix. You've got to attack it from multiple ends because it's a very complex, these are very complex problems. It's not enough to just tell somebody to get out and vote or to petition their Congress critter, you know, who, by the way, is probably funded. Their campaigns are funded by the very forces that are part of the problem that are creating these issues, right? So we're being asked to appeal to the better natures and the power of political forces oftentimes that have been compromised by big money in politics, that we haven't addressed those structural problems. So, you know, maybe the most effective way we can influence the mass public conversation isn't to try to become, you know, that mass media spectacle. Maybe it's to situate ourselves in this fragmented media landscape.
in a way that we can respond when the right opportunity presents itself. Because to do so, to try to do that other thing, is to actually compromise the real potential for social change. Now, I want to point to this example of Beyonce to sort of tease out this a bit. Because she did her performance about a week before Stanley Nelson's documentary Black Panther's Vanguard of the Revolution had its broadcast premiere on PBS. Now, I saw almost immediately after the Super Bowl performance among my networks of people, you know, looking on Facebook and Twitter and things like that who work in the documentary film space. So very, very excited about Beyonce's performance. And there was a temptation, which which often happens for us to, again, to overestimate the salience of our strategies by saying, look, Stanley Nelson's film has been out for a year on the circuit. It premiered at Sundance. It's had this film festival run. It's had all these great conversation. And look at how it has influenced the Super Bowl.
Right. Someone kind of said that on Facebook. And I had to kind of like, really? And I'm not saying it's not true. It's not it's not impossible that that Beyonce somehow saw Stanley Nelson's film and decided that she was going to strategize to create a whole public performance at the Super Bowl based on the influence that she thought that film was having on the larger national public dialogue.
What might have been more true, and again, the filmmakers can correct me, I will ask Stanley when I get back if this is wrong, but what might have been probably more true is that it was the 50th anniversary of the Black Panthers being established. She was in the Bay Area where the Black Panthers were partly established, and she did her performance based on the, you know, also on the video that she had just released the day before. That probably sounds like a more accurate assessment of the order of how those things influenced each other. So when Beyonce gets out there and she does her halftime performance, she sort of unleashes this public dialogue online about the Black Panthers, right? All of a sudden, it's just crazy amounts of information. And immediately, which is interesting because they didn't actually say much about the Black Panthers. The song doesn't reference the Black Panthers at all. They just got into some very sexy outfits that resembled the Black Panther beret and the whole thing.
So she puts out this performance and she unleashes this huge public discourse. And immediately, our Fox News, my former mayor, Mayor Giuliani, and a one-time presidential candidate, gets out there and critiques this and sort of problematizes her performance for the public discourse by calling it anti-cop. And that's within a day or two after the performance. And then by the end of the week, Saturday Night Live, which is the comedy show on live comedy show on Saturday evenings, satirizes that conservative backlash to Beyonce's performance with this crazy video about Beyonce turning black and how it's affecting white consciousness that they didn't realize that Beyonce was a black person until that moment when she came out so pro black. Actually, really.
And very, very funny, right? So there was this very serious conservative backlash to Beyonce's very fluffy kind of light performance that was kind of sexy and, you know, kitschy. And then SNL making fun of those conservatives who were so upset about this performance, which had very little political, you know, depolitical discourse or analysis baked into it, right? And all of this, while all of this is going on, it's only, it's happening over one week, right? So it's not even as if it's like a long term, but one week, the internet, at least from our vantage point, was insane with this conversation bouncing back and forth, boom, boom, boom. Now,
After all this is happening, that's when the Black Panthers film premieres on public television. And so I think, you know, and when it does, it has enormous ratings and it trends globally, globally on Twitter, the nine of the broadcast. People are the hashtag for the Black Panthers documentary is trending globally. And people like Macklemore are talking about how they're learning and all these other things. And why did that happen, right?
Because the public dialogue about the Black Panthers that was kicked off by Beyonce's performance was entirely about semiotics. It was not about any real information whatsoever about the history of the Black Panthers, who they were, what their politics were, why they did what they did. None of that was contained in there. Everything was about symbols. Everything was about symbols.
And people were responding to those symbols, right? And they were trying to understand what those symbols meant. And every time there was another moment in the mainstream media dialogue about the performance, it got further away from the actual reality, the real reality of the Black Panthers, and more and more and more into interpretations of what Beyonce's performance meant. So it got away from the reality and was just in this semiotic world where we're all having conversation and trying to make meaning of the images that we're seeing. And that performance was complicated by the video that Beyonce had just released the day before, Formation, where she had all this imagery in it.
that people were also trying to understand, right? So if you were a religious person, you could watch the film, the video formation. Now we're talking about the video the day before. You could watch that and be excited by the references of sort of like African spiritual traditions that were in there. You could see some elements of, you know, stuff from out of the Congo with the Kalunga line and Mami Wata and things like that. Or you could be really, really insulted that it looked like she was dressed in black at a funeral and talking very explicitly about her sexual gratification doing this, right? So both things are happening in this video. And depending on where you come into it, this is what you're seeing.
And it goes on and on and on from there. There's lots of different examples of ways you could read the different things. If you're a feminist, you could be excited about Beyonce calling women together to get in formation and fight against oppression. Or you could be pissed off that she was shaking her butt and showing off all of her body parts and being really sexually explicit. And maybe that's disempowering for women. You could be excited by her references to Jackson 5 nostrils if you're African-American, if you're black, and you want to feel positive about that. Or you could be mad at the fact that she's had several nose jobs, and it's really clear. So that seems very, very hypocritical, right?
If you were from the LGBTQ community, you could be so thrilled that Big Frida, who I'm a huge fan of, like a stalwart and a towering figure in Sissy Bounce in New Orleans, had his voice featured in the film. Or you could be in the short. Or you could be pissed off that he wasn't physically present, which some people were. So there are all these different ways that you could experience what you were seeing. And I think that the biggest one where we get to the anti-cop part is the dancing boy. There's a dancing boy. He's in front of the line of riot cops.
You could read that as the cops raising their hands in a gesture of solidarity with Black Lives Matter, which is how I read it. Or you could read it as anti-cop, which is how Giuliani read it. So the Panthers documentary lands at a moment when we are having this big public discussion about symbols and imagery and what it means. And here is a documentary that touches on almost all of the issues that the people were discussing, the symbols that they were seeing in the formation video and in the halftime performance. And though the documentary was clearly situated from the perspective of the Black Panthers, right? It's coming out of their history, their story, and their worldview. The documentary still showed them in a very complex way. It wasn't all peaches and cream. You got to see, you know,
how crazy some of them were um it interviewed the police both black and white police so you could get the perspective from from the the other side quote unquote and it provided all of those historical documents from inside of the fbi showing you know that they explicitly wanted to infiltrate cointelpro explicitly wanted to infiltrate the panthers and to bring them down So you have all this information that was not at all a part of any of the discourse and the documentary landed at the right moment to help people understand what they were seeing. So, you know, time's going to tell what the impact of having that broadcast at that very moment occur. But we already saw some of the response online through social media, as I was saying, like Macklemore saying, I'm learning and all these other people talking about this is stuff I never knew. So you can see the potential for a shift in consciousness and understanding about why the Black Panthers existed the way that they did and came to be. So that's sort of like a one way I like to think about.
the usefulness of documentary film and why it can have impact, the kind of impact that it can have in the world that we live in today, which is somewhat ahistorical, which is politically polarized, which is all about the symbols and full of this sort of symbolic information and so much information that it's very, very hard to make sense of things. This is sort of a responsive way, I would say, of having impact. I think there's also alternatives. I'm not just being responsive to the public dialogue, and this is something that I had to think about a little bit more as I was talking with Alex over dinner the other day, and still the desire that we have as impact producers and people who work in this field to have a real impact on the public discourse, to not just be responsive to what people are saying, not just put the information out there when they need to hear it, but actually drive it and to shape it and to make meaning. And I think one of the big things is That's possible, but it isn't possible necessarily on the very short time frame that we've set ourselves up for when doing these kinds of campaigns in the one or two year or even six month thing that we think that we're doing when we put a film out into the world with, you know, spending all the time with the strategy and the working groups and the activists and the whole thing, putting it all together, which isn't to say that work is not important. It's critically important to making sure your film and your media gets out in the world and does what it needs to do.
Perhaps we want to rethink how quickly that is going to happen and that this drive to quantify and to understand and to measure using all the big juicy data that exists out in the world is actually not helpful to our understanding of how change happens and what change is happening. So I want to talk a little bit about, you know, center up some of my work. It's not something I actually often do when I do these talks or when I talk to people. I don't actually talk so much about my own body of work. And so I'm going to talk about it a little bit today, sort of offer up a way of thinking about the kind of impact you can have over time. You know, first, I would say, you know, it's a funny thing, you know, hearing Gloria Steinem say, you know, when asked, how long does it take change to happen? And she says, 100 years. You know, and that's, I think that's true. It certainly feels like it.
I've been doing this, working on the sort of intersections of race and class and gender and the sort of intersectional analysis of how all of this plays out, at least in the United States. And now bridging into the world and sort of looking writ large across the world and the similarities between, you know, our settler colonies in the U.S. and Australia and Canada and, you know, Europe, the homeland, so to speak, and all the, you know, the rest of the global south. You know, there are trends, there are things that we can see and look at. And so I want to sort of speak to some of that.
um around my work so one of the provocations in the in the um in the in the sort of setup was you know how do we get away from this measurement of you know cheesy data points um impact metric data points which again those are important but they're they're they're not the whole enchilada right the whole enchilada for for for me and for a lot of the other impact producers are are the things like movement building organizing you know helping create solidarity across different groups that have common interests but may be splintered by you know certain uh drives or impulses due to identity politics? How do we actually create the kind of networks and the kind of support that we need? How do we use media and stories to do that? How do we talk about the human condition and tell stories that talk about the human condition and the experience of being human in such a way that it brings people together and helps them understand how to advocate on their behalf collectively? So in 2008, I met a first-time filmmaker, Katrina Brown. She was doing her personal family documentary, and it was called Traces of the Trade.
And in it, she discovers that her New England ancestors, which is where I am from, where I grew up, were the largest slave trading dynasty in U.S. history. They brought over more enslaved Africans than any other group of people in all of U.S. history. And I think they were thinking that something like one out of five African-Americans today are probably descended from one of the enslaved Africans that they brought over on their ships. So they have a really, really outsized influence on the creation of African-American people and identity. So in this documentary, she invites nine of her fellow descendants to join her in retracing the steps of the triangle trade to try to understand.
this legacy, this history. They call themselves the family of 10, and they document this journey as they're kind of uncovering the northern complicity in slavery, which is this history in the United States that we're really only beginning to unearth now, and it's hundreds of years old, but somehow we have forgotten the role of the North. The way that we talk about slavery and race relations and Jim Crow is all really centered on the South, and we kind of try to push it down there. Those people down there are the ones who did it, right? We up here in the North, we were the abolitionists. We were the good people. Well, it turns out...
that that was entirely true, that it was very much a part of the Norse economy and history and identity. And Traces of the Trade was probably really the first high-profile film or media of any kind, actually, where white Americans spoke openly and very publicly about this centrality of slavery to the development of America and how Americans, white Americans today, still benefit from those systems and that structure that had been set up that privileged them over African Americans. So when I came to this film and when I came to the family of 10, it was really a revelation for me because I had been working for some time on media projects that were focused on race in America and told from the African-American experience, you know, from that side of it. And I had, when I came to the project, I had just come from...
working on StoryCorps Griot, which was a national oral history initiative for the U.S., culling the stories of African-Americans who had kind of struggled through the civil rights era. And one of the things that happened when we were collecting those stories and sharing them with NPR and having them broadcast is... As I was out there, you know, for every one story that we would find and that we would air, there were probably, you know, 20 that we had to collect. Right. So the majority of the stories we were hearing and listening to were black people who were talking about some really painful experiences. Right. And they were alive today. It wasn't like they were talking about slavery or talking about, you know, what have you. These are people who were escaping Jim Crow terror and lynchings and all sorts of things who were, you know, as old as my parents are slightly older.
and had suffered some real terrible trauma from that era and that experience. And we were not really able to hold that. We were not really able to tell that story of how much pain still existed in African-American communities. The story that we told when we got on the air and put was the story of triumph and overcoming. This is post-civil rights. We have gotten over racism in America. Yay. And yet every month that I spent on that tour got me further away from that narrative. The distance between those two was so huge in my mind that, yes, on some level, we had
we had made some significant changes. And yes, things had gotten better. But there were still people who were suffering and had a lot of pain that had gone unacknowledged and unaddressed. And they lived with us every day. It wasn't like they were some faraway thing from hundreds of years ago. They were our cousins and our neighbors and our friends, right?
So to meet a group of white people who were willing to step into this public conversation and to talk about how they connect to this from their perspective, for me, was an act of solidarity. It was a moment of true solidarity. It wasn't somebody swooping in trying to tell the story, the sad, sad story of some African-American that did XXX or some poor Haitian somewhere else. I'm going to go save the world and volunteer. It was people who were centering their own selves and their own experience and how they connect to this issue and having a moment of self-awareness and modeling that for the rest of the country.
There's just a quote I quickly want to read from one of Katrina's interviews on Democracy Now that really sold me on this project and made me want to come on board. And she says, one of the things I've come to appreciate is the depth of the emotions that get in the way for white Americans. It's an example of a larger pattern, defensiveness, fear, guilt, shame. Those emotions get in our way, both really confronting our history and coming to appreciate the vast extent of sort of the tentacles of the institution of slavery and how fundamental it was to the birth and success of our nation. and to paving the way for the waves of immigrants that came subsequently. So discomfort looking at that history, obviously, but then also discomfort with grappling with the implications for today and really coming to grips with that.
I hear so many black Americans say, you know, we're not trying to guilt trip you or quit taking it so personally. We just want you white folks to show up for the work together with us of repairing those harms that continue to plague this country. So I have noticed how I have gone from extreme knee jerk guilt reaction to learning about my family and my region to a more grounded and I would say mature and calmer ability to take stock of the inheritance. We are an extreme case, my family. Yeah, again, but it provides a view into what I think all white Americans need to look at in terms of those legacies of white privilege and whatnot.
We built a really robust educational outreach initiative. We were able to sell the film to California Newsreel, and it ended up being California Newsreel's highest selling film of all time. That may not be true still, but it was at one point. And we worked with humanities forums around the country. public radio and public television stations and institutions that could help build in this information into their public programming, into their educational programming so it could be part of the way that people understood and learned about America and our history. It's not something that was going to solve racism in America. It was not going to change an immediate law. It wasn't going to get us to get the Congress apologized for slavery and gave over reparations. None of that was going to happen out of this one film. But what it was going to do was to start an important dialogue coming from
a key group of people, you know, the other side of the relationship, essentially, that could join the conversation and model to other people how to be a part of the conversation so that people of color aren't the only people holding this work, right? And I, you know, that was eight years ago. And a big reason why the film was able to be as successful as it was was because, you know, eight years ago, there's somebody named Barack Obama was running for the presidency for the first time. And America was debating on whether or not it was, you know, free of its racism enough that it could elect a black president. And because the film had landed at that particular moment in time where that public discourse and that conversation was happening, much like the Black Panthers film, we were able to have a much bigger impact and able to find a way into the public discourse in a more meaningful way because it gave people an opportunity to make some meaning. It gave people an opportunity to understand the situation in a different kind of way and modeled for them a way to approach thinking about work. I think my time is nearly up and I didn't even answer any questions, but I will say a couple of quick things.
That was the first in several films that I've been able to work on. It's really the primary one that comes focused from a white perspective. But I'm glad I got to show it to this audience because I think that there is something, even though it's very specific to our history and our history of slavery, I think that there is something that you all can take away from this work and specifically this film, is that solidarity and support and social change isn't always about you solving a problem for other people. Sometimes it's about understanding how you are positioned within that problem. You know, social change and the problems that exist in the world don't exist outside of us. They don't exist outside of who we are. They don't exist outside of our experiences. You know, it's not something outside of you. You are part of it. You and how you come into the world, you're part of this. And so when you're out there trying to figure out if you want to be an impact producer, if you want to be an impact filmmaker, if you want to get out into community, you have to understand your relationship to these issues, right? You have to understand the way that you're positioned, the way that you see things and why.
The way that other people perceive you and why and what you bring to the conversation. And that is the biggest impact that you can have is self-awareness, right? Is bringing that to the work. Thank you. You have been listening to an ACMI podcast. For more recordings, go to soundcloud.com slash ACMI online or the ACMI website.