This podcast is an audio recording of a live event. It may reference visual material that cannot be represented in this recording. It may also contain strong language and adult themes. The opinions expressed in this podcast do not necessarily reflect those of ACMI. Moderating the session today is Terry Calder, so thank you and take it away. Hi everyone, thanks for coming to this session. I'd like to begin by acknowledging the traditional owners and custodians of the land, the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nation, and on behalf of the panel, we pay our respects to Elders past and present and emerging.
I just also want to mention before we begin, I think if you've all been to the other sessions, you know that there's the app that you can ask questions through. We'll have time for questions at the end, but please fire off questions as they come to mind through the app. So filmmakers have been making social impact films, documentary films, since the beginning of making documentary films really, in order to get a message out and to create change. But I think what has significantly changed in the last five to ten years is this community of practice that's developed around documentary films and social impact campaigns and there's a whole structure around that and it has particularly been turbo boosted in the last four years by Good Pitch Australia and actually I just want to also acknowledge so 10 years ago DAF, Documentary Australia Foundation started and that was set up to provide fiscal sponsorship between philanthropists and filmmakers and that was started by Ian Darling who then also had a brainwave through going to a session internationally on Good Pitch to bring Good Pitch to Australia here which will then you know
has now evolved into this new Shark Island Institute. So Melinda Wink, who we have here on my left, is the executive director of Good Pitch. And she's also a consultant for international Good Pictures and has worked in Southeast Asia and Columbia and Miami advising filmmakers through the Good Pitch process there. And I'll introduce the rest of the panel. Stephen Oliver, who is a really talented filmmaker who is also just... How long have you been to the ABC? Just over a year and a half, nearly. Oh, it feels like just yesterday. I know. So Stephen's a commissioning editor of Documentary, and he's going to be talking on the panel today a bit about War on Waste, which was a hugely successful social impact campaign run within the ABC last year. And Brendan Shoebridge is also a very talented independent filmmaker who's made an incredible grassroots campaign film called The Bentley Effect, which we'll talk about. And Alex Kelly, who you...
seen starring in the trailer, is a really experienced Impact producer and filmmaker who thinks very deeply about these issues. She had a Winston Churchill Fellowship on Impact and has worked on big international campaigns like Naomi Klein's This Changes Everything and also as a filmmaker making some incredible films and she's got a film coming up called The Islands of Hungry Ghosts which you should all stay tuned for. So we'll start with... With Melinda. So Good Pitch Australia has been phenomenally successful. The funding and partnerships that have been forged, I think, we've raised over $14 million for 19 feature documentaries in the three years that Good Pitch was running, which is an incredible contribution to the sector. But not only that, the amazing partnerships that you've driven and established and the incredible advice and support that you've given filmmakers through this process. I know having been an impact producer on a couple of those films, I just felt so privileged to be a part of that and meet all you and work with you.
are some of the key learnings that have evolved the way you approach impact campaigns from the beginnings where you've seen films come through to now? Sure. Thanks, Terry. Well, I guess in 2013, the big learning that I had was that a glass of wine or even a bottle can change your life. And I had come back from Colombia where I was living at the time and I met up with Ian Darling, who I used to work with back in 2008 when I was running his foundation, Caledonia Foundation. And we caught up and we ordered a bottle of wine. And over the first wine, I'm like, you know, what's going on? What's interesting? And he said, oh, there's this thing I saw, a good pitch. And he started telling me about it. But as the wine bottle kind of progressively got drunk, I'm like, that sounds awesome. I want to come back. I'm going to run it. Let's do it. And so by the next day, I felt a bit dusty. And I called him and said, look.
I really want to do this. I think it sounds really special and amazing. And if you would back it, I reckon we could try and pull this off. What was interesting at the time was that, of course, Documentary Australia Foundation had been established in 2008 and had laid the groundwork for philanthropy to invest in documentary film. And when they started off, there was a lot of philanthropists who wouldn't invest in film because they had specific exclusions around it, not including it in it as an art form.
And certainly we also knew that a lot of philanthropists were a bit careful or cautious about funding advocacy. And of course the thing that we were proposing was to use documentary as a tool for advocacy. And so you can imagine my first year of Good Pitch, I was... First of all, trying to convince filmmakers that they should do this crazy thing called using their film for impact campaigns, and thankfully Alex had done a whole bunch of that work to spread the message about that. Thank you. So we lean heavily on your existing work in the field in Australia, but also to convince partners who'd never worked with film to use it as a tool for advocacy.
We went in, we selected seven films. Some of them were unknown filmmakers at the time, relatively, with films like Gaby Baby and Maya Newell, Frack Man with Richard Todd, Holly Pfeiffer with a film called The Opposition, Zack Ceremony with Aaron and Sarah, and Damon Gamow also with that sugar film. And we, you know, they're all, some of them were almost shot, some of them were still really early stage, and we were, I was basically knocking on doors and trying to use all charm and beguile people to back this thing called film and impact. Because our big, I guess, theory of change was that if you surround a film with... First of all, the storytelling has to be super strong, so you have to surround the film with the people who can help take that film from being good to great and make it the best thing it can be. If you don't have a story that's compelling, then you've got nothing and people won't watch it. So we put a lot of time and effort into ensuring that our filmmakers are supported in the creative process as well. But the second thing was that a film for it to have impact will always do best if it has diverse stakeholders. And some of those stakeholders won't be people who...
have ever really worked together, even though they might represent different parts of the puzzle in the film and impact space. So, like, Frack Man is an example. We had a CWA woman who's this incredible leader in her community sitting across the road at a table at Good Pitch from an investment banker who also had an interest in coal seam gas. Likewise, an environment across the table from a farmer. Bob Brown, Alan Jones, and that kind of diversity of those people and the different power base they have, the networks that they have access to, the knowledge or expertise.
or certainly the funding that different partners can bring, together makes those films and the impact campaigns quite powerful. And in the absence of that diversity, I think you've got something that's not as strong and certainly won't take some of the tests. that might be imposed on those particular films. And so, you know, we just had the dark PR session with the opposition and that diversity of partnership behind the opposition was actually one of the things that helped them to respond to some of the threats against them, to properly actually work out the risks and to, in that session that we had down in Kangaroo Valley, like just that diversity of brains and the trust that we had was so incredible for ensuring that we were already prepared for when the fight came.
So too with Gaby Baby where the film was banned by the New South Wales government. That diversity of partnership meant we had voices not just from the left but also all the way through the political spectrum who were speaking in support of that film. And we also had people who were taking that film to different places. So the diversity around that particular film was Primary Principals Association who wanted to use the film for professional development so that people knew that... Pitt's teachers were equipped to actually have age-appropriate conversations about the diversity of family in the Australian context. We had, obviously, campaigners who were working on marriage equality who used that film to take it into entirely different spaces as a tool for advocacy around marriage equality and also adoption equality. Other advocates, like youth advocates, took it into schools with the Wear It Purple Day, which is actually the thing that sparked the pan. But certainly that diversity of partnership is a big thing and a big lesson. It was our theory at the time, but it was certainly a big lesson that, indeed, that's the thing that adds value and strength to the campaigns that we run.
I guess the biggest thing of all, though, is to really be sure of what you're trying to achieve and the audiences that you want to speak to when you have your films and you're intending to have an impact campaign around them. I always feel sorry for the filmmakers when they reach this point in the process, when they feel that incredible burden of responsibility to change everything and change everything about the space and to fix the problem at large. And they're beautiful people and they feel that responsibility so deeply. And almost to unburden themselves with that, especially in the creative process, is so important. And to understand that you're only one part of this.
solution um sugar for example i can see anna up there like you didn't have to pretend to answer all the questions about sugar and its health impacts but you could start the conversation so a different conversation could take place um or um even though the sugar film was much more targeted at families and they're very sure about that particular audience and the way they use the message for that audience. It obviously then resonated to totally different and distinctive groups because it was so true to its message and who it wanted to speak to. And I guess also because these films often sit within the context of a social movement that is already working on these issues that you don't have to do it alone and that is the strength in those partnerships of being able to give the film over to them to actually do a lot of the work and use the film as the tool.
Yeah, so do you think with the next film, the next slate of films that are yet to launch, did you want to mention any of those films and some of those approaches? So in the end, after that first year of Good Pitch, we decided to do it again for another two years in a row. And so we have 19 films in our portfolio and, of course, not all of them are finished. We took a break last year and I did do some work overseas just to share the learnings from the Australian context. But we have Guilty coming out on the death penalty campaign, which is on the ABC in April. We also have one called Ghost Hunter, Happy Sad Man coming out this year and Dying to Live, which is...
Toddy's next film. So we really try to work with our filmmakers all the way through production and also the impact campaigns to support them. It's every stage of the journey. It brings its own stresses and challenges and opportunities. And, you know, we also take a lot of joy in the work that we do. And without it, I couldn't bear it. There's such great people that are in our community of mentors and support and also the filmmakers. And just a question on funding, because Good Bitch did sort of...
put so much funding into that space it's the 14 million dollars over three years is huge do you think that now that you've finished up good pitch that that um that the philanthropic community will continue to support support i mean i know they do through daft but not in the way that Not in the same way. Certainly in our first year we raised $2.4 million for the seven projects that we supported in the portfolio. That grew to $3.6 million in the second year and by the third year it was $7 million. And partly it was thanks to the work and the proof of concept from the first group that went through. It gave people confidence in the style of work and to start actually changing their own strategy philanthropically to fund and back advocacy and to back filmmakers as a big piece of that advocacy.
So, Mel, I'm just wondering, actually, because I'm just looking, gosh, we're moving very quickly. Do you want to talk a little bit about this new initiative and how, I suppose, the team behind Goodpitch is now running the Shark Island Institute and this new labs initiative? Yeah. So we remain quite committed to supporting documentary. in Australia and we realised by the end of a pitch we were going further and further into the development phase in order to find the projects and teams who wanted to do the work of social impact docs and so we're investing in these what we're calling the shark island labs and which have already opened for applications oops i meant to use this And the Shark Island Labs are about finding five projects in their early stage and actually backing development and pipeline of new story ideas with potential for social impact strategies to emerge from that. The labs themselves are much more about the story development. And we noticed that by the end of Good Pitch, like if you pitch an early stage project and kind of burden people with having also to run an impact campaign while they're still developing up their ideas and story. It's just too much. And so we wanted to have almost a protected lab or space where those documentary ideas could be formed up and also have room to fail and change and to do what's necessary.
necessary in the creative process. And so that's what the labs are for. It's still for feature documentaries. We're looking for films that don't necessarily have marketplace attachment or EPs attached. We're happy for film teams to come to us as they are, rather than having to kind of patch together partnerships too soon in the process before they really know what project they have on their hands or who they'd really like to work with. I think people should do that in a really considered and thoughtful way. And because often there are relationships you have for five, six, seven, if not longer, years.
and we're looking for a broad thematic base across the Australian context that represents the diversity of the kind of issues that we're facing as a country. Cool. The labs, actually, Christy, if you'd like to wave, Christy's running the labs, but they're basically involved two residential story labs down in Kangaroo Valley where we run all our workshops. There'll be both international and local mentors with ongoing support from our team to help you in the process of making your film and also up to 25,000 in development finance. And so will you...
eventually seek to perhaps executive produce a couple of these films or some of them? Well, I mean, what we really want to do is just develop up their stories and what we do next with those depends on all the IP states with the team. We just want to empower filmmakers and creatives to do the work that they love and to have power rather than having to make decisions in desperation in the creation of their team or signing marketplace agreements to really have figured out what project they have and what story they want to tell before they go and speak to someone like Steve with a full fully thought through proposition. Actually, that's a nice segue, Stephen. So, you know, television's, you know, really... So Good Pictures primarily focuses on feature documentaries and, you know, television's able to mobilise this mass audience in the way that sometimes, obviously, cinema documentaries and feature documentaries can't unless they're broadcast on television. But the ABC's always commissioned programming that engages a national conversation to spark change, I guess, but...
War on Waste, which was an extraordinary success for the ABC, has mobilised the nation to change their behaviour around waste and activated them to take on big business and government to do something about it. And I guess this pan-ABC approach is also not new. I mean, there's been the mental ads approach and pan-ABC approach across your channels in domestic violence and various other areas. But to me, it feels like War on Waste really has taken the broadcaster into new territory in the way that it engages with social impact campaigns. And do you think that's true to say?
Yeah, I think so. I mean, War and Waste has been a great success for us and we're really excited about it. I mean, it's been a brilliant project to work on. It's just, you know, it's worked so well because the ABC is a place that actually has a huge reach. You know, it has radio stations all over the whole country. It has, you know, multi-platform. We did a podcast with War and Waste. We did, I mean, the people inside the ABC that got behind the show. It just, I think...
Waste is an issue that we all, every week, we put our bins out and every day we throw things out. So I think it's an issue that every single one of us can relate to. I think a lot of these impact films are often about particular issues that certain people are really passionate about, but not everybody can relate to. And what I think was good about waste is that we all throw things out all the time. That's great. Sorry, I was just being cheeky. We all throw things out all the time. It's great. So just creating that realisation of where does it go and what happens was really important.
So, yeah, I think the way that we got Craig Rewcastle to host it, I mean, you know, it was a format, so we have to acknowledge that it was made in the UK, but we totally Australianised it and made the stories very specific to Australian audiences, and our stories are different to the UK, so it was a format, but we kind of did it our own way. I mean, Craig was a great host because he's a comedian who actually confronts politicians regularly. He's not scared to speak truth to power, but he's also funny and energetic, and he personally really gives a shit about the subject, and you could really tell that, so that engaging passion from him was also really good. But we kind of focused on one campaign per episode, and because we had three episodes as well, the TV offering... was three one hours but then beyond that we had all the local radio all over we had radio national doing their own radio national did a huge clothes swap for example in the foyer of the abc with 500 people came down to swap clothes it was like the whole foyer was taken over so there were these all of these other pushes from all parts of the building all parts of the organization sorry not just ultimate really was a pan abc across australia um kind of initiative and everyone just got behind it because I often talk about this thing of there being a low barrier to entry. People just got a reusable coffee cup, and then they felt they were part of it, and then they were part of a community, and then that conversation was sparked in their local cafe. And then they could say to the cafe, we could become part of Responsible Cafes, which was an organisation we partnered with, to give people a discount when they bring their own cup. And then you're having a conversation with your barista and your cafe owner and the person in the queue.
The next day they're bringing one. So it was a really small, easy thing to do. But you then felt part of the community. And that just spread and it spread and it spread. So I think that was one of the real things that we were able to do. So I'll just quickly summarise from the first episode. The first episode was about food waste. And we kind of had a campaign. We had a hashtag and a campaign for each episode. And that was size doesn't matter. It was about cosmetic standards. The second episode was really about plastic bags. So the hashtag was ban the bag. And that has had a huge impact across the country now. Every state has banned plastic bags except New South Wales.
sadly, but Coles and Woolworths have pledged to get rid of banned plastic bags by July this year, 2018, and they weren't doing that before. You know, there are a lot of people that have worked tirelessly in these areas for years and years and years, but what War on Waste did was just turbocharged the issue. And we did engage with those organisations and, you know, we hired an impact producer specifically for that, someone I knew outside of television who had years of experience in waste and the issues. So I managed to get him into the ABC and he, you know, did... partnerships with organisations that then just spread. And they all have their own huge communities and their own newsletters and their own Facebook groups and their own websites and all the rest of it. So that was a really good way that we just got to grassroots communities. So Ban the Bag was a really successful campaign in the second episode. And then the third episode was about fashion waste and coffee cups. And, you know, BYO coffee cup was the hashtag. And we did that tram stunt where we put the amount of coffee cups that are thrown away every half an hour in a tram, 50,000, and then drove around Melbourne saying, you know, this is what it looks like. And they go to landfill because they can't be recycled. So that also had a big impact.
Each episode had its own sort of campaign that the story was about. So we got a lot of traction on the BYU coffee cup and a lot of traction on the ban the bag. Interestingly, the hardest one to crack in terms of actual real world impact was the food waste, the size doesn't matter hashtag, which was huge. And we did a version on social media that became the biggest, most shared and viewed ABC Facebook post of all time. Shared and watched over 24 million and counting.
So that really resonated. We really care about our farmers in Australia. We care about the people that grow our food. So that was the actual sort of documentary style, meeting the farmer, learning about what their issues are and what those supermarket standards that make all the bananas look the same, what they mean for those farmers. And then so we kind of explained the issue in that sequence, which is longer in the episode. And then we created this kind of video, this sort of humorous video that Craig and some of his celebrity friends...
got involved to sort of launch the size doesn't matter hashtag which then on the back of telling people the story we then shared that and as a result of so many people having watched the story behind why this matters this video then also went viral yeah so that was then you know we used that in the show and obviously across social media and pushed it out on different platforms as a kind of short video to kind of show that size doesn't matter and use and sort of push that hashtag as well that was the most difficult um campaign to actually get traction on i won't go into the details it's extraordinarily complicated but um you know we got we got um an interview with the ceo of walworth's and um in the fourth episode so What we did was we had three episodes and then we did a fourth episode six months later specifically designed to be able to use it almost like a stick or a carrot or a banana when we were making the first three to say, well, we're going to come back in six months' time and hold you to that promise or see whether you actually have done anything about it. That was really interesting because you also got to demonstrate what had changed since the first three episodes. Yeah, that was the idea to show. And, you know, because the show really did really well and mobilised communities, we had brilliant sort of stories and follow-up.
feedback from everybody about what happened. And it was amazing. I mean, the Facebook community groups that actually sprung up independently in all different councils in different regions was really, really overwhelming and fantastic. So we were really happy with it. And since that fourth episode, has there been any other major impact achievements from that? Yes. I mean, we've commissioned a second season of War on Waste and, you know, we kind of explored what other issues we should look at potentially for a war on thing. But we realised there was plenty more stories about waste. So we're launching new campaigns on that.
e-waste, you know, throwing out your laptops and plastic bottles, you will be persecuted and demonised next year or the end of this year if you're seen with a plastic water bottle. So get your reusable drinking bottle, buy shares in a reusable drinking water bottle company. That's excellent. Love it. Good to see, Jane. One of the things I thought was really interesting for the ABC in particular is that, you know, during the episodes, you would have on screen, you know, if this matters to you, write to your local MP, write to Woolworths and Coles. I mean, that's, to me, maybe...
Very interesting that the ABC would be playing in that advocacy space as a government-funded broadcaster. Yeah, I mean, there are editorial policies around trying to change legislation for a government-funded broadcaster. But the thing about waste is it's not political. It's actually just a genuine issue that is going to make the world better if we actually learn how to reuse, recycle, reduce. And so we decided that we could call it out and we could actually campaign for the change that so clearly needs to happen.
Yeah, I'm really glad that we did that. And because everyone at the ABC was totally behind it, I mean, there's nobody that goes, no, I think we should send more. It's a crack to landfill. Yeah. So you didn't get any feedback from industry or government about it at all? No, we didn't. We didn't. They were genuinely kind of trying to listen to how... You know, I think the other thing to say about Warren Waste quickly, I know we've got to move on quickly, is that it actually was focused, we really specifically quite clearly focused on positive actions that people could take, that we all could make. It wasn't a Four Corners-style expose that just...
points the finger at bad guys and just leaves it to be enraged. She actually said, this is what we can do. So we focused it on being a positive call to action to how we can actually all be part of a solution and a better world. Great. On that note, I'm going to move on to our next speaker. Thanks, Stephen. That was really insightful. Brendan Shibridge has made an incredible film called The Bentley Effect, which is looking at a community in the northern rivers that took on the coal seam gas industry and with a really creative community campaign actually won and booted the fracking industry out of the northern rivers, which was a huge achievement. And, you know, so many environmental issues documentaries are just looking at the problem and leave you with, you know, at the end sort of going, oh, OK, well, now I've got it.
what can I do? But this was just this great example of actually a good news story of, well, this was a community that took on the campaign and won. And I guess that was probably a lot of magic for you in making that film, in that you could speak to that. And it's also the power of the impact of that film because communities can use that, I suppose, as fuel and inspiration and how to run a campaign. Did you want to speak to that? Yeah, sure.
Yeah, I mean, you know, we all love it when the good guys win, of course. So, yeah, it was a real sort of a treat for me. We, you know, I mean, like you say, there's a lot of films out there that sort of document the problem, but we were sort of able to offer an answer and sort of show what success looks like, you know. And we had a whole of community response, you know, to that threat of unconventional gas. And so, you know, we were able to show, you know, these really conservative landowners becoming radical.
you know, and standing alongside really deep green activists and everyone in between. Like, it was literally everybody. So, yeah, it was an amazing thing to live through, you know. And, you know, the other thing I was really trying to show is, you know, it doesn't have to be sort of a dry, sort of intense process. You can actually have a lot of fun while you're doing it, you know. And there was this beautiful campaigner, Nan Nicholson, and her campaign days went right back to Tranny Creek. And she used to always say, the only blockades that I regret are the ones I didn't go to, you know, and that troublemaking is a great source of joy.
So you've really been running your impact campaign on a shoestring, a very grassroots campaign. Can you tell us a bit about the response to the campaign and how communities are using the film? Yeah. Yeah, look, I mean, I've been just thrilled with the response the film's been getting. I've had these quite conservative people come up to me afterwards and just give me a big hug and say, you've activated me, I'm now active, you know. And like for a filmmaker, you can't really top that. So, you know, and like you were saying before, I mean, because...
you know, because of what it is, you know, groups are latching onto it and they're using it as a community building tool. You know, they're galvanising a group. They're sort of, you know, on quite a few instances we've had screenings where groups have just begun like straight after the screening, you know, and they've sort of got people to put up their hands and say, who wants to form an action group, you know, and they get really inspired to act. So those stories just sort of keep coming and, yeah, that's a tremendous thrill. But in terms of our strategy, I mean, we're really lucky because, you know, we...
there was already a well-established movement and a ready-made audience. So, you know, I think there's something like 480 gas-filled free communities just in Australia. There's, you know, you've got all the green groups with massive memberships, Lock the Gates and Wilderness Society. And I think there's at least 300 dedicated action groups. So all of them were really sort of hungering for, you know, something to top their tanks up, I suppose, you know, and to sort of share in this sort of success. So, yeah, we've sort of gone berserk with community screenings and it's worked really well and sort of fits the whole gas-filled free model, really.
Yeah, no, it's been really good. I mean, even today, there's a... I think it was two years ago, Victoria introduced the ban on fracking. Go, you Vic. And so we're having a screening over at Barnsdale, which is over sort of East Gippsland. And the guy at the... The organiser just rang me and said, it's sold out. Can you put something on your website? Which is awesome. It's only a little community, but we'd sold cinema around 180 tickets or something. So, yeah, and I'm absolutely chuffed. Is that the only state that's banned fracking now? Yeah, I think there's been moratoriums, but Victoria actually went ahead with the full ban. Cool. Yeah. So... No.
No, that's a myth. You have to watch the film. And so you also mentioned to me when we were talking about this some of the partnerships that you had, one in particular with I think it was an organisation called Anova, Australia's first renewable energy company. Did you want to mention that? Yeah, so I guess that was one of the big learnings. It was a bit tricky for me because I was coming off the back of Frackman, you know, Toddy's film. So we basically started filming at the same time. We had a sort of very parallel sort of journey, but Toddy got in just before I could sort of apply for funding. So he kind of scooped the pool, which meant that we...
was sort of forced to look at other avenues. And obviously crowdfunding and philanthropy were the obvious ones. And so we kicked off our campaign with a crowdfunding campaign, which also built the audience. And I think we got about 50 grand out of that to get us going. But I think the big learning was really the partnerships. To finish the film, we partnered with a wonderful mob called Inover Energy. And they're actually Australia's first community-owned renewable energy company, retailer. And the beautiful thing about that was that not only were they conceived at the camp in Bentley by some very clever people,
You know, they actually got over the line as a company on the same day that the licences were evoked. So it was a really nice sort of synergy and we could sort of, you know, go to screenings and spruik them and hand out postcards and sort of, you know, say a big no to this and a big yes to this, you know, the alternative. So that works really well. And so what they did was just ask their members to support us, you know. So I think that was, yeah, that was a major learning sort of thinking about, you know, those sort of thinking laterally about those partnerships. But also when I think about it now, in retrospect, I probably would have...
If I had my time again, I probably would have got at least the first $10,000 or $20,000 of that $50,000 and just flicked it to an impact producer and said, can you go and start building those partnerships now and building up all that capacity and just seeing other ways that we can support the project. And there's some good ones. In fact, we've got two just here. Good segue. Yeah. So actually, Alex, you screened.
The Bentley Effect, a film festival that you run in Alice Springs, didn't you? Yeah, and it was just perfect timing for the community because there's a stay on fracking in the NT, but they're kind of doing a big review about what they're going to do, and so it was perfect timing. It won the Audience Award as well, so we were stoked to have it at the festival. And so, I guess, what are your plans for the film now? I would imagine there'd be a lot of demand for it in the Northern Territory, given what Alex has just said. Yeah, yeah, we keep getting screening requests. You know, there's still a lot of outreach to do. I think, I mean, yeah, I think my next job is to actually find a broadcaster and an international sales agent. So is anyone out there? I don't know if you want to come and have a chat.
But, yeah, no, there's still a heap of work. You did a huge tour around the UK and around New Zealand connecting with communities there as well. It's not just... Yeah, yeah, yeah. That was really good, actually. You know, particularly those areas that have sort of got their backs against the wall, they responded really well. And I'd quite like to do a tour around the US, actually sort of replicate the same sort of thing we did in New Zealand and the UK because...
People tell me that we actually changed the whole energy of the campaign. They're starting a quote from the film and all that sort of stuff. It was really good. That's great. We're just talking on other countries and international. I'm just going to expand. Thank you, Brendan. Expand the conversation out internationally. So, Alex, you've been travelling a bit lately and actually both you and Melinda were at the Global Impact Producers Forum at IDFA and I know there was a lot of discussion there and I just wanted to throw to you to ask your opinion about that experience.
Where do you think the conversation's at? What are we doing well in this space, I guess, to start with? I sort of broke it down into a few things I thought I might touch on. And the first is kind of around this idea of like the literacy of change. And it's great to speak after Brendan, because in a way, the Bentley effect is one of those rare films where you actually get to learn a bit about how change happens, because actually, I think we're actually quite illiterate about it. We have certain ideas about petitions or protest or policy or think tanks, maybe a cursory understanding of how parliament works, but we don't really get into the meat of like, how does this stuff actually happen? And I feel like the impact space...
I kind of don't even like the term impact. It feels like it's come a little bit too much out of kind of the business world of thinking about social impact bonds or impact investing, etc. But I'm thrilled that the term was coined and that we now have a way of talking about this practice. And, you know, five years ago at AIDC, there'd be one small room in the basement at the Hilton where a few of us would talk about social justice films. And now we're in a big theatre. So this is fantastic. And I feel like now that we've defined what impact is, and this is sort of what I felt like was happening at the forum in Amsterdam, there's been a few years of defining, OK, what is it? And broadcasters and distributors and sales agents and funders going, where does this fit in a budget line? What is an impact producer?
etc and we've kind of bedded that down and so now I feel like we're getting to this the deeper questions where we're starting to go okay so if we know what it is how do we do this like what is this work how do you make change and we can start I think we really need to ask some really deep questions and do a lot of learning around that question and and it raises a lot of kind of ethical questions I think in terms of how we decide to do that going forward and I used to talk a lot about when I was talking about change making you know the fantastic messiness of it and the ultimate complete unknowability of the perfect template for how you make change is actually also the complete freedom of it because you know get up are trying to figure it out the australia institute are trying to figure it out health messages quit smoking don't put your seat belt on you know do put your seat belt on you know sexual health messaging filmmakers everybody is in this kind of ongoing struggle of if we did a comic book if we did this if the film was like that if we did an ad that did this everybody's always trying to figure out how do you make people do things advertisers are trying to figure out how to make us buy things and the fact that there is no ultimate answer is
freedom for particularly low budget shoestring culture makers because you know we can actually somehow despite all these other big institutions that have a lot more resource to ask that question we can also somehow have these amazing moments where we cut through But I think that we are entering into a moment where that is going to be really different. And this is kind of the era of the algorithm. And I think considering when we start to, and it's only just starting to come into our kind of consciousness, the power of the Facebook algorithm in terms of where people get the news from and also the really sinister stuff that Facebook are doing in terms of behavioural tracking of Facebook users and choosing how the algorithm responds to you accordingly. I don't know if people have seen the research of Facebook realising that they could...
target the moments that teenagers were very depressed and pick the kinds of advertising that they would give to them at those moments. Or that the kinds of moods of the work, of the kind of posts that you make will be affected by the algorithm and the kinds of moods in the content that you're seeing. And those algorithms are highly private. We don't know much about how they're being used. But Prash mentioned this morning, I think it's 17.9 billion people are now using Facebook. So when we think about...
the war on waste with all due respect using facebook as the platform to get communities to organize around waste use that on one hand it's like of course we'd use facebook that's what everyone does but actually i think we're opening up we need to open up much bigger questions about how and where we organize and look at the way that surveillance and particularly psychological surveillance is playing out with the bigger companies online because it raises questions about how is it that we want to make audiences do things and like if we could make the perfect algorithm to make people stop you know throwing away waste is that ethical is it okay to manipulate audiences to do things and there's some really big questions that i think that we really need to dig into there.
And the next point that I kind of wanted to raise is kind of about the fact that I think that we need to be much bolder than we are. And as filmmakers, you know, a lot of the things I just wanted to raise are things that have been really circling around in my head lately and I've been kind of really challenging myself on. And, you know, again, with due respect to AIDC, but if we look around, this is a pretty white sector in the documentary scene in Australia and it's quite conservative and it's quite privileged to be able to be in this space. And so sometimes when you're making a progressive or a campaigning or a social justice film... the people that you interact with in terms of funders and broadcasters and philanthropists and partners are sometimes more conservative than you. So you already feel like you're doing something quite radical because you're trying to pull that crowd with you. But actually, I think when we zoom out of our sector and look at kind of geopolitics at...
large you know the world is in crisis on so many levels that we actually are required to be much bolder than we're being so i i sort of feel like this sector is emerging we're articulating what we're doing but i feel like we need to go much much much further than we than we already are and to that end and it sort of feeds back into the question of literacy but we should really be paying attention to other sectors and other activists and other organisers because this is new to the film space and there's particular nuances of how you map a social justice campaign across film distribution and how you deal with bringing your funders or explaining, jumping through different ideas around holdbacks.
partnerships and grassroots screenings and all that that's particular to film but there are centuries of work about organizing tactics and how you know grassroots campaigns can be run and there's lots and lots of people that are really deep in that space and I think that those of us that are working in impact need to pay a lot more attention to that and also even in the documentary space and it's I'm really pleased that you know Brendan's on this panel as well but you know in there's some films and it's utterly brilliant that good pitch have created the ripples and the splash that they have but that's only 19 films that we know about that we see the profiler but there's heaps of other filmmakers out there I can see Heather who made Mary Meets Muhammad here who I think's pioneered one of the best distribution strategies in Australia when she rolled that film out and you know so it's really that thing of like learning from each other sharing that these really deep questions about how change happens diversifying who's in the room and and being bolder so that's my kind of overview of where I think we're at Melinda thank you Alex that was awesome
Melinda, do you have any thoughts that you want to add to that conversation? Yeah, I mean, I totally agree with you. The collaboration between campaigners who know how change works and how hard it is is such an essential ingredient for that we don't have to do this alone. We can lean heavily on some of the experience in the field around how to run campaigns, especially if your film is geared that way. But I think the cool thing that's actually happening, and it's also a challenge and responsibility at the same time, but it's the way, basically, the documentary is now kind of at the front line of protecting media and democracy across many contexts in the world.
see documentary filmmakers rising to that challenge and making incredible work responding to some of these crises across different parts of the globe using different ways of telling those stories. And the way that you see that kind of confidence being shown in the... in the major festivals as well, whereas documentary used to be like the poor cousin of their feature films, but now documentary filmmakers are much more the heroes, which I'm really enjoying seeing and getting the profile they deserve for all the incredible hard work they're doing. I guess...
I've got the privilege of sitting on a panel or a roundtable around investigative journalism in Australia too and I think we actually need to start collaborating with other groups who are facing similar challenges to their capacity to have freedom of speech and to start sharing strategies to protect that freedom. So journalists for sure, documentary filmmakers, we're coming up against the same challenges. But also to really collaborate with the campaigners, the NGOs are all, I mean, in recent days facing the gag bill that the government has proposed. We really need to be arm in arm and seeing not only the challenges that those particular groups are facing, but actually seeing it as them coming for us too in our sector and the repercussions that they will have across every single field of endeavour that's trying to engage in truth-telling. So I think that's the big challenge that we face. It's also...
means that we can rise to that. We've got storytelling as our advantage. It's a very persuasive and wonderful medium to be coming from in terms of connecting hearts and minds. It also serves us as a convening tool to tell and investigate stories. The War on Waste is a great example of how you can tell a story of many communities and very complicated messages across the longer format and giving insights and cause for action. We can do that in so many issue areas.
Yeah, I think documentaries are hot right now and we should embrace that and trust in the medium and really support each other in the endeavour. Thank you. So we've got about 12 and a half minutes for questions. I haven't seen any come through on the app, but maybe that's just me not being able to work this. But I think there's a microphone running around, so perhaps if you could put up your hand if you have any questions for the panel. There's just one up here. It's OK, someone's running up to you.
Hey, so you guys had mentioned for some of your films having inbuilt audience already from maybe campaigns that already existed. I was wondering more about any experiences any of you have had with audiences that would have been against your campaigns beforehand and any films that have really changed minds in any particular circumstances that have stood out to any of you? I mean, I could talk about... A campaigning series I worked on before I was at the ABC as a filmmaker, I made one called What's the Catch for SBS, which is all about seafood labelling. And that was actually, you know, we had to get fishermen over the line with persuading them that we should know what our seafood is and where it's from and how it was caught. So that, you know, that initially we met with some resistance in that community and we actually explained that if you empower consumers with knowledge, then they'll make the right decisions and that will reward fishermen who are doing things the right way. So that's just a personal example as a filmmaker I had making a show that...
Also had an impact campaign a few years ago for SBS. So that's a personal experience. I mean, with War and Waste, as I said, you know, there's not many people that just don't agree. So it was more about how can we improve things rather than meeting with people who didn't want to improve things, really. So it was a bit different in that regard. I don't know, Alex, do you have some of your work? I mean, you did the Naomi Klein.
This changes everything. We weren't, on that project, we weren't targeting. I mean, it comes up a lot as a question of around, oh, aren't you just preaching to the converted? And I guess my answer is a bit of a bad extension of the metaphor of like, okay, the choir, in my opinion, the choir are not even singing in harmony yet. So actually there's no harm in preaching to people we're calling converted because it's like Brendan said, he feels it.
theatre with people who are converted as anti-fracking but they're not working together yet so they form an action group after a screening so sometimes I think actually working with your natural audience you'll be surprised that the people who would turn out because they care about the film don't even know each other yet so I still actually think we've got quite this idea of the converted is yeah there is a converted but I don't think that they're organised enough so I tend to say yeah get the choir singing together better and then they can sing louder and then they'll bring other people into it. I could probably add to that as well. I would say if there's one key thing about the campaign, like I say, it was that grouping up aspect of it. Amazing things happen when people come together as a community and particularly if you can sit them in a dark room and give them a shared journey. And suddenly all that powerlessness and hopelessness that the industry and their political supporters will have you feel dissipates because you realise that actually you feel the same way as you and you and me. And so people start sharing all that collective intelligence and amazing things happen.
Yeah, I mean, I think that was sort of key, so I wouldn't let that stop you. But, you know, I mean, we were prepared for a bit of pushback, though, and I must admit I was hiding hard drives all over the region and, you know, doing these sort of crazy things. But in the end, we didn't get any... We haven't had anything come back. And I guess because we were just trying to sort of share a very honest portrayal of the protective movement, I suppose, you know, what are they going to say? You know, you shouldn't be protecting your land and water. You know what I mean? And maybe they're going with the old ignore it and it'll go away tactic, but fortunately it hasn't.
Another question just in the third row there. Is this working? I'm seeing a lot of social impact projects based around the web interactive and virtual reality space. I'm just curious to hear whether this is on any of your radars and what your thoughts are around that. I think you can apply this to anything. It's increasingly there's pressure on a lot of academics to think about impact producing their academic work. Again, caveats on the word, but yeah, I think there's a huge body of work in theatre and community cultural development that's been doing this for a lot longer than film as well. And yeah, I think there's a lot coming up. I think Ingrid Kopp can probably speak to some of the standouts in the VR space, but it's the tactics that are applicable across the spectrum.
When we fund some of our projects, the feature doc is obviously at the centre of the work, what we celebrate from our particular perspective. But there has been investments in aligned work as well. And I know there's one film project that we're working on that is looking at having podcasts and VR, et cetera, to extend the life and the audience of that particular film. So, yeah, I think it definitely has a role to play in changing minds and shifting things. Any questions? Just up the back here on the right.
Hi, my name is Violeta Ayala. And first I would like to thank you, Alex, for talking about the diversity of the room and AIDC and calling them out. I also like to call them out. I think change is happening, but it's too slowly. And I think that what you said about, I think it's important for everyone to understand that impact is new to film and new to white filmmakers, but it's not new to us. My mere existence is political. I am an indigenous woman. I survived genocide like the 3% of this country. And I think it's important to understand that the biggest organizers of Australia...
are the Aboriginal people. They can teach all of us. And we are in a very, very incredible moment, very dangerous too. And I'd like all of you to talk a little bit more about what you're going to do to open those spaces to people of colour in a real way. What are you going to do? What's next? I think we all, we each have a responsibility to do that. We all occupy different positions in the industry as funders, commissioners, et cetera. And even as directors and collaborators, I think we can bring people with us and support their endeavours and their projects. It's really important that we...
We build a community of practice that's an inclusive one. And certainly from an Australian perspective, if we are to shift the dial on a whole bunch of the issues at large, then we need new voices at the table who are speaking their truth. Otherwise it's going to be the same old narrative over and over again and nothing will change. So as much as we can, I'm totally committed to an inclusive funding arrangement for Shark Island. Did you want to make a comment on behalf of the ABC? Yeah, I mean, I think it's a really good point, totally valid, and it's absolutely on the agenda of how we actually keep making progress. There is progress being made. I'll just give a small example of another project that I'm working on that's an impact project at the ABC. It's called Don't Stop the Music, and it's about getting musical instruments into underprivileged schools, or schools in general, but in particular underprivileged areas, because...
The latest science behind learning a musical instrument shows that it's the one activity that connects the left and the right brain and actually improves kids' literacy, numeracy, and crucially, communication and social skills and general well-being. So with this campaign, which is, you know, it's a big TV show, it's going to be another multi-platform offering on the ABC, a pan-ABC initiative, but it's a school with a much higher level of Indigenous kids than a lot of schools in, you know, inner-city Melbourne and Sydney. It's in a remote area of WA, of Perth, of a suburb of Perth. I've seen some footage already of, you know, young Indigenous kids learning to play a musical instrument and as a result, you know, you can just see the change happening. They're much becoming more confident, better able to communicate with their peers, with their teachers. So, you know, I think thinking about kids and actually how do we actually create a better future, that's a small example that's going to be a feel-good show, hopefully, that actually will have a genuine positive impact for everyone and including and especially Indigenous kids as they grow older. Alex? Thanks, Stephen. Sure, I mean, I think it... I mean...
I think, firstly, that you're completely right in terms of who to look to for inspiration and organising. Like, talk about amazing organising under 200x years of bloody pressure. And also in the film space. I mean, you look at the power or cultural space that Indigenous music, film and theatre has had in shifting narratives in Australia. But I think partly what we're talking about is, and we never talk about it, is power. And it's kind of what I was trying to get at when talking about the literacy of thinking about change is learning how to name power, how power works in society, the power that we have, how we use our own power and those sort of things. And I don't know if it's a particular Australian thing, but it's something that we don't necessarily name.
And it means that we have murky conversations around the sides of things because we're not just naming it. And so, I mean, there's lots of ways that I can talk about my own practice, but I think I'm increasingly trying to figure out. both how to share power and share my networks and knowledge with other people but also I'm trying to work out when to be quiet and when to step aside and when to open that space and that's really hard learning because you know when you're in and this is partly about this thing of like who are you around when you're when you're an independent filmmaker that feels like you don't get many opportunities even though I'm a white filmmaker who probably does get quite a lot of opportunities it's not a natural instinct to go I'm not going to take that I'm going to step aside and so I think that's also part of a conversation we need to have with each other that we talk about power and how to share power so we can get better at it rather than it rather than it being performative like look at me I'm being a good ally but just actually like how do we do this because we've got to transform a lot of things you know i think we've got time for one more question um okay My question is to Stephen. I think War on Waste was wonderful in creating awareness. I've been working in the waste space since 2012. My name's Alana Rubinstein and I'm from Planet Earth. I am working in the battery space and also in the single-use plastic space. I've just been working with the Victorian police on keeping 4 million breathalyser straws out of landfill. My question to you is on the disposable cups and also on your opening statement with regard to we all throw our rubbish out. Personally, I've put my bin out six times in the last six years. I repurpose all my waste and I'm very careful with what I purchase. But I'm unusual.
My question is on the disposable cups issue. I think what you did was fantastic, so I'm reaffirming that. But disposable cups are recyclable. A plastic lining on a disposable cup is far less in terms of ratio than an ordinary milk carton that has a higher plastic content. The issue with disposable cups has been their shape. So size may not be an issue and shape shouldn't be either. So the shape was the issue, along with infrastructure for collection, along with many other issues. It's a very simple problem.
And I'd love to see that your next series deals with correcting the misnomer that disposable cups are not recyclable because they all are. And thank you. Quick response from Steve. Yeah, no, it's a complicated issue. And thank you. And great that you're so involved and active in space. We need more people like you. That's great. At four of one way, she might have seen that we met the guy who was showing how you can recycle them. And so the problem is not that they can't be. The problem is, I mean, there hasn't been an industrial level ability to recycle them successfully yet.
People are working on that. I think Warren Wates has been part of that. So we're making a new series. We're going to do some follow-up. So I'd be happy to put you in touch with the producers because they are working very hard on how we can move forward in that space. But thank you. Thank you. We're actually out of time now. So thanks very much. And if you could thank our panellists. You have been listening to an ACMI podcast. For more recordings, go to soundcloud.com slash ACMI online or the ACMI website.