The opinions expressed in this podcast do not necessarily reflect those of ACMI. Hello, everyone, and welcome to Creating Character with As Leo Cheng. We're really excited for this session, so thanks for being here. I'd first like to start by respectfully acknowledging the traditional owners of the land, the Boonwurrung and Woiwurrung peoples of the Kulin Nation, and pay their respects to elders past, present, and emerging. I'd just first like to start out with a big thank you to Edith Cowan University for sponsoring this session. And just to say a few words, I'm going to bring up Kathy Henkel. Thank you.
Thank you. So I'm fortunate enough to be the director of the WA Screen Academy at Edith Cowan University and we're delighted to be sponsoring this session with Leo for the presentation that you'll have today. I'm personally, I'm a documentary filmmaker as well, I'm personally fascinated and very interested in the subject of unpacking how we deal with character in documentary but we're also very fortunate to be bringing Leo to Perth and he will be coming along to present his film and an extended version of this to audiences in Perth. So it's an extra special honour for us to be sponsoring this session and welcoming him to Perth. So thank you and I'm looking forward to the session.
Thanks. Moderating the session for us today is Development and Investment Manager of Documentary at Screen Australia. So I'm just going to leave it with you. You're in good hands. Thanks. Thank you, Britt. And welcome, one and all. I too would like to acknowledge the traditional owners of the land that we gathered on today and to pay my respects to the elders past, present and emerging.
I'd like to welcome Leo. We're very lucky to have Leo with us today. This is S. Leo Chang, who's going to be talking to us, as Britt just said, and Cathy, about creating characters in documentary. Leo, I would say, has a particular talent in this area. He's had some success recently with some documentaries that have been very driven, first and foremost, by the rapport that he's built up with his characters. The first, his most recent, is Our Time Machine, which has won awards at Tribeca and at Dock Edge in 2019.
and his other documentary, A Village Called Versailles, was also nominated for an Emmy. So we are in esteemed company with Leo today. I'm sure that you've all read his bio, so I'm not going to be laborious in listing his credits, but suffice to say, we have a practitioner here who's had success in working out how to really get to the heart of characters, what makes them tick, and to find a way of building a trust and a relationship with them that then translates beautifully and fascinatingly. onto the screen. So mindful too that this is a craft session. We're going to get some insights from Leo, but also some practical tips, I hope, about things that you can do in order to make the most of the characters and the time that you spend with your protagonists and how on a practical level you can employ certain techniques, shall we say, in order to get the best out of them and also find a working space together that is comfortable and indeed ethical when you want to really capture the intimate moments with them.
I should also say that there's an opportunity for you to ask questions. We're going to allow about 15 minutes at the end. If you do have questions that spring to mind as you're listening, you can submit them via the app. If you go into the AIDC app, you can ask a question and magically it will pop up on my iPad and I will attempt to get through some of them at the end. And if it's all quiet, then we will have a roving mic at the end so that we can hear from you directly if things spring to mind at the end of the session. Either way, you will have an opportunity to speak to Leo at the end.
So by way of introduction, and for those of you that didn't make it to the screening of Our Time Machine last night, a full screening here with a Q&A with Leo, we're just going to show the trailer for Our Time Machine to give you the flavor of Leo's work. So if we can run the trailer, that'd be great. Thank you. Thank you.
It's a beautiful film. Thank you. Let's start at the beginning, finding characters. I think a lot of filmmakers, when they're looking for a good character, they tend to maybe go for the obvious, the larger-than-life, a person that maybe has already been on a journey, so what's left to tell. It's not necessarily the best way to go, is it? What, for you, makes a good character?
First of all, I'm really happy to be here and just want to shout out to AIDC for bringing me out here and thank you, Jeannie, for working with me and Britt for working with me to put this session together. I love character-driven documentaries. I love it both as a maker and as a viewer, as an audience member. And so I'm always on the lookout for a character that will work in a documentary. I do come across, especially in younger filmmakers, emerging filmmakers, when they get drawn to a subject, oftentimes it's a character that has already had a full journey behind them.
So in some ways, the most exciting things that have happened to them has already happened. So it makes it difficult to recreate that for the camera. And there's not as much or as many scenes or as much journey that you can go on with them. But not to say that you cannot make a great documentary with a character that's in that situation, but it just wouldn't be this sort of immersive, observational, character-driven documentary. They tend to be probably more historical.
I would say, you know, which can be excellent as well. But for me, I just have the soft spot of sort of building a film and allowing the audience to feel like they're part of the everyday lives of the characters. Good answer. What comes first, the story or the character? Because I imagine that in certain scenarios, you know, there's something interesting in a story and then, you know, you can find the characters to hang on that story or is that not the way you work?
I always prefer character first, but I don't think that always can be the case. I've done commission work where a broadcaster or a production company comes to me and say, we want a film about this subject matter, right? So what you would need to do then would be cast. It's literally casting as you would in a fiction film. You would have to do a research, really broad, cast a Ynet to find all the potential candidates who might fit.
the criteria of being able to be the storyteller that carries this particular issue forward. So I tend to have a harder time with that than just coming across a character and kind of really basically falling madly in love with them in whatever respect that is and just feeling so compelled to spend time with them and then to tell their story and then to just invest all my time and energy with them. But if you're in a situation where you are needing to cast for a subject matter, there are things that I look for. I think that just because they have an illustrious resume doesn't mean that they're a great character, right? So much of a documentary character is first impression. Like the second somebody pops on the screen, you right away have many feelings for them, and that is the most important thing. You need somebody who's expressive. You need somebody who is comfortable sharing. You need somebody who is generous with both of their time and also, you know, their thoughts. You know, I think that I tend to become very good friends with my characters.
Yes, that comes across in many of your films. I feel like I've seen many filmmakers that make a career out of making adversarial films, people who are confrontational with their characters, and they make great work, but I don't think I can ever do that. Maybe those filmmakers tend to have a more truncated or more managed relationship with these subjects. They're not quite as immersive as the approach that I would like to take, but I don't think I can handle spending... you know, years of my life with somebody I don't like. I don't know if some people like doing different strokes for different folks. But, you know, clearly not to take away with really amazing work that's been done. You know, I mean, somebody like Michael Moore, all he does is provoke people, right? But he also doesn't do these sort of immersive, character-driven documentaries. Yeah, I think you make a good point there about spending time with characters because, you know, we've all done it where you bed in with someone and then if you do rub up against them, it's quite hard to continue the time with them in a prolonged fashion. The relationship that you have with your protagonist is generally at the heart of your films.
How long does it take to build up that rapport? I think it depends, right? Sometimes you just click. I don't know. I'm full of dating analogies when it comes to talking about a filmmaker and their subjects. I don't know if it's appropriate or not. But it's really like sometimes it's love at first sight and it's, you know, what do you want to call it? It's returned. It's reciprocated. Thank you. And it's reciprocated, right? Like right away you hit it off.
and you're kind of on the same page and you're off and running really quickly. It doesn't mean that everything is smooth sailing, right? At some point, things get difficult. When you dig into the deeper things, there's a lot of negotiation that needs to happen in terms of how much of their time you can reasonably occupy and also just the power dynamic comes into play and it always happens as it is in a relationship. But sometimes, you know...
I've had experiences where it requires a lot of investment on my part to gain the trust. And once the trust has been granted, then... It went very well. It had gotten really smoothly. I've also had experiences where I invested a lot in the character and I just cannot break through. A lot of that, I think, is because of who they are. I made two films about two politicians and that's always been my really trickiest experience has been working with political figures because it's really not in their best interest, to be honest. I don't mean that in that sort of... But in terms of having a consistency in their message and presenting a very managed and packaged and consistent...
facade, right? It's important for a politician because if they do something wrong, they will be accused of being flip-floppers or too emotional or not stately enough, which actually at this moment, I guess we don't really have that problem with Donald Trump. So I've actually had a lot of difficulties, especially working with the two political films that I've had, and those have been challenges. So yeah, I feel like it really depends on the situation. I am actually producing a film for a wonderful Chinese filmmaker. He's very established. His name is Jian Fan, Fan Jian in Chinese. He's making his, I think, seventh feature-length documentary. His last film, called Still Tomorrow, won the special jury award in 2016. He's making a second film in a trilogy where he follows these two families. Both of them lost their only child during the 2008 earthquake in China.
And he's already made a film with them in their experience to try and conceive and basically have a replacement child. And 10 years later, he's making a second film with these two families that... are basically literally his family. I mean, they've known him longer than they've known their children. And they just have these beautiful relationships that just comes right out of the footage. You just cannot, you just keep watching those images and you wonder, where is the filmmaker? You cannot feel the filmmaker. I mean, I don't believe in this sort of like fly on the wall philosophy because I really do believe that the second you show up with the camera, you change life, you change the scenario. But clearly that relationship is so strong and so honest that they are...
he's literally there and they're acting as if nobody else is there or just somebody who's very much organically part of the family is there. And he's able to get these really beautiful, fantastic scenes. I guess that's the ultimate rapport, really, when the line is that blurred and you're getting that kind of rapport. I'm thinking as you're speaking, and when you were talking about the politicians and getting them to open up... There's kind of the tricky business of ethics, isn't there, with character-driven pieces where, you know, you want to portray the truth, but also you need to get the characters maybe to do certain things in order to take the film you want to make on a narrative trajectory. Can you speak a bit from your own personal experience about that? What is the line between capturing actuality, I suppose, with your characters and actually kind of manoeuvring and staging things so that the film can happen narratively in the way that you want and need it to?
I was very much trained to really have a fairly strict ethical standards when it comes to collaborating with subjects. I feel like every filmmaker have a different line, a different threshold that they will and will not cross. For me, that line has continued to evolve in interesting ways. At first, I really was very much come from the cinema verite school, that I should just bend myself backwards to accommodate, you know, whatever it's going to take place in the characters' lives to be there. when I need to be there because they have certain things scheduled a certain way to not interfere, to not ask for certain things to be specifically highlighted or, you know, I don't like the term set up because I don't think I set up anything. But what's been happening as my career go further along is I'm realizing that, you know what, if it's going to make it saner for my crew to shoot a scene at noon versus at nine o'clock and it doesn't matter to the subject, I am going to ask, can you schedule this at noon instead of at 9 a.m.? And I don't think that compromises.
the kind of material that I will capture. And a lot of that also, again, goes back to your relationship with your character. Are you in the position to do that without them feeling imposed upon? So it's really depending on what the situation is. I think we're leading to... Yes, we have a clip coming up because I suppose when you're bedding in with a character, you're getting to know them as intimately as you are, there starts to become a blurred line between...
Yeah, in terms of what you're showing and how you're showing it. We have another lovely clip, actually, from our time machine, which really demonstrates the intimacy that can be achieved, I guess, when you are working very closely with participants. Should we look at the clip first, and then you can tell us about how this unfolded in terms of what you were able to capture? Can we run clip two, please? It's not always a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form. It's not a form of form.
Oh, oh, oh. So that's obviously a really poignant clip of a filmmaker off-screen describing a scenario to the father who we see on screen there, who's clearly suffering from dementia. And interestingly, from a craft perspective, the camera is very close at that point. We are seeing him very close up. How did you feel as a filmmaker in this situation? Because on the one hand, it's a very poignant and revealing moment, but at the same time, it's teetering on the edge of being, I suppose...
Exploitative maybe, voyeuristic perhaps. Tell us a bit about what was happening there. So the voice you hear belongs to my film partner, Yang, who shot a lot of the film. And oftentimes it's him and the subject. And the reason why the cameras go so close is because he's literally at regular speaking distance with Mako, who's the father, who's our sort of first supporting character, the father of our main character, who is suffering from Alzheimer's. And he had just...
not long ago seen a piece of theater that his son put together specifically to dedicate to him, and now he can't remember. This, when Young finished shooting this piece and we were reviewing it, we were watching it, it made us really uncomfortable. But we, instead of sort of rejecting it right away and just thinking about sort of this being something that's perhaps sort of crossing the line, right, the line that we're talking about, We thought about it, we sat with it, and we kind of asked ourselves why we felt the way we did. And I think that we felt like we intruded on a moment where we were not supposed to be there. But that's in many ways what a documentary filmmaker is supposed to do. I think that what made us uncomfortable...
is the intimacy of it, is that that conversation is probably something that he would have had with a family member, but instead he had it with us on camera. So what does that mean for us? For a long time, we thought about not including that clip. But as we kept pushing forward with making the film, we realized that that was actually a pivotal moment to talk about the struggle of this family with the aging of its patriarch and what that means for him and what that means for everybody else around him. And how can we find a way to...
demonstrate this, to share this moment of intimacy without sort of degrading him or damaging his legacy. And I felt like we actually did a pretty good job constructing this moment and have it be extremely meaningful and contributed to who he is instead of it being something that's dismissive or that sort of demeans him. And in the run of the full film, it feels a lot better in a way than when you see it in isolation like that because there's context for it. Nonetheless, I guess that moment, did it come out of the blue? It wasn't something you were anticipating? No, Young was just visiting them in the nursing home that they had just recently moved to, and they were just chatting about the project. You saw them, actually, did we see the mom chatting about the project right before? Mom was basically having a conversation. They were just checking in about this play that we have been following the progress of its production. And the father starts to speak. And all credits to Young for holding the camera.
So I feel like, you know, that's actually one of the things I've trained myself to do as I become more experienced as a filmmaker is that one of the, if you are, you know, if you plan to be your own camera person, be your own cinematographer, one of the first things you need to train yourself is to not press the stop button. No, seriously though, right? You always have the choice of not using it in post. If it feels like you're not putting yourself in personal danger or you're putting your subject in personal danger, it's not going to destroy the relationship between you and the subject. You need to learn how to keep the camera rolling and hold the shot.
And he did that. He just kept the conversation going. He was just looking this man into his face and seeing what he's reacting. And then we end up with this really poignant, beautiful moment that otherwise we would not have. And if we did eventually decide that it was not appropriate or if somehow the family objected, at least we have a choice of taking it out later. But we always have a choice of using it because we got it.
To me, that's actually one of the most difficult things to do, because for a long time, I shot a lot of my own film, and I also work as a cinematographer for other people. The moments where I'm sent into rooms where I just like, I don't want to be in this room. It feels so uncomfortable, but you just need to learn how to disappear, and you need to learn how to just go in and just be a part of the setting somehow, and everybody have a different way of doing it, right? Another moment I remember sort of in my evolution as a cinematographer is like the first time I just walked down to a stage without asking for permission. Because if you, like in this situation, right, if you're shooting from where you're sitting, all of you guys are looking from that angle. But if you're shooting from here, right, I'm seeing us and I'm seeing you guys and only the camera sees this angle. That's what you want. You want, as a documentarian, you want to be behind the scenes, right? Like you're literally coming from a different perspective. That segues really nicely into a practical question that I have, Leo, around, you know,
As a filmmaker, you want to be in a position where if something does happen, you know, like those poignant moments that you don't know are coming and then suddenly they're upon you. On a practical level, do you walk around with a camera in your pocket or, you know, what do you do in terms of equipment to make sure that you've got your bases covered? I mean, we've all got iPhones now, so I guess you can always whip out a phone. But what's your kind of rule of thumb about trying to have something on you or, you know, so that you don't miss anything? Well, if I'm going to hang out with the subjects, I do tend to bring a camera with me. Again, I feel like when I was a younger filmmaker, I tend to...
be in constant fear of missing stuff um but it's so it's a moment when you know you sort of shut off for the day and then the key quote well you know i mean so so actually this is another sort of weird little practical tip which maybe you guys all learned in in school whatever is that you know some of the best interview moments is always the moment when the interviewer says thank you we're done And then all of a sudden you see the subject relax and some beautiful something comes out of their mouth. And if your cinematographer doesn't know to keep rolling until the very last minute, you will not get that. So for me, yes, when I hang out with our subjects, we always have camera with us. We also are much better now at letting go of the moments that we miss, not to try and recreate it. In the grand scheme of things, you will always miss things, and oftentimes you miss very important things. But there's...
Usually, I wouldn't say always, but usually there's a solution for it. And sometimes, and often, rather, the solution is actually better than the most predictable thing. One of the moments in the film, I hate to give away the ending to the film, but the screening was yesterday, so you guys are not going to see it for a while. So the end of the film was that our subject, Ma Liang, and his wife, his new wife, has a baby. And which is amazing because it's one of those moments where we, the filmmaking team, were dying for them to have a baby because it was the ideal ending to the film. I mean, this is a film about...
parents and children um it's about sort of the circle of life um and and what better way to to wrap that up you know to have the son have his own child We totally missed the birth. The baby came two months early. It's like, hello, real life, right? Are you going to go to the baby and say, hey, can we schedule so you show up when one of us is in town? So neither of us was in Shanghai. The baby came early. Ma Liang, who's actually a great photographer. That's what he does. The artist, that's the subject of the film. We sort of begged him to shoot, shoot, shoot. He's just being the father. He's not going to be getting us coverage in the delivery room. So we totally didn't have it. We had nothing. And we were like, shit, what are we going to do?
Then we ended up capturing this really beautiful scene at the baby's 100th birthday party. Basically, it's like introducing the baby to close family and friends. That was better than anything else that we could have gotten. That's what we ended up using. You don't need the gruesome 4 a.m. sitting with the mother for 48 hours. And sometimes storytelling doesn't have to be literal. It forces you to find another way to tell that part of the story. And often when it's not literal, it's more beautiful. Yeah, exactly. First choice is always not the best choice. I don't recommend filming birds. Anyway, it's a messy business. I want to explore, Leo, a bit more with you about the line between filmmaker and character.
And another thing that often comes up, and I think this is true, particularly when you're spending a lot of time with characters, as you often do, is at what point it feels appropriate, for example, to pay someone and give them, let's say, financial compensation for their time. And I know you have a particular view about this. Can you speak about that? I'm realizing that we're talking a lot about the things that my position towards it has evolved as I'm further into my career. Again, I was taught very strictly from a very journalistic perspective that you just don't pay your subject. You don't pay your subject. You don't pay your subject. It's going to influence the outcome. You don't pay your subject. It's unethical. That's always the conclusion. It's unethical. As I've gone further in my career, especially the kind of film that I make, which is that I am asking not a couple hours of my subject's time. I'm asking days, weeks, months of my subject's time, especially in situations where my subjects are in a difficult financial situation.
is it more ethical for me to not pay them for their time? Or is it more ethical for me to compensate their time for, you know, time that they spend with me? I've also made a couple of films about artists. Same thing. This is their livelihood. You know, you as filmmakers, what's more ethical for you to come and share your tips with me, but I can't pay you because of that ethical. No, I really feel like that.
sometimes it's more ethical to support, to support the sustainability, to make sure that they're not losing their livelihood because they're spending time with you. Again, I'm generalizing, right? Every situation is very different. It's very nuanced and very tricky. And in some instances, you do have these situations where if you pay someone, they sort of act how you want and do things that you want.
There was actually this really interesting film. I can't remember when it was. It's actually quite long ago. This duo in the out of LA, Randy Barbato and Fenton Bailey, who makes these sort of tabloid-esque but great documentaries about, I think they made a film about Eyes of Tammy Faye. What was some of the other ones that I named? Anyway, they had made a film about male prostitutes. They called, I think, 101 Rent Boys. So what they did was they paid their subjects, but they paid them on camera.
Right ethics is about transparency So if you show that your subjects are being paid on camera to me That's the most ethical thing you can do the audience then can make their own decisions about what that means in terms of you know, what they're watching. And in some ways, it's sort of perfect for that particular subject matter. So to me, you know, when that film was shown to me and I had these discussions and there's actually been a couple kind of great pieces written about it, it was kind of a revelation to me to really kind of challenge myself to rethink the relationship, the financial relationship between you and your subjects. I'm not advocating for it one way or another. I'm just really saying that maybe don't take that one thing.
So strictly anything that there's definitely very much journalistic scenarios where it's very much hardcore investigative journalism where things like that is totally inappropriate But most of us actually don't operate in that world strictly in that world I think as you say, it's very nuanced and it's very case-by-case and certainly when you're in a more journalistic area that becomes more of an issue and it's probably more of a no-no than when you're doing more observational pieces where you're bidding in with the character and as you say there's a transparency there about the relationship between you the filmmaker and the person that's on the screen so I think it's quite a complex subject that sadly we don't have time to go into so much detail about now. We've got another clip coming up, which is from another one of your films, To You, Sweetheart Aloha, which we've included in this session because you have a wonderful story about what happens in a way when you establish such a close relationship with a protagonist that real life kicks in. Do you want to speak to this clip before we see it, just to explain who it is that we're going to see and the nature of the relationship that you had with him?
So you've been watching my most recent film, but you're about to watch my very first film, and it's in standard definition. So it's very strange to see standard definition projected nowadays. So this is a film about a 94-year-old ukulele player from Hawaii and his unconventional friendship with his 28-year-old manager. And this is a situation where halfway through the production, Bill, our subject, came to us through his manager and asked us for money. And as young first-time filmmakers, me and my film partner, a different film partner, I've actually collaborated with three different filmmakers in my five films.
We freaked out. We had no idea what to do. We're young or poor. We're just out of film school. We had no money. And besides, you're not supposed to do that. You're not supposed to ask for money. What am I supposed to do? What if we don't give him money? Are they going to pull a plug? Is he just not going to give us any more access? So there was a lot of struggle back and forth. And actually, eventually, we kind of scraped together a few thousand, like two or three thousand U.S. and pay the manager. And we felt really uncomfortable about it. And this is also somebody who we've had built up such an amazing rapport with. He was this 94-year-old man whose kids have all passed and whose grandkids had no interest in his career.
basically taken care of by this 20-year-old manager of his. And us, when we're on the road with him, we are basically looking after him. So this is very much of a grandfather figure for us. So it kind of messed with our head in weird ways as well. Anyway, should we just watch? Yeah, this is sort of a half of a trailer. This is a punchline to come. Please, a round of applause for Mr. Bill Tapiano. I'm waiting for the forever Bill. This here is all my underwear. I don't want to be like everybody.
I was going to say, who is this dizzy blonde? Want a ride? Yeah. It's really odd to see a 94-year-old and a 26-year-old, but I have no strange or odd feelings about walking down the street, though. He's an amazing man, 94-year-old Hawaiian jazz musician who was born and raised in Honolulu, and he's probably the longest living musician who's still performing today. Most people my age, they lose their inspiration. Me, no. I feel young. I think young. If I was younger, I would marry her in a minute. He's in love with her.
She's not defining the parameters of the relationship clearly enough. I love this girl just as much as I love any of my family. It seems to be getting progressively more stressful to the point where I just need a break from him. So clearly an interesting dynamic going on there. Tell us briefly, Leo, I'm aware of the big clock ticking. Tell us the punchline, because obviously you spent a lot of time, as you say, on the road with this guy and effectively being, you know, looking after him. But what was the sort of PS to that relationship? What happened? So when the payment was done, actually things didn't get...
too much weirder we sort of carried on and when the film completed you know he actually joined us at many of the festival screenings and performed then we continued to have a really great relationship with him we went visited him you know um went to see his shows and whatnot um when he passed at 103 we get a phone call me and my film partner from his uh executor of his will and he said bill left you guys fifty thousand dollars um We were just incredibly moved. I don't know. I mean, I felt like that doesn't mean that the film is any better or worse, but we felt like we did right as documentarians that he thought of us, that he thought of us as somebody that was, people that were important in his life that he wanted to sort of leave a message for. You know, it was just really special. Did you plow that money into your next film? Promptly, we bought cameras with it. There's a poetry to that that pleases me. Don't we all do that?
That's fantastic. So I'm now thinking of the kind of back end of the process, really, the editing phase. We've got one more clip to show, which is Mr Gao. But this clip really speaks to how far you capture the character as far as you can in production. But the question to you is how far the character and the story actually comes out in the edit once you've captured your footage.
how that's crafted. Do you want to set this clip up? Yeah, yeah. So this film is called Mr. Gao Goes to Washington, and it was a commissioned work. I was commissioned to make a film about the first Vietnamese-American member of Congress in the U.S., in New Orleans. And he was tricky. He respected me because I had made another film prior to that about his community that was really well received. So he wanted to work with me. But, you know, as I was mentioning before, for him, there just isn't any reason for him to be super upfront and share his intimate.
thoughts with me. So I was constantly frustrated to try and capture those nuggets, those moments where I thought would be insightful beyond what's just really kind of propaganda. So he wasn't saying much? No, he would just... He wasn't saying what he really felt. And I got to know him well enough to know that that was the case. And I did come up with some tips. One of the things that I did was I started to experiment with times of day, scenarios where I could have conversations with him, or people that he's with where he tends to be a little bit more open. And I found out that he's really much more open when he's driving, and I'm just sitting next to him. So there's a lot of scenes in this film of me cranking myself like this, and then he's just kind of...
Chatting, chatting, chatting. I guess the lesson there in some ways is to really constantly examine your practice to make sure that you're doing the most you can do to capture the best footage you can capture. And then there's always some things you can try in post-production. Let's have a look at the clip, eh?
Mr. Gattell, how are you feeling today? We are still struggling with the loss of my father, but we are continuing our campaign, and I believe that my record speaks very loudly of the hard work that they've put into the Pacific the last two years, and I believe that the people have seen that, and they will cast their vote accordingly. Good. Thank you, Mr. Gattell. I appreciate that.
I feel a little bit down because I'm dealing with the death of my father. And I feel discouraged. I believe in a human nature that is honest, that has high integrity, that is focused on service. And to have the president of the United States, to the mayor of the city, to the local newspaper, endorsing a person whose character is highly questionable has been very discouraging to me. So clearly the car was the place to get him talking. Did you have lots of car footage? I'm actually kind of cringing in that last shot because the background is so blown out. It drives me crazy whenever I see it. So one of the things that I learned from that film and what we use really extensively as a device in that film is he talked to press a lot and he's always got something to say but what we started doing eventually was to end certain scenes with just a silent reaction of him.
I think that instead of hearing him kind of say things that at this point, the audience and I know that he doesn't necessarily mean, you might as well just leave a blank slate for the audience to project whatever they feel about that particular moment. So in a lot of scenarios, in terms of capturing the right material to construct the characters that you want, that is appropriate to the character, not to make it up, but to maximize the expression of the character. I often find that reaction shots are more important than getting the person speaking. Both the reaction shot of your main subject, but also people around him or her who's listening, those are going to be the material that's going to be really helpful in post-production. I think that dials right back to where we started this conversation in terms of finding a character. The most interesting characters are not necessarily the ones that are most vocal, that are larger than life. Maybe they don't speak much. Maybe they are hard to communicate with.
Nonetheless, as a documentary filmmaker, there are ways to capture them as people, and they are still interesting, even when, as you say, they're not speaking, they're reacting. So I think that's, in a lovely kind of way, that's brought us right back to thinking about how you actually find a good character in the first place. We're eating now into our question time, but I do, before we take some questions, excitingly, we have had some via the app. So I'm going to put a few of those to you in just a moment. But before we get to that, I just want to ask you, what would you tell the younger Leo? You've mentioned variously during our conversation that you've learned things as you've gone and that your approach to documentary filmmaking, to key character-driven filmmaking has evolved. So what would you tell the young Leo in terms of lessons learned?
I think that the first lesson I would tell younger myself is to trust your instinct. I think that we as filmmakers, what we're really doing is honing our instinct. We should get to a point where we react and we just know that that's the right thing to do. For me, there have been moments when it comes to casting, when it comes to choosing a subject where I know in the back of my mind that this is not the right thing to do, and I did it anyway, and I always regret it. So that's one. The other one, I think, for me is to...
sort of remind myself to invest myself fully but don't take it personally when something bad happens because it will always happen. It's this really tricky sort of, you know, there's not an equilibrium. You're always pushing and pulling of needing to just really be present and really be a part of this relationship that you're building with this person. See, it sounds like I'm married. But for you to be able to step back and see the big picture and to know that instead of taking certain things personally, you need to actually accommodate because that is what the relationship is. It is not a conventional marriage where you can actually fight back in every moment of the way.
And then the last thing is actually you can fix it in post. I mean, I know that's such a joke that everybody says. And again, not saying that you can fix everything in post, but you actually have way more latitude than you think. If you capture the material correctly, if you've been with your character long enough, if you've got all these great cutaway shots, if you have all the elements, you actually have a lot of flexibility. Big lessons learned there, and undoubtedly there are more.
I've cast my eye down the questions. Thank you to those of you in the audience who put them through via that app. We've actually got quite a flurry, so I'm not going to be able to get to all of them, unfortunately. But some of them do segue very nicely into the things that we've already been discussing. Leo, there's one here that says, how do you navigate your ongoing relationships with your subjects after the film is finished?
Well, the truth is after the film is finished, you actually are in this sort of distribution relationship with your subject, right? Like what happens generally is that, you know, I'm keeping them updated on where the film is going. They're actually coming to, you know, certain screenings or certain events. I might have things to ask of them. They might have things to ask of me. People would say, you know, can I have, well, I guess not anymore. I'm sort of dating myself. Can I have like 100 DVDs, you know, so I can go to my friends and I have to say things like, well, yes, but.
make sure that you don't give it to people in these markets because we're doing you know a broadcast there we're doing a theatrical screening there and we want to make sure that anyway um some of them remain friends some of them you sort of become this sort of check-in um relationship i i don't know you know i i felt like uh i had this idealized um an ideal vision that I would stay friends with my subjects forever. But that's not always the case. But I don't know. I don't think that there's a right or wrong answer to that. You know, if it feels like you're something meaningful in their life and there's something meaningful in your life, you just keep up the relationship. It's not. It doesn't mean that that relationship isn't there. It just isn't quite as close as it once was. And it will never be, right? It will never be this sort of weird, you know, symbiotic relationship that you have. You've obviously had some very good relationships with the characters, protagonists that you've worked with. We have got a question that is kind of the converse, which is...
Have you ever had a central character quit on a project? And if so, how did you win them back? No, I have not, actually. I've had a situation where a central character was demoted. I mean, not that they were becoming not the central character, but I was so frustrated with the access that I had with them. This kind of relates to that instinct thing that I had talked about earlier, trusting, like, the person's not quite right, then maybe they're not quite right. That I ended up promoting some of the supporting characters, right? And this is actually something that we probably...
come across a lot as observational filmmakers when you hang out with a group of people, what you initially project to be your main story or your main character change. And you need to be flexible with that. What happens to what was conceived as a one-person piece ends up to be kind of an ensemble piece with three main characters from the same group. So I ended up getting drawn into or finding somebody else more compelling, more willing, and they ended up getting way more screen time than we originally envisioned. But I've never had a main subject drop out.
Which is always, I think, all of our biggest fears. But I don't know, I always feel like... If you are building your relationship right, that will happen really early on. If it's going to work, then you'll find a way to work together. And I think at the beginning of the session, I said that you do have a particular talent. That seems apparent from talking to you, that you do find ways, you seem to be very sensitive to the different dynamics that happen within a relationship. I mean, you called it a marriage, which, you know, every relationship has its ups and downs, and you have to be sensitive to the particular person you're dealing with. You seem to have a particular knack for that. It does come out in your films, I will say. So I'm not surprised to hear that you haven't had any trouble.
with your protagonists. That's a really frightening thought, though, to have somebody drop out, especially during a pivotal moment. Okay, this I can share. I felt like I've actually known other folks who had that happen to them, but they were able to salvage the footage and make a film out of it, but then the relationship is very fraught from there on out. Sometimes legal actions are involved, and all that stuff just freaks me out. I can't deal with that.
I don't know, maybe I don't really have the stomach to be a documentary filmmaker. We've got various versions of the same question multiple people have asked this, so I'm going to ask it on their behalf. Can a filmmaker be the character? Another way of putting it is, what's advice that you would give to a filmmaker if you're in the film, essentially? I suppose that could happen if you're off screen, but clearly a presence in the film. What's your feeling about that? I think that there are great examples out there where filmmakers are...
in the film. And I'm not talking about first person, right? I imagine that they're not talking about themselves as the main subject, but that they participate in the film. I think if you watch somebody like Steve James, you guys all know who he is. American filmmaker, made Hoop Dreams. One of my favorite films, actually, the film he made about Roger Ebert, 2014, Life Itself. He's in every one of his films. I don't think people think about that. His voice is always in the film, but he does it so organically that you don't think about it. And then you have somebody like, what's her name, that made Edge of Democracy last year, the Brazilian filmmaker.
I'm blanking on her name. She literally made this really intense political film with access to two, you know, three presidents of Brazil. And she made it a first person film. She told the entire story through her own perspective. I think it's just a voice that you develop. And if it feels like that's, you know, feels organic to you, that's actually your signature voice. And I think that, you know, you should invest your time to develop that. I also come across a lot of projects that is so clear to me that it's actually the filmmakers film and they just refuse to be in the film. You know, I think that.
Oftentimes, if you ever come across a situation where somebody says, well, maybe you should be in the film, maybe you should think about what that would look like first before you say, oh, no, no, no, no, that's not. Because oftentimes that's the journey that people are most interested in. Do we have time for, we're right out of time. It's turning red, you're not joking. Well, it's gone pink, so we're in the dead zone. One more question, yeah. So there's a late entry here, which is kind of also, you know, to do with the relationship between what's going on off-camera and on-camera. Somebody has asked, do you find you can achieve the same level of intimacy with a subject when you're a director working with a cinematographer as when you're the shooter director? That is such a great question. That is a great question. Late entry, whoever sent that one in. Yeah, great question. I have a hard time doing it, but I think that's because I'm a shooter and that's my practice.
I always think that one more person, half the intimacy. But a lot of people have proven me wrong. You know, the filmmaker I mentioned earlier, the Chinese filmmaker who I'm producing for, he always works with a full crew. So there's a sound person and there's a camera person and they get the most amazing material. So I don't have an answer for you on that. But for me, I feel like the best scenes tends to be the ones where it's just me and the camera and the subject or subjects, you know, but because when you're just you and the subject, it's actually an interview. I know people think that's observational footage. No, it's not observational footage. It's an interview. No.
Good question and a great answer. So we are out of time. We are in the red zone, according to the clock, so I'm going to adhere to that. Leo, I want to thank you so much. I feel like I could have talked to you for hours, actually, because there's a lot, clearly, to think about when you are making character-driven pieces. But I think today, just in this hour, we've learned a lot, and I'm sure it will have galvanized many people in the audience who may be either thinking about going into a long-term documentary that has a central character or character.
or indeed in the midst of one and wrestling with the sorts of challenges and issues that you've spoken about variously from your own experience today. So will you all join me in thanking Leo very much? Thank you, Ginny. Thank you, everyone.