Skip to content
All Else Being Equal, Capitalism Will Suffocate the Planet episode artwork

Jun 7, 2021 53 min

All Else Being Equal, Capitalism Will Suffocate the Planet

from District Sentinel Radio Hosted by District Sentinel Radio

-Capitalists are operating on some dangerous assumptions about climate change, clashing with scientists’ warnings. An audio version of the latest newsletter: sign up at districtsentinel.substack.com -More Trump-era attacks on journalists were exposed last week. Chip Gibbons on the subpoenas of four NYT journalists in the latest edition of Chip-Chat. Music by Adam Fligsten www.adamfligsten.com This is an excerpt from Friday's District Sentinel Radio, available in full for subscribers at Patreon.com/DistrictSentinel

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

All Else Being Equal, Capitalism Will Suffocate the Planet

0:00 53:27
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is District Sentinel Radio. I am Sam Knight. Before we get into this week's Chip Chat, we have a special segment for you, an audio version of the latest edition of our newsletter, which you can subscribe to for free at districtsentinel.substack.com. Before we get into it, I'd also like to ask you to support us if you can. Head over to patreon.com slash districtsentinel and subscribe for just $5 a month. It gets you access to all our audio content, plus you get access to Means TV and all the great things available there.

If you can't afford a subscription right now, but still want to listen to all our stuff, reach out. We can hook it up. DM us on Twitter at the DC Sentinel, or email us at dcsentinelnews at yahoo.com, or email me personally, samueledwardsknight at gmail.com. We don't want money to get in the way of you and our news content, but if you can support us, help us keep the lights on for just a few bucks a month. Anyway, without further delay, here's an audio version of the latest newsletter post. All else being equal, capitalism will suffocate the planet. For all the claims about communism only working in theory, capitalist thought is built on thoroughly asinine assumptions. The idea that markets efficiently allocate resources hinges on the assumptions that individuals are purely rational beings and that information about commodities flows freely. The idea that markets are competitive is built on the assumption that business owners will not act on their class interests by colluding with one another over time, not even implicitly.

And the idea that a higher minimum wage causes unemployment is built on the assumption that one must analyze the impact of higher wages on demand for labor in a vacuum, ignoring the fact that poor people with more money will spend most of it, thereby stimulating economic output. With a few simple assumptions, alchemy becomes chemistry. Recently, we saw an incredible iteration of this type of narrow-minded thinking on display during a hearing held by the Senate Banking Committee. The top Republican on the panel, Pat Toomey from Pennsylvania, blasted the Federal Reserve for its meager approach to addressing the impact of climate change on the financial industry by making an incredibly facile assumption. Put simply, neither the warming of the Earth's temperature nor severe weather events are a threat to the stability of the financial system. Experience bears this out. In the last 11 years, a time period that included four of the five costliest hurricanes in U.S. history, we haven't found one bank failure caused by any weather event. In fact, we're not aware of any bank failure in the modern era due to weather.

It's maddening enough that Toomey's analysis comes with the steady rise of the oceans threatening coastal communities across the world. On top of this, the western U.S. is currently dealing with debilitating droughts with the hottest months of summer yet to come. Farmers in New Mexico are being told to refrain from planting crops this year. Ranchers in Washington are selling their cattle and applying for emergency aid as grass for grazing has withered. The governor of Utah, Spencer Cox, urged his state's residents to pray for rain this past weekend with soil moisture at record lows.

In North Dakota, at the start of May, wildfires had already burned six times as many acres in the state as they do in the average year. And 130 houseboats have been forced off of a receding Lake Oroville in California, which provides drinking water to 27 million people and water to 4 to 5 million acres of farmland. Yet, Senator Toomey wants us to believe that regulators overseeing the financial industry, which exists to manage risk, should be indifferent to these calamities, which are increasingly becoming predictable annual events. Even if oceans weren't rising, the parching of the western United States would be enough to cause panic among those tasked with ensuring economic stability. Fortunately for Toomey, despite his tantrum, the Fed's plans to address climate change don't amount to much. The central bank has merely been pressing big banks to reveal how their balance sheets could be adversely impacted by the effects of climate change, something that many banks have already been doing, in part because European regulators are getting ready to subject global banks to climate-related stress tests this year.

The Fed's aim, as Reuters reported on May 13th, is simply, quote, to identify risk. Here was Fed Chair Jerome Powell in March. We actually are just in the very early stages of considering stress scenarios, and that's what others are doing too. It's an emerging idea. It's not actually something that people are conducting now, but we're doing that and many other things to, again, to get a basic understanding of how the financial system can be resilient against what may be very significant emerging risks over time. We already know what risks are increasing to the financial sector and the entire planet, thanks in part to bank support of Dirty Energy Ventures.

A coalition of groups led by 350.org, Sierra Club, Public Citizen, Americans for Financial Reform, and Rainforest Action Network has therefore called on the Fed to implement, quote, capital requirements to reflect climate risk and to use its authorities to limit the financing of emissions. The Fed has declined to go this route, but with disclosure requirements, the central bank can at least pretend that it's trying to do something. The biggest banks in the country are also taking action of a similar kind, pledging PR-friendly moves that cast a pall over the planet's future. Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, Wells Fargo, and Morgan Stanley have all recently set themselves targets of financing ventures with net zero emissions by 2050.

In the short term, however, they will continue to finance dirty energy projects, despite pleas from scientists for governments to cease the establishment of new fossil fuel infrastructure to meet the goals set by the same governments under the Paris Climate Accord, limiting the warming of the planet from pre-industrial levels to 1.5 degrees Celsius, thereby avoiding the point at which the catastrophic impact of warming becomes irreversible. This call to keep oil and gas in the ground was recently echoed by the International Energy Agency, long an industry-friendly organization, but the capitalists who run the world, who put hundreds of billions of dollars into fossil fuel ventures annually, are continuing to ignore the pleas. This was J.P. Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon being asked about climate change before the Senate Banking Committee the day after Toomey scolded the Fed.

I think we need a really immature conversation on climate. We need carbon tax. We need industry policy. It's not just about banks stopping financing. We're going to need oil and gas for a long time. They're clearly operating on a different set of assumptions than the actual scientists. Let's chip chat. We're joined by journalist Chip Gibbons. Hey, Chip. Hello, Sam and Sam. Hello, Chip. Hello, hello, hello. So it seems like with Trump out of office, we're learning more and more about his administration's surveillance exploits against journalists.

We knew that a few weeks ago it was reported that Barbara Starr over at CNN was surveilled, which is funny because there probably hasn't been a Pentagon journalist more favorable to the Pentagon in the last few decades than Barbara Starr. Yet the administration felt like they needed to keep tabs on what was going on, I guess, probably to find some leaker or something or whatever their claim is. Now we're learning that some... She wasn't enthusiastic enough in her cheerleading and they were worried. They were checking on her. They were worried. She's been compromised. It was a wellness check.

So now we've got a new batch of reporters at The New York Times, it turns out, that were targeted. They had their phone records confiscated here. Correct, Chip? Yeah. So a couple of days ago, we learned that as part of a leak investigation, the Trump administration seized the phone records of four New York Times reporters. For people who don't know what that means, this is non-content information. This is metadata. So this is like who called them? Who did they call?

How long were the calls for? And we earlier in the last month have learned also that the Trump administration did something similar to Barbara Starr. They pulled the phone records of both her Pentagon extension number, the CNN Pentagon phone booth number, her work and her work email at her personal email. Once again, this was non-content data. This was who emailed her.

who she called, et cetera. And then slightly before that, it also turned out that they had done the same thing to reporters at the Washington Post. We've also learned that Bob Barr was seeking a subpoena against the person who was operating a David Nunes parody account, which continued on. It was a cow, right? It was some kind of cow?

Devin Munoz? I don't know if it was the Cal or not. I thought it was the Cal, and I read the—I don't know. There's multiple parody accounts involved here. There could be. I don't really track Devin Munoz's parody. It is not my beat. I'm a little bit fixated on, like, you know, the espionage act to see what fettitious— We'll bring on a different expert next week. A Cal expert. That's fine. That is fine. But they'd previously done so to two Washington Post reporters and—three Washington Post reporters. And all of this is in early 2017. It all centers around initially reporting around Michael Flynn's activities as well as around—

so-called Russian interference in the election. And these are part of, we know very little about what they were seeking other than their leak investigations. And it's worth pointing out that, you know, Jeffrey Sterling, the whistleblower who was in jail for three and a half years under the Espionage Act, convicted of giving information to James Risen, he denied he did so. The sole evidence against him presented at trial was the metadata of his cause with James Risen, right? That he had called James Risen, James Risen had called for him and they spoke for like...

two minutes and 30 seconds on the phone or something like that. And that circumstantial evidence alone was enough to convict Jeffrey Sterling in the Eastern District of Virginia. I will again note that Sterling claims he was wrongfully convicted and that I... you know, tabling for a second the fact that it's a whistleblower. I mean, if I was on a jury, I would not return an indictment based on that evidence. Right. I think it's extremely, extremely weak evidence. Unfortunately, due process and reasonable doubt don't mean very much in this country anymore. And so you get these sort of absurd convictions of people based on on metadata, especially reporters phone calls. I mean, reporter calls all sorts of people to try. And I mean, you don't know if information was exchanged there. Reporter could have just been digging.

Yeah. So, I mean, with these whistleblower cases, they sort of run these trials or indictments based on who knew the information and who spoke to James Risen. So, you know, in the Daniel Hale case, which we talked about a lot, Daniel Hale was not allowed to argue in court that someone else gave information. was the source of the leak unless he could prove the existence of someone who had that information and had a relationship with the same reporter. Funny story, in Jeffrey Sterling's case, his defense did present evidence of the existence of someone. One of the prosecution's witnesses was a Senate intelligence employee who had been fired from the committee for giving information to the exact same journalist, right? And the whole reason Jeffrey Sterling is targeted is because in 2003, he went to the Senate Intelligence Committee as a whistleblower and gave the information about Operation Merlin, the CIA covert action against Iran's.

nuclear program. And then it shows up in James Risen's book in 2006. And the Bush administration is very convinced that someone from the Senate Intelligence Committee had given James Risen this information. A number of people knew the information that Sterling had, that Risen published. And Sterling was not the only one of them to talk to James Risen.

But the metadata signed up to jail for three and a half years. So this is one of the types of reporting we've seen is this unprecedented, shocking Trump administration move. But with all of Trump's attacks on the press, all of Trump's attacks on whistleblowers, the precedent was very much set in the Obama and Bush administrations with Bush setting up a task force to go after whistleblowers, Obama prosecuting more under the Espionage Act than any other administration before him combined, and the Obama administration literally putting someone in jail based on the type of information the Trump administration was seeking from these reporters. So I do think it is important. to realize these tools are given to Trump by Obama. It does seem the Trump administration was looking for leaks about Russiagate and Michael Flynn. Usually with leak investigations, they do not originate within the political part of the branch. They come from the NSA or they come from the CIA and they push this. Whereas this does look like Trump was looking for reporters that are...

you know, implying he had Russian involvement. People know what I feel about that. His own legal matters. His own legal matters. Yeah, just like, you know, Barr pursuing the Devin Nunes Cal account, you know, not a national security matter as far as I'm aware.

So Nunes, sorry, Barr did not pursue at Devin Cow. It was at Devin Alt. It was at Nunes Alt. But the Devin Cow account has been mentioned in the background of the story because Nunes himself tried to sue. He tried to sue Twitter for $250 million. And he also sued Nunes Alt and at Devin Cow. And the suit was dismissed.

And he tried to have them unmask the identity of a cow. I mean, that was a huge, that was the huge free press, right? NAACP, the Alabama, you have a right to anonymous speech. You know, here you have the government trying to unmask people who are engaging in anonymous speech. That's supposed to be a no-no. Chip, is your alarm going off? Yes. Can I get that? Yeah, go ahead. We'll take a second beat here so that Chip can turn his alarm off that has been going, blaring in the background for the last two minutes of this interview here.

It's the injustice alarm. It uh sounds So buddy, I wish I could sleep past seven Chip you're talking about the president before three in the morning. So, you know, okay Well fair point if you know how many hours a night I sleep no matter how tired I am like from like 10 to 2. I'm just wide awake Yeah, we're on we're on different sleep schedules. I fall asleep at like 10 30 nowadays so you're talking about the precedence set uh the obama administration targeted ap journalists yeah yes specifically uh the the obama administration targeting ap journalists phone records there was news reporter yeah jeffrey rosen um Jeffrey Rosen followed me on Twitter for a while. It was kind of weird. He still might follow me. No one cares. I will say that Rob Schneider has unfollowed me on Twitter. I had Rob Schneider's follow for a while. Was he on a television show? He was on Saturday Night Live for a while. He was the making copies guy. He wasn't the guy who was on All in the Family and then became an expert on Russia.

I don't think so. Didn't one of the liberal resistance groups have, like, the guy who played the son and all in the family as, like, the spokesperson? And he's like, we're at war with Russia. It's like, I'm sorry. Sounds accurate. Sounds like that's true. That sounds correct. Yeah, he's Deuce Bigelow. He's the anti-vaxxer liberal. He's an anti-vaxxer liberal. There used to be a lot of those. Yeah, one of those Hollywood anti-vaxx liberals. There are a lot of anti-vaxxers on the left. There are. Well, it's a California thing. I think it's, like, a rich...

I think part of it was like an anti-corporate globalization. True. There was that angle to it. That's true. I think there's like an... I think there's also a link between people who criticize Monsanto and transgenic agriculture, which...

has problems for sure, but usually the people who fixate on these issues don't exactly get to the crux of why these things are problematic, why Monsanto and crops that are built to resist heavy applications of pesticide are problematic. Yeah, with the late 90s, early 2000s anti-corporate globalization movement, there is a lot of anti-Monsanto, a lot of anti-GMO, and some of that did bleed over into anti-vaxxer stuff. uh who then all became like sandy hook truthers i don't really understand the gmo to school shootings aren't real pipeline but it is uh if you go on that website right like naturalfoodnews.com have you been on that website like naturalfoodnews.com it's been a while and like all they're like oh i'm gonna learn about like organic kale i'm gonna learn about organic kale and like all the articles are like sandy hook didn't happen it was a false flag like why do you is this this is not news about natural food i'm very very upset i wanted to learn about like you know organic kale and how like corn syrup and the salad dressing caused covet um but instead i'm getting you know

Different conspiracy theories. Not the conspiracy theories I wanted to read. Well, before I got sidetracked by bragging about my followers on my big verified Twitter account, I was saying, you know, that there was that scandal, a quote scandal, under the Obama administration where it was revealed that they were targeting journalists. It should have been more of a scandal, but the only scandal was Obama wearing a damn tan suit. It was Tope. Oh, wow. Tope suit. Yeah. Do you remember that, Jeff?

I remember that. I've seen the meme. I've seen the meme. But that's not true because there was also the scandal about Barack Obama not saluting the helicopter. Oh, when he was carrying the coffee. Yeah. Even though no president did this before Ronald Reagan, as they are not, you know, members of the military. And Ronald Reagan was just deranged.

I thought he had been in the military because he'd been in a movie where he played a military member. In response to criticism, the Obama administration put out some window dressing reforms about how if journalists are going to have their phone records collected, then it's got to be signed off by the attorney general, which has thought, well, Eric Holder's a reasonable guy. I'm saying the way liberals at the time responded who were satisfied with these window dressing reforms is they trust Eric Holder. Of course, the next guy who was attorney general was Jeff Sessions, who seemed to have no qualms whatsoever about targeting leakers or being a part of this war on leakers within the administration and therefore any sort of safeguard that, oh, well, we're going to require the attorney general who knows the significance, obviously, of targeting journalists just immediately evaporated.

So one of the quote-unquote reforms that Barr put in place in response to sort of the FBI's, you know, both actual and imagined misconduct during the Trump-Russia investigation was that in order to open, I think, an investigation on a sitting elected official or candidate for office, you had to get the attorney general's approval, and the liberals freaked out about that, like, how dare you have to get the approval of the attorney general to spy on a elected official? completely reasonable reform. And when you have these types of investigations that are of an extremely sensitive nature, the person at the very top of the chain should have to approve each one. Do I think that Eric Holder or Jeff Sessions or Bill Barr are going to make good choices? The answer is probably not. But the fact that you have to get each of them to sign off on something, whether it's opening an investigation into a member of Congress or seizing a journalist's phone records, or even just opening an investigation into local anti-pipeline activists, I totally think the attorney general should have to sign off on it. As far as the Holder guidelines, one of the questions that has been thrown out there is whether or not

they followed them or not. And I know a lot of press freedom groups have sent letters to the Biden Justice Department demanding they answer the question as to whether or not the guidelines were followed. I know that Ron Wyden and Jamie Raskin are considering legislation on this subject. I generally prefer legislation to guidelines from the attorney general since they're harder to change. So yeah, after the James Risen scandal where Eric Holder tried to briefly consider putting James Risen in jail for not naming his source during the Jeffrey Sterling persecution, the end result of that was widespread horror and the implementing of these guidelines.

Maybe this is just my own fixation on this subject, but I'm still thinking about the Jeffrey Sterling conviction. And it seems like a good reform, a low-hanging fruit reform, so to speak, would be to move any national security case, so to speak, out of the Eastern District of Virginia, where you're more likely to get a jury full of people who either are like Pentagon national security contractors or who live on a street entirely. full of national security contractors and would therefore be more sympathetic to the prosecution's case by virtue of their own economy that they live in.

Yeah, no, I absolutely do not think these cases should be automatically brought in the Eastern District of Virginia. As we've discussed numerous times on the Chip Chat segment in relationship to numerous different trials brought in the Eastern District of Virginia, that there is zero way a whistleblower can get a fair trial in that district. The Jeffrey Sterling conviction is absurd. I do think there's a greater problem with erosion of norms around due process in our society, but I also think that's just also the Eastern District being absurd, returning a conviction based on... circumstantial evidence so i don't think most people realize this because circumstantial evidence is usually used as a pejorative term as a legal matter uh circumstantial evidence is no less evidence than like non-circumstantial evidence right and you can convict someone you can send someone to the death penalty you can get some the death penalty based you know solely on circumstantial evidence i don't think most people realize that because when you hear circumstantial evidence in layman's terms it's like you have circumstantial evidence saying i ate the m&ms implying that you know evidence is not real evidence to the evidence there's all sorts of types of circumstantial evidence some a lot stronger than than others but in legal terms circumstantial evidence is evidence you can convict someone on circumstantial evidence alone you can you can you can murder someone well there's certain circumstances that are irrefutable that are just like well there's only one one situation which these circumstances could have arisen

I'm not sure. I'm not sure what the debate is here, though. But we're getting into a legal epistemological debate that might be a bit above the two Sam's pay grade here. I think we're going to have to. Well, I think I think I think that, you know, there's a thing where it's like my jury. Well, there's people saying, well, you know, the Wuhan lab was located in the same place that the coronavirus started. You know, that's a that's a piece of circumstantial evidence. It's not it's not it's not as strong as scientific evidence that would find traces of the virus elsewhere not related to the Wuhan lab.

Just like the NDA authorization to investigate the origins of Lyme disease, right, is based on similar circumstantial evidence that Lyme disease, when we first recognized it, emerged in this town, Lyme, where there was a U.S. bioweapons facility, which is, you know, when illnesses, when strange illnesses arise near, you know, bioresearch or bioweapons, people tend to wonder, is there a connection? Well, I'm not familiar with this Lyme disease. The Lyme disease? Really? This seems like one of the conspiracy theories you'd be really into. So Lyme disease is named after a town called Lyme something. And like in that town was a U.S. bioweapons research lab. And several years ago in the NDAA, Congress authorized like 40 years after the fact an investigation into essentially was Lyme disease, a lab leak. Were they infecting ticks and stuff?

well since that like in the intervening 40 years between the discovery of you know Lyme disease a strange illness and like I think it was like Lyme Lyme Connecticut or something that I don't know and and you know the NDAA like we've discovered like like fossils or frozen ambers or something like thousands of years old with the same disease in it but it was first discovered after a weird outbreak in a town where there was a UO bioweapon It was an ancient alien research lab that leaked Lyme disease. Several, several. Okay. Do we have any idea, Chip, on how... No, I have no idea, but anyone who asked me, I'm not going to answer. Okay. We probably don't have an idea, but care to wait for a guess on how these records were collected? I'm thinking when it's metadata... You know? I mean, did the government just went to the companies and the phone companies and collected this metadata? Because it wasn't too long ago when we learned it was alleged that the government already had this data in massive stores that they could just kind of search their databases for. I would assume they either got a subpoena or a national... I believe...

I believe I've seen the word subpoena used in some of the articles, but not all of them. You can get this type of information either through a subpoena or a national security letter. You don't need a warrant. It's a very low bar. People remember my five-year struggle to release the FBI's files on the International Solidarity Movement. They pulled the call records of two of the ISM activists. I don't even know what they were investigating there. There was no reasonable suspicion of a crime or anything. So these records are not that hard to pull. And to bring in something that...

I have reported on. There were subpoenas. to obtain the personal information of WikiLeaks volunteers, many of whom lived in Iceland, were Icelandic, and one could presume that maybe they could go to a foreign intelligence surveillance court to get this sort of information. In this case, there were subpoenas delivered to Google and Twitter in order to receive this information. I think it's important when we talk about surveillance and surveillance without much due process is that there's an assumption that because there's this complete lack of due process. These are things that the government doesn't really want people to know about. But at the end of the day, I think they kind of do want people to know about some of these things because they want to, you know, create this sort of panopticon chilling effect. And they want people to know to a certain extent that they can obtain these files. Chip, you're looking a little skeptical here. No, I'm just thinking about sort of, you know, in the 60s, right? I think it was the 60s, Smith v. Maryland, the Supreme Court rules you don't need a warrant to get...

metadata there's an incidence where this woman's getting like prank calls and they go and put some sort of device at the phone company that records you know back in the 60s this is a big deal to see who's calling someone uh today you could just i guess look at the verizon bill um and and records all that the supreme court rules it's not a search and congress goes and passes legislation which requires you to get a subpoena or a national security letter to to get this type of information so uh this data is incredibly low but There is a standard because people in the elected branch were disturbed by the Supreme Court being like, this doesn't need a warrant. Of course, they didn't make the standard a warrant. They made it a subpoena or a national security letter, which neither one is that hard to get. I was also going to say, I think it's important to note that in the context of this sort of...

erosion of due process and the erosion of civil liberties that, as Chip noted, has spanned several administrations now, it really all stems from the war on terror mindset and the country's reaction to 9-11. And in some of this reporting, we see that President Biden is sort of saying that, oh, I would never subpoena the records of journalists. Well, Let's see about that. We're only five months in to the Biden administration. This is a guy who called Julian Assange a high-tech terrorist just for publishing information, a guy who didn't really seem to have much of a problem with the Obama administration going after James Risen, the AP reporters, et cetera, et cetera. It really stems to a deeper malaise in society and a collective sort of sickness that we haven't really been able to treat since the attacks of 9-11. Yeah, I mean, 9-11 is part of the story here, but the war against due process and just sort of mundane criminal matters.

predates 11 by a long shot. It goes back to, you know, as soon as the Warren court is making decisions like Miranda. And for decades, you have these Nancy Grace types on television who do this sensationalistic crime reporting. Everyone's guilty already because they know, because they're on the television and they know more than anyone else. And, you know, when people aren't found guilty, it's because of, you know, high price defense attorneys and liberal judges and just this sort of bullshit narrative that's not allowed to fester. And unfortunately, I think a lot of people across the political spectrum, you know, engage in a lot of Nancy Grace-like behavior or sort of question concepts like, you know, is someone, you know.

reasonable doubt and things like that. So I think it's a wider cultural problem. There used to be civil liberties groups that defend it, the due process rights of the criminally accused. That's increasingly politically unpopular, even more so than it was. I don't know. It's a dark situation when it comes to the state of criminal procedure in the United States. And the problem is far greater than the war on terror. And it also involves a lot of well-meaning people because like bad crimes do happen, right? Violent crimes, crimes of exploitation, crimes of abuse. And, you know, you get these sorts of highly sort of emotional subjects and people just come in and exploit that. They're like, okay, take away, you make it easier to search people's houses, make it easier to convict people, less evidence required, you know, vilify defense attorneys, vilify, you know, judges who don't throw the books at people. And there's a lot of different moving pieces here.

including some well-meaning people who are rightfully reacting to horrible violent crimes as well as just cynical authoritarians like Nancy Grace and the drug war. Drug war was a huge problem here and the war on terror. I think a lot of this also goes back to the need to abolish police. And these are federal investigators. They're not like your beat cops. But at the end of the day, they are police. And one common characteristic of a lot of police officers is they're really fucking lazy. And if they have tools and methods that allow them to find answers, regardless of the civil liberties that are violated in the process, they will often choose those methods. So if you're in a leak investigation at the Department of Justice.

Why not just go and subpoena every journalist or find every journalist phone records and do an easy job with your with your investigation there? So, I mean, even if we had some sort of cultural awakening that moved to enact tighter controls on investigators and police and rules. I mean, they'd still break them. I mean, I might be trending too much into like an anarchist argument here against that anybody in this position is going to be corrupted, so we can't have these positions. But cops aren't allowed to do a lot of things, and we still see them engage in a lot of these behaviors that violate people's civil liberties. Yeah, I mean, I don't disagree with that, but I mean...

I think they're both problems, right? And I don't think one nullifies or excuses the other, right? The fact that we have people in our society who may or may not be well-meaning, who are screaming that it's too hard to convict people in certain really bad crimes. How do we rectify the fact that we do have an unequal justice system that allows people who crashed our economy, who exploit millions, who engage in rampant fraud to not face any sort of punishment, whereas someone who uses a counterfeit bill to buy cigarettes is... executed by cops like you have to somehow highlight this discrepancy yes no i agree with that i agree with that yes i i don't have any sympathy for financial crimes um and in those cases the reason why these people aren't prosecuted is because they do have access to uh well-connected uh high-cost defense teams and there's a number of reasons why they're not prosecuted the complexity of crimes too a lot of the conduct is legal Yeah, well, there's a lot of legal. Yeah, I mean, there is a there is a two tier system of justice, but the problem is not, you know, too much due process, not, you know, bad defense attorneys. The problem is that that's not the problem. And like lowering the standards across the board. So we live in this sort of disturbing authoritarian society. It's very equal in which we all, you know, have our due process rights regularly. Violate is not the solution. I think some people seem to think it is, but it's not. Sam, I think your problem is you're not going.

anarchist enough. Well, I was just going to say that. Bring back the UFOs. I prefer that to the anarchists. Well, I just think in this case, it's not so much an issue of police abolition as it is of national security state abolition. Because in the cases of the reporters and the subpoenaing of their records, we're talking about the heart of the legal matter is we have an unofficial state secrets act.

These aren't, you know, quote unquote crimes. Yeah, that the, you know, that, oh dear, I may have talked myself into a corner here, but. you know, the idea that leaking classified information is a criminal act. We have an official act for that, Sam. Sure. Which was modeled in part off of the British State Secrets Act. Okay, well, fair enough. The broader application... I think it's a dot now, I realize that. A pedant. Two can play at that game. I guess what I'm saying here is that, like, this is not per se an issue of, like, the typical sort of over-policing that we see in marginalized communities. This is a case of a...

of a government that operates in extreme secrecy because it has global hegemonic interests all over the world. Redundant there. But anyway, the point is, is that the heart of this matter is maybe is the national security state itself and not overzealous policing as we commonly know it. No, I think there are two very different problems. And maybe that's not going too anarchist. I think there are two different problems that people oftentimes fold into, you know, one another. Yes, the FBI, our police, you know, the problem with like local city cops who like rummage through neighborhoods and beat people up is a very different problem than like what goes on in the Jagger Hoover building. They're involved in different types of policing. They're both bad. They're bad in different ways. I don't think folding everything into one category where like, well, all of the things are bad. Therefore, all I have to know is that, you know, they're bad. You know, it works. And I think there's a lot of.

simplistic thinking that is popular these days. More to my point was the use of certain methods that cops, like FBI agents, are going to use whatever tools they have at their disposal to conduct an investigation and arrive at a conclusion. And technology has given them very powerful tools to do this, that when using those tools, they can trample on people's civil liberties. But at the end of the day, cops, like FBI agents, don't give a shit because they are... lazy that was my ultimate argument i do think that they're i mean i do think that they're and i wasn't trying to to sort of make the broader connection of of the the the sort of war on terror national security state come home to police the streets and black communities but i do think that there are a lot of parallels there and a lot of the same motivations at work i mean the same way that the feds will set up a young muslim man to commit a an act of terror that was not his idea at all but just exploit this guy is very similar to the way like buy and bust yeah yeah the way the cops that terrorize black communities

The most horrifying thing to me in the movie Seven, the David Fincher movie about the serial killer who does horrible things, is the scene where they pull the serial killer's library records. Like the greasy FBI agent comes and gives the two. I've not seen this movie. Oh, yeah. Kevin Spacey, who probably didn't have to undergo a lot of preparation for the role.

But yeah, no, I was just like, okay, okay. And I'm like, oh my god, they've got the library records? That was my reaction while watching it. Yeah, I mean, I guess, like, at some point, police think it's useful to look at someone's library records, or else it wouldn't be a thing. Well, in the movie 7, it's key to the plot. Is it? Checking out books, how to do crimes, and then doing those crimes? No, they're checking out, like, Pilgrim's Progress.

A book about this. Never mind. A book about the seven deadly sins. The police officers are also, like, highly intellectual, as is the serial killer. Everyone is, like, has a lot of knowledge of, like, you know. Just like the real world. You just have criminals and cops, just the highest intellect people going at each other every day. A battle of the wits. A battle of the wits. Should we wrap it up there? Any final thoughts on anything? Snacks? The story? Whatever you haven't brought up? No, I have to go to work. I have to go to my office, so, you know. I would like to talk about these. I was going to suggest it this week, but maybe for next week or not at all.

But I am interested in talking about the government pushing the sonic weapons stuff, or the microwave weapons stuff. Oh, okay. I don't have any intel there. Neither does the U.S. government. Yeah, exactly. None of us do. So it makes a great topic just to bullshit about it. Maybe it was the UFOs, Sam. Maybe it was your friends the UFOs. Maybe. It's more likely than the theory that's being put forward by certain people. Let me just say, I'm a little miffed at some online conduct by two friends of the show, Chip and Ted, who were riffing with each other last night about how dumb everybody is who believes in aliens.

Not quite what happened, but... Okay, you're right. Maybe I'm exaggerating that. But let me say what exactly did happen is you and Ted, and I hope Ted hears this. I hope Ted does too. Ted shared a claim by some Twitter account that didn't include any link, any sort of corroboration that claimed that the Pentagon was already using the UFO releases to ask for more funding for more weapons research programs or flight research programs.

Which is a claim that's often repeated, but I haven't seen anywhere. I haven't seen this this ask anywhere Okay, what do you got? So the original the tweet that was quoted was did everyone catch Defense Department officials claiming UFOs exist and then immediately pivoting to using them as a justification for more military funding So the US can win a hypothetical in intergalactic arms race then Ted for stack retweeted that 12 hours ago Literally every time they start talking about aliens. There's a massive new Pentagon budget on the way to which I reply. Thank you I would just note that there is always... I would like to note that Sam made a claim that Ted and I were online riffing about how dumb everyone is who believes in aliens. And literally, Ted said something about Pentagon budgets, and I said, thank you. I would like people to recognize that Sam has a very dishonest style of... What were you thanking Ted for? I used to watch the Dr. Phil show. I went in the Dr. Phil house. Dr. Phil would physically shake you and tell you he was sick of hauling your lazy ass around. You would have to thank him for doing so. I would have expected...

I'm just looking for corroboration. I'm just looking for corroboration on the claim that was retweeted and that you thanked for. I'm looking for corroboration. That's all I want is a link. I want a link.

Thank you for sharing your lie, Sam. If we replay the tip, if we replay the exchange, and I'm not going to do it now, but the listeners can replay the exchange. I started saying something. Please do. No, no, no. Please read it again, because I have something to say about this exchange. Read it again. I can't read it. I can't physically read it. I don't know how to rewind the tape or anything. We're recording. I just want to say, I will apologize when I first started explaining the story. When I first started explaining the story, and listeners can go back and listen, I did explain it in a way that was incorrect, and then when you explained it, I said, you're right, you're right, you're right.

And then I pivoted to get more detail and clarity on what exactly my beef was. Not that you guys were calling, or you all were calling UFOs, UFOs, people who believe they're stupid, but that you were sharing uncorroborated, unlinked information, disinformation on Twitter. That's all I was saying. Let Chip go to work. For what? That's what I'm asking for. This is why you think circumstantial evidence should send people to the death chamber, Sam. That's what I think. Now you're lying about me. Now you're lying about me. No, this is Nancy Gray's erosion of due process mentality at work here, right? Wait, wait, wait. Like, one does not support the other. There is a textual record. There is a close reading of the text you can give. Anything beyond that is unwarranted speculation. All I'm looking for is a link. You're respecting me about my internal motives and dialogues to which you do not know because you neither have the capacity to read my mind, nor are you trained in psychoanalysis to the best of my knowledge. Yeah, to the best of your knowledge, that's right. And I said to the best of my knowledge, whereas you...

Yes, I acknowledge the limits of my knowledge. Sam Knight, go ahead, have the last word on this. Okay, the UFO Pentagon budget thing is circumstantial evidence because the Pentagon budget always increases every year. So by that logic, you can't talk about anything because if you talk about anything, the Pentagon budget will increase because it already is. Sam Knight, I'm glad I've taught you to be more rigorous in your argumentation today. I'm proud of your remark. Thank you. Now let's let Chip go to work. I have something to add, but I'm not going to add it. Chip needs to go to work. Chip has to go to work. I have something that would have ended this debate and declared me the winner, but I'm not going to share it because Chip has to go to work.

And then I'm gonna go and get lunch. Right, I'm just gonna be the person who shows right up two hours late. Enjoy your lunch, Chip. Enjoy your lunch. I will make an effort.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of District Sentinel Radio?

This episode is 53 minutes long.

When was this District Sentinel Radio episode published?

This episode was published on June 7, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this District Sentinel Radio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.