Skip to content
Altering Reality: How to Change the World episode artwork

Mar 16, 2021 27 min

Altering Reality: How to Change the World

from MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx Hosted by KULTURPOP

How do you disrupt change? Rather than trying to improve reality, is Big Tech focused on helping us escape from it and avoid the troubling issue of social change? Hosts: Matt Armitage & Richard Bradbury Produced: Richard Bradbury for BFM89.9 Episode Sources: https://www.wired.com/story/billionaires-use-vr-avoid-social-change/ https://www.polygon.com/2021/1/14/22228885/fortnite-music-concerts-travis-scott Follow us: www.kulturpop.com https://www.instagram.com/kulturpop/ https://twitter.com/kulturmatt

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Altering Reality: How to Change the World

0:00 27:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is a download from BFM 89.9, the Business Station. BFM 89.9, the Business Station. My name is Rich Bradbury, and this is Matt Splain. We're talking about altering reality and disrupting change today.

How do you disrupt change? I don't know either. But according to my arm of a tage, it has something to do with virtual reality. Matt, disrupting change?

OK, stay with me here. A couple of weeks back, I did an episode of A Bit of Culture, and I was talking about virtual reality, and how it has the potential to be used, not just as a catalyst for new experiences, but also as a means of control. Now, I don't know if I was just having a bad day, but my argument on that show was pretty muddled and unclear, and I think I probably came across as a bit of a crackpot and maybe even a conspiracy theorist. So I thought I'd revisit the topic here and hopefully frame it a little bit better.

Oh, just to reassure people that you are a crackpot? That's always possible. The bigger discussion around that, which I hope I will be able to elucidate more clearly today, is the way that technology is being used as an agent of social change in our lives. How it's solving problems, but more importantly, who it's actually solving those problems for.

So where did the inspiration for this brain gas come from? Well, as usual, something I read online, I mean, we all live our lives online at the moment. So this is an article at Wired.com by writer called Matthew Galt. It's titled Billionaires CVR as a way to avoid radical social change.

So you can see there that the argument is probably quite simple and straightforward. You know, we live in a resource-limited world, but our wants are essentially unlimited. We all want to live somewhere nice. If we've got kids, we want to send them to the best schools.

We want to have exciting and fulfilling work and social lives. But that is potentially an unrealistic goal because there aren't enough resources in the world to meet all of those unlimited wants and needs. And this is where technology like VR steps in to provide an approximation of those desires. So it's really about that balance and asking whether Big Tech is focused more on creating virtual facsimiles of the things we want, rather than using its skills to advance equity and increase equality.

Isn't that point about limited resources a valid one? Yes, but these aren't insurmountable issues. That's where technology and social design can be a force for good. I don't know if I mentioned the 15-minute cities movement on the show before.

That's something we'll have to tackle in a future episode. But briefly, the idea is that city dwellers should be able to access all the essential services and amenities they need from supermarkets to pharmacies to health centers and swimming pools within a 15-minute walk of where they live. Now these are deliverable goals. Cities like Paris are aiming to create that within their environment.

But when we're talking about everyone living in their own swank mansion with every conceivable gadget, driving a cool ride, wearing designer threads, those are the ones that we can't realistically meet for everyone. And is this where virtual reality comes in to create those approximate worlds? We'll go back to that wild piece, the writer Galt quotes people like former Oculus CTO John Carmack talking about using the technology to skirt those resource allocation problems and bring economic value to people. So certainly the stage at which the technology is currently at, it's not there yet, but maybe in the future, this is something that we'll start to see.

As the technology gets better, VR experiences are looking less like Minecraft and more closely approximating real life. So that makes the possibility of living out your fantasy life much more of a reality. So letting your imagination run wild, giving you the clothes, the property, the lifestyle, it's this idea of lapping going digital again if that's not to matter a description. In every other words, like every VR based science fiction movie ever.

In a way, Ready Player One is a good example. It's people living in a poverty-stricken dystopia, they live in houses that are made of these precarious stacks of trailers, the cities look like wastelands, but they get to escape the poverty and environmental degradation, and they get to navigate a thousand worlds as soon as they get online. The difference is that real life is already starting to blur with the edges of that world, even more so since the pandemic started. Look at the range of artists from Travis Scott to Marshmallow, who've performed live shows in Fortnite.

Now this has happened at a time when most real live venues are closed, and these performances blend gameplay with avatars and live casts. They aren't a simple telecaster of a show, they're something completely new. Very much so. Weirdly, they actually allow the performance to interact more.

The technology is a barrier of one description, but you no longer have those issues of stage and audience which you have for the traditional life. So how you run the show and incorporate the people, the audience, into that performance becomes about your imagination instead of something to do with logistics and safety. So when we look at open worlds, you have all of these flexibilities. You can customize your avatar, you can build your own persona, many worlds have their own currencies, so you can hang out at clubs and bars and meet friends, you can go shopping.

None of this is actually new. It's been happening since the early 2000s with platforms like Second Life. Duran Duran of all people did a virtual gig on Second Life way back in 2006, and a lot of the back and alien scenes in the Bruce Willis movie surrogates looked remarkably like things that were happening at that time in Second Life. Then there is that potential for VR spaces to open and enrich our lives.

Well, of course, going back to that concert experience, when we go onto social platforms and forums, you start to see a fairly large group of people who've never been to a live concert in real life, or maybe they've been to one or two and they didn't really enjoy the experience. So they've only really experienced live music through a screen through telecasts, which if you're at a big stadium concert with seats towards the middle of the back, that's arguably what you're doing anyway, for a lot more money and a lot less comfortably. Many of these big stadium gigs, because the artist is so far away from where you're sitting, you have to watch them on the screens on the side of the stage. So I'm a fan of small gigs where you're up front and close to the artist, even when you stand at the back, which is where I usually am, but that limits you to a certain type and size of artist.

So from my perspective, I would rather watch a big act in Fortnite or on my computer, rather than paying these huge sums to sit on a plastic bucket seat somewhere up in the gods and spend most of the day queuing to get in, queuing to get to the toilet, going to buy food, and then queuing to leave. OK. Now, discounting your old man agoraphobia. Could we also see the benefits of VR in other aspects of our lives?

Sure, and that goes back to our online lives over the past 12 months. So depending on where in the world you live, you've done all your meetings in Zoom or something similar. You've been studying online. You may have had consultations with doctors online.

So banks, insurance, most of the service industries, it's all been digital. And for a lot of people, it's been a really frustrating experience. It's allowed some semblance of normal life to continue, but there has been a cost. You know, in previous shows, we've highlighted how much more tiring it is to interact with people digitally rather than in real life.

So virtual reality might help to improve that virtual experience, that digital experience, and give you more of a feeling that you're actually in a room with people, as well as providing more of the nonverbal and behavioral cues that we miss from those person-to-person interactions. But isn't the point to get back to that normality rather than to seek an alternative to it in VR? Sure, last year we talked a lot about 2020 being a giant experiment, an experiment in new business methodologies and experiment in distributed working. The same goes for education, e-commerce and delivery services, coming full force to even the smallest retailers.

And we've learned that we don't all have to be in the same office to work. In fact, BFM has worked as a station over the last year with half of the staff being out of the office any one time. So we don't have to be in the same lecture theatre or classroom to learn. So that aspect of the movie Ready Player One, where people learn and work and, to an extent, socialise online, VR could make those experiences much more enriching and satisfying for us in our nonfiction lives.

But that still leaves us with that issue of hardware though? Yes, your previous version, Jeff Sandu, was a big VR fan, and I've always been a skeptic. I do apologise for the noise of my catch of art. It's going to be impossible to keep him off this recording.

So decent virtual reality rigs are expensive. The headsets can cost as much as a thousand US dollars, and then you need a powerful gaming PC setup to get the most out of them. Because the environments require a lot of processing grunt, and they do eat through data. And as Matthew Galt points out in his wide piece, they don't necessarily operate optimally out of the box.

They're going to need a bit of tinkering with, which is probably a drawback if you're the kind of person who can't switch a kitten filter off your zoom feed. And as much as these technologies are supposed to be an escape, they actually require a lot more empty vacant space to make the most of them than a lot of people have access to, like most VR rigs require about, I think, about two or three metres squared, because of the physical movement required. Not to mention the fact that you're wearing a blind box that puts your meat suit at risk in the physical world. But that's more of an earlier doctor argument, isn't it?

Yeah, I mean for sure, virtual reality has a growing following. So VR game titles like Half-Life Alex, which was released in March last year, that's sold around two million copies, which is, you know, a pretty good figure. Cyberpunk 2077, which we've talked about for all of its flaws, has sold in excess of 13 million copies to date. So VR is growing, but it's not the most popular way to experience open world platforms, at least not yet.

So the accessibility of the technology is still a major limiting factor. And, you know, as I said on the a bit of culture episode, I don't think virtual reality will really catch on until we can free ourselves from those headsets. You're determined to have a hollow deck, aren't you? I am, but also on a practical level, you know, to really give people the experience of living in a mansion or having a coffee in Central Perk.

I think we're going to need something that is immersive and a lot less intrusive. So how long it's going to take to get to that point from a technology standpoint is anyone's guess at the moment. But I think we have to be able to blend the real world and the virtual much more successfully to make it a realistic and mainstream proposal, certainly than the kind of augmented reality hybrids that we have today. And a lot of those, you know, they really just amount to holding an iPad up to your face and looking at overlays of the real world.

So the technology is not necessarily that helpful. So whether that emerging tech comes from holiday type screens or pass through glasses and contact lenses still remains to be seen. But also for the kind of control options that we've been talking about after the break, I think the technology will definitely have to advance. All right, disrupting change.

We'll be coming back here on Matt's Blaine on BFM 89.9, the Business Station. Fourth, Malaysia, BFM 89.9, the Business Station. Welcome back. This is BFM 89.9, the Business Station.

I'm Rich Bradbury, you are listening to Matt's Blaine. And of course this week, Matt's Blaine is all about the people. Yes, you heard right. Our own audio tyrant wants to protect you from cartoon villain billionaires.

Listening to that first half, it sounds as though you think VR on the whole is a good idea, Matt. It goes back to that thing that people used to say and that everyone is now kind of wised up to, which is that technology is neutral. It isn't. Many things can affect the impact that technology has on the lives, how widely available it is, for example, how affordable, how easy it is to use, and of course how impactful we find it.

You know, you can go on listing and listing things that affect the neutrality of technology for hours. So something that has had a major impact is how that technology is owned and controlled. And that's one of the reasons we find ourselves in this weird position of loving and hating social media platforms at the same time. You know, we love that they connect and entertain us and they provide a creative outlet for many of us, but we hate them because of the way their algorithms control the information we see and the way they monetize our lives.

You know, this nagging feeling that we're being manipulated and exploited. And of course, this flood of class action lawsuits from nation states around the world attempting to limit the power of companies that have turned into a gendered defining monopolies. But how does that link collector VR? As you mentioned, it's still very much a niche environment.

Well, one of the reasons we find ourselves in this current relationship with tech companies is because we didn't think through the long-term implications of where their growth would take them. Not many people in the year 2000 would have thought that struggling online bookseller Amazon would be in a position to act as a gatekeeper to everything from groceries to clothing to healthcare. We didn't realize what dominating the market for search meant, essentially that algorithms we don't have access to get to select what information is prioritized in the searches we make, or that a tool for connecting college students would end up with billions of users and become their primary source of news and other information. So we didn't understand how powerful these intermediaries would become in controlling the flow of information.

Governments and regulators and commentators also didn't think through the implications of the freemium model that a lot of these businesses based their revenue generation on. Including you? Absolutely. I mean, I thought that freemium could empower us all.

The idea that air travel might one day become free if we paid for it with advertising. That was an exciting one. You know, selling advertising and data to provide all of these services free looked like being a way to turbocharge digital adoption and the creation of digital economies. And it also promised to be transformative in developing countries where incomes were lower than the developed world, but rising fast and big companies were evaluating their potential as future markets.

Now, that might not have turned out to be the case, but you can argue that it was the right choice at the time. What few of us realized is how good those companies would get at making money from the way they target us and use those free services and monetize those free services. And also the kind of political as well of economic power that they would develop and wield. You're referring to the standoff between Facebook Australia this year?

Yeah, despite all the coverage it received, you know, if it hadn't been overshadowed by COVID and political events in the US, I think everyone would have made a much bigger deal out of that. Yeah. Facebook faced off against one of the world's top 15 economies, and it was the country that blinked. You know, both sides claimed victory, but I think Facebook emerged slightly ahead.

So whether that will be the case with similar legal challenges to the way the company uses content and does business in other countries, well, you know, obviously that's still to be decided, but a precedent has been set. So there's a fascinating piece on new scientists titled Self-Explanitarily, How to Spend a Trillion Dollars to Fix Climate Change and End Poverty. Now, a trillion dollars is a lot of money, but it's less than the US stimulus bill that was passed this week. It's less than half the value of Apple and rather less than the values of companies like Microsoft, Amazon, and Google's parent, Alphabet.

So as much as those companies are integral to my life, I'd trade any one of them to fix those problems. And I'm pretty sure I'm not alone in having that view. Yeah. And that's why you think we should be focusing on VR now because of what it could be.

Partly, as I said earlier, I think VR has enormous potential. So opening access to the world's top universities, for example, with virtual campuses, we lose the potential of so much talent because of imbalances in, you know, basic services like education, that trope about Einstein being a mediocre student may be overstated, but he certainly underperformed in some of his university entrance exams. So what would it have taken for the world to have been deprived of the genius of Einstein? And when you look at that, how many other people have fallen through the cracks?

So distance learning is already making the world's top schools more accessible, not just in terms of degree courses, but the kind of more flexible and fluid learning that platforms like Coursera offer, where you can take short courses, which are often free from those big name institutions. So virtual reality could make that experience much more valuable and build on the first steps that those institutions have made. And it's a similar story with medicine, virtual reality enabling specialists to see patients in a dozen countries in a single day. But you're worried about access and power?

Again, partly, you know, we'll do an episode on the right to repair soon as well. I'm stacking up so many topics to tackle right now. Can we go to a daily show? No, there's that issue of ownership.

We already see it with the devices we own. We own the hardware, but not the software that runs it. And without the software, those devices are essentially useless. Increasingly, that also includes cars as well as agricultural and commercial machinery, especially the newly emerging electric vehicles.

We can only service and repair those devices or vehicles or authorized dealers. And those dealers and manufacturers can avoid warranties if we tingle with themselves. So virtual reality has the potential to replicate those same models. You can have a virtual mansion, but you can't own it.

And we aren't just talking about a single house. We're talking about entire virtual worlds. So those companies are setting themselves up essentially as private governments. They control the laws, the property rights, the public behavior, and they have the power to sanction you or delete your possessions within that virtual world.

But in a way, this is actually the easy fix because it's something that governments can control if there's enough public will there to do it. So you're arguing about VR is actually a real world one? Well, essentially. So go back to what I mentioned about 15 minute cities.

That movement is looking to create livable cities. But the extreme outcome of virtual reality would be to create livable virtual cities instead. And that could be an enticing option for a lot of lawmakers, because improving the living conditions and welfare of billions of people around the world is a complicated and expensive task. VR offers you an escape route.

Instead of giving citizens about a house or flat in the real world, you give them a virtual mansion. Instead of fixing public transport, you give them a virtual economy. Instead of stabilizing the climate, we go online and choose whatever weather pattern best suits our mood. So when you say this is about disrupting change, it's about control.

Well, yeah, we've seen over the last few years, especially that societies have become a lot more activist in nature. So people are pushing back against lawmakers and corporations. They want action on equality. They want action on climate change.

They're demanding better jobs, better wages, better living conditions, better cities to live in. And we're seeing that trickle down effect, not happening in the way that it's been promised. So tax cuts are going to be irrelevant to you if you're working three jobs and you're still subsisting at the poverty line. So these are things that are pitting us directly as individuals against the desires of big tech.

Look at the drive to unionized Amazon warehouses in Alabama in the US, for example, or the disproportionate effect that the coronavirus has had on low paid essential workers who've had to go to work and risk their lives in workplaces over the last 12 months. And you see those tech based solutions as a bit of a fudge? Well, it goes back to that original argument about limited resources, but it neatly sidesteps the issue of redistributing those resources and the power that goes with them. So in a way, it's a bit like rich and powerful people saying that we know that life is unfair.

And rather than using some of the wealth they've accumulated to undo those injustices and inequalities, they offer us a virtual facsimile of their own lifestyle. So VR here is simply an example. It's an emerging industry and I'm conjecturing about the path that it could take. Whereas with the big tech companies, that power is already on display.

The influence is being wielded. That was what we saw in Australia with Facebook. It was on display to a different extent, admittedly, in Canada when Alphabet's Sidewalk Labs walked away from a smart city project in Toronto that had raised a lot of data privacy concerns. And I have to be clear, not everyone is going to agree with my vision.

A lot of people may be fine living in a coffee department and spending their time in a virtual mansion. You know, the matrix may be somewhere that you choose or prefer to live. But those are choices that we should make. They shouldn't be made for us.

You know, if you take the example of the matrix, that world has already been destroyed. How has concealed been changed and improved? And as customers and users and consumers, we forget that we can be disruptive too. But this is the kind of disruption that big tech is far less keen on.

Thank you very much, Matt. And of course, you can find Matt on Instagram and Twitter at culture. You can also head over to culturepop.com for transcripts of the shows and information about culturepop and its consulting services. And if you did miss any part of the show, don't forget you can head over to the Google Play Store or the Apple App Store to download the BFM app and stream the podcast by whatever you'd like to listen to BFM 89.9, the Business Station.

Thank you for listening to this podcast. To find more great interviews, go to bfm.my or find us on iTunes, BFM 89.9, the Business Station.

The MSP Show The Digital Nomad Podcast Where can you turn to speak with the movers and shakers in the IT industry? The MSP Marketing Show is your source for up-to-date business info. MSP Unplugged Paco Lebron MSP Unplugged is the weekly podcast for growing MSP owners running shops under $1M with 10 or fewer techs. Each week, our hosts sit down with MSP owners, operators, and the vendors who serve them for real, unfiltered conversations about what's actually working: growing revenue and landing better clients, cybersecurity, AI and automation, sales and marketing, and leading a team without burning out. Watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get podcasts. Business of Tech: Daily MSP News & IT Services Analysis MSP Radio, Dave Sobel, Managed Service Provider (MSP) Industry Analyst Vendors are rewriting the rules on MSPs faster than anyone can track — pricing, partner programs, liability, and now AI. Business of Tech is the daily MSP news briefing that tells you what changed and what it means for your business.Every weekday, channel veteran Dave Sobel picks the MSP and IT services news that actually moves your margins, contracts, and risk, and answers the one question that matters: Why do we care? No vendor cheerleading and no press-release rewrites — independent analysis for managed service providers, IT services leaders, and the vendors who sell to them.Short daily episodes keep you current in about 15 minutes. Longer interviews go deep with MSP owners, investors, analysts, and channel executives on where the managed services market is heading.What this MSP podcast covers:• AI for MSPs — AI pricing and consumption billing, AI liability and governance, and AI agents in the service desk• MSP pricing and profitability — per-user vs. usage-based pricing, margi SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners Dave Sobel, Amy Babinchak, Small Biz Thoughts, James Kernan Running a small MSP means being the CEO, the sales team, the HR department, and the escalation tech — usually in the same afternoon. The SMB Community Podcast is where MSP owners get straight answers on the business side of running an MSP.Every week, Amy Babinchak, and James Kernan — MSP owners and advisors from the Small Biz Thoughts community — take on the questions small MSP owners actually ask: How should I price? When do I hire? Should I give a proposal at the first meeting? What is my MSP worth? No vendor pitches and no theory — practical advice from people who have run, grown, and sold IT businesses.What this MSP podcast covers:• MSP sales and client growth — the MSP sales process, proposals, price objections, referrals, local marketing, and choosing a CRM• MSP pricing and agreements — MSP pricing models, single plan vs. tiers, price increases, managed service contracts, margins, and cash flow• Leading an MSP team — MSP hiring, tech compensation and commissions, accountabil

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx?

This episode is 27 minutes long.

When was this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode published?

This episode was published on March 16, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.