Skip to content
American Democracy Interrupted episode artwork

Oct 1, 2020 41 min

American Democracy Interrupted

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we take a close look at the first Presidential debate and ask is it possible for Joe Biden and the media to cut through with a disruptive figure like Trump. Monica Attard spoke with New York Times' Damien Cave and SMH and the Age's Nick O'Malley.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

American Democracy Interrupted

0:00 41:44
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the Gadigal Lands of the Aura Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Monica Atard. This week we keep our focus on the United States.

You may remember that last week we spoke to the New York Times has been Smith about a shell shock country dealing with the passing of an unwanted milestone of 200,000 people dead from COVID-19 and a president running roughshod over the news media. This week as the US presidential election heats up we discussed the fallout from the first presidential debate. We asked has the election taken a decisive turning point and is the Trump show coming to an end or is it just revving up and are we seeing on our screens the last throes of American democracy. Joining us today is Damien Cave, the Bureau Chief Australia for the New York Times and Nick O'Malley who is the national environment and climate editor for the City Morning Herald and the Age but also a former US correspondent and an expert on American politics.

Damien Cave and Nick O'Malley welcome back to Fourth Estate. Let's start our discussion with the debate. There had of course been a lot of anticipation around this first debate as it was to be the first time actually the Donald Trump and Joe Biden would clash in person. Before the debate lots of speculation about what Trump wouldn't do would Biden without one of his guests.

So what we've seen no guests but Trump dominated the entire debate showing is always total indifference to any form of conventional order. According to Slate Trump interrupted Biden all the moderator 128 times in 90 minutes which is quite extraordinary. In 2016 he interrupted Hillary Clinton just 51 times. So Damien can I start with you.

Has Trump refined the art of being Donald Trump in the years he's been in the Oval Office? Was this a very deliberate show by him to highlight the contrast in personality? That's a good question. I mean the people who I know who cover Donald Trump very closely would say that you're assuming there's a strategy when there may in fact not be.

After four years in the White House spending a lot of time with people who agree with him if anything he's just become a bigger Donald Trump than he was four years ago. A bigger version of himself, a more exaggerated version of himself. And so watching him I didn't feel as though this was a strategic thing so much as what he went in there when everyone told him to be which is himself which is to be as domineering as possible. That's how he is in news conferences and that's sort of what it reminded me of.

Times 10. So I don't know that there was a strategy so much as a just impulsiveness that has come to define his presidency. Nick is that the way you see it as well? Do you think that he's just an emboldened Donald Trump or a bigger version of himself?

I had the same thing. To me I learned nothing about Donald Trump. He did look and sound the way he did at news conferences when anyone dares to challenge him which he clearly after a few years surrounded by yes men considered to be a greater insult than he did at the outset. If there was a difference in Donald Trump you couldn't see it over the past by comparing this performance to his public utterances over the past few months.

But it did seem to me that for whatever reason he was more engaged in the old-fashioned sense of debate in a large series of debates he did with Hillary Clinton. Not much more but this was him. He didn't want to watch him. Look for a memory.

I haven't gone back and re-watched them but I watched some clips. He did have to engage in two and froze in that series of debates. And as he clearly didn't see the meets so in an almost petulant fashion he simply insisted on interrupting and countering incoherently anything that was said not just by Biden but by the moderator. Poor old Chris Wallace.

Now people keep on, some people are analyzing that as a victory for it. I think it's impossible to judge this debate on those old-fashioned terms of win and loss. If anything Biden, if he struggled to do that one by not losing it. But I think what stood out to me was just what America is now facing with a leader in the White House who is refusing to commit to a peaceful transition of power and refusing to condemn white supremacy.

That was my main takeaway. And it was about depressing. Yeah sure. It was depressing.

But we'll come to that. But if debates with Trump are just crazy and weird, these circuses, the circus that we saw yesterday, was the real aim for Biden just to get through this with no major gas be the adult in the room, the same sober quietly speaking voice. And if so, do you think that the American public, particularly that portion of the American public, is inclined to vote for the Democratic party, saw it in the same way? Damien?

No, I think it put Joe Biden in a really difficult position because if he was just trying to be the voice of decency and reason then it basically ends up looking to many weakness. And so I actually think he went in there knowing that he was going to have to punch back a bit. And I think that was a strategy that he deployed. So you have him using lines like, I mean, shut up man or calling him a clown.

I don't know that those were rehearsed lines. They didn't seem like it. But he definitely went in there knowing that he was going to have to punch back as opposed to just being decent. I think it was clear that he needed to be more than decent.

He needed to be, at least as combative enough to stand as an equal to Trump. And I think he did as well as he could. What I found striking too was the way he would sort of smirk and laugh. And this like, can you believe this guy met Manner?

Which in some ways was an effort to, I mean, other people have said this. It's like a schoolyard set of bullies or set of kids. I mean, it's so juvenile. But it seems to be an effort to say like, I'm not going to take this guy seriously and neither should you.

An effort to kind of bring himself up to Trump's level to bring Trump down to his level. Everyone described it. But it was clear that he was deploying a whole bunch of different tactics to say, listen, your exertion of pure raw power is not going to work in the same way that it might with others. I'm going to do my best to at least deploy some counter strategies.

And do you think that will work on that portion of the electorate that would be dis-otherwise, dis-inclined to vote Democrat? It's so hard to know. I mean, there was an interesting kind of group of undecided voters that frank lines with this Republican bolster pulled together afterwards. And a couple of quotes from there, these were undecided voters, maybe leaning Republican, including some of the couple people that previously voted for Trump.

And someone was asked, oh, what did you think of Biden being called, Biden calling him a clown? Was that a fence? We said, well, if the shoe fits, if the clown shoe fits. And so I do think that there is an acknowledgement that you're not dealing with a normal presidential candidate.

And so some of the same norms of how you respect the presidency aren't going to apply. The trickier thing, I think, is how many people are actually going to have seen the debate. The ratings were really low. You're going to have people who heard about the debate.

And they're just going to say, oh, this is just, it was just must have just been Trump being Trump. They're not going to recognize that it was even more severe than it has been in the past. They're just going to think, oh, yeah, but Joe was sleepy. I saw somewhere that he was slow to respond.

And so I'm not sure that it really will have as much power outside the circle of news junkies as we have. And so what do you think accounts for that decline though, right? Because it was quite significant, not 13 million people. I think a few of the people watched the debate, this debate then did the Clinton Trump debate.

Is that because they're saying, look, we know what Trump is. We know that he's a clown. He's a performer. And Biden's sleepy, Joe.

And he's a boring kind of candidate. So what's the point? Is that what it's about? I think Americans are so exhausted and fatigued from this.

It makes me think of everyone I covered the war in Iraq. And there was a point where I was talking to a few people about how when there are wars, one of the reasons, one of the things that end wars is just pure exhaustion. At the end of like four or five years, a lot of wars just come to an end because people are just too tired of fighting. And to some degree, I wonder if this election and the coming years are going to be defined by people actually a large mass of people being so sick of politics and wanting to have nothing to do with it that they actually disengage.

And so I think that's what explains the ratings. I think that's going to be something that Americans didn't have to deal with is a way to find a way to interact and so the society back together that in a way that's not through politics. But right now, I just think that it's a case of just exhaustion, frustration and disgust on all sides. And Nick, what do you think?

Do you think Biden did enough? Yes, sir. Yeah, Biden did what he needed to do. I agree that with those lines were rehearsed or non-isrespect somewhere.

That's what he needed to do. He needed to push back because this now, this fight with Trump is a macho game. And a lot of his character is macho posturing and a lot of his support adores that. And sadly, anyone who goes up against him has to demonstrate that they're weakened or intimidated by him, which detracts even further from what passes for debate at the top of politics in America.

I don't believe anyone learned anything from that. I noticed James Fallows wrote afterwards the Atlantic's commentator and I think a member of the while the other Australian things, he said he's not going to watch the debate because there's no point. And I thought that's quite a reasonable response. You're not going to get anything from this.

And if you do, it's going to be a gotcha. It's going to be Biden losing his call or Biden getting a name wrong. And in the end, well, that's meaningless. Nothing means anything in this debate.

And I watched also that that group of undecided voters that Frank once had choreographed people together because once it's really interesting, Republican polls that he always draws interesting people together, that my first thought watching that was how the hell do you find people in that country who are now undecided? Totally. And if they were, well, then do we really need to hear from them? Because if you're undecided in the United States of America at the moment, then you're not a particularly engaged citizen, I would have thought this is not to demean them.

It's just that America is not only polarized, it's polarized between a party that has become welded to this man which is not reflective of its history, and another party which is struggling to respond to that. But it's all about Trump. So another point that is interesting in this debate was the role of the moderator, Chris Waller. Talk about an enviable job.

He had times and looked like he'd lost control of the debate. I would have thought that actually he didn't really lose control of the debate, that it's impossible to control Trump in his current mind state. How do you guys rate his performance, Damian? I actually thought he did a decent job.

I thought when he stopped halfway through and tried to make that appeal, I thought that was a pretty savvy move in a debate where there are no breaks and there's no one saying, hey, this is getting out of control. And we had an interview with him today where he acknowledged I had no idea it was going to go down this path and I wish I had done more sooner. So he was pretty thoughtful and contemplative about it. I thought some of the questions that he asked Trump were actually really sharp and I think were surprising for those who think that Fox News is only panity.

Question about white supremacy, which was really telling, is not something that Trump clearly expected. And so I actually think overall he did his good job as he could have in the first debate of what was wildly non-normative to say the least. Yeah. And now the presidential debate commission is considering changing the rules for the third debate.

The second debate, I think, is a town hall number where the audience gets to ask the questions. But in the third debate, it's back to the format of yesterday. If they do change the rules, muting Trump, I think is one of the possibilities and the other is penalising him in the open discussion timing so that he gets less time on the next question. Will that even work?

That doesn't sound to me like it could even work. Nick, what do you think? Well, I can't see why it would work. I mean, the only thing that will work is Donald Trump choosing to curb his behaviour.

I think the fact that the next debate is a town hall means that the entire show will be different. It'll be more difficult for him to shout down actual voters rather than someone in the media he's spent four years castigating the media, even though Chris Wallace is from a friendly news organisation. And I agree, I think Chris Wallace is one of the best political interviewers of America, people interviewers, and he did as good as Trump as he could. In the long run, I mean, should you be muting a president?

I don't know. I guess it depends on the president, right? Sorry, but do voters learn something when a president speaks over their interviews? It just struck me as we were talking though, we've got to remember, was it the second debate last time around that Trump tried to derail before it even again by bringing along people who had accused Bill Clinton of sexual assault or impropriety?

We've got to remember that this guy will do anything he can to attract attention to himself. Yeah, exactly. I mean, it's about spectacle to some degree. And so, you know, the challenge with Trump is if you mute him or if you punish him with time, it just feeds into his sense of grievance, which is what he runs on anyways, and what fuels his campaign.

So, you know, it's a really, and then even if you mute him, you know, Joe Biden can still hear him and he's going to be distracted, but then you're not going to have heard what Trump said and what you're going to hear would be in response to. It just, it doesn't, I don't know, it's really tricky. I mean, I was wondering if part of this in his effort to create a spectacle is not an effort to kind of blow up the rest of the debates. Like, I'm not sure Trump really likes debates, where he has to be questioned in such a difficult manner, or he's not in control.

And so, I wouldn't be surprised if you see in the coming weeks that Trump campaign is saying, you know what, we don't want to do this. We're going to just talk to the American people at our rallies and we're not going to subject ourselves to this. So, we'll see. Well, which brings me from my next point, because it has to been said before that only media elites worry about the debates, and in reality, the debates don't really mean much in terms of US presidential elections.

I mean, is that true? It's hard to tell. I mean, you know, there's sort of, I think that views kind of change over time, and there's sort of like a long tail for debates in the sense that, you know, like, even, I was reading a piece about how even some of the things that Trump said last time there was this assumption that it didn't have any impact. Then if you look sort of over time, there is sort of a slow accretion of shifting opinions.

We'll see what the polling says after this one. I do think that I wouldn't say that they have no influence, nor do I think that they are as influential as you might surmise looking at the headlines on any major news or organization, including ours. So, I don't think a lot of people, you know, like I said, they'll read snippets and hear snippets of the debate, and it will shape their views a little bit, but I don't know that there's going to be a whole lot of minds changed. Right.

And, you know, what do you think that Trump was just talking exclusively to his base? Well, I agree that he didn't really have a strategy. He operates on gut instinct rather than strategy, and he's gut instinct is on the show. It was interesting that he's on his own campsite before the debate that he wasn't spending a lot of time directly on preparation.

Instead, he was seeking to leverage his experience, which means he'd done no preparation and his mind has couldn't grow out and into doing preparation. Instead, he was going to do what he always does, which is what he did. What I found interesting looking at media in the hours afterwards, you know, there's some interesting, very interesting analysis across the U.S. media.

But if you look at what was trending on Facebook, of the top 10 most shared political elements that I saw, I think eight out of 10 of them were die-hard Trump-based organizations or individuals. And if you look at the memes that were being shared on Twitter, it was all, you know, I saw one person or one particular meme being shared in awful luck, which was Trump looking like a tough guy and it was, you know, that's, and the slogan on it was, that's my badass president. So I don't think it matters to his base, or if anything, I think they probably enjoyed the spectacle. And then we go back to, you know, how many normally, you know, at the end of a race, there's three or five percent of persuadable.

So I can't imagine that there's even that thing on this occasion. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Look, let's talk briefly then about the, the New York Times scoop on Trump's tax returns. Do you think the revelation that Trump winning the ultra successful, you know, billionaire, but he's in reality, largely Washington, I'm dodging millionaire enough to move the needle in this election, Damien?

I mean, it's obviously an amazing feat of reporting, a question that people have been asking for a very long time. I don't know that it tells anyone, you know, anything completely new, the idea that Trump is either a Wheeler dealer, if you like him, or a condon and a cheat, if you don't, is kind of already out there. But the things that I thought were interesting and potentially damaging over time is that he does have a lot of this debt that he's dealing with and that there's there just hints of just outright corruption that he's benefiting, you know, from his position that he's funneling money to his kids that, you know, shouldn't be funneled to his kids. You know, that stuff is a little bit newer, I think, in terms of having numbers and some clear definition.

So over time, I do wonder if that's going to have more of an impact than anything. Do you think that corrupt aspect as opposed to the, he only pays, you know, $750 a year in taxation? You think that will cut through more? I kind of, I don't know, I don't know, cut through more, but I mean, I think, you know, when looking at the conversation afterwards, like 750 was a number that just seems to stick in people's minds quite a bit.

It was extraordinary. Yeah. And so I think that that actually will have influence, at least in some people's minds and degree of frustration. I mean, the irony of someone who is running a government that he hasn't contributed to besides a few hundred dollars or less that he probably spends on a couple of haircuts is pretty stunning.

And I do think it's the kind of thing that a lot of Americans, especially in, you know, a suburb where there's mixed views and, you know, it's not nearly as kind of white and conservative as Trump thinks it is, I think people who are hard working and trying to put their, you know, kids through school are going to think about that. Yeah. I think what do you think? Do you think it'll cut through?

I don't know that it'll cut through in the political race. And I don't know. I don't think that's its purpose either. Its purpose as pure journalism is incredible.

As you just said, it was a feat and it was beautifully told. It was beautifully displayed as well for journalism nerds. Another thing that stood out to me was that apart from 750 in taxes, he blew $70,000 on haircuts, which he then had the cheek to go and claim. What I think it does is it tells us more- Not just mention Bing Riftov.

Exactly. But it tells us a lot about who that man is and about his behaviour over 15 years. And that is an incredibly valuable contribution. I don't think, and I suppose I'm sounding a bit boring and I'm just repeating myself.

I don't think it changes rights at this stage. I don't because it doesn't tell much about him about his character anyway. It just feels in me the broader portrait of who this man is, which he's an important thing for us all to know in a long time. Even when you pick that figure up of what he's paid in tax against what Biden paid in 2019, which was $300,000, okay.

Well, then I think his supporters would say, well, Trump's a genius for not getting caught up paying tax. Well, again, and I think they would say, God, the American tax system is what a disaster. I have a friend who shared something online that was like, this is the American tax system and it was a Lamborghini driving under a gate from a mall. That basically, if you're rich, you get away with all kinds of stuff.

And that's, I think, what will have Americans take away from this is that the system is broken, which they already do. Right. Okay. Let's talk policy then.

I've put the crazy to one side. There seems to be a clear choice in policy terms for American voters. The Democrats' programme is by conventional standards, at least. It appears progressive, ambitious, detailed.

The Republicans, on the other hand, strangely offered no coherent plan, nothing except presumably more of the same for the next four years. Does the American media, Damien, do you think even have time, not to mention the energy to examine policy in the way it should, when they basically flat out covering the next outrageous thing that Trump says or does? I guess I think that it's not a question sort of is there time. I kind of feel like the policy differences are already so clear and so well known.

And the alternatives are so sharp that there's, I would much rather have the coverage we're focusing where I think it is focusing now on the threats to democracy and whether or not the system can withstand an assault from a president who doesn't believe that the democratic system is worth respecting if he loses it. So the policy of how American democracy functions is taken on much greater significance. It's been broken for a very long time, I would argue. But that to me is a better place to be focusing attention than whether or not, to me, whether or not the Green New Deal is 30% more radical than Biden's plan or etc.

I think that Democrats are getting away with the fact that they're not getting a whole lot of scrutiny on their policy. And so to that point, I think you're right that there should be more just explaining and laying it out for people. But I just don't know that anyone is really thinking so sharply about policy in this moment. And I'm actually not so sure that they need to be, frankly, they need to figure out a way to make sure that the system functions and their votes are counted.

So Nick, do you think that would you agree with that that there are many issues that require more scrutiny from American news media than the new side of policy data? Well, at the moment you have a president who's saying he might not respect the outcome of an election in 30 days. So going into policy differences does seem a little bit off-base. The other thing is that the, you could say, you could easily mount the argument that democratic policies are radical.

They're more progressive than they have been in the past. But by comparison to what the GOP is offering America and the world, so what? And also in the long run, given the general shift to the right for over a generation, they're not that radically in the border context. They are perhaps more progressive than Hillary Clinton's who's perhaps more progressive in some areas than Barack Obama's.

I mean, do you think that American journalism has found it more challenging to cover Trump than they anticipated that he's confounded journalism more than it could have been anticipated? I do think that's the case. I mean, even you think of Chris Wallace in the debate, like even when you think you've become acclimated to the way that he breaks through norms, you have to revisit that once again. Every interaction is potentially completely new and toxic and different than it was before.

So I do think that he's had a really hard time figuring out how to deal with him. And whether it's headlines or coverage, I do think that he's got a lot better out of overtime. And I think there's evidence that readers feel the same way. But it is a process.

And we'll see, I mean, the big challenge, and I know that at the New York Times and elsewhere, they're having lots of conversations about this, is what do you do on election day and afterwards when those norms of okay, calling who won or lost are also completely destroyed. And when you're dealing with all kinds of allegations and accusations at very local levels that are very difficult to determine what's room or what's fact, like it's going to get really messy after November 3rd. And so that's we'll see how well the media does in that in that mail stream. In this election also, there is potentially a lot more it's like I think than most voters might be willing to accept.

I mean, in conventional terms, at least if Trump wins by a whisker in November, he is a deeply unpopular president. He's seeing out another four years. But marches and protests decide if they occur could also be a really dangerous moment for American democracy. But it's essentially when you can say that it essentially gave up on itself.

Don't mean do we have anything to really worry about in relation to American democracy? Or is American democracy, do you think, at the end of the day, robust enough to withstand another four years of Donald Trump? Good question. I mean, American democracy is more robust than has dealt with more extremes than a lot of people remember.

You know, it's a country that was forged in revolution, there's dealt with civil war, there's dealt with civil rights, there's dealt with Vietnam protests, water, I mean, it's a country of extremes in every way. And the system miraculously does seem to bend more than it breaks. And so, you know, it's hard for me to imagine a scenario where, I mean, Trump is not a young man, at some point he will be gone. And at some point the United States will continue.

Will it continue in anything like what it was five or 10 or 15 years ago? Maybe not. But I do think that the system has remarkable resilience. And in fact, it's also quite possible that 10 or 20 years from now, you're going to look back and say this was the moment when American democracy realized it needed to change and reform itself, the really deep structural level.

And so, you know, we'll see what happens. I think the country is bigger and more dynamic. I often have to remind people don't forget America is not just politics. It's also beyond say, it's also a whole bunch of other things that, you know, are very powerful in their own right.

So you're hopeful? I am hopeful over the long term. I'm extremely concerned in this in the short to middle term, to be honest. I'm really worried that that this challenging of election legitimacy is going to have really deep consequences for a long time.

I was talking to somebody who studies power. And she was saying, you know, that once you start just using raw power, and that's the only means that is respected or dealt with, and that's what Donald Trump represents, then it just continues. It's a cycle that's really, really difficult to get out of. I mean, regardless of the liberal order is taking a shellaking, I mean, they're not just an American, they're number of democracies around the globe, it's shrinking.

And this week, yesterday, we have a president of the United States, more or less, winking at neo-fascist on national television. No president before Trump would have been seen within a thousand miles when it happened, like the Proud Boys. And, you know, today people just shrunk their shoulders when Trump, you know, not just fails to call them out, but offers words of encouragement. Nick, what the hell has happened to the liberal order?

And how do we end up here? I think it's been a generational shift. I don't think that Trump is the cause of this. I know other people said it's the symptom, but you know, I look back at New Gingrich coming into Congress, however many years ago, a generation ago, and then achieving power and instructing young Congress people to treat their opposition, their opponents as animals, and to describe that he put out sheets saying these the words you should describe Democrats, they should be described as inhuman or subhuman.

And I think it's been exacerbated year in, year out by that by both sides of politics, but in mind, you're mainly by one side and more by Republicans. And it's had a very dramatic effect on American civil life, but also its practical life when I was in the United States reporting. I remember for the first time surveys coming out showing up life expectancy, you know, you see that basic institutions are withering because they're not getting enough, not just funding, and they weren't getting that, but they weren't getting enough respect and support from the political system. On the other hand, I think this will continue if Trump loses in vast numbers in a few days, in a couple of weeks, I think that still there is going to be a very significant part of American politics, which is now emboldened and enlivened by his rhetoric of behavior, and it will take a long time for that to see if it does.

On the other hand, I do think that there are very strong institutions, which will act in concert to defend the order such as it is. I don't think, for example, that no matter how great the conservative majority is on the Supreme Court, that it will simply kout-out to a Republican movement demanding that it gives him an election. The Supreme Court, no matter who's on it, will defend the court and defend the order of the United States. So there are still strong institutions.

I think media will have to act in concert with them to defend those bits of it that are still resilient. So that brings us actually to the next point that I wanted to raise, and that is that Trump has been threatening to not accept the election results, if it's not a clear victory to him, perhaps not explicitly saying that, but alluding to it. This obviously is setting off alarm bills, but he's a professional troll. Is the talk of not accepting the result just more Trump blustered, Damien, that will quickly fade, or is it way more sinister this time?

I don't know. I'm not sure what his bluster fades so much. He usually does try to follow through on whatever it is that he's said and continuing. So I think you have to take it quite seriously, and we already have evidence that what he's been saying and doing is disenfranchising people as we speak.

It's also inviting interference from Russia and others to create the perception of greater chaos, to delegitimize it even further. So I think you have to take this one pretty seriously. I do think, though, like I said, that there are institutions that have shown the power to withstand the Trump assault. I think it's pretty interesting that the IRS still hasn't figured out how to negotiate his tax payments that he still owes, and they haven't bent his will.

You do still have the FBI and the CDC saying things that are out of line with what Trump wants them to say. The Supreme Court, Chief Justice Roberts, knows that his reputation is on the line, and he will do what he needs to do to protect himself and nothing else. So while these threats, I think are very important and very serious, I do think they could also create a surge of people that make it a landslide in which Trump loses and then suddenly the whole conversation changes. So I don't know.

I think you have to take it seriously, but I don't necessarily think it's destiny. Right. Nick, what do you think? How worried should we be about these threats from Trump?

The threats to the action. Sorry, it's serious. It's already serious. He's already so in chaos.

For the president from his pulpit, he's saying he might not accept the results of an election. That is the action. That's not just a threat. That is the act of instilling chaos and fear in a political system.

So that should be taken very seriously. But that is not to say that he'll necessarily get away with this. Obviously, and again, I'm not the first to say this, but obviously, the most difficult period that America faces is in the days after a close election or contested election. And that could pan out very miserably.

But yeah, it ain't over. And, Danny, how much faith would you trust in the Supreme Court, particularly if Trump's nomination gets up in the next couple of weeks, to resolve a very, very close race? I mean, they'll resolve it according to the law. They're not going to pick a winner.

It got tricky in 2000. Obviously, we've seen some Supreme Court play roles in elections before. But there's so many different possible scenarios. I mean, if there's one state that defines it or is the election going to be decided on some narrow law within some really small jurisdiction in Ohio, or is it going to be multiple jurisdictions and different laws?

I mean, there's also a provision that says that it would go to Congress. And there, I'm far less faith in Congress as you most Americans at this point. So it's just so, so hard to tell. I do wonder, I was just thinking of what you were saying about the liberal order and living in Australia, one of the things that I've instructed by is how confidence can be compelling.

And so, when you see countries like New Zealand and Australia beat back the coronavirus in a way that the United States doesn't and see trust surge as a result of that, there are also scenarios in which what seems completely dark and the abyss of America with a turnaround of confidence through this election could also be the beginning of something different too. So I'm trying to be hopeful through this. And I think it's worth remembering that that's possible opinions and trust in government can change very quickly. I love your optimism, Danny.

That's fantastic. And so far, a question to you both. If Trump wins another four years after all the crises, the controversies, the attacks on his country's institutions, 200,000 people dead from COVID-19, would that not be a moment of existential crisis for the media? Not just what doesn't do now, but has it shown itself to be largely impotent?

Because it's uncovered and documented time and time again, Trump's maleficentcies. And if he's what he elected, what does that point to? What does that say about the media? Danny, can you go first?

I think we've seen for a while that when we talk about the media, we think of it as this monolith that we all kind of listen to and participate in. But the reality is there are so many different medias. And as I was saying, on Facebook, there are a whole lot of people to find media in other ways. And this will simply confirm what their media has told them.

And so, I think it's important to sort of think of the media as a population of information as opposed to a single monolith. And so I don't know. But that said, I think in some ways, I don't know that it does speak to the weakness of media so much as the weakness of a society that's become divided and broken. I think sometimes we put too much faith in the power of the media anyways.

The reality is that, you know, there's only so much we can do. Readers have responsibility as well. And when they read us or read something else, it's ultimately on their heads as opposed to ours. Nick, what do you think?

Yeah, I agree. I don't think media can say credit or blame entirely for any large shift in the way a cultural society works. And I think we have tended to try and do that. The mainstream media, to use that terrible term now, has always or has recently, I think in the past decade or so, perhaps misunderstood how it's fracturing has detracted from its power, what power it did have.

So much information is now gathered, shared and understood online that what happens in the Sydney Morning Herald or the New York Times is not necessarily what people are understanding or appreciating. And it should also be remembered I think is David was just saying that it is not necessarily a media's job to be shaping society rather than reflecting it. And if society is being torn apart at the seams, if a dump truck has turned up in the middle of the civic square, that's not a result of the media, it's a result of many different fissures and fractures, which the media is useful for trying to understand rather than for shaping, I believe. Okay, let's take that a little bit further.

So if the media's role then is to explain and to open up for a discussion that if he wins, does that not indicate that tactic, that strategy hasn't worked? No, it means I suppose that it's overwhelmed by all the other currents and undercurrents in society because it is not the job of the New York Times we try to defeat Donald Trump. It is not the purpose of revealing his tax returns over the past 15 years to try and beat him at an election, but to reveal his tax returns and present that information to the United States and to the world. They've done the job and they did it really well.

So it says it suggests I would think that society is in a great deal of trouble, but that doesn't automatically suggest a failing of media. Okay, I think we'll leave it there. Thank you both for a fascinating and fabulous discussion. I think we should re-invain after the election definitive result or not, but thank you both very, very much for being with us today.

Thank you. On that note, I'd like to thank Damien Cave and Nick O'Malley for being on Fourth Estate and thanks also for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the help of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support.

You can subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and everything in between. We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to the producer Anthony Dockwell, my name's Monica Atard and thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on October 1, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.