Skip to content
Andrew Jaspan In Conversation episode artwork

May 3, 2019 39 min

Andrew Jaspan In Conversation

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we speak to Andrew Jaspan about the media's coverage of the election and why Google and Facebook should help pay for our media. We also touch on how he started the Conversation and its importance.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Andrew Jaspan In Conversation

0:00 39:23
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from Tursiara in Sydney on Galigal lands on the Oronation right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Fray and I'm Co-Director of the Centre for Media Transition at University of Technology Sydney and my producer today is Anthony Dockroll.

Today we are going to delve deep into the future of journalism in particular how to fund it with one of the country's most experienced editorial executives and media innovators. On the line from Melbourne, welcome to the Fourth Estate, Andrew Jasmine. Hello Peter, I think you've probably matched my experience I'm not sure I think you've shamed me but anyway it's not that sort of competition. Here is a taste of Andrew C.V.

Founder and Editor of the Conversation, Editor-in-Chief of the Age, Editor of the Observer in London that is, Editor of the Scotsman, Editor of the Scotland on Sunday. There's a few more I've missed but why not actually Andrew is your title now? I'm now the Director of the Global Academy which is based here at RMIT University with the support of Western Sydney University actually RMIT, Melbourne University, Deakin University and Monash. Well okay we'll get to the Global Academy later in the show but first I'd like to start off with just a couple quick questions because we are in the middle of an election campaign in fact just passed the halfway point.

It seems to me, I'm interested in your impressions on the election campaign so far, it seems to me that it's been pretty negative, pretty messy. How do you think the media has performed though in all of this? I think it's a very difficult question Peter because I think I was thought of by saying I think most people have made up their minds. If you take the polls they've been incredibly consistent for the last three years or so and don't forget these polls are asking people the same kind of questions every two weeks so there's been no swings at all for the last three years.

It's all pointed to a change of government and I think most people have made up their minds. So there are a few people in the middle who potentially are kind of saying let me see what bribe I can be offered or what sweetener I can be offered and I'll make my decision on based on that but I think to a large part there's no real discussion out there and the media is wondering what the hell to do. I'm wondering what the point of a four-week contest even is and the fact that so many people I think it's anywhere between half a million and 600,000 people have already voted. I think you'll find that number will inflate to well over five million before election day on the 18th of May.

It just shows that frankly people are not really bothered about the debate. I think the debate is very poor. I think people lost with the size of some of the numbers being thrown around. I'm just staggered by the number of kind of bribes that have been pulled out of the hat constantly.

I think the whole thing's pretty poor Peter and I think most people have switched off. I really I mean I talk quite widely to people including by the way students here and I don't find anybody really engaged in this election. Okay so if you were still editor in chief at the age and if I were to say still editor in chief at the scene we were here what would we be telling our reporters to do? Should we go on leave save us the money?

Get off the bus and start talking to the real people. I mean is there a risk? I don't know if there is but it might be a riskier that the journalists who are on the bus kind of you know mesmerized by this election that no one else has mesmerized by might be in danger of missing you know what the real people are thinking. So for instance is Clive Palmer Donald Trump what do you think about that idea?

Well first of all and you probably know this video because we've worked together in the past but I'm no fan of you know reporters being locked up in a bus and being spoon fed stories. I just think it's the lowest form of journalism really is and frankly I would pull people off the bus and save my budget because it costs money to be on the bus all the plane or whatever else. I do think there are some sort of really big issues at stake in this election. I think it's a bit of a cross road election and it's really around I think two very big issues.

The first one is around climate and I won't go into that because I think you're well aware that there are very strong feelings now and I'm just delighted in many ways that it's made a bit of a comeback and this is driven by international pressure. So as you probably know there are strikes being held by schools around the world where kids are really getting involved in the subject and particularly in London there's a lot of activity. So that's the first one. The second one I think is broadly around two things which are actually the same issue and that is taxation and public services.

So on the one side you've got a party that is arguing really for reducing or cutting taxation which means you've got less money to spend on services and on the other side you've got a party that wants to spend more on services which means of course you've got to raise money one way or another which is taxation to support those services. So it really falls down to an ideological split. Are you for public services or would you rather public service will broadly privatize where you paid for your own school, you paid for your own health, you paid for your own car, you etc or do you believe in public schools, public transport, public health etc. So there's kind of an ideological divide there and just because people are somewhat tired of the old parties although I do think there might be somewhat of a swing back to that.

You've also got all the minor players who are in a sense playing out either local issues or parties like Clive Palmer and One Nation which have a bit more of an appeal in sections of Redneck Queensland and other Redneck areas around Australia. But I think if I can just make this final point I do think that during this campaign probably just before One Nation has been holed just below the water by the Al Jazeera investigation, the investigation carried out by them and Ronald ABC initially into James Ashby and Steve Dixon's activities in America and then the follow up on a current effect on Channel Nine into the topless bar activities of Steve Dixon. I think those two have meant I've seen their poll numbers tumble from 8% before to 4% or maybe less and there's also a lot of stuff now. I think there's a little bit more scrutiny thank goodness on Clive Palmer and his unpaid bills and and he's supposed to pay the amount of money to Aboriginal trusts which effectively amounted to zero.

I think there's a little bit more scrutiny there which might make people in parts of Australia think twice about voting for some of these minor parties. So some of the best journalism as you say is actually might have been done by Al Jazeera. By far reporting. By far?

Maybe we'll just outsource Australian journalism please. Well no no because we're going to go to have we got a fund in a second. Well we are. Before we get to that point just quickly because we both had the pleasure of working with Anthony Catalano the former domain CEO who as we all know has emerged victorious and he's quest to buy the former Fairfax regionals for what looks like to be a bargain deal of about 115 million.

So that's a job lot that includes the camera times and because Harold the one on Gomirkary the bottom out and about more than 150 more publications. Is this a good move for Australian journalism? What do you think? Well look we both know Anthony you've had the privilege of actually editing the camera times which as you recall when it was owned by Real Press was run on not only the smell of an oily rag but I don't think even was an oily rag to smell.

We should have ran. We passed the run. So look I honestly do not know what he's going to do but let me tell you there's a couple of things which which I think all go well and I may be proved wrong. The first is that he actually has been a reporter and does understand the value of journalism.

Also when he was at Domain and part of Fairfax he actually argued at board level for retaining the City Morning Herald the age and the other mouse heads on the basis that he thought this provided him with market differentiation to the Australian and the tabloids in the Murdoch's table who support Real Estate.com. So he thought his mouse heads gave him a slightly higher ABC market as it were in such as demographic terms and he thought they really helped the business. So I think he will use his new mouse heads to support what he knows best these days which is either Real Estate or Advertising Businesses. He's very much involved in that area.

He also owns by the way an advertising purchasing company that's not exactly the right word but buying company. Yeah so he knows a lot about buying he knows a huge amount about Real Estate but I actually do think he values the role of quality journalism. That's the first thing. The second thing sorry for a slightly long winded reply is that he's paid so little money for this.

Let's not forget when Fairfax and Royal Press merged, Royal Press were valuing their papers at something like three billion. That was only 12 years ago so he's got properties which were worth three billion back then for 150 million of which by the way he's only paying 105 million because there's a 10 million to be paid later on. So he's paid just over 100 million. That's the second thing.

Now the reason I mention that's not just the steal it means that he's not overpaid for these properties which means I think he's got the ability to invest in them and I've heard him elsewhere talk about the requirement to invest in them. So he's bought cheap and can invest as opposed to buying expensive and having to immediately cut costs and invest. I don't know if you follow that argument but you see what I'm saying. Yeah absolutely.

Yeah well I just say it will wait and see what happens but yeah I mean I was on Canberra Radio the other day saying I thought it was potentially a very positive move for the Canberra Times and others so let's wait and see. Okay let's get to the chase to the big picture. Let's talk about social platforms and how they may or may not wish to be seen and or how they may or may not wish to fund journalism. In recent days we've seen Facebook continuing to try and clean up the well in essence is the crap on its platform and I guess in doing so its own image most of the last few days in terms of banning hate speakers and the like and there's been other moves around previously and such like but the bigger picture and the picture that you've put in a submission to the ACCC is this creation of harnessing the wealth really of Facebook and Google to create what you've called an independent future fund for journalism funded by what in essence is a kind of community levy on the digital platforms.

Talk us through that. It's a kind of turnover tax right? Yes. And tell us how would you see that working and what's the plan?

So the brand new figures which have just been there in the city because the figures I've got I have been so these are created by year and what they actually show in the year 2018 Facebook alone made 598 million in Australia's last year. Yeah. Now on that they only paid 8 million tax. Just for any of your listeners when they do it goes as follows.

They sell advertising in Australia out of either Singapore or Dublin. That means that the money doesn't actually touch the straight out and point 8 million in tax and in the do have example they do have some and that kind of makes sense. That's about right. The problem is that 598 million which seamlessly flows out of the country.

Yeah. I mean just so the platforms would say but hang on we're growing a business here we're investing in Australia we're even spending money on Australian journalism. What do you say to that? I mean they're trying to do the right thing or you're basically saying you know.

They're not doing the right thing at all. So what they're taking is there's a pool of money out there. The sums of money and forgive me Peter but you and I have both seen the age of the grand money is something like about 8 billion in advertising. Take a lot more they take about four and a half billion of advertising.

So between the two they've got about five at the 8 billion advertising dollars removed from Australia. So it's just so they conduct business in this country and whereas everybody else pays 10 you know their headquarters in Mountain View or where you're at. You would in essence try to close that capacity to. No no no my argument is this is I think this is doing its money out of once of the higher journalists in this country anyway.

Since about 2012 I think yeah. So the lights have gone off in many user rooms all over and the expertise of being replaced by anything. Because the money is not there to fund them. It's just be or a social license to operate.

This is in my submission. We'll see let's apply a 10% which is like a community levy which goes into a fund. So 10% obviously it's 500 million which goes into fund which then business etc of town halls police rounds and parliaments and the four be able to apply for this money and borders back into the give us the service what to do. And when you talk about the election this allows you then to scrutinize muddies of candidate seeking elections.

So what sort of responses have you had to this idea? I mean you know the atropsey is still working on its final report. That's out in a couple of months probably. So we haven't seen a response from the atropsey but when you talk to others about it I'm assuming that most people in the news media industry would think it's a good idea.

To say no is like voting against mother in the middle. Yes. So everybody thinks it's a good idea that the I get the feeling all the atropsey won't give me a tick that they can pick up and the second thing is it depends on who wins the election because I've sort of art and areas in labor are things as well. And I think this is kind of proposal that they might and on the coalition side of things I think equally they are commissioned this atropsey some good ideas.

The critical thing is there's in this the charge upon them on that billion. It means they don't take five billion in others countries taking out an enormous amount of money which is also in one sense it's a bit like a resource rent tax. Mine is a charge for basically extracting the common wealth small-seek on the wealth of Australia. Correct.

And it deals with doing right now they're just moving it out so it can't be taxed in this country. Has Facebook or Google said anything to you about it? I don't know Peter I haven't actually sent it to them. They would have seen it.

That's all. Well it's loaded on the atropsey website which is publicly available. I guess they're waiting for the atropsey. Yeah what I guess I just want to make this point to you is that I think the idea of just small incremental grants as in let's put a million into here and a million into there.

Although it sounds good and everybody applauds you know that somebody's put a little bit of money in. What I'm talking about is actually a sort of building capacity at scale. Yeah it's a game changer if that would happen. I should add as by way of full disclosure is that the Centre for Media transition has received some of the small amounts of money Andrew's talking about from Facebook and some small amounts of money well actually under $1000 or so from Google to set up the first draft initiative which I'll be talking about in the near future.

But so and to be quite frank about that is that there isn't a lot of other places perhaps other than say the Judith Nielsen initiative that is offering sort of money to support public interest journalism right? Absolutely. And you know again Peter I think it's terrific that Facebook and Google give you money but can I tell you because I've looked into all this that money actually comes from their PR and marketing budget. So it's a way of them kind of trying to cover their blushes in a sense.

Yes I just try to cover mine. No no well I think it's good you know and I would take money from them obviously if they were to offer the money but I think one has to just be aware of what they're up to. I mean you know when they're taking out between them $5 billion and they then give you a $100,000 just just bear in mind the game is. No I go course I'm not an honest.

Both of us welcome the Judith Nielsen Institute. Yeah. But that's a hundred million not a hundred million a year by the way Peter that's a hundred million endowment in the US. What I'm talking about here is an annual turnover or an annual social levy or a quite like your term of a resource tax that we're which is which is which could be in the area of 500 million a year.

Yeah. A few hundred heavily could build up it could go into and what I'd like to do is to find a way to ensure that those monies are protected and a little bit like a future fund for journalism. Future fund for journalism yes right. So just talk about money and funding because one of your great great contributions to Australian journalism has been the setting up the idea of and the setting up and the editing of the conversation.

For people who don't know what the conversation I'm sure most people want to listen to the show will know what it is but tell us about the conversation and how you came up with this idea and you know and how you started and you know how tough was that? Well Peter the toughest bit of all was after I left the age I was just really trying to figure out what to do next and I was approached by Glenn Davis who at the time was by Johnson Melbourne University and we talked about the state of journalism and I said that rather than write endlessly about how precarious and how bad things were I'd like to actually try and do something and he said well look what do you think that'd be I said I'm not quite sure but I'd like to see if there's a different way to produce high quality informed journalism and he said well good luck I'll give you a desk here's 10 people I think you should talk to amongst my smartest and I went away and spoke to them all and it suddenly came to me that these are the smart people I would love to inhabit my virtual newsroom. So they were academics man. You know I'm talking about Nobel scientists here and the like truly smart people well informed that the one thing they don't have as you know Peter is the ability to sometimes speak in plain language as it were and the other thing is they don't obviously have the discipline of a newsroom in terms of a word length and when the story has to be in by and so on and so forth.

So what I actually came up with was this idea of a hybrid where the academic in a sense was the reporter and the journalist sitting alongside just helped them knock that into shape in terms of being an 800 word article which which had the usual sort of conventions of journalism and a deadline and I launched it I managed to raise nine million dollars to get it going over three years. And that was all from universities man. Well no sorry the third was universities the third was Victorian sake government the third was federal government. It was free matching funds and we launched it in 2011 and it's now you know a great success and operates in seven different countries around the world.

So that was in a sense scaling up journalism without I mean at a fractional cost because most of the reporters and by the way in Australia something like about I think the figure is in the region of about 10,000 academics across Australia have written for the site over the past seven years and you know so it's just in a sense using an untapped resource. And what happens to the just for the rest is what happens to that copy it's sent out into the world as a creative college. So it's free to anyone. Yeah so the editors are commissioned at edited and then dressed it up in terms of putting a picture on it, a headline on it and then it's pushed out and anybody can read it for free on the on the website.

And I see the conversation which you're still not really involved with the conversation anymore. Well you have an advisory role is that right? Yeah I have a sort of quality advisory role I think because I'm formally meant to be an advisor but nobody seeks my advice so there we are. Right well I was going to say the conversation has you know the last few days started a reader drive, reader revenue drive, much in the manner of say the Guardian which is very successful.

So what do you think of the idea? Read a revenue? Well I started that I think in year two of the conversation. It's a great idea then.

Yeah and the thing is that I managed through through one of my contacts to get Wayne Swan to give us digital gift recipient status which means anybody giving money automatically gets a tax deduction. So very few organizations have that. I mean it's something for example you mentioned that you did the Nielsen Institute. That's something they're looking for and everybody tries to seek.

It's very much the holy grail. It's difficult to do and it took me quite a bit of time to organize but I had a friend who managed to persuade Wayne Swan to adopt it as part of a bill he was putting through Parliament which gave us that status. And that was I think in 2013 we got that and we launched in 2011 and we've been doing those drives. They've been very successful but what's happened is the Victorian State Government that was supporting the conversation stopped giving money from the end of last year or this year.

And that's quite right. I mean if you think about it to get money for seven years from a state government is pretty exceptional and I think I always work on the basis but the Victorian Government would stop giving money and I think they're having to push the barrow even harder to try and make up for the loss of revenue from the state government. You still see the conversation as a relevance to the entity though. Oh yeah absolutely.

I'm immensely proud of that Peter. And I think what the idea has done has been transformational and the fact that it's doing so well particularly for example the UK and also I happen to know that the French edition is doing extremely well is just testament to the fact that it was a strong idea which has been able to be replicated elsewhere. So Thomas strong ideas you mentioned at the top of the interview the Global Academy. What is the Global Academy?

Is this your next venture I think? Yes we're still kind of working at through Peter so I'm going to be a little bit tentative but essentially the clues are all in the name as in it's global and it's an academy. The academy and the academy is the global universities essentially. So what I'm looking at is fundamentally looking at how we can work with universities around the world to do a very different kind of service because obviously they don't want to replicate what the conversation does.

So you know we're looking at doing something quite different and we're just still defining exactly how that's going to work, how it's going to be distributed, how it's going to be funded, you know what the governance procedure and the rate is. It is absolutely and you know that's something which you know I've been very lucky to be involved in journalism since I left university and I just see it as a seamless although I've worked on you know quite a few newspapers, I mean you listed some of them, there are many more. It's been a seamless journey in so far as I'm just interested in one thing which is how do we provide high quality information for citizens to be able to understand the world they live in and hopefully be able to make informed decision, comments, contributions, discussions about those things. I mean I'm not really interested whether it's print online, you know video, whatever I'm just interested in high quality information, better informing people.

So just one more word on the Global Academy though. How will it be different than say the conversation because it does have some of the same elements, universities, internationalization, obviously it's going to deal with some big ideas, big issues, so how will it just, I know you're still working out but how do you think it'll be different? Well I think a critical issue is just staying well away from the what I call the breaking news environment because the conversation does that well which is kind of informing live issues with deeper contextual material and explanatory material. So just staying away from that area because I think the conversation does it well but in terms of actually how we're going to package it up and do it, that's literally what I'm working on right now and once I've got it all figured out and we've got it funded and so on and so forth I'd be delighted to talk to you again.

Okay another edition of the fourth estate you've just booked it. We're running out of time but just a couple of broad questions. In terms of the Australian environment and media innovation, how would you rate Australian news media companies in terms of innovation? Poor.

Poor. Why? Because they're so busy trying to make a quid? No, look there's a structural problem in Australian media which is it's imbalanced where you have one major player naming news court having an influence which is way beyond what I think is healthy in a participatory democracy where there ought to be a contest of ideas and equal confess of ideas.

I think there's one house that's got too much share of voices that we're in Australia. That's the first issue. The second issue is that that's become progressively worse over the last 15 years I've been in Australia because the papers you and I used to work for, the Fairfax paper, Sydney Morning Herald, Canberra Times and the age no longer belong to Fairfax because Fairfax doesn't exist anymore and I put that down to extremely poor leadership of the Fairfax by people who are interested in running them as advertising companies rather than media companies. What I mean by that is they had no real commitment to the editorial role of those papers and that meant constantly reimagining how one would do a good editorial which would capture an audience which you would retain and that didn't flow into any of the executive decisions in terms of how to run these papers with one exception that was how you could reduce costs which went take headcount out and of course the end of the day if you keep chomping away at a donut you're left with just a hole.

And that's where they ended up. Now in contrast if you look at the interesting things that are going on say at the Guardian and it's an extraordinary story with the Guardian because the Guardian was in trouble or has been for a while and this year they've broken even for the first time and that's because they've got almost a million people now making a monthly contribution. If you look at the New York Times how they've changed the sort of way in which they do business, the way in which they connect with readers and so on and so forth. The same goes for the Washington Post and others but in every case has been innovative thinking plus investment which was absent from the Fairfax papers.

I don't know what will happen when they're eaten up by Channel 9 Entertainment which is not a media company, it's an entertainment company. On the flip side with News Corp I think they do do some innovation. I think they do have people quite passionate about papers. My reservations are just the ones I made too earlier.

It's not to do with the caliber of the people running it. Okay well look this is another episode of the Fourth Estate. Andrew Jasmine thank you so much for your time. I know you've probably got another meeting to go to.

Busy Busy. Just final question, are you optimistic about the future of Australian journalism with or without your 500 million a year? Well look there's a couple of things which need to be to have a glass half full while in empty. The first one is the one we touched upon which is the role that Antony Catalano and the HCM could provide us with.

The second thing is the Jizz Nielsen Institute you touched upon. I think that will be providing some really innovative funding for some new projects. But in terms of a transformational change, and by the way we've not touched on the ABC which is another subject we can maybe talk about next time, I think there needs to be a structural approach to Australia where one does say that we've got to get more journalists back into the system because there's been a reduction of as we said 4,000. How do we put journalists back in to actually get out and do some shoe leather journalism meaning get out and see people report, find out watch dog scrutinise and what's going on.

And the second thing we need to do is introduce more voices, more players and there have been a few new players who have come into town but a number of them with exclusion of the conversation and the Guardian have actually not done terribly well. So as you know Buzzfeed and Huffington Post and others have all had to cut right back because their models are not really functioning very well in this country. Yeah we live in a period of great change in terms. We do.

And on that note, I'd like to just thank you so much for being on the fourth estate. My pleasure, thanks Peter. Thanks Andrew. We've been talking to Andrew Jasmine, the former editor-in-chief of the age and the founder and editor of the conversation along with lots of other senior editorial jobs.

Thank you so much for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios at 2SER and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Make sure you subscribe to the Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk about journalism, media, politics and a few things in between at your leisure and we'll be back next week. But in the meantime, stay in touch with us on Twitter.

Our handle is Fourth Estate AU and many, many thanks to my producer, Anthony Dockrell. My name is Peter Frey and thank you very much for listening. A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars.

And it means there's no need to wear me when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us.

Learn how at Ontario.ca. Safer Ontario. Pay for by the Government of Ontario.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on May 3, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.