Skip to content
Are You Tracking Negative Backer Volatility? episode artwork

Feb 22, 2026 24 min

Are You Tracking Negative Backer Volatility?

from ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! Hosted by Tyler James

In this session, Tyler responds to a question about whether there's a reason for a seeming spike in cancelled pledges when launching projects today? It turns into a discussion about the importance of distinguishing “noise” during a live campaign from meaningful “signal.” Then we discuss ways to turn observations into comparable rates and introduces a simple DIY metric called “negative backer volatility.”

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Are You Tracking Negative Backer Volatility?

0:00 24:46
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

What's up with all the canceled pledges these days? Is anyone else experiencing this? I swear my backer list is as red and green as Christmas. Prepare to launch. This is Comics Launch, crowdfunding for writers, artists, and self-publishers on Kickstarter and beyond. This is the show that teaches you the mindset, strategies, and tactics to fund your dream projects, energize and expand your fan base, and take your creative career to the next level. You'll hear some of the top minds in crowdfunding share what's working now for independent and entrepreneurial creators like us so that you can successfully bring more of your art to a world that needs it without waiting for anyone's permission to take action. If you're getting ready to launch, you're in the right place.

Comics Launch Session 552. Are you tracking negative backer volatility? Today's session is brought to you by Gemini Comic Supply. Use discount code COMICS LAUNCH at checkout and get 10% off comic flash mailers at GeminiComicSupply.com. Hello there. Welcome to the Comics Launch Podcast. This is your host, Tyler James, and this is the show all about mindset strategies and tactics for comic creators, crowdfunders, folks that want to use platforms like Kickstarter to bring their projects into the world. And on today's episode, we're going to talk about...

backer volatility, specifically negative volatility. So backers dropping their pledges or lowering their pledges or dropping and then coming back and then dropping again and then jumping all around. I call them yo-yo backers. But we're going to talk about that and a way to sanity check what's actually going on in your campaign while you're in the middle of your campaign so that you don't let the distraction that can be a volatile backing situation derail you from what you need to do to succeed with your launch. Before I do that, though, I did want to call a little bit of attention to a feature that Backerkit, a crowdfunding competitor of Kickstarters, rolled out for their crowdfunding platform and share what this feature is and discuss whether this is a feature that should be more widely accessible across crowdfunding platforms. And the audio that you're going to hear for this episode actually came from a Comics Launch Pro live coaching session. So sometimes I will...

for the podcast, pull some snippets from the live coaching sessions, and I'll share those with you all. So that's what you're going to get today. Backerkit has been putting out a slew of new features lately, specifically for their crowdfunding platform. And one of the ones that they've just launched, which is pretty interesting, is the instant access rewards. So you can see, for example, here's traditional crowdfunding, the limited edition hardcover and PDF, but it also includes instant access, Blade 68 PDF preview, instant access, Roll20 Quickstart. So basically, instant access means...

your sort of PDF bonuses. But instead of having to wait to look at the campaign, you collect the survey and everything, it opens up immediately. And so I just want to open the floor real quick to see what you all think of this pros, cons, thoughts. Yeah, Eric, kick us off. Hey, looks pretty interesting. A couple of questions for anything else. Is this only for if you run the quick campaign on Backerkit? Or it also, what if somebody backs and then you give them the prize and then they drop the pledge, you know? Otherwise, it looks pretty cool. Yeah, I mean, that would be my question about it. If a PDF download is being made available instantly, you could see them losing access to that link. But if they already have it, I don't know that there's that. I don't think they have self-destruct PDF technology. So that is that's sort of a downside to it, potentially. Is it worth the potential upside? David, thoughts? That was my same concern. And then there's the alternate.

the back end of that. What if they see the PDF and say, you know, I don't like this and tell other people? You know what I mean? It's kind of like, that's the risk factor to me is greater than reward in that idea. I guess I would challenge that to say, maybe that depends on how confident you are in your stuff, right? Because, I don't know, you know, I'm somebody that... What if they're just a troll? Somebody that likes to say they don't like it, but they got a PDF and they can like, you know, cut and paste, you know what I'm saying? Yeah, so they start drawing crude drawings all over your stuff? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, that could happen, but, you know, most of us are already out there like giving away freebies to get people on our email list or putting stuff out online. So they can already do all that stuff, right?

Yeah, but if your stuff is public in any way, if your stuff is public in any way, if you are out there, that is a risk. And in fact, the bigger you get, the increasing percentage of inevitability that there will be haters and trolls coming after your stuff. So yeah, that's definitely something. What did you say, Greg? What was your thoughts on this?

just the fact that people can back out. So it's a thing I've encountered on Shopify with automatic digital delivery. I've had a number of people buy my comic on my store only to turn around and charge back, which is a real pain in the head because it's about three times as much as you earn from the comic. But it doesn't happen enough to make it, hasn't made it happen enough to make me stop selling on my store digital. Yeah. Yeah, instant. Yeah, and so I do think there's probably a fine-tuning of you don't want to give...

You don't want to give something that's going to turn backers off, but you may not want to give something so much that it's like, oh, I got this for free and now I'm just going to bail. So like, I probably wouldn't do like, hey, you know, you can get instant access to the digital version, even if the digital version is already open because then that, but like things like a preview or like a PDF preview, or sometimes we do things like indie comics backer bundle. That might be something that you might want to give out or you might want to only give out like a teaser or something like that. It could be behind the scenes stuff or an extended. We say a lot of times Kickstarter videos are things that you want to keep nice and tight, but maybe there's an extended trailer or something or extended teaser with some stuff off the cutting room floor, a longer interview, digital, that might be something cool that it's not the thing itself, but it gets them more excited to it. How many of us, if there was a four-minute cut for the next Avengers trailer, but you had to trade your email for that, I think a lot of people would trade their email for that, even if it was not the thing.

So, yeah, it's an interesting thing. I'll be curious to see if something Kickstarter looks to adopt. Other thoughts? And there's another problem, too. I'm giving away my age here. Oh, you don't need to buy that new album. I'll just make a tape of it for you, and you can listen to it for free. If they've got the PDF, and you're in the middle of a live Kickstarter to raise money, oh, you don't need to buy it. I already got it for free. Here, this is what it looks like. Save your money. Yeah, that's true. And so, yeah, I mean, again, just looking at this example that they provided, you'll see that the PDF for the full issue is not one of the instant access things. It's sort of like they're giving the same thing that they might give away to get people on their email list. Yeah, Eric.

Yeah, first part of my question was, is this available on Kickstarter or only a campaign on Backerkit? Yeah, this is just for Backerkit's crowdfunding platform. It's a Backerkit-specific feature. Yeah, Greg. Did you say that someone would, like, if they've taken that, you automatically get their email address? Have you tested that? That is a good question. Because that would be worth it long-term, even if they bailed. Potentially. And I think...

Yeah, I'm actually not sure how Backerkit handles that. I do know Backerkit gives you some ability to message people that are following your campaign on Backerkit so that you can add those people to your launch list so you do have some access to their email in some way anyway. you know, that could be, that could be something to that effect. All right. So if there's any other thoughts on this, please let me know. But yeah, it'll be interesting to see how that ends up, you know, if there's good uptake there, or if that's something that, you know, Kickstarter might experiment with in the future, because they seem to be, you know, a little bit more nimble these days in terms of rolling out new stuff. This one was from Nate. Nate said, what's up with all the canceled pledges these days? Is anyone else experiencing this? I swear my backer list is as red and green as Christmas. A lot of them cancel and return and cancel again, bots, economy, ideas. And so...

I don't know. Put a one in the chat if you feel like you're seeing more of this kind of stuff, like the canceled pledges or the backers coming and leaving and coming and leaving. My approach with questions like this is always to try to make sure that we're looking at signal and not noise. And I think there might be a good lesson here in signal versus noise. And so like a noise statement might be something like, wow, it sure feels like there's a lot of canceled pledges and adjustments and yo-yo backers on my latest launch. Because the truth is it is noisy when we have, we're getting all these updates on our phone and we go there and click there and see like red, red, red, red, red with people making adjustments that are negative. But you're in the middle of the campaign, it's noisy. But is it actually signal? And so like a signal statement would look, would be a little bit more sophisticated. It might say something like, you know, hey, my backer adjustment rate is 20% higher.

than my previous two campaigns. What might be contributing to this? And so a way, like a good habit to just get into whenever we're trying to make sure that we're focusing on signal and not just not being distracted by noisy stuff is to try to put things in a rate or a metric that we can create, right? Because a thousand negative backer adjustments on the Transformers campaign that had, I don't know, 20,000 backers would probably be expected and raising millions of dollars. Like nobody's going to care about that, right?

But if you can put it into a rate, then you can kind of compare across campaigns and compare historically. So an example of a rate might be something, or a metric that we could just kind of create here would be something, and I'm just making this up. I don't know that there's an official term for this, but I'm calling this negative backer volatility, okay? And if you go to your dashboard when you have a live campaign or even after the fact, you can click on there and you can click on adjustments. and it will show you red are either cancels or lowering pledges, and greens are positive pledges. But here's a rate you would create. You could just say total number of negative adjustments, the reds, divided by the total number of backers during the campaign. And I would probably use not just the total amount of backers at the end of the campaign, but the total amount of backers altogether. And you can find that pretty easily by just kind of selecting all of your backers, including dropped backers or canceled backers, et cetera. And you can also see like...

with the last backer number, what the last backer number was, and that'll give you the total number of backers. And then if you can do this across campaigns and you get a rate, you can actually start to then think about, okay, you know, what's going on? So the last Kickstarter, I just did this just for fun. The last Kickstarter campaign I did that wrapped two weeks ago was for Epic, and I had a 5.2% negative backer volatility rate, my new metric, okay? Again, a rate, one rate doesn't really tell me all that much. Is this good? Is this bad? Is this high? Is this low? I don't really know. But when you can compare it and benchmark it to other campaigns, then you can find out.

Here's a campaign, Sink Halloween Special. That was the one that I did before that, right back in October. And that one had 11.2% negative backer volatility. This one had over 220 more backers and raised almost three times as much money, but it had almost double the backer volatility. So that's interesting. And then here's the campaign that we did before that. That was for Groglar and Shanks. This was a first time Kickstarter campaign. And this one was sort of in the middle of the last two, 8.2%. So again, these are all now.

these are three data points, right? So it's still not a tremendous amount of information, but at least it's helping me put this in some kind of perspective. And so again, some things to consider, something I preach a lot, like focus on data over drama. It may feel like you're getting a lot of adjustments, but are these results actually historically weird for you? Or did you just forget about all those adjustments for those campaigns that you are no longer in? That happens a lot. And then also like, are your results weird for you? Are the results weird compared to what other creators are seeing? And then if they are,

then you might also then think, okay, well, I've got some signal here. I'm getting, it's a lot lower or it's a lot higher. Well, what might drive more backer volatility? We can think about that. And Nate mentioned a couple of things, the economy, you know, bots, et cetera. But some of the things that I think probably correlate even more to it is that the bigger your launches, the more campaign browsers you tend to get. Meaning like the first 50 people into your Kickstarter campaign are probably your...

diehards you're dead in the wool like they're coming out your rider dies right and and for small creators it might be just your first 50 for bigger creators it might be your first 150 or 200 but eventually you're going to get to the point where you're where most of your diehards or your existing fan base is kind of exhausted and so the people that are coming in after that for the bigger campaigns when you start getting into the hundreds and thousands of backers they're going to be less sort of already committed to you and your project and and so you may expect that the chances that someone that hey, this project looks cool and it's doing well on Kickstarter. Let me throw some dollars its way. But that person might be less invested than the person that's on your email list and watching your TikToks and has just been hanging out with you for forever, all right? You might also be looking at things like, well, did I have higher tiers, more expensive tiers of this campaign? Were there more choice? Was there more opportunity to change my mind? Did I roll out?

like enticing lower value tiers in the middle of the campaign and some backers may have adjusted down? Or in my campaign, did I provide any incentives for people to stick? Was I doing stretch goals and really keeping people like engaged and having the value keep continuing to get better and better and better as the campaign went on? Or did I not do any of that stuff? So there's a lot of different things that will play a factor into this. And then the other thing to consider is though, is where do you want to put your focus and energy when you're in the middle of a launch? I try to put very, very little of it, of my focus and energy on

individual backers making adjustments that are negative because that kind of takes me out of it. So I turn the notifications off for the most part. I get messages and check the comments and things like that. But I am not obsessing on the tab that shows me just like what individual backers are doing. Because the truth is, there are some backers, I call them yo-yo backers, but they will literally, they might pledge and unpledge and adjust up and adjust down like multiple times, five, six, seven. I think the record I saw was one guy that did it like 20 times in a campaign before ultimately canceling. And it's like, is this a troll? Probably. Or just someone that cannot make a decision to save their life.

But I don't know. Other thoughts or questions or concepts on this? Anybody want to? Sure. Eric says, it seems like you could do one more calculation to make adjustments ratio ratio to backers and end up with an apples to apples metric across campaigns. Yeah. I mean, there are probably other metrics that you could do or you could weight this scale. And yeah, you know, I tend to do like do things that are a little bit on the simpler side, but I'm sure that the juicy statisticians out there could have a field day playing with these metrics and get some really good insight there.

In a moment, I'm going to give you today's comics launcher, but first, we need to thank our sponsor. Hey, are you getting ready to ship rewards to all your awesome backers? With more than a decade of publishing under my belt, I've shipped my fair share of comics and graphic novels over the years, so you can bet I was shocked to realize I'd been doing it wrong. One of the most overlooked aspects of the Kickstarter process is your shipping materials, which is a shame because how your package arrives is often the last impression your campaign will make on a backer and will be a big factor in whether they choose to support you again. And yet, I can't tell you how many creators are out there disappointing their backers by shipping comics and graphic novels in shoddy packaging. Now, for the longest time, I was using and recommending rigid-stay flat mailers for comic shipping, only to hear back from...

some upset fans that their packages were decimated by a mail carrier who must hate them. No more though. I now use Comic Flash mailers from Gemini Comic Supply and the shipping complaints have all gone away. Comic Flash mailers are engineered specifically to secure comics and graphic novels. They're constructed with high quality durable corrugated paper while still being lightweight to reduce shipping costs. Each mailer has a flexible capacity and is perfect for shipping a single bagged and board issue all the way up to 12 bagged and boarded comics or a few graphic novels in a single package. And here's a pro tip for you, especially for those of you guys in the US. Comic Flash mailers will slip comfortably into a flat rate legal envelope, which can save you up to 50% or more on the...

cost of shipping domestic, depending upon the weight of the package, of course. Now, I reached out to Brian Kelly at Gemini, and I told him I was a huge fan of his company, and I secured a special deal for Comics Launch listeners looking to upgrade their shipping game. Just use coupon code COMICSLAUNCH at checkout at GeminiComicsSupply.com, and you'll get 10% off your very first order over at Gemini, and you will be able to treat your books and your backers with the care they deserve. All right, your Comics Launcher for Session 552 is to take a look at your previous, let's say, three to five campaigns, and just calculate what the negative volatility rate for those campaigns are. Easy calculation. Just take the total number of negative adjustments. You can see that on your Kickstarter dashboard and divide that by the total number of backers during that campaign. And you can see that by going to your backer list and just selecting all of the possible categories of backer. And that will give you the total number of people that pledge to your launch and quick division. It'll get you a rate. And then you can compare that rate across campaigns. And then once you've done that, what do you see? What do you notice? Is there are they consistent across campaigns for certain campaigns, higher or more volatile than others? And what's your theory on why that might be?

All right. Hope you enjoyed this discussion. We talked about a new backer kit feature and we talked about a concept around negative backer volatility and why some campaigns might be more volatile than others and how rather than get caught up with the noise that can be a yo-yo backers or a lot of volume of backers adjusting or dropping pledges and things like that. It'd be very easy to let that distract you during a launch. But one of the ways to turn noise like that into signal is by making sure that you're normalizing it and keeping it in context of what has gone on in the past to make sure that your present is, if it's an outlier, it's actually an outlier and not just present and on your mind because it's going on and it feels like it's in your face. And over the course of my crowdfunding career, I think I saw that I've had over 25,000 backers that have supported ComicStribe and related campaigns. And so that...

probably means we've had, I don't know, 10, maybe 10,000 backer adjustments over that same period of time. And yeah, when you can put it into perspective, it makes it easier to roll with those punches. So I hope that is some context that resonates with you. And I hope this gives you some skills and some tools and some mindsets for thinking about what is signal and what is actually noise and not to get caught up with one when it's the other that is the more important thing to pay attention to. Thank you so much for listening. Let me walk with you as you're taking another step forward towards your next successful comics launch.

Looking for something new? These projects just launched on Kickstarter. Hey, Comics Launch, this is CJ Hudson, creator of Granite, which is live on Kickstarter right now. Granite is the story of Elena Callan, the rock-skinned celebrity superhero of the Summit universe. Our story picks up with Elena losing her powers and coming to terms with her new status quo within the world that she used to protect. If you're a fan of alternative superheroes or just interested in exploring Summit titles like Granite or Pinnacle, then you should definitely check out our Kickstarter today. Hello, Comics Launch. This is Aria, creator of Modern Vixens, live on Kickstarter. Modern Vixens is an illustrated art magazine devoted to the feminine mystique, where sensuality, light, and artistry intertwine.

Each issue is a curated collection of portraits celebrating beauty, not as perfection, but as presence. The way a gaze lingers, the way light brushes against skin, the hush between strength and softness. If you're a fan of evocative, intimate art that captures the poetry of the feminine form, then you should check out Modern Vixens on Kickstarter today. Are you a Comics Launch listener with a project that's launched or about to launch on Kickstarter? Tell us about it at comicslaunch.com forward slash voicemail, and we might just feature it on our show.

Launching a successful and profitable comic book Kickstarter campaign is possible, even if you're a new creator with a relatively small fan base. But to do it, you'll need a roadmap. And so I put together a brand new guide called the Profitable Comic Book Kickstarter Launch Roadmap, and I'd love to give it to you right now over at comicslaunch.com forward slash roadmap. In this guide, you'll get nine easy steps to follow that will set your comic book Kickstarter campaign up for success. You'll discover the key to getting Kickstarter to promote your project for you, and you'll get free comic book Kickstarter trainings delivered straight to your inbox each week when you grab this free roadmap. So just go to comicslaunch.com forward slash roadmap to hit the ground running with your next launch. You've been listening to Comics Launch with Tyler James. Go to comicslaunch.com for show notes, free resources, and to connect with me. Thank you so much for listening, and I can't wait to see what you launch next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond!?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode published?

This episode was published on February 22, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.