Skip to content
Assange's Last Chance? episode artwork

Feb 22, 2024 30 min

Assange's Last Chance?

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we look at Julian Assange's last chance to avoid extradition to the United States where he faces 17 charges for his work with Wikileaks. To talk about the legal challenges and his options with spoke to Professor Holly Cullen. Produced and hosted by Anthony Dockrill

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Assange's Last Chance?

0:00 30:04
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from Tariqi Ancini on the lands of the Gadigal people, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your divinist across the globe via podcast. I'm Anthony Dockwell. The fate of Julian Assange will soon be known.

Currently his legal team is arguing for a full appeal in the UK, and that is allowed, may stop his extradition to the US to face 17 counts for soliciting, gathering and publishing US military and diplomatic documents. Assange founded WikiLeaks in 2006 and in 2010 released large amounts of documents that were embarrassing to the United States over its activities in Iraq. He's been fighting extradition first to Sweden and now to the United States since 2010. He famously entered the Ecuadorian embassy in 2012 and remained there until 2019.

So just one of the implications of Assange's current appeal and what protections are there for doing journalism if Assange finds himself in the US. To discuss Julian Assange's appeal and the legal challenges he faces, we are lucky to have someone who's been following Assange's case closely. Professor Holly Cullen is an adjunct professor at the University of Western Australia. She is an expert on international law and human rights.

Professor Holly Cullen, welcome to For the State. Welcome. The Julian Assange is currently appealing his extradition to the United States. It's been almost a five-year battle to stop this extradition.

Is this his last legal hope inside the UK legal system? Well, we're at sort of a fork in the road. If this is a request for leave to appeal, if that is granted, it goes to a full appeal on the merits at some time to be settled later. Probably best guess would be later this year.

If he loses, then the only possibility would be to make an urgent application to the European Court of Human Rights to make order to the UK not to extradite him, handing a full hearing by the European Court of his claims. Am I right in saying that if he's unsuccessful and if he isn't given the ability to appeal this through a European Court, he could be in America in a matter of days? It could be. I somehow think that even the application to the European Court would take a little while because it's, you know, say there are serious legal arguments to be heard, even for an interim border.

So when they say days, I suspect it means more like a week or two. Look, I feel the case is complicated and this protracted. It needs to be unpacked for listeners a little bit. Assange has been fighting extradition for five years, but this matter goes back even further.

Let's go back to the beginning of his legal problems in the UK. How did this all start? Well, the beginning is the WikiLeaks leaks in 2010, including those that related to the conduct of the US in Iraq and Afghanistan. Shortly after that, an unrelated matter was charged as a sexual assault matter in Sweden and the Swedish prosecuting authority saw a European arrest warrant.

This was a lot ago. The UK was still part of the EU then to interrogate him in Sweden about the allegations. Now, at the time, Assange said that he didn't want to go to Sweden because he was afraid he would be expedited to the US from Sweden. That has always perplexed me because if you look at the US Swedish extradition treaty compared with the US UK expedition treaty, I personally would prefer to be fighting extradition from Sweden rather than from the UK.

The UK US expedition treaty was updated shortly after 9-11 and makes it very, very easy compared with other countries to expedite the US. But in any event, what happened was after his challenges to the European arrest warrant ran out and he was unsuccessful, he walked into the Ecuadorian embassy, claimed political asylum and refused to leave and therefore the order for him to be transferred to Sweden could not be executed because if you're in an embassy that is protected, territory protected, property and the authorities from the host state cannot enter without permission. So the British police could monitor the comings and goings of the Ecuadorian embassy but they could not go in and arrest him and they could not do that until 2019 when the Ecuadorian government gave the permission to do so. And that's where we start with the extradition proceedings.

Now, I understand Sweden has withdrawn as a quest for extradition, but America has shown no signs that it will withdraw these charges against Assange. Is that unusual? Is that typical for the US to be this dogged? I don't know.

I couldn't say having looked at that I've looked at this comprehensively. You also have to remember these are very different types of charges, substantively, and the legal systems are different. In Sweden, some of the charges against Assange actually had to be dropped because it was too long since the original complaint. So by the time he became available again in 2019, most of the charges had already lapsed, there was only one left, and the Swedish court said no, it's been too long, be difficult to have a fair trial, and therefore we're not going to let you proceed with this.

So that's what happened to Sweden. With the US, because most of the charges against Assange are under the Espionage Act, that is regarded as both criminally and politically more serious, and it's unsurprising that once they took the decision to pursue the charges, that walking away from it is much more sensitive. If this appeal is unsuccessful, you've just mentioned there's one avenue left to him, which is an appeal to the European Court of Human Rights. What would that appeal look like?

Well, it would be an application for the European Court to hear his rights claims, and accompanying that would be a request for interim orders to ask the UK not to remove him from their territory until the full case has been heard. That happened recently in respect of the UK when they've been trying to set up an offshore, refugee, Simon Secret processing system, not dissimilar to what's been going on in Australia, but with Rwanda as the place where the offshore processing is taking place. That obviously has been very controversial, and some of the people who were subject to orders to be deported to Rwanda for processing applied to the European Court of Human Rights, and they did get an order saying, no, you can't you can't deport these people until we've heard the whole case. So they won that order, and that was respected by the UK, so I expect the same thing would happen with Assange.

What would be the legal arguments you think of Assange be making if he went to the European Court of Human Rights? Well, they won't be very different from the arguments he's made in the UK courts, which draw in part from the UK Human Rights Act, which incorporates or makes accessible the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights in the UK legal system. So freedom of expression, fair trial, cruel and inhuman treatment in the prison system, abuse of process, that kind of thing, it would be very similar arguments that he's been making since the beginning of the proceedings. Now the Obama administration looked at charging Assange, but chose not to, not out of love for Assange or WikiLeaks, but because it felt a successful conviction would have made much of the work of being a journalist in America illegal.

The Trump administration saw this as a feature of a problem in pursuing Assange. Is this an argument that could be used at the European Court of Human Rights? Is this an attack on the practice of journalism and speech? Yes, that's really the basis of the freedom of expression argument, is that because Assange is essentially being charged as a publisher of sensitive information rather than as the leaker, that this is a direct attack on journalists and anybody who's engaging in the public, you know, the public dissemination of sensitive material as opposed to actively leaking it.

Now, that argument, of course, is available in the US under the First Amendment, but some officials under the Trump administration argued that in this kind of circumstance, in national security situations, people who were not US nationals could not rely on the First Amendment. That's not an issue that's fully resolved, but it is obviously a very worrying development in his potential legal arguments if he winds up in the US legal system. The downside of the freedom of expression argument under the European Convention on Human Rights is we don't have any European Court of Human Rights precedence applying the right to freedom of expression as a bar to extradition. So we are in some extent uncharted legal territory with that argument.

Look, there's been a seismic shift in the political opinions around Assange and Australia. Assange now enjoys support on all sides of parliament and Albanese government has raised the matter several times with the Biden administration. US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken has recently publicly rebuked the Australians request for the charges to be dropped. Have you been surprised at how little impacted the Australian government has had with the US on this matter?

Well, in a way, yes, I think because of the political sensitivity, it becomes very difficult once you've gone down that road to walk it to walk it back. So even though under the Obama administration, not only was Assange not charged, but he commuted Chelsea Manning's sentence and released and pardoned her. So there was a general feeling of let's draw a line under this. But once it's been decided, it then becomes, well, you've decided this is so important for our national security.

Why are you changing your mind? And that becomes a big deal. And it is an election year in the US. So also what you see with things like this, where you have an Australian detained abroad and the government making representations, is it looks like nothing's happening until it's successful.

So you really don't know with these kinds of diplomatic representations, whether there is movement, but not yet enough movement to achieve the desired result. Were you surprised that US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken was so public and he's rebuked? A little bit because these things usually are being discussed at a diplomatic level. It possibly suggests that he was responding not only to repeated questions from journalists, but also responding to conversations that he had with members of the Australian government.

Now, at the end of the day, although Blinken or the president could make a political decision to end for execution, the person who actually has the signed paperwork is US Attorney General Merrick Garland. It's worth remembering that it was mentioned during the debate on the parliamentary resolution on Assange last week that Australian Attorney General Mark Dreyfus has raised the Assange case recently with Merrick Garland. So those conversations are having the actual decision-making. What level of legal support has the Australian government given Assange so far?

Well, he's had consular support throughout, in other words, officials from the Australian High Commission in London have offered him support at various times. Now, for a few years, under the previous government, he declined support from the High Commission, but recently has accepted again. And the current High Commissioner to the UK, Stephen Smith, who was a former Foreign Minister, former Defense Minister of Australia, visited Assange personally early in 2023. So there's been quite a public display of support as well as whatever practical support they have been giving him.

Is there more legally that the Australian government could be doing? I don't know. Assange has a very good legal team with very experienced legal practitioners supporting him. He has had access to consular support.

It's difficult to see what more can be done in terms of support for him in the case, as opposed to the diplomatic representations trying to get the prosecution ended altogether. Assange has won a walkley. He's also on the Sydney Peace Prize. If the matter finds itself in front of the European Court of Human Rights, do you think the Australian government should be more vocal and make more of this issue than they have so far?

Well, it's difficult to say the Australian government, of course, wouldn't have standing to appear before the European Court of Human Rights, it might be able to put in written representations in the same way, say that an NGO like Amnesty International does in some of these cases. I don't know whether that would be more persuasive, it might, to see that. But there's certainly lots of evidence on the public record that the Australian government supports Assange. So I think that that's something.

The question of his standing as a journalist, I'm sure all of that information about the walkley, et cetera, would be put in evidence. I think a lot of it comes down to whether the court could be persuaded that there's a serious risk that he wouldn't be able to rely on the First Amendment in the US, because in exhibition cases, there is a tendency for courts in places like the UK and Europe and Australia to respect the courts of another country, where that's a democratic country with a good rule of law. So I think on the freedom of expression issue, the main difficulty would be persuading the European Court that there will be a serious risk that his freedom of expression rights would not be protected by an American court in this process. If Assange is unsuccessful and finds himself in the US, what kind of jail time is he currently looking at?

Well, the maximum sentence for all the charges he faces comes to 175 years total. Yesterday in the court proceedings, the lawyers for the American government said that they would expect it would be a 30 to 40 years sentence. I don't know what level of remission and possibility of role there would be with that. So it would still be a very substantial sentence, particularly given, we're talking about somebody who is 52 years old, has had many health challenges, even a 30 year sentence, even with remission for good behaviour, is going to be a substantial part of the rest of his life.

And I know that his legal team are basically arguing that it's a death sentence if he's sent to America. But there's also the fact that America could put additional charges on Assange if he's extradited to America, and those extra charges could attract a death penalty. Now, my understanding is that UK normally refuses extra editions where death penalty is in play. Is that being played out in the appeal at the moment?

It I think it has been discussed that there is the fear of other charges. Now, one standard feature of extradition treaties is that you can only, if your state ex requests extradition from state Y, state ex can only charge person with the offences that they have listed in the request for extradition. So if they were to add further charges that involve the death penalty, that would be a violation of the UK US extradition treaty, which would be quite exceptional. If Assange does stand trial in America, he already touched on this, would he would he be able to argue that charges are unconstitutional because of the First Amendment?

I mean, that normally would be something that a journalist in America would be reaching for straight away, wouldn't they? Definitely, definitely. I think that there is, there's definitely a possibility he could argue that. There would be very likely this argument that he cannot invoke the First Amendment because of being a non-national, and this is a national security situation.

I don't think there's clear precedent in US case law on this, so it would be argued probably up to the Supreme Court. There is also concern that some in the legal community in the US have argued that the interpretations of the First Amendment are too protective of journalists in any event, and they would like to get the Supreme Court to be open this issue more generally. So this is a very, very big issue for journalism in the United States, and it is interesting that that was the reason why the Obama administration did not pursue charges, that they felt that that was, to do so would undermine the First Amendment. So there's actually a lot riding on this case, if it does make its way to America.

What have John Lewis and America been talking about this matter? Well, I can't say I have a comprehensive view, but I think that certainly he has a lot of support amongst journalists, even as in the UK, some journalists who maybe had less than good working relationships with him and with Ricky Leaks are far square behind the idea that these charges are a terrible idea. Could Australia request a science being moved to Australia? I mean, this is if he's found guilty in America.

Is there a mechanism for that, or has there been a precedent in that situation? That can always be negotiated between states. In fact, that is one of the points that the US government has raised in their diplomatic assurances about the treatment of Assange in prison, that if he is convicted of these offenses, that they would at least consider allowing him to serve his sentence in Australia. You've been following this matter for a long time.

I've noticed you've written a number of articles in the conversation over the years. What are your feelings about the Julian Assange case? It's a pretty exceptional case about extradition. You do sometimes see extradition matters that get thought all the way to the top court of the jurisdiction.

We've seen some of those in Australia, but this is really exceptional both because of the international implications of it and because of the various delays that have happened. I mean, one of the reasons that the proceedings in the UK have taken as long as they have is the courts were closed for a while because of COVID. What was supposed to be the first stage of the hearing should have been completed by about mid to two thirds of the way through 2020 and in the end, the judgment from the district court was only issued in January 2021. Some of this has been choices that Assange has set himself as made, such as going into the Ecuadorian embassy.

Some of this is circumstances like COVID and some of it is just a really long complex process that is touching on almost every aspect of its tradition. Let's end with the appeal that's happening at the moment. It's meant to be over-vited today. How quickly do you think we'll hear the judgment?

I don't know. I had a quick look at the coverage of yesterday's hearing, which was the US government's arguments and the court has basically said they will give the judgment at a late date. I tend to think that the longer they take to think about this, the more likely it is they'll decide that this should go to a full appeal, but I'm actually wrong on that. I guess we'll know very soon.

Do you have any feelings on how this will play out in the short term? I don't know. My sense is now that these stakes are very high and some of the behavior of some US officials might make some of their earlier assurances a little bit less rock-solid, shall we say? I'm a little bit more confident that he will proceed to a full appeal than I was after the first rejection of a review of the on-secretaries decision to expedite.

It's really very difficult and the usual practice is for courts in countries that have received extradition requests to process them and to defer to the courts in the requesting country, particularly if in democratic countries with establishing rule of law mechanisms. It looks like we had a real fork on the road in which it's been an incredible legal story here and one that obviously cuts to the heart of journalism. We'll be covering this, of course, on Forfustite and Professor Holly Cullin. I'd love to have you back on whether this is going to appeal or whether Julian will end up in America.

For the time being, thank you for being on Forfustite. And pleasure. And thanks for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of TURS-R and heard across the country on the community radio network.

What for stage producers for the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation. Thanks to the foundation for the continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Forfustite on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back for more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter.

Our handle is Forfustite.au and we are also on threads. I'm Anthony Doppel. Thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on February 22, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.