Skip to content
Australian Media Has A Diversity Problem episode artwork

Aug 20, 2020 43 min

Australian Media Has A Diversity Problem

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we are all about the new report from Media Diversity Australia looking at the lack of diversity when it comes to who brings us the news on our TV screens. The report called Who Gets To Tell Australian Stories paints a damning picture of an industry out of step with Australian society. Monica Attard spoke with Sushi Daz and Bakri Mahmoud. You can read the report here: https://www.mediadiversityaustralia.org/research/

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Australian Media Has A Diversity Problem

0:00 43:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gannical Lands of the Ural Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the blog, Vibe Podcast. I'm Monica Atard. On Monday this week, a new report from Media Diversity Australia sent shockwaves around the country, and of course it's newsrooms.

Or maybe I should say, should have sent shockwaves. The report is called Who Gets to Tell Australian Stories, and it paints a danny picture of our newsrooms not just being overwhelmingly white, but in many cases, completely lacking any form of diversity outside the on-European sounding name. We'll get to the details soon, but consider this. When our newsrooms are overwhelmingly Anglo-Saxon and European in makeup, how can I speak for all and to all Australians?

If a pandemic is taught as an elastating lesson, it is that we really are all in this together, but it seems together doesn't extend to Who Gets to Tell the Stories on our TV screens. Before we begin, a declaration from me, I'm a founding member of the Media Diversity Australia Advisory Board, and I am committed to its mission. So to help us grapple with this most important issues, I'm happy to say that we have two Australian journalists with us who will bring their experience, their knowledge, and their diverse backgrounds to this matter. So she does is the Chief of Staff, RNIT ABC Fact Check.

She's also a former opinion editor for The Age. She's the winner of two Melbourne Press Club quill awards, including Best Columnist in 2005, and she's also the author of Deranged and Marriage, a memoir. Buckly-Makwood is a social media producer for the ABC. He's been a media cadet for ABC Life and Reporter at ABC, Far North Queensland.

So the report, Who Gets to Tell Australian Stories, it took a two-week slice from all five of our TV networks and major regional players in June of last year, that is 2019. The results are damning or should be damning for anyone working in or managing in the media industry. In short, when you look at the industry-wide figures of 270 presenters, commentators and reporters during the time sampled, almost 89% were Anglo-Saxon or European in background. And when you start to break this figure down, the picture just gets worse.

Channel 9, for instance, was 97% Anglo-Saxon or European, with 2.9% coming from non-European backgrounds and 0% identifying as Indigenous. To put this number of less than 3% in perspective, the 2016 Census found that 21% of Australians are non-European and 3% identify as Indigenous. And the major regional stations were also just terrible in their lack of diversity. So, so let me start with you.

The report was pretty damning of the media industry, showing it to be hopelessly unrepresentative of the wider community. Were you at all surprised by the findings? No, I'm afraid I wasn't. We have seen this picture before of a lack of representation of diverse voices in the media.

We've, there have been other reports in the past, certainly previously by the then-racist-rimination commission at Tim South. Tom Sand had a report where he looked, where they found that it wasn't just a lack of diversity in media. There's a lack of diversity in politics, in business, in public service, and in the high-ish ones by universities as well. So, I'm afraid this report didn't come as a surprise to me.

No, and back away, what was your response when you heard the news? I had been following media diversity's reports for a while, so it didn't really come as a surprise to me. It was kind of distinct where suddenly there was a lot of attention on it. And so I was like, okay, they must have finally released the report, but you can't absolutely no surprise, I think.

The numbers are visibly clear in any editorial, meeting or newsroom that I've ever been in. So, Buck, you've been working in the media for a couple of years now. First of all, can you skip a little bit of your background? And also, talk to us a little bit about how easy or otherwise it's been for you in the media.

Yeah, absolutely. So, I come from a journalism background, but I also come from a kind of facilitation, conversation, facilitation and creative arts background. So I do a lot of things outside of journalism in terms of content creation. I have been here in the industry for maybe four or four years now.

I think it's been an incredible journey in terms of opportunities and meeting really lovely people, and it has been challenging and easy at times. So, I think the challenges have been more so in the sense of, I think, let me put it to you this way, I don't think there's ever been a white journalist that's been the only white person in the room, where I'm often the only black person in the room. And to me, it's not so much just about colour, but really kind of cultural background and class and kind of connection to a class that you don't really see in the newsroom. So, a lot of the people I'd work with, lovely people, great, well-meaning people, but often kind of come from a similar upper middle class background, and mainly very white neighborhoods and have very similar life experiences, material, best university and all that stuff.

So, they're informed people, but they don't have a kind of lived experience with a lot of everyday Australians. So, I kind of enter these situations often. I know how to do my job, but I don't think like everyone around me. I don't know how to use a rhetoric that exists in different bubbles.

So, I kind of went into the industry thinking the stuff about race and class and education that my friends and I kind of aware of. I went into this thinking, well, I'm going to be working with all these experienced professionals. They would know all this stuff a lot more than me because they would be a lot more educated. And I was really surprised to find that a lot of people just had no idea about this stuff, and they didn't really understand racism and discrimination.

And you kind of mentioned things and thought of it that way, like, I've never come up and that really kind of threw me back. So, it was interesting to hear you say that you would bring up those issues and they would express surprise. Do you think that they took on board your lived experience? Yeah, look, it depends, right?

So, not every kind of department I've worked in has been the same. So, I'm having been particularly in the arts, I've kind of been a lot more understanding because again, a lot of the time with arts, we want cultural diversity because there's a kind of dry up with the same story, so they need newer stories. But in terms of kind of political news, I think what the industry does is that it just kind of listens to itself, so it listens to its trusted fellow journalists who've been writing the same thing for another year, and it kind of goes around in circles. So, when someone like me comes in, he's like, well, there's a whole other take-out, there's a whole other voice that we don't really listen to under response I've gotten.

And then passes like, well, no, that's just identity quality, because it's not, you know, it's people, why do we care, why should we listen to them? It's like, well, these are the people that you're writing about. These are the voices that need to be represented. And where do those conversations end up?

I mean, are your ideas then taken up? Are the people that you're suggesting to be spoken to spoken to or is your experience that generally speaking, what ends up being shown to an audience is what was originally intended? I think sometimes it can be on a superficial level. So it's kind of this thing where like, okay, well, let's just find a brand person to talk to you.

Like, let's find, let's meet the things that we've got to range and where we're being. And it's very clinical. It's not like, let's come to understand this whole new perspective, that challenges the status quo. Like, let's understand the source of it.

And I think sometimes that might be done a bit more, particularly with the public broadcaster, in kind of meeting expectations of what like the audience puts pressure on. So I think the way they push the kind of impartiality situation is like, okay, well, we'll hear from a Muslim woman, but we'll hear from like, you know, a racist white man, because you know, we want to have both perspectives. And so the audience then kind of backs one side and detests another side. And so they just, you know, just clowing like, oh, well, okay, all right, like, you know, we don't want to upset our audience like that.

They pay our funds like we have to go with that. And so it kind of allows the ebb and flow of the quality of journalism to not reflect Australia's actual kind of makeup, just reflect who's kind of being allowed as putting the most pressure up. Yeah, who has the biggest who has allowed us for us, I suppose. And so what about your experiences?

You came from Spain looking for a fresh start. Is that really easy for you in the media? Well, I worked at the age for 22 years. So I've been a journalist for 25 years or thereabouts in Australia.

And I've had various different experiences when I was at the age. And I want to give you some real life examples here, because very easy to talk in general terms about not being taken seriously or whatever. I think it's the examples that speak the loudest. When I was in the age and I was covering stories, I found it sometimes very difficult to sell stories that had, you know, anything to do with that, you know, brown people or black people, okay?

So I covered the dodgy college's stories almost for two years. International students were being ripped off by these colleges. It was a huge money-making machine. The federal government was fully aware of what was going on and actually very slowly to put it right.

But yet I struggled to sell my stories for, you know, particularly for the front page. I thought it was a national scandal. But I really started to sell my stories for the front page. And why do you think that was?

Oh, look, I don't know. I sometimes felt that I just wasn't taken seriously, okay? And I have sometimes I joke that I've got a couple of things working against me. It's not just that I'm brown.

Sometimes I feel like it's being a woman. It also doesn't help, okay? When there was a story, there were a number of stories where dodgy colleges actually closed down. And those, the students who were affected, they were domestic students, okay?

When those stories happened, they made it to the front page. And I found that really frustrating, okay? So that's just one of my experiences that I had. But having said that, when I finally worked in the position of opinion editor, and I did that in an acting role and in a proper role for nearly 10 years, that was the first time that I felt that I could make a change.

And that's because I was in charge of the opinion pages. And I could commission the articles that I thought were important. And I could also bring on a columnist who I thought we ought to have. And how was that received by the internal in the organization and by audience?

It was received well, okay? To be honest, I took on Lali Dali. I took on a whole bunch of female journalists, female columnists as well. And I thought that that was important.

And I'm really happy to say that Lali Dali is still there, right? Yes. A weekly column. And I think it was well received by my colleagues and by readers as well.

And I think that that's the kind of change you can make when you do for Douglas, journalists in leadership positions, and allow them to make decisions and then the organization backs those decisions. You can really make a difference. And I felt that the first time that I could really make a difference was when I became opinion editor. Right.

Right. Okay. So let's look more closely at the report. I mean, the general response to it should be said, I suppose upfront is that it's kind of fallen into two camps.

There are those who acknowledge that there is an issue, that there are problems. And then there are those who are pushing back both seven and nine who are the worst offenders when it comes to diversity have made statements that are kind of ducking and weaving around the issue. So she in 2020 isn't enough to say, look, we're trying the people who are culturally and linguistically diverse. And we're applying for our jobs.

Well, it's interesting that the commercial network, at least one of them that I heard said that there were insufficient numbers of diverse people applying for those jobs. I think the first thing you have to do is take that comment seriously. I think it's too easily dismissed. Okay.

And we have to look at, well, is that the case? I think that there are a number of barriers to entry for people from diverse backgrounds. Okay. Yeah.

Firstly, I think, if I can just quickly run through them, socioeconomic groups, we've got to accept first that large generals do come from middle class backgrounds. And a lot of people who are from migrant backgrounds often come from, you know, families where there are significant economic and social challenges. Okay. So we need to acknowledge that.

Secondly, I think we have to face up to the fact that media in some areas, like newspapers, for example, the tectonic plates are still shifting. Newspapers are becoming smaller rather than bigger. Some of them are even closing down. And you've got to ask whether, you know, are people still interested in working in industries, which are, which appear to be on the decline.

Right. I think also you have to look at, I'm going to use Asian families as an example here. A lot of Asian parents don't think of journalism as a profession for their kids. They often want them to go into medicine or engineering or become lawyers or whatever.

Certainly that's the case with Indian parents. And I think also Chinese parents, they don't always think of journalism as the first choice for their kids. And we have to bear that in mind. I think also that journalism in many ways is a closed network.

I mean, you know, we say, you know, it's not what you know, it's who you know, well, it's both. When your connections provide you with a pathway into an industry, things can be so much easier. And these connections are simply not well established for people from ethnic backgrounds. And the last one I just want to make is that I have an issue with lazy newsrooms as well.

Few newsrooms actively seek out ethnically diverse voices to work in their newsrooms. They dream about it, but they don't actively recruit those people from those backgrounds. They could have quotas if they wanted to, but they don't. I certainly think there are barriers to entry.

Backward, what have you found? Do you recognize there are barriers and if so for somebody like you, what are they? Yeah. So for me, I think the barriers are not only just so much in getting in.

It's once you're in, you kind of have to rain down your voice, the alternative voice to something that's more palatable to the kind of homogenous culture that exists inside newsrooms. I think often journalists tell themselves that like, you know, we don't have, you know, we have a culture of objectivity and inaccuracy and that's kind of all. But reality, you bring any group of people together and they create a kind of culture, a group mentality away of what's normal, what's taboo and what's not. And so when you don't have enough of a range of perspectives and experiences, there's not really going to be anything that's kind of challenging that status quo.

So for me, I've found out to be a barrier. So if you have one black person in an editorial meeting and they speak up, there's not any, there's not three other, you know, Asian or black people that have to be like, yeah, that makes sense. Or I see that it's just kind of like you're the one person and everyone's like, I've never heard of that concept before. So do you think that's causing people of diverse backgrounds who actually make it into industry to not remain there, to feel as though there's not enough in the business for them?

Yeah. I think it makes them feel that they can't be their true selves. They either have to adapt to what is palatable or just kind of, I'll just be sure that a lot of people don't really care about any of this stuff. And so they kind of just go with this, that's what.

And then the ones that often use rooms will kind of uphold and be like, yeah, look, we have this kind of ones that can also diverse. So yeah. And it's beside the point, and then the rest of the people in the room kind of what I'm saying background. So it's not really diversity.

It's just the one kind of token individual. Okay. Okay. So I mean, part of the pushback on the report is the idea that Anglo and European journalists can cover all kinds of stories, even those from outside of their own personal lived experiences.

Is that kind of missing the point that that statement or is it fair enough? So what do you think? No, I mean, I think if you have a newsroom that is full of one type of one group of people, you are in there, you're able to be, you're going to get a sort of homogeneity in viewpoints. And that tends to produce a sort of uncritical consensus.

And that's the issue here. It's not just about having more diverse journalists so that you can reflect the community on which we report. I mean, that's in portrait too. But you just got to be aware that if you don't have those diverse voices, you do end up producing a homogenous viewpoint and this, you know, uncritical consensus.

And that is when that happens, you have done your audience or your readers a disservice. Okay. Because when you have lots of, you know, a lot of diversity in newsrooms, the final news product will tell the widest possible range of stories that best meet the audiences need. And that's what helps to build and expand audience or read a trust.

And that's really important. So no, I think vanilla Germans, if I can put it like that, where it's all coming from one point of view, does the audience a huge disservice? And do you think that that uncritical consensus, which I agree with you, is definitely a thing, but do you think that he's driving some communities away from mainstream media, causing a level of distrust that might be insurmountable at, you know, insurmountable full stop driving them to media sources that speak to them? Yeah, absolutely.

I think there's a distrust in media kind of across the political spectrum. So be it, you know, often angry men who feel kind of constantly attacked by what they proceed to be kind of leftist, feminist media or gummy John Sky or Fox. They turn to YouTube and they find some YouTube artists telling them something that's not necessarily accurate. And so they kind of chew that up and buy that up.

And they tell themselves, well, I'm a bit more informed. I'm getting the truth. And really it's kind of, it's confirmation bias and they're hearing what they want to hear. And these YouTube makers kind of thrive off that.

And so you do have this thing because of that lack of trust people are going to other sources and being misinformed along the way, which would, sorry, which empowers like, yeah, big political agendas via from Russia or Trump or whoever's kind of trying to pet a little bit, probably again, that at a time. Yeah. How critical a problem is this at the moment? Do you think, Sushi?

What, taking on? Yes. Well, I think it's really important. And I think it's not just, it's not just important to take on those type of people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

But it's important that once they're there, they're retained as well. And that the organization fosters a workplace culture that sort of makes those people feel that they can be themselves. You know, when I, I have an incident once where, you know, when I was a reporter, I lent my, you know, the earbuds for the recorder to a colleague who wanted to borrow them. I gave him to him.

A few days later, I went back to him and said, can I get my earbuds bag? And he opened his drawer. He pulled them out. He sniffed them and said, oh, they smell like curry.

They must be yours. Oh, no. You're kidding. No.

No. Now, to me, that kind of experience is, well, it's really quite offensive. And that kind of thing can't, it just cannot happen. It must not happen.

But, you know, I went to a lot of colleagues and I was absolutely gobsmacked. And I said, I really don't know what to do. And in the same newsroom in which that person worked, I found others who said, you must demand the written apology, which I did in the end. And he did apologize.

So, I mean, I'm just giving you that one example of, it's not just that we have to take on people from diverse backgrounds. We've got to make sure that the environment in which they work is inclusive as well. And of course, that comes from the top doesn't. Creating those environments is something that bosses are charged with creating.

And I think by the staggering things about this report as well from Media Diversity Australia was that 100% of news directors are anguosax and male. In senior leadership roles in the news, seven has 0% women. Nine is just 14%. So, behind the camera, it's worse, actually, than what we're actually seeing in our living group.

So, how long do you think we should be? How concerned do you think we should be about the possibility of new newsroom cultures when those sort of statistics start at the very top? We should be very concerned and we need to make a loud noise about it. And I think, you know, I think the ABC has done really well in this area.

I mean, they've actually got a diversity and inclusion plan. And they do have, you know, targets that they've set for, you know, I think they want 15% of content make-up roles and 15% of executive roles. We feel by culturally and linguistically diverse by 2022, I think, is their current target. That's the kind of thing you want.

The BBC has something very similar. And once you put those targets in place, then you've got to measure them. Okay, and you've got to see whether you actually reach those targets and then you've got to report on them as well. And that's the kind of thing we need to encourage those commercial networks to think about.

But that's not going to happen until we start making a loud noise about it. We can't make a loud noise about it every time someone produces a report and then we all forget about it. And then, until the next report comes out. That's true.

Back when do you think the quote has helped? I really do think quite as well. And I know that's kind of controversial because people are well, everything should be based on merit. I think merit is a complicated thing and deceiving because we talk about privileges and opportunities.

I'll just give a try to give a list of examples of the Kedexi program. I was a brand new program that the BBC had introduced and the aim was to bring in young, media savvy people from a diverse range and not culturally diverse but across class. And there's one kid in there who was white but also not from upper middle class. And this room sanctity was a fully-fulfity flipping burger right now.

Now, he's killing it. And literally all of us in that Kedexi program are doing amazing things. Because I think fundamentally when you create opportunities that aren't as organic as like someone, you get the job, you get the appearance back to the whole way, you have more experience. But if you kind of go along the corridor, what happens is you find people that will never thought they would have opportunities before.

And as a result, they're a lot more driven. Sometimes you have to be more patient with them because they need to be more support in some ways. But in other ways, they're a lot more driven and a lot more really willing to step up and bringing fresh new diverse content. And we saw that as a result from us.

We produced some of the freshest content and really kind of audience expanding content with the ABC, which is the purpose of having us there. And I think that is a kind of successful and positive result. And but it's not, you know. And that was well received, was it?

Yeah. A lot of the time it was really well received by audiences. I think at times there's sometimes a situation where certain kind of apartments, when they're brought up to the agency, I kind of worried about losing some of their main audiences. So if you have a story that kind of represents a young, brown person, you might not get your majority middle-aged white women all listening to it, or that's your base audience.

But you're going to get a lot more young people paying attention. And so sometimes they kind of way up and go like, well, like this doesn't get high numbers because it's like, well, because you're trying to get a new audience. You don't have those high numbers of that new audience here. So you have to be willing to accept that and just keep trying and let the audience expand.

But sometimes they see, and I imagine the commercials are the same. It's like, well, no, like our audiences just, they look like, they look like this. And so if we give them something that's completely different to how we usually do, like they're not going to pay attention to us. And I think they just struggle to accept that.

And you're like, sometimes you have to accept that and keep moving forward. Because that's how you're going to have audience scorers. You can't constantly trying to be appeasing your base audience with every single piece that you do. Because there's no development on growth or anything.

Yeah. Certainly there's an argument for challenge there. Now, I wonder what the two of you think of that cartoon that the Australian published last week on Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. I'll start with you, Sushi, if I might on this one.

What was your take on it? And would a diverse newsroom have published that cartoon? And if so, stood by the way the Australian has. Well, it's interesting because, you know, as opinion, to the 10 years, I dealt with a lot of cartoons and cartoonists and had to look at what they threw and make a decision about whether I would put it in the paper or not.

The first thing to say about that particular cartoon is that I just don't think it was a very good one. Before we can talk about race or anything else, it just wasn't a very good cartoon. OK. That's the first thing.

But I think I'm really struggling with these kinds of things because I think that people do jump to this. Oh, it's racist. OK. I looked at that and I thought, is that racist?

Or is it just outrageous or provide outrage? Yeah. The thing with the cartoon and I think where we can see that they were running into trouble was when the editor or whoever it was, tried to justify or explain how that cartoon worked. And the response was that, well, those were Biden's words and we're just sort of a text part as well.

Now, the argument is illogical and actually quite stupid because, yes, of course they're Biden's words, but you've got to think of the context in which he used them and the context in which the cartoonists has now used them. OK. It was not an accurate reflection. It wasn't funny.

It wasn't clever. It was just a daft cartoon. I think that, you know, whenever this kind of issue comes off, I always ask myself, would I, would I have run that cartoon? I don't think I probably would have, simply because it's just not a very good cartoon.

It wasn't funny. It wasn't clever. It wasn't witty. It wasn't smart.

There was nothing in it that I thought was particularly good. I agree. The Australian's defense of the cartoon that it, that leak was mocking Biden, not Harris. Do you buy that?

I do see that point because I would almost, as far as to say that I agree, I, as the Black man, don't trust Joe Biden. I don't think his interest is to actually represent Black people. I think it's interesting to just win as many votes to defeat Trump, which is what politicians do. However, I think the way they did it would have been a lot more tasteful if they had a diversity of people in their room as they're creating these comics.

I refer to it like I've made sketches myself in working comedy rooms. And when we have a writing room of a diverse people, when we're discussing a joke, having people there that challenge us always just makes for a longer conversation, but for more kind of, I guess, informed humor. So I think the point that we're trying to make about Joe Biden is not a completely invalid point, but I think they just did it in a very lazy and tasteless way. Okay.

Now we've touched on this issue a little bit before you brought it up. So she met the pathways in to media and journalism specifically. I'll just kind of like to thrash that out a little bit more from that. Because if you graduate from one of the major universities, found an internship at nine of the ABC, for example, chances are that your particular background is actually middle class.

Yeah, quite possibly white. Now, that's not a judgment. It's just a fact. How do we open up the media?

So it's not just more, so it's more open to culturally and linguistically diverse people. And also open to people from all sides of the economic divide. How do we do that? Because it's hard, right?

Yeah, it is hard. I think firstly, look, I think that journalism schools have a responsibility here, where they have to make sure that when they interview the students who apply to them to do courses that they have some sort of focus or attention being paid to whether the J schools are filling their classrooms up with white middle class students. So they need to be aware of that kind of stuff. And the J schools are the ones that...

So can I just stop you there? Are you suggesting that universities, for example, should put a quota on the number of white middle class students studying journalism? Look, I think quotas, as we were saying, only quotas are problematic, because first thing is that, you know, the argument is, oh, look, it's got to be based on merit. Yes, I agree with that.

Of course it does. But if you just... I'm just talking about quotas, not universities, but in the workplace at the moment. If you have an insufficiently diverse newsroom, it means that there aren't any panelists with merit at this stage, all right?

And I would say that the lack of quotas is a system that hasn't worked thus far, has it? We don't have quotas at the moment, and look what we've got. I think that journalism schools, before I sort of say hard and fast, yes, they should be quotas, perhaps it would be appropriate to simply say that they need to be attentive to this, okay? And if they aren't at the moment, they should be.

I know RMIT certainly is, but the J schools need to bring in those students. Now, the other thing I do, and I do this outside my normal work, I actually do go to schools and I've offered up, you know, when they talk about some careers and young people choosing what careers they want to be, they make those decisions when they're in year nine, year ten, or whenever it might be. And I have gone to schools and said, would you like me to come and talk about the career of journalism? And I use that opportunity to tell students, look, you can be a journalist, you know, if you come from a Chinese background or background, Indian background, whatever, that's my personal attempt at putting this thing right.

But I think the journalism schools are important, and also let's not forget, journalism schools are really important when it comes to finding internships for journalists. Yes, and I was about to get to that point, because I mean, as a journalism educator, I think one of the biggest problems that I see is that people who are from a diverse background and who tend to come from a lower socioeconomic background as well, are finding it very, very difficult to do the internships that are required, if you really want to work as a journalist and get a foot in the door as a young graduate. So the issue of paid versus unpaid internships becomes a very, very live one. But do you, was that your experience?

Do you see the lack of paid internships, paid opportunities to get your foot in the door as one of the major contributing factors for the porosity of people of diverse backgrounds in our newsrooms? Yeah, absolutely. I think in terms of being able to build experience and kind of get hours under your belt, it's a lot harder if you have to also sustain yourself while studying to then just be working for free. And so some people are going to have the opportunity to be supported by their parents while they take on an internship.

Very fortunate, look, for me, I towards the end of my degree, I was doing a paid internship and I'm really grateful for that because I don't think, I don't know where I would have been if it wasn't for that, because that allowed me the first time in my life to focus on my studies and work in something that developed my career and insight and also allowed me to sustain myself. And when I got to that point, I was like, okay, I really believe I can make it now. But before that, it was a constant kind of sense of uncertainty and people don't have that kind of familial support and backing and you're constantly hearing how the industry lacks people that look like you. There's a lot there to tell you.

Okay, look, we're running out of time rapidly, but can I just end on this question to you about how hopeful are you and in what timeframe would you expect to see some change in the makeup of our newsrooms? I think that's really dependent on how quickly we change the leadership inside newsrooms. So I think we're constantly going to have a kind of more cultural and diverse and gender diverse people graduating and wanting to become journalists, but unless you kind of change up who the editors are and who the kind of chiefs of staffs are, the process of change is going to be really slow. So if we do change the editing, I see things being much better in the next five or so years, but if we don't, which I don't think we will, I don't see it becoming much better, you'll probably take decades.

Okay, so you're pretty pessimistic. What about you, Sushi, what do you think? Look, when I always want to be a journalist all my life, I never want to do anything else. I had to first battle my parents who didn't want me to be a journalist.

I had to go through an unpaid internship. I had to go through the selection process to get onto a newspaper. And then once I was in, I had to battle the newsroom itself, if you like. Okay.

I think my feeling is that Australia is a bit of a backwater when it comes to culturally diverse newsrooms. I think other countries, particularly the US and the UK, I do it better than us. And but I think we are seeing increasing focus on the issue. And I'm really heartened by the ABCs diversity and inclusion plan, whether other commercial networks will take up something similar is difficult.

But I think government, if you just have the right noises made at higher levels, that will help. I'm a little bit like I think the time frame is slow. It's been slow thus far, and there's absolutely no indication that it's going to get hit you fast or anytime soon. So I wish I didn't say have to say that, but I'm afraid I don't think that the momentum, the momentum is not there yet.

But hopefully, hopefully it will be there before my own daughter, she wants to become a journalist. I hope she didn't have to face some of those things I've had to face. Yes indeed. Well, I think we'll leave it there.

Thank you both very, very much for joining me today. It's been really enlightening. I hope that you're both wrong on that timeline for resolution, but fingers crossed, and I think a lot of hard work. So let's roll our sleeves up and try to get it done.

But thank you both very, very much for joining Fourth Estate today. Thanks. On that note, I'd like to thank you both, so she does and Bucking-up Wood for your time today. It was a great discussion.

And if you'd like the report who gets to tell Australian stories, just go to the Media Diversity Australia website. And thanks for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country of the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation.

So thanks to them for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and of course everything in between. We'll be back with more next week. By the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter, our hand with their youth Fourth Estate are you.

Thanks as always to my producer Anthony Dotwell. My name's Monica Atard, and thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 43 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on August 20, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.