Skip to content
Australian Media Still Has A Diversity Problem episode artwork

Dec 5, 2022 41 min

Australian Media Still Has A Diversity Problem

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we look at the latest report from Media Diversity Australia titled Who gets to tell Australian stories 2.0. We looked at the first report back in 2020 and since then the story has not changed very much at all. To help us unpack the latest report but also look at the road ahead we spoke with Dr Lee Martin and Sushi Das.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Australian Media Still Has A Diversity Problem

0:00 41:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to For For State, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from Touristia in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Euro Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to the Vice Across the Globe by a podcast. I'm Anthony Dockrell. We often hear that Australia is the most successful multicultural country in the world, but turn on your TV at night and watch the news and you might be forgiven for thinking Australia was not a very diverse place at all.

While all facets of our society have become more diverse, our media, like much of our politics, has been stubbornly holding back. Today we have a look at the latest new report titled Who Gets to Tell Australian Stories 2.0. To help us unpack the report, we're lucky to be joined by Sushi Dazz, Chief of Staff at RMIT ABC Fat Check and Dr Lee Martin, Senior Lecturer at the University of Sydney and Co-author of the Media Diversity Australia report. Well, let's jump in.

Lee, let me start with you. Do you think the media today is closer to representing the Australia of today? No, unfortunately, and disappointingly. No, it's no closer than when the first report came out in 2020.

So this recent report just released, we had been hoping to see an improvement, but actually, while there are some pockets of improvement, the overall picture is really no more positive than two years ago, which is surprising in a way and disappointing. Look, the media diversity Australia report has found some stark findings about the representation of cultural diversity of Australian TV journalism. What did you find? And how does it compare between a commercial networks and the public broadcaster?

Well, the short answer to our finding was that basically what we're seeing in front of the cameras is not reflecting the makeup of Australian society more broadly. And also, we looked at behind the cameras, so who is in the boardrooms and who are our editorial leaders, and they're also not reflective of the cultural composition of the Australian population. So the Australian population is more diverse than ever, so we've used the latest census figures and found that it's even more diverse than when we did the first report, but that is not being reflected in front of or behind the camera. And we also looked at in our report, we looked at the perceptions of diversity and barriers for culturally diverse and Indigenous peoples in the media industry, and the perceptions are also not that great, either, in terms of improvements on the first report.

There's perceptions of greater barriers for Indigenous people and culturally diverse people, people with culturally diverse backgrounds. We looked at perceptions of audiences in terms of whether they think that cultural diversity and Indigenousity could be better represented on Australian TV screens in news and current affairs programs. And we also looked at perceptions of newsroom staff and editorial leaders in terms of things like the career progression, barriers to career progression for culturally diverse staff and Indigenous staff. And these are areas where there's a lot of room for improvements still.

So, Shihi, from your position, have you seen any improvements since the last time you on the floor? Was that chatting about this very issue? Well, I can only go on what I see on TV and what I read in newspapers in terms of looking at it from a consumer's point of view. It seems to me that I can see different types of faces on the ABC news.

SBS is always reliable for that kind of stuff, obviously, but there has been a change on the ABC, I think. But it's not just about the kinds of reporters who are in front of the camera. It's also about people who make decisions in the newsroom. It's also about people who are in leadership positions in those news organisations.

So, yes, I have seen a lot more diversity in front of the camera from the ABC. I don't know what the picture is higher up the ladder, if you see what I mean, because I think that's really where you want to start seeing some concrete changes. Okay, well, before we dive deeper into some of those things you just touched on, what have been some of the improvements that you've seen since the last report? Some of the improvements have been in Indigenous representation in terms of the frequency of appearance on TV, though not so much in terms of the number of presenters and reporters.

So what I'm saying is basically that we are seeing more frequently Indigenous representation, but that is often due to just the addition of a single talent at a network. So they don't have a lot of heavy lifting, really. A lot of it is down to one person or a very small number of people, rather than taking on a lot more Indigenous presenters and reporters. But that is nevertheless progress in terms of the number of appearances at least, we're seeing progress in terms of Indigenous appearances.

Where else have we seen improvement? I mean, that is the main area, I would say, that's really stood out in this report compared to the first report. One thing that did stand out as an improvement, and really it couldn't have got much worse, the boards do seem to be a bit more diverse than in 2019. Is it fair to say that?

There is some progress in terms of the boards. I would say in terms of cultural diversity, there's still lots of be desired on some of the networks. SBS was the only network that actually did have representation across all four cultural categories that we looked at. So Anglo-Celtic, European, non-European and Indigenous.

And the rest of the boards, I mean, the rest of the networks had boards which had some cultural diversity, but still a number of the boards didn't have any Indigenous representation on their boards or any non-European representation. Okay, well look, I think we've touched on some of the things that have improved since the first report, but at the same time, as you've foreshadowed, it's been a fairly disappointing result and Channel 7's board and it's only a talent has not moved at all since the last report. Were you surprised at large sections of the media haven't moved at all? I was surprised in a way, but also not so surprised because I think that when you turn on the TV, you can still see how white it is.

You can really see the lack of cultural diversity on TV. And so from that perspective, I wasn't surprised. But there has been some improvement as Sushi pointed out on ABC. I do feel like when I turn on the TV that the ABC is showing more cultural diversity.

So there are some areas of improvement. So it was surprising in one way that there wasn't, they didn't appear to be more of an improvement based on the fact that the networks would have known that this second report was coming. So this has the same parameters as the first report. They knew that we were doing this report card update.

And from that perspective, I'm a bit surprised that it appears that more effort wasn't put into making sure that they scored better on this report card compared to the first one. Look, the report includes a new focus on regional newsrooms. How are the regions looking? The regions are looking very Anglo-Celtic.

So yes, it's actually, in terms of diversity, they're not culturally diverse. And there's a lack of Indigenous representation in the regional newsrooms. But what was interesting about this part of the report for this time, which was a new area that we looked at compared to the first report, was that we did interviews with editorial leaders. So we could actually dig a bit deeper into what their perceptions are and their practices in hiring and that sort of thing.

And what was interesting was that there was, in general, an awareness of the importance of injecting more cultural diversity and indigeneity into their newsrooms so that they could present stories from these other perspectives. But, and there was an awareness of that changes needed, that action needs to be taken. But in terms of whether they felt that they could implement it themselves, these editorial leaders, that was a different question. So even though they wanted to take some action, they felt quite time constrained and they recognized that this might lead them to lean on their own biases a bit too much in terms of trying to just choose the easy option.

And someone who looks similar to them has similar background and experience to them is someone that they think that they will fit in and easily learn the ropes. And that can be sometimes what guides their decision in terms of who to hire. So I think it was interesting and encouraging that there was that level of awareness and evaluating of what cultural diversity can bring to their newsrooms. But also, it's somewhat disappointing that there is such a lack of cultural diversity and indigeneity representation in regional newsrooms because that's what feeds into the metropolitan newsrooms.

So really, the pipeline is not looking good right from the start. Well, that's a really interesting point there about the pipeline. And the pipeline, yes, I mean, in the metro areas, quite often they are finding and sourcing a talent from the regions. But it's also probably fair to say that the regions are sourcing their talent from the universities.

What are we seeing at the university level? This is not something that we especially looked at in the report, but this did come through a bit in terms of the interviews with editorial leaders in the regional newsrooms. And they were saying that one challenge for them was the lack of applicants from culturally diverse and indigenous backgrounds applying for positions. And so that does partly come back to who is actually studying journalism in universities.

And is that sort of the very start of the pipeline? And that could be where the problem stems from, or at least partly stems from. So one of the suggestions that they had was to actually engage more with high school students so that people can see themselves in this career, see this as a viable option to study. And also, I think it's important to highlight role models as well.

So even though there are not that many culturally diverse and indigenous presenters and reporters, there are some. And it would be good to really highlight those so that people can really see themselves as that this is a career option for them because they see people like themselves succeeding in this industry. Well, Sushi, you're working at RMITa. Do you see that there is an issue with the lack of diversity in the student pool?

Well, I think it's a bit of a mixed picture. I know that RMITa has made big efforts to make sure that the journalism school takes on students from all sorts of different backgrounds. And I think you're rightly, a lot of students, it starts really early, you've got to get in there at the high school level. But I think there are quite a few barriers to entry.

Just talking about Asian families for a moment, I'm from an Indian background, and Indians and Chinese make up a fair amount of the Australian population. And I think that Asian students don't necessarily get encouragement at home to get into journalism. Indian parents often focus on medicine, engineering as a career area for their kids. And Chinese parents don't always think of journalism as their first choice for their kids.

So I think it really, if you want to go right back, we're talking about that family environment where journalism is not the kind of profession that's elevated in those communities. But there are other barriers to entry, for example, I think being poor, for example, people from Michael Bracko's often face significant economic and social challenges. And I'm not sure that journalism is where they're thinking. Well, yeah, I mean, look, we're talking about how unfortunately our media is incredibly wide, but it's also incredibly middle class.

Yeah, that's right. It is. And university is, you know, you've got to be able to afford to go to university as well, before you can even think about what kind of career you're going into. I mean, I think on top of that, you know, you have to do, I would say that journalism is a bit of a closed sort of network.

So unless, you know, if you do come from a poor background, or if you do come from say an Asian background, if you don't already know people in the journalism industry, it's just all that much harder to get in. I mean, when I first started in journalism, you know, 500 BC or whenever it was, there were no brown people that I could see in the newsroom at the age. I was there for 22 years. I think there was one other brown journalist for most of the time that I was there.

And how big was the newsroom? We're doing hundreds of journals, okay. But I think so, and this I think does come a little bit down to lazy newsrooms. How many newsrooms actually have got a program in place, a proper structure to try and get diversity in their newsrooms?

And I think, you know, until you start seeing people in newsrooms making those kinds of decisions, you're not going to get any change, you know, because change doesn't just happen all by itself. Yeah, I think that these are really great points that you raised about. Well, I think the thing about networks and also, you know, generally being middle class, these are the people that you see in working in newsrooms with a university education. This is actually something else which came through the editorial leaders in the regional newsrooms that we interviewed picked up on.

And they said that, you know, one of the ways that we could try to get more cultural diversity and indigeneity into the newsroom in regional newsrooms would be to actually have targeted cadetships or traineeships where, you know, it doesn't rely on having a university degree to get in. So I think that definitely that's recognized as an issue that's contributing to this problem, this sort of quite homogenous workforce that we have entering into regional newsrooms. And also the networks, that's also an interesting point because one of the things that one of the comments that came up during the interviews was that sometimes people from culturally diverse backgrounds, I guess those who perhaps haven't been educated in Australia may not put together an application in the same way as someone from an Australian background would, Australian educated background which. And so one of the newsroom editorial leaders said, you know, that for people in their network, they would actually sit down and help them to craft an application that, you know, has a greater chance of success.

And so it's really important to have those networks. And that is something that could be lacking for people from certain cultural backgrounds or indigenous backgrounds. And so something that is really important to try to cultivate, I think, is that network for before they come in, but also when they join to have an industry wide network of people from culturally diverse backgrounds and indigenous backgrounds, so they have that support system and more likely to succeed and feel included and feel like they belong in the industry. So I do think that those are great points that you've raised sushi.

And also in terms of the cultural factors like parents, not particularly wanting to push their kids into this industry as a career because of cultural factors perhaps. And I think that is true. That is something that I've heard anecdotally. And I've also conducted research with Chinese Australian multicultural individuals about their career choices.

And this is also something which has come through in that research, which is separate to this report. But also, I think that the more they see people like them on screen, the more those attitudes and perceptions can start to change. And this can become a possible career option for people of different backgrounds, although there will always be that cultural factor. But people are changing, the generations are changing in terms of how much they accept their parents' influence over these sorts of matters.

So even though there's, I think, always going to be that element of different cultures valuing different types of occupations and perhaps media industry not falling into one of those categories. But I think that there are cultural shifts too. So yeah, I think there's still hope. Let's turn to trust.

Lee, the report found that a higher proportion of respondents with a non-European background had stopped using new sources because they thought it was biased. Did you find out why? Well, this is the first step of exploring this this aspect, I suppose, about trust and how people from different cultural backgrounds trust the media. So no, we didn't delve into why exactly.

We just we asked this survey question. And I guess this would be a really interesting thing to explore further in future research. So, should you think it's a lack of representation while it's at a high level of distrust? Quite possibly.

I think that if a country is increasingly ethnically diverse and news organizations don't reflect this in their coverage or the people they hire, then they will inevitably lose audience share. And that's the fastest way to irrelevance and death, if you ask me. I often don't understand why newsrooms are so slow to take on people from diverse communities. Because I mean, that's the truth, isn't it?

If you can't see yourself on TV or hear yourself on the radio or people like you, then why would you listen? Don't you want to be made to feel that you're a valued member of that society? I think journalists need a deep knowledge of the nation's communities and constituents, particularly during election campaigns as well. And I think it's really important that we build these ethnically diverse newsrooms.

Not we can't just dismiss it as tokenism or political correctness. It's about good journalism as well. And the point that I really want to make is that diverse newsrooms, I think, help to ensure that the final news product will tell the widest possible range of stories that best meet the audience's needs. And when you do that, you build trust.

Diversity of viewpoints is extremely important. We're in this age of really profound political polarization, right? And publishing stories that reflect this wide range of beliefs, experiences, viewpoints, and all the rest of it. I think that that could help expand reader trust.

And I think also that a homogeneity in viewpoints produces a sort of uncritical consensus and in this environment, journalists who have little or no diversity in their newsrooms collectively become sort of blind to evidence that might counter their own preconceptions. So you end up sort of looking through this lens of vanilla journalism, if you don't have diversity. And having a diverse newsroom, I would argue, it's good for journalists from diverse backgrounds because they can bring their insights to journalism. It's good for news organizations to protect and expand their audience share and build trust.

It's good for the public who we serve because we can give them a fresh perspective. And it's good for journalists from European backgrounds because it educates them to be in an environment where ethnically diverse journalists work. So we can all learn from each other. I mean, I can only see good things from having diverse newsrooms.

And so I don't understand why newsrooms are so slow to get on to this. Let's turn the clock back a little bit. In the 1970s, the Fraser government introduced SBS. It also helped drive community radio, which is major part of the diversity in Australia media for over 40 years.

However, I wonder if how you both think about the idea that we both we're all still trapped in this 1970s ethnic model of diversity. One that caters for diverse Australia, but it partitions away. And the major mainstream players don't need to worry about it. Lee, do you see structural issues here?

Like the fact that we in some respects, Australia was very much at the forefront of multiculturalism and to these amazing initiatives. But maybe they have also trapped us in this kind of silo model of how we view the media. Yeah, I think that's a very perceptive comment. And I think it's actually very telling how some of the networks reacted to our report, which sort of does reflect this siloed view.

SBS came out and said, why did you not count SBS Arabic and SBS Mandarin in your report? And it's almost as if they feel like they've covered the cultural diversity bit there and don't need to worry about it as much in the main SBS programs. And they're not the mainstream programs. Those other programs that they talk about in terms of being in other languages.

So same with Indigeneity. So SBS actually scored quite low on Indigeneity, Indigenous representation. But they have NITV, which is part of SBS. But if you look at SBS itself, Indigenous representation on SBS is actually very low in terms of who we see on our screens.

So I do think that it seems like there's not so much an effort to increase cultural diversity and Indigenous representation across the board. But it's more like we can do well here, and that can make up for our lack of progress in this area instead. And I think a lot of the responses to our report from the TV networks had that sort of flavour to it. So why didn't you look over here?

Because we're doing better over here. But actually, you know, you need to be doing better across the board. And it's kind of weird that they do not understand that they're not reflecting Australia back to Australians. Yeah, it's just the responses are quite bizarre to me because I don't think that anyone who watches Australian CV could argue that there isn't a lack of cultural diversity.

Because it's just, it's very obvious to me. And I think it should be obvious to anyone who watches Australian TV. So news and current affairs programmes I'm talking about, although the problem is also broader than that. But I'll report looked at news and current affairs.

Okay, I guess we've come to a point where these problems are very deep-seated and we're not improving and not improving fast enough. There are some approaches we can do. I might mention that all for word quote as soon. But I want to touch on the UK.

The UK does provide a way forward for Australia. What are they doing better? Well, the UK actually tracks its cultural diversity, not just cultural diversity, but other diversity aspects. So they actually have a communications regulator of comp, which has been collecting data of the cultural background of people employed in TV for the past five years and also in radio for the past four years.

And so they're able to compare in terms of their journalists and their on-screen talent, what proportions do they have who are in minority ethnic groups versus white ethnic groups. And so that's really useful to have this industry-wide data collection. And that's something that we don't have in Australia. So apart from this report card that we've produced, there's no other industry-wide effort to do a similar sort of auditing of the cultural diversity and indigeneity.

And another thing to point out is that some of the networks came out and said, well, we do have diversity within other ranks of our organisation. So we have looked at the senior leaders of newsrooms and we looked at who's in front of the screen, but they're saying, well, behind the scenes at other levels we have good cultural diversity. And in that case, if they're collecting that data, then release it. Let us know what is going on in various levels of the organisation.

So we don't know, we really don't have much of an idea of the cultural composition within media organisations because that data is not made publicly available in Australia. So I think that the fact that the UK have actually, this work has been done by the Communications Regulator that shows a real government commitment to holding media organisations accountable for the diversity that they have within them. So do you see something happening in the UK that isn't happening here? Look, I don't know the answer to that question, but I do know that migrants in Britain have been there since the 1950s and 60s.

We're looking at people in the second generation, third generation, and a lot of confidence among those communities as well to push for change. Whether that's happening here, I really can't say, I can only talk about my own personal experience, and that is when I came here first back in early 90s, I really felt there weren't many people my colour around, certainly not in newsrooms anyway. And it really was, it wasn't easy, trying to get into this space. So I understand how difficult it is for people if they want to get into journalism and they're not the uniform, white background.

I think things have changed in Australia, but they're just really slow. That's the problem. The pace of change is really slow, and I don't understand why that is. But I mean, I remain optimistic.

I can sit myself very lucky. I've held some senior positions at the age and now at the MIT Fact Lab and MIT ABC Fact Check as well. And I hope that on a real world level, there are young journalists from diverse backgrounds who can see that there are some role models here now that they can, and we stand ready to support them and help them get ahead. Why it's happened in the UK faster than it happened here, I can't really say, but I think the UK gives us a really good example of what it can look like if we can just all get on with it.

But it does require a commitment. It really does. And it does require us to see people from diverse communities as equal to us in their talents and the skills that they bring. And just to give you an example, when I first started at the age, I remember going to a press conference where I was greeted by an MP.

The only other brown journalist on our paper at the time was a wonderful woman called Farah Farooq. And I remember arriving at this press conference, and the MP puts hand out, and he said, ah, hello, Farah. And I said, no, I'm Sushi Das. Farah is the other brown one.

And I really, I was angry in that moment. But sometimes I think about that incident because it stays with me. And I just feel, you just get this feeling that sometimes people just put all brown people into the same bracket and sort of can't see that we're individuals who bring our own experiences and different skills to the job. And I think that's what we really need to break down and just see that people come in all sorts of chetron forms.

And we've all got something to contribute if you only just, you know, if only the door was left slightly jar for them to get through. Okay. Well, let's end by discussing what Australian media companies need to start doing. What do they need to do, Lee?

What can they start doing? Well, I think that a good step would, the first step would be to read the report that we have produced and read it with an open mind. And with a view to the scene where they can make improvements in their own organization. And it's really important that it's the leaders of these organizations that take our recommendations to heart and really start valuing cultural diversity, just as Sushi has said.

And I'm not saying that they don't at the moment, but I think that the initial responses to our report has been a bit disappointing and hopefully it's not indicative of how they, you know, how they react when concerns are brought up, say, by their own staff members about cultural diversity. So we've, you know, we've pointed out areas that need improvement and we've pointed out, you know, steps that can be taken to try to combat those issues. And we hope that they can really be a bit introspective and try to take some genuine actions on that. And so we've, you know, we've laid out various strategies in the report on what they could do.

But I think that an important point is that it needs to be about diversity, equity and inclusion. So all of these things go together. And it's not just about increasing the diversity, which is important. And that's about, you know, trying to reach out to, you know, advertise jobs in places where culturally diverse and Indigenous readers would actually see those job advertisements and want to apply.

So things like that is actually trying to improve the diversity in applicants, but also it's about making sure that that they see these organisations as inclusive places to work that they feel included once they join. So it's about the culture of the organisation, which really comes from the top and also about equity. So can they actually progress their careers? Can they rise up to those leadership positions?

And the findings from our report is that, you know, the perception is that that's not there, that's not the case at the moment. So, yeah, so leaders really just have to be careful about what messages they're sending out by their actions, including things like, you know, their response to this report. What message are they sending to their staff and to people who are looking to join their organisation, people from culturally diverse backgrounds and Indigenous backgrounds, by how, you know, by the response they're taking to this report. And are they looking towards the future and what they can do better?

Or are they trying to instead trying to justify why they've already done a lot and, you know, try to deflect attention from those areas of concern and just try to say what they've been doing that is good enough already, you know? Yeah, I just want to say, if there are any newsroom leaders out there who want to have a diverse newsroom, but somehow don't know what to do or how to do it, I reckon there are four things, four things that they can do. One, announce that you've made a commitment to having a diverse newsroom. Two, set up some realistic quotas.

Three, set out timeline for when you wish to achieve this by, and then lastly, say how you're going to measure your improvement. Those four things are the first four things I think any newsroom leader needs to do is they want to change how things are at the moment. Look, on that note, I'd like to thank you both for being on For For State. Thank you.

Thank you very much. I really appreciate the chance to discuss these issues. I think it's really important that we keep the conversations going on there. So thank you for the chance to talk about a report findings and Sushi, thank you so much for your insights, which I found really interesting too.

Thank you both. On that note, I'd like to thank Sushi Daz and Dr Lee Martin for being on For For State, and thanks for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of TIRIS-R and heard across the country on the community radio network. For For State is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation.

Thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to For For State on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is For For State.au.

Thanks to my producer, Marlene Even. I'm Anthony Dockrell. Thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on December 5, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.