Skip to content
Balancing Stakeholders Featuring Jim Heffelfinger | Episode 292 episode artwork

Aug 6, 2026 1 hr 34 min

Balancing Stakeholders Featuring Jim Heffelfinger | Episode 292

from Hunt Talk Radio Hosted by Randy Newberg

In this episode of Leupold's Hunt Talk Radio, Randy sits down with wildlife scientist Jim Heffelfinger to discuss the complex factors impacting mule deer populations across North America. They cover significant conservation challenges, such as landscape-scale habitat changes, the impacts of human population growth, and the difficulties of managing herds amid changing environmental conditions. They look at how difficult it can be to balance scientific management with social and political pressures that often influence wildlife policy.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Balancing Stakeholders Featuring Jim Heffelfinger | Episode 292

0:00 1:34:52
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The title sponsor of Hunt Talk Radio is Leupold. Leupold Optics are the trusted optics of accomplished hunters and shooters. If it has a gold ring on it, you know it was built by American Hands in Beaverton, Oregon. Whether it's a new rifle scope, binocular, a spotter, rangefinder, or eyewear, go to leupold.com to learn more and look for these fine Leupold products at your high-quality retailers. At exactly 11.14 p.m., Kelsey DeMarco was not walking to buy chips and pop to power an all-nighter before her exam, so she did not break off the heel of her left boot, and she did not then stumble into trash bins full of raccoons.

only to be spotted by her ex-boyfriend Jean-Francois. Instead, Kelsey skipped it, and with the Skip app, had her chips and pop delivered, allowing her to study and totally rock her midterm. Smart move, Kels. Skip to the good part. Hey folks, Randy Newberg here. Welcome to Leupold Hunt Talk Radio.

Hey folks, Randy Newberg here. Welcome to another episode of Leopold's Hunt Talk Radio. Today I lucked out. One of my good buddies, Jim Heffelfinger from Tucson, Arizona is in town. And Marcus had him most of the day interviewing him about mule deer. And I said, Jim, been a while since you've been on the podcast. I got a lot of questions I'd like to share with the audience that I've been asking you over the last couple of years. And if you know of Jim, if you follow him, if you read his stuff, he's just an unbelievably smart guy.

prolific writer, shares so much information, and I don't know how he finds time to do everything, to be quite honest with you. But he was up here in Montana, and if I get a chance to have Jim Heffelfinger on my podcast, I'm going to go back through all my old emails I sent him in the last year, and I'm going to write them down, which I've got a sheet full of it here, and share those questions with all of you, because I pick his brain a lot, and I'm very indebted to Jim Heffelfinger, and there's a few others like him who, why they put up with all my questions and all my ignorance, I'm not sure. But I'm really, really thankful that they do. So anyhow, I hope you'll stick around. Jim, you know, passionate hunter, in addition to being a scientist and a researcher. And I mean, he's got all kinds of titles and he leads the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agency's Mildear Working Group. And he's the coordinator. He's like the guy who coordinates so many things with them. And he's just...

such a valuable source. You know, mule deer are having a lot of challenges and that's a lot of the questions I want to ask you. Am I related to that? And he's one of the guys who's helping anyone who has research going on about mule deer gyms probably in some way, shape or form trying to help them out. So anyhow, appreciate y'all being here. Hope you're having a great summer and stick around for an hour or so and Jim and I will solve all the world's problems as it relates to mule deer and the importance of science. And maybe we'll get into some of the stuff about how we can trust science or maybe there's times we shouldn't trust science. So anyhow.

Here we go. Jim Heffelfinger, how are you doing, man? You came up here to cool off in Montana? I did. People were complaining about how hot it was the first afternoon I was here because it was like 77. It came from 105, so it felt pretty good for me. Yeah, compared to 27. I had my nuts packed away for the winter, but for the summer. You brought it up. Pull it out. Oh, man. Well, thanks for coming up this way. Yeah, appreciate you having me. Oh, yeah. Yeah, you and Marcus solved all the world's problems earlier today. We did a lot of good stuff. I'm pretty sure that by the time Marcus is done with his mule deer series this fall, probably double or triple the number of mule deer on the planet. Yeah, but seriously, looking at the topics, like the outline that he puts together. Yeah.

Really well informed. And he really put together a package. And he asked if I could add anything. I said, I could send that probably to the Western North American leading mule deer people in my mule deer working group. I don't think there's anything to add. I mean, he did a good job. Well, that's where we really benefit from the fact that Marcus has his undergrad in wildlife and then a master's in film. So you're going to have to get up pretty early if you're going to pull one over on him. But anyhow, you are here. Your real daily work. You work for Arizona Game and Fish. What are you? I'm a wildlife science coordinator. Science coordinator. And that's just to make sure that the...

policies we make and the decisions we make are well grounded in a good foundation of science. And so I'm kind of a science guy. I enjoy that. Yeah. And then with the Western, is it the Western Association or the American? No, the Western. Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies. We call that WAFWA. Those of us who talk in acronyms. Yeah. You lead the Mule Deer Working Group. Yep. Correct. The last 20 years. 20 years you've been doing that? Yeah. The directors in the 90s put together the Mule Deer Working Group in 97. At a meeting in 97, we met the first time in 98 in Jackson. And I was the Arizona rep and the...

chair of the committee about eight years later, retired, and they passed the torch to me. So I've been leading the group for 20 years. Wow. Well, thanks for doing it. Yeah. It's been amazing to be in amongst some of the best mule deer people in the West and having those conversations. Well, if anybody wants to get an inside view of what the mule deer world is like, they need to be on Jim Heffelfinger's email list. Because I just got one from you, I think on Monday, was it? Yeah. Yeah. Whatever. And the amount of stuff that you put in there, do you sleep much? No, I don't sleep much. I told my doctor, I only need six hours. And he said, well.

Jim, do you want to talk about the science behind that? No, I want to talk about the science behind that. Yeah, but the Mulder Working Group, we've got a website that's just MulderWorkingGroup.com, and Mulder Working Group is just all one word. We've got tons of products that we've produced over the years on Mulder Conservation Management. Products, in other words, studies. Publications, yeah. Mostly, they're all PDFs that you can download. They're all free. And a lot of what we do is pull together the science behind a particular issue and put it in an easily digestible, kind of easy-to-read format. So make all that available to people. Yeah, so I know you and Mark have spent a lot of time going through this stuff, so I apologize if I ask some of the...

same top bring up some of the same topics at a more elementary level because i don't have marcus's well most of what we did this morning probably end up on the cutting room floor so it wouldn't hurt you know our friends over at meat eater they've almost made you into a quasi star i hear my name quite a bit yeah i do it's kind of embarrassing sometimes yeah and sometimes i'll be mowing the lawn and i'll hear my name and the earbuds and like yeah and did they ever tell you how they got a hold of you I don't think so. Oh, Giannis called me. You mean the first time? Yeah. Giannis called me. He's like, who's that? You mind putting us in touch with that Heffelfinger guy that you hang out with in Arizona? Never heard that. And I'm like, yeah, what's up? He's like, well, Steve wants to have him on the podcast. I'm like, heck yeah. If anyone's voice needs to be amplified, it's Jim Heffelfinger. That was probably.

18, 2018 or something. Somewhere in there. It was back then. Because you and I had just done a podcast and we'd done some videos in like 16 or 17 or something. Yep. So they like, this guy might know what he's talking about. He even makes Newberg seem like he might know what he's talking about. Yeah. Mark Twain or somebody said, everybody's ignorant just about different topics. Yeah. And I like that. And it's true. Yeah. That's the value of having a bunch of people together working on something. Everybody's smart in different ways. Yeah. Well, up there on my whiteboard, when you come in, there's a, I have some one liners that I just, I got to remind myself of these every once in a while. So I keep them up there. And one is spare me the false comforts.

ignorance that's right because everything i've ever done where well if when i was in college it was usually because alcohol was involved but in my adult life pretty much every time i've stuck my foot in my mouth or went half cocked and thought i knew something i was way more ignorant than i understood which i think gets to the old saying if you don't know what you don't know yeah right and so that's why i try to have this network of people like you and others you know, peers in the old world and in the conservation world and even in the world of policy and politics. You need to constantly strive to keep learning more because a lot of times I've been, like you said, you're in the comfort of ignorance. You've been really comfortable with the position and then you start doing some more research and you get less comfortable. Yeah. You get less comfortable with your position. Yeah. Yeah. And the times that we've probably all listened or watched or sat in on a meeting where we were invited and it's like, I never thought about that before.

And you try not to blush. So, Jim, you and I are the same age. Yes. Born in the same year. A couple months apart. You were born on the other side of the river. Why do I look so much older? Is it that mountain tough stuff? No. As little sleep as I've been getting lately, I probably look like I'm Methuselah's grandparent or something.

One of the things you and I were talking about earlier is when the year you and I were born, there were 190 million people in the United States. Now, I just looked it up. The U.S. Census estimates that as of today, there are 342 point something million people in the United States. Is that clicking up on the website? Yeah, it's like the debt calendar. Every day if you went in there, it'd be a different number. That's amazing to think about. Yeah, that's an extra, what, 152 million people. Where are they? Where do they live? Where are they recreating? Well, that's where they live. And we actually are part of that problem.

You and I have both left the Midwest 30 some, 40 years ago. And we moved to the Rockies in the, in the Intermountain West. And you look at the states that have had the greatest population increase. The first percentage wise is Nevada, followed by your state of Arizona. And then you go into them, depending on where you want to measure from, you look at Colorado, you look at Utah, you look at Idaho. These are the core of a lot of certainly mule deer. And that much presence on the landscape and you can measure it or equate it in habitat.

reduction, human presence. Like my favorite spot to hike anymore. I almost feel guilty going there because there are so many dogs and dog walkers and, and hikers and mountain bikers. But as much as I want to get away from that, a part of me says it's probably not helpful if I go find some other desolate piece of the mountain in June when that mule deer is lactating and I displace her to the next place and to the next place. And then so using the same footprint. Yeah. So there's just this year round presence that, yeah, we talk about development and urban sprawl taking up habitat, but

People talk less about the indirect effects of that urban sprawl, and that's the recreation, like the influence into additional habitat that's not disturbed, but that influence and disturbance that lowers the ability to use that all the time. Yeah. I mean, I just think about the 20-some years I've been hiking in that spot. You know, I used to go there after work, and there'd be one other car, two other cars. Now there's so many cars there, they had to put a shitter in there, which I'm glad they did, because it was like people. Yeah, I know. That's terrible. So that tells you just in this little part of the world, and we don't seem that populated compared to other parts of the world.

how human presence is changing things. Which if you get to a species, tell me if I'm wrong, mule deer are maybe not as adaptable as white tails or as adaptable as elk. Would that be as safe? I would say not as adaptable as elk either. Yeah. And so we're changing so many things about their habitats and the specifics of what they need when they need it.

And we always hear this, wow, you know, back when grandpa was hunting, there were mule deer everywhere. Yep. Yep. And so in my head, I'm like, yeah, that's probably true. And I go back, I read the Bridger mule deer herd right here in the Bridger mountains, north of Bozeman. We used to shoot more mule deer bucks out of that herd than what the current herd is. In the seventies, the harvest reports, Dr. Mackey. Richard Mackey. Yeah. Did you ever? I met him once, I think. He was.

We founded a little rod and gun club here in the nineties. He was there all the time. And if some study came out or somebody stood up and said something that was kind of like barstool biology or coffee shop talk, he'd be like, wait a second. I did this research or I know someone. I mean, he kept everybody on it. Yeah, good. But his data showed, they did the surveys of how many mule deer were taken.

In the 70s, in the bridge range. We don't even have that many deer in the bridge range as an entire herd now. And because of the buck to doe ratio, I mean, that's even more significant. Right. And, you know, he would have today been able to say, told you so. Because his statement was, mule deer need certain things at certain times of the year. I remember him saying that. Because we asked him to give a presentation about mule deer. And all of us, we all wanted the bridgeers to go to limited entry. And he's like, that ain't going to help you, boys. But if that's what you want to do, knock yourself out. Well, here we are, you know, a group of...

50 of us were in such an argument that we're like, well, he's got the PhD and a career of researching. Let's listen to what he has to say. And he said, as long as you guys keep letting these subdivisions go in up here in the critical winter range, yeah, there's going to be deer walking through those subdivisions. Some of them are going to survive. He said, but to think that that's good for the long-term future of this migratory herd. He said, I can tell you, they summer on the east side and as quick as the snow comes, they come over and they winter on the west side.

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Watch Steps, now playing only on Netflix.

With Export Development Canada, Canadian businesses are competing, leading, and winning in more international markets. Like how agri-food businesses are strengthening global food supply, and critical minerals are powering industries of the future. Their ambition can't be contained. And with EDC behind them, neither can their growth. Export Development Canada is the financial partner for Canadian businesses going global. Visit edc.ca for more. He had all kinds of data. Well, it's been on a limited entry draw since 1998. And every year, they have to lower the number of tags. Yeah. Oh, that's so sad.

So it's not human harvest. They now, and I'm sure you could have never imagined the everyday activity from the south end of the Bridgers to the north end. I see that in a lot of mountain ranges that are near some of the cities in Tucson and Phoenix. They're just climbing with people. Like on a weekend in the spring, there's just colored clothing everywhere. And so as leader of that Mildew Working Group, I've read a few things about how elk are affected by...

year-round, 24-7 type, non-hunting, but human presence. Is that relevant? That's certainly in effect. There's not as much research on recreational disturbance. It's an emerging thing, and certainly there's states like Colorado talking a lot about it, and so it's a big issue in some areas. I think we're waiting for a lot of the science to catch up. I think there's not a lot of big, decades-long body of information on disturbance, but there's no doubt when an animal is standing in place.

having it be disturbed and have to flee somewhere that comes at an energetic cost it comes at a cost it's fleeing somewhere which is going to be not the place it wanted to be right and so there's there's those subtle effects happening throughout a population and if you have these animals on a weekend in the summer being bumped several times a day that's just that's not good it's really bad yeah well here in the places i'm talking about they're getting bumped all day long yeah through the whole summer and pretty soon they just like i'm not going to hang out in that area and they go try to find something else which is either another deer's home range or it's an it's a type of habitat that they didn't it wasn't their first choice their first choice was where they were and now they're being pushed to occupy some other area which when you push them Probably a lower net choleric intake for what they're investing to go and find those calories. Higher predation risk because now they're in a place they're not. So that's why I started with how many people are on this. That's really at the foundation of it. Now you think about everybody moving west. Well, they're not vacating the east. There's an increase in total population. Like you said, there's a lot more people and they're just spreading. And they're moving disproportionately. But they're, you know, I originally, early in my career, I was thinking about people being.

displacing themselves, like moving from one spot to the other, but it's more like they're being, they're being pushed, but there's more people where they came from too. Yeah. Yeah. We're kind of like that young bighorn ram that is bumped out of the herd and he just goes on a walkabout and ends up in a different mountain range. Yep. I mean, I'm oversimplifying to use a comparison, but that's what humans have done. And so the other thing we always hear is, well, in 1960, whatever, and I wish I've went and done this before, Blooming Crockett has their database. It's called the Trophy Search Database. One time I went to look.

to see how many entries there were from the year I was born. And then I wanted to compare it to, I'm sure I was inaccurate in it, but I tried to summarize how many mule deer hunting licenses were sold or how many deer licenses were sold in the mule deer states that year. And then I tried to extrapolate it forward. And I can see why people say the 60s and the 70s were the glory days because when I did that, and I wish I would have kept it, I did this like 15 years ago. Yeah, there must have been a lot of older bucks walking around at that time relative to the number of hunters. And older, yeah. The 50s and early 60s were a...

a big artificial swelling or boom of mule deer. And part of that came from, you know, back in the late 1800s and early 1900s. We didn't have any laws, any restrictions. People are just killing whatever they needed for meat and leather. And so those populations, everybody knows that story was way down. And then through the 30s, we started to have the Pittman-Robertson Act in 1937. A whole bunch of other things in the 1930s happened along with the development of game and fish departments and then started having shortened seasons, male only, don't kill the does, all these restrictions on harvest and that restriction and protection of those populations.

At the same time that we've had a whole bunch of logging, and so some of these forests are being opened up, sunlight reaching the forest floor, forbs and browse and shrubs that deer need to be healthy, growing all over the forest because of that disturbance, and it opened up. We had fire suppression, which let those shrubs mature and stay on the landscape instead of getting burned out. We were dropping 1080 poison. We were trapping, shooting predators, like an active predator eradication campaign. Not sustainable harvest of predators like we have now, but active eradication, dropping 1080 poison baits from plains. I mean, just poisoning, and throughout all of that.

It shouldn't be any big surprise that deer populations from the 20s and 30s and 40s and 50s swelled up into the 1950s and early 60s at that time. But that's not our benchmark. We're not going to try to go back to dropping poison baits, eradicating predators like everywhere. Logging in a lot of cases was too extensive, huge, huge clear cuts that were way too big. And now we're logging and we're restricted smaller areas. So the deer have some cover nearby with all that food that it creates. And so things are changing now in a way that we can't ever go back to those conditions that created those high deer populations. So to talk about.

mid-century deer populations compared to now, or 1950s compared to now, it's not a valid comparison. You know, the West, like we're talking about, the West has changed a lot since 1950. And I don't know how anybody can expect us to have deer populations like we used to. We should all be striving for bigger deer populations, but let's be realistic about what our benchmark, what our starting point, or our comparison is. Yeah, and I think that's part of, as my grandma used to say, frustration is the result of unrealistic expectations. That's true. And there's a lot of frustrated deer hunters right now. Yeah, and so you end up with people who...

They want to talk about when dad or grandpa or whoever was doing it. And I get that. That would be great. But the challenge we have ahead of us and the challenge of today is how do we accept the reality and not try to live in an old universe? Here's the reality of today. And we're having all these other factors in play. I mean, we're talking about human population pressures, which is really, really big. It changes landscapes because it introduces.

all kinds of different things, fire suppression. Yeah, roads and fences too. These things that fragment the habitats. You got roads and fences and then even roads that aren't fenced or the fences aren't an issue. You've got traffic volume that's so high that it creates a barrier to movement. And then we talked about recreational disturbance. All that stuff is something that's just increasing from the 1950s to now. And then we get large expenses of cheatgrass. That's the one thing for me in the mule deer country that when I was in college in the 80s, I went to college in Nevada. And it's probably as dramatic there as anywhere, maybe Southern Idaho, maybe some other places.

I would just leave. When I was done working at the sawmill, I was out of town. I was out in the hinterlands. And you would see, and I lucked out. I lived there during a really wet cycle in 84, 85, 86, 87. Yeah, talked about the 80s this morning. Oh, did you? Okay. And so we had like a five-year higher moisture cycle. And the sage, I mean, you would see the new stuff on the sage tops, five, six inches. And all of a sudden, Nevada's got 270,000 male deer. I mean, you walk around and it's like, how many deer tags you got? Hey, did you draw? No, don't worry about it. I'll go get one over the counter. I mean, it was insane.

But at the time we thought that was, well, this is going to be the norm. And now I go back there whenever I can draw a tag and the large scale habitat or landscape level habitat changes I see. And I know the crew is tired of me saying, oh, when we go into this basin, it's the best sage and buck brush and stuff. And I go there and it's nothing but cheatgrass because it burned 20 years ago. Yeah. Repeatedly. Yeah. And we're talking not just like a hundred acres. We're talking hundreds of thousands of acres. I'm using Nevada as an example, but you go to Utah, you go to Southern Idaho, you go to Southeast Oregon.

I experienced that in Nevada. A couple of years ago, I was asked to come and talk on a mule deer summit, Nevada Division of Wildlife. And we talked about mule deer issues. And afterwards, we did a field trip. And we went out near Winnemucke. I'm not even sure where it was. We went out to an area in this giant basin that was sagebrush.

and there's sagebrush around that basin, but we were in a giant, giant basin from rim to rim. There wasn't a sagebrush plant. And they talked about how deer would come down here. This was their winter range. They get nutrition in the summer up in the high country and then snow covers it. They gotta come down to the winter range. They eat that sagebrush just to kind of maintain their body condition. They're not getting fat on winter range. They're trying to survive winter so they can get back up to the good groceries in the summer. And they come down to that winter range and they subsist on that sage and some other browse and the cheatgrass invaded. And instead of sparse little bunch grasses, native bunch grasses in between sagebrush, you now had a thick mat of...

cheatgrass, which then dried out and cured into a tinderbox and you get, and then you get a fire that gets sparked from something and you get not only just one fire raging through and killing some sagebrush, but the cheatgrass loves fire. So it comes back even thicker the next year. And then it burns maybe two years later or three years later. And this, this increase in fire intensity and increase in fire frequency in the sagebrush communities, pretty soon you're standing like I was in a basin of grass, of cheatgrass and Nevada wildlife. The deer biologists are trying to bring back what kind of like sagebrush and they try to replant sagebrush and it's not getting established because with the loss of that community and more drought and drier summers, they can't, they actually can't get sagebrush reestablished. It's shifted that baseline of that ecosystem to be something different. And so now they're trying different browse plants that are good for deer and will withstand the fire and will grow in that area. But it wasn't until I think I stood in that basin that I said, wow, I saw, I instantly saw this issue firsthand. And it wasn't just a little bit here and there. It was landscape scale loss of wind range.

And that's happening all over the Great Basin. Yeah. So I try to get specific and call it winter range, as you did, or transition range or whatever. Because when you say habitat, people will just kind of... Pretty nebulous. Yeah. They're like, what does that mean? And so I try to use a term that makes them really think about it. And, you know, a lot of meal, they're not all, but a lot of our meal, they are migratory. Yeah. As you explained, they use a higher summer range for... That's where they get fat. That's where they get fat, get ready to have their young, get their young, have their young in the spring down when they're coming off a winter range. But they've got to get.

that nutrition they've got to get that fat layer yeah and so now you know if people want to call it long-term drought or climate change i don't care what anyone wants to call it i can look at since the late 80s until now we have been less moisture, hotter weather, whatever term anyone wants to put to it. So even the alpine environments that the mule deer traditionally could rely upon, the timing of when that becomes their lush, greatest forage changed. The quantity and quality of that forage is different than it was. There's a lot of things stacked against.

a mule deer trying to make a living when all these humans are here. That's right. They are under a lot of pressure. I'm always an eternal optimist. And so people talk about, you know, what's that mule deer are declining, mule deer are disappearing. And I feel like that's too pessimistic. The Mule Deer Working Group puts out a document every year and it's a status of mule deer and black-tailed deer in North America. And what we do, because there's no way you can say how are mule deer doing and you just talk about mule deer in general.

We have the biologists for each state and province write specifically a page or two about how mule deer or black-tailed deer are doing in their jurisdiction. And then we look at it overall, and we try to do some summarization that we can. And out of 21 jurisdiction states and provinces that have mule deer, more than half of them are stable or increasing in the last three years. So it's not all doom and gloom. I think we've got, like Colorado, half their game management units are at population objective. People don't talk about that much, but there's areas where mule deer are not doing too bad. Arizona itself had this big decline in the 1990s, and that's when a lot of mule deer populations were declining throughout the West, and when the Waffle Directors put together the mule deer working group to address that.

After that decline in the 2000s, the Mueller population in Arizona took a long, steady, 15-year steady increase and really recovered. And during that recovery, people were still talking about the Mueller decline because we had advertised that so well in the 90s that I still get asked about the Mueller decline. But like Arizona is an example of a lot of states that recovered from that decline. And then lately, there's things that are affecting them. With Arizona, the last six years, we've had a really bad drought and that population turned down. In the Rocky Mountain states, the winter of 22-23 was a really harsh one. And then we've had mild winters, two winters after that. And reproduction is really high. I just saw numbers in the bridges were really high reproduction in this year. And so there's the last two years.

the Rocky Mountain states looking good, but there's these weather fluctuations, whether it's drought in the Southwest, harsh winters in the Rocky Mountain states from the North, affecting deer populations on an annual basis. And then you have the habitat, long-term habitat changes we were talking about kind of in the background. working more insidiously. But I'm more optimistic than most. I think if we all continue, everybody that cares about mule deer continues to work at a local level by improving habitat, working on habitat projects, staying in touch with land management agencies, the Forest Service, BLM. If there's grazing allotments that might need adjustment, you're staying communicating with the land management agencies for the good of mule deer. And we keep doing everything we can for landscape permeability. I think mule deer have a bright future in occupying what habitat we leave it. And that's what it boils down to is how much habitat are we going to leave mule deer? And I think they'll do fine in what we leave them.

what we leave them. That gets into this whole policy thing where I get my butt handed to me because I'm one of these guys who occasionally goes from policy to politics. And if you really want to stir people up, Jim, become one of these guys who communicate about science. Because in our North American model, we say science as the basis for policy, right? That's one of our seven tenets. So when you say that, and then you get over here to this little nodule called...

policy. Where does that come from? Yeah. That shares the same root word as politics and politicians. For a reason. Yeah. I see why you stay over on this side of the fence. Yeah. It's way better on this side for sure. Yeah. And I saw a quote once. People always talk about trying to just keeping the politics out of science and what we do. And I saw a quote once that says, we need to get the science out of politics. And I thought that was funny because the politicians trying to pretend like they have the best science and they're really biased in some way. And I thought it was a funny way to look at it is let's keep the science out of politics. Yeah. Well, we're going to get into that because one of the things on my...

list of topics I want to cover because you are the science guy is the fact that society has lost a lot of trust in science. And I think politicians wanted to kind of let's wrap up mule deer and habitat and stuff like that. So you are an optimist. I've known you for 10 years and you are definitely an optimist. Right. Which you should be. Both your parents are in their 90s. That's right. That's right. I think that's where my optimism comes from. I mean, I only got a year to go and I'll outlive my dad. Yeah, I know a lot of friends that have already. I'm very fortunate. So I can see why you're such an option. I think you are by your very nature. I would love to think about...

how mule deer has this bright future. Because I do read way too much stuff about CWD, about this disease, about that concern, about predation, about habitat, about migration. That's what sells, though. Articles on the sky is falling always sells very well. And it's hard. It's not as interesting to read an article that things are all okay. Especially if you're talking about deer and you write an article that says, I'm optimistic about mule deer. The person who didn't get a deer last year is going to send you an email.

They're not very optimistic about deer. I'm not happy till you're not happy. I like that. I've used that a lot. I like that. I know a lot of people like that. This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Watch Steps, now playing only on Netflix.

With Export Development Canada, Canadian businesses are competing, leading, and winning in more international markets. Like how agri-food businesses are strengthening global food supply, and critical minerals are powering industries of the future. Their ambition can't be contained. And with EDC behind them, neither can their growth. Export Development Canada is the financial partner for Canadian businesses going global. Visit edc.ca for more.

Well, I just think about my state of Montana. You know, we had that hard winter in 22, 23, not as bad as Wyoming did or Southeast Idaho or Northeast Nevada. There were parts that were really bad. Yeah. And so we had this longer term issue that drought over the course of a two or three year period, that's hard for fawns to get up on plane right away. And you're losing some of them anyhow. And then you have a bad drought going and all of a sudden here comes a little man winter. Right. If you've had that combination of drought and winter.

That's bad news. Yeah. And so that's what we've had here. And, you know, I've read our reports, our mailder numbers are slowly rebounding. But a lot of people want to, I think it's easier because we spend so much time focusing on hunting regulations. How do I get a tag? How can I, when can I hunt here? How do I plan my calendar? That we have a tendency to think that hunting is what drives. Right. Cause that's our focus all the time. Right. Well, I have a sad story for you. I don't, I didn't get a deer tag this year.

and my two sons. I put it in my two sons in Arizona and got nothing. And we don't have, we've got like three leftover muzzleloader tags. We have basically no leftover tags. So I'm out. I'm not deer hunting in Arizona this year. And I spent 23 years as a regional biologist and I was very forceful about let's use the resources as much as we can. Let's let people go hunting with their friends and their family. And so where we had sometimes a local biologist wanted to be a little more conservative, I was always pushing my whole career as a regional biologist, pushing more permits, more permits, more permits.

Since I joked with the current biologist that now I'm out of that position, I can't get a deer pay. Is that a coincidence? But the premise there being that you can't stockpile these deer. Was that kind of the, I mean, along comes a drought like you guys have had or along comes a winter like we've had. And hunting is like the last little knot on the tail of the country.

we're mostly buck only hunting through a lot of areas in the west except for some of the doe harvest and some of the areas where they need to maintain that population but Arizona's buck only and so removing those bucks is not affecting the abundance of deer in the population the habitat the environment rainfall frankly in Arizona in the desert rainfall is just almost everything and people don't like to hear that like the biologists are just folding their hands and saying, we can't do anything about it. It's just, it's just rainfall. But in areas like the Sonoran desert, you can't go in there and improve the Sonoran desert. You can keep your eye on grazing. You can put some water catchments out to distribute water, but you don't go in and put a food plot in and you don't go in and plant browse among the saguaro cactus. I mean, there's not a lot you can do in some environments and it is rainfall driven. And unfortunately we've had some bad droughts the last few years. Deer permits have rightly been declining to keep in line with our guidelines. We try to maintain a certain buck to doe ratio and maintain a certain hunt success. And to do that, you need to decrease permits when the population is dropping. When we see the same in Nevada.

We've seen it in New Mexico. We've seen it in Utah. I probably have less sympathy for Utah and Nevada where probably 70% of the bucks harvested are four points or better. Come on, let's start using some of those mule deer. Well, have you ever sat and listened to a Nevada commission meeting? Years ago I did. We had some issues that I was. I try to watch as many of the commission meetings in the spring as possible. So you must have some disciples, Caleb or some of those people within NDOW, Nevada Department of Wildlife.

Because they recommended more tags. Hey, our numbers are starting to come up. More tags, more tags. I didn't know that, but it doesn't surprise me. They should. And there's some good people. This is two years in a row now. I've watched them recommend this level of tags because we don't know when the next tragedy is coming. So let's provide more opportunities. And nothing against their commission, but a lot of them are older than I am. And they've kind of hunted and filled freezers. And now they're kind of in that phase of hunting where I just like, even if I don't fill a tag on a big buck, I like seeing big old bucks. And so they throttle those tag numbers down.

And the biologist, I mean, what's the biologist going to say? Hey, you can't do that. The agency director and the biologist work for the commission. There was a number of years back where I think it was a Nevada commission that just cut eggs 25% across the board. That was two years ago. It was more than two though. I was thinking it was more than two. And just like, there was no biology behind that. We just want to be more conservative overall. We're just going to cut 25%.

And then pretty soon you got 60% of the bucks harvested are four by fours and you have a whole bunch of people sitting home watching football because they can't go deer hunting. Exactly. And so there's always that balance and that's the hunting part of it. And I get, if you're a commissioner, you got one person down at the coffee shop complaining they didn't get their tag this year. You got another person complaining, I had a tag last year and I didn't see any four points or enough four points. And so they're in a tough spot. They're kind of that shock absorber that tries to take the science and the modeling and the public and give.

be the go-between for what the social pressures are for the public. And social pressures can't be dismissed because wildlife agencies, the public owns wildlife. The wildlife is a public resource. Wildlife agencies manage, as trustees, manage the wildlife resource for the public. And so...

an agency as trustee can't ignore what the benefactors want. And so even if there's things, we talked a little bit about antler point restrictions. So even if there's things that agencies have tried and they've not been successful, like antler point restrictions, sometimes 10 years later, there's a faction that rises up and demands antler point restrictions and no science in the world is going to deter them from their mission. And so sometimes an agency using in their public trust responsibilities will open a couple of units to antler point restrictions because that's what the. some segment of the public wants. So there's a lot of give and take. And it's not, I don't ever see as a biologist for 34 years, if for a state agency, I don't ever see that, like, like giving the public something they want, even if it doesn't make sense. I don't see that terribly negative. It's just part of the public trust responsibility of, of managing the way people want to manage. Yeah. I mean, when we end up.

Hearing about here in Montana is predators. You know, it's predators, predators, predators. And so I'm like, you know, predation is definitely a factor. The more compromised the habitat, the higher the rate or amplitude on the population of predation. But I'm thinking to myself, well, let's see, I can hunt wolves from September to March.

I have a spring bear season and a fall bear season, and I get that tag over the counter. I can hunt coyotes 24-7, 365. I got a bobcat season. There aren't a lot of bobcats here, but I can go do a lot of bobcat hunting and trapping. We have lion quotas that are high enough that they never get filled. So when I'm asking you, Mr. Game Manager, to do something about predation, it's like, well, what more can I do? You want us to send state employees out there to fill these quarters and fill these tags? Some of them might want helicopters involved, but you know, an agency is not going to do that to the native predator guild.

And so I get it. Some people just, you know, they're looking, they're frustrated and they're looking for a solution. But this is a, all of these are really complicated problems that are not going to be solved by raising the lion quota. Yeah. Predator management and nutrition or habitat go so closely hand in hand. Like you said, if habitat conditions are so good, predators can't keep up. They just can't, the deer population increases no matter what predators are doing. If habitat's in bad shape or you get into a drought, then that's when predators have a greater impact. So predators don't drive deer populations down. Predators can.

can accelerate a decline that's caused by bad habitat conditions. And as they're at low levels and the deer population's recovering, predators, especially if it's kind of out of whack, predators can actually dampen or slow that recovery, but it's more of an effect on what the habitat's driving the population to do. Well, there's all these things that are out there that if... The point of the commission having to listen to the social side of it, the human side of it. You know, I think about how different every state is in their mule deer management. And that's how it should be. Because every state has a different hunting culture, a different hunting history. Now, in Montana, we let anyone who is a resident go down to the hardware store and buy a deer tag. And with a rifle, you can hunt from the last Saturday of October till the Sunday after Thanksgiving. And pretty much all of our mule deer units. Not all, but pretty much all.

That is a social thing in Montana that anytime they've talked about tweaking that, I think that's more volatile than a fee increase. Yeah. I remember in Wisconsin, they've always had a nine day gun season in November, always a nine day gun season. And one year they said, how about we do two weeks? We just give you guys two weeks. And the hunter said, no, we have a nine day gun season. Get that into your head that we have a nine day gun season. That's what we have. Don't start messing with it. And so, you know, people will say, well, we should do this and we should do that. And we should do this and we should do that. And I think it's worth considering everything because.

Every state doing something different, you're going to learn a little bit more about, hey, that worked there. That's a different landscape or this changed. And guess what? This was a good solution. So it's worth considering all that. But a lot of people get on because they don't get that worked up fighting and arguing about mule bay regulations. Because I know in the long run, it probably isn't that big of a difference. But you're right. The hunting aspect of it. We focus on that 100%. But we have...

professionals making sure that there isn't an overharvest, professionals making sure that the population is running over carrying capacity, they turn on some dough tags and they reduce that reproductive potential, and the population is down, they take away dough tags. There's professionals doing that, and so we've got kind of people, someone at the wheel on that aspect, and we need to be paying attention to the main things that drive abundance, not buck-to-dough ratios around success. I don't know if you and Marcus talked about this, but it was three years ago? So we decided we're going to go hunt mule deer in the office. I'm more of a whitetail guy. I haven't shot way more whitetail than Montana than I have mule deer. So I said, if I shoot a buck, it's going to have to be really old. And not by score, but just body type. It almost looks like they've got a short face because their nose and everything is so big. So I'm watching this buck and he's nothing spectacular. He's a two by three, but he is running off some nice four by fours. I'm like, he's the guy. Went over there and shot him eight and a half years old. And then the wives of two guys who work here, they shot.

bucks that were between seven and a half and nine and a half. On public land in Montana, which the season type, like I explained earlier, there wasn't a one of them that scored over 160 inches, which gets me to this point of unmet expectations. There's so many things that go into the one buck that grows to be 170 inch buck. It's not all age. Everyone likes to think it's genetics. So how much opportunity and...

freezers being filled and other stuff. Do we give up in our effort to try grow that 170 inch or bigger buck that might get eaten by a lion anyhow? So you think about all the things it takes, how many bucks start out at whatever, what a small percentage of them get there. And so I just think about that and the human component of what wildlife managers have to do. Are we realistic in our expectation? I want to draw that tag because I'm going to shoot a great big buck.

Yeah, I know. It's tough. Expectations are important, and they have not been an issue with me and my family because I raised four boys on spike meat for 30 years, and we're happy. I mean, our rule is if it fits in a tortilla, it's going home with us because that's all we were interested in is putting something in a tortilla, and we've had a ball for 30 years hunting together, and I've got a nice 4x4 on the wall, but it was only because it was the first deer, the first legal buck that I saw on that particular hunt, and that's the truth. That's the only reason I have that one. Yeah, and I think our game managers try to address all these different social ideas, like in Montana now we have.

seven or eight units that are limited entry trying to have a bit higher buck to dough ratio maybe a slightly higher age class Most agencies do that. We've done it for a long time. We call them alternative deer units and we just purposely reduce the number of tags there. And then we have different benchmarks to monitor whether we're being successful in providing an alternative opportunity. And one is a higher hunt success. And one is we have some kind of measure of age. Sometimes it's antler points, but sometimes it's we pull teeth in those units. We pull the incisors and we do some manual aging. And so we'll have like a certain percent of the harvest needs to be between three and five and a certain percent needs to be older than five. And then when we survey, we want buck to doe ratios within a little higher band. And so we're looking at older age structure, better buck to doe ratio, higher hunt success.

fewer hunters out there because we reduce tags. And I think most agencies provide some subset of their units in some kind of alternative unit. And that's the way it should be. And the proportion is probably appropriate because a vast majority of people just want to go deer hunting. And that's shown in surveys state after state, year after year, decade after decade after. And we'll get people at a commission meeting, talk about how they want more big bucks and all their friends want big bucks and everybody wants more big bucks. And that conflicts with scientifically and statistically valid surveys of the hunting public, which continues to show people just want to go deer hunting. But that doesn't mean that we don't provide some areas for those people that are perfectly willing to wait out three years for that other opportunity.

Hunt Talk is brought to you by Peaks Equipment. If you're a public land hunter like me, you know gear has to work when you're miles from the truck. And Peaks makes gear that I trust, like the Backcountry Duo headlamp, the Peaks Medkit, Backcountry Elite cork trekking poles, and the Solace sleeping bag. If you want to support a brand built for public land hunters, visit peaksequipment.com and use promo code Randy to save 10%. Well, my chance to shoot a great big buck was in your state in 2007. Almost 20 years ago now. I was one of the Mack Point holders and I drew the Arizona Strip in a terrible drought year.

I know someone who that happened to. And I ended up that, actually my desk drawer at home, that tag is still in that drawer. So my theory is, you know what, Randy, if you can't find that great big buck on the Arizona Strip, you're just kind of snake bit. So get on with it, go hunt some more whitetails. And I know some people don't have that option. And I know some people live for mule deer hunting. That is their passion in life.

And I grew up in Wisconsin hunting whitetails. And then I did my graduate work in South Texas, working on trophy whitetails and coyote predation on trophy whitetails. So we were doing helicopter surveys on a private ranch with old age structure, giant South Texas whitetail bucks. And then I moved and became a biologist in Arizona. And the first year we did helicopter surveys for Arizona game of fish. And we're in the helicopter and the other biologist said, look at that boomer whitetail, turn around, turn around. And we turned the helicopter around and there's like a 100 point whitetail there. And I thought, why are we turning around for a 100 point whitetail? Oh, that's a toad. Holy cow. And I started to realize, oh, these are different kinds of whitetails than South Texas. And then I saw my first desert mule deer.

big desert mule deer and i said oh that's a deer that is a deer and having no prior exposure to mule deer i just fell in love with mule deer at that point and and so i'm i'm done with white tails yeah i want mule deer well this winter i had the benefit of talking to oregon game and fish and one of their game managers about their whole new change i mean completely I don't want to say completely, but as far as the units and how they manage, they didn't, over time, I suppose, just, yeah, this highway divides that. Let's call the east side whatever unit and the west side whatever unit. But they weren't, and they have different season types. I've seen in those data when they started looking at herd movements. Yeah, and so now they're managing by herd rather than from geographic, you know, a human put highway in here or a mountain, you know, a divide of a mountain range where, guess what, one day that's... Summering all up on top. Yeah, on both sides. And so there's a lot of things that are being tried.

When you use your, you put on your optimistic lens, what are the things that you're seeing out there that, is it anything we can control or is it mostly just, hey, it rained this year? But as far as like, we're talking about managing herds. You know, all the agencies are doing different things and they're doing the best they can. There's some states that can't do helicopter surveys because it's boreal forest or even like provinces, boreal forest. In other places, like in Arizona, that deer densities are so low, there's not much else we can do but helicopter surveys and it lends itself to that. And so the agencies, as far as management, they're doing a good job and they're doing what they can with the habitat they have and the deer herds they have and the financial resources they have. The bigger picture things that we're talking about in the habitat and in the Southwest, unfortunately, is a lot, just it's rainfall and it's what kind of year we have is dictating that population. But we still monitor grazing levels. We still work on water catchments.

I think all of the migration stuff in the last decade has been really an exciting thing. And the lower cost of GPS collars and the ability to put a lot of GPS collars on a lot of animals and start defining herds like Oregon did, start defining road crossings and try to fix that with an underpass or an overpass and learn more about how they use that landscape in an annual cycle rather than just where we saw them during the deer season or whatever. I think that's probably the most exciting thing is what we're learning with these cheaper GPS collars, all kinds of things. Yeah. By Kevin Monteith.

I've been on this podcast a couple of times with all of his research out of University of Wyoming. Fantastic stuff. A lot of people there, including Kevin, doing great stuff. Yeah, him and Matt and a whole bunch of them and Paul and so many people down there. Jared Merkel. Yeah. And so he had me come down and be the emcee at his fundraiser in April. I'm like, Kevin, man, I don't know. You might not get the results you wanted here. But it was great fun. Two days of interacting with people who are really passionate about Wyoming's mule deer.

and pronghorn and really interested from all walks of life by career by industry by background by education level They were all really interested in a lot of the work that, I don't know if it originated out of the Wyoming Migration Initiative, but a lot of migration study going on there just because there's such long distance migrations. Yeah, a lot of agencies were doing some migration stuff, but that was back when GPS collars were just coming online. And so there was limits in what people could learn, what technology they had available. And about the time those collars started getting more available and cheaper, the Wyoming Migration Initiative was formed out of the Wyoming Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Unit.

They were so good at outreach that they garnered a lot of the attention because they were doing some really neat things and they were displaying some really neat maps. So they got a lot of attention. And some other agencies probably are overshadowed by how good of a job Wyoming did. But other agencies are doing and we're doing really good things. But the Wyoming Migration Initiative is one location with a whole bunch of people doing some really, really good cutting edge work. Yeah. And so it was just interesting to see the passion so many people had for.

I call it their passion for knowledge. They were there. There were a lot of science-based people there, but there were people from all kinds of walks of life, a lot of hunters, a lot of industry people. And by industry, I mean like energy industry and grazing and livestock industry. And every one of them were interested in finding solutions too. Okay, now that we've learned that these deer and pronghorn are migrating this far, how do we do the things on the landscape that accommodate that? And that's where science...

To me, this is fascinating. That's where the rubber meets the road. It's where you can really sight of some wind turbines in a slightly different location that is the same as far as gathering wind, but avoid this migration quarter now that we know that it's there. Yeah, and now you hear a lot of these producers who are thinking, you know, I might be into virtual fencing. It's still really expensive, but maybe for my internal fences, maybe you're getting groups that are saying, hey, if you're interested, could we help fund some of that cost? Because we want to see if it's effective or not. And so it's for me, and maybe it's because I run in so many different circles and go to so many events.

I'm fascinated by what science can do for us. Yeah. And energy companies are ponying up a lot of money for some of that migration stuff. Yeah. They're really helping fund some of that. Well, that, that gets me to my enthusiasm for science was dampened in the last couple of weeks because I did a video series about the, and this was about elk, not meal there, but all the studies I've read. And when it comes to elk, I have a workbook, a word document that anytime I read a study that I think, Hey, somebody, I want to remember that I put.

like one sentence and then a link to it. And so I go to those a lot, especially if I draw a tag in a place I've never hunted before. Well, I was talking about how we have all the studies that show how elk respond to human activity a lot in some ways motorized activity. Yeah. I think there was a paper by Jack Lyon in 1970 in Idaho, if I'm remembering right. I said my first study was 1976. I think it was my first study that I found. But anyhow, all of a sudden this became politics.

personal preference and not science. And so when I push back on some of these people, well, can you show me the science that shows that elk benefit from more roads and more motorized travel and why more elk stay on public land when we open up the public land to unmanaged motorized travel. I'm not saying that just because there's a road, elk go a hundred miles, but the study's done. There's a definite relationship to the amount of roads and the health of that elk hurt and their preference of where they want to be. And in a place like Montana, where we have a lot of private land, that preference becomes inaccessible private lines. And so I go through this whole process and I'm back and forth with some of the folks on the comments. And very often when people just were tired of my asking and probing, they're like, well, I just don't trust the science anymore. You know, that's the default when you push them enough. Yeah. And you're kidding yourself, Randy, if you think science is unbiased, which gets back to your point earlier, how about we take the science? Did you say take the science out of politics? So this is now where we're trying to close in that loop, if you want to call it.

We unfortunately see so much stuff put out there under the premise of science. It's just the public doesn't stand a chance filtering all that stuff. It's really unfortunate. A lot of what I try to do is pull more complicated science and present it in different formats, magazine article or something, in a way that people can just understand it. Or as a chair of the Mule Deer Working Group, there's some of these topics people have questions about, and I'm in a position to be able to speak about what most of the Western Mule Deer experts think and pull and draw from their expertise.

the public is exposed with social media just so much. And now just complete false AI stories. There's some stories I've seen that include maps with animal GPS tracks. They're completely fabricated. They just made them up from scratch and they have animals that aren't in those areas. And so, I mean, the public, I think is starting to realize that some of this stuff is just, it's not biased. It's completely made up. It's completely fabricated, completely wrong. And I don't know how, it's just tough for non-scientists to try to wade through this group.

has the science they're citing and this group has the science reciting they're saying opposite things right sometimes people say well everybody's got their own science but i say science is science right some people are selectively citing some of that body of science but it's not like people have different science people are selectively citing what they want even in the same scientific paper a lot of times someone can peel a quote out and cite that paper and someone with an opposing view can pull another quote out and cite that paper yeah um and it's hard to wade through all that i think the best people can do is rely on sources that they think are reliable, sources of information. Like if you're gonna get some CWD information, for example, you can get that information in a lot of places, but there's a website, cwd-info.org. It's cwd-info.org. And that is run by Wildlife Management Institute. I think Rocky Mountain Up Foundation contributes to that. Not sure if Mueller Foundation still does, but that's a source of reliable information. And if you see something somewhere else, you can check it with some of these sources. Just know your source is the main thing. And that's where I, it's not just in our space. You get outside of hunting.

Whether we're talking about what's happening with ocean temperatures or what is happening with invasive species. You see a lot of people using, when science is not vetted and it's selectively cherry-picked, it becomes propaganda. It is not science at that point. Science, one, it's got to be peer-reviewed. It's got to be in the totality of what was researched and what conclusion was drawn. Yes, right.

A scientific paper always has several sections. It has an abstract introduction, and then it has the study area description, and then it has methods, how we did this research, and then it has results. And the results are the results they got from this research. And if you agree on how they set the study up, you think it's a pretty valid way to set up a study, then the results are just the results. But the last section is called discussion. And in the discussion section is where the scientist is supposed to take their results and interpret them for the reader on what they think this really means in a bigger scale. And in that discussion section, there's a lot of leeway for scientists to start veering off into personal opinion and their own normative values. And so you do have...

to get your information from peer reviewed sources, but there's a lot of peer reviewed papers that have things in the discussion section that are just complete. They're not related in any way with the data that was collected. They're just complete speculation. And so even in the peer reviewed paper, people have to really be cautious. And that goes back to people not trusting the science. And sometimes I talk about how untrustworthy the scientific literature is becoming because so many biased researchers are starting to just produce things that look like scientific papers. And they're really based in their advocacy for some policy decision. And there's no way around that. It's in the peer reviewed paper. So I start talking about how

Even I don't trust the science in a lot of cases because it's garbage. It's bias. And so how someone then navigates me, and I have two positions. I have a title at Arizona Game and Fish where I'm full-time, and I also have a title at the University of Arizona where I'm adjunct faculty. And both of my titles have the word science in the name of my title. So it pains me as a science person to say I don't trust the science, but unfortunately some of it you can't trust. And so that makes it really cloudy because we want the public to be able to rely on reliable knowledge on these things. And wading through it is just incredibly difficult.

When you say it's incredibly difficult, it's a lot of work. And that's why, for me, I know I am easily swayed towards what my original bias is. If there's a conclusion where it conforms to what my original bias is, I might disregard the other 95% of the findings. That's what you call good study. That's a good study. But that's why I have guys like you. I can pick up the phone. I can call Andy in Colorado and pick up the phone. I can call Cody in Nevada and pick up the phone.

I feel so indebted to all of you that you put up with my dumb questions. No, we're indebted for you for getting that information out and using that platform to provide that reliable information. And I think that it kind of becomes a mutually beneficial relationship because, and I just gave a presentation in Elko, Nevada for all the researchers in the Wild Sheep and Mountain Goat Conference. I didn't say it quite this way. Like I often say on the podcast is if you don't tell your story, someone's going to tell it for you. But very, very few scientists are trained in communication. Yeah, that's true. You are a prolific writer that puts you way out. You are an outlier on that. Yep. And you're not hesitant to be on podcasts and other stuff. You are the outlier. There's way smarter people than me that never open their mouth in public. And they're way smarter. I mean, they're really good, but they just, they don't have an interest in that kind of communication. They don't do it. Right. And so when we aren't communicating.

science when it's good or communicating science when hey there's some flaws and how this was done or what conclusions were drawn that lets everybody else grab their bits and pieces and tell their story about it and that becomes even a bigger wave of people to try figure out well randy said this one study said blah blah blah but someone over here told me no that but if you read a different paragraph in the conclusion it questioned whether or not And so it's in today's world of instant communication, it's really hard. And that's where, for me, you probably got this from Marcus, you get it from me, where we ask a lot of questions that might seem repetitive, they might seem dumb, but we're working our butts off to try to be informed because this audience trusts us. As they should, because it's the information that comes out of your products is good and reliable. Yeah, and when...

People already have this bias against the trustworthiness of science. I've had life experiences at Cutler Massage. If we make one mistake, it's going to cause a lot of people to say, I don't know if I can trust that guy. And that's really all we have is trust. And that's why we're so indebted when people like you and others who are in this space of...

trying to understand and quest for knowledge that we call science are willing to share that with us. So you've got, you know, you've got a busy schedule doing all of your stuff and then I have a busy schedule, but it's part of my job to be taking a deep dive into these, some of these scientific issues. And it'd be kind of a waste of time if I didn't use that time that I spent learning to try to share some of that with other people. Yeah. I mean, some of the most simplistic things I, I thought that here's then this other tangent I could, I find myself going on in a lot. I've spent the last five years probably doing a lot of study about human behavior and how humans make up their mind.

and how they determine what they're going to believe, not believe. It's fascinating. I've heard that there's a huge body of literature, but I haven't been in it. Yeah. And it is just fascinating for me because I have to hopefully gain the trust of people who are just doubters or skeptics of like, you know what, fool me once, you know? And so I got to try, put myself to where are they coming from? What are they thinking about? Or why, why would they think I'm full of BS? Yeah. Sometimes what motivates them? Yeah. And you know, there's a lot of things that play in the bigger society of which we're just a small sliver, that bigger society.

A couple of them would be that a lot of younger people trust that you can get the same information from a Google search that you can from reading a scientific peer-reviewed journal. Yeah, or people think a Google search is unbiased. Yeah, there you go. Garbage in, garbage out, right? If you ask a query, I can almost get ChatGPT or Google that. Tell me whatever I probably wanted to hear. And I've had AI like ChatGPT return an answer that's 180 degrees from the truth. And I'll respond and say, you know, you're missing some science that was done in the 1970s. And what you gave me was completely wrong. And it'll come back and apologize. I know. Oh, you're right. It will apologize. I found these papers in the 90s. You're right. And so you take all that. And that is, this isn't a linear path. This is an accelerating path.

of how information is being used, being distributed, which is how it's being consumed with no real sideboards. There used to be high barriers to entry. If you wanted to publish a scientific book, that took a lot of work. That was years of your career to do that. Now, somebody who might be a bot, I don't know, just grabbed a little bit here, a little bit there, a little bit here, and acts like it's...

You know, some scientific paper. I actually got a scientific paper sent to me by a scientific journal. And now there's a million scientific journals right now. So people can get anything, any trash published that they want in some scientific journal. I had a journal send me a paper to review as one of their official reviewers. And as I was reading it, I recognized this is 100% AI writing. I can recognize this text. Large blocks of text were 100% AI. And I told them that. And I responded to the authors. And I was not.

I was not kind because they just wait. And it was only a five page paper, but it was, and it was about Mexican wolves and it was just like complete AI dribble. Yeah. And it was submitted as a scientific paper by somebody. Yeah. And then if it gets kind of through that first filter, then advocates and people with agendas are out there distributing it in their emails, on blasts, on social media, and it kind of becomes until proven otherwise. That's, that's the body of knowledge. Yeah. Yeah. That's really unfortunate. I deal a lot with that. Yeah. And so that's just a trend that's happening.

in our greater society. And anyone who thinks that's not happening slept through the whole COVID event, right? I mean, if you measured America's trust in our science in 2019 and measured it in 2022, in the course of three years, it would be astronomical what had been done there. And so now you get, because a lot of people will say that when they're like, I don't believe in science, Randy, just think back at COVID. I'm not a medical professional. I have no idea what was or wasn't correct.

The effect is the same, the distrust. So if we won't, how do you, and this is what the question I asked myself and our crew is, how do we not let the world just disregard science because it doesn't conform with what I wanted as my outcome? Yep, yep. I think what's really important is to be able to convert that scientific gobbledygook writing to something that makes sense to people. And just try to explain some of these, some of the more important studies. Yeah. Well, for me, I'm all about...

learning more. Because every time you and I spend an hour together, I'm like, oh, I better go find out what Jim said there. I didn't want him to know how ignorant I am. And then I leave and go, I got to go look up that law that I don't know anything about. But I think...

I want the hunting community to be consumers and sponges of this. And that is a trait and a characteristic that got hunting and conservation through a really dark period 140 years ago. Yeah. Through the dirty 30s, through its kind of like glory days. And we are living as beneficiaries of that today. And it wasn't because we were science deniers or, oh, gee, that's kind of inconvenient for someone to tell me that if I dump all my chemical waste in the river.

And the oil company over there does the same thing. And the chemical company over there does the same thing that the Cuyahoga river could start on fire. You know, that's inconvenient for someone to tell you that, you know, but the folks in Flint, Michigan probably wish somebody would have told them that there's some science out there that your water quality isn't that good. And so my point in all this is how do we, as the hunting community, maintain this confidence in this passion and appetite for having our biases. pushed and challenged without feeling like, well, that's not what I used to think. So I'm going to spend all my energy rationalizing what I think. Right. And there's people that spend so much energy trying to rationalize why they're not wrong. Yeah. Yeah. You ever read stuff by Jonathan Haidt? H-A-I-D-T. Oh man. It's, this is the guy I, I, I subscribed to all of his stuff. He's a research psychologist and he's done so many studies about this stuff and he's a professor. Yeah. That's right. Anyhow, I'm trying to remember which of the books he's written where

and this was like a light bulb moment for me because i do i know i've done the same thing is that we the way we have evolved our immediate Gut instinct is kind of what we go with. Then he talks about, you know, if you think about that from an anthropological standpoint, back in the day when there were some two guys, he said, I'm going to go steal his spear. You had to right away properly assess. I think these are the enemy. And you just went with it. Because if you made a bad assessment, they were slow making the assessment. Yeah, they stole your spear after they killed you. And so I'm giving a different example than he did. But he said, you know, the human mind evolved.

having to make really quick decisions. And then, okay, let's deal with the consequences of my decision. So now we're inundated with all kinds of information, all kinds of options, but we still have this bias of, this is what my gut tells me. And no matter how much, what rationale, how much data science has put in front of me, you're going to play hell. It's hardwired in your DNA. And so I was like, okay, why am I wasting my time then with the person who, on that specific topic anyhow?

this was their decision. You know, I'm probably, I don't have enough data to convince them otherwise. So how do I approach that? How do I get people to think in a wider scope before they make their decision? And he uses, he talks about, well, we like to call it open-mindedness. And he said, really what it is, is we've trained ourselves to have a little slower pace by which we immediately grab on opinion.

We're all, you know, we can call it whatever we want. We just slow things down before we make the decision. That's an interesting way to do that. So anyone who wonders how important it is that we have the best information and the best science, if we want people to make decisions based on that, should go read some of his stuff. It's fascinating. It sounds interesting. I'll get that from you. As much as I travel, I listen to it all now when I'm on a plane or driving down the road or whatever. And that has nothing to do with hunting, but it has everything to do with people trusting what the folks like you are doing and how effective we can be in using that. Because nobody trusts it.

Yeah. I spent a lot of time in scientific fights, but for good reason. I'm glad to, because someone needs to fight back on some of this stuff. Yeah. And so those are, there's a lot of bigger things going on in bigger society. You know, it concerns me when you look at the math and science scores of Americans, it's going down and it's going down. And so is that lack of interest in it? Is it lack of how we're teaching it? Because a lot of the things that science is based on.

are those things. Yeah. Yeah. Right. You know, and reading comprehension is going down. That's depressing. I haven't seen that stuff. Oh, really? Oh, you don't want to, you don't want to read that stuff, Jim, about America's reading comprehension. Are their thumbs getting bigger? I mean, the study didn't say anything about their thumbs or being able to drive and operate something at the same time. But no, it's, it's concerning when you see what reading comprehension and reading or writing the ability to express in writing as someone who writes as prolifically as you do.

So those are going to have consequences. It'll just be one generation and those will have consequences to what we're trying to do within the hunting community to be this sponge that embraces and is not offended. It's a sponge and a filter to have like critical thinking and skepticism. Yeah. And so when you see those happening and the trends just measured in the last 10 years, it's like, oh man, if we think it's bad today. Yeah. Right. Right. That's too bad. So I don't know. Maybe now that we're of the age we are, maybe we just blow up our social media accounts and have a party. Hey, come on over, blowing up our Facebook and Instagram and YouTube. But I don't know. I think a lot of it can be used for the good also. And it is. It's like every, everything. So, but before we wrap it up.

Can I ask the audience, the audio folks can't see what I have in my hand here, but the video audience can see it. You brought me a gift from Wisconsin. Well, no, she's in Tucson with me. Oh, she's with you now. Yes. My 91 year old mother knit a couple of cast iron scrubbies. Wow.

She's an expert scrubby. So she's got abrasive yarn. And I asked her to knit a couple for Randy and a few other people. And that's all I use on my cast iron. Now people are probably going to want to know where they're going to order one. They're going to ask. Your mom have a Shopify store or something? Nope. I don't think she's going to. She told me that that abrasive yarn, doing so many of them, abrasive yarn hurt her fingers. Oh, really? Oh, man. Feel proud you got one. Wait, what could I send her to?

Show my appreciation. I can't buy it online. That's right. I don't know. Maybe I'll send her some pickled pike or something. She is from Wisconsin. No Lutefisch. No Lutefisch. Heffelfinger, what is that? That German? It's Swiss German, which I learned later in life was Switzerland. The German part of Switzerland. I grew up thinking that we were Swiss Germans, but we're really German Swiss. But we've got good family history. It goes all the way back to 1728 when the first Heffelfinger bought some land in Pennsylvania in the Lehigh Valley. Really? And I've been out there a couple of times looking at old farmsteads. Look, on my Onyx account, I've got the actual outline of that.

125 acres he bought in 1728. And I found the gravestone of his son. His son died in 1791. So the first Heffelfinger lived and died in the colonies before it was America. Really? I'm a recent carpet bagger, Jim. My family is not nearly that colorful. It comes from Sweden and Finland in about the turn of the 1800s to 1900s. And in the immigration paper, it doesn't even say Newberg. It was Johansson. Really? Yeah. Wow. Yeah.

There's a story, I suppose. Grandpa was so full of BS, I don't know if I... What's true about it? But grandma, every once in a while vouched how the name got changed. Maybe there's some truth to that. But none of them lived... Well, on my mom's side, they lived to be old. My grandmother on her side lived to be 102. So your mom's still probably got 10 or 15 years of knitting. Yeah, those scrubbies. Scrubbies, yeah. And your dad's still around? Yep, 93. He killed a mule deer when he was 90. Killed a javelina when he was 89. That is so impressive, Jim. Yeah, that is amazing. That is impressive. And we elk hunted...

a year and a half ago in December, he was 91. And we all come to Ron Flagstaff. Wow. That. What's his name? Robert. Robert. Yeah, I want to be like Bob. Bob and Dolores. I know. I want to be like Bob. Yeah. All the kids back in the days, you know, I want to be like Mike, talking about Michael Jordan. No way, man. I want to be like Bob. That's right. With Michael's money. I don't think I got to worry about that anytime soon, but well, Jim, thanks so much for making time for me and Marcus and your trip up here to Montana. Yeah, I enjoyed it. Thanks for the invite. No, it's always so helpful and the audience gets a lot out of it and keep doing what you're doing. You know, the first thing I asked you, and this was mostly out of fear, I'm like, how long are you going to keep doing this, Jim?

Because I'm afraid that if you retire and just take up, you know, pickleball or something, who am I going to call? Yeah, no, I'm having too much fun. I'm doing too, and not only having fun enjoying what I'm doing, but I feel like I'm being really impactful in some cases on a national level. Yeah. And so.

I've got no, no reason to just hang it up. Yeah. Because so many of us depend on people like you. We need more people like you. I know myself, a lot of people that are my peers that are now retiring and I'm feeling that loss. Like they were like people I turned to for certain things and, and good colleagues and now they're retiring. Yeah. I think that in your graduate programs of wildlife sciences, you should force people to take at least a semester, maybe two of communication. Yeah. Right. I think they always, they have to have some interesting early in my career. We had our information education branch of our department call in some on camera, local TV station people to come in and, and.

talk about, and even run through some mock interviews on camera, talk about communicating with the media, things to do, things not to do. And it was really helpful. It was really, it was amazing. Yeah. I mean, you're talking to a guy who, I was the captain of my high school football team as a junior and a senior, and I had to give the homecoming speech as a junior. And I hated public speaking so bad. I just about wet my pants. And then next year I was hoping I wouldn't get voted captain because I didn't want to have to give the homecoming speech. That's how much I hated public speaking. Yeah.

Now, here I am. People are like, well, how do you cross that bridge? Well, when I was in college, you know, you get to take your electives. I took most of them in communications and public speaking. Oh, I didn't know that. I didn't know you did that when you were in college. Yeah. I forced myself. I'm like, look, someday I got to get over this. And I was going through this whole process of make yourself uncomfortable, make yourself uncomfortable. And so I, that's how I ended up becoming. That's what people need to do in general is to identify their weaknesses and then bolster them up rather than avoid them. Yeah. And so.

That's why I tell that story to some scientists and I'm like, nah, I'm too late for that. I'm not going there, Randy. Nice try. But the summary of all that is I hope that there get to be more communicators out of the science world. Yeah. Because it's, like you said earlier, the best science in the world, if it's not communicated, doesn't have much value. When you were a junior football captain, you probably never dreamed how much you'd be spending on microphones. Zero. None. At that time, most of my money was spent on girls. Yeah, right. And fishing and hunting.

I really lucked out that fur prices were what they were. Because I ran a trap line every morning before I'd go to school. And it was in the late 70s, early 80s. I mean, furs were worth a lot. And then I'd work out in the woods, logging and cutting wood on the weekends. Man, I had way more money in high school than I did in college. But I wasn't old enough to drink when I was in high school, so maybe there's a correlation there, too. But anyhow, thanks so much, Jim. Really appreciate it. Thanks for being here, folks.

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Watch Steps, now playing only on Netflix.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Hunt Talk Radio?

This episode is 1 hour and 34 minutes long.

When was this Hunt Talk Radio episode published?

This episode was published on August 6, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Hunt Talk Radio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.