EPISODE · Oct 2, 2019 · 38 MIN
Baltimore: Sister Cathy and Tom Nugent's Hunt 1
from Foul Play: A Historical True Crime Podcast · host Shane L. Waters, Wendy Cee, Gemma Hoskins
In Sister Cathy's series milestone episode, investigative journalist Tom Nugent joins the... As Gemma and Shane intertwine the threads of journalism and crime-solving, they revisit the unresolved complexities of Sister Cathy's case. Season 2's Foul Play takes listeners into the haunting case of Sister Cathy Cesnik, whose murder eluded resolution, weaving its way into Baltimore's dark urban legend. Sister Cathy, a prospective educational reformer, faced her fate with steely bravery. A graduate of St. Mary's Seminary and University, her dedication to her students was indomitable. Prestigious yet humble, Sister Cathy strove to bridge educational gaps with her innovative teaching methods, exemplifying genuine devotion. The late 1960s was defined by upheaval and revolutionary ideals, with Cathy's disappearance emblematic of societal turbulence. As hatred collided with hope, her unsolved murder carried a piercing indictment of systemic failings and societal indifference. As Tom Nugent joins Shane and Gemma, they examine into his years-long quest to uncover the truth, piecing together elusive facts, buried leads, and shattered hopes. His insight into the ghostly whispers that linger over Baltimore provides a necessary, if unsettling, perspective. Listeners will dive into the careful world of investigative reporting, revealing how journalism can be both a guiding light and a consuming shadow. Tom's account enhances understanding of Sister Cathy's unsolved case and its ever-complicated legacy. We work through the coils of this dark chapter, balancing near-silence and fervent outcry for justice. --- Support Foul Play: Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/foulplaypodcast Website: https://www.mythsandmalice.com/show/foul-play/ Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/foul-play-crime-series/id1525832703 Follow us: Instagram: @foulplaycrimeseries Twitter: @foulplaypodOur Sponsors:* Check out Kensington Publishing: https://www.kensingtonbooks.com* Check out Mood and use my code SHANE for a great deal: https://mood.comAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brandsPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
What this episode covers
In this milestone 50th episode in Sister Cathy's series, Shane and Gemma are joined by veteran journalist Tom Nugent, who brings his investigative acumen to the perplexing case of Sister Cathy Cesnik. With a career dedicated to uncovering the layers of truth in complex narratives, Nugent's involvement in the case provides an invaluable perspective to the series' relentless quest for justice and understanding.Throughout this first part of a two-episode dialogue, Shane, Gemma, and Nugent examine into the many facets of Sister Cathy's investigation, examining the pervasive abuse within the Maryland religious community and the clergy's harrowing betrayals. They explore the complex web of silence that has long shrouded the truth, bringing to light the stories of the victims and the systemic failure to protect the innocent.Nugent shares his personal journey through the labyrinth of this story, from his initial reporting to the resurgence of interest following "The Keepers." His role in the documentary series underscored the unresolved questions and the continued search for answers amidst a landscape of evasion and denial. The hosts and their guest discuss the influence of Nugent's reporting on public awareness and how it has impacted the victims, the church, and the broader community.This profound conversation does more than revisit the past; it ignites a renewed determination to confront the present implications of these dark chapters in history. As always, listeners are encouraged to engage with the narrative, share their insights, and find solidarity and support through itsfoulplay.com.Join us for this in-depth exploration with Tom Nugent, where the pursuit of truth is not just an act of journalism, but a commitment to the greater good, honoring Sister Cathy's memory and the lives of all those affected by this tragedy. Our Sponsors: * Check out Kensington Publishing: https://www.kensingtonbooks.com * Check out Mood and use my code SHANE for a great deal: https://mood.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
NOW PLAYING
Baltimore: Sister Cathy and Tom Nugent's Hunt 1
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Jan 2, 2026 ·47m
Dec 21, 2025 ·46m