I saw my friend on the other side of the street. I was heading to school with the kids. I let go of Mom's hand to wait. I had already forgotten their lunches.
I ran over to hook her. She came out of nowhere. And then... It stopped.
Sometimes the moments that never happen matter most. Volvo's automatic emergency braking helps ensure a safe ending for everyone. Learn more at VolvoCars.ca. And I for an eye podcast contain subject matters that many may find disturbing.
Listener discretion is advised. Hey, Goss, what labels they give me? Does it mean that that's what I am? You can make me an officer.
I call it a killer. Demon challenge, say you need a car. I don't care what the name you give me. It doesn't mean I ask a line.
Welcome back everybody. We are here today to present to you our friend eye podcast, your favorite true crime podcast part of the Murderly Network, which we are so proud to be a part of. If you haven't already, check out murder.ly, which is a website. It feels weird not saying.com, but that's the website where you can find all of our Potter and Pod family, our true crime pods that you will love on there.
But we're going to get into it today. I am your hostess always. So I'm your host Lisa. I'm your host Lisa.
I'm your host Lisa. Come and ask you strong with our guest co-host that is a reoccurring guest co-host on the show because we all love it and death. And my trusty co-host is streaming and screaming. Our girl Cara, say hi to everybody.
Hi. So Cara's here with me today getting into, again, a little bit why I started this podcast. I have these conversations in real life with Cara, with Matt, with Randall and friends here and everyone willing to listen to me talk about true crime. This is a case that Cara and I have actually spoke about.
And that's how this came about. It was one of those where it was like, yo, we should do it. It was your answer to one of my questions on one of my episodes. Yeah, yeah.
We'll get into that because we don't want to spoil it. But basically, in this case, definitely not for the faint of heart. It's really disturbing. And it's really, really sad for multi-toot of reasons.
So trigger warning right here right now. A kid does. A little kid. Yeah, really, maybe kid horrible, horrible way.
It's really messed up. This whole case is just really horrible. So I just wanted to throw out a trigger there if those kind of things, if kids, well, it should have said, you know what, but you know, if that's a trigger for you, this is not the episode to listen to today. So if you're still with us, we're talking about Eric Smith today.
Let's get into it, Cara. So for some background about Eric Smith, he was born on January 22nd, 1980. That makes him 48, 38, 38 in Cuban County, New York is where he was born. He spent his early years, like many other children, spending time with his grandparents, playing outside, going to school.
And his grandparents would say that he'd always come in and give them hugs and kisses. And he liked being a clown. He gives me like a gacy vibes, but I don't think it's going to be a bad idea. I'm not mean to laugh at that, but that's kind of funny.
Guys, we're trying to never be the same. You're right. We'll cause our fucking skin. You're not going to get a gacy vibes.
You should be on it. There we go. She's coming back. Yeah, that's what causes her.
Pretty being a matter of what. I don't know if they were until I've been to the Museum of Death, which has the largest collection of gacy art. Didn't you like draw himself as clown? Oh, yeah.
I'll look at this. That's nature clown. I'm sorry, no proof. You should have snore.
They have people that just stand there. That's annoying. I get it, but I guess it's annoying. So during her pregnancy, it was said that Eric's mother continued to take her epilepsy medicine.
Try to get on. Try to get on. Don't add that. That might be very wrong.
You know I'm about an sensation, pronunciations, any kind of an sensation. Which if admitted start doing pregnancy, you can leave Dufidel try methadone syndrome. Maybe it's a pronunciation. It looks like it.
Try methadone. Try methadone. That eye is messing with me. But this may result in some issues with the child that could cause facial dysmorphism, like a short up to her nose, slantid eyebrows, cardiac defect, intrauterine growth restriction, and mental retardation.
So we can just fuck up your pregnancy. It's not good to stand this medicine. Right. And I don't know if that was really widely reported back then.
I don't know if it's a mom's fault for taking medicine when she's pregnant because I don't know how widely reported that was back when she was pregnant. I feel like it was like lots of us. And it's also one of those things where it's like if you do have epilepsy, how do you manage it when you're pregnant? I'm sure now we have something to do so.
But back then I don't want to be like, oh yeah, she messed this kid up. Eric had lower set protruded ears, thick glasses, a speech impediment, red hair and freckles. No, honestly, I think he looked kind of cute as a little boy. He was a adorable kid.
You might be like a steward little. Yeah, like just like a little red head. Yeah, like a little baby cutie pie. This made him an easy target for bullies when he was growing up.
Makes me sad. And he stated that the constant bullying led him to have extreme pent-up rage. But yeah, I don't think, like they say, that saying that medicine would have caused his like years in physical defect, but I don't think he looked or even still, I mean, I don't think he's like, I don't have a princess. I don't think he's attractive.
Yeah, but I think he's not like a serial killer. Right, he's just like a guy. Yeah, I mean, I think he looks kind of creepy now, but- But that's because you know what he did. Yeah, but you know what I mean, I think I don't know.
I'm so anti-bullying. It's just like it's incredible because I've had a lot of that happen throughout my life, both, you know, very close to me with friends, all that kind of stuff, with family. And I just think it's horror. Like when I have kids, if you bully them, mama bears, I'll take you down.
And I'm gonna take your house down. Mama wolf's coming out. In my head, I just saw your chocolate chimes. See, that's what's gonna happen.
So don't mess with my children because we have Russian blood. We during vodka smeschblas over here. But yeah, I have no tolerance for bullying in any form, whether you're old, young, short, tall, big, small, whatever, I think it's disgusting and it's really sad and no one deserves that. So this is like- We see the things that happen because of it.
And but also people get bullied and don't do these things, but like it's, you're right. It's just, it's, it's a mess up where we live in. It's really sad that, that it's even a thing. But I mean, I'm sure bullying always is going to be around, unfortunately.
However, I do think with our generation, as we still become the majority, more tolerance is being brought into the mainstream. So, you know, I feel like bullying that stems from somewhere. Like I don't feel like people are born hating other people. I think that's taught or it's like learned from experience, like watching.
So I think as our generation starts to kind of take over the majority, we're, you know, I think we're kind of straying away from that being a thing that's tolerated. That's what I was trying to say. So again, huge, huge, huge trigger warning. This is horrific.
We're going to get into the, the grisly details of everything right here. I think it's important to know because it really does kind of go with I for not. It kind of, it's, it's something you need to consider when you're thinking about what happened here. And we'll go over that in more detail, but there's horrific crimes against a small child coming up ahead.
So I want to give that additional warning now if you are not into a gory things. I mean, I hate when I say like into because like everybody knows I'm not into any of this. But you know what I mean? If that's something that really offends you or you can't hear like me and I can't even, I don't want to make these equipment.
So you know what I mean? We're going to get into the new three. So in August 2nd, 1993, so that makes Eric 13 years old. He was riding his bike to his summer day camp in a local park that he had gone to in the summer.
Along as well, he spotted a four year old Derek Robbie who was alone walking to the day camp. Now, no blame anybody. I'm just commenting. It's crazy that a four year old could.
I mean, it was a different back. Yeah, back in the end. I can't hear it doesn't seem that long ago. When I was born.
Yeah. This was like right after I was born. So Derek was two, three years older than us. Oh, I didn't think about it like that.
That makes him really sad. But he was just crazy that a four year old could walk to more because Chandler is my nephew with six and he's not walking anywhere by himself. It's a different world. I really agree.
I think it's um, yeah, you're right. I mean, like we said, no blame throwing anywhere. She did explain it and I can't remember what she did. I think I wrote about it a little later on.
But you're right. I mean, I can't imagine any. My mom's a preschool teacher. She deals with four years.
I don't think. I don't think anybody are going anywhere alone like that. I can't even pee without someone standing there. Um, but at a different time, I really do believe that's a lot of the reason.
So yeah, he was walking alone. I'm to the state. I don't know how far away it was from the house. She could like see the park from his house.
But in any case. Clearly he wasn't. Yeah. But in any case, clearly, no, I was watching him.
Um, again, no blame nothing like that. We don't want to be insensitive or anywhere. But you know what I mean. So Eric decided to go up to the little boy and alarm off the path.
Now he wasn't really reported what he had said or what he did. I think he kind of was like, hey, this is a shortcut. Cooler, older boy, you know, and you when you're four, or even when you're 13, you know, when you're dealing with someone older than you, you're like, oh my gosh, yes, like that's exciting. I want to do it.
I want to be, you know, like with the mature kids. And as a kid, you're not really like, worried you don't think about like, you don't think of other kids being predators. Yeah, exactly. And so, you know, this little kills me this whole time case just hurts my soul.
Yeah, so he lured him into the woods off the path that they were taking, you know, kind of side by side, he was across the street. So he crossed the street, went up to this four year old, little Derek and probably said something along the line, hey, I know Shorka, we're going to see him please come with me. And the boy's probably so excited, which hurts my soul. Julie is core and trusted this 13 year old boy, Eric, and went with him.
So while in the woods, the pent up rage that Eric was talking about from what he blames on, you know, being bullied or, you know, relentlessly tormented in school in his 13 year old's time, and 13 years that he's been on this earth, he exploded. Eric took the little Derek by the neck and began strangling him. Clearly he's four. So he was super overpowered.
Eric then picked up two rocks. One large rock and one smaller rock and brought it down on the little boy's head multiple times, effectively bashing it set in. He then went into Derek's lunch bag and he smashed a banana, which will come into play a little bit later, which is interesting. So that's the point I wanted to add.
He did smash a banana in this little boy's lunch bag and he took Kool-Aid and poured it into the little boy's wounds. Eric also sodomized Derek with a stick he had found and he seemed to pose Derek's body post mortem. So it seems like he was messing around with the body a little bit after death. And I think actually the stick thing was also after death as well.
This would later be brought up in court as the prosecution would say he enjoyed it. He was hanging out with the body he was doing. He wasn't freaked out by what he did. He spent time doing things to the body, which is disturbing on many levels.
Now the cause of death was determined to be blunt trauma to the head, blunt force trauma to the head with contributing at Cixia. So the investigation. So this was, it was daylight, right? Yeah.
Was it a wanted area from guessing? Yeah, he took him off the path into the woods. So like the way I've researched and the way I believe it happened is they were like a cross street from each other. Eric was riding his bike on the one side of the road.
Derek was walking on the other side of the road. He, I think he crossed the road. Eric. I think so, yes.
And he was like, hey, like, we're walking to the same place. I know what I'm imagining. Cause I can't imagine what else he would say that I'd make this little boy go off the, you know, I mean, he could have said a lot for other things. But I feel like, yeah, I'm gonna show you something.
Or I know it's like a secret pathway. Or I have a tree else. You should come check it out. Something that intrigued this little boy.
Or he trusted this kid. He was also a kid, you know, to go with him. So that's important. It's just, these cases aren't easy.
Like we make jokes and I know people sometimes get offended at that. And it's just cause it keeps us from crying honestly. It makes it, it's so dark to research. There's kind of things to go into all of the articles about it.
It's even with the Wikipedia pages for these things hurts. You're so old, young, no matter what. So I do want to know like any time we're giggling on the show, which I know we got for that from the type of news episode, we're not laughing at anything. None of this is funny and we're not sociopaths.
We know that. It's just so dark that like without some kind of light within the conversation, I'd be in a hole somewhere. You know what I mean? I would not be able to do this.
So I just want to say, none of us have laughed during any of this. But I just want to say that if we do crack a giggle somewhere or say something that's seemingly jovial, it's not because we want to like make light of a situation that's so dark. It's cause we're trying not to be trapped in this horrific, crime. Some investigation.
What happened here? Before we move on, I just wanted to say like the point it sticks out to me and that is that he smashed the video and he took Kool-Aid board into the woods. It's all just so juvenile. And I mean, you think about it, he was 13.
Think of yourself and you were 13. I was having a butment spell. I became a woman. I was not, but I was a kid.
Yeah. Yeah. You're not in these days. I mean, it's different now because kids are growing up fast.
They're maturing early. Oh my god, if you saw a picture of me at 13 versus actually, that was cool. I mean, I wasn't. I think I had one blonde streak in my hair, like right at the front.
And I would. 13 is what, seventh grade? 6, seventh grade. Come on there.
But you're just a kid, like especially back in the 90s, kids or kids. But yeah, so what an investigation. So after the murder, Eric, Kool-Aid returned home as if nothing had happened. And around 11 a.m.
Derek's mother, Doreen, went to the park to pick up her son, only to find that he had in a ride to the camp that day. Which I can't even imagine. The panic that would have gone over you. In a state of panic, she immediately called the police and set out to find her son after only four hours of her extensive investigation.
Which is pretty quick for that kind of thing. I think because of his age, I mean, we were actually, it's going to seem like a lot longer ago when this airs. But yesterday I did a recording with Matt. And we were talking about this.
Do you know what the missing child's time frame is? So you know how sometimes for 18 years, like 24 to 40 hours or something, do you know what the stipulations are per age? I don't. Because I feel like with young kids like this, it's like instant.
They don't waste time. But sometimes it's like if it's an 18 year old, they'll give it 24 hours, they might have run away. Obviously a four year old son. I'm running away.
Yeah. So I think there is. There's 100%. There's a difference.
I just need to look more into it what it is. So like you said, they found it quick. And again, a 13 year old isn't being too, I don't want to say clever, but they're not being. He doesn't think through.
I don't want to say smart either. But I'm sure he did effectively put the body somewhere that's not really found. Yeah. So immediately this case made headlines.
It do immediately the age of the victim, the perfect nature of the crime. And it would say in the headlines, once the age of the killer came to light as well. Which really makes this case unique. Five days later, August 8, Eric would confess the awful truth to his mother and the Smith family informed law enforcement later that night.
Which I reminded me of the case who was it. I think the girl thinks Maddie. Maddie Clifton? Yes.
Where the mom is going to? The case messes up too. We're going to cover it, of course. But I always, and like, go mom.
Oh, yeah. Because can you imagine how hard that is? You know you're about to give your kid effectively. Unless things go wildly different for you in court.
You know when you're reporting something that serious to the police that you have a chance you're never going to see your kid outside of a jail cell again. But knowing that was the right thing, you're not going to be right. Oh, I just can't imagine. Or does Coles see them or maybe?
Right. So when investigators questioned Eric, at first he denied him seeing Derek. But then he started to slowly admit that he did see him. He described what he was wearing.
And he affected his point of view at the scene of the crime. Yeah, so he was pretty much letting investigators. Because he didn't. I don't think he realized what he was doing.
But he basically told people that he saw him exactly the time. He disappeared. You know what I mean? He put himself where they found the boy.
Yeah. So throughout the investigation, Eric seems to be enjoying himself when he would give the investigators little glimmers of information. It seemed like he had it was kind of like a game in his mind almost as how they kind of reported it. I'm not 100% sure if that's accurate.
But that's what investigators said. They said he would light up when he said certain things and then he would get real quiet one other thing. So his grandfather later admitted that they knew he was hiding something from the family that day. He realized that quickly something was going on with Eric that didn't seem quite normal.
And he said, quote, in no way did we feel he had done it. So we felt that he knew something, maybe someone had threatened him. That's why he wouldn't tell. So they thought he knew something about this.
Because he was acting a little strange when it would be brought up. However, they didn't think he would have had anything to do this not in a million years. So that's never going to be like your first assumption. So it's not.
Unless you like a little sociopath. Unless it's like, have you seen a movie when you talk about having which is another movie we're going to have to reveal? No. Oh, you have to see it.
It's also a book. But it reminds me of that. Unless you were that mother, you're not going to expect your kid to be this kind of person first. So shout out to it when you talk about having a great movie.
We'll do it on stream and stream at some point. So this is where the banana thing comes in. It's really interesting. I found this through some research.
Yeah. And we actually, I was researching this on my lunch break at work. And I would turn to Karamik. Did you know that this is so?
You wouldn't know this just from the algorithm. I heard it on another podcast. Yeah. I think it was my favorite murder.
Yeah. Yeah. I don't remember the first one I heard about that. Well, mine was probably a killer kiss.
I've known about this case for a long time, but I didn't know that detail in the past couple months. So this was interesting. So neighbors and friends admitted to believing that Eric had known something as well. So his family and also neighbors and family friends kind of thought something was up with the little boy, which he can't imagine the feeling that gives you either.
He would ask questions to other neighbor families and friends, like, quote, what would happen if it turned out to be a kid? End quote. And the responses were normally several online. So I think they would need some serious help.
And he would be like, OK, and walk away. Now, Marlene Huskel, who was friends of Eric's family, was the one who reported having these conversations with Derek, not Derek, but Derek the most. OK. Which one was going to happen?
Yeah. Derek and Eric are like the same name without a D. But she said that he was always questioning about DNA, like how that works, and what that would show if they found DNA on his body. And it just seemed like more than the average child curiosity, kind of like a Mary Bell where they were like, oh, how did you die?
I want to see him in his casket kind of thing. I mean, obviously, he didn't say that part. But it seemed like he showed a morbid interest, not just like a general kid interested in what's going on. It was more morbid.
And that's where red flags started going up in the family friends, and especially Marlene Huskel's mind. Now, there's more details throughout the crime on the news, because this is obviously really widely reported, trying to figure out who had done it. Marlene had some theories that were wrong. Now, yeah, at the scene like we talked about, there was a smashed up banana.
And because of that, Marlene suspected that the crime had to have been committed by a child who didn't like bananas, as she figured an adult would not have just thrown away a banana if they did not like it. Question over before I move on. Is Marlene just coming up with this or did they not feel like was it suspected that it was a child? I'm just going to get to this is all happening within the first five days.
Now, is it just her own personal thing? I think it was her own thing, but I'm not 100% drawn. I mean, I don't know. If anyone knows, let me let us know.
I know it was reported that that was at the crime scene. Clearly she knew that that was a thing. So maybe it was. Maybe she got that theory from an investigator.
Because I was just going to say that to this point. If I saw a smashed up banana on the floor, I would not immediately think, oh, a child smashed up a banana out of anger at bananas. I would think someone probably stepped up on a banana near the scene. You know what I mean?
I mean, I guess I knew that that was packed for his lunch. So that probably impacted as well. But my first thought when I read this was not, oh, like it's an angry child who hates bananas. My thought was, oh, like, anyhow, stuff.
And if I saw a watermelon, I'm not going to sign it. I could go through a underground. It's just a weird thing to pick up on. But maybe I think you could be right.
I think that could be part of the differentics of it. Maybe that was because I don't know who would think that. But that's what she thought. She thought whether it was Fattua or whether it was actually her own thought.
She did have that idea. This is some sleuthing. Yeah, it's pretty amazing. Actually reading this, I do think that it came from her brain.
Because if it was reported, she would have been like, oh, OK, did this. If it was just her sleuthing around, then it's a theory. It seems like it's a theory. What if I kid did it?
Yeah. So she's like, oh, it's all out on that. So of course, super sleuthing Marlene decided to go to the store and get Sundays for all the kids, making sure to include bananas on every single Sunday. Now, clearly, they had a close neighbor.
The kids were always around each other. So she thought to herself after doing a little sleuthing that since she believed it would have to be a kid who doesn't like bananas. Let's feed bananas to all the neighborhood kids and see which one doesn't need it. Which I don't feel like that's the most accurate way to do this.
But it seemed to work out for her because I wouldn't eat bananas back then either. I don't like bananas that much. So my ass would have picked the bananas off too. But it was interesting because it did work out in Marlene's favorite.
She gave the kids these Sundays, all of them have bananas. And she stated, quote, I went up to the store and I bought ice cream and nuts in syrup in bananas. And I went home and asked everybody if they wanted Sundays. Of course, they all did.
Eric was going to have the nuts in the syrup, but he did not want banana. No, I don't like bananas, he said. Immediately she called Nancy and she said, Eric doesn't like bananas. I'm scared.
End quote. Real Canadian Superstore has everything you need this back to school season. Save on lunchbox savers like Ziggy Slice Dellingy Product for always 375. And get life brand pure Vita shampoo or conditioner for $8 each.
At Real Canadian Superstore, when you're ready, we're ready with the whole world and more. So that's the stuff. It sounds like based on what he said, it was more of an outburst, not like a, I don't say. I don't like it.
Yeah, like no two things. Yeah, I think they found bananas. It was like a four-year generous offer. Which maybe?
I mean, I don't know because I don't know how why the banana thing was reported clearly it was because they knew about it. But I wonder if that was a point that Eric knew that that was something that they were looking into maybe, or like the bananas really pissed them off. I'm not sure. And they were near where this happened that didn't like bananas.
And that was her theory that that had to have been. And with all the questions he was asking and just everything together makes him a pretty likely suspect. Right. So we're going to take a quick break to just not think about this for a second.
And we'll be back. So let's get into the investigation. Well, we kind of went over the investigation, but the conviction. What happened?
So Eric Smith was brought up on the second degree murder charges and just a second degree murder definition. That is, that's not premeditated. What makes what's the difference between first and second? Second degree is any intentional murder with malice afterthought.
Second degree murder is ordinarily defined as an intentional killing that is not premeditated or planned nor committed in a reasonable heat of passion. So it's not like a passionate artist. It wasn't planned. You just got mad and you did it.
But it was not passionate. Yeah, it's a killing caused by the dangerous conduct. The and the offenders obvious lack of concern for human life. So what's that?
So what would a third degree murder be? Would that be an active passion? I think so. Yeah.
Kind of a passion surgery. So first degree is planned. You planned it out. You knew exactly what you're going to do.
You went with the intent to kill second degree murder is you didn't plan it at all. But you ended up killing someone and it was kind of planned right then. It was just like then and there you kind of knew you're going to kill someone. And then third degree is you just fucking explode it and kill someone.
So first degree murder is where first degree. Yeah, because it was second degree. And third degree I can't think of that kind of passion. And I think that that penis off.
Yeah. I think he didn't talk. Yeah. I think what makes this second degree murder and not third degree murder because he would, I think Eric Smith would probably say this was third degree murder because he said he had the brain disease exploded.
However, they said that we'll get into this a little bit more when we start talking about it. But they said that he intentionally crossed the street and let him into the woods which showed that he knew that he was taking him out of public eye to do something nefarious. So I think that's what makes this second degree murder. And not.
It's like, it's not an area. That makes sense. Yeah. Yeah.
So he was brought up on second degree murder charges. The jury heard that as a toddler he threw temper tantrums and bang his head on the floor, which sounds a little different than the story the grandparent said that we talked about at the beginning when he was cuddly in love with the community. He was like a little clang. And head injury.
Maybe. The trifecta. Yeah. Did he win his bed?
I don't know. I don't think you heard animals either. I think they're on the floor is just more like people that's like their head. Or when I get murder charges all the time, people always have head injuries that end up committing horrible crime.
Boys and I, it's called the, the McDonald's child is peeing the bed setting fires and killing it. Oh, OK. Head injuries is just also. I just think it was like my fear murder.
Like, it's just a thing. They don't stay on LP2. So I think it could be. Like the whole banging their head on the floor.
That's like a thing. What is that opposition to fine? That's like a, that's actually nowadays. That's like what that's a good symbol of her.
A good symbol. You don't think that's a good symbol. I had speed problems. He was held back at school.
He was relentlessly bullied. Which again makes me really sad. When he asked for help with his anger, his adoptive father did not seem equipped to give it to him. His dad cited a, what was he adopted?
Was it a stepdad? I think it was a stepdad. I think like the mom's husband adopted him. Like you have to do it.
Like officially adopted. Yeah, like Eric's real father gave up right. Yeah, OK. That's what happened.
So his dad cited a conversation he had with Eric. Quote, he was really upset. He was crunching his fist and shaking and told me that, quote, dad I need help. I said, hold it.
When I got angry when I was here, H.I. I described a bag in our barn and started beating on it until I was too tired to do anything else. I heard a door shut and I turned around and he was gone. And I got to the window.
He was coming back in the door and he was calmed. And I looked down. And I noticed his knuckles and his hands were kind of skinned up and bloody. I asked him what happened.
He said I hit the tree a couple times. It seemed to be OK. Which I've seen with the dad I'm good intentions, trying to help him. It just, like they said, not equipped.
It is kind of sad also that he did kind of ask for help. He said, man, I have this anger inside me. What am I supposed to do? And like you said, I think the dad meant well, 100%.
This is, Matt always talks about this. He talked about it in the last episode. He always says that his dad took him into a garage and taught him how to beat up when he was bullied. Because Matt, he talks about it on a show.
He dealt with bullies in his life as well. And the way his dad taught him how to deal with it was beat the shit out of the person that's being you. And which I don't think he ever really did. But I think that's one of the things where it's like, sometimes that's how dads think that just beat it out.
And that's not malicious. That's not. But in a way, do you think, I mean, this case is interesting for that reason too. But do you think not intentionally at all, but do you think that kind of taught him to take his anger out physically?
For sure. Instead of like, taught to a therapist. Yeah, 100%. This will be an interesting way to have a Matt.
Because he keeps telling me that that would end all be all for bullying. One time when I got mad when I was a kid, I punched a door. And I got in trouble. And I never did it again.
Yeah, I'm not a violent person physically. I'm a bad person. My words. And that's why, because I would have got my ass buried alive.
Yeah, my parents didn't appreciate a punched door. Yeah. I'm pretty good at all. But it's interesting.
Obviously, this is not playing right. We think he had the best of intentions. It's just interesting that he kind of let him down. The hey, just hit it out.
He'll make you feel better if you just physically punch a bag. Which is interesting. I just wanted to talk about that person. Because that is interesting.
And Matt and I, like I said, have this debate often. Because I have bullying very close to my family. And Matt and I have debated this. And I'll bring him in.
We can talk about this another time. But basically, he was saying, you know, I was taught to fight. I think it all depends on the person that's being a true person. 100%.
Yeah, 100%. This guy Eric's just had pre-existing issues. And it's a little too. Not now, if you.
And so getting back to these on defense psychiatrists, doctors gave him hermodynamic with intermittent explosive disorder and control of the rage. Not not laughing. It just seems funny that that's the diagnosis. Yeah.
Does that do it? Uncontrolled of the rage. However, not the control of it. Yeah.
The prosecution experts had a rare disorder that was rarely seen at this age. And we talked about this, I think it was on the Monday episode, about how in courts they're always just like, oh, he has this. And this and this. And everyone's kind of like, yeah.
It's hard because everybody wants an explanation. And I think sometimes there isn't one. They're just kid was angry and lash out. Like I could punch another wall.
And that doesn't mean I have intermittent explosive disorder. I could explode it intermittently. Yeah. He was subjected to extensive medical testing from specialists from both sides of prosecution and the defense.
And Dr. Herman still believe there was something wrong. Quote, something happened in his brain, but we can't measure it. Why?
I don't know. And they did say that when they examined his brain, that the hormone levels were normal. Like they didn't find anything to indicate that he had these explosive rage problems, which is interesting to know. It's interesting to see that he was examined a gazillion times.
One side says, oh, you have all of these disorders. And you have a control of a rage. And the other side says, there's absolutely nothing off about your brain chemistry to explain why this would have been the outcome. Which is interesting.
I was talking about this with my cousin saying not to get so sidetracked, but I always find it really interesting how the defense and the prosecution lay things out so differently. I mean, this is not the best case for the example. But I was listening to a podcast where, and I think I talked to you work about this, where the two sides had completely different ideas of what happened. And my question was, do you think lawyers just kind of make things up using evidence to try to fit a story that would better help their client?
Or do you think this is the story that they were actually told by their client? And they submit it to try to get them the best outcome possible? I mean, I'm going to ask a few lawyers. I think it's dependent on the scenario, though, in the evidence presented and what the prosecution has.
I'm sure there's a lot of factors that go into it. But sometimes it's just like, like, Casey Anthony, how do we go from drowning in the pool to being overdosed? You know what I mean? It's just a very, very different stories.
And I know that a lot. I mean, not those they bias, but I know they're a lot of defense lawyers are you called? I know some defense lawyers are going to go, like, if you did it, don't tell me you did it. Well, because then I think that's also like a bias.
How can you morally defend? I mean, I guess they're job. But how would you morally defend? I asked my uncle that.
Again, we're getting a little chopper. It's interesting. And I think it has to do with this. But I asked my uncle, who is a defense attorney, when they hope to get on the show.
But I think I swear too much is it right now. Yeah, he's in school, so in Pittsburgh. He, I asked him when I was younger, because I've always been interested in true crime. And I'm sad I didn't pick his brain more, but I didn't think of these questions then.
But I basically asked him, like, how do you defend someone when they did something so horrible? Like, how wouldn't you want them to be put away? And his response was pretty much, and I was younger, so we didn't really go into much detail. But his response was pretty much, like, at least it's not my job to decide whether they're or not it's my job to get them the best possible outcome for what they are charged.
That makes sense. Which is interesting, but then I wish I would have followed up now with, but do you make up a story to get your guy off or do you take the evidence that's there and use that to your, you know, like how does that work? I don't know, I should ask my ex, he's a lawyer, because I don't think he's a defense lawyer, but it's all interesting. It's all interesting.
So both sides were saying different things. One of them saying his brain's messed up, and he has these rage issues. And one side was saying, I'm not seeing any of this in his brain, there's nothing in his brain chemistry to explain why this would have been the outcome. So I thought that was pretty interesting.
So of course, the prosecution made it a point to that Smith knew full well that his actions were wrong because he admitted, like we're talking about earlier, that he lured Derek into the woods for this sole purpose of killing him so no one could see. Because like he said, if it was third-degree murder, if he just like, he kind of explains just blew up with all that pent up rage, he would have killed him right down the street. It just would have, you know, it wouldn't have been that forethought to take him out into a, like a wooded area where he could not be seen. So it's interesting because that was a huge point that was made by the prosecution.
They said, hey, clearly you knew you were doing something that was not right. Clearly you had a plan in your head, because you took him out of eyesight. You know, if this was just an explosive thing, you would have done it right then and there. Throughout the trial, Eric Smith's face was you're really blank and I think that probably has lots to do with his age and the confusion of the case and I'm sure, I think it's just, I think all of this is just a mess.
But I don't think that that's fair. You know what I mean? I just don't know if he was really, I think you can be a shop, you can be- I don't know if he was really, I think- Don't make any facial expressions at all, because he's a piece of this. I know, if he was a bias talk, he's anti-bluic smile all the time.
Yeah, and he told, the prosecution told the parents to not react to anything. I don't think that part is fair. It's gonna be interesting to just guys drive for this case because I have some thoughts and carrots and thoughts and I don't know if they completely line up. I don't know if they do or not.
I still don't be friends. I have some thoughts. Yeah, actually she's never gonna be on the podcast. I'm just kidding.
Throughout his trial, he seemed to show no emotion and seem to express no remorse. But like we said, we don't know if that's completely fair because sometimes we talked about, they're told to not say a thing, not do a thing. Pretty much anything you say or do will be used against you. That's kind of like, you know, if he blinked the wrong way, I'm sure people would be like, oh my gosh, he's a nasty killer who has a devil for soul.
It's all like personal perception. Yeah. That's what perception is. But it is kind of interesting because when you think the defense would be like, cry.
I don't think that really makes you any more sympathetic. Yeah, I guess you're right. And almost makes you a gun hinged. Yeah, but I feel like if you show the remorse, you have more people saying like, oh, he feels bad.
Whereas clearly what he was, what he did isn't working for him because people like he's an emotionless monster, even though he's 13 years old. You know, it's interesting. I'm curious. I think everything would be perceived anyway.
Or like being over dramatic or anything. That's interesting. I think also I guess I'm kind of comparing it to how I feel. I would react if I was convicted or something like this.
I think why I could never kill anybody. But I feel like if I did, I would be horrified by myself. So I feel like I would cry. And I would just be so shaken up because how could I've done that?
So maybe that's why it was reported like he's a monster. Because normal perception is, quote unquote, normal possession. You'd be shaken up if you were remorseful. Now in August 16, 1994, so the year after, Smith was convicted of a second degree murder and was convicted of second degree murder in sentence to the maximum term then available for juvenile murders, which was a minimum of nine years to life in prison.
Smith was held in a juvenile facility for three years and then was transferred to an open prison for young adults. In 2001, he was transferred to Clinton Correctional Facility and Deanna Nemora, New York, which is a maximum security prison. While in jail, it is interesting to note that Smith wrote an apology letter to Robbie's family, where he read on public television. And I think he was told to do this by his parole lawyer or whatever.
So he said, and they quote, I'm just saying I can find a clip of this. So if I can, I'm going to answer that clip here. If not, you're going to hear me read it. So he wrote, I know my actions have caused a terrible loss in the Robbie family.
And for that, I'm truly sorry. I've tried to think as much as possible about what Derrick will never experience. His 16th birthday, his 16th birthday, Christmas, any time, owning his own house, graduating, going to college, getting married, his first child. If I could go back in time, I would switch places with Derrick and endure all the pain I've caused them.
If it meant that he would go on living at such places that I can't. At the end of the statement, he states that he cannot bear the thought of walls, razor wire, and steel metal bars for the rest of his life. He also apologized to Derrick Robbie in interviews. Now, he has since been denied parole nine times since 2002.
So he was first up for parole eight years, September, which brought us to 2002. And most recently, he was denied an April, this past April, so like two months ago. In 2004, Derrick's family sent a letter to the parole board along with a video showing Derrick's short life. So they wanted to make it a point.
We lost someone. As a result of this guy, we won't have these. We don't have any more than this. This is all we have of our son.
So after the field, 2002, hearing parole board cited a concern for public safety in its decision. And Robbie's parents opposed his release. So they said, you know, they weren't gonna let him out because they feared that he would be a threat to the public. And of course, they took Robbie's parents and the thoughts into consideration.
At that hearing, he told a parole board he would not return to Savonia if released. Instead, or Savona if released. And instead, it would go to a shelter at Halfway House. So he was kind of saying, you know, I'm not gonna go back there.
I'm not gonna like terrorize this family. I'm gonna get the help. I'm gonna take the steps to properly be put back into society. I don't, I'm not asking you to put me back on the streets tomorrow.
I'm asking you to give me that opportunity to be in this halfway. I mean, he didn't say any of that, but I'm guessing that's what he meant but I wanted to go to the shelter at the Halfway House. Now, at his 2014 parole hearing, Smith said he had been bullied by other children at school and also by his father and older sister. And he confessed that he took his rage on Robbie so he killed him.
And that was the first time it was noted that he kind of gave a reasoning for why he'd awaited it. Because then before that, it was kind of his defense team talking for him. But this is the first time out of Smith's mouth that he said, this is potentially why I did what I did. So he also said in that same parole hearing that the stick was inserted in order to ensure death, which is gross and confusing, but I guess that was just something he did in his brain to ensure that the little kid was not.