Part of the Press Play Podcast Network. Look up in the sky. It's a bird. It's a plant. It's... This is Jason J. Lewis, the voice of Superman on Justice League action. This is Mark Waid. You're listening to The Crypt on the Earth.
Welcome to the Krypton Report special Batman Day special. That's right, I said special twice. You know why? Because this is an extra awesome day. And we have a full house for a really cool conversation. If you tuned in and listened to our Multiverse Justice League episode, this is kind of a companion piece to that. We're going to go through our Batman villains and pick who we think are the greatest live actions that we've gotten so far of Batman villains. And I can't do this alone. I have with me my usual, the man in red, the man with the beard, the man who makes all other men jealous, Mr. James Cole.
Yeah. Thanks. How's it going, Tyler? I think I'd come up with something by now, but man, it's always some, some kind of different, interesting, funny hype stuff. It just makes me think of like, I'm a, I can't remember his name. Damn it. Uh, Michael Buffett. No, I'm a, from a Knight's Tale. Oh, Chaucer. Yes. And, uh, he's a Heath Ledger. But also, as you heard, I got, we got from, from the gravely amusing podcast. It's host, my buddy, my best friend, the guy who pretty much just put a cot in the living room and live here. Mr. Brian Peters.
Hello! And then, couldn't do this without my boy Solomon. That's a long pause there. Hey, alright, good job Solomon. Hey, how's it going? I'm trying to make it mysterious. You know, mysterious. And then, we brought in some new blood to the Krypton Report. I'd like to introduce all the way out in pretty much Woodsboro, California. Dre.
Great to be here, man. Glad you're here. And then, last but not least, we welcome the man whose beard might start to rival James, a young Chris Kringle from Santa Claus is coming to town, Trey. Nice comparison there. I haven't heard that one. Take it back to high school. Hey, I love that show. I got that a lot as a kid. But it was a good show.
But, you know, we're coming up. See, I'm kind of a special, like a two-in-one package. I was born on Easter Day, so I'm the Easter Bunny and Santa Claus, so. He is the ultimate gift-bringer. That's me, his new intro. The ultimate gift-bringer. There we go. You're born on Easter? Mm-hmm. The floating holiday. It mixed up, Christmas. It mixed up, Easter.
A bunny rabbit who delivered a present for the children. I put eggs in the gift boxes. When people open Christmas presents for him, they have eggs. All right, here we go. We're going to start off. These are not Batman villains, but I did want to go down a whole thing of Batman characters. We kind of covered that on our last episode, but these were not included. But we're going to talk about first and foremost, the most important member of the Batman family. We're going to start with who is your favorite Alfred. We're going to go in this order. We're going to go James, Dre, Trey, Brian.
Solomon than me. Okay. So Mr. Cole, start us out. Alfred. Michael Goff in live action. Solid answer. I don't think we can really argue with that. Four movies. He's got some great sarcastic comments to all of his Bruce Wayne characters and he's very guiding. All right. Dre. No, you're fine. Nice. Nice. I'm sure that I'm sure that won't be the only time that he's mentioned.
Trey, your outfit. For me, it's going to be Michael Caine. I mean, I really don't feel like I need to justify my answer there. As long as no one says Ian Abercrombie, then there is no justification needed. Okay, okay. See, I thought that Finch would have went with Ian Abercrombie, you know? Abercrombie Finch. Hey! All right, Brian, what you got? Michael Goff. I had to. Like, he just... He's that father figure. He's...
You know, the older gentleman, he's got the sarcasm, he's got the wit. The only reason I almost didn't choose him is because of Batman 89, he lets Vicky Vale in the Batcave. Yeah, I've probably never done that. And he got called out for it in Batman Returns. He sure did. Somebody let Vicky Vale in the Batcave. But that's my choice, and I'm sticking through it. All right. Solomon. I pick Jimmy, Jeremy, Iron Iron. Irons. Irons.
Excellent choice, sir. I and Jania both picked Jeremy Irons. When they announced Jeremy Irons, I was like, okay. I didn't see it. But seeing the movies, I was like, yeah, I really like him as Alfred. But I also think he works great as like that kind of newer idea of him being more like MI6, a little bit more Batman's sidekick, or not sidekick, but partner, more than just being just a butler. But like I said, there is no wrong answer. I wanted to say Andy Serkis, but I was just like, eh, it's a little early so. Yeah, that's really how I feel about Andy Serkis.
Yeah, Jeremy Irons is the best one, but I knew that was going to come up plenty, and Michael Goff needs some love. Yeah. All right. Okay. Go ahead. I can't even talk. Badwin Brown over here. Jeremy Irons is an Alfred I wanted more of. I think if we got more Jeremy Irons, he probably would have been the defendant of Alfred.
Well, if we would have gotten the Batman movie, the Ben Affleck Batman movie, we would have gotten so much more of him. I will say that Jeremy Irons, out of all the people that cameoed in The Flash, he was the most solid. He still felt like the same character. Yep. No inconsistency of this either. Absolutely. When I die and go to heaven, some people ask God, hey God, why did this happen in my life or whatever? He'll ask these same questions. I'm going to ask.
Can I see what that Batman movie was in? Can I see Batgirl too? I'll be like, and Tyler's here somewhere, isn't he? Yeah, he's over there. Let's be real. I'm going to die before you. Okay. After that, more good things. Let's go on to, probably if there is a companion, another one. Let's talk about Jim Gordon. Mr. James Cole. Who is your favorite Jim Gordon? My favorite Jim Gordon, I'm going to go with...
Gary Oldman. Cool. Cool. Solid. Disagreement there. She's mad at you. She's not cool with that. She wanted you to say Batman 66. She's like Pat Hinkle, man. Pat Hinkle. All right, Trey, what you got? I'll hold my explanation as we go. All right, Trey. I'm going to have to say Gary Oldman as well. I just like the consistency of his character throughout the Dark Knight trilogy. Brian. I am going to go with Gary Oldman.
I came very close to Jeffrey Wright. Yeah, very close. But Oldman was just a little bit older. No pun intended, right? What's that? No pun intended, right? Oh, yeah, absolutely pun intended. And he had a little bit more of a connection with – you got a little bit more of that backstory of young Bruce Wayne and that connection. And, like, yeah, it's just slightly better. But I think Jeffrey Wright is really going to knock it out of the park more if he does the job. All right, Solomon. I'm going to have to go with –
The Batman. So I saw him on Jeffrey Wright. Jania went with Gary Oldman. And I went with, this was tough, but I did go with Jeffrey Wright. Because there is an element about him that I feel more with the weight of knowing that people are dirty in his department. And then finding out that people are dirty, like when he finds out Coulson's dirty. And then the way he's leaning on Batman that I just really liked.
You see with Oldman, I think Oldman's great, but there's something in the right performance that I'm really digging. And I like the way he ends his last sentence with man. See, why I chose Oldman is part of that conversation that he has with Aaron Eckhart's Harvey Dent and Dark Knight. Harvey Dent's basically like, we know you work with Batman. We know you're on his side. We know you're hiding stuff. And Gary Oldman's just like, I don't know what you're talking about. It's the facial expression. Speak to maintenance about faulty equipment.
All right. So now we're just going to jump to the top of the list. Okay. You're going to go right for the jugular. Unless you guys want to work up? Okay. All right. I think Joker's too big of a villain to go right to it. Hey, you know what? I mean, it's your big podcast. All right. So this one's a tricky one, but the Wayne Murderers. That was a tricky one for me. And basically what that means is like...
Because it's tricky, but what do you think is the best scene that depicts the Wayne murders? Oh, you mean the best scene? Yeah, like the best murderers. It goes all hand in hand. The scene who killed the Waynes. Siri's the best Wayne killer. See, I didn't think of... Shut up, woman! I didn't think of it as a scene. I can give you that answer right back. But I thought of it more as seeing that actual character.
Well, the problem with that is, in some, it's directly Joe Chill. Some, you never find out who it is. Right. And then we had Jack Napier. So it's kind of like, what do you like? Which depiction? Yeah, I can give you that answer. No problem. So we're going to start with Mr. Cole. Best, I hate saying favorite, but what do you think is the best depicted Wayne Mercer scene? I mean, the best one, my favorite one is the Batman versus Superman, where it's very much like Frank Miller, Dark Knight Returns depiction. Okay. Dre? The hell you just say? All right. The hell you just say?
Calm down, Brian. We've been friends with this guy for 27 years. He says he loves Napier being the killer. We're going to go over here. I haven't seen too many scenes, or at least that scene, but I'm going to go with the classic here, Jack Nicholson. Well, listen, it's the quote.
Like that quote, I mean, at the end of the film, when Batman delivers that quote back to him, that's awesome, man. Tim Burton just, Tim Burton was on that one, right? Yeah. That's what I thought. I mean, he just, perfect. You know, Tim Burton is, you're born and you know who Tim Burton is. You do know that Tim Burton didn't direct Nightmare Before Christmas, right? No. Oh man. I'm disappointed in myself. I'm sorry. That's okay. He gets all the credit, but he does. Yeah. It's, it's his creation. His character. Isn't his name on the title though? It's because he produced it. Okay. He, he wrote it. Okay. He like, did the character design. So basically his name's all over. He just didn't direct it. I gotcha.
He gets all the credit. He didn't direct it. That's the worst choice in that whole movie. You do. You need to do that. All right, Bri. How could you pick... It's okay, man. This is... Hey, there is no wrong answers. We are among friends. It's all about opinions. And this is all about love, man. Okay? So, it's okay. Have a long... Yeah, for me, the best Wayne River depicted is in Batman v Superman.
And the selling scene is when the pearls fall in the barrel of the gun. And as it goes off, the pearls break. I love that. And I love just them kind of laying in the gutter, like forgotten. I thought that Snyder knew what he was doing. We've seen that scene a million times, but Snyder just took it to another level. All right, Solomon, what you got for the Wayne murders? BBS. BBS. Jania has BBS.
Mine, I chose this one for the emotional impact that it left me with is Gotham. It's Gotham. Because the way that Daveed Mazous screams. That one is so good. When the parents are murdered. It's so good. It reminds me exactly of the Greg Capullo page in him and Scott Snyder's one where they jump back and you see the night the Wayans are killed. And it's just Bruce Wayne crying and saying, help. It is so emotional. And to have the kids sitting there screaming. Because every other version we see.
There's either no audio, like in BBS, or he's quiet, like in 89 and Batman Begins. But that scream, it stays with. To let it out. See, that's the correct answer. That's probably the correct answer. Yeah, that scene actually, something I read recently is something that isn't ever considered as Bruce Wayne sat there with his dead parents for, in what was recently revealed, like 90 minutes in that alley along with his dead parents before anybody showed up to help. All right, moving on. Lesser known, but does make a few appearances, Firefly.
I'm going to start with Mr. Cole. I preferred the actress from Gotham. Okay. All right. Trey. Awesome. Trey. I'm going to butcher her last name, but I'm in agreement with James. Michelle. From Gotham. Yeah, from Gotham. I think a lot of people just like to spin on the character because typically, I mean, he's a male character. So, nice spin.
Okay, I'm going to say this. Jania didn't have one. Brian, go ahead. Brandon Frazier. Me Solomon and Brian. We all did Brandon Frazier. I knew it. I knew it. If we would have gotten it. I was going to say we never got it, did we? Nope. It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter. I've seen him behind the scenes. It's out there somewhere. Well, I would have said the same thing if that was the case. Come on now. But, but, but, in essence of fairness, because I respect Ray, I like you respect me for saying Jack Nugger. Give me a break. Goffin, I really like the female twist on that. I like her origin.
Um, it was really, really great, but I can't deny that Brandon Frazier would have knocked it out of the park. Like he, he would have got the stupid humor in it. It would have been like back early year one, like right off the page. It would have been awesome. Yep. But, uh, me and Solomon are still sitting on Brandon Frazier because it's my podcast and I can if I want to. Fair enough. See, that is the rules of being those. So, but I mean the Gotham, the girl in Gotham was awesome, but I just, you know, it's one of those things like Brandon Frazier. I mean, has there ever been a better robot man?
Okay. That's a better George in the Jungle. I mean, no. That guy who did it in the sequel sucked. Right? All right. I forgot there was a sequel. It was that bad. Yeah, it was that bad. You forgot about it. I've seen it again. All right. We're going to take it to Mad Hatter. All right. Mr. Cole. I'm going to have to go with Benedict Samuel from Gotham. All right. Dre.
Trey? This one's going to be a little bit of a hot take because I know the show was really bad. But I'm going to say Amite Marmor still? I just like his look and the style and just how they brought the character to life. From where? That one, that one. Sorry. But I mean, I just like the character style and stuff like that. The color of them. I just feel like it popped from the comics almost. So I liked it. And no, I'm not going to cheat on this one. I could cheat on this one, but I'm not going to, I promise. Because I do have...
On my phone, I do have the behind-the-scenes test photo of Martin Short as the Mad Hatter when they were looking at doing the fifth Batman film. You know, I'd be okay if you said that as your answer. I'm saying I'm not going to cheat. I have a legit answer. I'm just letting you know that that would have been awesome. Brian, go.
Martin Short. Oh, right. Come on now. I've seen that image and it's pretty awesome. No, my real answer. I have a real answer. But Martin Short blew out of the water. I can't remember his name, but the Batman 66, Matt Hatter. Solomon, who did you have for Matt Hatter? Matt Hatter I had is gone.
All right. Jania did not have, for the next few, she didn't have some, so I'll bring her back when it comes time. I, too, chose Batman 66. You wanted Batman 66. I did. So what was it for you? To me, it was just more of the looniness of the character. I found the Gotham a little too serious, and I didn't like the Alice relationship. And the Batman one was cool, but I did like the Batman 66. I chose 66 because in his debut episode, his whole purpose of what he's doing is he's trying to collect all the 12 jurors that convicted him.
He had more sinister motives whenever he appeared. And even though it was a campy show, his motives were always more serious. For the show? Compared to other villains? Compared to other villains, yeah. And he's a redhead. So the next one I have right now is Professor Pig. And I'm pretty sure there was more than one Professor Pig, but then I started second-guessing myself. See, that's why this was hard for me, because I couldn't remember another Professor Pig. I thought it was on Batwoman, but I could have been wrong. So does everyone just have Gotham for Professor Pig?
Yes, I only found one. It was Michael Cerveris. Yeah, that was my blunder. See, okay, I thought so. I thought there was another one, and I started second. I'm going to say that there are some villains that I'm going to eat some crow on on this episode, and I'll talk about it more. But that woman did have a few villains that popped, and they'll come up here. But yeah, Professor Pegg, okay. Because like I said, now, we have, the next one we have is the Joker's Daughter. You guys hear me okay? Yes. Okay, so Joker's Daughter, we'll start with James Cole.
The only one that I can really remember was, and it's because I probably saw her most recently in Gotham Knights, Olivia Rose Keegan. Okay. Trey? Yeah, we'll accept the name, the show, like any of that works. All right, Trey. Olivia Rose Keegan, Gotham Knights. Yep. Brian. Joker's Daughter, eh? Yeah. I put, I don't care. Because I don't care. Wow. Joker's Daughter's less. Okay. But if I have to give an answer, whatever you choose. So, Solomon didn't have one for this. Yeah, I did. But then he wrote one. What do you got? I said Gotham Knights. Yep.
So I have to be more respectful. I'm sorry. I guess the one on Gotham Knights. Well, here's my, I think first of all, the character itself is a weird character. Sure is. And I'm eating crow on this because I finished Gotham Knights because I'm a completionist when it comes to my DC shows, even though I couldn't get past, I couldn't get past the pilot for Naomi and I still have one season to go on legends. And I will say this, this is me eating the crow. I think though I have issues with each of the Gotham Knights themselves, the world that it builds, the way that it used the court.
was much better than I thought it was going to be. And it was actually a better show than Batwoman. And I gave that show so much crap when I saw the first trailer and everything. So I'm eating the crow for that. And I have a whole breakdown of what I think could have really helped with that show. But yeah, so I'm going with Joker's daughter from Gotham Knights because I actually did make sense of why her name is in the comics, Duella Dent.
So they actually do a really good... I was going to say, when I was looking up the character, I was getting like a Dwella Dentnik. I was like, holy moly, that's a mouthful. She's a character that doesn't make sense, and they actually tried to pull it in and it makes sense. I think she comes to the comics after Crisis, or maybe a little bit before. Sometimes those comic origins are so convoluted that it takes a show or something that actually kind of breaks it down to something more that makes sense. Her first appearance was Batman Family No. 6, August of 1976, created by Bob Rosakis. Rosakis, I think.
Yeah, it's interesting. Okay, ready? Solomon Grundy. Let's start with the coal. I will pick Drew Powell from Gotham. He's a cool dude. Yes, it's really the only, he is, and it's really the only portrayal that we had of him, of Solomon Grundy doing anything. You know, I mean, there was Cyrus Gold. Dre's about to drop it on us, because Dre's about to drop it the way Solomon dropped it. All right, Dre, you go for it, because I bet you're about to drop it the way Solomon dropped it on me. Boom, I knew it. I knew he was going to drop it like that.
All right, Trey. I said Graham Shields from Arrow. I mean, when I think I saw him running, I think of, you know, big menacing dude. He looks the part, so. Brian? Stargirl. Stargirl. Tyler. Stargirl.
Because that, we and Solomon were filling out his list. He goes, I said, Solomon Grinney. He goes, you guys got a cheat sheet, huh? He goes, he goes, you know, Stargirl. I go, oh shit, I forgot about that one. So I scratched mine off. I was like, my son dropped it on me. Oh, holy crap. Yeah. Like, I didn't even consider that. It is a live action version in a, in a sort of way. Yeah. Kind of. Kind of. He just looks so great. That's that loophole. And they got the character down really well. Yeah. They really did. Especially in season two. Absolutely. All right. So, Killer Croc. We're going to start with James.
He comes once a year. Santa Claus Cole, go. Adwele from Suicide Squad. I mean, he was very much a carnivore, you know? Ate meat. They talked about him being cannibalistic. You know, they at least portrayed him having some skills, underwater abilities. All right, all right. Dre.
I think it's Ottawa. Yeah. I don't want to butcher his name, but he's awesome. Yeah. All right, Trey. I was going to go with that answer, but then I changed it up to Heidi Ben from Arrow. I have never personally seen the show, but if I was to come across that look compared to Ottawa's Killer Croc, I feel like Heidi Ben's is more terrifying in my opinion, so. All right. Ryan. I absolutely hated Killer Croc in Suicide Squad. I hate everything about it. Me too. And I want to say, Solomon loves Killer Croc. That's one of his favorites. And they butchered it for him in Suicide Squad. In 2020, we used to do, we'd throw theme parties just to entertain ourselves.
And we did Batman Night one night. I dressed as Batman. Genia was Cat 1. Sailor was Harley. He went as Killer Croc. And we got in the car and went to McDonald's for the drive-thru. But he was not happy with Suicide Squad. I did pick Suicide Squad just because I think it was the best of what we got. Genia picked Suicide Squad. I only said who I hated. I didn't say who I liked. Oh, Brian, who do you like? My bad, Brian. I'm sorry. It's hard being the host. He's a fan now. No, I had to look up other Killer Crocs because I hated the Suicide Squad one so much. But the look of the Batwoman Killer Croc, it looked pretty good.
Like, he looks somewhat comic accurate. So I went with that guy. You said Batwoman? Yeah. I went with Batwoman, too, because... Talk louder, buddy. It's just, it's kind of like the Suicide Squad one. It's like the same size, but a little bit bigger. But also, um, the green skin, because I did not like him having a white skin.
Is that the one you got from Batwoman? That's Batwoman, too. That's the one I got from Arrow. Oh, it must be the Arrowverse. Okay, okay. So, okay. Yep. Oh. I don't know. I looked it up. It looks awesome, doesn't it? Yeah, I thought it looked pretty great. All right. Moving on. One of my all-time favorite Batman villains, in a way, or idea concepts, is the Court of Owls. So, we're going to go. James Cole, what do you think is the best Court of Owls?
Okay, well, I actually just went with Talon. I kind of didn't separate them. Yeah, I mean, the best Talon I saw was on Gotham Knights, just the action portrayed from that version. I didn't get to finish the season yet, so I don't know how well the court was portrayed. So the only other court is really Gotham. That's because James is a big Turner Hayes fan now. He's a champion for Turner to come back because James loves Turner. Yeah, he's going to have to have his own moniker. He needs his own spinoff series. Turner Hayes, Man of Crime.
The Dark Knight 2. Turner Hayes for James. All right, Trey. What you got for the Court of Owls? Trey. You're probably going to be disappointed in my answer, Tyler. I said Brandon Allen Smith for Talon from Gotham. Okay. I'm not going to be disappointed. I actually got to interview the lady who was the head of the Court of Owls when we used to do a Batman podcast that we reviewed Gotham and got to interview her. So that was cool. All right, Brian. I chose Gotham only because it's the only one I've seen.
Pathetic. I expect more from you. I told you it was such a high standard, the way you hold the rest of us to a high standard. See, my answer was acceptable. Well, here's the thing. Gotham Knights' trailer was really bad. I know. I know. I'm eating my crow. Dude, I'm eating my crow. I know. Isn't Batman in a suit on the street with just a Bat cow on and he dead? Yeah. I had to wait until the show was canceled on HBO so that they wouldn't be affected by my ratings of watching it. So in saying that, Gotham wasn't that bad. Their talent looked at Kato with an out mask.
You're not wrong. But that's what I chose, and I will change it next year. All right, Soul Man, what you got? I picked Gotham Knights. I picked Gotham Knights, and Janita did too. I really love the way they did the court. Was that the only thing really worth the show, in your opinion? Like they said, the show, the adult characters, the world building, the little things here and there if you're paying attention, the fact that the bass player from my all-time favorite movie appears in Gotham Knights as, what do you call it?
Stephanie Brown's dad was a big surprise. So that actually knocked it up a couple of points for me. I was like, yeah, I mean, you could see the moving pieces. And I, and I think, like I said this before, part of my issue with the series was it was from the people who did that woman. And I thought that moment just when they, it just kept going downhill. So I was like, but all right, we're gonna do the doll maker, James flipping Cole doll maker, Michael Eklund.
I believe he was the Dollmaker in Arrow. Okay. Yes, I believe. He was very creepy. It was when Arrow was really dark. Jania did not answer this one because she looked at me and said, they have not done a version of the Dollmaker that fits the comics that creep me out so much. This is true. He was sufficiently scary and a horrible, terrible person in Arrow. All right, Dre, bring it to us. Yep. Dre. Make a three in a row. Brian.
I went with Gotham. And because that was the only one that was always stuck in my mind. I couldn't remember the one from Arrow. Okay. Solomon, did you answer this one? Yes, I did. And I went with Arrow. And I went with Arrow as well. He was like, he filled them full of that stuff. He seemed menace silicone down their throat. Yeah. Yeah, it was pretty scary. And Michael Eklund, I just watched him in the episode of Smallville where Clark fights Titan. Oh, nice. Yeah. Okay, next on the list. Talia Al Ghul.
I'm going to start with James because always the women start with James. You got to do. Lexa from Arrow. Oh, Lexa Dogel. I don't even, I couldn't remember her last name. I started with a D. I had a D-O-I-G. That's what I thought too. All I know, she's married to Michael Shanks, AKA Smallville's Hawkman. So I found that out in a podcast interview she gave. Oh, I didn't know that. Yeah. Things you learned from listening to people talk. Yeah. That's a good one. All right. Dre. Okay. Trey. Don't hate me, Brian.
I swear to God, if you say the Nolan trilogy, I'm going to just run you over with a card. No, I just want to get a rise out of you. Yeah, it's Lexa for me. That's your choice? Yeah, I'm not going with the Dark Knight Rises. No, absolutely not. It's Lexa from Arrow. Yeah, of course. I mean, yeah. Okay.
I chose the Aeroverse one. Whatever her name was, I can't remember. Alexa. Yeah, that's the one I chose. I mean, she actually somewhat looked like Talia. I mean, that's pretty important. You know, she played it well. Well, me, Solomon, and Jania all chose The Dark Knight Rises. And the reason why? I didn't see it coming. Like, it was all... Oh, really? Like, it was all there, but I really didn't see it coming. Because I was like, no, there's no way. That'd be stupid. Because a five-year-old was like, hey, you know what?
Have her be evil. I can admit though, it was like, you know, it was just, her character's only in for one film. It's like, oh, this is just a side character. That's not important. Wait a minute. There was so much. I told Brian a long time ago that I really wish they would have played with us in the marketing and not let us know that Gal Gadot was Wonder Woman. And I just believe that she was Talia. And then because there's one part in Batman v Superman, she goes to get off the plane and the stewardess says, Miss Prince, you cut that out. The whole time you could tease us that it's Talia Al Ghul.
Because the way she talks with him about the sword and everything, and then you have no fricking clue, there's nothing in the marketing, then all of a sudden Wonder Woman drops in. You're like, oh my God, Brian's on board, I'm on board. You would have been like, you're on board, I'm on board. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So when Tyra and I first talked about that, absolutely. Oh yeah, one of the biggest downfalls for Batman versus Superman was that extended marketing, how much money they put into marketing. Well, the fact that they just kept, every time something happened, someone was cast, every piece of news, like, hey, just know this, know this, know this. All right. Superman's gonna die in this. Enjoy.
Spoiler alert. Jeez. Right. Okay, here we go. This is a good one. I want to hear everyone's thoughts. There is a wrong answer. Oh, no. No, I'm just playing. When you're the host, you can say that. We're going to go with... Or if you're Brian Peters. I will accept other answers to this if you can make me believe why. Yes. Two-Face. We're going to start with James Cole.
I went with Aaron Eckhart. And I don't even feel he is like the greatest portrayal of Two-Face as comic accurate as Two-Face can be. This is why I love James. Because his explanations... James is the greatest critic I've ever listened to. Because the reasons for his answers are always spot on. Yeah. I appreciate that. You should. Because it came from me.
I will say this before we recorded because my wife missed the end of the last episode. I went back and she watched his scene, his two-faced scene because she's a big Supernatural fan. So she's been championing for him. Yeah, I wish I had seen the rest of it so I could at least have that as a reference because nobody else got to be actually two-faced and stand in there. And Tommy Lee Jones was just playing the Joker.
Trey, what you got? I'll let you know. Okay, so I really need to watch the shows, but I said Aaron Eckert. And I was really torn. I know James isn't going to like this, but honestly, like looking back on it, Tommy Lee Jones' character wasn't terrible. I mean, yeah, it's not what everyone expects, but I think it's just because how that movie was written. And let's face it, I like Jim Carrey. I don't think he's a good writer. We'll talk about that. Yeah, but I'm going to stick with Aaron, though. My thing is there's one scene in Batman Forever where Tommy Lee's Two-Face is why I feel like they didn't quite understand the character. It's when they're in Wayne Manor, and...
Like he flips the coin. Yeah. And then he just keeps flipping it. Basically, you don't know why, but basically the scene plays out like he's flipping it so he gets the answer he wants, which isn't the game. Yeah, no, it's it. So, Ryan. I chose Aaron Eckhart.
I almost wanted to say Billy Dee Williams. But I would accept, if you said Billy Dee Williams and you want to tell me why, I would accept it. The only one that would be the hard sell is Nicholas Disargio or whatever from Gotham because he's in one episode in season one. But if you want to try to sell me on Billy Dee, I'd hear your argument. I'd appreciate it. I chose Aaron because we got to see the pretty boy overconfidence of Harvey. You got to see the whole downfall. It was nice. Yeah, we got to see the whole story. All the other Harvey's, you didn't get the whole story. So, you know, we got to see the downfall. We got to see, you know, him flip. The breaking point.
And that CGI, like... It holds up because it's... I remember sitting in the theater at, like, midnight all by myself in Uniontown, Pennsylvania. I went right after work, ready to go. And I was like, oh, my gosh. Like, when he poured that gasoline on him, I was like, oh, man, they're really going to do Two-Face in this? You know, like, I wanted that to be the third movie. But...
When he's laying in that hospital and he finally turns his head, I was like, wow, he looks pretty good. They did pretty well. I mean, I like makeup. I'm all about makeup. It's makeup with CG and parts. And that's why it works is because it's blended together. I liked the take where he got his name in Nolan's trilogy because when he's laying in hospital dead, he's full of anger, rage. Yep, Jim's in there. What was that name they had for me in IA?
And then going back to the CGI, though, when he's in the bar taking that drink of tequila, just out of the side of his mouth, it's like, ugh. That's the way it needs to be. That would hurt so bad. Yeah. That's one of the many reasons that The Dark Knight is such a good film overall. You ready, Selma? Ready to drop the series? Mine is The Dark Knight. Excellent choice. Mine is The Dark Knight, and Jania's as Misha Collins.
So, and like I said, I can't argue with it because you do get a good story and everything. Two-Face is my favorite Batman villain. And I liked Aaron Eckhart, but I still feel that we haven't got the perfect portrayal. We're like, that's it. Like, you know, like that, as we'll get to, as we get up here, as we get to like these definitive characters that we feel, as we get to the ones that have multiple choices, we still haven't got that Two-Face yet. I, like Brian, had hoped that...
Two-Face is going to be the big villain for the third one. They were setting him up. I hope that Matt Reeves puts Harvey Dent in The Batman 2 and that we get a whole movie of just Harvey. And then in Batman 3, he becomes Two-Face. Because we need to know who Harvey is more so we can care about him. Because one thing that I got to... I listened to Scott Snyder talk about Two-Face, and I believe this too, is the character is split.
that sometimes Two-Face does good things because that's part of the other side of him. Too often they lean into the bad side, but it's whatever the coin says. And if the coin says, I think there's an awesome story. if you had two face hunting, say the Joker or the penguin, because that's what the coin dictated. So that side of him led. Yes. That, so that is a side I really missed because when two face first started out and you know, he would flip the coin. If it was on the nice head, he like, he could commit a crime earlier in the day and like rob a bank, but then he flipped the coin later, what to do with the money. And then like, sometimes he would like donate it to charity. Yeah. And like, so they'd be like, Oh my God, what are we going to do with this guy? You know, I like the idea that two fees is not a good guy. He's not a bad guy. The criminals don't. Yeah.
And the good guys don't like it. He's very much alone with himself. But what we need the most in live action is we need that whole movie with Harvey. Just being Harvey. Because who is Batman most afraid of? It's not the Joker. It's not Ra's al Ghul. It's not my mom. It's not your mom. It's not my mom. It's not James Cole's appendage. He's afraid of Harvey. Because every time he looks at Harvey and deals with Two-Face, he feels he failed. It's Jason Todd.
It's Jason Todd, all the times he failed. Gotham, all the times he's not killing Joker, whatever. It's all rolled into one. He looks at Harvey. Going back to the film. He was my friend and I, and this happened to him. There's nothing I can do. And that's what we need. We need that full story of Harvey and then the turn to Two-Face. We need it for character billing of Bruce, but we also need it for the definitive. Well, I mean, like you're saying, for the Dark Knight, I thought it was just nice how he was going to be Gotham's white knight. He's built up and he's doing good. And then that scene happens and Batman's in there. He's just like, I failed you. I have personally failed you. I'm sorry.
But at the end of the day, I mean, it's, you know, Batman can only do so much. So, but like, like you said, it's, it's a Jason Todd moment. It's like, you know, you know, Hey, I was, I was supposed to protect you. You were going to be the new savior of Gotham and I failed you. Yep. So last year, Judy and I recorded two episodes on Two-Face. February 2nd, 2022 was our first part one of Two-Face. Then February 22nd, 2022 was our second Two-Face episode. So we had to capitalize. All right. Black mask. We'll start with James. Um, I mean, Ewan McGregor. Come on. You're right.
Trey? Might be a little biased, but I mean, it's Ewan McGregor from Birds of Prey. Come on now. It's not you, McGregor. Yeah, all right, leave. You can leave. I hate that movie. When's the last time you watched it? I bet. I bet it's the guy you portrayed in Batman. The movie gave me COVID. Listen, the movie can be bad. The movie can be bad, but there can be memorable characters. The thing about that movie, because when Jeannie and I reviewed it and everything, that's Margot Robbie's best performance as Harley Quinn. Like, she puts her all into the character and does a great job at it. Without a doubt. And I'm sad. The movie had its problems. First of all, it should have never been The Birds of Prey. If you were into Birds of Prey, it should have been The Gotham City Sirens versus The Birds of Prey and not been Harley-focused been...
you know, two, you know, groups. Wasn't that film like her, like breaking off from Joker and being her? I gotcha. But it should have been more just her versus Black Mask. They shouldn't have tried to bring in the Birds of Prey. I mean, yes, they did. Sandra Cain, horrible. Like, they completely ruined that character. And my precious Renee Montoya. Renee Montoya was mishandled. They tried to make her too much. They should have never made it rated R. That was a big, big issue, I say, with that. Like, it should have never been rated R. Because I feel like you don't take a character that you're selling Harley Quinn merchandise to, you know, teenagers and kids and then give her a movie and make it rated R because you've just limited your audience.
especially when you're trying to make money. Okay. So I chose, so I had to look up like tons of clips, like the Gotham one. I didn't like, like, I didn't like the mask. My man, Todd Stashwick. It's just like, there were, there were, there were parts of it that were okay, but we're friends on LinkedIn. Great actor. So my answer is, my answer is really up in the air, but I guess I have, I guess I have to go with Batwoman. And the reason I go with Batwoman is because there were some torture scenes where he really struck fear into women and like, like what the heck he's going to do. And there was some gruesome scenes and stuff. And Black and Mask is very much a torture person. He loves it. He gets off on it and he loves being the top dog.
So I went with that. I was torn, but what I, I went with you in because there's moments where he changes, where he goes from being like, like the scene in birds of prey where he's like, I'll let you live. And then the girl's nose running and he's like, no killer. Like he'll just flip like that. It's just eerie. Like when they're in the club and all of a sudden he like tells the girl to get on the table. Just snaps. And he just like, he just goes to this dark place like that. It's, it's creepy because he goes from this happy, fun place to just being this cold day. It's just, that's what I'm afraid for you, man. See, see, but like in the comics and in war games, like, like black mask is more in control. Like he's more,
He's not flipping on the Switch and stuff. He's more put together in it. I don't know. Black Mask is more of a Catwoman villain to me. Because Black Mask killed her sister. I'm sure I remember who I killed. But the issues where Catwoman shoots him and he falls out a window and we don't know where Black Mask is. He's more of a Catwoman villain.
I don't know. I will watch that movie again. Birds of Prey. I'll watch it eventually. Because I love Ewan McGregor. And when he was cast, I was really excited. But that movie was just so bad for so many reasons. And I think that's why I just can't save him. My biggest question about that is, I wonder if that was Ewan McGregor at the end. Because I feel like when he put the mask on, I feel like that was all reshoots. But they went and put it in because they didn't actually have the mask on. And I wonder about that. But you need to put Ewan and Solomon, I'm trying to read this, put Ewan McGregor as well. Okay.
Victor Zass. That man who likes to stick you as much as James likes sticking people too. James, go. I mean, yeah, but... I also tell you guys this, for you guys that don't know. One day, James was really feeling bad. He had some stuff going on. Brian and I basically went online and found the best Chuck Norris facts and just dropped out Chuck Norris' name and put it in James Cole and just kept messaging him back and forth for hours. Inspiring. Yes, it was. It ended up helping a lot. All right. Victor Zass. I mean, Anthony Kerrigan from Gotham. He was...
He was great in that show. He gave that character personality. All right, Dre. Yeah. It was the second or third episode of The Flash. He's the mist. All right, Trey. I'm going to go in a little bit of a different direction here. Alex Morf from Batwoman. Again, I know the show is bad, but from what I've read and stuff like that, it seems like he was a memorable character from the show. I did like the characterization of Zaz in Batwoman from what I can remember. There'll be more on that later. Brian.
To me, Victor Zazz needs to make you uncomfortable. Very uncomfortable. And for Gotham, he didn't make me uncomfortable. He had a personality, and he killed people with guns. He was a hitman. So I went with Alex Morton in Batwoman. So once I looked up who played Zazz, and I saw Alex's face, I was like, ah, he was in Daredevil. And he was awesome in Daredevil. Did you just watch that episode?
So I had watched the scene where the dude's Sheena's wife and Beth and stuff, and how he kills him, how he puts the bodies there, and then pulls out the razor blade and puts the checkmark. That's Victor Zazz. So the year went with Gotham, Solomon went, who did you put for Victor Zazz? Gotham. I went with Batwoman because I remember Janine and I were watching the show and that became the show that we kind of kept on in the background like we were doing other stuff like laundry just so I could get through it but I remember we were literally watching it one night and it was that episode with Zaz and he came on and I literally stopped and watched it and I was like that's good. It's memorable. I was like that Zaz is creepy. That one made me feel uncomfortable. Now I will say that Gotham I think he's good but I will give him the break that it is early. He still has time to become.
Zaz as we know it. Very creepy, because he had only just started getting those cuts on him. Alright, the next one? Poison. Poison Ivy. That thing that James tries to avoid from getting on his crotch. James! Yeah, it's horrible. Like, you have no idea. We're only human. Alright, Mr. Colt, Poison Ivy. I mean, I debated this, like, I wanted to go with Peyton List, you know, I mean...
Of course you did. Smallville alum, come on. She's a good character actress. But I actually went with the person who played her before, Maggie Gea. Yeah, Maggie Gea. Yeah, Gea. So Gotham number two. Gotham version two. Yes, Gotham version two. Version one was really good too. I mean, I liked how she was very interested in the child. Yeah, and she was very interested in plants. It was an interesting character, but the evolution of how she aged up because of the chemicals and whatnot.
But yeah, the second, the second version I feel was, was a better character than, than was the best of all three. All right. And I mean, Uma Thurman is just, it was, it was what the movie was. It was very comical. All right, Dre. What do you say? Looks. Monday. Monday. That's all about it. I don't know. From your description, I'm just like, huh?
Okay, we'll come back. We'll come back. We'll come back. All right, Trey, you go. For me, I said Uma Thurman. And I know a lot of people might say, you know, oh, it's just because of the name. For reasons. Yeah, yeah. For reasons. But I mean, me as a kid, when I watched that film, yeah, it's more comedy than anything. But I just thought, I mean, from what I understand of the character, I thought she did pretty well for the character. Especially how she's trying to get Batman and Robin to fight over her. I mean, that's, you know, it's hard for most villains in Batman's universe to get him and Robin to fight amongst each other. She's going to kill you.
Alright, Brian. For me, Poison Ivy needs to send blood down below. It needs to happen. And Uma Thurman could not do that. The only actress that I felt could do that and did do that was Maggie.
She was a redhead. She held herself very well. She probably didn't mess with men. I don't think there's a definitive poison ivy yet. Maybe one day. But Maggie was the closest, I think, to how ivy should be. Do you think I could do it? I have red hair. Yeah, you could. I mean, the beard might throw it off. All right, Solomon, who'd you have? Solomon had Uma. Jania had Uma. This one was tough. Because like Brian said, I don't think there is a definitive poison ivy. I went with the Pamela Isley version from Batwoman.
Okay. I just feel like she was closer than what they gave us with Gotham and her character and her motives. They did do kind of that thing in Batwoman season three where they kind of like did newer spins on characters. So I went with the Pamela Isley version from Batwoman. All right, Dre, you're back, man. What you got? The other one. Yeah, she's like the Batwoman version, not the Pamela Isley, but the other. Yeah. Okay. Cool, cool. Okay. Respect. Hey, that Batwoman version. There's a lot of reasons there. I'm still sticking with Maggie.
But yeah, but there's reasons. What's his reasons? I'll just add something. There's a lot of reasons. Enlighten me. There's a lot of reasons. Solo 10 more years. You can talk about all the reasons you want. Dang. We'll look at we have two more years before we talk about this. Yeah, but he's not going to figure things out for 10 more years. I don't know what the right reasons are.
Are you a quick learner? Those are the conversations you can have with Uncle Brian. You can't talk to Uncle James about it, because then there will be plenty of each other. I mean, the kid needs to know what he's doing. All right, Mr. Freeze. We're going to freeze it up here and change it. Mr. Cole, which Victor, well, let me just say, which Mr. Freeze?
Which Mr. Freeze. Well, you know, we were talking about how comical it was, but I went with Arnold. Of course you did. You know why? Because James likes to work out and pump the iron like Arnold. Pump the iron, huh? It makes sense. All right, everyone. Chill. I do. I laugh every time and I cringe. I like a robe, though. Yeah, I want a robe. Yeah, I forgot about that. All right, Dre. I hate when they talk in the movie.
What killed the dinosaurs? The Ice Age! I can probably recite that whole movie. All right, Trey. Nathan D'Oreal from Gotham. Like Dre said, I like the look. It's very classy. This is one I'm interested in. I don't like it. You don't like it? No? No. Brian. You know, I really love Mr. Freeze. I know you do. I really, really do. That's why I should have saved you for last. That's why I'm excited for this. So, like, as a kid watching the 66 show, like, I thought, oh my gosh, I just got free stuff. Like, I love Iceman. Three versions. Three versions. So many choices. We love Iceman. You know.
I almost wanted to say audio from your, because he was wild. Um, but no, I went with Nathan Darrow. Um, he, yeah, he was awesome. His version was really great. And like, I, even though I like a Mr. Freeze that has the helmet over and we really haven't got that live action, I, I, you know, uh, Nathan, his story with Nora, um, just his look. It's just, it was, it was really awesome. And I, I hope we see Mr. Freeze again in the Batman too. Uh, let's see, Jania went with Arnold. So what'd you got? Arnold. I went with Gotham.
I thought he was one of those really good versions. Now, Brian, for the next Batman for Pattinson, would you want Nathan to be casted as Mr. Freeze? Honestly, I would like Ralph Fiennes. Who? Mr. Freeze. I probably put his last name, Ralph Fiennes. It's Ralph Fiennes. It's that English name where it's a letter.
You know, Thomas Dower from, you know, I always thought that Mr. Voldemort. I always had for Mr. Freeze would have been great was Mark Strong, because I think Mark Strong's an amazing actor. And then somebody said, I don't want to butcher his name, but the actor that plays Moff Gideon and was also the head guy of Voight in The Boys. Yeah, he would do a good job.
Yes. So I'll butcher his name. Okay, so here's a tough one, boys. Catwoman. That was the most tough one for me. There's only one wrong answer to this. Anything else? I'll accept. There is one wrong answer. Can you tell us the wrong answer now? Yeah, it's Halle Berry. Okay, thank God. Thank God. I'm in the clear. Other than that, there's arguments for everything because I even have an argument for one you might not think of. Okay, James Cole. You're up.
Uh, I went with Zoe, Zoe Kravitz. Um, I really enjoyed the portrayal. Uh, I'm glad at least for some reason she had, she was a cat burglar and she had ears and she was pretty skilled at a lot of things fighting and, and what she did breaking and stealing. Oh, Lord agrees with you. All right, Trey. All right, Trey. Um, I went with Michelle Pfeiffer. Um, I just, you know, I liked her character. Um, I liked kind of like the downfall we see, you know, she's just a regular person. I mean, yeah, we don't see a whole lot of crime she's committing, but I mean, just the way the character develops and stuff like that, I did like that. So Michelle Pfeiffer for me. Right.
This one was so tough. Yes, it is. Because I have an answer right now. I'm so not sure that's what I wanted to be. Because I fought Michelle Pfeiffer, but Michelle Pfeiffer just... She wasn't...
She wasn't hot enough in both parts. She was very sexy as Catwoman, but she didn't... Not a good look at Selina Kyle, huh? Yeah, she wasn't a good look at Selina Kyle, and her civilian part wasn't Selina to me. And then I thought about Lee Merriweather, because Lee Merriweather really put Adam West... Really distracted him. The 66 Catwombs were very distracting to Batman, and they were thieves, and they were really good. But my wife actually chimed in on this. She said she thinks Eartha Kitt was the best Catwoman. I did have that as an option.
At the end of the day, I went with who I thought could have been the definitive Catwoman if she had more screen time, and I went with Anne Hathaway. Okay. All right. I can't really argue with you because I have a bunch of the same debate that everything you said I agree with. Solomon. I went back in return. He went with Michelle Pfeiffer. All right. Jania went with Gotham version one. So she played more Selina into Catwoman. I got you. I highly consider her. I really, really did. I will make a case.
Much like what you said about Anne Hathaway. She looks like Selina should. I thought the girl that they cast in the final episode of Gotham could have been an amazing Catwoman. I think she did really good because she only got the one episode. The finale for Gotham is so weird because it's like a reverse pilot. It's a pilot for a show you never get is what it is. And they age up everybody. And they bring in a new actress for Catwoman. And I cannot remember her name off the top of my head, but I thought she was great. The one that did the laser scene. I have Anne Hathaway, but at the same time, I'm going to go with Julie Neumann.
I respect that. Look, James, you there, buddy? James and I are both big fans of Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. The greatest musical ever made. And all I'm saying is, Julian Neymar in that movie, too. She definitely made a young Tyler perk up and notice. I might have to change the bathroom. She is very striking as Catwoman and has that allure. Much like you said with Anne Hathaway, I think Anne did great, but she was so close.
But I'm going to go with Neymar. Was it Lily Simmons? Yes. Okay. She was fantastic. Anne was fantastic. Michelle was fantastic. Like I said, there's no wrong answer unless you said Halle Berry. That's what I'm saying. This is one of the big ones. I'll change my answer to Julie. Okay. Because Anne just didn't have enough screen time. So my answer to Julie. Okay. Now we're going to move on to Solomon's other favorite Batman villain known as the Scarecrow. Mr. Cole. Man. So I went with the only one that looked.
Great. And that was in Gotham. Okay. And I did like a lot of the fear aspects they use. They've done some interesting portrayals. And of course, Cillian Murphy is amazing as Crane, but he's hardly Scarecrow beyond the first, his first appearance. I just want to hear James's opinion on everything. That's a new podcast we should watch. James Cole just gives his opinion. All right. Dre, Scarecrow. Oh, I thought you were going to say the one from Titans. Are you too afraid of Brian's wrath to say the one from Titans and he's going to come after you?
Yeah. I do it. That's right. That's right. Who strikes for you? I like that actor's portrayal for a little while, and then it just took a turn. It was like, aw, why'd you do that?
It started great, and then it went downhill. Okay, Trey. So I try to avoid, like, looks. I mean, yeah, looks is, you know, a big part. But I'm going to have to go with Cillian Murphy. He didn't get a whole lot of screen time. Like, I wish he would have. But, I mean, like James said, yeah, we don't seem as much as Scarecrow. But he has a menacing, he brings a menacing feeling to the table. It's like, you know, it's unsettling. Like, you know, it's like, are you nice? Are you evil? You're creepy. I can't get a read on this guy, you know. Especially in Batman Begins when he goes to visit Carmine. You know, he's in there. It's like, hey, you know, get me out of here. Help me out, you know. Oh, yeah, I can help you out. And then all of a sudden, freaks him out in
Scarecrow is like my favorite. I love Scarecrow. I went with David W. Thompson, who was the guy that actually was Scarecrow in the suit. So, there was two guys that played Jonathan Crane, Scarecrow, and Gotham. There was a kid that was from that Wayward Pine. You know who I'm talking about. The one that was Crane first. So, the one that walks into the warden's office with the scythe and the whole suit was David W. Thompson, and I went with that kid. I thought his Scarecrow, not completely perfect, but pretty darn close. His voice was good. Yeah, that's the one I gotta go with. I can't believe that this is so crazy.
But, alright, can I, like, is this allowed? You're the son of the podcast. He's gonna hit us with it. You're the son of Patrick, you can do whatever. Okay, um, I'm kind of with both. With Matt Richards and Gotham, when he walks into the boardroom's office. Um, Gotham, I have the looks. But on the gens, the actor is good. The way he acts and stuff like that? Yeah, so I'm like...
Which one? Solomon's Night Scarecrow. Yeah. Did you see him in the games? I was about to bring that up. I mean, is it fair to say we've all played the games? Yeah. Arkham series? He's saying how much he loves. That Arkham Night Scarecrow? Oh my. It's great. Yeah. John Noble? Yep. Those songs that he loves. The one that you picked. He also likes Kelly Murphy, so he's torn. Yeah. I think...
I mean, my official answer is the same as Solo's. I thought Cillian was an amazing crane. But Scarecrow just didn't hit it, even in three movies. We didn't get a full suit and we just get a mask. It was kind of disappointing. But again, great actor. But wait, I guess you maybe could count Cillian because in the fear scene in Batman Begins when he's on a horse, it's actually Scarecrow, right? I think Cillian Murphy because I love him. I think that it's a Nolanized version. But I love the scene where he comes in, like just him, like the same thing Trey said. He makes you uncomfortable because you think he looks like a nice guy.
But then you're not sure. And then how he like comes in. He's like, you want to see my mask? I use all my experiments. And then he gases him. And then, you know, and then later he puts on it. But then you got to love in the dark night. He's like, I told you my drug would take you places. I didn't tell you would be places you want to go. Yep. And he's, you know, and then he's like, not by my diagnosis. Like there's a different era. And he just, I love it. Okay. Yeah. Moving on. Moving right along. The Riddler. James Golder. Riddler. Corey Michael Smith.
From Gotham. Yeah. He was a really interesting character. The shy portrayal and the split personality. I like the suit that he got to wear. Got to wear the bowler hat and the nice green suit, not just a suit with question marks all over it. And definitely not a leotard. All right. Great.
All right, Trey. Like James and Dre said, I mean, the way they brought that character to life, I wanted to go with him, but I didn't. Well, I'm getting there, but I did like how they brought the character to life through Gotham, you know, seemed like to be a normal good guy. And then, you know, as a downfall and all that stuff, I went with Paul Dano or Dano from the Batman. I like the darker theme of the Riddler and I like the inspiration, like the whole Zodiac thing that was heavily inspired for him. I did like it. And from, you know, someone, I read a little review that kind of, you know, so for me was not only does he enjoy doing the riddles again, darker theme for the Riddler, but he also enjoys the actions of murder, which, you know, I, I thought it was a good take. It works. It works. If you read a lot more since DC rebirth Riddler, he starts to fall a bit more into that darker, more darker tone. Right.
For me, the Riddler doesn't have a split personality. There's only one wrong answer to this one. So I couldn't go with Gotham. And I couldn't choose the Batman because he wasn't really the Riddler. He was the Zodiac Killer. So I chose Frank Gorshin.
I was sure you were the last time that Frank Gorshin comes up. John Ashton is the wrong answer. You know, but Gorshin, Gorshin had, you know, the Riddler didn't really have much of a laugh in the comics, but he created this Riddler laugh. He was obsessed with the puzzles. Like even in Batman, the movie in 66, you know, Joker's like, what the hell, man? Like we, what are you doing? He's like, I have to do this. Like I have, he had the impulses. He had a narcissist, the insecurity, like, and everybody else has been kind of an invitation of Gorshin. All right, Solomon, the Riddler.
You picked Jim Carrey. Solid answer. Jania went with Gotham, and I too went with Frank Gorshin. I think he comes out. Him and Lee Mayweather are my favorite two villains that come from Batman 66. I like Gorshin's energy, and I just feel like Jim Carrey just played an updated Gorshin. He didn't really play the Riddler, he played Frank Gorshin. I was about to ask you, what's your thoughts on Jim Carrey? Because as a kid, I loved it, and then looking back, I'm kind of torn, but I've never seen Gorshin. But I mean, if you're saying it's basically an updated version, it sounds pretty good. Okay, so we're going to jump back. Carmine Falcone.
So this is where we're going to jump out of order real quick. We're going to do Carmine Falcon, James Cole. Um, I mean, I'm really torn on that because I really liked the Batman version. He was, he was pretty cold and just the air around him. And, and I love the actor's portrayal. Um, but we got to see so much more, um, of him running things in Gotham in the show. So yeah, I think I'm gonna go Gotham. All right. Dre. Yep. Yep. I forgot about that. Wow. Sophia.
All right, Trey. I went with the Batman as well. But James brings up a good point. Compared to the Gotham show, yeah, you don't see him get to run a whole lot or control a whole lot of things. You do get a brief snippet in the Batman, I feel, a little bit. But James does bring a good point. But yeah, for me, it's going to be the Batman. All right, Brian. I went with the Batman.
I really did like Carmine in Gotham. I really, really did. But, you know, in the Batman, Carmine was more Italian. Sure. You know, and, you know, I knew that Catwoman is Carmine's daughter from the side comic. When in Rome. When in Rome. You know, I knew that. And I thought they portrayed that very well. And that relationship there and his cockiness to Bruce and, you know, Batman. Yeah. I liked it. Salmon? Carmine? I mean the Batman.
It's all on his own. Pick the Batman. Junia picked the Batman. I picked Batman Begins, but I think he's just an arrogant prick in Batman Begins. Yeah. He thinks he's, and he gets knocked down a peg, but he thinks he's- Especially makes gas. Exactly. Not in my town. You know, that's power you can't buy. Pulling the gun at the table with the judge in there. Yeah. And I love the character in the Batman, but I have a really hard time of just seeing John Tutorial as that character because I just really think of him as Pete from Oh Brother, Where Art Thou? Really hard. So it just makes it really hard for me to see him all serious.
All right. The next one, I think it's pronounced Mr. Raz Al Ghul. So Mr. Cole, give us the Al Ghul. I think, well, I just had to go with Alex Siddig from Gotham. Gotham did a lot of things or a lot of villains pretty, pretty well. You know, they gave him, they gave him a history and he's been around for a long time. He actually resurrected. So. Okay. Great. No.
And Trey. Yeah, Liam Neeson. I mean, cool now. Like I said, if you're going to whitewash with a character, you know, Liam Neeson, he's like, Brian. So I think that when Batman Begins came out, you know, Finch and I were talking in high school and I was like, okay, Liam Neeson, Liam Neeson is a...
supposed to play a heavy new card. And, like, we looked at each other, and we looked at how we looked in the movie, and we're like, okay, Leeson's Roz. Leeson's Rozable. I mean, come on. My choice is Neeson. Because he, if you're going to, you know, if you're going to whitewash, you want to look as close as you can. Neeson did great. But how Neeson trained him, and how Neeson, you know, showed him, like, we have to destroy Gotham. Like, these people are just corrupt. He portrayed, I love Rozable. He portrayed how the mission is that we're just going to kill all these people, let Gotham rebuild.
and how he played with what Bruce's mission was for Gotham to be able to be that symbol and kind of save it. They did that really well. I think of Rajagul as almost like the Dracula of DC Comics. Like how he just keeps coming back. He's immortal. That's the way I think it is. And Neeson is the closest, I think, that we've got to the way he should be. The end. Okay. Salman, Rajagul, who'd you pick? Matt McGinn. Yep. Jania chose Liam Neeson. I chose...
Ken Watanabe. Ah! You slick SOB. No, I went with Liam Neeson. But I love Ken Watanabe. I think he's a great actor. I really wanted that to happen. I really wanted...
When they announced they were going to bring Ra's al Ghul to Arrow, I remember a lot of people wanted Odette Fair to be Ra's al Ghul. I thought that would have been amazing. And he would have been an amazing Ra's al Ghul. And probably the closest to a definitive Ra's al Ghul we've had. But they didn't do that. They picked the whitest white dude on Arrow. So, what the heck? Okay. Now we've got four more to go, listeners. It's crunch time. Harley Quinn. James Cole. I mean, I really liked how, like, Mira Sorvino, like, ran things behind the scenes. But I had to go with Margot Robbie.
All right. Trey. Trey. You know, I want to say Lady Gaga, but I can't because the film isn't out yet. And honestly, I don't know if she'll be good. I have hopes for her because, I mean, with Joaquin Phoenix, the first movie, it was pretty good. I mean, it was great. So I have hopes for her. I can think of two actresses that I'd recast for, but I'd go Margot Robbie. Brian. I hate the character. What? Why? But there's only one person that's made me actually start to somewhat like her, and that is Margot Robbie.
Margot Robbie looks like Harley should. She acts like Harley should. And Margot just, yeah, she does great. Salmon, what you got for Harley Quinn? I got Margot Robbie. Salmon's got Margot. She has Margot. I chose...
I went with Tara Strong, the deleted scene from Arrow. No, I went with Margot Robbie. Especially, I really liked her in The Suicide Squad. I feel like what we got in Suicide Squad was good. The extended cut was better because it gave us more with her. But I really liked her in The Suicide Squad. Who's Milton? Milton's still with us? That is my favorite part. I know. Do you have high hopes for Lady Gaga? My thing is more about the balance of tone of that movie. Because, like I said about the first movie, Joker.
It was like, hey, we wrote this really great movie about mental illness, but there's no way we're going to have a large audience. Just set it in Gotham and call it Joker and people will eat it up. That's what they did. But that's going to be a full-blown musical. I don't think it's going to be a full-blown musical. But my thing is, if you're dealing with people in delusions, the idea of singing and dancing in a delusion makes sense. So having these musical outbursts...
will make sense in the idea of people who have lost their sense of reality. I also wanted to put Christina Ricci for the audio drama, but since this is live action, I just want to say a shout out to Christina Ricci, who I don't get to meet again for the second year. I just can't cancel. One day we will meet her. See, now I'll say this real quick. For the recast, for the upcoming movie, if they were to recast her, the reason I say this first one is because my wife made me watch the movie, Cruella.
Emma Stone. She was really good in it. I think she could do a pretty good Harley Quinn. Emma Stone would do it great. That's what I thought. The way I would want Harley Quinn to be. And then the second one would be Anya Taylor-Joy. I think she could. I could see that. That's pretty interesting. Like his ideas, huh? This man's a young director in the works.
I think she'd be a good Poison Ivy. Yeah, that's a good one, too, yeah. Yeah, I'm just... I know. I'm telling you, man. Did you say Emma would be a great Poison Ivy? I don't know. All right. She'd also cast Princess Peach, my favorite movie. Yeah. Is Todd Phillips directing The Sovereign Joker? Yeah. Okay, yeah. Okay, I have faith. That's what I'm saying. Todd Phillips, you know, the guy who brought us such great, wonderful classics as Old School. You know, when you take the early flight. Sometimes you take the early flight home, and that's my best man toast. All right.
We've got three more. All right, let's do it. Penguin. Mr. Cole. Let's bring it home. Did we lose James? No. So for Penguin, my two favorite interpretations would have to be Batman 66 with Burgess Meredith, but Robin Lord Taylor for Gotham. Both are amazing. I mean, I'm not arguing either way. All right, Dre. Yeah, he's going to show, right? Yeah. All right, Dre.
I'm going with the twist here. I really liked Tim Burton's version, Danny DeVito. You know, at that time, Danny DeVito was more known for comedy and family films, which still is going to be considered a family film. But I like the grotesque nature of Penguin, you know, the hands. And then, you know, at the campaign meeting, he bites that dude's nose off. Like, I don't know. I just like his Penguin. All right. Ryan. I absolutely love Penguin.
You know, so many good interpretations. My answer is pretty much just like James. I really love... Burgess Meredith as a Penguin is the highlight of all Batman 66 villains, in my opinion, with Frank close second. Like, that laugh and just... Does he have the model? Oh, he's so great. Oh, he does? But I chose Robin Lloyd Taylor because Robin Lloyd Taylor gets the insecurity perfect. The relationship with the mom, you know, the dependency of other people. He just... He knocked it out of the park. And he gets the water right. I like, you know, how the water looks like his foot's messed up. It's just...
Yeah, Robin was just, oh, man, it was so good. That's part of the show. And just some flat-out, like, scary murder stuff with him. Absolutely. Absolutely. And, like, I love how in Season 1 of Gotham, you know, you're just watching him work for Maroney, and you're watching him play both sides. Yeah, being so duplicitous. And you have no, like, you don't see his plan right away. Like, you just think things are just happening because of circumstance. But this dude is manipulating things left and right, and you never see it coming. And that is Penguin for me, man. Like, he's so good. All right, Solomon.
Um, Gotham. Do you need to put Gotham? I was kind of split because I, I really like Colin Farrell as Oz and that, that rise in Penguin. One of my favorite lines in that whole movie is, it's not even like it would be that funny, but to me it's like, is that the mayor? Oh shoot, it is. Like, please look at the picture. Like, it just, to me, it was like, felt like just that.
Thug, douchey. But Robin Lord Taylor is Penguin because he gets that full arc. And you see him go as Oswald into embracing that Penguin. That's the beauty of a show. It can be. Some shows, I feel like they slow down the pace too much. And then, of course, he is kind of robust. They try to make him in the finale and everything. But I think he got the character. All right, guys. Two more to go. Yes. Paul Rubens. Oh, that's right. Yeah.
And what's funny is I believe him more as the Penguin's dad in Gotham than I do in Batman Returns. All right. James Cole's favorite Batman villain. They actually modeled. Did you know this? They modeled this character after James. I believe it. Yeah. Sure so did. James, bring us home with the Bane. Oh, man. All right. Well, I picked Tom Hardy's Bane because there was a physicality, definitely, to the role and the character. But also the brains, the smart, his articulation.
of being able to talk and manipulate people and events. So for the first two-thirds of that movie, yeah. All right. Dre? There is a wrong answer to this one. There is a wrong answer, but it's not that one. Trey? I'm with Tom Hardy as well. I mean, just the portrayal of it. I mean, he can play a good villain. I mean, just movies he's played in before and stuff like that. He's flawless with every character he handles. I think he got out of the ballpark with Bane.
Brian. I picked the bane that was born in darkness. Molded by it. That they laid on a table and injected him with chemicals. I picked Jeep Swenson from Batman and Robin. Nice. Because it would piss on Dave, and that's what I'm about. I actually consider it.
Solomon, who did you pick? Solomon picked Batman and Robin. Did you pick the Dark Knight, Tom Hardy? I picked Tom Hardy. The only answer that would be wrong would be Shane West. Can we really talk about that being whitewashing? Is that the Gotham one? If you pick Gotham's Bane, you are one dumb mofo. Gotham's Bane is up there with picking Halle Berry as Catwoman. Alright, we are at the final one. Perhaps absolutely the worst thing they did on Gotham.
So here we go. The last one. The Joker. This is probably one of those hot topic debatables we're going to get into. This is where friendships are made and friendships are divided, people. So let me start with a hot take then because I'm going to cheat and I'm going to go with Cameron Monaghan in Gotham. Okay. I'm not picking one. I'm saying Cameron Monaghan. I don't think I like that. All right. Dre. He won. He's led you. One post morning.
All right, Trey. I went with Heath Ledger as well. I mean, there's really not much explanation needed in my opinion. I mean, you want to know how I got these cars? Just the way he approached the character, you know, isolating himself in a hotel room for months and getting into character. That's unbelievable. You know, it's unfortunate what happened that, you know, he couldn't finish the film all the way through because there was supposed to be one final scene wasn't there before. Yeah. But I mean, the dedication and all that stuff. I mean, you know, it was perfect. Now I will say if we never had a Heath Ledger Joker,
I would say Joaquin Phoenix. Come on now. It's not terrible. He doesn't count. Why doesn't he count? Because he has a name.
No, because he's not the Joker. Would it make you feel better if I said Jack Nicholson? You say what you want to say. No. You can say, Joaquin. He won a freaking Oscar. He won Best Actor. Well, I mean, he's not bad. Like I said, if we didn't have a Heath Ledger Joker... I'm just kidding, crap. He was amazing. I think when we watch Joker this coming year, we're going to do a commentary on it. I'm going to bring you back. Oh, yeah? Just because I think it'd be fun to do because there's a lot in that movie to dissect that you don't think about. That'd be fun to bring you back. I'm looking forward to re-watching that. It's been a while since I've watched that movie. That may be a good one. That's so good. I picked Cameron Moynihan.
When they said that they weren't going to do the Joker in Gotham, and then they showed that kid, I'm like, okay. I wasn't sold on that kid during that whole episode of his first introduction, but when he's doing that interview, and that dude's like, yeah, I'm your dad and stuff, and then he's crying, and he looks down at the table, and then he comes back up, and his face changes, and he just starts laughing uncontrollably. I'm like, oh my gosh, this kid. And then in season two, when he's dropping bodies off that roof, and he's trying to spell stuff, that's Joker, bro. He...
That kid knocked it out of the park. So good. Because before then, Jack Nicholson was my Joker. Like, just through and through. But Cameron was able to play not one, not two, but three separate frickin' Jokers, and he killed it each one. That kid is Joker. That's just... My man, thank you. I want Jack Nicholson. You want Jack Nicholson? Okay. Excellent choice. Janias. Don't hate my wife. Jared Leto from Zack Snyder's Justice League. Really? We gotta hear the reasoning. Did she give you a reason?
She loves Leto. She hates that all of his stuff got cut. All the more scenes. Yeah. And everything, but she thinks he just has an eeriness and an interest into it. And she, and she loved Ledger. Yeah. Okay. But she really liked what Leto was doing. Which specific movie did she choose? She put Zack Snyder's Justice League. Okay. That's, that's, that's only answer that Brian Fierce woke up. I like, I like the clown. I like the clown prince of crime in Suicide Squad. I mean, I like the scene where he intervenes. I like the clothing, the jewelry, the, the nice things that he likes. I like the, the.
Prince angle. They gave him there, but I like the scene in suicide squad where he interrogates the guy in the meat. Yeah. Oh yeah. Yeah. And then he sits on his lap. He could do well. They just cut his scenes and gave him nothing. Yeah. But in, in Zack Snyder's justice, like when, when he's talking with, with Bruce and like the different, you can just see it in his, in his face and his mannerisms in his eyes, like when he switches, you know, like, like when he switches and he's about to lose it. And then when he stops and it switches back and he doesn't.
It is so good. And he says this comment says, who else would give you a reach around? That, that, oh, all right. Leto could have done, he could have done great, but the damage on the forehead. Yeah. Release the haircut.
All right. My answer, I have not really much more to say, but my answer is Cameron from Gotham. Everything Brian said, like he got screwed by just because they wouldn't let them say Joker until like the last episode on the third version. And that was like the weirdest, but the way he went from being the Jeremiah of Valeska to where he started, he did the face thing. They made it all creepy and they brought it back and then he had the twin brother. So then he played a whole different clean cut angle of the character. Yeah, actually more acid, more like.
Like the classic, like the old Joker and the three Jokers where he's like laughing as painful kind of character. He gave you every single type of Joker that you could want. He hit every single one of them. You like Ledger more? You get it. You know, you like more Nicholson? He puts on the old gangster suit. He gives you anything you could want from the Joker. Hanging in there, Solomon. So we're going to wrap it up here. We've been on here an hour and 40-some minutes. Guys, happy Batman Day for all of our listeners. Also, the day after Batman Day is...
It's the second greatest day ever. Second only to the birth of Jesus. That's the birth of Brian Peters. Happy birthday, Brian Peters. I wouldn't go that far, but I'm glad you did. Thanks for hanging out with us, Solomon. You all right, buddy? Thanks for having us. You're welcome. Dre, you're welcome. All the way out in Woodsboro. Stay clean, buddy. Don't get killed. James? Yeah, good talking to everybody. You got some crime to fight, buddy. All right. And remember, everybody.
What's up, everybody? Chase Smith here from the Chase Smith Podcast and Caps of the Break NBA Podcast. And I'm JD, host of the Hyman Podcast, part of the Press Light Podcast Network. And we are super excited to bring you a brand new show starting next Tuesday, the Fanfare Podcast. The Fanfare Podcast is all about your favorite movies and our favorite movies and the best moments in cinema. To help guide our discussion, each episode will feature one classic. And we will grade this movie using a report card like Scale A through F. We're going to be grading categories like acting, directing, cinematography, the score, and even the movie poster itself. And when we're not featuring a movie report card, we'll be sharing our movie rankings, franchise deep dives, actor and director interviews, and everything in between.
Movies have been a major part of our lives, and we cannot wait to share our thoughts with you. Our premiere episode will drop Tuesday, June 27th, and JD and I will be reviewing Raiders of the Lost Ark in preparation of the release of Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny on June 30th, the fifth installment of the franchise. Join us on the Fanfare Podcast, available on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcast. Hello, Brooks here with the Books with Brooks monthly book club podcast. Here's how Books with Brooks works. We read one book a month and then we talk about it. Classics like Stephen King's The Shining, debut novels like We Are the Brennans by Tracy Lang, and tons of other compelling, life-changing stories, one book and one month at a time. So come read along with us and then listen in.
Here at Krypton Report, we believe in the power of podcasting, the power of speaking your voice and speaking something that comes from you. So here's a couple of podcasts you can check out with people sharing their voice. I am Brian Peters, the creator and host of Greatly Amusing. For the past 30 years, I've studied the history of gods and monsters in pop culture and our world. As a student of theology and history, I've tried to understand evil and its impact on us. As a writer, I've tried to share this knowledge. As a comedian, I've tried to make people laugh as I do it. But as a man child, I'm still that scared seven-year-old boy.
Join me as I share the history of horror and sci-fi, discuss classic and modern pop culture, and share a creepy story or two. This podcast may scare you, it may horrify you, or it may leave you gravely amused. Listen to Gravely Amusing on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeartRadio, and wherever podcasts are found. Follow us on Twitter at gravely underscore amusing or on TikTok at gravely amusing. Hi, I'm Taria Maynard, and this is my co-host, Jania Patrick. We're a couple of sisters in Central Ohio who created a podcast.
Our podcast is called The Confessing Heretics. The basic premise of the podcast right now as we see it is we're going to talk to you guys about our stories in religion, would you say? This podcast is about sharing our truths, our religious traumas, and our histories. We'd love for you to join us on our journeys as we talk about our pasts and discover more about ourselves along the way. We will be featured on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. Just look for The Confessing Heretics.
We have a $1 Patreon. Yes, I know everyone asks for money, but our $1 Patreon each month gets you commentary tracks for releasing movies, DC movies. It gets you my requel series where I pitch ideas about movie sequels, prequels, or whatever. It also gets special bonus episodes of whatever else some of the friends of the network chime in and drop. So check that out for $1 a month. That's all we ask. Keep it cheap, keep it simple, and help us keep going. Check out the link in the show notes or Patreon Krypton Report. Follow the link in the link tree or in the show notes below patreon.com slash Krypton Report. And if you want to have a good time, keep listening to the Krypton Report.
We just want to say if you've enjoyed this podcast, please check out other podcasts on the Press Play Podcast Network. If you are like Tyler and James and can't get enough super talk, check out these other podcasts. Digging for Kryptonite, Supergirl Radio, The Last Sons of Krypton, The Superboy Legacy Podcast, All-Star Superfans, Superman The Animated Podcast, The Aspiring Kryptonians, Always Hold On to Smallville, The Geek of Steel, and Truth, Justice, and Hope. Remember to check out Krypton Report on all social media platforms. Go to linktree.com slash kryptonreport. You'll find out all of our...