Skip to content
Behind the Dorm Room Door episode artwork

Jan 12, 2026 1 hr 34 min

Behind the Dorm Room Door

from True Crime Brewery Hosted by Jill

On May 4, 2003, just as the sun was rising over Western Kentucky University, one dorm room was especially dark. Katie Autry, a bright and beautiful student, was lying dead in that room. She had been raped, stabbed, drenched in an accelerant, and burned alive. Join us for Behind the Dorm Room Door. Two men […] The post Behind the Dorm Room Door appeared first on Tiegrabber.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Behind the Dorm Room Door

0:00 1:34:04
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised. Welcome to True Crime Brewery. I'm Jill. And I'm Dick.

So on May 4th, 2003, just as the sun was rising over Western Kentucky University, one dorm room was the scene of really unimaginable horror. Katie Autry, a bright and beautiful student, was dying in that room. She'd been raped, stabbed, drenched in an accelerant, and burned alive. So major trigger warnings, this is one of the more horrific cases that we've covered. Join us for Behind the Dorm Room Door. So two men emerged as suspects once the investigation into Katie's death began. Stephen Soles, a poor drifter.

and Lucas Goodrum, a well-off young man with a history of violence. So one confessed while the other denied everything, and the truth behind Katie's murder seemed lost forever. So what happened in that room? Who was responsible for this act of cruelty and this just horrible, horrible crime? The echoes of that terrible night continue to resonate in Bowling Green, Kentucky. Is that where the beer's from? Beer is from Louisville, Kentucky. I was a little worried because, you know, Kentucky's not really known for its beer production. Okay, but bourbon.

Bourbon, sure. But I did. In my search, I saw that I'd had four different beers from a brewery called Against the Grain Brewery. So we're going to talk about an IPA called Rico Sauvent, brewed by Against the Grain Brewery. It's an imperial IPA, 8.2% alcohol by volume. And I had a note there that I had this on tap at one of our favorite restaurants in Maine when we lived there, When Pigs Fly. So the beer was an amber color, small tan head, a lot of lace into it. The aroma was okay, but a little bit muted. Citrus and caramel I could get. The taste got a bit more assertive. Lots of citrus, grapefruit, lime, some tangerine, and the caramel malt background.

Pretty hot forward beer. A lot of great fruit in the taste, but I enjoyed it. And we will enjoy it again. We will. Okay. Why don't we open it up? Okay. So down here at the quiet end, we actually took a week off, which we hadn't done since 2018, I think, which is crazy to think about.

I know that's a while ago. Yes, it is. Yep. So I feel like I'm just kind of starting new at this, which is probably a good thing. So anyway, Melissa, who went by Katie, her middle name was Kate, was born June 10th, 1984 in Rosene, Kentucky, which is where she spent most of her childhood. She's remembered as a loving person who seemed really pretty happy most of the time. She lived with her grandparents, Peggy and W.D. Autry, her mother, Dawn, and one younger sister, Lisa. But Katie was just seven or eight years old when she went into foster care.

Now, she never knew her dad, and her mom was sick. I'm not sure what the illness was, but it seems that her mom is still alive as far as I know. But whatever the situation, she was unable to take care of her two girls. So the sisters, Katie and Lisa, both went into the foster care system together and ended up with the same family eventually. They had moved foster homes several times before they finally found Jim and Shirley Inman. They were Katie's foster parents for 10 years, and they were very loving and supportive. Eventually, her birth family, too, would become important in her life. So she had really two families when she died.

Two groups of people who cared for her, if you will. Yeah, two families. Yes. So when Katie lived with the Inmans, her life was more sheltered than most of her peers. She was allowed to go to church. She attended school and school functions. But Katie was not allowed to go out with friends or to date. Her foster parents were just trying to keep her out of trouble. And it seemed to work. In school, Katie was incredibly determined and worked very hard. She was an A and B student. She was on the honor roll and in many different clubs.

She was also on the track team and a cheerleader, and she got awards for cheerleading. And she was such a tiny petite girl that she was on the top of the pyramid during the cheerleading. So you have to be very, very tiny to do that. You sure do. So you're on the top of the pyramid. You don't want to fall off. No, you don't. For sure. I think I'd be afraid. But, you know, she was pretty bold, pretty brave. So in the tiny town of Rosene, there weren't many opportunities for work or a future career. They had a factory and a fast food restaurant. But Katie really didn't want to end up in a dead-end job. She wanted more from life. So she really looked forward to going to college. And she would be the first one in her family to go to college.

Actually, one of the family members said there had only been one of them before who graduated high school. So it was a very big deal to go to college. Yeah, big enough deal just to graduate high school. Yeah. So this was above and beyond. And she had a lot of goals. She decided to go to Western Kentucky University and she wanted to study to be a dental hygienist. So once at college, the freedom was probably a little bit overwhelming for Katie. She became a little bit wild, drinking and partying a lot. And she did get a bit of a reputation for being promiscuous.

Now, this was a gorgeous young woman, so she did attract a lot of guys. But there was also quite a bit of racism at this university, and the rumors of promiscuity were definitely amplified by the general disapproval of her dating some black guys. So that was something that they kind of looked down on her for. It's hard to believe, but yeah, they did. It really wasn't completely acceptable. It is the South, and it was a very conservative area, I guess. So Katie had already overcome a lot in her life by the time she was 18. From the time she was just 10, she was kind of a mother figure to her little sister. And I think she was probably more mature than many of her classmates.

If you're thinking of kind of coddled young people who their parents have taken care of everything for them and they go straight to college, you know, Katie was different. She'd actually been through quite a bit. So she'd really experienced more life than most of her classmates, I would guess. But her independence at college was new to her because, remember, her foster parents were very protective. Yeah, she wasn't able to do much of anything. No, but she had grown up a lot faster and she had had a lot of trauma. So she lived her life as she wanted, but was sometimes unfairly judged by people. So Katie's first roommate disapproved of her dating a black guy and eventually moved out of their dorm because of it. But this actually had a bright side because it led to Katie meeting her good friend, Danica Jackson, who's actually, I think, her best friend.

Danica was mixed race, so she didn't care about that at all. And she was a little bit like Katie. She'd lived a little more life. So Katie left the foster system while in college and worked her way through school. She worked at a smoothie shop during the day, and then she started dancing in a gentleman's club some evenings. And gentleman's club is a very polite way to put it, because it looked like kind of a dive. Basically this dive bar, but she was able to make more money there than in the smoothie shop, of course. She would only be there for a short time, though, before she decided she really didn't want to dance at a strip club.

But still, the fact that she did this was another thing that caused people to judge her and would actually be used later on for some victim blaming. Well, it's easy. Here she is having sex with several guys, maybe not at the same time, but she was sexually active. She dated black people, horrors, and she'd stripped. Boy, tough thing to overcome. Well, I don't think she really cared. Well, I hope not. No, I think she really didn't care what people thought. She was determined. She'd gotten into college, got very good grades. And even though she did go a little wild once she got in college, that's really not that unusual. No, it isn't. And like you said, she did well academically. Yeah. Yeah, she did.

So when Katie and her best friend returned from seeing a movie on May 3rd, 2003, they entered Poland Hall and went to their dorm room, which was number 214. The room was what you would basically expect of a dorm room, two twin beds, two dressers and two desks, all kind of crammed into a cinder block walled room covered in, you know, photos and magazine things, things to personalize it for the girls. Their room always had piles of clothes on the floor and the girls, you know, that's the way they lived. Not unusual again, but they took a nap that afternoon. They were tired and the rest was very good for Danica.

Something had been bothering her all day and she really wasn't sure what it was. She just felt like something was not right. And of course, later she would make a connection between that and what happened to Katie. But in hindsight, who knows what she was really feeling. But anyway, Katie woke up hungry and she took Danica's keys to borrow her car to get some dinner. Then once out of Danica's sight, she called her friend Maurice Perkins from her cell phone and she offered to pick him up some fast food. So he wasn't Katie's boyfriend, but he was more than a friend and he was actually a big crush of hers.

They were talking and hanging out. And I don't think he was taking it that seriously. He also had a girlfriend who lived out of town. The girl had found out about Katie and had sent her a threatening email saying that she wished she would go to sleep and never wake up. So there's a little drama there. Yeah. Now, did Danica not like Maurice? No, she didn't. Because you were saying that she waited till she was out of sight before she called him. Yeah, she didn't like him because he already had a girlfriend. And he really wasn't that into Katie, but she was way into him. So she would do things for him, like bring him food, clean up his room. You know, she was very into Maurice for whatever reason. Yeah. And Danica thought she should be more independent.

Yeah, invite a guy that really liked her just as much as she liked him. So Maurice and Katie's relationship may have been casual, but to Katie, she thought she was in love with him. But he was more of a typical young guy that had a beautiful girl and really didn't want a serious relationship yet. The relationship in her mind was not the same relationship that Maurice had in his mind. So Maurice had been a high school sports star in his hometown of Indianapolis, and he was majoring in computer science at Western, but he was also a wide receiver because she came from a town with a tiny, tiny black population.

There was actually just one black student in her high school. It surprised some of Katie's friends that she was so open-minded about being in these mixed-race relationships. Over time, the stigma of mixed-race relationships has lessened in Kentucky, but for many, they're just still taboo, still a lot of racism. Danica thought Katie was discovering her own attractions and finding her way, but also she thought a little bit of it was probably rebelling. Sure. Just look at the 10 years that she lived with her foster parents and what things they instilled in her. So I can see it's a bit of rebellion. Yeah, sure.

Now, Maurice and Katie had met the previous October at the smoothie shop where she was working. She went to Maurice's dorm room later that night when he had friends over. So Katie was quiet and reserved, but in good spirits. And she would become a frequent visitor at Maurice's dorm, hanging out and playing video games. But that evening, when she called up Maurice, she asked him if he wanted her to pick him up some fast food. And he said yes, so she went by to drop it off. Maurice came downstairs to get the bag, so she didn't even go into his room. But she did ask him for a kiss on the cheek, and he gave her one. So Katie couldn't stay long anyway because she was breaking one of Danica's main rules about the car.

It was not to be used to visit Maurice. Danica didn't like him, and the feeling, I guess, was mutual, too. He wasn't crazy about Danica. Maurice thought that Danica partied too much and was a bad influence on Katie. Danica thought that Maurice used Katie and would selfishly accept the gifts that Katie showered on him, despite her not really being able to afford them. Katie always seemed to be crying about him, too. He was always breaking her heart, and her weakness for Maurice really frustrated Danica. Katie would ask Maurice for one of his t-shirts to wear. She just wanted one item, like a souvenir of him, to always have with her. And Danica thought this was ridiculous because Katie could get a lot of nice guys. She didn't need to be feeling this way. But this was the guy that she thought she loved.

So Maurice had finally given Katie a large turquoise t-shirt, and she would lovingly wear it each night to go to sleep. Maurice did do some nice things for her. He wasn't all bad. Katie was always in need of a ride, and he would chauffeur her around. He would often pick Katie up from her new job, but he really was shocked when he learned that she wanted to be a dancer at a club. The club Tattletales was on the edge of town between the interstate and the river, and it really attracts college students, locals, and businessmen, some of them Japanese businessmen that come into town for short periods of time. On weekend nights, the parking lot was filled with pickup trucks and SUVs.

And the shabby gray building was divided down the middle into two sections. So there was one area for drinking and another for watching the dancers. So it's pretty silly, but if you were under 21, you could go to the stripping section, but you couldn't go into the drinking room. So another local law banned the exposure of women's nipples too. So dancers at Tattletales followed this by strategically placing duct tape on their breasts. So you couldn't drink and watch them at the same time, and they couldn't show their nipples.

But they did have some private dances, too. I don't know if they were lap dances, but you could purchase a private dance. Well, they were lap dances. Yeah, probably. So back in April, Katie and Danica came in looking for work and started soon after. Katie's original goal of working at Tattletales was to earn enough money to buy herself a car. She wanted to just buy a cheap Dodge Neon, and then she could earn a lot more in a short time stripping than she would at the smoothie shop and be able to afford things. But there must have been more kind of psychological than monetary reasoning here, conscious or even unconscious, to make her start stripping. You know, it's a bold move for a young woman. Certainly one who is as protected as Katie was. Right.

And the transition of Katie from the shy and sheltered little girl to kind of an exhibitionist, I mean, you kind of have to be in that situation, was pretty striking. This was the ultimate rebellion for Katie. But when she was dancing, she felt safe and she gained confidence. It also gave her a feeling of control, empowerment, and maybe even a sensation of being loved and admired. I don't know about loved, but admired? Yeah, well, it could make her think she was loved. She was a young girl. Well, it could make her think that she's popular. Yeah, exactly.

Now, Katie's first performance on stage was awkward, but getting on stage got easier. Common to the profession, the dancers at Tattletales used stage names like Summer and Alexa and Shimmer, and Katie became Crystal. And Katie also became quite popular with the clientele. They tipped her on the runway by slipping dollar bills into the elastic of her G-string, and they would pay extra for the private dances. Unlike some of the dancers who generally attracted a certain type, Katie's admirers were from all races and ages. One regular patron, a high school senior, asked Katie to go to his prom with him. And not knowing how to politely decline, she said yes, but later would back out of going.

So Katie made a few hundred dollars a night at this club. This went a long way living in Bowling Green, where a nice apartment could be rented for about 300 bucks a month. No one could believe that the cheerleader Katie had become a stripper. She told her boss at the smoothie shop three times that she was doing this before he would believe her. He thought she was kidding. So back to May 3rd. Katie and Danica were drinking Everclear, which is a dirt cheap 190 proof pure grain alcohol mixed with Sierra mist lemon lime soda. Have you ever had that? I had a taste once. Pretty bad? Oh, it's like paint remover.

Yeah, and I think you get drunk really fast. Well, it's 95% alcohol. Yeah. 190 proof. Yeah. That's real fire water. Yeah. Plus, she was a tiny girl. So they were down the hall in room 211 with Danica's ex-roommate, Amy, and one of her friends who was visiting from Louisville. Early in the first semester, Amy and Danica had been close, but the two started having problems and they stopped speaking and eventually stopped living together. This was the first time, actually, that Amy had ever hung out with Katie. And Katie was the girl who had taken her place in room 214. So this get-together was kind of a prequel to the night's real event.

which was a fraternity party at Pi Kappa Alpha, referred to as Pike House. Katie was excited for something to do, especially since many of her friends had gone to Louisville for the derby. So after an hour or so and a few drinks, Amy dropped Danica and Katie off at the Pike House. And this was around midnight. The frat house was a two-story stone dwelling with a really attractive exterior, but just an awful mess inside. All the furniture had been moved into one room, and about 250 people had come to the party that night. I can't even imagine that. That's a good crowd. Yes.

Around 70 people remained there, and a DJ played commercial hip-hop, and one of the cleared-out rooms was used like a dance floor. So that night, Katie was extremely intoxicated. Danica wasn't very tipsy. Katie didn't know her limits, and her tolerance was low, and she would be drinking, and suddenly she's just intoxicated. But she didn't know enough to stop. She'd keep drinking. Even if Danica tried to get the alcohol away from her, which she always did try and do, she was really a pretty good friend to Katie, trying to help her. But the alcohol could really bring out some pent-up emotions, and Katie would get teary. Her smile would fall away, and all the pain that she had inside would start to come out.

Now, Katie had not gotten to that point yet, but as time passed, she became more incoherent. She was wearing a burgundy shirt and dark blue jeans with black high heels. She carried a purse that was woven like a basket and had brown leather handles. Both she and Danica's cell phones were in her handbag, which was normal. Katie would always carry a purse and Danica preferred to just throw her makeup and things into Katie's bag and...

let her carry them than being stuck carrying a purse around all night. So these are good friends. Danica's quite protective. It seems like Katie's a little more out of control. Maybe Danica knows her limits a little bit more. But anyway, they were having a good time. She got way too drunk, but it's really not that unusual. And one good thing about this party is they had designated drivers. Oh, good. Yeah, something they never had when I was young. No. No. And this was pretty much before Uber was a thing, the early 2000s. No, you needed a designated driver. So Stephen Souls was a local young man who was going to the same party that night. When Stephen was younger, he had dreams of becoming a star basketball player.

But he now just spent a lot of time with his buddies and cousins, drinking and smoking. Stephen's mooching was annoying and expensive. He didn't have a car, bum drives everywhere. He didn't have a cell phone, so he used everyone else's. He didn't have a job. He didn't have any prospects of a job. He dropped out of high school. Now here he is, 20 years old, with a ninth grade education. Yeah, so his life was not going well. But his grandma and his relatives really were supportive of him. And I guess they thought this was just a phase and he was going to get better. So that day, May 3rd, Stephen was picked up from his grandmother's house by his friend, Wesley Garman. Stephen sat in the front seat of Wesley's white Dodge Dakota.

and their friend Chris Bradshaw was in the back. So Stephen and Chris were distant relatives. Wesley drove toward Bowling Green, and Stephen was excited to get drunk and go to the frat party at the Pike House. He went to Western as often as he could to visit his buddies who were enrolled there and hang out at their dorms. But remember, he was not a student. No. So they stopped at Walmart and wandered around the aisles. Then they went to a liquor store and bought two 18-packs of Coors Light, then drove around drinking the beer and listening to music. Eventually, the Scottsville guys were tired of driving around and drinking beer. Chris Bradshaw called Sarah Cardwell, a local girl he was casually dating.

who had her own apartment. Sarah agreed to let them come over until they went to the Pike party later that night. So at Sarah's apartment, they drank more beer. And it wasn't long before Wesley just passed out on the couch. After a few more beers, Stephen wanted to smoke some weed. He took Wesley's cell phone and he called up Luke Goodrum. Luke's roommate, Matt, picked up the phone and told Stephen that Luke wasn't there. So shortly after Matt got off the phone with Stephen Soles, Luke Goodrum returned to their apartment. So Luke Goodrum and Stephen's older brother, Daniel Soles, had been best friends growing up. And later on, they were both on the high school basketball team.

Now, Stephen and Luke's relationship was never close. On the rare occasion when they talked on the phone, it was Stephen trying to buy some weed from Luke. Stephen was a frequent customer. He explained that they were having a warm-up to a frat party at Western and asked Luke to join them. Now, Luke had never been to a frat party before, and it made sense to get out of town for the night in case the police returned to his apartment regarding an earlier issue with Luke's girlfriend. An old boyfriend had called Luke's 17-year-old girlfriend, and he had gotten quite pissed off about that. Now, Luke did have a history of domestic violence issues. He was thought of as a privileged kid because his stepfather owned the Dollar General Corp., but his mother and stepfather lived in Texas.

And they were not on good terms with Luke, who lived with his father. So he wasn't as wealthy as some people imagined. No, I mean, he was better off than Stephen, but he wasn't this rich kid that he was kind of portrayed as. Not like he had a bunch of money. No.

So, if you think you might like more of our storytelling and analysis, both of little-known crimes and well-known crimes, I want to just remind you of our option that we have to subscribe to our premium show at tiegrabber.com slash subscribe, or on Patreon at patreon.com slash tiegrabber. So as a subscriber, you can enjoy every episode without ads, so you can stay immersed in all the sordid details, and you'll get access to exclusive bonus episodes about the most fascinating and disturbing cases. Your support helps too. It helps keep the beer coming in and the stories flowing. And it also allows us to continue making new material. So whether you're here just for the psychology, the mystery of it all, or even you just really are into craft beer, subscribing is one of the best ways to show your appreciation for what makes True Crime Brewery entertaining for you. So head on over to tiegrabber.com slash subscribe if you're interested and join the Tie Grabber community today.

Sarah drove Stephen to the bowling alley to meet Luke. And this was because Stephen was not allowed at Luke's apartment. Now, soon after they arrived, Luke pulled into the lot. He was going fast, and he kind of slid into the space in front of Sarah's car. Luke hopped out of his car and got into the backseat of Sarah's car. On the way back to Sarah's apartment, Luke shared details of the earlier issue with his girlfriend, Brittany. He'd had a physical altercation with her, where he hit her, threw her cell phone at her, and choked her with a seatbelt in her car. And Brittany's friend called the police. Oh, good.

Yeah, this was bad. And we'll probably get a little back into that. But that was what was going on at that point with Luke. So he was kind of avoiding the police. Let's just say he didn't want to be around them. Right. Plus, Brittany's dad was looking for him. So they drank more beer and brandy, too, and passed around two joints. Stephen drank about 12 beers by himself. Soon, Luke and Stephen got into their friend Brian Moon's Ford truck and went to the party. But Stephen was so drunk, he never even made it into the party. He passed out in the truck. So he was really just laying in the truck for the whole frat party.

In the meantime, at the party, Katie was very intoxicated and she kept running all over the place. So according to Danica, she would just stand in one spot and watch as Katie came in and out of the room. She was just so out of control. She was drawing a lot of attention to herself. So lots of people were asking, you know, who's this drunk girl? What's wrong with her? She repeatedly called Maurice, her big crush, and begged him to come to the party to be with her. So she's saying, please come, yada, yada, yada. Not that unusual because she was really had quite a crush on this guy. And he finally did agree and showed up at the party. But when he got there, Katie was just in terrible shape. Maurice suggested that she go home.

But, you know, she's past that point. She's at that drunk stage where you won't listen to anybody. And she insisted that she wanted to dance. Maurice said no. And that's when Katie screamed at him and slapped him across the face. So after that happened, he'd had enough. He left the party. But after that, Katie is described as dancing aggressively with other guys. You can kind of imagine what that would have been like. You know, obviously just trying to make Maurice jealous. Finally, someone did call security and told them there was a girl who'd had way too much to drink. So she was taken out of the party.

But Danica intervened and said she would take Katie home. You know, Katie didn't mean anything by it, but she'd been rejected by this guy and she'd had too much to drink and yada, yada, yada. But then a guy named Ryan showed up and he said he would drive Katie home. Now, Ryan was a pledge and he was a designated driver. That was his job. His job was to drive drunk people home. So he really was just trying to be helpful. Yeah. So as a designated driver, he doesn't drink. No, you can't. Right. So Danica is kind of irritated at this point with Katie for the way she's acting because it's a lot, right? She's kind of babysitting her at this point. Yeah. Well, you get to a stage where you just don't want to be around him.

Yeah, yeah. Now she knew and trusted Ryan. And another thing was she had a guy that she wanted to go home with. She kind of hit it off with someone at the party. So she agreed to let Ryan drive Katie back to the dorm, which is totally fine. That was his job. So she was taking care of her friend okay. She actually told Ryan if anything happens to Katie, she would come for him and he would be at fault. She told him he needed to take care of her and make sure she got home safely. But this was something Danica would regret for the rest of her life. After what happens to Katie, there's just a lot of guilt, even though I think she was being a good friend. It's not like she was just leaving her there. Right. And she knew this guy. Yeah.

This was a guy who was driving a lot of people. So Ryan, though, it's funny, he didn't have his own car. So to do these rides home, he borrowed cars. And he borrowed the same truck where Stephen's souls had been passed out throughout the party. So it's just a horrible coincidence, or what would you call it, when just two things happen that end up bad. Bad karma. But it's just like a horrible coincidence, almost like those Final Destination movies where this happens, then that happens. And it all ends up in a disaster, right? And that's what's going to happen here. Yes, unfortunately.

So he's borrowing the truck that Stephen Soles is in. He's passed out in the back, right? Yes, but he wakes up, unfortunately. So it's very tragic that this happened. What are the odds that Stephen would be in the back of the truck that Katie gets a ride in? But anyway, it's all bad. So the next day, May 4th, or the middle of the night, you know, when they get back. After midnight. Yeah, good way to put it. Between 1.30 and 2 a.m., the desk clerk at the dorm saw Katie return to the dorm alone.

At least that's what the clerk said. The driver, Ryan, was outside waiting to make sure she got inside okay. But then Stephen wakes up and climbs out of the backseat of the truck, and he says to Ryan, I'm going to go holler at her. So that means he's going to go talk to her. Yeah. Probably hit on her. That's Kentucky talk, right? Yeah, I think it's a little bit of Southern talk, yeah. Now, Ryan was supposed to drop off Stephen at another dorm because he was the designated driver. Stephen was supposed to spend the night at this other dorm building. But Ryan couldn't wait for Stephen to come back after talking to Katie and get back into the truck to get his ride. Ryan had to go back to the party and take more people home.

So Ryan left, and Stephen followed Katie into the dorm. We're not sure how, because the clerk did not see him. At least that's what the clerk said. So at 2.15 a.m., Sarah and Luke arrived at the dorm where Stephen was supposed to meet them and spend the night, but Stephen wasn't there. Luke sat on the couch while Sarah asked the dorm check-in person if Stephen had arrived, but he never did. So Luke says he'll just go home since Stephen isn't there, and he waits for the designated driver while Sarah drives herself back to her place. So at 2.26, Danica called Katie to check on her, and Katie answered her phone.

It was obvious to Danica that Katie was just right on the verge of passing out. She was really out of it. She sounds like she's face down on her pillow. Danica asks Katie if she's okay, and Katie says yes. She's made it back to the dorm room. But right at that moment, Danica hears a door shut, and Katie says to her, someone has just come into the room, and she's scared. So this just gives me chills. Just haunting to think about. This is the man. This is the murderer. Yeah, yeah. How does he get in? Did he lock her door? I don't know. I don't know if she would know enough to lock her door in that condition, or what happened exactly. I don't even know how this person got into the building.

But we'll talk a little bit more about that because it was supposed to be more secure than this. Right. So Danica actually told Katie, give the phone to whoever just came into your room. And Katie did. And the guy took the phone and he told Danica, he's the guy who brought Katie home. And this is weird because Danica knew Ryan and this was not Ryan, the designated driver. So he said he was checking on her because she got sick in the truck and he just wanted to make sure that she was okay. So Danica tells this guy to put Katie on her side so if she throws up again, she won't choke on it. But then Danica thinks she hears another male voice in the room. So Danica's talking to one guy and hearing another voice in the background.

Katie takes her phone back and says she just wants to go to sleep and hangs up the phone. So this call ends at 2.28. Danica called Amy, her former roommate who lived down the hall, to see if she could check in on Katie. Because Danica was concerned, but she wasn't super worried. She didn't think someone was going to rape or kill her friend. She just wanted someone to check on her and make sure she was okay. She was actually more worried about the vomiting and choking. Yeah, she was worried about the spell of drunkenness. Exactly. So she just thought Katie was drunk. But the call went to Amy's voicemail. Amy did not answer the call.

Then at 2.35 a.m., Ryan, the designated driver, arrived at the other dorm to pick up Luke. He drives Luke to his car at the bowling alley where he'd previously met up with Stephen. And at 2.40, Luke stops at a gas station where he buys a Coke and there's a receipt to confirm his purchase. So Luke will say that he arrived at his father's house where he lived at 3 a.m. So now at 4.08 a.m., the fire alarm goes off in Katie's dorm.

The Bowling Green Fire Department gets many calls to the college's dorms, as you would imagine. I'll bet. Yeah, usually because someone burnt their food, or someone's playing a prank and pulling the alarms, or the smoke detectors are faulty. So engine number five pulled into the parking lot at 4.18 a.m., and three more trucks were following it. Captain Bob Sanborn was in charge of five's crew. Dorm alarms were pretty routine and usually amounted to nothing.

So Sanborn and firefighter Matt Jones went to the second floor and put their masks on in the stairwell before entering the hallway. Light smoke filled the air. A steady stream of water was coming from underneath the door. Sanborn opened it and saw that the fire was out, but kind of smoldering, and the room was filled with what they call cold smoke, which is like black clouds of smoke from an extinguished fire. Water still came from the overhead sprinkler. The sun hadn't risen yet and no light was coming through the window.

So Sanborn stared into the black, and he did see something kind of glistening on one of the beds. The overhead fluorescent lights from the hallway were reflecting on something, causing a slight shine that pierced the blackness. A mass hung overhead, and Sanborn assumed it was part of the ceiling sagging down. But this was actually Katie's afghan wrapped around the sprinkler's spigot. And also the smoke detector was hanging from its wires like someone had ripped it out of the ceiling. Yeah, and what's the afghan doing there? So the murderer did that to...

reduce the amount of water coming out or what? I think so, to keep from putting out the fire right away. So Sanborn stepped inside and the door closed behind him. He tried to adjust to the blackness inching toward the bed, which he could see was covered in a smoldering pile of blankets and clothes. He tried to focus his eyes, and then he saw that that glistening was a patch of exposed flesh. The skin burnt off an arm protruding from that mound. So he brushed back the burning stuff, and at the time he didn't know if this was a male or a female, but he saw that it was a body.

and he saw that the face was wrapped tightly around the nose and was pressed down with some kind of cloth. So someone had tied a cloth around the face, and we don't know if that was to help stop breathing or what that was. So a white t-shirt was knotted around Katie's neck, and the remnants of the turquoise t-shirt that Maurice had given her, the shirt that she lovingly slept in each night, was stuck to her shoulders. He saw Katie's chest was still rising and falling, and he was shocked to see these signs of life. He scooped Katie up and wrapped her in the charred wet sheet.

Now, at most, she was 110 pounds and she was terribly, terribly burned. Three firefighters carried her down the stairs in a sheet. The stairwell was slippery from the water. There was water pouring down the steps. When she was down to the ground floor, the ambulance had not yet arrived. So when the ambulance did pull up, the firefighters were already helping Katie to breathe. And amazingly, she was actually fighting the O2 mask that they were putting on her face, which is just horrible, horrible to think of the pain she may have been enduring. I know that some of the things I've read about this said that burns were so thick, she would have lost feeling because of the nerves.

But it sounds just dreadful. If they get deep enough for the burn, yeah, you will lose feeling. It's horrible. It's just one of the worst things ever. Now the EMS crew loaded Katie onto a gurney and into the ambulance. The paramedic tried to get an IV inserted into her arm, but you can imagine it was really difficult because of the extreme burn damage. Katie actually spoke, one of them said. She said, just take me home. And she limply tried to swat at the mask on her face. The damage to her larynx had reduced her voice to just kind of a little squawk.

So this was Mother's Day, and despite the early hour, Katie's mother, Donnie Autry, was awake. Donnie and her boyfriend were in Bowling Green spending the weekend at his mother's house. She had stayed up into the early morning hours listening to their police scanner. So Donnie heard Hugh Poland crappling through the speaker numerous times. And Donnie tried calling Katie's dorm phone, but no one was answering. Police were doing a preliminary search of the dorm room. Some items had been washed into the hall by the flowing water, including a bandana and a purple can of hairspray. Scraps of the sheet used to carry Katie out were strewn about the linoleum floor.

So when Katie was wheeled into the emergency room, she was covered in burns. She had third and fourth degree burns, which are the most severe, extending through all of the skin layers, the epidermis, the dermis, and the subcutaneous tissue. Also into underlying muscles, tendons, ligaments, even bone, often appearing charred or black with exposed tissue, and causing destroyed nerve endings. So her skin was as hard as wood, and her body was still smoldering. So I guess you could say Katie was conscious when she arrived in the ER because she was moaning and making some purposeful movements. But the probability is that she had absolutely no idea what was happening. She was severely burned.

Physicians use, when they assess burn damage, they use a rule of nine. So 9% of the body is the head. Each arm is 9%. Each leg is 18%. The front of the trunk is 18%. And the back of the trunk is 18%. And there's 1% for the groin area. So you have a mild burn if you're less than 10%. Moderate burn, 10 to 20%. And a major burn is over 20%. Now, I think she was around 40%, wasn't she? We'll find out. But she had a very major burn and probably was not going to survive just from the amount of burning. Well, I have rarely heard of fourth-degree burns. That must be...

unusual, that's when you actually get down to ligaments and bones and muscles. Yeah. Which is horrific. I mean, third degree, you've taken out nerves. So Katie had about 40% of her body with third and fourth degree burns. So the likelihood of her surviving was pretty much zero. Yeah, but of course the family had hope. Well, sure. Just the fact that she had arrived there still alive, you're going to reach out and try to grasp the hope that she'll make it. Well, of course. Now, she probably had no idea what was happening. I hope not.

The t-shirt was knotted around her neck and she had obvious bruising on her face. Also an indentation on the left side of her face and a black eye. So she'd been beaten too. Yes. Now the other thing they noticed was her burn pattern. She had no burns on her back or her legs. It was all on the front and from the top of her breasts down to her mid-thighs pretty much. So pretty much purposely burning her trunk, her breasts and her genital area because she'd been sexually assaulted. So it's really horrific. Now also noticeable were two puncture wounds on Katie's neck.

her eye was bruised and swollen shut the techs put paper bags on katie's hands in an effort to preserve whatever evidence they could they bagged the clothing cutting away the t-shirt tied around her neck now katie's toenails were polished a silvery blue color and there was a thin ring still around one of her toes her belly button ring was melted into her skin so this is a complete horror scene So Katie was intubated and was transferred to the Vanderbilt Burn Center by helicopter. Before the first law enforcement officer got there, the helicopter was already there and the hospital had been on the phone demanding somebody from law enforcement come in because they knew that this was not an accident and that there was going to be a homicide investigation. Yeah, there were a lot of questions about security at the university too. It was supposed to be impossible for anyone who did not live in that dorm to get access. Now we know when Katie arrived because there was someone at the front desk who saw her and said that she entered alone.

Now this was supposed to be the only entrance because all of the other doors were supposed to be locked. Stephen Soles had to have followed Katie into the dorm and gotten to her room that way. We don't have any evidence that he knew Katie prior to that night. So if he snuck in one of the other doors somehow, how would he have even known where her room was located? Yeah, so you figure he followed her in. Yeah, and that maybe the desk clerk had gone to the bathroom or not seen him or something. I don't know. It's just kind of strange the desk clerk hadn't noticed him. Now do you need a key to get into the dorm or something?

The dorm room or the building? The building. Yes, and she had the key. But what we're saying here is the doors weren't being locked as they should have been. The keys to the entrance to the dorm. Well, I don't think it was locked like it should have been, is what I'm saying. So then anybody could have come up? Yeah, I think so. Although you're supposed to check in with the person at the check-in desk. They said nobody checked in with Katie. She came in alone. Okay. But this is probably just another student, and that's a lot of responsibility. Well, he had to have come in after her, because how would he know what room she was in? Yeah, that's what I'm saying. How would he? So he had to have come in behind her some way and followed her. Now, Amy from down the hall in the dorms called Danica.

to tell her about the fire that morning. She told Danica that smoke was coming from her room. She said, oh, great, thinking Katie had drunkenly kicked over one of her candles or something. Yeah, minor fire. So, you know, Danica's young too. And she's probably got like that illusion of invulnerability that most young people have. Yeah, nothing's ever going to happen to me. Exactly. So they were young and strong and everything should have been fine. She asked Amy where Katie was and Amy didn't know. Danica told her to go find out what was going on and to call her back. So about 20 minutes later, Amy called Danica and told her what she had heard.

that Katie had been pulled from the building and was blackened by smoke, but was breathing. So the gravity of the situation really didn't sink in right away. Everyone at the apartment where she was that morning was still drunk, and Danica was stuck there without a ride. But then she finally did find someone to pick her up and bring her back to the dorm. When Danica got to the dorm, the police approached her. She didn't understand why they were questioning her about certain things, like they had told her that Katie was at the hospital, and then they started asking her questions. Were there any scissors out in your room? Did you have knives in the room? Finally, they told her Katie had puncture wounds.

And that was really the first time Danica realized that somebody had done this to Katie. It was not an accident. We're not talking about an accidental fire here. So when Katie arrived at the medical center of Vanderbilt, she was sedated and connected to a ventilator. She underwent additional resuscitation. A doctor cut long slits in Katie's skin, a procedure called escharotomy, so Katie's chest could rise and fall when she breathed, as her epidermis was too toughened by the fire to do this. The doctors were excising the burns and replacing her skin with grafts from cadavers.

So they need to have something covering the skin or the skin that's gone. You can't let them be left alone. You're inviting infection. And her burns were so severe that it was like she was in a cocoon or something. So they had to incise, get into this tough leathery skin or remnants of skin in order to put skin grafts and stuff on. Horrible. It is. Burns are a horrible way to die. Yes. Now at 10 a.m., her condition was listed as being extremely critical. And an hour later, it worsened to severely critical.

Katie's biological relatives met the Inmans at the medical center in Bowling Green. And once at Vanderbilt, relations between the households really started to deteriorate. The Inmans and the Whites did not see eye to eye at the hospital on quite a few things. One being who would make the medical decisions for Katie. So when Stephen Soles woke up that afternoon, on the television there was an update on the fire at Poland Hall. He walked outside to the foundation with no house in the neighboring lot. He took a handful of jewelry from his pocket and dropped it into some cinder blocks. Inside, he was using the bathroom and talking to Chris Bradshaw on the home phone line when the call waiting beeped in.

The caller identified himself as Special Agent Richard Vance from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms and said that he was looking for Stephen Soles. Stephen told Vance that he was Stephen's cousin and that Stephen was away working in Louisville. Stephen quickly ended the call and then went to play basketball at the park with some friends. Well, thinking quickly. So if we're assuming that Stephen did this to her, the fact that he went out and played basketball is really cold. This guy's a sociopath. Yeah, although...

Maybe you'll tell me later. When people were talking to Danica, or when Danica was talking to Katie after she returned, she gave the phone to somebody who was in the room, and Danica thought she could hear another male voice in the room. That's right, and we don't know who that is. Right. So the residential advisor, who had been on desk duty, would tell the Kentucky State Police detectives that she'd seen Katie come in alone between 1.30 and 2 a.m. She told them that Katie had not signed in any guests and that she had taken the elevator. The WKU police had each Pi Kappa Alpha member fill out a questionnaire.

about that night's goings-on. The WKU police picked up Ryan Payne and his roommate. While he was interviewed by Detective Kevin Pickett of the Kentucky State Police at the WKU police headquarters on campus, his room was searched. Remember, Ryan was the designated driver. Pickett learned that after dropping off Luke at the bowling alley, Ryan went to a friend's dorm room in Bemis, Lawrence, and stayed up playing video games with a group. This was later confirmed by multiple witnesses. But Ryan's description of taking Katie back to her dorm was very shaky. I got her in the truck, he told the detective, took her to Poland, and I was like, can you make it up the steps?

And I said, do you have a key to get in the door? Because I figured most of the doors are locked. And she was like, yeah. She said she was fine. Fine enough to walk up there alone. I said, just go on and get up to bed and sleep it off or whatever. And she said, all right. So I watched. I watched her walk about. But now Ryan hadn't mentioned the presence of Stephen Soles. And he didn't do that until the police asked him outright. This would be the last interview that he would have with the police, too. From then on, he'd have an attorney.

So some people might look at that as suspicious, but definitely I don't have any problem with someone getting an attorney, especially in a circumstance like this. Oh yeah, lawyer up. Now Ryan and his roommate were taken to the hospital and they both agreed to submit to sexual perpetrator tests. Later that night, Luke was on his sofa watching the NBA playoffs when headlights shined through the blinds. He looked out the window and saw Britain's father, Ed, climb out of his van and head to the front door. Luke opened the door. Ed's face was flushed red with anger. Ed considered himself to be cooled off compared to the night before when he found out what had happened. Stay away from my daughter, Ed said, and he punched Luke in the face.

The encounter, though, wasn't very effective because the next evening, Luke called Brittany and told her that if she pressed charges against him, he would do the same to her father. Luke and Brittany both agreed not to legally go after each other. And shortly thereafter, they were a couple again. Yeah, so this Luke, he's no Prince Charming. No, he's going to be an abusive husband, spouse. Yeah, and he's an abusive boyfriend and not a great guy, but we're going to learn he probably had nothing to do with Katie's death. So on Wednesday, March 7th, Sergeant McCarty of the Bowling Green Fire Department and Special Agent Richard Vance of the ATF went to interview Stephen.

Stephen told them that he had been so drunk he didn't remember any girl getting in the truck at all and that he'd never been to Poland Hall. He told them that Brian Ritchie picked him up from Bemis Lawrence and that they could ask him if they needed to. So McCarty and Vance met Ritchie at a Wendy's parking lot, and he did confirm what Stephen had told them, that he picked Stephen up around 2.15 a.m. Despite her awful mortal injuries, Katie held on for three days after the fire, and on May 7th at 7.10 p.m., she died. So how about if you go over the autopsy for us? So her autopsy report reads, pathologic diagnoses.

One, multiple traumatic injuries. A, thermal injuries, third degree burns to approximately 40% of the total body surface area, including extensive injury to the genitals. B, blunt force trauma to the head and neck, extensive contusions of the left side of the face and head, multiple contusions of the neck muscles. C, multiple poorly defined sharp force marks on the neck. D, associated conditions, extensive diffuse alveolar damage of the lungs, severe pulmonary edema, visceral congestion. These are all complications of the burns. Cause of death, complications of thermal burns, contributory cause of death, blunt and sharp force trauma to the head and neck.

manner of death, homicide, circumstances of death, assaulted and set on fire. That's just so horrific to me that someone would set someone on fire. Not only the pain and the awfulness of it, but just destroying the person's body like that. It's really horrific. She had puncture wounds on her neck and bruising on her face. Antibacterial hand lotion had been put inside her vagina, squirted into her purse and also smeared on the doorknob. And we're thinking this was some lame attempt at hiding or destroying DNA.

The purple can of hairspray that had been washed into the hall had been used as an accelerant, so she'd been sprayed with it specifically on her breast and genital region and then set on fire. The smoke alarm had been ripped from the ceiling, and her afghan was tied around the sprinkler head to lessen the flow of water. The door to her room had been locked from the outside with her own key. So Katie's murder could have been left to the Kentucky State Police or the Bowling Green Police Department, both of which assisted in this initial investigation. But there was also participation from the FBI, the Bowling Green Fire Department, and the ATF.

but in a very unusual precedent, Western's campus police took control of the murder, rape, and arson investigation. This was the decision of WKU police chief Robert Dean. It happened on our turf, he said in one newspaper interview. So Dean had worked on over 300 murder cases, but not since 1989. He had a long career with the Detroit police working in the homicide division from 1973 to 1977, narcotics from 77 to 82, and then back to homicide until 1989. In 2000, he was offered the job of chief of Western's police force and came to Bowling Green.

So Dean put WKU police detective Mike Dowell in charge of the Katie Autry case. And this was actually the university's very first homicide. The only violent crime he had ever been involved with was one of the robberies when an assailant had punched a taxi driver. So really in over their heads here. It just seems really stupid. I mean, it's nice that they wanted to do the investigation because it happened on their turf. But there's much more experienced homicide detectives. And this is a really serious, horrible crime. Yes, it is. Should be done by an experienced homicide team. Now the morning after he met with the police officers in the Wendy's parking lot.

Brian Ritchie called them to recant his statement. Remember, he had given Stephen Soules an alibi. Yeah, he picked him up. So now he realizes how serious this is, and he nervously said that he didn't want to talk on the phone and that he wanted to meet with police in person. So a meetup was arranged, and they met Ritchie at the fire station for a second interview. Ritchie told them about how he had really seen Stephen at around 7 a.m., the morning of the fire, when he accidentally sat on him because he was sleeping in his house. That he didn't pick him up, as stated before. Ritchie admitted that he was suspicious after Stephen asked him to lie, and then he tried to find out what happened.

but Stephen's story had kept changing. After leaving Katie's dorm, Stephen had stolen a child's bike and rode it home, and Stephen denied having anything to do with the bike when Brian Ritchie found it in his yard. He also insisted that he got to Ritchie's at 2 a.m., but Ritchie knew this wasn't true. Since his girlfriend had stayed up packing until after 3.30 in the morning, they were planning a move that day. Detectives Pickett and David McCarty went to Evangeline Sewell's small cottage, but she didn't know where her grandson was. They tracked Stephen down to a cousin's house. At almost 11 p.m., Stephen was trying to eat.

and he'd been crying. Stephen admitted to his cousin that he had been with Katie Autry and that the two of them had sex. Stephen admitted having sex with Katie, but denied having anything to do with the fire. They agreed to get picked up the next day for further questioning. Well, Pickett arrived the following morning, May 10th, at 7 o'clock. Stephen woke up and agreed to get the clothes that he had worn the night of the fire. Stephen carried them in a green garbage bag and placed them in the trunk of the squad car. Then Pickett took Stephen, along with his father and his brother, to the Kentucky State Police Station in Bowling Green. When they arrived, Stephen was escorted into an interrogation room.

Now Pickett began by asking him to describe what had happened on the night of Katie's murder. Stephen told of his ride with Ryan to take Katie to Poland Hall. He said that he and Katie had been making out in the car during the trip. He said that Ryan dropped her off, got out to make sure she got inside all right, and that she invited him up to her room. He said he took the stairs because he was afraid of elevators. Stephen said that he and Katie had sex, but then she got sick and had to go to the bathroom. So he left at 2.30 or 3 a.m. and was at Brian Ritchie's by 3.30 a.m. But Ritchie's since dissolved that. Yes.

And he did, though, admit to speaking to Danica on the phone, so we know that was him. So we know he was up in the room. I'm not believing that he was afraid of elevators and took the stairs. Not at all. No, I would think that he did that angle, wondering about cameras. Oh, yeah. Well, after he was confronted about his fingerprints being found on the hairspray can, Stephen said a buddy of his came into the room with them, and that was Luke. So Stephen really didn't come up with this on his own. The police were using a clever technique where they give the suspect kind of a way out, and then they can start confessing. Someone else had done the crime and forced Stephen to go along with it.

Now Stephen was afraid and needed to tell the police what had really happened. So one example of this method being used is in the case of Chris Watts. And that's when a detective suggested that Shanann had killed the children, and Chris just lost his temper and killed her after finding his children dead. This is not believable at all, of course. She did not kill her daughters. But Chris did confess to killing her when given this way out.

And that's when he started bringing Luke into the conversation is when the police started giving him that opening. Stephen had come up with Luke as his accomplice, probably because Luke already was known for having a history of violence. Everything he said about Luke was probably a description of what he had done to Katie, but also the story would change several times. Yeah, well, as I give more information to Stephen, he's got to go back and correct some of his falsehoods. Exactly. So the story's going to continue to evolve. Well, Stephen said, I guess Luke knew the girl that he talked to her at the party. He said he came in and saw that Stephen and Katie were having sex, and he wanted to get in on it. But she wasn't okay with that, and then things went crazy, and Luke got forceful with Katie. So this was the first time anyone had implicated Luke Goodrum in this crime. But the police were already familiar with him and the other Scottsville boys who attended the party. According to Stephen, Katie slapped Luke, and that's when Luke started hitting her.

Then she started screaming, so Luke put a pillow over her face and started hitting her more. Stephen claimed that he walked out into the hall and didn't know what to do. Then he came back in the room, and Luke was raping Katie. So Stephen denied having anything to do with killing Katie. He denied seeing Luke tie her up or set the fire. He said that he left before Luke started the fire. But again, Stephen's going to change this story at least four times. And to me, it's stunning that the police were actually believing a lot of this. It's just ridiculous, if you ask me.

So Stephen's interrogation, which had gone on for just about an hour and a half at that point, ended. Stephen agreed to have a sexual perpetrator kit performed on him, and the police began the process of getting a warrant for Luke's bodily fluids and to search his car. In his next interrogation, held two hours later, after he returned from getting his blood drawn and having hairs plucked, Stephen had built up his confidence. He spoke more clearly, and specifically, he described what he said had happened, and there was a detachment to him this time, kind of like if he was describing a car accident that he had witnessed on the highway. Yes, Stephen had asked someone to lie and give him an alibi.

and he was the last known person with the murder victim. He'd also lied to authorities multiple times, and he had admitted to at least watching a rape, which is horrible right there. But Chief Dean of the WKU police did not arrest Stephen, and Stephen was free to go. Luke was at a convenience store when two police officers took him to the Scottsville Police Department. He was driven to the medical center for a rape kit. Blood was drawn, and 30 hairs were plucked from both his head and his pubic region.

He was taken to the Kentucky State Police outpost and escorted to a small interrogation room, where Luke leaned against the white wall, and he seemed a bit casual. Detective Pickett eventually entered the interrogation room, and Pickett showed empathy and calm. They explained to him that he was not being arrested, and Luke signed a form waiving his Miranda rights. When asked to go over the timeline of May 3rd, Luke said he'd gone to meet Stephen Soles at the bowling alley, and then went back to Sarah Caldwell's apartment, and then on to the Pike party. Luke described the night, and Pickett asked him if he noticed anything strange or unusual.

He said he saw Ryan Payne leave and take a drunk Katie home. The questioning led to where Luke had gone once he had left the bowling alley after Ryan had dropped him off. Luke said that's when he went to his father's house in Scottsville. He had not seen Stephen at all since arriving at the party, he said. He also said he didn't know Katie at all. He did have an alibi and a receipt for buying that Coke at 2.40 a.m. So the police really tried to pressure him into confessing, claiming to have some of his hairs from her room and then saying they had video recordings of him at the dorm.

But he really didn't believe them, and he strongly denied everything. He even called their bluff to show him the videotapes. But they changed the subject because, of course, they had no videotapes. But that's also a common thing that police will do, is pretend to have evidence they don't, to get you to confess. By midnight, Luke was formally arrested. So Stephen was let go, and Luke was arrested. Luke was charged with capital murder and taken to the Warren County Jail. That's when he called his mother in Texas, and she immediately hired David Broderick, the really go-to defense lawyer in Bowling Green, because, remember, his mother and stepfather were very rich.

Yeah, so then after being questioned again, Stephen changed his story again. He admitted that, in fact, it was he who had hidden the jewelry next to his grandmother's house, not Luke. Stephen was taken back to the station for more questioning, and he told Detective Pickett that Katie kissed him on his cheek during the ride, that he touched her breasts, and that they had kissed. The desk attendant did not see Stephen or Luke Goodrum enter the building. From 11 p.m. to 7 a.m., the doors to the hall were supposed to be locked, and a key was required to enter the building. In truth, most often, the doors remained unlocked, so people were not sticking to this. The back door, which was a fire exit, was often used by students to enter and exit the building, so the building was not secure. It doesn't sound like it was very secure at all. No.

Stephen repeated the story of Luke's attack on Katie in a very calm tone, occasionally illustrating with his hands. In this interrogation, Stephen now said that Luke threatened him during the assault of Katie. Like, if you say anything, I'll kill your family. He alleged that in the beginning of the attack, Luke had said, I'll hurt your family if you don't shut the fuck up. Stephen claimed to have watched Luke rape Katie for 30 to 40 minutes. So even if he was telling the truth, that's disgusting. That's horrible. Now, after Luke and finally Stephen were arrested, they were pitted against each other. And it was kind of proposed in the media as rich against poor.

So this came to the public's attention on September 17, 2003, when Western announced that they had accepted a $500,000 pledge from Cale Jr. and Margaret Turner, the aunt and uncle of Luke's stepfather. So people were outraged and saw this as Luke's family attempting to buy the university off. I would think that. Luke's connection with the Dollar General store fortune helped to portray him as wealthy and privileged. But Luke really was not close to the stepfamily and was not totally considered a relative, so I don't think he was really set up to inherit a lot.

But under orders from his attorney, and they did pay for him to have a good attorney, Luke remained silent. Stephen, on the other hand, somehow was evoking sympathy. He was considered by many to be a victim himself. Stephen was portrayed as the manipulated pawn, a poor boy taken advantage of by his rich sociopathic friend. Now, at first, Katie was known as the college co-ed who'd been tragically attacked and violated. But once the papers started reporting that she had worked at Tattletales, the tone of the reporting changed. Her murder became a morality tale, like to say, this is what can happen to young girls who stray.

Articles never failed after that to mention her employment at the club. Although her job at Tattletales had nothing to do with the crime, it really became a constant topic, which you can imagine would be upsetting for her family and friends. Oh, it must have been terrible. Yeah. A letter printed in the Daily News reads, I think most college girls have been in that position. So this was just the worst kind of victim blaming.

On July 22nd, the Commonwealth of Kentucky filed notice that it would pursue the death penalty. The judge denied Luke's bail. The public defender represented Stephen. His family supported him and believed in his innocence. On July 22nd, the Commonwealth of Kentucky filed notice that it would pursue the death penalty against Luke and Stephen. The judge denied Luke's bail. The public defender represented Stephen. His family supported him and believed in his innocence. Now, that August, the DNA results from the vaginal swab from Katie came back. It was tested against samples from Maurice Perkins, Lucas Goodham, and Stephen Soles. Maurice and Luke were ruled out, but Stephen was a positive match.

Yeah, Luke's lawyer, David Broderick, filed again for bail, citing a lack of evidence. But again, it was denied, and Luke was held in jail. In March 2004, Stephen Soles was offered a deal for his testimony against Luke Goodrum. The Commonwealth would spare him the death penalty if he agreed to testify against Luke. So in return, he would receive life without parole. Stephen withdrew his not guilty plea then, and he pleaded guilty at a hearing to murder, rape first degree, rape first degree by complicity, sodomy first degree, sodomy first degree by complicity, arson first degree by complicity, and robbery first degree.

As per the deal, souls would receive life without parole for the murder charge, 20 years for the robbery charge, and life imprisonment for the rest of the charges. Stephen's sentencing was postponed, though, until after Luke's trial. Commonwealth of Kentucky v. Lucas Brian Goodrum began on March 9, 2005. No physical evidence was ever found to link Luke Goodrum to Katie Autry or to Room 214. The DNA found in Katie's body belonged to Stephen Soles. Contrary to the detective's remarks in interrogation, videos of Luke in Hugh Poland Hall did not exist. The university had not installed cameras in the dorm. Luke's former roommate, Matt Heyer, gave some of the most persuasive testimony regarding Luke's behavior.

He said that Luke returned to their apartment the day of the murder at approximately 5 or 6 a.m. and that Luke slept in his closet for about three nights afterward. Danica Jackson testified to thinking she heard those two male voices during the final phone call with Katie when she spoke to Stephen Soles. But she wasn't 100% sure about this. And I wonder, it couldn't have been Luke because he was out and then he bought that Coke. I wonder if maybe it was Ryan who just entered the building. I don't think Ryan had anything to do with it or necessarily had any idea what was going to happen. But he could have come up there and said something. Yeah, possibly. I'd also say it was Danica.

Absolutely positive she heard two male voices. No, she wasn't. No. Because I don't know how Ryan would know where to go. Well, unless Ryan followed them both. If Stephen followed Katie and Ryan followed Stephen. Yeah. We don't know that to be true. I mean, that's just something I'm throwing out there as a possibility. We don't know if there was any other male voice, actually. So the three men who were intended to be the prosecution's star witnesses against Luke had only briefly met with him at different points in his time in jail. Prison snitches really are not the most reliable witnesses, but the Commonwealth must have had no choice but to call them because they really didn't have much evidence.

So after each of their testimonies, it became clear that having no witnesses probably would have been better than using the three jail snitches. First, we had Terry Campbell, who had been incarcerated with Luke for two days back in May of 2003. Campbell claimed that Luke had talked to him about the case and Katie. He repeated details that were a matter of public record only. And upon cross-examination, it was revealed that after coming forward with the information about Luke, Campbell, who was being held in lieu of a $100,000 bond, was freed without having to post bail and was just signed out by his girlfriend. So that was a pretty good deal.

Now the next ex-inmate on the stand was Richard Kneeler. He was a thief and had to admit that he had once told a judge in writing that he was a compulsive liar. The prosecution then finished with Micah West, a nervous, skinny, fast-talking young man who was in the same cell block as Luke for just 45 minutes when he claims that Luke confessed. And this was when Luke was first arrested and brought in on May 10th. He also claimed there were 10 people around but couldn't explain why none of them had heard this so-called confession. Not one of them had any information that really helped in convicting Luke.

Stephen Soules took the stand and calmly retold the story of going back to Katie's room, Luke showing up, and brutally attacking her. He explained why he had lied to Pickett about his involvement, and when the defense questioned Soules, his demeanor became more guarded. The jury watched recordings of Stephen's different accounts of the crime during his interviews with police, and the effect of this was quite powerful. The discrepancies really piled up, and much of what he had said didn't even make sense. The defense presented two confiscated letters, giving two other accounts of what had happened in room 214, with different details by Stephen.

So designated driver Ryan Payne's testimony was pretty useless to both the prosecution and the defense. As the last person to see Katie and Stephen together before driving Luke to his car, Ryan claimed a total lack of recollection of the details. Considering that he was the one sober person at this party, his memory was shockingly poor. So why was he so secretive about what had happened that night? Remember, he didn't even mention that Stephen Soles had been in the truck until the police had confronted him with the truth. Like I said, I wonder if maybe he was inside the dorm building that night, but didn't want to be placed at the scene of a murder when he found out what had happened. Yeah, that's a possibility. I guess he wasn't aware if Stephen sounded asleep, passed out in the back of the truck, right?

At first he claimed not to be, but then he said that he did see him climb out. So depends what you want to believe about him. Okay. I mean, otherwise, if he went somewhere and came back and hadn't seen Stephen follow Katie into the dorm, how would he know where to go? How would Ryan know where to go? Yeah. Well, we don't think that Ryan went inside necessarily. I mean, that's just a theory I'm throwing off the top of my head. Yeah. And I'm trying to figure out how good a theory it is. I don't think it's great, really, to be honest with you. Okay. I don't think it's great. I basically think that Ryan did not want to get involved. Maybe his family, his attorney told him, no, don't say anything. I don't know. I don't think Ryan had anything to do with the crime, though.

There's no reason to believe that. Now, the defense's examination of WKU police chief Robert Dean was particularly detrimental to the prosecution's case. He was the head of the WKU police force, and he had not even been called by the Commonwealth as a prosecution witness. So that's pretty crazy. So they must not have thought that much of him. The defense began by questioning Dean's decision to take over the investigation. And throughout the questioning, it really did become clear that he wasn't qualified to head up the investigation. So I don't know if it was an ego move or what. Well, he had been a big city police officer at one time. Yes.

Now, Luke took the stand in his own defense, and he told the jury about his stop at a Citgo for a soda and some gas. He testified that he had paid in cash and then arrived at his father's house at approximately 3 a.m. Luke also stated that his stepmother, Judy Goodrum, was present for a lengthy discussion with his father about the incident with his girlfriend, Brittany. Luke said that his father offered him a place to stay until morning in one of the extra bedrooms, but that he went to his car to sleep instead. Luke claimed that he thought he was picked up by the police only because of the altercation he'd been in with his girlfriend, Brittany. One constant in each of Stephen Soule's retellings,

was that Luke was not in room 214 during Danica's phone call. And we pretty much know that to be true. In the defense's closing statement, their main theme was that the investigation was deeply flawed, that Luke was arrested just on the word of Stephen Solves, and that once Luke had been apprehended, the investigation pretty much ended. His defense attorney asked the jurors to think about the timeline of the crime and the implausibility of Luke being able to be at Poland Hall or even knowing what room Katie would have been in. And lastly, there was no physical evidence whatsoever connecting Luke to the crime.

So the jury reached a verdict after less than three hours of deliberation. The foreman passed the verdict to the judge who read all the counts of the indictment with the same decision after each, not guilty. After the first not guilty was read, Luke knew that the rest of the counts would also come out in his favor. He made the sign of the cross on his chest, and the Goodrum side of the courtroom just seemed absolutely joyful. But Katie's family collapsed into one another with sobs and moans, because they truly did believe that Luke was involved. And maybe they were just led to believe that by the police. A brief press conference was held immediately upon Luke's release. Luke sat surrounded by his family and defended him, all wearing Lucas's innocent buttons in front of reporters and television cameras. I knew the truth would prevail, Luke said in the microphone. I mean, it had to. After two years of being wrongfully jailed, I'm happy to be a free man and be able to be with my family.

So on May 12, 2005, Stephen Soles was officially sentenced. Soles had signed a plea for life without parole in 2004, but the judge still did have the power to alter this arrangement and could give Stephen the chance for lighter sentencing if he wanted to. Many friends and family members had sent the judge letters pleading for leniency for Stephen. Soles was sentenced to life imprisonment with no possibility of parole. After the trial, it seemed clear to some people that Stephen had acted alone. There is that second voice that Danica said she may have heard in the background while on the phone with Katie.

And we know that couldn't have been Luke because he was out and seen during that time. Maybe it was Ryan who went into the dorm, but left before the crime was committed. Remember, he couldn't have hung around. He had to leave to pick up more people from the party, including Luke, who he drove back to the bowling alley. That's right. Now, although the jury found Lucas Goodrum not guilty, the verdict did very little to sway the opinions of most of Bowling Green and Scottsville's residents. The public had been conditioned daily for years that Luke was indeed a murderer. His prior history of violence was well documented and broadcast. The jury might not have fully heard about his past, but the public knew all the details.

There was barely any public outcry on the mishandling of the case either. Very little anger at the authorities. The only staff changes at Western's police force were actually promotions. Many people believe that the injustice here was that Luke was set free. So pretty convinced they were. That they were. Despite pleading guilty to murder, rape, sodomy, and arson, and despite DNA evidence linking him to the crime, many of Stephen's family members believe he is innocent and stand by him. Some saw Stephen as a victim, not of small-town justice, but of Western and his police force.

Part of the insanity of Solz's statements to the police is that he never had a weapon pulled on him or anything like that. And it's illogical that anybody would believe that story. I mean, especially when he was able to leave the room while this crime was apparently happening. In one of his versions, he left the room two times, but never called anybody. Now, despite this, he had never bothered to leave or try to make a phone call for help or anything. And the one thing that Stephen still can't tell anybody and that the police can't explain is how Lucas Goodrum would have known where Katie Autry lived or how he knew that Stephen Solz was supposed to be with her that night.

He really wasn't anywhere around there. No, he wasn't. So again, in the spring of 2007, Katie's murder made headlines. On April 19th, the Kentucky Supreme Court ruled that Western Kentucky University and the WKU Student Life Foundation are immune from most of the lawsuits. On April 24th, an emergency protective order against Luke Goodrum was issued by his ex-wife, LaDonna. She wrote on the domestic violence petition, Lucas called and found out I was getting married, and he went off calling me names, so I hung up.

Then he called me back telling me he had a gun. He shot two rounds and said that he would be in Franklin in the morning with a surprise. So yes, I don't think Luke did this, but not a great guy at all. He is a domestic abuser. Yes, he is. And room 214 in Poland Hall was converted to a storage closet. So a tragic thing that happened and they did make changes, hopefully to make it safer. But we know that girls in college are not safe. There are a lot of rapes in college to this day. A lot of sexual assaults.

In fact, the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey, NISVS, recently published the results of a survey. One out of every three women college students has been sexually assaulted. The University of Washington did a study, and they found in theirs that 74% of women reported sexual violence in their college. Wow. Well, I mean, that doesn't really make you want to send your daughter off to school. It doesn't make you feel very confident about it. It doesn't seem like enough is being done. No? Well, I think a lot of colleges have the designated drivers, and not just for drunk drivers, but you can call and get a ride if you're afraid. I know that at the Massachusetts College, where our youngest son went, they had that.

so that women weren't out at night walking on their own. You could get a ride. As far as the Western Kentucky University in 2005, they implemented some security upgrades, and that included magnetic locking doors on the dorms. But the big problem is these kids aren't taking that that seriously a lot, and doors are propped open, things are overlooked. It's just kind of the nature of things.

Yeah. Well, look at this case. They have entrance to the dormitories is locked. It's supposed to be. There shouldn't be any way to get in without proper credentials. Well, and checking in with the front desk. And yet it happened. Yes. Yes. And I'm sure there have been many similar circumstances where women were sexually assaulted. This is just an extreme crime. Yes. Very extreme. Yeah. So you have to think that Stephen Soles is just horrible. I'm just shocked at how much support he's gotten. Because even if Luke was in on it, just the things he admitted to doing are horrendous. And he's where he should be. He should never get out of prison.

No, he shouldn't be ever released. No, and hopefully he won't be because he did get life with no parole. He got a nice deal, actually. Well, he's not going to face the death penalty. I guess as far as that goes. Yeah. OK, so we're going to move on to some feedback. You ready? Ready. It's time for listener feedback.

Okay, so Dickie, you have an email that you can read us for feedback? I do. Louise wanted to hear us do an episode on Jackie Bevins. And I think that's because it's a fairly big deal from southern Maine where we used to live. On April 3rd, 1990, Jackie Bevins shot and killed Jack, her husband of 23 years. These were kind of a power couple in Agunquit, Maine. Oh, Agunquit, yeah. He was a businessman and she ran several restaurants. So they're kind of wealthy. Well, that's a popular place for travelers. It sure is. Tourists, yeah. Yeah, big tourist place. Jack had a long history of abuse, both mental and physical.

And the day she murdered him. You mean abusing her? He was abusing her. And it was kind of open knowledge around town among their friends that he was not a good guy. So apparently one day Jackie had had enough. She shot and killed Jack. Now she got arrested and charged with homicide or first degree murder because she fired 15 shots at him. She reloaded her gun twice. Well, that sounds like a pent up rage or something. Doesn't it? Yeah. So her defense team claimed that she had battered woman syndrome. Okay. It's possible. And the jury apparently believed this.

In her defense, they deliberated for just three hours and returned with a verdict of not guilty. Okay. I just can't buy that. I could buy that she has battered women syndrome, but that doesn't mean you can shoot someone to death 15 times. Yeah. The prosecutor said afterwards that they should have gone for manslaughter or a lesser degree. Maybe, but because she was claiming that it wasn't premeditated. Right. Right. Okay. Battered women syndrome is the psychological effects of experiencing persistent domestic or intimate partner violence. And a quick article I read gave four characteristics of it.

The woman believes any violence is her fault. The woman is unable to place responsibility for the violence elsewhere. The woman fears for her life, which Jackie Bevins had said to several of her friends. And the woman has an irrational belief that her abuser is omnipotent. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Well, I guess I can see that. So let's cover it because I can totally see a battered woman wanting to kill or feeling like she needs to kill her husband for her own protection. But the 15 shots, the stopping to reload twice is, that's a tough one for me. Yeah. I mean, I think in Maine, there's a lot of talk about that. That was crazy that she was found not guilty. That's the overall opinion of the people there.

Yeah, there's no question that she did it. Well, she overdid it. Well, she did a bit. Okay, so yeah, let's cover that. Give us a good excuse to take a trip back to Maine. Yeah, we can do that. Yeah, okay, I'll read the next email. This is from Chris M. Dear Dick and Jill, if you get a chance, please watch the documentary Who Took Johnny? It's about Johnny Gosch, his disappearance, and possible kidnapping. And it's a very good documentary. I mean, his mom sometimes seems a bit unstable, and so is the one guy who claims that he's seen him. But still, it makes you wonder what the heck actually happened to him.

Johnny Gosch disappeared September 5th, 1982, while he was delivering newspapers. His body has never been found and no one has ever been charged. His parents feel that Johnny was abducted by a child sex ring. And Johnny's mother has devoted her life to educating people about sexual abuse in children. So that I think I have watched, but I don't remember that well. So I would do a rewatch because I have considered in the past covering this case. Yeah, I thought you talked about doing it. Yeah, I think we have. So we'll look into that. And then Chris goes on with something about Natalie Holloway.

So Chris writes, there's another one that just came on Peacock called Pathological, which goes into Natalie Holloway's disappearance and basically the investigation behind trying to prove Joran did it. Then it switches to when he killed Stephanie Flores. Just interviews with different people. Stephanie's dad made me weep, I must say. The documentary goes into the different cases and everything very well, but it does have Joran's wife in it. Yes, wife. Yes, someone married him and thinks he's a good person. I'm like, what? Anyway, I checked and you have not covered these cases yet, which is amazing because they're well known and you've been doing this for a long time.

Anyway, love the podcast. Chris M. from Kansas. So I know we've talked about doing Natalie Holloway's case before, and I think we always kind of fell to the opinion that it's been overdone. There's so much about her, yeah. But it is kind of slowing down now, so we might be able to get around to that. Yeah, that might be something. It might be. I know we watched a documentary, oh, probably two or three years ago, which was mostly her father taking a trip. Yeah. Yeah. But they were promising in the promotions for it. I know. We're going to find out the truth. Yeah, they supposedly had an insider, and that was really just a bunch of channel bait, I call it.

Not clickbait, but channelbait. Because they did get us to watch it and they kept coming up with, wait, there's more. And then there was never really anything. Nope. So we'll watch this pathological one. And if that seems like it has more kind of grit to it, then yeah, we could definitely cover that. We sure could. We could. Okay. Well, I think that's what we're going to hold it to today because it's been a fairly long episode and those are some great emails. Aren't they? Yeah, they really are. So thanks for your feedback, Chris and Louise. And thank you to everyone for listening, for writing in, for subscribing.

for everything you do. And welcome to 2026. I think it's going to be a good year. It should be. Yeah. I mean, it really can't be worse than 2025. Oh, it can always be worse. We're looking for a good year. Cheer me up. Okay. Well, thanks, everyone. We'll see you next time at the Quiet End. Have any seats. Come on down. Absolutely. Bye-bye. Bye, guys.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of True Crime Brewery?

This episode is 1 hour and 34 minutes long.

When was this True Crime Brewery episode published?

This episode was published on January 12, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this True Crime Brewery episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.