Hello and welcome to Full-State to show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the Gadigal Lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Monica Atard. I'm Rebecca Leek, sir.
You're the president and people tuning in to these briefings. They want to get information and guidance and want to know what to do. They're not looking for room for it. I'm the president and you're fake news.
And you know what I'll say to you? I'll say very nicely. Daniel's doing what there's a lot to break down from the president's more than hour-long speech. Anderson, this president is a serial liar and he's serially lied tonight.
I counted preliminarily more than 20 false-armous leading claims. I close it down from China. You bought yourself some time. You didn't use it to prepare hospitals.
You didn't use it to ramp up testing. You're so disrespectful. It's so disrespectful. I just went older.
It's all so sad because it's none of it is true. And so to me when you say, oh, I forget how you characterize it, to me it's just people being gullible. Or afraid of what? I was afraid of the dark when I was a kid.
I thought there was a boogeyman under my bed. In many cities across this country, red and your so-called red and blue states, will you commit to making sure that there is a peaceful transfer of power after the election? Well, we have to see what happens. You know that I've been complaining very strongly about the ballots and the ballots are a disaster.
But people are rioting. Do you commit to making sure that there's a peaceful transfer of power? We want to get rid of the ballots and you'll have a very peaceful, there won't be a transfer, frankly. There'll be a continuation.
This week, America passed a milestone that many saw coming, a staggering 200,000 people did from COVID-19. To put that figure in some perspective about how truly terrible it is, the American death toll in the capital terms is in the order of 18 times worse than Australia's per capita death rate. As you can see that figure also consider the idea that Donald Trump, the president who called COVID-19 the China Plague and insists on holding mass rallies as the virus continues to spread, is poised to get another four years in the White House. With an election a matter of weeks away and the country gripping what could be described as a partisan civil war of sorts, how should the media conduct itself?
That is, with a figure like Donald Trump is objective reporting not just impossible, but even morally acceptable. In this special edition, we asked not just what does Donald Trump mean for the trade of honest objective journalism, we asked how can the media serve a broken country that is searching for a way out of the worst mess in over 100 years? With us this week is Ben Smith, media columnist for The New York Times. He's also the founding editor and former chief of BuzzFeed News.
Ben is known for fearless writing and a take-no prisoner approach to his columns, where the helm of BuzzFeed famously published the dossier into a legendings between Russia and Donald Trump. As a media columnist, he's taken on the media darlings like Ronan Tharrow and written critically about the media industry in the age of Trump. Ben Smith, welcome to the show. Thank you for joining us today.
America has had four years of Donald Trump. The one booming economy is now retreating this week. They've had the news that over 200,000 people have died in your country from COVID-19. Crazy question, but here you go.
Can America take four more years? I don't know. That's above my big red. It is.
I mean, I think it's not that things aren't going great here. So you think that America would settle if Donald Trump were to receive another four years? Because certainly from the outside, it looks as though it's imploding. Or is that just the way we're seeing it from a faraway land through the eyes of the report each that we're receiving?
No, I mean, it's a total mess, I think. But I think it's also a very unpredictable mess. And I think, obviously, there are some potentially horrible outcomes of the election, partly because we just don't have a system where if it's close, there's anything like a clear resolution. It's just incredibly disorganized and decentralized and messy.
And so anything resembling a close race turns into a battle in court and possibly in the streets with nobody on with one side, ending at totally convinced that the winner is illegitimate. And I was going to ask you about that because of course, with the passing of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, it does seem like another front has opened up in the election. And it does look at this point in time like Trump does have the numbers to force his high court pick through the Senate. How do you read that?
Does that really change the race for the White House? No, I don't think it does, honestly. And I think it's the latest major event that everyone has said, oh my god, this will change everything. And in fact, the race has just been shockingly stable from the first debt with Trump in the low 40s and Biden in the high 40s.
And it's not a lot of people undecided. So not that you could imagine something changing the race. Ginsburg's death certainly really energized a lot of Democrats who gave a lot of money to Senate candidates around the country in particular. But no, 60% of Americans can't name the substitute justice of the Supreme Court.
And it's kind of an insider, I think, illusion that this is something that's going to profoundly change people's votes. I mean, the most plausible theory I've heard is that if the Republicans really race to push this through, it could well become, and Biden will try to turn it into a referendum on abortion rights and on the Affordable Care Act. This is a justice who's against federal protections for both. And those are unpopular positions.
They're trying to install somebody with unpopular positions and big issues. And I think that's if it becomes a fight about that, that's probably helps Biden, who think Trump is going to lose anyway, are basically willing to pay that cost. Right. I'm interested in that you say that most Americans wouldn't know who the members of the Supreme Court were and certainly not who the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court was.
Is there any sense beyond its kind of liberal intelligentsia circles that America has had enough of the Trump show? Is this all inside baseball stuff? I mean, it's to some degree inside baseball. It's also a very, it's a very close race.
So lots of different things could matter. Now, I mean, one thing that you alluded to earlier, and that is the true idiom of Trump, is that he kind of looks from the outside as though he's absolutely ill-suited to the job of President. And America from the outside looks like it's it's lurched from crisis to crisis. But on the other hand, he's been wildly successful as a Republican president.
He's delivered for his base. Are the Republicans, do you think really happy or do you think there's concern that the grand old party has has kind of changed forever? I mean, I think the perception from the inside is pretty much the same as from the outside that's a disaster. And I don't think that it's hard to say that he's delivered for his base.
I mean, he hasn't, you know, he sort of promised big infrastructure plans that haven't developed. He promised unpopularly to get rid of the Obamacare and replace it and didn't. I mean, the one place that he really has been effective is in restricting immigration. But broadly, it's hard.
He doesn't actually deliver it on much that he said he was going to deliver on. But he's delivered tax cuts to the wealthy, as you say, he's delivered on immigration, climate change is another area. It just does seem to be kind of already neat to his base. I'm wondering whether that's a thing that's written to his base.
He was promising to tax the riches. He's sort of governed at times as a kind of more conventional Republican. But I think he's really, you know, a lot of Americans are very, very engaged in this kind of propaganda war on both sides, right? But then in the culture wars and Trump really delivers on that every day.
Okay. So let's talk about the media for a little bit. Because the last four years have been a really wild ride for the media in the US. And I suppose it's fair to say that it's, you know, whilst it's been attacked ruthlessly by Trump and his supporters paradoxically, it's also kind of done well from him being in the White House.
The New York Times, for example, sent a huge surge in subscriptions of people embraced media institutions as almost like a safe harbor from Trump. Has the media, do you think, probably considered a way out of Trump if he loses? You know, I think that's a really interesting question. You know, Trump sort of, you know, turned the media itself into kind of a polarized issue and rallied a lot of the left and literals around the new places like the New York Times.
People who don't like Trump. And I think some of that you could certainly in cable news, I think you could, I mean, I think everybody is sort of hoping that, you know, in a more normal country, people aren't that interested in politics and aren't watching cable news all day and getting terrified by it. So I do think everybody, everyone in media is bracing for an extremely boring Biden administration. So do you think that the business of media has a post-Trump future?
I mean, if they don't have a business plan, so to speak, for a post-Trump America, or what then? I mean, the media business is changing so fast and in so many directions that, you know, I don't think it's a simple question, right? You just got to kind of keep moving with this crazy sort of fast moving thing, which is, you know, which has very promising signs around subscription and very, and very scary ones around advertising, for instance, in the business. But I don't think it's too complicated.
There's no one story. And do you think that that subscription model and the future, it seems to promise now will hold up in, as you put it, a boring Biden administration, will people really want to be paying for news, which includes, as it's based, political news? If there's nothing much there to excite them and report on. You know, I think it probably won't get that boring.
But also, I think people have been trained, people were just not paying for digital news, and now they are, and that's a huge shift. But it also comes along with, it's not just news, right? People are paying for digital subscriptions of all sorts, Netflix and Disney Plus being the big ones. And so I don't think people are going to make small transactions on your mobile phone or here to stay in the business as benefit, massively, from that broader trend.
I think it's overstated. In fact, how much it's just Trump, right? Netflix isn't booming because of Trump. And in fact, at the times, which I'm very much not a spokesman, right?
I just work here. But it's sort of an under-told story that a huge part of their subscription growth has been from their cooking and crossword puzzle apps, which have driven like a maybe 20%, 30% of their overall subscription base. So I think that there's been a shift in how these companies make money that will survive Trump, even if the most sort of sensational kind of resistance journalism won't. So this week in your column, you're paying CNNs, President Jeff Zucker, for the complicity in the rise of Trump.
What about the rest of America, what role do you apportion to them? I think in differing degrees, most of the media has wrestled with the same challenges around Trump, which have to do with this sort of, do you fall into his trap or do you ignore what he's doing, neither of them particularly satisfying? I mean, so much of his politics are about a theatrical fight with the media. And I don't think there's some clever strategy that nobody's thought of that gets you out of that.
But do you think that was something that Trump kind of happened upon? That he starts out attacking the media, and there's this happy result for him at the end, that the media almost becomes complicit in his continued popularity because it becomes then so polarized into these camps that have pro-Trump or anti-Trump? This is how he has always been. The person he is now, I'm not sure it's some complex new strategy.
He's always sort of had this sort of theatrical battles with the media and made that part of his personal drama. I do think he's managed to persuade a lot of Americans that you can't trust the media and done a lot of damage. Now, Ben, I use that up, I understand better than most that modern media platforms are driven by engagement, the clicks and the sharing, and all that happens with a certain level of emotional response from the audience. So where is Trump in his equation?
Who's exploiting who? Was he just the kind of inevitable outcome of a media looking for its next click, or has the media been exploited here by a kind of Trump family enterprise that's worked out how to gain the system? I would say some of both. I think the story of Jeff Zucker in CNN is sort of the clearest parable and probably the most important piece, which is that Zucker was running NBC Entertainment when this show called The Apprentice came on and really helped reshape this version of Trump, this frictional version of Donald Trump and the president as this heroic business leader.
Then took in some ways some elements of that same narrative to CNN, which had historically been his channel, but also had these sort of entertainment values. But I also think some of the things that you say, like this new media is fueled by a motion in entertainment, like you guys have tabloid newspapers in Australia. We didn't invent this in Silicon Valley in the year 2014. And a lot of the sort of staple demagoguery and attacking foreigners is not like some brand new tactic born at the internet.
It's just the oldest stuff in human politics. Okay, well, let's talk about the polarization because I found the comic you wrote this month about the polarization caused by Trump, which has forced people to embrace organizations, for example, like the New York Times, because it's anti-Trump. You implied that the media organizations can move more radically into positions because that attracts an audience. It's kind of writing for love, right?
Your position is a generalist and not people to be loved just because they take on Trump. What is your fear when you write about people loving journalism because of Trump? People are thanking journalists for telling them what they want to hear. And right now, maybe that is mostly correct, but it's not why hopefully we're doing it.
And it does create this incentive just to pander to your audience rather than to challenge them. So do you think it's moving journalism more into the advocacy space? I'm sure advocacy is the right word. It's almost like affirmation.
Has Trump made it possible or rather impossible for journalists to be objective and just cover the news, just cover him? Yeah, he has, actually, because so much of his persona and what he talks about is the media, right? And so he's sort of attacking you personally and lying about you and cheering that you've been hitting the leg of the rubber bullet. It's not something you can say that, you know, say, well, you know, some people say I was hitting the leg of the rubber bullet and some don't, right?
Like it's, you're sort of pulled the media reluctantly at times and other times are equally into the fray. So are you saying that journalists can't pretend that they have no skin in the game or that they ought to continue to try to pretend that they don't have skin in the game? I mean, they shouldn't pretend in general, right? I mean, I think they just do have skin in the game here, but they aren't, but they should also be transparent that their interests and their jobs aren't necessarily aligned with the go-by and sit all times.
Right. So then when Trump lies, you call that that lie, right? And he lies a lot. So that does then force the media in general or American journalists in general to appear pretty consistently as though they're anti-Trump and definitely- Right, no, it's kind of a dare.
You know, daring us to call them a liar. And there's no, and in order to trap us into not appearing neutral. It's a very, I mean, it's hard to, it's a clever strategy and there's not an obvious, they're not a simple way around it. What's the solution?
I mean, okay, granted, there's no simple way around it. But how then does American journalism, how should it be responding to that? How does it call that out? I mean, I think the best thing it can do is not spend a ton of time engaging in sort of arguments about him within the press conferences over words, but really focus on what he and his government are doing.
And there's a lot there, you know, whether it's the ICE detention centers or the sort of, you know, the rollback of various kinds of regulations. And I think you can try to, or by the way, the sort of overly racist campaigning. And I think you can, I guess my own impulse is that it's more effective to point to things that are happening than argue about what he said in order to provoke you and get a story about what he said. Right.
So in other words, don't call him out on these lies. And you call him out on his lies, but don't spend all your time doing it, right? Like, I think it's a bit of a proportion. I mean, you don't think that there's a risk in trying, they try to protect, you know, the old game of journalism, which kind of seems a bit quaint in ancient these days, but, you know, rather than playing or taking a stand that we lose our souls in trying to be objective and trying to move it on and move the story on and accept that we end up accepting or that American journalists end up accepting the lies, basically.
Yeah. I mean, I think this is like a less than zero sum game and everybody's worse off at the end. I don't think there's some clever solution here. I think you can call a lie alive but not spend 80% of your time, your reportorial energy.
You know, the news organizations have a certain amount of time in space and you can spend it covering what he says or what he does and balance those things. I think it's, you're better off covering what he does because otherwise fundamentally, he is setting the agenda. He's just deciding what you're right every day. Okay.
So what sort of stories do you think that the American media ought to be covering with him? I mean, a lot that they are covering, right? I mean, the American media is a huge diverse set of institutions. I mean, I think that some of the best coverage has been of, you know, everything from his attempts to build a to do a deal with Putin, to build a diet department building in Moscow in 2016 to what's actually happening in these camps on the near near the southern border with Mexico to the rollbacks of climate regulations in particular.
You know, too. Yeah. So I mean, those are all great stories. So if Trump wins been another four years after, you know, all that the United States any day the world has been through in his turn, all the controversies, the attacks on the country's institutions, the 200,000 COVID deaths, would that be, do you think, a moment of almost existential crisis for the media, particularly the American media?
Not just what does it do now, but has it shown itself to be largely impotent? That's certainly true, right? Like, you know, every newspaper in America endorsed against Trump and it didn't matter. And I think the sort of depth of the alienation from these mainstream institutions of, you know, 40, 50% of the country is obviously, you know, it's been true for a while, but is, you know, Trump made it incredibly clear.
That doesn't make it impetent, I think necessarily, or pointless, but I think that it certainly clarified that. And what would it say about the news media's ability to hold truth to power? Does that still work, if he's way elected? I mean, I guess I'm not sure these are such binary questions.
Like, media has often reported on horrible people doing bad things and been ignored for decades in both of our countries. And I'm not sure that makes it irrelevant, but also, but also, I think there's an impulse from those of us who work in media, or spend too much time on Twitter, just always to overestimate the power of the media, the role of the media in, you know, in shaping society. So Ben, what happens if Trump loses and he refuses to leave the White House? How do you think the media covers that one?
Again, there's no sort of the media, right? And I think what that exactly means is it a close race that's being litigated in court and they're sort of competing legitimate claims versus is it a, and they're sort of tactical and, you know, tactical things, sort of actions playing out within the framework of American law versus, you know, something even more dire, I think it depends. But I think the US, the media is going to cover it broadly as a crisis and not be very, very skeptical of any Trump claim to hold on to power. I mean, Fox News is the huge question mark here.
And I think how, and speaks to, right, if the big and most watched channel in the country speaks directly to Trump's base. And I think the question of how they handle it and how they interpret it is incredibly important. Because I've been, they've been difficult to to continue to have a game and there have been some at Fox that have been quite skeptical about Trump. What do you think of general attitude?
What do you think? I mean, I know that we can't answer that question in a blanket way. We don't know what individuals will, where individual journalists will land on this one. But overall, what's your sense about where Fox will land on this one?
You know, I think they're going to face an enormous amount of pressure from Trump. They've had a leader less at the moment. And ever since Roger Ailes left, he had a one by a kind of son of Riverbird-Ups and kind of a group who's kind of an absentee landlord and then a regent who rules on his behalf of Riverbird to the re-anyone's and charges running the show from the housewolds. And so I think, you know, it would be a question of whether these kind of middle level box producers are getting screened up at the President of the United States, what they're going to do.
On that note, I'd like to thank Vince Smith for being on For The State and thanks also for listening to For The State. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the community radio network. The program is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support.
Make sure you subscribe For The State on your favorite podcast app so that you can hear us talk media and politics and everything in between. We'll be back with more next week. But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is For The State.
A.U. Thanks to my producer Anthony Dockwell. My name's Monica Atard and thank you for listening.