Skip to content
Big Cap Chinese Stocks: Values or Traps? episode artwork

May 27, 2021 21 min

Big Cap Chinese Stocks: Values or Traps?

from Zacks Market Edge Hosted by Zacks Investment Research

Many Chinese stocks have sold off in 2021. Is this a buying opportunity? (0:45) - The Chinese Stocks Are Selling Off: Buying Opportunity or Value Trap? (5:35) - Tracey’s Top Stock Picks (18:20) - Big Takeaways From Chinese Stocks: BABA, JD, TCEHY, BIDU, TAL

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Big Cap Chinese Stocks: Values or Traps?

0:00 21:51
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is the Value Investor podcast with Tracy Rinek, all things value all the time. Welcome back value investors. After I did a recent Zex market edge podcast on Zex number five strong sell stocks, I discovered that a lot of the Chinese stocks have sold off hard. Now many of you know if you follow me on Twitter or stock to it's that I'm not a fan of the Chinese stocks.

That's why this was all news to me. I'm like, what the Chinese stocks have sold off? Because I don't own any and I don't own any in my Zex portfolios either. So my own personal portfolio or in the Zex portfolios I don't own any directly.

I'm sure I have exposure because I own companies that do business in China like Starbucks, but I don't own any direct ADRs of Chinese companies. So yeah, many of the Chinese stocks have sold off hard. So as value investors, maybe it's time to take a look, right? So I've also noticed that many of the viewers had been calling into Jim Kramer on his Mad Money show and they've been asking about him quite consistently recently.

So then I knew something also had a be up if a lot of people started calling in there and asking him about it. So it is time to check in and see if any of these are values or are they value traps. Now I've done the show on the Chinese stocks before, but it was a couple of years ago now I believe the last time I did it. So things have changed.

And like I said, the stocks have sold off here in 2021 for the most part, the ones I looked at at least. And so this might be a buying opportunity in some of these names, right? So let us recall what the difference is between a value stock and the value trap because they can look very similar, but there is definitely a difference and you don't want to get caught in one of the traps versus just buying the solid value stock. So value stocks remember have low classic value fundamentals, like a low price to earnings ratio, low price to book ratio, low price to sales ratio and low pegs.

So that's how you find the classic value type of stock. And that's the method most people use to find value. Now there are these other ways to find value versus your peers and that kind of thing, but it really doesn't have anything to do with the actual price in terms of finding value, but it's what you're paying for the earnings and the sales and this kind of thing underlying the company fundamentals. So the traps, those can look like value stocks.

They can have low pegs. They can have these other low fundamentals the same way. But the one thing that's different is that the value traps will have declining earnings. So I'm talking about not within the year.

I'm talking about year over year. So year over year earnings are on the decline and not growing. An indication that there's might be a reason that the stock is cheap or that Wall Street is running away from it or that they're ignoring it is because the earnings are going in the wrong direction. And Wall Street professionals for the most part want to get companies and want to own those that are growing their earnings year over year and seeing those earnings increase.

So let's take a look at some of the most widely held Chinese stocks. I just pulled five out of the air. The ones I know that most people are calling Jim Crane or about or that talk about on the various chat boards and that most people own if they own any of the big Chinese companies. So you know what these are.

These are basically the chosen ones. Some of them are like the Chinese equivalent of US companies like the Facebook of China or the Google of China that kind of thing. And these companies were supposed to be like the golden ticket. They were the way to access billions of users in China because Facebook can't.

So you can own the Chinese equivalents because they can. So how could you not want to invest in these these like just huge giant tech giants that are still growing. But as we've seen with the shares weakening here, there have been some underlying challenges with the Chinese government crackdown on big tech companies that's happened here in 2021. That's really hit a lot of these shares.

And then other just pandemic related things and individual company related issues that have hit the shares. And then just when the growth stops have weakened, most of these Chinese companies are still growth stocks. So they have joined in that weakness as well. So could some of them be values here with the sell off or are they the traps.

So let's dive right in. I picked out five and so let's take a look. So the first one I picked is the most obvious one. This is the one I talked about on the market edge where I was surprised at what's happening with the stock is Alibaba.

B.A.B.A. is the ticker. So here to date, they're down 8.7% versus S&P 500 up almost 11% during that time period. One year though, this is the real underperformance.

One year up to 6.4% versus the S&P up 41% in that time period. So huge underperformance in the last year. So the PE now, however, is at just 18 times. So this one is actually getting to be kind of cheap here on a P basis.

The peg is 1.08 here. So the peg even is getting close to a value peg. But we have to take a look at those earnings because that's the key, of course, right? So fiscal 2021, they made 994.

Fiscal 2022 expected to make 11.45 again, a 15.2%. Fiscal 2023, 14.42 cents up another 26%. So we are seeing earnings growth year over year of 15% and then 26%. So we're not seeing earnings decline.

So no trap here. The estimates, however, are have been cut for 2021 and 2022. Five of them were lowered. Only one was raised for 2022.

So that's why it currently has the ZAC strong sell ranking because the analysts have been adjusting those earnings estimates and they have lowered them recently. So that's where you get the ZAC rank. But the actual earnings growth is pretty nice here. I took a look at first quarter revenues were up 64% year over year.

Their mobile monthly active users in China was 925 million up 20 million from December. So still seeing again that growth, the shares are getting more attractive here. So I actually think this is a could be a value here Alibaba for those of you who are interested in some of these large cap Chinese stocks that the shares now that they haven't really done anything but those earnings are on the move higher means that the PE is contracting here instead of expanding. So yeah, Alibaba is a value here, a value stack.

Okay, the second one we're going to look at is JD.com ticker JD. This is similar to Amazon in China. It's used by a lot of the consumers. They do a couple different business methods though.

They have logistics. They have the huge retail arm and they have what they said was a fast growth in advertising services. So similar to what you find again at Amazon, maybe not with the movies and all that stuff, but the retail side is very similar. So year to date these shares are down 16.5% but still up 47% over the last year that is beating the S&P 500 which is up 41 to 42% in the last year.

So still has a pretty good one year track record, but the shares have somewhat gone on sale here. So let's take a look at those earnings. 20, they made $1.62, 2021, expected to make $1.60. So down slightly 1%, so down 2 cents, that'll probably change as the year goes on, basically flat, but 2022, analysts see more growth resuming and up 44% to $2.30 there for 2022.

The estimates have been cut for both 2021 and 2022 in the last two months with three cut for both years, but none of the estimates have been raised. So analysts, a little pessimistic here. This one is also as X number five strong sell currently. So revenue though in the first quarter was up 39%, so they don't seem to have an issue on that part of the equation.

They're still seeing the strong revenue growth. But so let's ask the question, is this a value or value trap? They're not really seeing any earnings growth for this year, but it is basically flat. So not too much of a trappiness here.

And I do like that they're expected to see the big growth happening again in 2022. If that does result, then this is looking a little bit more attractive, but the PE ratio is still pretty high here at 45 times, but the peg is just at one. So peg is telling me there's a little more value there, but the PE is still pretty high even with these shares down 16% year to date. So keep that in mind, but on a basis compared to where it was, this is looking more like a value here as well.

So the third stock is Tencent ticker TCE-HY. So it's one of those five tickers, five letter tickers TCE-HY. And year to date these shares are up 9.7%. So just a little bit under the S&P 500 there at about 11%.

And one year up 49.6%. So beating the S&P on that. What does the earnings outlook look like? 2020 made a dollar 84, 2021, 239.

So that's a gain of about 30%, 2022, 292. And let's looking for another gain of 22%. So we have some nice earnings growth there over the next two years. So that's not the trap, right?

The PE is at 32, for some reason we have no peg, but the PE is at 32, pretty pricey, but not extreme. And this one you're not getting on sale quite as much as year to date. They are up the 9.7%. So there's that.

Maybe that's why they're a little bit more elevated. So Tencent is in social networks. So it's kind of always been called the Facebook of China. So social networks, games, online advertising, and a big FinTech and business services side as well.

They have the WeChat there and they had 1.242 billion monthly active users in the first quarter. Revenue was up 25% year over year. And that year over year comparison would have been to the lockdown quarter of the prior year and the pandemic over in China. So keep that in mind as well.

This one is not a five. It's a number three hold here. So yeah, this one is looking like a nice growth stack here with an attractive valuation, but I wouldn't call it dirt cheap by any means. If it pulls back some more if the shares weekend, then this one, Tencent could be much more attractive.

Okay, then switching on to the fourth stack, which is Baidu, ticker BIDU. A lot of people are in this one for its AI business. It's in the cloud, autonomous driving, all of that. And this one year to date, the shares are down 9.8.

So they have gone on sale. One year, they're still up 88.9%. It did soar into February of 2021 before this downturn began. So this could be a buying opportunity if you're interested in this one, but is it a trap?

So 2020, they made $9.80, $9.80. 2021 expected to make $9.82. So just two cents higher, much like JD.com. So basically flat year over year, but 2022 expected to be up 1231, up 25%.

So again, this does mirror like JD.com where the analysts are much more bullish going into 2022. Two estimates were cut over the last 30 days for both this year and next year, however. Which is why it has a ZACs number four, sell rank on it because those estimates cut. Now their first quarter revenue was also up big, up 34%.

Their non-advertising revenue was up 70%. So they're really emphasizing that they're trying to make a little bit of a change over to other things other than just advertising. They are doing a share buyback and they said they were in the top three in cloud services in that quarter. So what does the PE actually look like?

PE is at 19.6. So not super crazy sky high here. The peg though is at 4.2. So pretty high on the peg.

So you're paying a lot for the growth. But that's also probably because those earnings are expected to be flat this year. But by do, a lot of people have been trading this one and the shares have gone on sale and it is not a value trap here as long as they're holding on to these gains heading into 2022. As long as they actually do see that growth return for 2022 on the earnings side.

So that's by do ticker BIDU. And then we're going to wrap it up with something a little bit out of the range of these other four, which is towel, education, TAL. I know many of you have been in these and this is the I'm quoting off their site, the leading K-12 after school tutoring services provider in China. So they have both learning centers, they have online and they have tutors that you can get, private tutors, their learning center network covers 90 cities now.

They also operate an online education platform, which has a different name in addition to their online courses. So you can imagine that things have been pretty good during pandemics and laptops and what not with something like this. So towel education, TAL is the ticker there. Year to date, these shares are down 44%.

Over the last one year, they're down 25. So a lot of difficulties for anybody trying to hold on to these, but let's take a look at those earnings. Is there a reason that they're down 44% year to date? Fiscal 2021, they made 14 cents a share.

Fiscal 22 expected to make 61 cents up 335%. Then fiscal 23, 98 cents up another 60%. So the earnings are going in the right direction in a big way. And some nice earnings growth there.

But the PE, even though the shares are still down 44% year to date, PE is at 69. Peg is at 2.1, to be exact. So still a little pricey on the valuation side, even with the shares coming down to Earth per se. But no value trap here, but you are paying a decent amount for that growth, but no trappiness.

So I guess we should conclude, and I want to say I didn't look up any of these before I picked them. And so I had no idea if there would be any value traps in any of these or if they would all be values or what their valuation was like, I just knew that there'd been weakness in the Chinese stocks. So I was surprised as anybody when I dove in to see what was happening. So the earnings outlook for these five Chinese stocks looks quite impressive, actually, and mirrors what is happening globally coming out of the recession.

So no trappiness here heading into 2022, a little bit of a lag with a couple of JD and Baidu here in 2021, a flatlining a bit. So taking a break, as you might say, but then hopefully resuming that growth for the following year. So I think that's one of what you're paying to get those earnings and evaluations you're able to get. But as some of these continue to weaken a bit here on this growth weakness, you might be able to get even a better deal on some of these.

So that's something to keep in mind too, because the trend right now for all of these on the chart, other than maybe 10 cents, which is up a bit here this year, is still to go lower. So the trend is still not the momentum you hope to see in some of these. But that's why they're values or at least have value characteristics, right? Because Wall Street is ignoring them and the rest of investors and traders have been disillusioned and have gotten out and are too scared to maybe to get back into some of them either.

So that's why you get values. So it's worth taking a look as a value investor if you're interested in the Chinese stocks, because you might as well get them on sale. And that is mostly what's happening right now. There's some value here.

And so you might want to keep them on your watch list. So let me recap those tickers again. We had Alibaba, which is the cheapest on a PE level of the bunch and has a good peg to you at 18 times on the PE and a peg around one. Baba is the ticker, BABA.

Then we had JD.com still pretty pricey here, even though the shares have pulled back. But that ticker is JD. Then Tencent is one of the ones that is not lower for the year. It's actually up the ticker.

There is the five letters TCEHY, then Baidu, which is a favorite of many of you looking for growth in China, especially on the AI side. Baidu, BIDU, and then Tal education down big this year might be one to put on the watch list there. TAL is the ticker. And as always, I'm bringing you as many value stocks as I can and wondering whether or not some other industries and stocks might be traps as well.

But if the Chinese stocks are any indication, we might have a hard time finding real traps here in 2021 as earnings growth is looking tremendous here heading into the second half of the year and the economic reopening. But we're still going to be searching for value every week. So you want to be sure to get us somewhere. We're on Spotify, Amazon Music, Apple Podcast.

You can get us with the market edge on SoundCloud. Be sure to get us somewhere and I'll see you again next time with some more value stocks.

The Investor's Podcast (We Study Billionaires) - The Investor’s Podcast Network The Investor's Podcast Network Hosted by Stig Brodersen, William Green, Shawn O'Malley, Daniel Mahncke, and Kyle Grieve, The Investor’s Podcast has proudly reached nearly 200 million downloads, as the world's largest stock-investing focused podcast. On the show, we study a range of businesses and their investment prospects, from Spotify to Amazon, serial acquirers like Constellation Software, deep value plays, and more, using lessons from some of the world's most famous investors, like Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, and Howard Marks. Leverage the lessons we learned from studying, and talking to, the wo Capital Ideas podcast Capital Group Want to learn how professional investors do it? The Capital Ideas podcast brings you the latest investment thinking from Capital Group, one of the world's largest investment management organizations. Each week we'll get inside the minds of portfolio managers, analysts and economists to break down market trends, macroeconomic forces, investing approaches and lessons learned from personal experience. Take 30 minutes and tap into the intellectual capital of Capital Group. Capital Client Group, Inc.All Capital Group trademarks mentioned are owned by The Capital Group Companies, Inc., an affiliated company or fund. All other company and product names mentioned are the property of their respective companies.For full disclosures go to capitalgroup.com/global-disclosures. Growth Triggers: Content Marketing & AI Luis Diaz Discover how to use your podcast to generate leads, sales, and influence in any market. On this show Luis shares his best tested and proven secrets, tips, and strategies from launching over 300 podcasts in over a dozen different niches and generating over 59 Million Downloads for his clients. Learn how to increase your podcast listenership, create multiple new revenue streams with your podcast, sell more of your core offer and build a show that gives you leverage and authority in your space. From picking the right monetization strategy for your podcast to learning how to position your podcast in a crowded market on Apple and Spotify; this is show is the ultimate marketing and sales resource for online business owners who want to know what works with podcasting. Get in touch over on Instagram <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" class="link" href="https://www.instagram.com/luisr

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Zacks Market Edge?

This episode is 21 minutes long.

When was this Zacks Market Edge episode published?

This episode was published on May 27, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Zacks Market Edge episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.