Hi, everyone. This is Katherine Adams and Elizabeth Wallace, and you're listening to Binary System Podcast number 467. And tonight, it's our usual thing. We are going to talk about another episode of Station Eleven, and then we're going to talk about another episode of Star Trek Lower Decks. So we will just jump right in with Station Eleven. And I have to say, right off the bat, Episode 7 of Station Eleven is kind of the high-water mark so far. I mean, apparently Hannah was really excited for us to get to this one. And I can understand why, because it is beautiful and also very tragic, and it had absolute perfect music choices the entire way, and such a great way of doing what was basically a flashback.
episode yeah this solves the mystery that they've kind of been leading up to for the entire season obviously giant massive spoiler warnings but we start with kirsten she's in the woods she's lying in amongst all these bodies And then she sees the younger version of herself, but she's dressed like the younger version of herself with like a long skirt and a big puffy coat and everything. And the younger version is just very cheery and telling her, you're dying. Because apparently one of the red bandanas who attacked her, she took them all out. But one of them shot her with like poison darts, I suppose. I went back and re-looked at the end of the episode and he fired poison darts out of a little pan flute that he had with him. So he fired multiple ones into her arm. And yeah, she can see they've got that like blue-black crawling up her veins on one of her arms. And little Kirsten says, this is the antidote. He used to be a dentist. I have no idea what that one has to the other. But she just...
very cheerfully starts running for it and our kirsten older kirsten has to chase her through the woods and then finally finds a doorway but it's one of those doorways it's just like it's a regular doorway hanging in midair yeah that's never stops being creepy it's just especially when it's very dark when you go through it but she does go through it and what she finds herself at is frank and jeeven's apartment when the pandemic was first getting started yeah now there's a countdown through this whole thing there's actually a lot of different countdowns one of the countdowns is of course like the blue black inky stuff the poison in her veins you see it creeping higher and higher i always like that as a kind of a countdown um but the other countdown that will appear on the screen is counting down the days to the play. And they don't say anything else. They just say the play. Yeah. And Nathan was the one that remembered in the episode when Jeevan and young Kirsten were in the cabin and he's getting upset. And I think she told him it was your idea to leave. And I think he said, we had to wait until you did your play or we had to wait for your play. Well, now we find out what that exactly was referring to. Now, I don't know when this happened in the episode. We took some notes, but not a lot of notes. But before they get there, Frank actually talked to Sia. That's their sister's name, right? He talked to her on the phone.
read another recap of this episode that pointed out that Frank had said that he hadn't talked to Sia so I don't know if this is it's probably not a goof it's I think he just lied to um Jeevan he definitely did not want Jeevan coming in because he was very much a recluse and everything but he was on the phone with Sia and Sia was telling him you have to let them in so she's the reason why Jeevan and Kirsten were able to even get into the condo and it's another trauma that both Jeevan and Frank have to deal with is the fact that realizing yeah it's pretty likely their sister's dead and uh Kirsten meanwhile is you know she has the whole thing where she finds out that her parents are both dead obviously and and she's trying to Everybody goes back and forth between trying to be reassuring to everybody and despairing. And at one point, Kirsten starts singing the first Noel because it's Christmas time. And, oh, that actress has got some pipes. I mean, you could have played that many different ways. And one of them would have been very halting and off-key. But this is a theater kid, so she does a very good job. It's just...
It's just very, very sad. And I think they've all been listening to the news reports and like the coverage of how bad the pandemic is and a newscaster saying we weren't prepared for a flu that has no incubation period. Yeah, we were wondering exactly how many people died in this thing. Apparently this flu has a one in 1,000 survival rate. So that's worse than decimated. And another thing before I forget, when Frank had talked to Sia and she convinced him to let them in, one of the first things he did before they got there was he had this like bundle of stuff and everything. It's obviously a drug kit and he threw all the drugs away.
And it comes out later on that he's a ghostwriter, and she even manages to pull it out of him, that ghostwriting is the only thing that he feels like he can do anymore. We'll find out a little bit why, what has sort of traumatized him and everything. But he feels like even with ghostwriting, the only way that he can do it is if he's high. But I'm going to tell you right now, we never see a withdrawal period for him. We don't really see him even...
itching at himself or being uncomfortable and i don't know if they just skipped over that part or if he's one of those people who i don't know i dated a guy at one point who'd been a big smoker but as soon as we started dating he just quit he's one of those people who just stops he's like oh yeah i'm just not gonna do that anymore and i'm just like kind of makes a little bit of a sociopath but maybe that's what frank is maybe frank's one of those people that it's something that he wanted to do and he was mad that he really didn't feel like he could do it anymore because there's a kid in the house But at the same time, he's like, well, that's enough of that. And he just doesn't do it anymore. It's also the fact that it's only been 10 months that he's been taking heroin. True. And I think Jeevan thinks at first that he's on it because of the hip. But he's dealing with some trauma. And there's a lot of wonderful little bonding moments between young Kirsten and Frank. And he actually opens up to her at one point about what it was that happened. He was a journalist, I think, traveling to Sri Lanka where he wasn't supposed to be. And he meets somebody that's his contact who's going to be showing him around. And they walk for like half a day. And then the last thing he remembers.
is that he hears something, he looks around, and his guide is running for it. And then something explodes. So I guess the guide set him up to be blown up for being a foreign... correspondent of some kind. So yeah, yeah. Or if you want to be charitable, I don't know, maybe he stepped on something and the guy recognizes the sound of a bomb about ready to go off and just took off. But yeah, it's probably more likely the former. Another wonderful little scene between the three of them is that he tells Kirsten that he woke up in a military hospital and he starts freaking out and he looks over and Jeevan is asleep on the floor and said that he had like got himself a plane ticket using his sister's credit card. And Jeevan comes in and says, and I came in first class and Sia never knew. And Frank looks at him, she knew. Really?
And then they all start laughing. So maybe she did know she didn't, but it's all very cute. It is so cute. But this episode jumps around in time so much of the time, and you have to sort of pay attention to what's going on. If it's, you know, if there's anything going on with, like, lights or possibly, like, a TV or whatever, it's fairly early on. Later on, when the power goes off, when it's dark, and they are all...
just about ready to freeze to death you know it's getting closer to the play but there's a wonderful image at one point where they're standing in the window and they're watching the lights in the city just all go out as the power grid fails and it's like i don't know if you would actually be able to hear something like that but the sound work they did on that where you hear this chunk chunk chunk chunk as you see gigantic patches of lights go out all at once moving their way down the um away from their view window and oh god they're chilling now so we know what frank's trauma is that sort of made him kind of the way he is he doesn't feel like he can write anymore and he certainly got problems with his hip and he thought that turning to heroin was a good idea and everything do we know exactly what caused jeevin's trauma because at one point when the lights are kind of out and they're lighting some candles frank says something to him like are you still scared of the dark and jeevin's like yeah and so i don't know if that's did we find out anything about what might have caused Jeevan to be the way Jeevan is? I don't think so. I mean, I'm going back to when they were in the grocery store and he's having a panic attack. And I think he's like, he's trying to find his coping mechanisms. So this is something that he's been having to deal with for a long time. Yeah, yeah. So as we go back and forth, we start getting into more arguments because...
Jeeva knows that, yeah, it's great that they've got this spot right now, but there is just no way that they're going to be able to stay there forever. They will run out of food. They might freeze to death and everything. And Frank doesn't want to hear it because Frank's in denial. But Frank also is just thinking, there's no way that this is going to go on forever, right? You know, somehow, somehow we're all going to come out of this. But Jeeva eventually takes matters in his own hand and he goes out into the hallway, opens up the sealed up door to their place to walk into one of the other units. And it's somebody...
who I think may have smashed open their window to let the cold in as a kind of suicide. And, oh, boy. And there's a piano in there, and the sheet music is for a friend's List piano concerto, and it just has a message on it that says, impossible. So, which, apparently, yeah, that's pretty impossible. Yeah, I read a recap that pointed out that List had, like, really big hands. People with smaller hands have a much harder time. But, apparently, the recap also pointed out that that is what Sarah, the conductor, was playing on the keytar when she first met Kirsten. Oh, no kidding! Oh, that's awesome. That was really nice, yeah. However...
I'll tell you right now, they didn't play it in the closing credits. And I'm like, I think you guys missed a trick. That's OK. That's OK. Now, all of this time this is happening, Kirsten, adult Kirsten, is just watching all of this. And I feel like there's some things that conversations that she wouldn't have been privy to, like when Frank and Jeevan start talking to each other in Hindi, I think. But I guess she's also remembering stuff that she hasn't thought about in a long time. And at one point, she actually gets the young Kirsten's attention and tells her, don't write the play. You leave one day late if we keep up with the play.
so now we've got that as part of the ticking clock yeah the play that she's writing by the way is a version of it's like a scene from the graphic novel that she's been reading over and over and over again and later on in the episode it takes a while because of course she even wants to leave immediately obviously frank doesn't want to leave at all but kirsten's like we have to do the play and so frank's like yeah we gotta do the play you know because he just doesn't want to go and she makes the costumes for it and A recap that I pointed out said that it took them out of the moment because clearly the costumes were made by adults who were trying to make stuff that looked like they were made by kids. And I'm like, I didn't get that. I just, I thought they looked great. I did too. And I'm pretty sure I read the same recap because I can't believe they were complaining about that because it was just like, it's space helmets made out of cardboard. But like one of them is made out of strips of cardboard that are kind of pasted together in an almost spiral pattern to make the shape of the faceplate there. And it's just like, oh, it's so elegant. And then Kirsten's got hers on and it's just made out of toilet paper rolls. It's so delightful. Yeah, I thought Frank had one.
the bottom of a Tupperware where they've cut out the bottom of it so that you have like the square around the edges and that kind of makes the viewport and I'm thinking that is just genius it's great but also something I could see a really smart kid coming up with now one thing leading up to this that makes the play when they're finally performing it really heartbreaking is the fact that Frank tells Jeevan that they need to go themselves, but he needs to stay behind. He is not going to be going on this excursion. He's not going to be leaving his condo. And he tells Jeevan, you won't survive if you have to take care of me and she won't survive without you. So this is the only way for you to not be alone. It's just, oh my God, because he's got a bad hip. I mean, I think in the book it was a wheelchair, but I think it's a little bit more subtle here when you have him. He can still move around with a walking stick, but it's just one of those things. Oh my God, it's the apocalypse. I mean, any kind of mobility issue and he's still doomed, but this kind of allows Jeevan to think that, well, maybe we could all go together. So he's still
hasn't let go of the idea of having frank come with them no and every time he gets upset you see him he's sort of made a little tent for himself in the living room i assume that uh kirsten has the closet space that she made but there's also like a spare bedroom but yeah she's got his own little tent but he goes in there sometimes and he has these whole long conversations with sia and they are a bit unhinged but i remember at one point that young kirsten was talking to old kirsten and old kirsten had thought that that kind of stuff started when they were in the cabin and young kirsten's like no no it started here so they're they're very much communicating with each other this whole time So we have the play and it involves Frank's character gets stabbed by Kirsten's character. And they have the whole thing where you have a little red streamer that comes out to show off the like stabbed in the throat, that sort of thing. And Frank is, he's telling Jeevan's character that it's time for him to leave. And Jeevan has a line that he just can't say. And I think it's because he doesn't want to finally say goodbye to Frank knowing that they are going to have to leave now. Yeah. And then somebody walks in the door.
it was so creepy. And immediately Kirsten does what every good kid should do. She immediately starts yelling. She knows that this is not right. And they yell at her like, go run, run, run, close the door, lock the door and everything. And she does. I mean, she does exactly what she's supposed to do. But this guy who's standing there, who's sort of wearing winter clothes and everything and has this big knife in his hand, he just very calmly, but very creepily says, please leave. I live here now. And you're like, oh, crap. Golly. And Jeevan's just like, he's placating him. He's like, it's fine. We've got all of our stuff ready to go. We were just leaving. Frank, let's go. He's like, Frank?
Let's go. And Frank is just looking at him and he looks at the guy and says, I'm not leaving. This is my home. And then the guy rushes him with the knife and manages to stab him. And then there's this whole wrestling. I mean, it's like this guy who attacked them is obviously not some kind of militia leader or something. It's a desperate guy who's decided that he needs to kill before he gets killed. But of course, it's not going to be like a big cinematic fight. It's just going to be everybody throwing themselves at each other and trying to wrestle the knife away. And finally, Jeevan getting him down on the ground. And then he picks up some kind of stick or something, whatever. And he just starts beating him. And you don't see anything. You don't see where the blows are landing. But he's going to make sure this guy isn't getting back up again. And the whole time you've got...
Kirsten in her room and we've seen little bits of this over the season where she was yelling their names and everything and she was listening to what was happening um but I think Kirsten says older Kirsten talks to her and there's this wonderful moment where young Kirsten is realizing she's like we shouldn't have done the play and I love how older Kirsten is just you got the two of them in profile and she's just so completely straightforward and comforting she's like this didn't happen because you did the play I mean and now she doesn't want to tell Kirsten you should have left you you know this is too late and everything now she wants to tell her younger self this didn't happen because of you it's just something that happened oh and so Frank's on the ground and he actually pulls the knife out. And Jeevan is still in damage control mode. He's like, oh my God, you're not supposed to take it out. And he's just bleeding. And Jeevan starts screaming for Sia at one point. And I'm sitting here going, oh my God, my heart. Yeah, it really, oh, it just got me choked up at that moment and everything. But Frank is very, very calm. And he looks at him. What is it he says? He said, I would like to lie down in my bed.
Yeah, yeah. And then that's it. That's it. He just lets out a breath, and then he's gone. That was his last words. I'm like, oh, God, my heart. Of course, Jeevan has to carry him into his bedroom and put him down and then cover him over. And Kirsten, this older Kirsten, our Kirsten, is now standing in the room watching this happen. And then Jeevan leaves, and he slams his bedroom door behind him. And then he and Kirsten have got to get going. And I had wondered, because...
Some of the recaps thought that Kirsten would not have known then that Frank was dead, that she would have just assumed that they were leaving and he wasn't going to say goodbye. But I don't get that because I don't think Kirsten would have left without hearing a goodbye from Frank. No, yeah, I thought they made it pretty cool because... Jeevan was in the bathroom at one point and he was cleaning blood off the clothes in water that at first I was just, why didn't you put ice cubes in the water? I'm like, oh shit, that's because this apartment is really cold. But he's trying desperately to wash the blood stains off and Kirsten comes in. He doesn't say anything and Jeevan looks at her and says something like, I liked your play. And she gives him a hug. She knows he's dead. She definitely knows he's dead. She actually asked him if the man that had come in was dead and Jeevan tells him you're safe now. So that's one way of answering the question. Yeah, and they're getting their stuff together and she walks through the living room and she tries to get older Kirsten to come out of the bedroom.
But older Kirsten tells her that, you know, she has to go. And meanwhile, like the black poison that's on her is like all the way up to her chest at this point. It's really not good. But younger Kirsten walks through the living room and you see her walk over the body of the guy who attacked them. And she makes kind of like a face and everything. But she sees his knife and you see her pick it up and look at it. And she wraps in cloth and takes it with her. And that's how older Kirsten got her thing about knives. Yep. I think that might be the knife that she still has by the time the current day stuff is happening.
You have this wonderful shot of Kirsten in Frank's room, but now the room is filled with sunlight and plants and everything. I mean, Frank's body is still there on the bed and he's still wrapped up, but everything looks so much more benign when you can just hear sounds of nature. And like, obviously the window's been blown open ages ago. And she just looks down at him standing there and she said, goodbye, Frank. And that's where the episode ends. Did you listen to the credits? Did you go all the way through the credits? I love this. The song they were playing, which is a Paganini song, which is really a lovely song. Not the list that I, in my heart of hearts, I was just like, but the list is not as poignant a song as the Paganini, so I totally get it. But yeah, as it's playing, then you hear Kirsten, and I want to say she says something like, thank you for letting me stay with you. Oh, wow. Okay. Now I have to remember to watch to the end of the credits. I didn't realize that they were doing that. I usually watch all the credits because I like whatever song they're playing, so you have to be quick. You have to hit the little hide button on the autoplay thing so it doesn't go to the next episode. But yeah, I was just listening to the song, and then I heard that, and I went, aw.
my heart i gotta tell you this whole time when they left there was part of me that was really really really hoping this whole time that they just left frank's place and frank wouldn't come with them and so they don't know what happened to him i knew that wasn't likely but up until the very end i was like maybe he survives he doesn't survive well i have been picking up stuff from various recaps they have apparently changed a lot from the original book and i'm fine with that because a i don't remember everything from the book and b the stuff i do remember it's nice to think that they might be surprising me on stuff, which they have, I think. Yeah, yeah. I think, I mean, Douglas Adams did that with Hedgehog's Guide to the Galaxy. Every version of that that was done from the radio play to the book to the movie, several movies, several TV shows, it was always different on purpose because he said nobody wants to listen to the same story.
Twice. So yeah, you've already read the book. You know how the book goes. You've got the TV show. I've got the TV show. Yeah, that's great. Yeah, it was a great episode. It was really, oh, beautifully filmed. Oh my goodness. Every shot was just, and the little touches, like when they did the play and they've got those big windows and they've put paper stars all over it. And then there's a wonderful scene. Oh, there's a wonderful scene where Frank is talking to Kirsten because he knows they're going to have to leave. And he had talked to Kirsten about how he got this place because he wanted to be able to see like the sun, I guess, and it was facing east. And he gave her a present at one point. It was a compass.
And he said he liked that image he had of her where she was facing east of the sun. He gives her this compass and he said something like it's broken. Everywhere you go, it only points east. Oh, my goodness. And thematically perfect. Oh, it's so good. Gracious. Anyway, really good.
Okay, so we're going to jump right now into the first episode of Star Trek Lower Decks Season 5, and this is called Dos Cerritos. And that's because one of the main storylines on this is that the Cerritos accidentally go through a warp in the fabric of the universe and end up in another dimension, and they find the other Cerritos. However, this is not the usual good-evil versions that Star Trek does so well. Everybody is kind of like the same in the other universe, just some little differences. And Mariner is now the captain of the ship. And she is referring to herself as Beckett Freeman. And did we know that Mariner was actually her middle name that she took on because she didn't want to like automatically get associated with being the captain's daughter? You know, I feel like...
I feel like we didn't know it before then. No. I'm not sure we did. But the other differences are interesting as well. Like Rutherford, our Rutherford has been working himself to death so he doesn't have to think about the fact that he misses Tendi. The Rutherford in the other universe, he starts referring to as Otherford, which is adorable, but he's almost Borg. He has just been replacing parts of himself and deleting memories of Tendi so he doesn't have to be sad. So he is very, very robotic through all of this. Chief of Engineering Billups, well, he's a king in the other universe. So we know what that means. He finally had sex. That's right.
And Boimler's alternate is like ultra confident and has been the acting captain bunch of the time. He's very suave and everything. And he'll wink every now and then. Boimler's like, oh, when I wink, people think I'm having a stroke. The people must think the same thing about me. Winking is hard. But the biggest difference is that...
Becky Freeman, Mariner, she has decided that to be a good captain, she has to be scary. And she will just throw people into the brig at the smallest provocation. She even has a riding crop that she brings out to smack people around if they're not obeying her orders fast enough. And Mariner stops her at one point and says, wait a minute, you can't hit people. And Beckett says, you can have friends or you can have crew members. And Mariner's like, yeah, and I don't hit either of them. Right, right. So logic is not sound here. So you can tell that everybody's intimidated as hell about her, but they're still trying to obey all the orders. And then you've got the usual fights between people because nobody wants to agree what's the good universe.
universe or the bad universe what's the real universe and the fake universe and everybody's getting mad at each other and if you got a little x-ray thing where you look to see the credits they're all doubled because it'll be the regular character and then the double character so all of that's fun but they do all manage to work together to reopen the rift to get our cerritos back but before they can go through beckett freeman kidnaps mariner because she wants to go back with the other people because she's realized how fun it was to be a hothead and not be captain anymore and mariner's here like why don't you just do that here but she's not hearing it so she does manage to get over and She doesn't convince anybody, I don't think, that she's the actual Mariner. And they do manage to get the two of them switched back at the last second so they can go through. But it's just, I mean, it was just a fun little standard template of an episode where you've got the alternate universe. These are the alternate universe. I mean, I called it when Beckett Freeman pulled a phaser on Mariner. I was like, oh, she wants to go back to the other universe.
Except I thought it was because her mother was dead in the other universe. But it turns out her mother is in Station 80, I think, Starbase 80, the horrible one that no one wants to go to. So, of course, our Captain Freeman is kind of appalled to hear that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. They haven't had the episode where you get to see that station, have they? We saw it briefly when Mariner was assigned there, but she didn't stick around for very long. And when they realized that they'd sent her there by mistake, they went to get her and they see a little bit more of that. But it's just, it's kind of squalid, I think. Yeah. I want to say...
I want to say there's an episode coming up where they address that. It's been a long time since I've watched these episodes, but yeah, I want to say that's a thing. Yeah, I figured if they brought that up, it's going to come up later on in the season. But the other storyline is Tendi, who's working with a crew of Orion pirates, trying to work off her debt to her sister so she can go back to Starfleet. And one thing that her sister found for her to do would be to recapture this old ship that had been lost somewhere on the planet that they just found the coordinates to. So they go there, but there are blue Orions, a bunch of guys that are trying to get the same thing, and they're obviously opposed. And meanwhile, Tendi is trying to get her crew to stop trying to kill people because she's like, we can...
Work this out without fighting! but they're not hearing it. Oh, but it turns out, I mean, they're all really good fighters, but what they really want is to be good enough so that they can do what Tendi did, which was to stop being a pirate and go do something that they really wanted to do, like be a dancer or be a baker or go ahead and teach a class at the community college. So it's all very, very cute. It is, yeah. And they do manage to beat the Blue Orions and they get the ship and I love the design of the ship. It was all steampunky and everything. Oh, so cool. But the problem is, is that Tendi used a non-pirate way of attacking the other, the Blue Orions, which is to like release laughing gas into the ventilation system. So now they've declared war on...
and Tendi's family. And Tendi's sister tells her, you've worked off your deal with me, so now you can go back to Starfleet. And Tendi's like, no, I got us into this mess. I'm going to get us out of it. And that's where we leave the episode. And I was like, good, because I was waiting for her sister to do something else underhanded to try to keep her around as the Mistress of the Winter Constellations. Yeah, they know what the tropes usually are, and they do a good job in subverting them a lot of the times. It's like, yeah, you might think this is what's going to happen, but no, it's actually going to be this. I was kind of hoping that Tendi at some point would have read her sister the riot act for the fact that Tendi was trying to rescue her friend and her sister puts her in debt and to...
actually work as a pirate instead of being in star flight where she wants to be and then they give her a crappy ship anyway just like that was also underhanded yeah you know now that i think about i don't think they address that i think that was just her sister being a pirate i guess something a pirate would do so you know obey the letter of the what is it obey the letter of the law not the spirit of the law type of thing something like that but i mean the only other really funny thing was that um the vulcan to lynn uh talks with her counterpart and they are just like identical except to lynn says fascinating when she sees something that's surprising and her counterpart says remarkable Um, that's the only difference between the two of them. And when they are, you know, Rutherford and Mariner and Boimler and Tallinn are all sitting at a table. And at one point Tallinn says, remarkable. And everybody's like, oh my God, are you the, and there's this long pause and Tallinn says, I have fooled you. I'm like, oh, of course she played a practical joke. And she doesn't, she doesn't laugh. She doesn't smile, but she obviously did that on purpose. I know. I love it when they play around with the Vulcan tropes.
But I guess with that, that will wrap us up for the week. So make sure to check out PixelatedGeek.com for all the book reviews, the movie reviews, the comic book reviews, the photo galleries. As of today, the day this episode drops, it is San Diego Comic-Con. And the day this episode drops, it will also be GalaxyCon in Raleigh. We are going to have so much nerd content. We love, you know, interviews are kind of fun. Panel write-ups are fun. But what we really like is taking pictures of cosplay. Yeah. That's always the most fun. So look out for all of that and more. PixelatedGeek.com. So I still...
Don't think we're going to have a Night Vale episode next week. No, I think the next time we record an episode, it's going to be like a couple more days before the new one drops, but that's fine because we'll be talking about GalaxyCon and San Diego Comic-Con. That's right. And probably Station Eleven and probably Star Trek Lower Decks because that's what we do and whatever else distracts us. So one way or the other, we will talk to everybody in one week. Talk to y'all later. What do you call the prison? The breaks, okay. Let me try that whole thing again.
She even has a writing crop that she brings around to smack people around. At one point, Mariner's like, wait a minute, you actually hit people with that thing? Or she, let me try again. Wait, she, let me try. But she stops her. And you know what? I'm going to start all over on that one. Okay.