Skip to content
Blasphemy in Pakistan episode artwork

Sep 20, 2012 8 min

Blasphemy in Pakistan

from Witness History: Archive 2012 Hosted by BBC World Service

In 1998 a Roman Catholic Bishop killed himself in protest at Pakistan's blasphemy laws. His name was Bishop John Joseph - and he believed that the laws were being used to persecute Christians. Hear from a Catholic priest who knew him well, but who still believes he should not have taken his own life. Photo: AFP/Getty Images.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Blasphemy in Pakistan

0:00 8:59
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, and thank you for downloading Witness from the BBC World Service. Recent charges of blasphemy against a young Pakistani girl have focused attention on the country's controversial religious law. Fourteen years ago, the Catholic Bishop of Faisalabad committed suicide in protest at the legislation. Mike Lanchin reports.

It's May 1998. In central Pakistan, tens of thousands of Christians have gathered for the funeral of Bishop John Joseph. The frames of Faisalabad Cathedral in Punjab, and a vast red warning protects the mourners from the withering heat. They sit cross-legged, their gaze directed towards a grassy bank.

On it lies the Bishop's coffin. The Church authorities feared such a crush that they have surrounded the coffin with rows of nuns in their black and white habits. Amid the sorrow, there was also anger, directed at Pakistan's authorities and the country's blasphemy laws, which many blames for driving the Bishop to take his own life. Young Christian men parade through the streets of Faisalabad.

Bishop, your blood will bring revolution, they chant. Passions are running high. For Pakistan's small Christian community, it had been a dramatic 24 hours. When I saw the dead body lying, I was crying.

Because first of all, I was very much close to him, then secondly, I could never think he will kill himself and he will die such a tragic death. Father Aftab James Paul was a local parish priest near Faisalabad when John Joseph was the Bishop there. He'd first met him when training to become a priest at a local seminary. Father Aftab remembers him as a lively but complex character.

He used to come to us in the evenings and used to play volleyball with us and used to bring sweets and other things. He was, age-wise he must be old, but physically he was very fit, he was very healthy, very tall fellow and he played volleyball better than us. We were young, but he was an expert in playing volleyball. Sometimes he was very much disappointed and sad.

Sometimes he was very hopeful, sometimes he used to say that the situation is such that it can't be changed. It was an increasingly difficult time for Christians and other minorities in Pakistan. The country's age-old blasphemy laws were being expanded and even unintentional slights against the Prophet Muhammad were now punishable by death. Bishop Joseph had become a leading voice in the campaign against the laws.

One after the other, the cases against Christians were being registered and he was going to every place possible he could go. And he was meeting people, meeting Christians, meeting Muslim leaders, meeting human rights organizations, and he was trying to fight back. So he was giving hope to the people that not only the Christians are victims, but Muslims who are in majority in Pakistan, they are also victimized. Not only did the bishop tour the country speaking out, but he went on hunger strike in protest.

He offered refuge to the Christians accused under the blasphemy laws and tried to use his influence with those in power. In Urdu, he was known as Awami Bishop. Awami Bishop means a bishop who goes to the people, he talks to the people, he sits with the people. Anyone could meet him, anyone could talk to him.

He was helping people with so many other police cases and official cases. So in that way, he was very friendly with the government officials and with other influential people. It was very easy to access him. In the months leading up to his death, the bishop appeared increasingly frustrated with what he saw as persecution of Christians.

One of the bishop's parishioners, a young man called Ayub Massif was charged with committing blasphemy in a public place. And in late April 1998, he was sentenced to death. The verdict seemed to hit the bishop hard. I was a parish priest in another parish of the diocese in a small town called Chichavatni.

So one week before his death, he came to Chichavatni. There was something special with the nuns. I could see that he was not so happy, otherwise he was always laughing and talking to people and meeting and hugging and this and that. But that day he was looking very sad.

So I spoke to the mother superior of the convent that I said something extraordinary today with the bishop. He is not acting as usual. Just a few days later, the bishop sent Father Aftab a copy of a pamphlet he put together for the anti-blasphemy law campaign. In it, the bishop had written, A day will come when we will protest in such a way that the whole world will be left wondering.

Now I was astonished. I was thinking that what kind of protest Bishop John is going to state. So I was talking to some other people, also to the sisters and some of my friends, that I can't understand. So it is only the day he shot himself that I came to know that what he meant.

On May 6th, his last evening, the bishop had sat down for a meal with the nuns in Siwal, the city where Ayub Massif was awaiting execution. He'd barely eaten, the nun said later, and again he wasn't his usual talk to himself. Later that evening, the bishop had asked another priest to accompany him to the local courthouse. So it was dark, almost the time beyond evening, and when they reached the court, he told both of them, to the driver and to Father Yaqub, that you stay in the car, I am coming back.

For a few moments, they heard the sound of the shooting. So they rapidly, at once they came out of the car and they saw that the bishop was lying on the ground. His pistol was also, revolver lying close to him, the glasses also, so he was lying down straight. The bishop had shot himself.

It was a dramatic way to protest. It had never been done before by Christian bishop in Pakistan. But Father Aftab thinks he was wrong to do it. It's a sign of weakness, a sign of disappointment, and a sign of, what to say, that you have lost hope, you don't believe in yourself, you don't have confidence in yourself, you don't have confidence in the people, you don't have confidence in God.

He was a symbol of hope, symbol of love for the people, committing suicide by killing himself. He expressed a deep disappointment which he had. And in this way, I don't think that it was a act of good nature to kill oneself just to protest, but he should have carried on his struggle and some people call him martyr, but I don't know. And his death was perhaps in vain then because it didn't change anything.

Yeah, but let's say that things can't change overnight and especially such things. Fourteen years after Bishop John Joseph killed himself, amending Pakistan's blasphemy laws has been on the agenda of nearly all the secular parties, but no progress has been made. And given the growing religious conservatism in the country, governments remain wary about losing public support over the issue. Witness was written and presented by Mike Lanchon.

For details of our complete range of downloads and our terms of use, go to bbcworldservice.com slash podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Witness History: Archive 2012?

This episode is 8 minutes long.

When was this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode published?

This episode was published on September 20, 2012.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.