Hello, and welcome to episode 26 of Structured Visions. Structured Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and I'm very grateful for you listening today. You are very welcome here.
Now in today's episode, we're going to talk about my favorite subjects, which you can probably imagine what my favorite subjects are. You all know that grammar is one of them, but we're probably not going to talk so much about grammar today, as we are going to talk about bodies, cells, the relationship between the body and the self. The relationship may be able to have a chance to talk about the relationship between the body and the soul. You might not have a chance to talk about that.
And also the idea of the self, how that's linked up to the notion of the individual, and the relationship between the individual and society, or the individual and social structure. So what we have here are some of, in some ways quite abstract, concepts that are in relation to each other. And sometimes that relationship is, we think of it in terms of part whole relationships. Sometimes we think of them as oppositional concepts.
So we'll be exploring all of those ideas and wondering about what how those concepts serve, what notions, what sort of understandings those concepts actually serve, what purpose do they serve. And it's clear that we rely on a distinction between those concepts. So if the language structure is divided up into different sets of concepts and terms and things like that, it's because in theory those distinctions are necessary to us in some way or they serve some sort of purpose. Now I'm just going to start with that distinction between body and self, potentially maybe even body and mind, by telling you a story about when I was about nine or ten, I was in the fourth grade, and I was in a science class.
And we were learning about the neurological system, the nervous system. And so we had sort of an image of the brain in the whole body is kind of on the screen, I guess, and maybe on our worksheets. And there's an image of the brain and then all of those nerves moving to all the different parts of the brain. So you're kind of looking at the body as it gets some kind of circuitry.
And I remember the way, this was so astonishing to me. I remember the way in which the teacher explained how the nervous system works. And she said it like this, something like this. She said, you want to move your arm.
And so your brain sends a message through the nerves that connect up to the nerve, that connects up to the muscle in your arm. And it tells the muscle in your arm to contract. And I thought that was amazing. I just, that absolutely floored me.
That was like a mystical moment for me. It was very easily entertained as a child. So when I decide I want to move my arm, a message goes from my brain to my arm and my arm moves. Now that idea, it puzzled me, it I found it so curious, I spent the rest of the day moving various parts of my body and thinking, now I want my thumb to move.
I'm sending a message to my thumb and I'm moving, of course, it's instantaneous. But that idea that there's a distinction between a self and I, who has a desire, who wants to move something and then who can move it by sending a message from the brain. So what we have there is this idea that there's this distinction between the self, the thing that wants to do something and the body, which is the thing that's manipulated by the self and that those things are connected up by a sort of, you know, bodily function, which is the nervous system. And the idea that my wanting to do something became embodied through this neurological system, and I'm sure I wasn't thinking about it in these terms, but it was fascinating to me.
And I think the thing that made it fascinating was that it required me to articulate in some kind of vague way in my mind a distinction between a self who wants something and a body that can be manipulated by that self. And that it seemed almost like there were two worlds coming into contact. And that often does give, you know, if you think there are two worlds that don't have any connection and then suddenly they meet, that can feel actually quite mystical. So I think that was what I was experiencing at that point.
And so there was a, there was, I don't know if you call it a purpose, but because there was a distinction, in my mind there was this distinction, it made clear to me that there's a distinction between an eye and a body and the eye can affect the body in various ways, then those two things come together and it was like, whoa, that's amazing. So I'm not sure everyone will sort of share that amazement of my nine year old self who's moving my body in various ways. But there we go, that distinction between the mind and the body, maybe it's artificial, maybe it's just a conceptual system, et cetera. But it did produce a kind of aha moment for me.
And so I went almost in a way bring to light the other distinctions that we have. So we've got this distinction between the body and the mind. And then we've got this distinction between the self and society or the self and social structure. And I just want to kind of point out that those distinctions do hold in certain circumstances.
So let's skip ahead. Let's move again, two years, move ahead two years. So I wasn't the fourth grade and now I'm in the sixth grade. And now I'm in a social science class, social studies, I can't remember what it was called.
And the question was we were learning about the different levels of government, about the local government, state government, federal government, et cetera. And the question that was put to us by our teacher was, how are you affected by your government? How much of a role does your government have in your everyday life? And all of us kids in the sixth grade classroom were also saying, well, it doesn't really matter to us that much.
We just go about our lives. The government doesn't impact us that much. And the teacher said, really? And we said, yes.
And then the teacher said, OK, describe your day. So write down all of the things that you've done today, starting with waking up in the morning. So OK, woke up in the morning, had breakfast. What did you ever breakfast?
Well, it's cereal, we poured milk on it. And then we got dressed, caught the bus, got to school, just in time, et cetera. So we're writing all these things down. And then the teacher's pointing out that all of those things are in some way or other controlled or affected by the government.
So the fact that we had cereal with milk on it, OK, well, we would have, our parents would have bought that food. And they would have paid sales tax on that food. And the food, the food would have been farmed. And the farms themselves would have been regulated by the Food and Drug Administration and various bodies that control what's acceptable, what can go into food and what can't go into food.
So even the fact that this stuff is allowed to be sold as food and we're allowed to consume it as food, that's controlled by the government. The fact that we got enough school bus, OK, the school bus is funded by people's taxes and it's organized by the local government, you know, associated with the school board. And then the fact that we had to go to school at all was, you know, illegal, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And so the idea was to get into the heads of a bunch of 12 year olds that, or 11 year olds, that are what we consider to be our Alzheimer's cells are actually in relationship with all sorts of governmental controls, if you like.
And so that was a little bit of starchy. Now I have to note that no minute wasn't particularly a mystical moment, but it did sort of give me some free for thought. And I think you could have moved that beyond just thinking in terms of government policy and government institutions and legal systems. And you can think also in terms of concepts themselves or languages.
And you know, your very use of language requires you to be part of a community whereby you share the language or even the notion of particular concepts or ways of seeing the world. All of that is something that you're sharing with a collective, a culture. It isn't something that you hold individually. And this can be illustrated by something I used to ask my students sometimes when we were talking about various things.
One of the things I would ask them is when did you first know? What was the moment when you knew that the earth traveled around the sun, rather than the sun traveled around the earth? And I've never had a student. I've asked that lots of times over the years.
And I've never had a student actually say, I knew it at this point. This is the point at which I learned that. Most of the time what students say to me is I always knew it. I never thought about it in a different way.
And I said, well, that's confusing because your experience of the world is that when you're standing on the ground outside and you watch the sun moving over the horizon, when you watch it while moving over the sky, you see it as moving around you, moving around your earth. So you would have had to be taught that your perception was different from the quote unquote reality. So but none of the students could ever remember having been entertained to the thought that the sun does something else. They didn't notice it.
They didn't or if they didn't notice it, they didn't remember having noticed it or wondering about it or that type of thing. And so they said, you know, we always knew. And so we're comparing this back to time when people didn't know that that's the way it was. And we talked about this notion of, okay, is that the reality?
Is that the truth? Well, what I would say is, well, okay, it's a truth. Is it a scientific truth? Okay, it has been discovered through a range of scientific methods, not always, something, you know, when it was first thought through, presumably it was just some kind of speculation.
But in any case, we could see it as a scientific truth. But we could also see it as a cosmology, a cultural cosmology. So the culture's way of seeing the world is one in which we have a model of the sun at the center, something we call a solar system. And then we have planets moving around that.
Now, you could say, okay, but that's the truth. But what we're actually saying is, well, how are we defining the truth? Well, the truth is something for which we have empirical evidence. Well, I have to put my hand on my heart and say, I've never had any empirical evidence.
I've never seen the figures. I've never been able to understand the figures. I've never been able to sort of understand all of the movements and how they operate in a way that could be called empirical evidence. My understanding of the earth moving around the sun is based on a model that I have that was given to me when I was in school and through various other cultural media is an image that I have that I take is true.
It's my culture's cosmology. I myself do not feel that I would be able to prove it, if you see what I mean. I would not myself be able to present the empirical scientific evidence to convince someone else who didn't believe it that the earth made around the sun. So for me, and I think for most people, that image is a cosmology.
It's a view of the cosmos or one little part of the view of the cosmos. And so the ideas we hold are notions of the way the planet works, the notions of the way things work, our concepts, our language, the things that we deem acceptable behavior, our morals. All of that comes from something bigger than us. All of that comes from our culture and our society.
And yet, as the sixth greater self kind of made clear, there's a clear sense that we want for whatever reason to think of ourselves as autonomous, to imagine that the self is separate from society, or at least that it's separate enough to be able to reflect on, make changes to act independently of the society. It's like we need to imagine that we are not totally determined by the social structure. Now, again, why would we need to think that? I've already mentioned one idea, which is, if I, as a think of myself as an individual self, then that makes it possible again for me to reflect on social structure.
So in all these podcasts, if I'm completely determined by the social structure, well, then how can I separate myself from it and say, well, I don't like social structure, I think social structure should be different, I want new visions of social structure, etc. So clearly, I'm relying on a notion of the self that is at least a little bit autonomous, a little bit separate from the social structure. However, so that allows me to say there's something about the ways of social structure that I don't like, and I would like to change it. And in example of that, I was teaching a language and gender seminar, and the students and I were discussing various ways in which there's still sexism in society, and there's this prejudice in homophobia, and I was like, why is it sanctioned?
Why is it okay? Why are they still these implicit homophobic messages in the television we watch? Why are there all of these ways in which women minorities are still portrayed in the media that put forward these damaging ideas? How can certain pressures are simply accepted and not questioned?
Why, why, why, why? asking all these questions, and I want student who has answered to it the whole time, was it's society. She said, and when she kept saying society, I mean, I don't know where society written in all capital, it's society. And she didn't say this, but it's almost like the underlying message I'm saying is it's society, and it sucks.
I thought, wow, we're not going to be able to have a productive conversation. It's one thing to be critical of the society that we're in, but if we're constantly saying, oh society is bad and it sucks, then we're at a dead end. It's like, well, what can I do about it? What can I do about it?
We want to do something about it. However, then we're in a strict position, which is, well, if I conceive of myself as an individual who can do something about society, well, what if it's society itself that makes me feel like I'm an individual? So that's the Foucauldian position. So that's the position of Michal Foucault, which is that it's a particular type of social structure that constructs the individual in such a way that their individuality is seen as paramount, that they need to be monitoring their self as a separate individual.
And so maybe I need to be a little bit cautious about wanting to see myself as an individual, because maybe that is socially determined. So maybe all my ideas about being an individual are actually socially determined. So it turns out, oh, I'm not separate from this idea after all, I'm determined to know what part of the matrix I've got caught in some kind of causal loop, but I don't know what to do. Right?
So the other thing that we might want to do is say no, actually, from the perspective of social change, it's important that individuals see themselves and that we see individuals as being able to act in the world. So this is a perspective that is seen from, this is a kind of practice theory perspective. And I was talking to you in many podcasts that talk about the French theorist, Michel Bourdieu. And he has one perspective on practice theory.
The idea is that yes, there are individuals and they are acting in society. They have agency, which means they have the power to act in society. However, they have to rely on societal resources in order to act. So if you remember last week, I was talking about Bourdieu in the various different types of capital that you need, economic capital, you need cultural capital, you need symbolic capital, you need social capital.
And if you can sort of bring all those things into play, then you're acting in the world. But the capital itself gets its value, if you like, from the cultural marketplace. So I don't, as an individual, get to decide what value my particular way of behaving has or a particular qualification I have or the particular people I know or my language use, etc. I don't get to control the value of that.
That's controlled in various markets or various marketplaces. So I have to rely on societal resources in order to act in the world. So let's just compare and contrast those two positions for a moment. We've got Foucault, who is effectively saying that contemporary society has constructed the self as a mechanism of power.
So power surrounds the self and the self monitors. And that's the way that we can have a power system. And the implication is that power system is actually not a good, it's actually a form of subjection, subjectification. And with Bourdieu.
So for Foucault, there's a deterministic sense. Society constructs the notion of the individual autonomous self as a mechanism of power. So you're fundamentally being duped by society in Foucault's world. And then we've got Bourdieu, who says individuals are actors, so they have some autonomy from the system, if you like, from society.
But they in order to act in society, they're reliant upon different forms of capital, different resources. That and those resources are structurally determined. Those are determined by society. Okay, so we've got a Foucaultian notion quite deterministic.
We've got a Bourdieu notion less deterministic about the relationship between the self and society. Okay, let's add the body, right? So where's Foucault on the body? Well, Foucault's idea is that the society inscribes on the body, the marks of society, and it does that through discipline.
So in order to be accepted as a legitimate member of society, you have to put your body through particular disciplinary procedures in order to be accepted. And if you don't do those things, then society categorizes you as a parent. You are delinquent when you don't just subject your body to disciplinary forces. And bodies bear the marks of the societal inscription, if you like.
And Bourdieu's perspective on the body is that the way we move our bodies, the way we operate the world, the way we walk, the way we sit, all of those things are all value-laden. The things that we like and enjoy, the things that we taste and enjoy the taste of, those are all value-laden. And it is the social market, the cultural market, if you like, the marketplace that gives those bodily movements, bodily actions their value. Okay, so if you know particular ways of walking, particularly ways of sitting, all of these ways, particular ways of moving your tongue and your mouth in order to produce a particular accent when you speak, all of those things are what he calls hexas, H-E-X-I-S.
And these are value-laden gestures that effectively are again inscribed on the body. Now you can, I guess, train your body to do something else or to, you know, to fit in with a different type of field. So in one case, perhaps it's most acceptable for you to cross your legs and in other case maybe you hold them open while you're sitting down. But in any case, anything that you do with your body is symbolically laden.
It has, it has capital. Okay, so we've got sort of two different images of the self and we have two different images of the body. What are we noticing here? That both models rely upon a notion of the self in contradiction if you like, to society, right?
So again, in the same way that when I was in the fourth grade, I had this distinction between the mind and the body. These two social theories, these two descriptions of the social world rely upon a distinction between the self and society. And I would just ask you to think for a second, you've got Foucault's deterministic notion in your head, you've got Borgia's slightly less deterministic, the radical notion in your head. And I would just ask, how are they shaped?
How is the individual shaped in relation to society? Okay, so you might even draw a picture. Draw a picture of the individual in relation to society. What does the society look like and what does the individual look like?
I think if I were going to draw the picture, I would draw a sort of small self and a big society. And then the next question I might ask would be, where does the power flow? Who's got the most power? And again, I would imagine in both of these images that society has all the power and the individual kind of gets the it's like a trickle down, the individual gets the best it can.
The individual maybe has a little bit of power, society has a big amount of power. So in both situations, if I've interpreted them correctly and if my images are accurate, we have big society, small person, powerful society, less powerful person. So we've got particular images of society and particular images of the self. And also one more thing, who are we championing?
Right? If it was a movie and this is how the individual were two different characters, who would you be behind? And I think again, if this were a movie and I were watching it, I would be championing the individual, not the society, right? So again, a particular image is two concepts, all those to David and Goliath, right?
The self is the David and the society is the Goliath and the David character is battling against this big, huge monster that we might call society. It sucks. Now, I too am interested. I am very critical, as you know, of social structures and I'm critical of particular configurations of society.
But my challenge to myself has been not to go to battle against society, but instead to get intensely curious about it. And in that curiosity, I've come up with my own way of thinking about it, which is to say that we all have available to us new ways of thinking about social structure. And these new ways do not require us necessarily to assume that society is big and bad and evil. We can see the way it's shaped and we can say to ourselves, what would be a better shape or what would be a different shape, even just a different shape, if it's shaped like that, how else might it be shaped?
So we've got the shape of the big society and the tiny individual who's got this body that's getting impressed upon by society. Is there a different way of understanding it? And so I would propose this as one different way of understanding it. Let's imagine that society is trying to change itself, right?
Let's imagine that society doesn't want to get with a character in the movie. It doesn't want to stay the same. It doesn't want to be the big bad guy. It wants to transform, right?
We're just working in the world of mils here, right? Okay, so we're just putting forward a new myth. Society wants to transform. Now what about the body?
What does society want to do with the body? So society wants to transform. And what if society thought the only way that I can transform is if I have a body, if I am embodied, and then suddenly I will be able to dream up new possibilities. Okay, now I've put that forward as a myth.
It's a little bit ridiculous, but is it any less ridiculous that imagining society is this big bad, you know, goliath character? Let's imagine that as our myth for fun, right? And when I started imagining that as my myth, and I start looking closely at where I think society or social structure shows up, which is in conversational texts, I start to notice that when I think about society embodying itself, I do notice these possibilities for new ways of thinking about society. I'm going to leave it there for now.
I'm going to leave you with that. This image of society wanting to change, this image of society wanting to be embodied, rather than impressing itself on individual bodies, poor guys. Society wants to change. It wants to be embodied.
And we can explore that by looking at conversational texts. Thank you so much for educating me on the idea with me today. I will talk more about it in upcoming weeks. I hope to talk with you next week.
Thank you.