Skip to content
Bolt, Sky News, Buzzfeed and ABC Life episode artwork

Aug 9, 2018 32 min

Bolt, Sky News, Buzzfeed and ABC Life

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we look at Andrew Bolt's attack on immigration, the fall out from Sky News and that interview of Blair Cottrell, Buzzfeed's story on Emma Husar and ABC Life goes live. To help us navigate our way through all this we are joined by Ben Doherty from the Guardian, Kathleen Calderwood from the ABC and Cara Waters from the Age and SMH. Your host this week is Anthony Dockrill.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Bolt, Sky News, Buzzfeed and ABC Life

0:00 32:11
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. You'll listen before the state of the show where journalists talk journalism coming to you from To RSCI in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Euro Nation right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your advice across the globe by a podcast. My name is Anthony Dockwell. Coming up the immigration debate hops up in Australia and across the media.

First up, Andrew Bolt's contribution to the debate has caused the storm and not just because he singled out ethnic and racial groups but also for his figures which might not add up. On the weekend Sky News became a full-on dumpster fire when they interviewed Blair Cottrell a man who's on record thinking a picture of Al Fiddler should be in every classroom. Buzzfeed would not just the first to break the story of Emma Hissar and the allegations of bullying but also got her to announce she would not contest her seat at the next federal election. Should Buzzfeed have published and where does public interest begin and end on the story?

And to all the news junkies out there who may have heard the buzz in your feeds about ABC Live, well it launched on Monday and despite the warnings the sky hasn't fallen in yet. Joining me in the studio and across the country we have Vendardy who's immigration correspondent for The Guardian. Hello, good evening. Kathleen Coldabood who is the ABC's western suburbs producer and she's also been awarded the Andrew Ollie Scholarship in 2017.

Hello, hi. And joining us online for Melbourne, Kara Waters who is a small business reporter for The Age and the City Morning Herald. Hello. Hi, Barbara.

Now Andrew Bolt is no stranger to controversy but last week the daily telegraph of the Herald, the Scrivia Mail and the Adelaide advertisers all carried an article attacking immigration and arguing in a near-historical turn that there is almost no us anymore. And if by us Andrew Bolt meant all the first generation Danish immigrants working for News Limited, then no us is fast disappearing. The article is highly inflammatory and almost every sentence could be used here to illustrate its heightened attack on immigration. But here's one to give you a flavour of Bolt's viewpoint.

In Melbourne, North Colfield, 41% of the residents are Jews including hundreds who've likely fled South Africa. While most of the News Limited papers of Kerry Bolt's piece presented it dryly, the daily telegraph really got into the spirit with a headline saying foreign invasion and a cartoon of a collection of different ethnic groups sitting down to eat a pie the shape of Australia. The white man in the middle looking less than impressed. Let's kick this off with a Dorothy Dix question to the panel.

Did Bolt go too far? Kara, I'll give it to you first. I think he definitely did but that's what Andrew Bolt does. I read the hell's done because it's my job to read it but I generally just ignore Andrew Bolt's column.

I read it for the occasion of the show and it's pretty horrible. And yeah, I think he shouldn't have written it in the first place and shouldn't have been published. Then what's your say? Look, I think one, it's pretty lousy journalism.

He got a lot wrong. There's lots that's factually incorrect. He got his numbers wrong. He essentially doubled the number of people of Chinese ancestry born in China in Boxhill.

And they sort of manipulated figures to try and prove an argument that didn't exist. So again, looking back, he got knocked over a few years ago for falling foul of the racial discrimination act. I just think he fails to check his facts and it's just poor journalism. But the other thing I think that's really dangerous about these sort of pieces and I agree with Kara entirely that I'm very surprised that it got passed and edited as eyes and published is this way that the migration debate and discussion about immigration is used as code for talking about race.

And the black letters, I'm talking about immigration but really I'm talking about race here. I'm talking about people who don't speak English, people who aren't from a due to an aggression background. And I think that's a really dangerous path down which we're heading. And I think when someone like Bolt who is, like him or like him, has a massive leadership in his country, he opens up a space for people behind him to use this sort of language, to use this sort of pejorative language, to humanizing all of the sort of trends where we're seeing immigration reputation in this country at the moment.

He's kind of enabled by columns like that to kind of push the boat right out and then people sort of falling behind with that sort of stuff. I think it's a really dangerous trend. And rightly there needs to be a measure of push back against it. My question is, and I think this is something that lots of people are wrestling with this, how strongly do you push back against something that because that's essentially what he's looking for.

He's looking for controversy, looking for clicks, he's looking for debate and outrage and all of this, all of this sort of stuff. These things need to be called out and opposed, but it's almost falling into the trap. Oh, look, before we delve into that deeper, I'll just look at Kathleen's take on it as well. I would agree.

I think it was poor journalism. He regardless of whether the stats were right or wrong, he was bringing in all these different elements of it, race, language, small businesses, all that kind of thing. And I think the immigration debate is a difficult debate for us to have, but it's probably one that needs to be had. And I don't think this added anything to it, constructive really at all.

And I think a discussion, and a serious discussion about immigration policy and how it's set and how it's controlled, are absolutely legitimate subjects for journalistic interest and public discussion. But this kind of quasi-soo debate around immigration, which is really about race, I think is a dangerous trend. And what about the term, us and the way that he used us? I think we all know who us is, us is white, English speaking, Australians, we like a me pie, we like a footy, aussie, aussie, aussie, aussie.

It just kind of leaves me, this kind of strange talk about Australian values. I don't know what they are. I don't know that I share many of them with someone perhaps like Andrew Bolt or others. This idea that we have to be homogeneous in the way that we see the world.

And the democracies are built on debate and discussion and disagreement. People don't all have to think exactly the same. And I think this idea of making an us and them is the countless examples and history of dehumanizing and distancing people, as prelude to more nefarious activities. It's everywhere.

It's a really obvious trend. I mean, I always find the us quite a hilarious thing, a disturbing way, because I'm an immigrant. I moved to Australia and I have to keep it all. But from the UK, I looked completely Australian, sound completely Australian.

And I'm pretty sure that I'm not in the name that Andrew Bolt is focused on. But in reality, I am an immigrant. So I find it quite interesting in the way that I've been demonized or immigrants. And I suspect Andrew Bolt thinks I'm an us, but I was born in Singapore.

So I'm not sure. And that's the whole fallacy to his argument. I mean, basically, unless you can trace your ancestry back to Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander people, we are all immigrants, including Andrew Bolt, most famously. So where is the argument here, other than a racial argument?

And an argument that is, when he uses the word colonization, he uses it in the most tone-def way. That's even imaginable, to use that word. 100%. I couldn't imagine how offensive it must be to Indigenous Australians to hear him complaining about Australia being colonized.

But that aside, I just think he has a very different set of Australian values and in common with a lot of people in Australia, you only have to walk around Western Sydney to see that not everyone looks like Andrew Bolt. And that's not just on so-called monoculture places, which I would argue with anyway, like LeCembe or those kinds of places that he pointed out. But you walk through the mainstream of Parramatta and it is a diverse place of many different kinds of faces and people. So I think he just is picking on one set of values for a very carved out audience that he thinks he speaks to.

And I don't know what the reaction might have been from the people he was trying to talk to. Look at the same time Bolt was lamenting the loss of us. ABC John Wissasman for Rookie found himself in the end of a lot of online abuse simply for entering the plastic bag debate. I mean, how old should we be about the toxic nature?

What's going on in our public discourse at the moment? Because it's toxic. It's stopping people from having a well considered, thought out, intelligent debate. Like we're all entitled to our own opinions.

But if you're going to get shut down over something like plastic bags, Cosmon was faithful for his safety as far as I was reading, getting death threats and things like that. I think that's a bit extreme, really. I think it's interesting as well that you see this flow on effect from this really toxic, as you say, language and publication. And then it's going over onto social media.

And I think when we move on to talking about Sky News, it's quite interesting that some of the fallout from that has been, again, some females in response by Sky News broke out and people had to look inappropriate. And we're subjected to her ring, there's the piece on Twitter. Yes, yes. And as Ben mentioned earlier, Rocketman writing in the Guardian's pointed out some of Bolt's figures, the underpinnies arguments were rubbery at best.

And in light of the general outrage, I mean, should news limited as a company, pool bolt article? Ben? Look, I don't know what good it would do. You know, it's kind of just feeding to it.

Yeah, and he loves and lots of companies love to climb censorship from the pages of National Dailys and broadsheets that have circulation to hundreds of thousands of not exactly sure how they're being silenced. Look, it's the old Churchill, I don't know if it's a Churchill, quite a bit of everything. Eventually gets attributed to Churchill. You know, the lies halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its boots on sort of thing.

I mean, it's out there now, people are talking about it. I think it's important that it's discussed. But I mean, pulling it now, I don't see achieves much. I think there's a large element of performance to what Andrew Holt does, too.

It's not journalism. I think a lot of these sort of common pieces, look, you know, we live in the kind of age of the commentary at the age of outrage. I suspect a lot of these views that are kind of being pushed around aren't terribly deeply held. They're pretty shallow and people put them out there for clicks and for attention.

And for the controversy, the outrage that follows, you know, the Twitter firestorms and whatever else, that's exactly what's being sought to be generated. But just going back to that performance aspect of Andrew Bob, which is definitely there. But, you know, unlike, say, Mark Leifen, the performance aspect is that he is a serious journalist. He presents himself as that.

Clearly, this is not the work of journalism that we would normally recognize. You know, if you're looking at it in the way it was presented in some of the New Zealand papers, outside the Delhi photograph, it actually looked a bit like journalism. Does that trouble you? I think it was, you know, he was speeding out a lot of facts and figures, which were, you know, found to be incorrect sort of in the in the follow up.

But if you were reading that as the reader of the daily telegraph, I can see why or the Korean male or whoever else I can see why it might have come across as a legitimate article. I did read it as a bit like he's spitting out a lot of facts and figures, but not really making much of a point with those facts and figures. So, yeah, I guess that is a dangerous element of what he does. I mean, you know, it was it was any opinion pages.

It wasn't presented as news, but and comment pieces existed for a long time. But they need to be grounded in some sort of facts. You can't sort of base your argument on this on this faulty foundation essentially. And I think that's perhaps pointing to a broader issue, you know, with the sort of the fusion of media.

And, you know, and we've I'm sure it's like on this program before about media bubbles and all those sort of things that we almost don't have a kind of agreed set of basis facts from which to debate issues of of of significance. And, you know, in this case of national importance, because everyone's sort of cherry picking their own facts that they choose to believe that reinforces their own. Well, we don't have a kind of shared foundation understanding of what we're talking about, which I think leads to pieces like this. Before we move on, Karos, I think you're like that.

Well, I just think it's interesting that there has been complaints to the press council about this. And Andrew Bolton said that he is not going to respect the press council process. So, it's sort of like there's been complaints that, you know, they think it appears to be from Robert Mann's article in the Guardian, like we inaccuracies and false, you know, just statistics and it doesn't seem that there's anything that will happen. That is.

Well, for me, let's make a big jump and move on to Sky News. On Sunday, Adam Guile was interviewed by a betrayal. And after the interview, I went to social media posts promoting the interview and suddenly all hell broke loose. A 20 second Google search would tell you all you need to know about the betrayal.

He's a far right figure, not credible in any sense the word unless you happen to have a picture of Adolph Hitler on your wall. In the aftermath of the interview, Sky News pulled the interview, deleted social media posts and issued a groveling apology. Adam Guile's program has been suspended, American Express, Spexavers and Huggies have pulled their ads. And everyone at Sky News seems to be very, very sorry.

And if that wasn't enough, Blair Cottrell posted on Twitter and since deleted a tweet joking, he might as well have raped Sky's Laura J's on air. Now, seeing Blair Cottrell's credentials were there for everyone to see, how the hell did he end up on air and does Sky News need to do more to convince us that they've learned from this event? Kathleen, what do you think? Well, I've suspended Adam Jealous's show, which I think says something I find it hard to believe that they weren't conscious of what kind of controversy this might have caused.

Obviously, there's been some pretty big consequences for Sky with the pulling of the advertising deals and stuff like that. But I think they were probably putting them on to be provocative and it was successful. This is no accident. This is page one of the Fox News Playbook.

And this has been done before by Sky. They push, they push, they push, they go until they get the record amount of outrage. They walk it back a little bit, they do it again. I mean, it was recently around some of the straps that were put on the outsiders' program on the weekend.

This sort of controversy is deliberately confected and then sort of merely mouth-apologised for and then done again. There is no accident about this. Everyone knows who Black Outrell is. And this was quite a deliberate provocation.

And the fact that we're even discussing about a self-investing Nazi being given a platform on our one life. It's just how have we got here? That's the question. It's just scandalous.

So, okay, so what you're saying is Sky News is sort of an official thing that they're a bit like a charisma flu, a little bit too close to the sun. That's not the casey at all. I'm not privy to Sky's editorial decisions. So I just can't see how this is an accident.

Yeah, like you said, 20 seconds and you can see here where you're like, how could you not? No. He has appeared elsewhere though. So you can say, I mean, in no way can don't even experience on Sky News.

But I think other outlets have justified it in the way he was presented. And I do think that there appears to be a real lack of editorial oversight in allowing him to go on and allow him to be presented in the way that he was as an activist where he's actually a convicted racist. Well, look, I guess, and has resigned after five years as a commentator for Sky News. Apart from his disgust, he said the reason for quitting was that he's far before it against the Nazis and was a prison of war.

And to his way of thinking the normalization of the far right was for him a problem, but he couldn't ignore it just smooth over. Is he right here? And the media are normalizing and embracing elements of the far right? I think in some cases they're amplifying them.

I mean, this is a bloke who hopes of meeting them, you know, four men and a dog turn up sort of thing. And they're giving him a national platform. I mean, we're sitting here talking about it now. This has been a news story for three or four days.

They are being dragged into the kind of mainstream of the political debate from the extreme fringes where they are. And I've seen other arguments around that we should listen to people and to ideas we don't agree with. This has been on that. Yeah, but this is a whole new level.

I'm all free and fair and open to bait and a free press, but sort of bringing these kind of extreme ideas, these absolute beyond the pale ideas and presenting them as a legitimate political opinion is just outrageous. Well, look, in this situation too, I mean, Sky News is about to go out regionally on Twitter at television. You know, at night it clearly is a big Fox News model. It's a very different place at that time.

I think Sky News. Yeah, so I mean, we can do anything about this. How wide should we be about the direction Sky News is going, also knowing the weight that it holds and the fine journalists have with it. Well, and that's how I feel.

Sorry for that. There are some really very strong, very straight down the line, Geno Supercool. I think the gallery team, Spears and Gilbert and Jay, you know, those guys do a really good job. And they kind of are constantly being undermined and undercut by this kind of wildness at night.

There's a very interesting thing is I think what will, as you mentioned, what will hurt here is the advertising. And that's what will have the power. It's not all everyone getting on their soapbox and saying, or how outrageous it is, if sleeping giant movement, which is pressuring advertisers to pull advertising from these kind of programs, is successful. That's what will change the entire money talking.

Well, now it's my turn to be cynical. I mean, we've seen the sort of thing happen before 2GB. The sponsors pull out, but when it all quietens down, they go back. I mean, is this going to be a situation here with Sky News that, you know, people are saying, okay, we don't want to be obviously associated with Nazis.

But when it all quietens down, they'll go back and they'll be sponsoring Sky News at night. Yes, that is definitely the same. I think Zandran is a bit of a pro-thing, but that's exactly right. Okay, now look, BuzzFeed first broke the story on Emma Hersa being investigated for Bulling back in July.

And last week, they published a huge scoop. And let's just save it. I was working on Labor MP, Emma Hersa. It hit Australia for six.

The article was based around a leaked letter from lawyer John Joseph Willan, listing a series of allegations that range from WordPress, bullying, spreading false rumours, and acting out a famous scene from Basic Instinct. The article was explosive to say the least, and here's where it gets messy, because Hersa has rejected the claims and the most sensational being, the scene from Basic Instinct. And the person in the letter who's mentioned to have witnessed this move, Jason Kler, has also rejected the story. As of today, Emma has said that she will not contest the seat at an expert election and still rejects all allegations.

She said that while she's not perfect, enough is enough. So while the story has come to some form of conclusion, I still want to talk about this. And as I think there's something to debate and unpack inside of what's just taken place. BuzzFeed have been criticised since the story was published.

The question I have is should I have published, and was it in the public interest then? Shami and editor who would have knocked back that story for a reporter. It was a story every day of the week. Has Emma has been treated unjustly?

Has she been denied natural justice? Has she been essentially hung out to drive? Absolutely. Absolutely.

She's been treated unbelievably unfairly, and this has been a brutal smear campaign against it. She hasn't been hung out to drive by BuzzFeed. They've got a very strong story. There's an investigation into a sitting MP.

It involves the use of public funds as well, you know, Comcast or all this, which we've looked at on both sides of Parliament. This is a story, obviously the Sharon Stone thing sort of captured, you know, a lot of the salacious attention. But there is a story here. It was good journalism that got it should have been reported.

I think any editor in the country would have run it. Has she been treated unfairly? Absolutely. And this, I mean, I think this says more about the state of the political parties than it does about Australian journalism.

Yeah, so I mean, BuzzFeed, obviously, working here for leaked information. So they had the story called it, was right. No one's saying they got it wrong. I agree.

Alice Werkman is a very, very good journalist. I find it hard to believe that it wouldn't be watertight, especially to publish something like this. You would really want to have all your ducks in a row. I do think, you know, that we haven't been able to, you know, we haven't seen the results of this report.

And obviously today, Emma has told us that she is not going to recantest the seat. So that will be quite tragic if she is exonerated in a few days. But I don't think the story is sound. Yeah, but it illustrates more the sort of descent to the Australian politics.

I mean, if you're a young woman with political ambitions, why would, you know, young man, anybody, why would you go into this? These are people on your own side who are like, it's just the brutality of all, actually really has been treated accordingly. Yeah, I think the interesting thing is what you raise as a female politician, because I think the sexual nature of these allegations, as the female, cannot recover from that. Like, so devastating.

And that's a really difficult double standard, I think. Do you think Cara Barney Joyce was treated differently? I think, well, he was, he's, I mean, he's talking with me. So as opposed to her.

So, I mean, it does seem that these were an ongoing investigation that people haven't concluded yet. Some of the claims it appears may be untrue, but it definitely does seem to be, you know, an issue there. There's a 20 different complainants. So, you know, there does seem to be an issue, but yeah, it does seem that the standards for Barney Joyce and the people.

Well, bringing up on the question of public interest, I mean, it has what happened to him also that brought in a definition of public interest. Because I do remember when that story broke, there were a lot of journalists who were caught fluffing at the time, thinking that it wasn't in the public interest, and then retrospectively saying, you know what, it was, has his case, in a sense, opened the flood gates here, even taking out the obvious sexism between the two cases. Oh, well, if the public funds, you've noticed that, sorry for them, it makes a very clear cut, I suppose, that's public interest. I think I agree, but I don't think you can take the sexism out of the argument, to be honest.

Like, if this had happened and Barnaby Joyce had, I still think it would have rolled out much the same way. I also think Barney Joyce sort of campaigning as a, you know, as a family values campaign, a campaigning against same sex marriage, all the while conducting an illicit affair, while married to somebody else, I think completely undermined your credibility, and I think that alone would have been a grounds for a story. But absolutely, the public funds every time, there is always public interest in the way our money's being spent, or miss been. OK, all of the consensus is that the public interest here is really clear cut, but I just want to just end on political commentator Peter Van Olson.

He said on the inside is on Sunday, regardless of the truth, the allegations basically ended her career, which, you know, that's come to be true, but I mean, the point that he was making, the truth really wasn't actually an issue here in the end. And to me, that does underline the importance of making sure that this is truly a public interest story. I mean, what do you think of his point and how it's all played out? Look, I think it's been a grubby and horrible episode, but again, I think it had this process been handled properly.

It should never have come to this. These stories shouldn't have been there to be written, but I don't see how, if these allegations are being made, and we see elements of it that are absolutely in the public interest, how they can't be reported, you know. Otherwise, media is sort of practicing self-censorship about what they report and what they don't. And if there's a letter, I suppose, if there's a letter saying canvassing both the Sharon Stone, allegation as well as public funds, you can't sort of report something, not the other, can you?

And to be fair to Ellis Workman, I mean, one of the points she made on the insiders was that the AOP of essentially settled this about six months. Yeah, I think that's relevant to you. He also has been charged with interesting people. She feels that people left feel very wrong on that she published the allegations, and that she feels there's been more backlash against the four-day allegations than there have been public stories, which is interesting.

But I also think that's something about the kind of nature of social media blowback in that she was sort of darling at the left when she was pursuing the Kali Cash. And she had everyone cheering for, I mean, the sort of vicissitudes, you know, wash back and forth and often as a journalist, everyone's angry at you, probably doing your job pretty well. Yeah. And finally on the fourth estate, there's been much talk about ABC's lifestyle website, ABC Life.

It launched on Monday, and no, it wasn't the ABC doing Buzzfeed, but more a friendly lifestyle website using mainly content from various arms and channels of the ABC. The response to launch has been mainly positive, although it seems the Australian is not a fan. Jeremy Poxon has got my award for Tweeter of the Week when he tweeted, surely for balance, Auntie must also launch ABC Def. So after all the nashing of teeth and worries about the ABC taking on Buzzfeed and Chunky, the truth was a little more of a nice portal into the world of the ABC.

Ben, have you checked out ABC Life? When I knew I was coming on this to talk about it, I had a little bit of afternoon. To be honest, I was neither here nor there about it. I wasn't sort of brutally offended by it.

I didn't think it was absolutely amazing. I mean, it's sort of just starting off. I think there is a lot of those sort of sites out there. And you know, you can certainly raise the question whether that sort of core ABC business for the National Broadcasting, but I'm not deeply offended by it.

I thought it was fine without being remarkable. And Cara, you love a good recipe. Have you made it part of your daily routine? I do, some of the columnists I've got on there in the three-door, particularly good, I have to say.

But the, I guess the thing is, I mean, I agree, I don't think, you know, it's setting the world on fire, but it's, you know, the ABC's always done lifestyle content. You know, Garden Australia, Play School. It's not all serious hard-hitting news. So I don't know if it's quite as revolutionary as some people may think.

Yeah, yeah, I'm old enough to remember Peter Russell Clark. So now, you know, the claims of the website was gonna be an ABC Buzzfeeding itself. You know, they clearly turned out to be wrong. The one serious point I wanted to talk about here was, you know, did the ABC kind of mess this up by not correcting the record sooner?

Because clearly, they'll never go into Buzzfeed themselves. They let that stay out there for a long time before they corrected it. Maybe a little bit of the compliment. Maybe they're still working to work in the buzzfeed style.

Oh, again, I'm kind of, I'm finding it hard to get sort of terribly exercise about this. It's, I mean, there is from some quarters of media a kind of concerted effort to sort of tear down any, essentially anything the ABC does. As I said, I think it's fine. I think it's a perfectly reasonable thing for the ABC to do, but I don't kind of have terribly strong feelings about whether you caught the buzzfeed.

There's a ABC light or whatever. It doesn't bother me. Well, that's it from us on the Fourth Estate. Thanks to my guest, Ben Derrady from the Guardian.

Kathleen Coddlewood from the ABC and Carl Warders and Fairfax. Next week, Peter Frey, we'll be back in the hot seat. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app. You can also talk to us on Twitter and our handle is Fourth Estate AU.

My name is Anthony Dockwell and thanks for listening. Oh, and if you think it's been a rough week in the media in Australia, well, this is a small slice of info walls after I got bit off Facebook, YouTube, Spotify and iTunes. You'll never, never defeat the human spirit. You'll never defeat God.

You'll never win. Never, never, ever. And this is where we get tested. So rejoice the God Almighty for this animating contest of Liberty.

Ah!

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 32 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on August 9, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.