Skip to content
Bonus - Kelly Boyce Hurlbert Revisited episode artwork

Oct 27, 2025 24 min

Bonus - Kelly Boyce Hurlbert Revisited

from Already Gone Podcast

On July 5, 2013, Kelly Boyce Hurlbert was struck by a dark colored vehicle (possibly a truck or SUV) while riding her bike home from work in Traverse City, Michigan. Kelly was fatally injured in the incident and died at Munson Hospital. Her family is still seeking justice and answers in this case. This episode includes an interview with Kelly's sister, Nicole. If you have information, contact TIPS.FBI.GOV You can listen to the original episode about Kelly's case HERE #michigan #hitandrun #unsolved #coldcase

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Bonus - Kelly Boyce Hurlbert Revisited

0:00 24:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

In the early morning hours of July 5th, 2013, newlywed Kelly Boyce Hurlburt was making her way home from work on her bicycle. Suddenly, she was struck by a vehicle. The vehicle hit her and dragged her for a couple of blocks before she was dislodged. Kelly would suffer fatal injuries during this incident and passed away at Munson Hospital in Traverse City. Here we are 12 years later and Kelly's case remains open and unsolved. A mystery that plagues the region and causes great concern for her family, friends, and loved ones. I recently went to Traverse City, where I sat down with Kelly's mother and sister for a brief interview, which I'm going to share with you today.

As you know, I covered Kelly's case on the podcast back in 2019. I want to cover it again. And part of that is doing this push this weekend to get people talking about her case again. I have had at least three different people give me leads on the case and say, look, we went to the... And the woman, we dropped off some flyers, and she was like, wait, wait. And she wanted to tell us, look, I thought it was this person, and I went to law enforcement, and I really didn't feel like they took me seriously. They never followed up with me. We stopped by the police station. And maybe it's because I'm from the Detroit area, but I was floored that there was nobody there on a Saturday. So we had to wait around 20 minutes for someone to come and pick up some flyers for the detective.

It's disheartening. That's what I'm seeing in the, what, 36 hours that I've been here? I've actually been here 24 hours. So, you know, I can't imagine what you've been going through as a family over the last decade plus. It feels like coming into town that the community is very motivated in Kelly's case. Has that been your experience? Yes. Yes. Very motivated. And all around, it's just I don't feel like there's the support there should be from the proper channels.

Which has been my experience. I called law enforcement to let them know. I emailed to let them know I was coming. I called several weeks ago and expressed my frustration on behalf of the family that you're not getting the dialogue from them that you need and the information from them that you need. And I was told that I would get a call back from a higher up in the department who never followed up with me. Exactly. And even if we're not asking for a constant follow-up with us, we'd like to know that they're still actually working the case and taking the tips.

And following up on the tips. And because you do hear from a lot of people, we called in, but we never heard anything. And some people are not doing anonymously. Some people are saying, hey, we'd like to talk to you. And then we hear a lot of, there's no follow up on it. So I just really don't know what.

the Traverse City Police Department is doing in respect to it anymore, and we don't get straight answers to it. Have you been getting annual updates on the case? No. Do you have a liaison with the department? Not so much anymore, no. There's been a lot of retirement shifting around, so no. And we did, was it two years ago, around the anniversary with Keith Gillis when he took over, and some very promising leads. I mean, he personally called me. Okay, is he a detective? He was the captain, and he took over, and then he called me. We were there. He did a press conference. He did the whole thing. He said he had promising leads. He called me personally himself a week after and said that he thought he had

something and whatnot. And then all of a sudden he retired suddenly. And I don't know to me, I don't know why I don't know what the circumstances were. We were never told nobody ever fall back up on the lead. So he called me about himself, which for him to take the time to call me meant something at that time and felt pretty hopeful and then nothing.

Well, I reached out to the FBI and introduced myself as a victim's advocate. I am a credentialed victim's advocate. And I was calling on behalf of your family to find out, can we get a person to be a point of contact for tips and leads that come in? And what I was told was that we need to use the tips.fbi.gov, which I tried to use this morning, but there's not actually, there's not a tip line. But also when you go through, you have to choose, is it a cyber crime? Is it an election crime? Is it a drug trafficking? Is it a bank robbery? And I'm like, no, it's none of these. It's a murder. And there's nothing to slot it into the proper.

The right channel. So who's it going to? So it's just getting lost out there. And I feel like that too. A lot of people since even the beginning have said that they feel like some of their tips, and I get they got flooded with a lot of tips and they have to weed through them. I understand that. But we hear it constantly from people that it doesn't get followed up with. And then the FBI says they're involved and they're working it with them. But I really don't know how much. Are they working together really? I don't think so.

That was what frustrated me, is when I reached out to the FBI, I was looking for someone that we could have as a point person to hand all of this information over to, and they weren't able to offer that, and that was really disappointing. So, I mean, I felt I can't imagine how you were feeling. And my question would be, is the Traverse City Police, will they give you a person, the Traverse City Police Department? Well, I thought I had a person, and he never responded to my inquiries. You know, you've seen the flyers that I have that I'm handing out this weekend. I dropped some off for him, but there was nobody there to take them at the department. We had to wait around for, what, like half an hour for somebody, you know, an officer in a squad car to swing by and pick up a stack of flyers. Yeah.

I guess my thing is that I just I don't feel like they're working anymore. They say they are. And I'm sure there's the tips line, but I don't know. They're taking them. But I don't know. And we've asked this question way back in the beginning. We've never seen it all. We don't get to see it all. They say there's binders and binders and all this stuff, but they don't. And because it's an open case still, it's not a closed or gone to cold case. So they don't release anything. Which after 12 years, in my opinion, having worked on cold cases off and on for the last decade and worked with law enforcement, they should be able to give you something. They should be having annual meetings, at least with the family to say, this is where we are. This is what's going on. Even if it's to say, we don't have anything right now. We wish we had something to work with. Right. That's an update also.

Yeah. But you're not getting anything. No. And they've had a lot of, I mean, over the years, oh, we've got this person, we're following this, we're following this. And I get there wasn't a ton, but I think there's more than they let on that they had because, you know, they follow this lead and that lead, but then nothing comes of anything. And then to hear that there's so many tips, don't tell me there's not something in there. We wanted like an analyst to come in and go over the tips and organize them, give them some. And they said, no, they didn't want to. They declined the assistance. And that's kind of been how it's been the whole way is that they don't, they want to keep their hands on it.

And it doesn't want to go anywhere. But exactly. When does it come to a point when this gets moved on to? Is it a cold case? They have a new cold case squad or detectives. When does it go to them then? Get some fresh eyes on it. I mean, when do they call in the Michigan State Police and ask them to take it? And they'll say, oh, we've worked with them or this. But they don't want to give it up. And in the beginning, you know, there was a point where the FBI was involved. They put the reward. But same thing with them. I don't think that they're.

It was there, but they don't actually have anybody. It wasn't handed over to them to be there. So they got involved somewhat, but not as their case. So like you said, not having a point person, not having. And I guess I've always felt like they probably have a little bit more information or there could be more information if they ask the right people. Right. And I don't think that they have followed up. There is one place that I have said they need to go back to and circle back around to for years. And I do not believe it's happened. I brought it up the last time when we were up there. Have you followed up with them? The neighbor right at the corner. Yeah. There was people outside.

They were the people with the ghost bike was there, the memorial. They were the people that wanted it removed. They did not want it there. They had teenagers. The teenagers, I mean, it was known that it sounds like, oh, no, they went right. The story changed a little bit, but it's not like some of them were in the backyard. But then, I mean, these were teenagers and she wanted it removed. So her kids didn't have to see it when they came out. And it was like, it's not like little kids. If they didn't hear or see anything, why does it affect them so much that that is on the opposite side of the corner at the end of the road? Why does it have to be moved? Because she literally came out when we were up there afterwards and we were maintaining it. She attacked us.

And yelled at us that she did not want us there. We were cleaning it up and we're there. And she came out to us and started throwing a fit that she didn't want it there. Her kids shouldn't have to see it. And it wasn't.

like her kids were little kids or they hadn't supposedly witnessed or heard anything, then why was it affecting them? Have you circled back around this? And there was friends, teenage friends. So when they got questioned, they were under age. So they had parents with them that didn't want to be involved. Have you circled back around to any of them? And I've asked that question and I've never gotten an answer. And that's a fair question. And for those who aren't familiar, a ghost bike is basically a bike memorial to Kelly at the site of the incident. And why? And you know, and it was there and then people complained and Traverse City was, nope, okay, we'll remove it. If there's not something...

I guess at this point, I feel like there's somebody does know something and the right people are able to say, oh, yes, no, remove it because it's all they're all over the place for people. Why can't it be there? Yeah. And, you know, and so why can't it be there? And it was great. And it wasn't like it was a couple of years. I mean, they wanted it removed.

Permanently, quickly. I mean, it was only there. And so you see them all the time. But it's like, how come Traverse City didn't say, no, it can be there? And that's where it's just that bothers me. Understandably, that's a fair question. But I guess I feel like, why did the city let it get removed? And then there was one of her good friends that a few years later went through quite a hassle to try and get it back up at Cherry Festival time. But they could not put it in the spot. They had to. They actually put it in downtown. Like by the, I believe, under the walkway bridge, there was a spot. And I was like, why can it not go back where it should be? I mean, that doesn't even get a ton of traffic. It probably was more seen visually, yes. But that wasn't the point. And she had to go through the city and get them to approve. And it could only be there for one week.

the week of the charity festival. And it was like, and so it was like, it was more of a fight than a... No, that's super frustrating and disappointing. You know, going back to not having access to the files, this is a 12 and a half year old case. It's not like it's 18 months old. There should be the ability to share information, if not with the family, then with other law enforcement agencies to hopefully shake something loose. I understand that there is very limited evidence in terms of which vehicle was involved in the incident, but...

That's where you need to push harder and get people talking. Because somebody knows who had an accident, who had a crushed bumper, who had a ding, who had a scrape on their car that weekend. Exactly. And blew it off as, oh, I hit a tree or I hit another car. Somebody knows who that person is. And I feel like they do not work with. I feel like they should be happy to work with you.

And be more like, oh, you're in town. I'm going to take time to come and talk to you. I want someone. I mean, we all know that these podcasts actually solve more things or get it out there to people. Like it should have been today that the lead detective, the supposedly detective on the case said, you know, I want to work with you today. I don't care if it's Saturday. I want to spend the time and work with you because you're going to get this out there to people. And you're and I'm going to give you more information, even if you want to give it to me, but they should work with you. I mean, you're like you said, you're an advocate. You've got the stuff. You do this. They're not. You saw nothing.

No, and I messaged them a week ago and let them know my schedule. I was here yesterday by what, one o'clock on Friday. So there was all day Friday afternoon if they didn't want to do it on the weekend. But I never got any response to the email that I sent. Exactly. And that's what's frustrating is because I'd rather, it's one thing with us, I'm not going to unfortunately probably be able to solve it or get it in front of the right people all the time, but you could. And they know that. So why don't they want to work with you and give you the information? And why does there have to be so much? It's an open case. We can't release this much. And we have a lead here, but we don't know this or that. But it's like, or let you see some of the, they don't exactly, it goes back to the point. They don't want to say, I have no idea how the tips are sorted. Are you just?

Is there just a person in the office logging them now? Are they following up with them? Are they just how are they deciding that they're good, not good? Oh, this is incredible. It just and that's where it goes to a lot of the detectives have retired or moved on. And it's like who's actually doing it? I don't know. And I guess and I want to know this. I mean, I asked this and it's I mean, I've had interviews and different things and it's never been exactly better. But how many unsolved murders are there in Travers? I don't.

One. There's one. Exactly. Now, in Grand Traverse, there's a couple that are, but in Traverse City proper, there is one and it's Kelly. And you'd think that there would be a greater desire to see it resolved. Exactly. And that's what makes me, I'm at a point now where I don't want to completely be like...

to the Traverse State Police Department. But on the other hand, I just don't feel like they are doing anything. You're frustrated, which is completely understandable considering how things have been handled. And you're not asking for a lot. You're asking for a dialogue with the department and it's not happening. And that is super frustrating. Or to have a dialogue with you. I would have honestly, I mean, even like I said, more than myself or even, yes, have a dialogue with us. But like someone like you that comes to town and says, I want to put this out there. I want to work on this. I want to see what we can do. But you get nothing. And that just shows you where we're at. If we're not getting, you know, if you can't even, you would think they'd want to. It goes right back to if there's one unsolved murder.

And sometimes I feel like they don't want to look at it like that. They're not looking at it. Where I've changed my complete belief on this, this is a murder. Whoever did this, when you look at this stuff, this is how this went down. In the beginning, tried to be like, okay, was it an accident? This, trying to be reasonable. I'm past all that. Someone intentionally tried to get it. Yeah, you know, it's way past that now. Whoever did this, it was intentional. They did it, tried it in the beginning. Okay, maybe they'll come back around. You had hope that they did this. Okay, were they drinking? They wanted to collect themselves, what they wanted to do. And that didn't happen. Or if it did, did they take the tip?

Did they really follow up with it? Is it there? And they just didn't follow the right one because they were stuck on this one or that one? I don't know. I really don't know. Well, and there's, you're not asking for anything exceptional from law enforcement in this case. You're asking for annual meetings with updates on the disposition of Kelly's murder investigation. Or pass it to someone else then that wants to work on it. You know, there's absolutely no, there's nothing wrong with saying this is stalled. We're going to try another tack.

The problem becomes when the case stalls and they throw up their hands. And I don't know if that's where we're at. And then there's part of me that says, you know, because there's some other legit leads and tips out there that I think that I've heard through different people. You know, I'm at a point of, was it someone important? And they know it and they're not following up with it. And I shouldn't say important, but somebody that sits somewhere that's connected and they have enough to follow it, but maybe not. And so they've backed off because we don't want to ruffle feathers.

That could be. I've heard that numerous times. I've also heard that. But I've also gotten tips very specific. This person confessed, you know, person A confessed to person B that they did it. This person had a dark SUV and moved out of town, out of state the week after the accident happened. They packed up and yeeted right out of Traverse City. All right. That's odd. Why would you abandon your jobs, you know, apropos of nothing and move cross country in the weeks following the incident? Exactly. And there should be no reason, though, that if someone like you that has it's not just someone from the street, but someone like you that comes in there and tries to ask the detectives that are supposedly.

still handing them the case, they should be able to answer those. They should take the time and answer those to you and say, yeah, no, we did follow that one. This is where it led. OK, we'll squash that one. Then answer those questions, whatever happened, because that is a very legitimate tip that should have been followed up. And you and I are not asking for them to violate confidentiality or God forbid, we don't want them to do anything that would jeopardize a future prosecution. We are just looking for annual updates in the case, a normal dialogue between a victim's family and a law enforcement agency that is investigating. We're being respectful. I want it weekly or monthly.

You absolutely deserve to have it weekly or monthly. You are her mother. Nothing. Nothing. And that's not right. I would really like that they would be more open with like you. You're going to be able to follow up. You get this out to more people. You know the right. But why can't they answer you? They didn't take the time to answer you. Like the tip you just brought up. Why can't they say, well, that led to this? Or we're aware of it. That's not going to impact the case. If you're telling us, were you aware of it? Did you follow up with it? If they did follow up, we'll use that example. They followed that tip. And they can say, nope, that was a dead end. That's not impacting the case. But they won't even answer those questions anymore. And that's where I go back to so. So the ones that I've heard that this is somebody.

that they do know and it's somebody that's connected somewhere. Is that why they just are like, nope. There's an erosion of trust in law enforcement when you can't have a basic dialogue about an open case. And so that's where my... I support law enforcement. I don't want to sound like I support them wholeheartedly. But on the other hand, in this instance, I'm at a point now of what are you hiding? Why are you? Is it hiding that you're not working on it? Is it hiding that, you know, you kind of have some avenues to go the right way and you've been told not to follow it. So you just blow it off. Otherwise, what's that's the point I'm feeling that now is what's the reason that we're not? Why is there an utter lack of urgency in her case? And you don't want to pass it off to anybody else, though. You don't want a cold case. You don't want the state police. You don't want the FBI because it's an open case. If you can't solve it, then give it to somebody else. Yes, I agree with I agree with you completely.

I agree with you completely. And I've worked with other. Sorry, I'm addressing Kelly's mom. Yes, she said they may be overwhelmed if they are. They have resources available to them. There are other departments and other opportunities to have this case investigated that maybe it's time to do that. But whatever they decide to do, it would be nice to see them doing something measurable, something that includes the family in whatever steps they decide to take moving forward. Yes, exactly. I mean, just do something. I just I'm at a point where I don't think they're doing anything. And what's the reason? Right. I don't know. I don't think that they're.

I don't know if they're sorting the tips. I don't know what they're doing with them. I just feel like, and like you saw, the lack of response is very frustrating. And it's like, if you can't, at this point, most departments, if they don't have the resources, even if they're overwhelmed, if they're overwhelmed, then give it somewhere else. Look for the outside sources. Like you said, universities, there's people that can look into this and that's what they're doing. There's no, why is there a reason if you, you know, it's always been over because we're working on this lead, but nothing ever comes of that lead. Right. So is there really that lead out there? I don't know.

I've been told it one too many times. It's always circled back around to this or circled back around to that. And I've had Bill and I have been, you know, around town last night and today and people are like, oh, you're working on Kelly. Like, let me hear. You know, this is what I've heard. There needs to be a better dialogue. There needs to be a reestablishment of the trust between your family and law enforcement. And I understand that law enforcement can't invite you into the room, but they can pull the curtain back and give you an idea of what's going on. Exactly.

Because the community has absolutely been engaged and interested and involved and wanting to see resolution of this case. The positive response from the community that I've seen has just been fantastic. Yes, the community has been wonderful. All the way since the beginning, they've wanted nothing more than to see it solved. And that's the frustration of a lot of people. And like I said, I understand limited evidence in a sense that, you know, so that makes it hard. It was laid at different things. But do I think they had some things? Yes. And, you know, and there's come on, there's different.

They were able to get tire tracks. They got things. We all know I'm not in law enforcement, but we all know that there's things that can be sent off, things that can be done. And I'm not saying that they haven't, but it still just goes back to when we all said it was going to be in the tips. I still think it's in the tips somewheres. And they just haven't circled. They focused either hyper focused on certain ones, overlooked other ones, or they're choosing to not follow up on other ones. I don't know. And that's what it feels like. And you're not getting the dialogue. And the community has been great. I mean, different things.

They've just been great support. Always have. They're willing, like you said, to tan out the flyers, to do things. I want to give a shout out to the Bigby Coffees here in Traverse City because they offered to put her cards in bagel bags this weekend. So they took a ton of flyers. So stop at Bigby Coffee and show your appreciation for their support. Yes. I also want to give a shout out to B&B Printing, who printed up all of our flyers. They look amazing. Yes. He was wonderful to work with. And thank you. And thank you so much.

If you have information on the unsolved murder of Kelly Boyce Hurlburt, please contact tips.fbi.gov. That's tips.fbi.gov. We are still seeking justice in Kelly's case, and I will continue to share information and updates in her story as they become available.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Already Gone Podcast?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this Already Gone Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on October 27, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Already Gone Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.