This is a global player original podcast. Hello and welcome to Your Wrong About ADHD. I'm Katie Breathwick. And I'm Sam Pittis.
Great to be back with you, Katie. And you, Sam. We will soon be back with a brand new series of Your Wrong About ADHD, but there is a lot of conversation about ADHD at the moment. There's lots of things going on, and so we wanted to get back in the studio and talk to you and look at some of those issues and answer some of those questions.
And Katie, there's a lot to talk about. There is a lot to talk about. In the last few days, all I seem to have heard about are the changes to pick the Personal Independence Payment. Now, let's be brutally honest.
Hardly any ADHDers have been able to apply for it. There's a lot of paperwork, a lot of time. How many people it affects is hard to quantify. But what is becoming pretty clear is that the changes that are coming in are going to make it nylon impossible for somebody with ADHD to apply for PIP.
So what is PIP? Well, up until a few days ago, you could apply for it if you're over 16 and you had a health conditioner or a disability that caused difficulties with your daily living or your mobility. It had to last for at least three months, and actually you were more likely to get it if it went on for nine months or more. So those were the sort of general criteria.
And then they would look at how you live your life and they would measure you in certain things like how verbal are you. Do you need to support with getting dressed, eating, planning daily tasks, all these different things? Now, the nature of ADHD, obviously, has meant that if you had the where was all to apply for this in the first place, you would score very low in all of those criteria. And at the end, they'd then add up all your numbers and see if you qualified by adding all those numbers together.
And if you scored high enough, then you would qualify for PIP. These latest changes mean that you have to score highly in one of those areas. You have to get at least four points in one of those areas. And to me, it seems that that has now shut the door on ADHD is because we won't score highly in any of those areas.
And therefore, those people who are really on their knees and really, really need this sort of help. Just one minute. So they've tightened up the requirements for receiving PIP. I mean, it's one of those conversations that you always have as a journalist around benefits or any sort of support is that there has to be a threshold somewhere and always some people miss out.
It's just particularly difficult when the people who listen to this podcast are directly affected. The other thing the government are reviewing is access to work. Now, access to work is support that people get in work. So what they do is they do a sort of workplace assessment and they will look at whether you need noise cancelling headphones or whether you need support getting to work, depending on what it is you struggle with.
Now, again, we don't quite know what those changes are going to look like. It's the first time it's been reviewed, I think, since 1994. So it may be that it's appropriate to come and review this. But I think the reason that has felt like an issue is because access to work has been at the centre, I think it's safe to say, of a culture war.
Oh, gosh, yes, absolutely. Open any newspaper, actually, or log on to the internet at the moment and read any of the news organisations online offering. And ADHD appears somewhere and someone is having a go at us. And I just feel that that's exactly what this is.
I do feel really upset by these changes. I have a brother who is disabled. So over the course of my lifetime, and certainly here's the way in which society supports people who are not able to look after themselves, has always been something that I have been interested in. But this feels like they've joined the culture war.
It feels like they're also having a bash at us. And there's one aspect of this that I find particularly upsetting. And it's the fact that they've excluded people under 22, completely for applying for incapacity benefit. And we've talked about this in the podcast before.
Those kids, those youngsters who are most vulnerable, most at sea because of their ADHD, struggling most with their mental health, most baffled by why they don't seem to be able to get on with things when all of their peers can are the ones who have been cut off from receiving any support or help. And that's OK for those kids who've got really supportive families. But what if you're a youngster coming out of care, or you're somebody leaving school at 18, who doesn't live at home, and you are really, really struggling with putting food on the table or making sure that you turn up to working clean clothes, all of these different things. And I just think we have cut a generation, a drift, who have been through the pandemic and have already been served a pretty raw deal by history anyway.
You know, I don't sit on the fence. I just have a view where I say clearly we're in a situation where the government has to make tough choices. Clearly there is a decision to be made about finance. So, so, raise taxes.
Yeah, there are tough decisions to make. You know what? Yes, absolutely. Let's put taxes up.
We know that there are external factors that are making things difficult for us as a country. OK, we have all sorts going on internationally that makes things difficult for us. We have an excuse now to raise taxes because as a nation, we're having to defend ourselves. OK, they've raised the defense budget, so there's money somewhere, isn't there?
But regardless of the ADHD community, there's no question that a whole bunch of people will have been pushed into poverty by these changes to PIP. And that makes me feel deeply uncomfortable. And the fact that ADHD has new applicants, let's be clear here, will never qualify, will never meet these criteria. Makes me feel really uncomfortable.
It does depend on what their other underlying conditions are, of course. And that is, I'm sure part of what the government would say is that, OK, if there's other things going on for you, they'll be measured as well. But certainly, it does seem that it's going to be much, much harder to get support if you've got ADHD. And I think the thing that concerns me is that it again comes back to this idea of, do people fully understand the difficulties surrounding ADHD?
Do people fully understand what it is? And I think all the stuff I've seen in the newspapers about, essentially, it is people with ADHD have got a diagnosis because they're a bit lazy and they're looking for an excuse, so they don't really have to work. And that couldn't be further from the truth. The people I know with ADHD, obviously, where are those people?
Where are those people who are just on the sick for a laugh? I don't know any. The people I know with ADHD have gone through real difficulties and are looking for support to function in life. And I think we talk about access to work.
You only get that if you're in work. And it seems to me that if a company says, right, we've done an assessment and OK, we need to get you some noise cancelling headphones, or I don't know, we need to get you a particular type of software and that's going to make you more productive. What's the problem? Absolutely.
And I think we, people with ADHD have to, I was going to say, fight back. But what we actually need to do is continue to educate. Because in some ways, I can understand these questions. I know I feel like I'm jumping from two different positions here, but I can understand why people are asking these questions.
I can sort of understand some of the criticism. Because if you don't understand ADHD, and you think it's just people being lazy, and there's been a sudden shoot-up in diagnosis of ADHD, you might say to yourself, hang on, what's going on there? But let's be clear, it's still under diagnosed in this country. You know, we hope we've identified the level, the percentage of the population at large who should have a diagnosis.
And we are way below that number. So yes, yes, yes. Way more people are being diagnosed. Just like in the 20s, they were allowed to be left-handed and were accused then of pretending to be left-handed for the sake of this, you know, sudden weird thing that was going on, people were kind of, you know, just jumping on the bandwagon and being left-handed.
It is not a phase. It's not something that people are pretending to be. It's under-diagnosed in this country. And until it reaches the levels where we expect it to be, there is absolutely no argument about this being over-diagnosed, which is all I seem to read about in some of the broadsheets.
This is a developing situation. And until we've got to the end of it, until we've given all the people who need it, access to a diagnosis to see if they qualify for one, we can't comment on those figures. Yeah, and I think, you know, everyone's a bit ADHD or ADHD is everywhere. It isn't true.
There is a certain number of people who have ADHD and there's a lot of people who've been undiagnosed for years and we're catching up. And that's all it is. But I think we do need to try to, you know, say, right, this irritates me, put that to one side now, and you need to explain this to people. Well, we've got ADHD now and that's really hard to do.
But we, I just think in the face of this, we need to continue to explain that to people. We have to continue to say, hang on a minute. My brain works slightly differently. That has caused me all sorts of difficulties in my life.
I've got diagnosed so that I could take responsibility and I could find ways to manage and I could function in life. I'm not looking to be lazy. I'm not looking for a handout. I'm not looking to show up responsibility.
What I'm looking to do is to be honest about who I am and then actually find a way to manage. So let's take a closer look at some of those changes to PIP and have a look at some of the issues surrounding ADHD and what we can do about it. We're going to talk to Henry Shelford from ADHD UK in a moment. Hello, Henry.
It's lovely to have you back. It was one of a beer. What is your take on the current situation? It's just so awful on every single level right now.
You've got people looking to get an assessment with ridiculous wait times. We've got a lot of media articles. They have one recently saying ADHD is just a scam. People think they're just getting an ADHD assessment to benefit and to get PIP.
And I just could not be further from the truth. Like the difficulty of someone with ADHD to try and get PIP, it's near impossible. And not pretty much everyone I speak to. They want support to work.
They don't want support not to work. Can I ask a bit more about the award of the personal dependence payment? So we don't quite know how all this is going to shake out yet, but it certainly seems that it's going to be tightened up in terms of the requirements and the threshold for receiving it. What does this mean for somebody with ADHD do you think?
So we've been running some research on the site, which has been asked on people about PIP. It's been going for a number of years. And looking at the hundreds of responses, majority people struggle to get PIP. The vast majority of those who do get PIP have multiple conditions.
And I could identify only two who had ADHD only and who reported ADHD. And when they've talked through their stories, the impact is very clearly incredibly severe. And so PIP's way of structure is so hard for someone with ADHD to get. It is really hard to see how these changes, what that impact is going to be.
It obviously can only be negative. I just wish as a balance, put so much more effort and work into support, because that at the moment, often you have to wait enormous at a time, varying levels of impact. That's the bit where I think we need to do more work. Access to work is being reviewed as far as we understand.
It's the first time it's been reviewed in 30 years, the government says, that is about giving people support in work. I think part of the misunderstanding that seems to be out there in the conversation around it at the moment is that it's some sort of benefit. Actually, it's about people being encouraged to be in the workplace. You presumably are concerned about the changes to that too.
I'm hugely concerned about it. And to be honest, concerned about it now, right? Because if you apply for it in employment, you're looking to wait time for five to six months, and that's probably going to have you, if you're struggling, you may not be keeping your job in that period. Talk to countless people, frankly, with that has been the case.
You have articles in the paper saying that people who try to help people with access to work are sick fluences, who are negative, that they're helping people get support, that help them succeed in work. And the government's return on investment on it, they're on average, taking 30% of salary. So the return on keeping someone in employment is so good for the state. Where people are struggling, this is not for everyone.
It's for the people who are struggling. Making that difference is life-changing for them, and for the country is economically absolutely the right thing to do. Absolutely. It is not a new thing, is it?
To say that, A, it's good for someone to work for all of the reasons, you know, mental health boosts your self-identity, all of those different things, your self-image. But also the fact that you then become a contributing member of society, is there are all of those different reasons that make this a worthwhile contribution. But you mention what feels like, to us, a culture war. I wonder whether you are also sensing that there's been a rise in identifying ADHD as something to attack.
Without question, it's one of the most awful things. For example, recently, ADHD is a scam. We had one of the news channels saying that ADHD is wildly over-diagnosed, just not true. It's turning around and talking to parents whose children, whose child has taken their own life.
Or you're talking to someone hugely struggling, and you've got these people who are just willfully making our lives so much more awful. When we're struggling anyway, it's just absolutely awful. With a journalist sat on, which isn't always the best hat to wear, I can see where some of this comes from, because we have seen a rise in the discussion about ADHD. There does seem to be a mass rise in diagnosis.
It's probably worth you stating, perhaps restating some of the facts around this. Why are we seeing so many people being diagnosed ADHD at the moment, and is it over-diagnosed? It is absolutely not over-diagnosed. Actually, with great fortune in January, a study of 9 million GP records in England looked at ADHD and found only 0.32% had the diagnosis of ADHD.
If you do an average population of children adults, you're looking at about 3.8%. So we're looking at an 0.32% versus a population of 3.8%. So we're not even at 1 in 10. And so categorically under-diagnosed, which we know what people are confusing is the fact that we're finally having a conversation about ADHD for the first time ever.
Some people, and definitely not all by long stretch, are happy to say they've got ADHD. And so for people who aren't part of our world, this is completely new, and they've not had that conversation. And they're going, where's this all come from? Actually, most of it's come from the fact that so many people stigmatized us, made us not talk about it, and made us be quiet.
And you've got those same people trying to silence us again, and trying to say, like, you need to just quieten down. Like, there's too much noise, there must be too many of you. You're like, you know what? We're not even at 1 in 10.
Do you think we're noisy now? Just you wait. Like, we're going to get noisier, and we're going to start to talk more loudly about how we are being so brutalized by the system and ignored, having ADHD can be extraordinarily tough. Particularly if you don't have a diagnosis, don't have support.
We know that the suicide rate for men is 1 in 10 men, or boys with ADHD at some point trying to take their own life. For women, we know it's 1 in 4. And for me, that is the element of the conversation that never, ever, ever seems to make it into the press. We see all of these articles, all of this criticism of people with ADHD, of, you know, we're told it's a scam.
We're accused of leaning on the NHS too much. We're told that we've made it all up, and actually, what people never, ever, ever seem to acknowledge is that it can be completely life-limiting in the most complex way, and that some people just can't cope at all. And I wish that that was something that we acknowledged more as a society. It's a statistic I have taken from you, and I have used in conversations personally again and again and again.
And every single time people find it shocking. It is a shocking statistic. It is a shocking statistic, and people are active in the community. You know how true it is, right?
Because you mean too many people where you learn that story. The big study, the one of 9 million GP records, also looked into this, it looked into particularly around self-harm and suicide on a person's GP record with ADHD. For men, it is up 480%. And for women, it's similar numbers.
It's 383% up. So an increase, so an increase of 3 and a day. It's so much more. Anyone listening to this conversation, I personally don't think we'll be surprised by what you just said.
But it's those people out there, the ones who are leading the culture war, it's those people who don't seem to be able to absorb that argument. The ones who don't seem to understand that, these simple measures, the diagnosis and the subsequent help, not they don't just help you get back to work. It saves lives, it improves marital relationships, it helps somebody parent, it helps them completely university degree. These are life changing things.
And we know, because we're sitting here, either medicated or we've been through therapy, we know that these things have changed our lives. But for us still to be having this conversation, all these months, years later, about whether or not it exists is just so dispiriting. Say someone listening to this podcast for the first time, maybe suspects they've got ADHD and they've started down that rather lengthy road of trying to get a diagnosis. What is your advice to them going forward for now?
Before a diagnosis we talk about it, it's like you're an amazing writer. And you're banging things, banging others, hurting yourself, I think that's not meaning to you. A diagnosis and a knowledge that comes with it turns the lights up. And suddenly you can see your mates, which is more difficult than it is for most.
But you can see it. And that allows you to navigate it in a completely different way and succeed in a different way than what I was un-treatable before. But it is the enlightenment, it's the knowledge of the understanding, which comes with a diagnosis, particularly so you can know to make those stronger decisions. So the biggest thing to learn about it, listen to this podcast, learn about ADHD from sources you trust and talk to people.
We run lots of free, but then if you can, support groups, everyone's trying to find that line. When you first diagnose, which is the line is like, what's driven by unique me and what's driven by my ADHD? If I was a unique person, plus ADHD, you're trying to work out where's the line and treat those two things differently. We put in strategies for success that really can make a huge difference.
And so to do that, you need to understand yourself in your ADHD well and then you need to understand strategies. So going to support groups, just learning, hearing other people and getting a grasp, I think is a really great thing to do. If you're looking for a diagnosis in England, go and look at what's your local wait time and what's your option on right to choose. The shortest option right now on right to choose is something like four to six weeks.
So pretty hard to beat that. If you're struggling to learn your exact wait time or your half, you've been waiting a while on your local NHS. GPs sometimes, maybe they mostly know out of like experience of like I referred to someone else that's been seen. The best thing to do is just slam in a freedom of information request.
And then you go for someone who was referred to like December 24, when would you expect them to ask your question, but like not person to you, but to that date point, you should also always ask how many people are waiting, what's the throughput, what's your current expectation? Because then you can work out where you are in the queue and roughly how long it's going to be. But the best way to actually learn is to do a freedom of information to your local trust and get the absolute data on you. Otherwise it can be more accurate and they're looking right.
So if you're outside of England, then your options are just local NHS or going privately. Private options vary a lot. We are going to be starting a page where we are going to list private options. We're not going to get paid for it because we don't want that to be compromised.
We are however going to ask anyone who's on it to contribute time to run some of those three support groups. And that then helps us get really high qualified people to people in need quickly. And of course, prices there range a lot. I think the lowest price we can see for an assessment right now is around 300 pounds, up to multiple thousands.
One of the reasons we want to publish this page is because too often people are find the one talk from education and that monthly cost is really, really high. With that private provider, it's often not made clear to you until you're there. And we need to get clarity on that, particularly for people who are, you know, the stuff in Scotland right now is just awful. We've had a vote where they've literally removed their adult ADHD and autism service.
Like just removed it. Like it's a big belief. So it's so shocking. We do have a health divide at the moment where people are finding themselves having to go private and those who can't, they're getting failed by their local NHS.
And that's much worse in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. But we do at least want to be able to tell people what their options are and what price to try and help them get the best one for them. You are doing fantastic work. And I would say, you know, you're looking at your website.
The resources are available from what you're saying, Henry. And it certainly are experienced. Things are hard, but there is support from ADHD UK. We will put the details in our show description so that people can access that.
And we will keep on talking about this. Thank you so much for joining us today, Henry. And thank you for what you're doing, Henry. Thank you.
A big thank you to Henry Shelford from ADHD UK. A lot to digest from that conversation. After we spoke to Henry, we did reach out to the Department for Work and Pensions for a comment. We haven't had a response from them yet, but it has been some other changes since we spoke to Henry.
Just to go back a bit, you may remember right to choose, which is the system where people can choose where they get diagnosis and treatment for ADHD. It is essentially supposed to circumnavigate the waiting lists. Well, NHS England were consulting on proposed changes to right to choose. ADHD UK were concerned that those changes would have a negative impact on people with ADHD.
And they were asking people to write to their MPs. And people have done so in the hundreds and indeed thousands. And NHS England has now announced that it is scrapping those proposed changes to right to choose, which is great news, but still those waiting lists remain. We know that there are still long waits for people trying to get diagnosis and treatment.
We've been speaking to NHS England. NHS England is being scrapped by the government. It's been described as a zombie by ADHD UK, so we do need to watch this space. And we still need to make the case for better diagnosis and treatment for people with ADHD.
In terms of the culture we've talked about, it can feel really stark. And at times like a personal attack, the important thing to remember is ADHD is being talked about. It's helped there in the conversation. That gives us an opportunity to step in, to share our stories, and to help others truly understand what ADHD actually is.
Yeah, and if this episode is for a little intense, do as we do take a breath, do be kind to yourself. Know that you are not alone. There's a whole community of us out there, and conversations like this that Sam says are moving the dial in the right direction. And we will be back very soon for the brand new full series of You're Wrong About ADHD.
We've got lots of guests and topics lined up, including masking, therapy, memory strategies, and much more. In the meantime, don't forget to rate, review, and share the podcast. It really helps others find us. Take care, and we'll see you soon.
This is a Global Player Original Podcast.