Thanks for downloading and welcome to Take Orally, the emergency medicine podcast recorded at Dream, Queen's Medical Centre at Nottingham. In this episode we'll be discussing breaking bad news. As ever, all information is correct at the time of recording. Any guidelines mentioned are correct for Nottingham University Hospital's NHS Trust. Other trust guidelines may vary. All views and opinions of the speaker's own.
Hello, my name's Jamie. I'm one of the teaching fellows in emergency medicine. I'm Anna. I'm one of the teaching fellows in obstetric and gynecology. Welcome back, Anna. Hope you had a nice Christmas and New Year. We're recording this in February. Thank you for having me back. Thank you for coming back. Before we go any further, I'd just like to say thank you to Rebecca Lilywhite, somebody who, one of our listeners who messaged me on Facebook to let us know that the seizure podcast cut out just at the end, just as we're about to talk about status epilepticus. So, sorry about that. We've fired the producer. You are the producer.
Don't say that. And we've put up the full CJ podcast mentioning States Epilectica, so thanks for that, Rebecca. Right then, like I said, thanks for coming back, Anna. In this podcast, we're going to be talking about Breaking Bad News. And this is something that you've noticed students feeding back about during your own teaching, isn't that right? Yeah, that's right. So we run a simulated on-call for our students at NUH.
That's to say Nottingham Hospitals. And the feedback that comes out all the time is that one of the stations is a patient who's had a miscarriage and they're required to break the news to the patient, but they feel quite inadequately prepared to deal with that situation because they've not had any formal teaching, have very little experience in how to deal with it. And so we thought it would be a good idea to maybe have this podcast so they could have something to listen to beforehand, and then maybe the feedback will change. Yeah, and to be honest, it's something I think students are fed back sometimes when they're in placement in the emergency department as well. Not necessarily breaking the bad news, we don't ask them to do that during that, but I think witnessing it and having never really thought about it beforehand and maybe formalised how it takes place, like you do with so many other things that we practise at medical school. So I think we can agree this is probably every doctor during their career is going to have to break bad news at some point. Yeah, and absolutely. Classically, you think of it as breaking bad news, cancer diagnosis, don't you? Yeah, yeah. For some people it might be a bit strange that the odd-and-line registrar is talking to you about it, but actually it affects...
all sorts of different specialities and in fact we were just talking before we started this that what is bad news for one person is not necessarily bad news for another and so actually you might kind of find yourself in a situation where you're breaking bad news when you didn't actually anticipate that it would be bad news In some situations, in fact, what is good news for someone else, maybe bad news for someone else? Yeah, so, yeah, I mean, I've made a patient cry telling her that she was pregnant in A&E, when obviously she didn't want that. And then I've made another one cry, excuse me, tears of happiness by saying she wasn't pregnant, because, you know, this is something she'd be worried about. So, I mean, like you said, exactly, it's what's bad news for one is not necessarily bad news for another. So I think, you know, what sort of...
What circumstances do you think an early junior doctor would be expected to break bad news in? I think probably in the early life of a junior doctor, so foundation years, that early SHO, probably from the forefront of breaking bad news, junior doctors are probably quite protected from it. It's kind of seen as a job for the senior doctor or the consultant. I've certainly worked in hospitals where actually breaking news of a cancer diagnosis was solely the job of a consultant, it was not ever the job of anyone else. And that's kind of reasonable that it should be that way, but then it makes it difficult for people to get experience and know how you can break bad news properly and how you can do it well.
The types at times when I've broken bad news as a junior doctor, I've worked in obstetrics and gynaecology for a long time, so certainly breaking the news of a miscarriage is pretty common for us, or an ectopic pregnancy. Telling someone that they have a cancer diagnosis, I mean comes in lots of different specialities. Telling someone they have a sexually transmitted infection can be desperately bad news for some people, whereas other people don't see it maybe as quite a dim light. I don't know what is situations where you, as a junior doctor... Yeah, so certainly I think in accident and emergency, obviously it's not a clinic environment. It's so, you know, when you are the, I think, you know, we've started having F1s, so it's different now. The F1s do see where the consultant birth means, certainly F2s and above. You are that patient's responsible clinician. And unless you specifically ask for it, you will not get somebody who's seen you coming in. So it is on you to go in. And then, yeah, certainly as an F2, I, you know, had to take the break news of brain tumours, of, you know, potentially life-threatening conditions, like ischemic bowel, AAA, immediately spring to mind.
and patients can deteriorate very rapidly as well, and having to keep relatives informed about that as well. So I think in A&E, certainly you have to be on your toes a lot in A&E about things like that happening. Are there any preparations you think we can take before we have to break bad news? So I mean, as we just discussed, sometimes you find yourself in that situation where you're kind of suddenly breaking bad news and you didn't realise that it perhaps would be bad news for the patient, so you're suddenly in a situation where you have to deal with it. But I think the classical things you'll read about, you know, making sure that you're kind of prepared, making sure you understand exactly what it is that you're telling the patient, that you perhaps understand the test result. And if there is any confusion about it, that you've discussed that with one of your seniors or maybe delayed providing that information until, you know, it's perhaps more certain if that's appropriate. You hear people saying, like...
don't have your blimp with you or your mobile phone so that actually you're away from being you know distracted whilst you're trying to give the patient that information in a quiet room away from you know other people on the ward um despite what a lot of people think the curtains around beds are in fact not soundproof and so it's not really appropriate um when you're like an open bay for example if you're just using the curtains that's not very private um for a patient um it may be the patient wants to have someone with them or if that's not possible you know if not relative it may be a nurse so someone can be with them just to you know look after you know for the patient rather than just doing it one-to-one. So, yeah, I mean, I think nurses are very good. I mean, I think that's also a bit of a comfort for me as the doctor, I think, sometimes. And the very good nurses, of which we have many in the emergency department, they're all very good, I should say. They're all very good. They might do. They will say, do you want me to come in with you? And I think nurses, I think, as well, especially when I speak to student nurses or nurses just starting, are very good at translating doctor-ish into patient-ish. So, I mean, I've been there on a research shift.
where the family come in and you can you know you're busy something else but you can hear you can hear the relatives going when's the doctor coming to tell us what's going on and you know you you come in and you you think that you're giving the best translation of doctoration to layperson language you think you're explaining it really well you take all the time you can and then as I'm leaving what I hear is them turning to the nurses going so what does that mean then and then the nurse is having to you know being that translating step I mean it's interesting what you say about you know the location because I think there's something that I've I remember when I was a surgical F1 the registrar I was working on SEAU, the surgical admissions unit, and we had a patient who came in with painless jaundice, so we thought this was pancreatic cancer, and the scan confirmed that there was a pancreatic mass. But the registrar in question, who saw him with me after I clerked him in, said, we won't tell it here, this isn't the right environment, and booked him into the consultant's clinic so it would be seen in a clinical environment, in a clinic environment, rather than being on the ward, which I've never seen before, but the registrar thought in that instance was more appropriate. So the senior saying that A&E is not a good place to break the news of...
a possible cancer diagnosis that should be done later on. But then other people say, no, that's not the case, and patients should know when they should know. I think it's difficult, isn't it? It is, because actually you don't want to inappropriately delay the patient knowing what's going on just because you don't think it's an appropriate environment. In fact, if you're on a ward or if you're in the A&E department, there are side rooms available.
that this kind of thing can be done in. I can see why some people think that A&E might not be the correct place in order to break bad news, a very busy clinical environment where maybe not all of the information is readily available to you, so it might be an incomplete picture. But certainly we should be telling our patients the information that we know. I don't think that we should deliberately hide or keep that from them. Even if we have to say we don't have all the information at the moment, this is what we do know so far, the possibilities are X, Y and Z, but we are worried that this is possibly...
a cancer, for example. What's the difference between saying there is a mass versus you have a biopsy confirmed carcinoma, isn't there? But I think, I mean, we'll talk a bit in a little bit about warning shots. I think certainly if you're seeing the patient early on giving a warning shot, I think it's a bit more collegiate to your colleagues further on down the line by saying that this is one thing that the specialist may end up talking to you about. Yeah, it makes it a lot easier for people later on rather than, you know, when they have got all the information, they have the scan results and it comes completely out of the blue for the patient and they had absolutely no idea what the possibilities were. That certainly makes life a lot easier.
for subsequent people seeing the patient, yeah. I think you can time it as well. So in A&E, relatives hopefully will come in and see their patient in A&E and you can wait till they're all present to just break bad news. I think when you're the award junior doctor, you can wait till visiting times and they're present. So if you're a GP having it as well, you could make sure that they come in with somebody so there is somebody there that they're not driving home alone, having been told potentially some very bad news. Okay, so we've sort of hopefully set our scene. We've got our patient relatives, advocates all there. How should we begin the consultation, do you think?
I think it's really important to explain to the patient who you are, give them your full name, what your role is, and I think then the next step is depending on how much information you already have, because it might be necessary in order to give the patient information properly that maybe you need a bit of information from them. Certainly I think you need to check what the patient understands already, which may be to understand, for example, ask the patient, do you know why you had the scan? and they may tell you, yes, they were looking for an answer. In which case, that makes them going on to talking about that a lot easier, because you know the patient's already in the frame of mind, that they already understand what the possibilities are. Which is very different to if the patient actually tells you that they have no idea, they've been referred into the hospital, but actually haven't been told anything so far, and you're the first person seeing them. In which case, you do need to maybe ask them a few questions about what's been going on. I'm not talking about taking a full history of everything in the world, but maybe some kind of salient questions that might guide you as to what's been happening so far.
Yeah. I mean, possibly the worst ever example I ever saw that as a medical student was in a head and neck clinic, which was an MDT clinic. So there was a, I think it was maxillofacial, there was ENT, and there was an oncologist. And they all introduced themselves to this patient who came in and said, oh, I'm one of the oncologists. And he was like, oh, so what's an oncologist? And he was like, oh, it's a cancer specialist. And he went, oh. And you could tell that this guy had not, he'd been referred in by his GP through the whole two-week ways and things, had not been warned at all. And you could just see the colour go from his cheeks.
Not a good example of how not to do things, I think. Hopefully we don't see that a lot as doctors, and hopefully our medical students don't see bad examples of breaking bad news, but I suspect that there are a lot of people that carry with them examples of when they saw bad news broken really badly. which shouldn't happen, but actually it's quite the learning point of things that you shouldn't do and help people actually go forward. Hopefully we'll give lots of examples of really bad things on this podcast, so people can learn from that rather than from actual experience. From actual practice, yeah. And I should say, I've seen this so much better. The pro examples I've seen of how to do break values versus the bad stuff is much more on the positive side. So we mentioned a bit of warning shots again, and clearly that guy in that clinic I saw hadn't had a warning shot.
What is a warning shot, then, when we're breaking bad news? I think it can take several forms. We've already mentioned about how someone may have given prior warning to the patient about what types of things we might be looking for. And so that might be at the point where they have the biopsy taken, whereby we tell them, actually, we're doing this biopsy because we wanted to see whether or not there is cancer or not. So that's a bit like a warning shot, but it's given ahead of time. Typically, warning shots are, rather than just jumping in, you've had cancer, it's to say, I'm sorry to have to tell you today.
but I have bad news. So it's a little bit less of a shock to the system that you've just flirted it out. I think it just makes the consultation and the rapport with the patient a bit better if you've actually given them a little bit of pre-warning that what you're about to tell them is in fact bad news. And I think most patients actually will probably have some idea that the news that you're going to tell them is not good from the way the consultation is going. But for some patients it's really important if they actually...
really have no idea about what you're about to tell them. Yeah, I mean, it's something I say to all my students and it's something I try and do in my practice, is if I'm doing a blood test for something or I'm doing an imaging for something, I tell the patient why. So, for example, we are doing a troponin, we are looking to see if you've had a heart attack. We are scanning your head, I'm looking for a bleed, that's one thing that I'm worried about. And then at least it's there. And yes, it worries them, but you say, look, we will find it, we will try and manage it, whatever we find. And like you said, I think I have a lot of problems with Dr. Google and patients Googling things.
the general knowledge that is in the population is so much better now. And I think sometimes it isn't... We should just say, you know, what are you worried that this is? And if the patient says, I think I might have had a stroke, I might have had a heart attack, I might have cancer, I think it's then our point to go, well, yes, that is one possibility. Or, no, it's not, don't worry, you know, or that is one possibility and that is something we're looking for. And then that is that adult conversation with our patient rather than, you know, I am a doctor, just listen to me. Sure. I think. Yeah, I absolutely agree. I suppose then, also, I mean, I've already mentioned how nurses translating from doctorish to...
to patient-ish, I suppose we should be avoiding medical jargon as much as possible? Yeah, I think the general answer is don't use medical jargon. But of course, I think it does depend on the type of terminology that your patient's using. Because if you've already spoken to them or you've already asked them their understanding, if the patient actually uses terminology that they clearly understand, then I think it's appropriate to then use that terminology when you're speaking to them. But otherwise, in general, using medical jargon is not very helpful. And in that situation, like you say, they turn to the nurse and say, what did he say? What's the problem then?
I think it's very easy for us when you're a doctor, actually translating something from medical jargon back into layman's terms for a patient is actually quite difficult and quite a skill to do well and takes a lot of experience. When you're a medical student and you're learning, because you're always learning from people that are talking to you in medical jargon, it's quite difficult, isn't it, to actually then put it back. Absolutely. So for me just taking AAA for an example. tell this patient who's retired, who left school at 12, that their aorta has ruptured. And then you do find yourself going well, so there's this very big artery, and you're telling me, an artery is a blood vessel. And you do actually find yourself going down, down, down to this most simple level. And that's not because you're patronising, but you think, well, everybody knows what an artery is. They don't, actually. And it is a skill. I completely agree. It is a skill in itself. And that's something, actually, that...
comes back to another point that we were talking about, is about how actually it might change. So your conversation changes depending on the response you get from the patient. So if I start telling somebody that they have endometrial cancer, for example, but then it's kind of clear to me from their body language, from their facial expression, or maybe they verbalise to me, they don't understand, then actually I have to adapt how I'm speaking to them. I have to adapt, as you say, going kind of further, more and more basic in how you're describing something. And that's true of a lot of things with breaking bad news. You find yourself in a bit of a flux situation. It's not necessarily going to happen in one way where you kind of start the consultation, you then do X, Y, and Z, and then the patient leaves at the end of it because actually it changes as time goes on depending on various factors. So how the patient responds because they either understand or they don't, whether or not the patient accepts what you're telling them or are they in denial. It may be that the patient, you tell them about the management possibilities, but the patient actually refuses to kind of...
complying with the management that you're telling them. So various things can kind of change during the consultation, which means that you do need to be quite adaptable, which again, is a skill which is gained, I think, probably only with experience. And that does happen. It happens, I think, about three or four occasions where I've gone down this route of, okay, so it's a blood vessel, you know, very simple. And then one of the family members turns to me and goes, I'm a nurse, so what, you know, oh, no, I'm a doctor, okay. So what's going on now then? What's their, you know, what's this score and things? What's their EWS and things? And, you know, I really want to score, oh, okay.
Then you have to go the other way, back up. So you talked a bit about the patient not necessarily agreeing with the management plan. How early on do you think we should bring the management plan in? I think sometimes it's really important. So sometimes how we go on to manage the bad news is a key part of the whole consultation. So you told them what the situation is, what are we now going to do about it? And so sometimes it's important to bring that in straight away. Other times it may be actually, maybe because of whatever you've diagnosed, or maybe it's because of the patient's condition itself, maybe they need a bit of time to actually kind of process that information, go away and think about what...
questions they want to ask and maybe they need to bring a family member back with them to help them help them do that and so a good example of that is miscarriage actually that we have to have something else so we told the lady that it's been a miscarriage but actually if she's clinically well and she's not bleeding or in a lot of pain it's completely appropriate for us to give her some time to process that information and then bring her back and so we'll give her that option so I would say do you want me to talk about what the management options are or would you like me to give you some time first and we can come back later or you know you can come back another day to discuss it and then it leaves it a bit more in the patients level in their court and about what they want. But I think if you're dealing generally with most situations, you probably would start putting out there what the possibilities are now for management. Yeah, I mean, I think being A&E specific, I think when I seem to be using cancer as an example here, say if we found a brain tumour, for example, I will speak to neurosurgery first before I go and see the patient. So at least there's a management plan in terms of...
giving medication to reduce swelling or to give anti-seizure medication as well. We know that we're going for a staging CT and things like that. So there is a plan there. Same as if you know. go back to AAA again, I've spoken to surgeons, these sorts of things. So it's important to have full information, it's no good to tell someone what's going to happen, it's no good telling someone what you think is going to happen, it transpires that actually something totally different is going to happen, that's like a lot worse. I think you don't, yeah, always stick to your specialty, I mean, don't go beyond your specialty or what you think and all your level of experience, and certainly don't when you're breaking bad news, go, yes, they're certainly going to come in and they're going to cut this out, it's going to be amazing, and the surgeons are actually going, no, we're not, you know, yeah. At the same time, I think it's useful when you say that processing, because I think it's the Macmillan cancer advert that's been on, where she, it starts with a guy receiving bad news about cancer, obviously.
but then this volume just goes and he's just seeing the specialist mouths move, but he's not hearing a thing. I think it's the one that then they start singing You'll Never Walk Alone in. But I think that bit, he's clearly not processing anything because he's heard the word cancer, and that's, I think, do you need a moment? They can be sat there going nodding, but it's actually not. Nothing is going in. Going back to what you said about management, I think you need to, even if you perhaps don't intend on explaining the full management plan to the patient, I think most patients, I don't know if you'd agree, would, after you've told them something bad, they would like to know what's going to happen about it. And so you probably should have that information available to you before you start the consultation. There's not much use giving them the bad news. They ask, OK, so what are we going to do now? And then you say, oh, I don't know. Yeah, absolutely. So definitely some idea, even if the plan is...
we need to speak to X and X in order to understand what the next management perspective is. Yeah. Somebody from another specialty will come and talk to you. They are on their way. I don't know at the moment. Like I said, it needs to be something. Yeah, it needs to be something. Just stick to what you know. Don't lie. So how do you think we should, I think we've already talked a bit about the initial shock. Is there anything else I think we should expect our patients to sort of be feeling and showing when they're receiving bad news? I don't think you can kind of necessarily predict how someone is going to respond. So you've kind of had anger, denial, grief, shock. The stages of, yeah. The stages of, what are the stages?
Yeah, there's the Kubler-Ross model of the five stages of grief and loss, aren't there? Yeah, we definitely did not just look that up. We definitely didn't just look that up. Denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance. Well, I think what we're saying is that actually when you tell someone bad news, you don't really know at which point they will fall on that. And so some patients might go through all five stages in order and be very textbook. Some patients are quite accepting of what you're telling straight away, maybe because they've already understood what the possibilities are, they've already gone through the other stages, and actually at this point that you're telling them, they can be quite accepting of it. But I think...
don't expect a patient to react in any way because if you expect them to react in a certain way and you've kind of pre-planned in your head how you're going to deal with it and then they act in a completely different way it will throw you and you won't then know what to say to them to deal with that particular emotion. Yeah. If you're a Simpsons fan, the episode where Homer Simpson eats some fugu, he goes through the five stages in about five seconds. Have you seen that? Yeah. It's very good for Simpsons fans listening. So how should we then think about ending our consultation then, once we think we're at that point? Because obviously we don't want to go, bye, and just walk off. So there are certain things that we would kind of classically do, I think, to tie up a consultation where you've broken bad news. And obviously the exact bits will depend on what exactly you've told them. But I think generally we have to talk about follow-up.
Are we going to arrange to see the patient again? And when exactly that likely to be, if we're going to do that. We should be offering them an opportunity to be asking questions of us, so if there's anything maybe they haven't had an opportunity to ask so far, and give them some time to formulate those questions as well. If they don't have anything to ask at this particular point, make sure that you tell them they can always come back at a later stage, maybe offer them a contact number, maybe there's a specialist nurse that they can speak to, if they think of any questions that they want to ask. they should probably have some kind of in diagnoses where you're talking about something like a cancer or something which requires some kind of follow-up there normally is a specialist or some member of the team or consultant secretary for example who they can contact if you know they have anything else they want to ask or they need to make any changes to the follow-up plan that's being made MDT involvement as well and in my experience I think with specialties where there is a heavy involvement with oncology, they're very good at then getting in, you know, people like Millen and getting that in early, there's lots of pathways in place. So making sure the patient is aware of kind of all of those. And then of course, it sounds always a bit cliche, but information leaflets, because... Always in the OSCE, information leaflets. Always in the OSCE, definitely. But it is useful for the patient to have some kind of written information just to reinforce to them what you told them, and something for them to show their relatives if they're not quite sure how to verbalise what you've told them, they can say, actually, they've given me these leaflets, this is what's going on. So I think, yeah, that's quite important. And...
I suppose we're not machines. We're humans as well. Our patients are humans. Should we acknowledge the emotional response that our patients show? So if a patient starts breaking down in front of us, you talked about being adaptable. Yeah, that's one situation where you have to be very adaptable when there's an extreme emotional response to what you told them. So crying is really common, or anger as well. Then I think we should acknowledge the emotional response because we should...
hopefully have built rapport with the patient that means that we're able to be personal with them. So actually to say, you can see that this information is really upsetting to you. And giving that bit of time to sink in, make sure that you give them time to process it. Don't try and ask them loads of questions if they're really angry or they're really upset off the tissues. I think people always wonder how much body contact you could give someone. If it wasn't someone where you had that doctor-patient relationship and someone was really upset, your immediate instinct for a lot of people would be to put an arm around you. And actually, if you feel it's okay to put a hand on their hand. And a lot of patients will really appreciate that.
I think in most situations, I don't know if you would agree, actually trying to be kind of standoffish and not actually make the situation almost more... I think so. I mean, you do get, I mean, you know, we're not psychopaths. We come into medicine for good reasons. And, you know, there is that spot, you know, to put their hands on their shoulder or their hand. I mean, obviously don't jump on the trolley and give them a cuddle. But there is that thing, you know, and I've said it before, yeah, you know.
You're right to be angry. It isn't fair. It isn't fair that you've got whatever this is. And I can't promise that everything's going to be okay, but I can promise that we will look after you. And just being a human, not staring at the clock and giving them eye contact and just holding their hand like a human being would. And just being kind. There's a saying that patients won't always remember what you did or what you said, but they will always remember how you made them feel. And I think that's...
At this point, more than ever, that's a very important thing. In fact, when we do our simulations for some of the undergraduates that have been through the process, we're more and more asking our simulated patients to tell the students how they were made to feel by the students' response. Actually, that's incredibly valuable to learn from. I think that's right. The patients often will remember how they felt.
Yeah, so that means the simulation can be very useful to get feedback from, and it is that kind of, you know, not you weren't listening to me, it's I felt when you were staring at your watch, as I was telling you, that, you know, that's a silly example, but you know what I mean, you can give a concrete example there, can't you? Absolutely. So what do you think, what happens if the doctor themselves in that environment, or the students in that environment, starts to feel upset themselves? That's very, it's quite difficult. And I think as a doctor breaking bad news, you feel like you should be the patient's rock. And that actually you shouldn't get upset because that will show weakness in you. It would show that you weren't maybe in control of the situation. You should have experienced this enough times before that you shouldn't get upset at breaking bad news. And I think most of the time those things are true. We didn't get upset. But there are certain situations where I felt quite upset by a situation. And actually, I cried once whilst giving a patient news, bad news.
She told me that me acknowledging my emotional response to acknowledge hers actually helped her more than anything else. But is that the way that we would normally do it? I wouldn't recommend crying, no. Because, actually, it's very difficult if you feel so upset by breaking bad news, it's something that you do so often, you'd just be a complete wreck. Absolutely. You'd be emotionally drained at the end of every day. And it's not the doctor's responsibility to carry the emotional situation. So I think if you are feeling the situation is too much, you have to play it basically by ear, depending on what's going on.
But you can always excuse yourself and say that you're going to have a break and give the patient some time to think. You're going to go and have a break and that you'll be back to them or your colleague to continue the consultation. I've seen that in A&E where, you know, we're going to specifics, but colleagues were looking after a patient who had a specific diagnosis that hit home, you know, because of the colleagues' own family members had a similar thing. And they had to just, I really can't look after, you know, not because I don't want to, but because it will just affect me. And there's a case of, again, being collegiate again, going, fine, I'll do it. You know, I will step in and do that for you. And for colleagues around, you know, there may be an awareness that it's not appropriate for someone particularly to be breaking values.
Because they know that it will be too close to home, so obviously you don't know everything about your colleague, so sometimes these things kind of spring up, but it may be that you do know that your colleague... I have to use Officer Guiding, sorry. Go with Officer Guiding, it's absolutely fine. Your colleague is just having a miscarriage themselves, and they've only just returned to work. And so actually, you wouldn't, yes, they will have to start doing that kind of over time, but you can step in and say, actually, no, I'll take this one, knowing that it probably will be posted home. Yeah, exactly. And I think it's about fostering that environment, isn't there, within your team, that you feel that you could identify it, or at least if I wasn't noticing it, that somebody could come and talk to me and things. I mean, seniors with children say this all the time, I mean, I don't have children, but when...
in A&E when really poorly children or even sadly child deaths come in hit you so much harder when you are a parent and I can definitely personally agree that's definitely true so um you know I think it's identifying you know do you know what I'm really not in the right space for this in this moment um and you know identifying support that is out there and if you're a student who's seen something that is you know has upset you and you're taking it home with you obviously to speak to the university and then access the support that is there is a good pastoral support at the university or through you know your your clinical teachers or your consultant that's been allocated to you I think if you do see something that's really really upset you and it's really important to talk about not brought something up. One thing I will say, it was another insight from a simulated patient. It was one of the sim days when I was a student and they had an actor in being, the patient was a mannequin, but the actor was his son. And the scenario was a very difficult relative who was obstructing everything and being very, you know, the patient was clearly very ill. And, you know, at the end, I think when he was debriefing, he was being as nice as possible to prove that he was actually a nice guy because I think we'd all obviously got really annoyed with him by the end of the day. But he said, and it was something that's always stuck with me, he said,
For you guys as the doctors, this will just be, oh, you remember that relative that was difficult and while you're having a drink in the mess or something, I'll remember them. But to me, this is the day my dad died. And I think that actually, when you frame it like that, I think keep it in perspective sometimes, especially if somebody's being difficult about things or having that level of understanding and empathy as well, very important. I suppose we're getting to the end of the podcast now. I suppose it seems a bit strange. Can breaking bad news ever be positive? Can it be a positive experience, do you think?
I think we can, by everything that we've discussed during this podcast, I think you can do things to make... the experience better for the patient. Positive is a difficult word, isn't it? Depending on what bad news you're giving them, that may never be seen in a positive light. But the way that you break bad news, the way that you acknowledge the patient's emotions, the way that you deal with them and make a follow-up plan or whatever, the patients will remember that. And even if they've been given a bad diagnosis, they remember the day that they were told. And if you do it badly, then that can stick in their mind as a really bad, bad experience. Whereas actually, if it's done well, it can just be seen as,
you know, this has happened, but actually we can see the light at the end of the tunnel now rather than it being something that kind of sticks in their minds like the worst ever day. So if somebody's listening to this and thinking, well, you know, I'd like to get a bit more experience in breaking bad news, apart from, you know, your brilliant simulations and things, where else do you think students or anyone listening could get some experience? I think it really has to be, you know, the ward attachments. So in the clinical phases, you're spending a lot of time in the wards. People are probably breaking bad news to patients more than you think they are.
So spending time with the clinical team, your consultants, and watching how other people do things and gaining as much experience from that, whether or not that be taking away the negatives that you might not do again, taking away the positives that you take forward into your practice. We're not ever going to ask medical students outside of a simulated environment to break bad news. No, of course not. And so you are going to just have to kind of glean it, I suppose, from watching others. It's almost like a skill, much like every other clinical skill you...
practice it, you observe it, and you practice in a safe environment as a student, obviously. Like you said, I didn't like that bit, so I won't copy that, but that was really good when that doctor did that. So I'll take that on. And certainly I think there is a lot more simulation going on where breaking bad news kind of forms perhaps part of that simulation. And so make use of those situations, although they might be quite daunting, where you think, well, how am I going to do this? How am I going to do it? It actually is just a simulated environment. It's not going to matter if you say something wrong. You can always time out in a simulation as well, can't you? Hang on, this is going wrong. Can we just, you know? Yeah, so we do that. We do it here as well. We say, hang on a second, this is like really going down the wrong track. Everybody stop and just rewind to the beginning. Stop in. And you can do that for us in a simulated environment. And I think that's probably the best place to kind of practice. And hopefully as our medical students go through.
go through their attachments, they'll kind of spend time coming through the Nottingham Hospital, they'll be doing this a lot and hopefully get some experience. I think, I seem to always be saying this to my students, the books will get you through exams but in order to be a good doctor you have to be on the ward. this is an apprenticeship in my mind anyway I subscribe to that theory you need to be seeing this kind of stuff this isn't something you're going to learn from a book or just listening to this brilliant podcast although it will help you you do need to be seeing it and growing and things I think certain teams so I mean we recently down here in Dream when I'm not podcasting I run our academic meetings and we had the organ donation team come down and they did a session with us and they do run sessions I think students can attend I mean it's very specific but it is on things like you know approaching a family and talking about organ donations very specific as i know but i'm sure teams do run certain things like that you know training and uh and things and like you said to experience on the ward that was the take aurally breaking bad news podcast you can find us on facebook and twitter where we'll put up links to any guidelines mentioned and you can contact us to suggest topics you'd like to see covered in future episodes more information education research opportunities within emergency medicine acute medicine major trauma you can find any way stream on both facebook and twitter