Welcome to the weekly standard podcast. I'm your host, Michael Graham, with us a weekly standard to talk about President Trump's first ever budget proposal. Michael Warren, and you might have seen budget proposals in the past, although not as many as some people, because we're with the whole phase for a while there were about two budgets. Yeah, continuing resolutions and all sorts of things, right?
So your big picture for someone who is just now finding out that Trump did a budget. What do they need to know? Well, first of all, it will never become long. I mean, or it will never be enacted.
This budget, this is more of a, almost a statement on policy and how more particularly what the Trump administration would like to spend money on. And then interrupt you right there. Yes. Is that the case for all executive branch budgets?
Generally, well, sort of by definition, because Congress is who actually passes a budget and who actually writes it. I mean, there are budget committees that actually write the budget. This is essentially what the executive branch is saying. We want you, Congress, to a budget and appropriate money for.
So it really is a statement more of policy. And so for people sort of just kind of tuning in, what you see is essentially what Donald Trump promised. He would provide cuts to parts of the federal government that conservatives and sort of populist Republican, and leaning populists have wanted, cuts to the State Department and foreign aid. This is a big sort of sticking point.
And then increases to the defense budget. Not quite as big, although not quite as big as what defense hawks would like in Congress, though not as small as some of the budget hawks, including somebody like Mick Mulvaney, the OMB director for Donald Trump would have liked. So you're kind of seeing a standard issue, Republican, almost, I think, someone in the Washington Post compared to a Reagan style budget. And I guess we shouldn't be surprised.
Do you agree with folks who've said that this budget document is even more aspirational than a traditional one is? It's not as filled out detail by detail. It does even more than in the past kind of set a direction, rather than say, this is what we're spending on Thursday on Head Start. Right, no, I think that's right.
Look, this is actually sort of to fill out the rest of fiscal year 2017, this particular budget. So it's not actually really the first full budget that the president is proposing for. That would be for fiscal year 2018. But yeah, I mean, it is more aspirational.
It's more about sort of setting the course for where this administration wants to go, which, of course, is freaking out liberals, as it always does when Republican presidents are in power, you know, cuts to this, that or the other. It should also be, we should also, a word of caution. I mean, again, Congress is the one who sets this, the budget, not the president, not the executive branch, of course, will end up signing into law, those appropriations and those spending measures. But those always end up having a lot more spending than the Republican president would like and end up being usually generally an expansion of government, even when a Republican president proposes shrinking it.
I asked our friend across the aisle, Washington examiners, Tim Carney, who's one of their budget people, will the United States end up spending less money or more than the budget year this covers than the year before? More. Yeah, totally. I mean, that's just what I mean, look, I mean, the problems for spending really are two things.
One that isn't really addressed by the budget. And the other that I think Donald Trump has said he wants to do, but can't really do it through the budget, which is the first is entitlement. So that's none of this touches it. And Mick Mulvaney sort of admits that from the very beginning when he first started talking about this last week.
Entitlement spending is not discretionary. It's not discretionary. It's automatic. And that's going up.
And so that's crowding out the budget, but also it's increasing spending every single year. The other part is which I think is sort of harder to kind of put into numbers. It's more easy to sort of speak about generally, which is the administrative state, which is something that President Trump has said he wants to dismantle. That's all the bureaucracy in Washington, around the country, in the federal government.
That is where you're seeing a lot of that's another big reason why spending continues to increase, because there's never any real change to that administrative state. And it just keeps growing. It sort of perpetuates itself. And it's really hard to kill.
So those two things are really not addressed by this budget. So the question of will the government spend more money? Yes. But don't really blame this budget for that.
This budget is more about, again, policy and sort of setting the course. So now let's get to the question. Everyone's going to answer A, does it pay for the wall? And B, will we see the receipt where Mexico paid for it?
Yes, it does pay for the wall. TBD, whether we'll see that receipt from Mexico. There is a line item in this budget. It's basically through the Department of Homeland Security and part of the Department of Homeland Security's budget.
But the question of will Mexico pay for it? I mean, this is sort of one of these weird things where money is fungible when they're talking about sort of getting money from Mexico through piece of fees, exactly some kind of custom or tariff. Exactly. It was to say through trade policy.
So it's kind of a convoluted way of getting that. So are we ever going to actually get a receipt? Are we actually going to get sort of a bill of sale or some kind of note that says Mexico paid for this? No.
I mean, at the moment, and the administration has not hid this fact to their credit. The taxpayers, the American people will be paying for this wall if it ever gets built. I'm a little skeptical of that. But at least the money is sort of budgeted for in this president.
And I've always thought that the dumbest argument ever was Trump's lying about Mexico paying for the law because Mexico's not writing a check for it. Well, they were never going to write a check for it. It was always going to be you build it, and then they have to cover the cost by, say, putting a fee on cash that sent back to Mexico. Right.
But I will say, Michael, though, that I think that Trump benefited in the election from blurring that distinction and really kind of, look, I honestly do think he tried to argue that Mexico would write a check for this. And people did believe this. And I mean, we can laugh about it. It's kind of crazy.
But I think it was a big part of the selling of what sold into the American people or the certain segment of the people who voted for him. But it's just not true. And he should have said it that way. But just like the people on the left who think that what's coming out today is, in fact, the budget.
Right. And that Trump will be showing up at people's homes, taking away their milk money. Right. Exactly.
And big bird, this is the other thing. So yeah, ridiculous. I predict that government funding for the corporation for public broadcasting will be around a long time, even though no one can give you a single legitimate reason for why a single penny of public money goes to that project. Because that's just the way Washington will always be there.
Michael Warren, thanks for joining us for your time. Thanks. You've been listening to the Weekly Standard podcast, and you can find these podcasts at weeklystandard.com. It's a big podcast button right there.
I've got a better idea. And it doesn't involve sitting a check to your local public broadcasting station. Just go to iTunes and search weekly standard. The podcast pops up.
You subscribe to it. Then whenever we have a new podcast, and sometimes we sneak in a surprise, it'll pop right up in your iPhone, iPad, wherever you like. Thanks so much for subscribing. Thanks so much for subscribing.
Thanks so much for listening. I'm your host, Michael Graham.