you're listening to knowledge nation bringing you knowledge wherever you are now here's your host jess lewis Hello and welcome to Knowledge Nation. I'm your host Jess Lewis and today I'm continuing with the Breast Implant Awareness Special. A French company producing PIP implants came under fire when it emerged that they had been making breast implants with an industrial-grade silicone not suitable for medical devices in humans. It appears owner John Claude Mass was going at great lengths to cover up what he was doing or there was a few blind eyes being turned. He is currently serving a four-year prison sentence which he is now appealing through the courts. The German firm Rheinland TVV who were in charge of the product testing seemed to have avoided all responsibility for passing the implants as safe when a French court ruled that they were not to blame and compensation paid to the victims tell them explant their implants might have to be paid back. The PIP scandal has...
now expose potential dangers within medical devices but also contraceptive devices and even pacemakers. This week I'm joined by PIP Action founder Jan Spivy and PIP campaigner Tracy Armett. PIP Action is an international campaign group for justice fighting in the courts but also at the heart of the European Commission and nationally against the government and Department of Health. Both ladies have been deeply affected by the PIP implants they had put in after they started making both women extremely sick and needing further surgeries. They are now helping countless other women through their support group and also campaigning for changes. I'll be discussing all this plus how unregulated the industry is included in the UK and more. So let's welcome the ladies onto the show.
from Knowledge Knowledge Nation. Hello and welcome to Knowledge Nation, ladies. How are you both? It's great to have you on the show. Today we're going to be discussing all the latest about the PIP breast implant scandal and everything that's going on with the core cases. We're going to be talking today about the safety regulations and testing involved in implants, but also the lack of knowledge with surgeons about the dangers of breast implants, as well as the ingredients, and we'll also be addressing things like whether breastfeeding is safe. Tracey, hello and welcome. You had your implants removed and replaced as soon as you found out they were PIPs, but you had new implants that burst four times.
a lot of different operations to correct the damage. Now you're helping bring awareness and doing some amazing work with PIP. So hello and welcome, Tracy. Jan, welcome to Knowledge Nation. You're the founder of PIP and you had your implants put in after reconstructive surgery following breast cancer. Only you discovered they were making me sick. Now you are part of two legal cases currently running and ongoing with the PIP implant scandal and fighting for justice, I guess, along with many other women. So hello and welcome. Thank you. Yes, welcome. Yes, thank you. All right. So today we're going to start with you, Jan. Jan, you found out a number of years ago that you'd been given PIP implants after breast reconstructive surgery following cancer. What sort of symptoms did you have?
Well, a whole range of random symptoms. And I was looking back over some correspondence from the pain management clinic that I attended at the Royal Marsden. And they referred in several letters following visits there that I had a constellation of symptoms. And they really ranged anything from I had debilitating headaches. I lost the use of my shoulder and virtually my left arm. I kept losing sensations in my fingers. I had terrible pains in my chest and in my back. And I started to develop symptoms of autoimmune illness, including...
inflammatory arthritis, very painful joints, particularly in my hands, in small joints and in my elbows, for example, and my wrists. And I mean, the list, honestly, it felt almost endless because things like night sweats and headaches start disrupting my sleep. And then lack of sleep contributes to a tremendous amount of fatigue I constantly felt. And I had also started, I think, to feel depressed. So it was making everything, all my symptoms.
seem much much worse yeah it's horrible because you know there might be women now um with implants with a whole host of different symptoms going on and obviously the doctors aren't going to connect the dots um but actually you know what from now on if women have implants doctors should actually think could this be it um because yeah there must be so many women have all these different health complaints and they're not actually realizing it's to do with their implants yeah and uh and it's not just that the women the women i think very often realize and uh it's not just um uh an issue affecting women with pip implants but implants in general you know they've got a very long and controversial history for example in america they were banned silicone breast implants were banned for 16 years And that was because the authorities felt that there simply wasn't enough evidence that they were safe. And what started to emerge was a series of maybe studies with perhaps vested interests.
of the authors who, through a series of... If you take a series of studies and you tease out all the relevant information from those studies and then produce your own report, that's called meta-analysis. And a lot of this kind of meta-analysis takes place with regards to breast implants rather than relying on actual conducted studies. And what the authorities and the manufacturers have managed to do through meta-analysis is tease out these factors that tend to negate any claims of... links or associations with, let's say, for example, autoimmune illness. So through a series of meta-analysis in studies undertaken by researchers, perhaps with links to manufacturers, have declared that there are no links between autoimmune illness and implants, which means it becomes very difficult for women who are suddenly starting to experience lots of symptoms. They then trot along to their GP, rather than going back perhaps to the private clinic that gave them the implants, and they're presenting with symptoms that the doctors there are not linking with the implants, and the women are discouraged from pursuing that line of investigation.
So it becomes very difficult for women to actually find the answers they need regarding their health. And it's also very, very difficult for women to find out what the process is for notifying when they experience problems that they feel maybe down to their implants. It's such a scary situation. I mean, what were you taught by the company that put yours in then, Jan? Well, I was diagnosed with breast cancer. I had two small tumours, aggressive tumours in my left breast. And as part of the mastectomy and the treatment for the cancer, I was offered reconstructive surgery by the NHS. So it was, in fact, a senior breast cancer consultant who undertook hours and hours' worth of surgery on me to remove the tumours and to reconstruct my chest. And as part of that treatment, I was given, regrettably, PIP implants.
Horrible. So obviously, as soon as you found out, you wanted to get them out. So did the company, was the company like, okay, yes, I will help. I mean, because I know, I know, speaking to a lot of different girls, and by the way, outside of these interviews that I'm doing, I personally know a lot of girls that have had problems and that have had these PIPs put in, right? So I know through all of this that each company would seem to be dealing with it differently. Some of them were saying they'd take them out, some were saying they'd have to pay.
I think the critical point is this, that with PIP in particular, we understand from police reports, which we've now seen via our legal representatives in France, that the police were sent in to PIP. And after a thorough inspection by the health authorities, the police closed the factory down and arrested the directors. And that all took place in March of 2010. Regrettably, I can't think of a more appropriate word really, but it is now well known that it took the British health authorities 22 months to notify British women of the concerns regarding PIP implants. And what made things worse for these women, and for virtually all women in fact that have breast implants, was the news was only broken via the press six days before Christmas in 2011. Why did it take the British government? Why did the British government not act? I don't get it.
Yeah, we don't get it either. But we have been looking more closely at the government organization that is responsible for pharmaceuticals and medical devices. And medical devices can be breast implants, but they can also be hip prosthetics. They can be stents or pacemakers. They're any device that's surgically implanted into the body. And in the UK, we have one organization. It's called the MHRA, the Medicines and Health.
um i can't i don't know the rest of it but they're called the mhra and it's their responsibility um to monitor medicines it's um it's a very worrying area pharmaceuticals and medicines you know forward you know has a big role and they have to be monitored and they have to be checked but for some reason um in the mhra there was a department dealing with the uh with medical devices but from what we um what we can gather from subsequent government reports was nobody was actually staffing the medical devices desk and they weren't necessarily keeping an eye on what was going on in particular with regards to breast implants so when the notification was raised in France and it came in December 2011 as a result of a French woman dying because she had ruptured PIP breast implants so along with the news reports were shockingly alarmist for women imagine finding out this way i can't even imagine i mean you know what the press are like right they love to sensationalize and um you know really you really get the shock factor and so there it is you know woman sat there reading this headline for the first time finding out about this is horrendous considering our government knew about this for 22 months before yes and ladies were finding out six days before christmas that they could potentially have these time bombs
Taking time bombs. And then we were also informed that, regrettably, the health department were closing down for Christmas and there wouldn't be anybody available to take any kinds of questions or concerns from the women affected. And during that period, it was possibly, I mean, I have received a cancer diagnosis, so I know what being scared out of my wits is like. But I also knew that that's how it was affecting other women, including me, over that Christmas period. And in one way, you know, for me, with a cancer diagnosis, there's lots of help and support out there. You know, there's lots of websites, there's support for my family members, there's support for me.
you know charities and charitable organizations and volunteers and very good people there to provide help and support when you're facing something as shocking as cancer for me having to come to terms with the fact that I had PIP implants I put on a level very similar to finding out that I had cancer finding out I had PIP implants for me was about you know the same level of shock and desperation the difference being there was absolutely no help nobody to turn to nobody to talk to and being alone over the Christmas period with this idea of these terrible implants being in my body was, and not just me, for thousands of women, we were all feeling the same. So, you know, just absolutely shocking, shocking times. Tracy, thanks for staying on the line there. How did you find out about your PIPs?
You couldn't even make it up. I just can't even get my head around the fact that the UK government actually knew. And you, Jan, and you, Tracy, like, finds out this way. It's just unbelievable. So what happened to you then, Tracy? Did you go and get them checked?
scan please and they were like no no i don't need to so basically so basically you've got no compassion from the the man that put them in you whatsoever um basically as soon as you found out you didn't have any money you didn't want to know oh that actually concerns me that there's people out there surgeons like that i went to a top clinic you know so i've done my research before I wonder if the reason that, because I'm not being funny, right? Like, I know a lot of girls with breast implants, and all of them, all of them have PIPs, right? So I'm wondering, because this Jean-Claude Mass is using such cheap, and obviously industrial-grade silicone, cheaper than anyone else, he's probably getting these implants, because everyone's got them, and I just think, how has he infiltrated this much? I would like to, I would like to by my surgeon. I asked how much he'd be in £500, and when I found out how much pit cost...
Tracey's right about the clinics and the different clinic approaches and what we discovered correspondence with the Department of Health was that it was well known that there were problems with PIP implants and of all the national health trusts in the country only six of them were using them in breast reconstructive surgery and then of those six only three hospital trusts implanted 11 PIP prosthetics and the remainder were implanted by just three NHS trusts and what we know now is that there was enough information within the NHS in particular to
move from PIP as an implant and use other manufacturer implants. But what we also discovered was that three of the largest breast implant clinics and providers, one of which was Tracy's, had particular contracts of distribution with PIP. And in around 2007, the providers, the largest providers, started putting PIP under pressure to reduce the costs of the implants. And so at that point, the factory started to develop a new experimental recipe of implant gels. And once they felt satisfied with the design, these implants are now recognized as using a gel called, the authorities have referred to as PIP Gel 2.
But it was a much, much cheaper version. And this was when the price difference started to become apparent that there was an introduction of a new cocktail of silicones and it coincided with a massive drop in price, which seemed to us to have been negotiated by the clinics. And in the main clinics, this would be one of the reasons why a lot of your friends and people you know with breast implants, it was because the largest, very largest PIP provider was using PIP exclusively. but their charges weren't any lower than anybody else's, but they were making a much, much higher profit. And the roles of the clinics really do deserve to come under scrutiny because when the scandal apparently broke in the UK, don't forget this is like nearly two years after the French authorities have recalled the product, the clinics are being called in regularly to government meetings to make comments and to contribute to the understanding of PIP. And what becomes apparent is that the clinics don't want to help women. They don't feel it's their responsibility. They're not prepared to pay.
to put things right for the women and they have not been maintaining proper records on aftercare for women to report problems and they are not properly insured to offer the services that they offer. So as consumers with rights, women were prevented from having diagnostics without paying for them and the situation became impossible for women to get answers from the clinic. or to be treated unless they were paying the money, which is what Tracy herself witnessed. Tracy, so you had your PIPs taken out and the new ones put in, which burst four times. So obviously this is a different brand now.
Do you still have symptoms? Do you still have symptoms? Humans and women, and they've tested help, they know what's happening to us, and still we have no help, even though we're crying out for help. That's horrible. And the thing is, they knew for years what was going on with PIP, because they were forming the Department of Health, MHRA, for years that had been into women's breasts over the years. It's absolutely horrific. You couldn't even make it up. Do you still have problems with the... Obviously, the implants cause you health problems. Are you still suffering now, Tracy, with health symptoms? With symptoms of this? I used to think I'm going to...
So horrible. Now you're doing stuff with PRP Action, so what is it that you do there? Tracy, what's your role there?
It's good though, I wouldn't say it's a little input, I would say it's a big input because since I've started with this story about breast implants, right, I've had a few women send me some inboxes, inbox messages on Facebook and they're terrified because It's coming around to the whole self-confidence thing, isn't it? It's like they're terrified because they've got implants in, but then they're terrified to have them out and how they're going to be able to deal with that. So I think you do that role is so important. The thing is, models and things like that, we're insecure about our bodies and that's why we've got implants in the first place. So we're already insecure as women. So to then tell us, I'm going to take your implants out, I'm going to cut away a lot of your own breast tissue, your skin's going to be so strep, that's how I'm going to leave you. Women are panicking, you know? Somebody's women, they've been going around for years with...
if they know when they're really, really sick. So it's just like... Horrible. But this is the thing, that's why it's important that, you know, it's amazing that Jan has set this up and that she has such a great team and I think it's great that she's got you on the team because, you know, you've been there, you know what it's like and you've had them taken out. You know, you can't provide that support because you hit the nail on the head, darling, because...
You know what it is? Years ago, I can't remember how many years ago, maybe in like sort of 2008 or 2009, I tied with the idea of getting implants. I tied with the idea of getting implants for many years. I mean, I'm talking years and years before this. But I took, I was seriously considering it at this one point. And I was living with a girl that had multiple breast surgeries, right? They were up. She used to get me as bigger, smaller, bigger, smaller. I don't know why surgeons were still operating on it, but they were, right? Anyway, so I went for a consultation. She took me for a consultation. And this surgeon was like,
these are the breast implants and he gave me like two different ones to have a feel of and then I said to him I was like what are the what are the risks and he was like oh nothing you get a lifetime guarantee like these you won't have to change them so basically I was like oh so you don't have to change them every 10 years and he was like no um you get life like the last year for life basically and then they're totally fine there definitely would have been PIPs because I know girls that went to that same surgeon who got PIPs so like it's just it's crazy think to that you know something was always exactly this is it right something in the back of my head just always prevented me from actually genuinely going through with it um but it all boils down to self-confidence in the fact that I there was a part of myself that I didn't like and that I felt um didn't look nice and it'd given me um self-confidence issues in that department um I never ever liked my boobs and and I would say I felt like that from when they developed until maybe like three years ago do you know what I mean but the one thing that actually did stop me was the fact that I didn't want them it wasn't that I wanted them bigger
I wasn't happy with the shape. I didn't feel confident about the shape. So I wanted to change the shape, but then I was scared of just enhancing what I already had, which I didn't like. So because of that, I thought, well, it's a big risk. It's a surgery, you know, for it might enhance what I've got. And I'm still left with the confidence issues. So I think, do you know what it is? I think women should really ask themselves, why do they want to get implants? Like, why is it that you want to get implants? If it's a self-confidence issue, like, just work on your self-confidence. Definitely. My friends lack on the grief of my mum.
I think the market for cosmetic surgery is very big and it's very powerful and it knows how to...
connect with women's concerns. So whereas you might have been less open to the issue of slightly increased... breast implants for a lot of women the reassurance is that it's a one-time surgery that the implants last a lifetime that it's perfectly safe and they're going to be instant results and you can trust me because i'm a doctor um it all plays into insecurities of the women but also they um they started getting quite um the clinics were getting quite um sophisticated with their marketing techniques and they started introducing uh special um deals that if you signed your contract for um for your surgery within a certain timeframe, then you could expect to have discounts. There were Groupon coupons that you could reduce the cost. You could get two for the price of one. So take your mum or your sister or a friend along and both get surgeries. And not only was the market growing from women wanting to do, you know, just undergoing a little bit of surgery to feel a little bit better, it was also growing from the perspective of surgeons who were now, rather than speaking to the patients themselves, were employing people to work in the clinics to provide the sales gloss.
over the issue of breast implants. So instead of consultations being more a question of where are you going to place my implants, it became a, you know, put this implant in one hand, weigh it up against the size of another, have a look on this 3D computer screen to see what you're going to look like with these slightly enhanced breast shapes. And everybody was paying in too. an entirely unregulated system. So the treatments weren't being treated professionally. So the surgeons weren't necessarily coming from a properly qualified background. Women were being forced to undertake their own research.
face it you know we're faced with a fraud that's been going on under the noses of the regulators for 10 years what is it that the industry expects women to find out when they do their googling research on the risks or the surgeon or the clinic responsible for their for their surgery it's very difficult but what it does do is it provides another opportunity and this is very clear in the cosmetic surgery industry in general is that it's very easy to undermine the women and to take on a little bit of victim blaming so even now we hear it with other women going along and having a different brand of implant for example and then in comments will say you know it's great look at me i feel wonderful they're delighted with their implants and their comments are you know i did my research i found this great clinic i found this great doctor and that's why i haven't fallen into the same situation as a lot of those women with pip the other issue with that with victim blaming um runs to the price of the implants too because um the implication is that these women sought out clinics that were offering cheaper surgeries or um a cheaper deal and again these women were undermined wherein in fact many of the women um did a lot of research they did check whether or not their surgeons were on certain registers and and they didn't rush into their decisions but when you realize that it's a very it's a fast-growing industry it's heavily under regulated
You can be a veterinary surgeon, train as a veterinary surgeon, and then do cosmetic surgery on the weekends. Or you can fly in from Romania and provide treatment for 30, 40, 50 women in an afternoon and fly back. Or women were being encouraged to look at packages overseas. And all of these things were additional pressures on women, but also providing women with solutions to what they saw might be their personal issues. But where the problems start to occur is exactly at that moment, when the problems start to occur.
you know, the most immediate issues maybe for women are infected. incision wounds or infected wounds there are maybe 25 things on a list of risks that are directly related to the surgery that you're undertaking and then after that there are all sorts of implications and risk complications that are associated with having those implants and one of the most one of the highest one of the most important factors here really is that when things start to go wrong those same clinics have no interest in or no responsibility for a duty of care and that's exactly what we saw when the when the PIP scandal was exposed.
I'm going to come back to this a bit later on in the interview, actually. I want to go right into detail with this. So hold that thoughtful later on. Right. What I want to know is, right, do implants have to rupture to begin to cause health problems, Jan? No.
No, regrettably. In particular, we know very well that the implants don't have to rupture to start leaking. And that's because it's not just the gels that are non-compliant. The manufacturing techniques are unknown too. And there are lots of opportunities in the manufacturing process to cut corners. And that's what we know the...
That's what we know PIP did. So, for example, I sent my implants for analysis once they were removed. And under a microscope, the University of Milan researcher looking into the implants for me could confirm that in my case, I didn't have an anti-bleed barrier on the implant. kind of what it is it stops the uh the silicone leaking out from through the shell and um they're usually the implants are usually dipped through a curing process and uh to create a shell that keeps the gels inside and prevents the gels from leaking but in my case um in order to cut corners presumably um pip hadn't put the uh the anti-bleed barrier on my implant was that yours specifically was this a mistake with your implants or was this the general No, it's just that I've got the clear evidence that my implants didn't have to, my left implant didn't have to rupture for the silicones to be leaking through what appeared to be an intact shell. That's horrible. Tracy, did you find the same? Day one, day one, they were leaking into our bodies. So, yeah, I had a few obliques, so it was just leaking straight forward into my body. Horrible. How long did it take you to feel symptoms, by the way, then, if it was leaking straight away? Can you recall symptoms quite early on or was it somewhat later on? No, I had symptoms massaging them.
to cancer so I then went to my doctor or surgeon said I said well they said it was okay but I'm one he said well if he said that they're okay they should be okay and medical notes as well you know that that's what happened and then until it got very very ill and she was very very ill and when we was even having to do with the implant so I carried on being real the alert come out I've been so ill all these years where it's just getting worse
horrific, absolutely horrific. So the man at the centre of all this is Jean-Claude Mass. It was his company that were buying this industrial-grade silicone. This is not suitable to be used as a breast implant. In fact, it's not suitable to be near a human body at all. And he's basically, he was given a four-year prison sentence, and now he's appealing. I think he's got a plummet cheek. So what's the latest with that? Well, the appeal started on Monday of this week, and...
If it wasn't so serious, I think, and if it hadn't affected so many women in such a devastating way, I think... Well, I mean, it's almost laughable. Four years for impacting on the lives of 500,000 women and their families. The four years is almost an insult. We think there are clearly tactics that Jean-Claude is using in court. And one of them is his age. He keeps referring to himself as an old man. And he's also implied that he's relying on just his state pension as a form of income. So his arguments actually in court for the last couple of days, we've been watching very closely. French victims are there at the trial.
And he's made a couple of statements already implying that he thinks that the gels are perfect. And he's continuing on this line that there's no evidence to suggest that there's any dangers associated with the implants at all. And I find myself getting really very cross that the courts haven't actually brought in any real experts and that we're still giving this man space and time to talk utter nonsense, which is really what it is. In addition to some of the observations made by the women in the court, there were five defendants in the appeal, and Jean-Claude Mass has been given the biggest sentence of, like I say, four years. When the police originally detained him in 2010, he again claimed he didn't have any money, and he didn't have enough money to pay his bail. So he did serve, I think, around nine months in a prison cell, but his lawyer, who's the French equivalent of O.J. Simpson's lawyer, managed to...
persuade the authorities that the old man shouldn't be locked up, and he was released on a tag. And the appeal, the actual court case, the criminal case against Jean-Claude Maas, was concluded, I think, around May of 2013. So it's taken him virtually two years of living a life on a tag before he's come back into the courts and he's making his appeal. I did read a press comment yesterday from a French journalist who's in the court. It seems that he's managed to spend a few holidays in Costa Rica since he's been free on the tag from prisons.
So again, it's just all very concerning, the seriousness with which the authorities seem to be attaching to this particular case. Yet, in real terms, it is a very significant matter, and not just because of the impact on women with breast implants, but because of the implications for members of the public relying on medical devices. Because really this is what the VIP scandal has exposed, is that the manufacturers are running the show, and the show is a three-ring circus. And experts really don't play a large role in this. And the victims are not taken seriously or treated with any kind of compassion. So it's like women suddenly become an easy target. Tracy, what lengths did Jean-Claude Moss go to to hide what he was doing? I mean, obviously he was getting this dodgy silicone for cheap. But I understand there was some sort of cover-up going on. I don't think he was hiding anything. He was built by a gypsy. And when Jan went to his market, it was being closed down. I'm going to talk to you about the photographs. And there were lions and lions all up in it.
How were things monitored in the UK, Jan? Well, up until 2005, 2006, we used to have a breast implant registry so that every surgery that took place was registered along with the manufacturer, make, size, the reason for having the implants. And at the time the news broke, one of the reasons that women weren't contacted was because nobody was keeping a record. And the question was, what happened to the breast implant registry? And it turns out that for some reason, it was just ditched.
as a concept in 2006. And when we pressed for answers, when we pressed the Department of Health and the MHRA for answers about the registry, which we felt was very important. One, we felt that it would be a way of keeping an eye on the performance of the implants. And we can see actually that was taking place with the previous registry. But then we discovered that the reasons that the Department of Health were giving for closing the registry was the women.
weren't taking part. And again, this is consistent with the victim blaming that we found in the government and in the Department of Health for dealing with these things. So in a series of government reports and industry reports now, it's very clear that in the event of a scandal such as PIP, you need to be monitoring the devices, but you need also to be able to contact the women involved. And it's been recommended now by Sir Bruce Keogh, by Lord Howe, who is responsible for a report on the MHRA. The recommendations from the...
cosmetic surgery industry are all that the registry needs to be reintroduced so that they can monitor the performance of the of the implants and keep a register of the women and to date we still have nothing that resembles a registry in the UK and that again for us is unacceptable it's one of the first lessons that should have been learned and after a fair amount of pressing we did get the MHRA and the Department of Health to release the minutes of the meetings and that took place to close the breast implant register and the myth that they were promoting that women themselves were responsible for the closure we found to be an utter nonsense again so we have been pressing you know quite urgently for the government to introduce the registry the problems the government says because they don't have any money especially for women with breast implants so there's a commitment to dragging dragging feet and it's not considered a priority and it's not considered a health matter and we obviously disagree with all of those issues and we continue to press yeah absolutely because it is a health issue because it's
affecting people's health so it has to be a health issue it can't be anything else absolutely who puts the ce mark on these implants i mean what does that even mean if these implants were passed to put in people's bodies anyway there's um there's a series of directives and regulations which is supposed to um police the system for uh for medical devices which is what breast implants are it's what all surgically implanted devices are referred to and in theory the the regulations mean that the um the product should be effectively safe to be used um And what we've discovered, in fact, the CE mark, which applies to lots of things, you know, it applies to electrical products to make sure that they're safe. It applies to toys. It applies to lots and lots of things with their own set of strict regulations. But it turns out that rather than being a license, a certificate of safety that we can rely on, it turns out it's just a passport for trade.
within Europe. And that was the rather regrettable thing about PIP. In 2000, the American Food and Drug Administration, who also have responsibilities for medical devices, came to France to check the PIP plant and on finding an unacceptable number of major non-conformities, refused to license PIP at all anywhere in America. And immediate advice was given to prevent any of the products being imported into the USA. So in a similar move to thalidomide, in fact, the FDA again had highlighted the problem.
with uh with thalidomide and they again refused to license it in america so america didn't suffer in the same way as the rest of europe with thalidomide and it didn't suffer women didn't suffer in the same way as a consequence of pip breast implants but there were you know some of the the red lights and the warning signals that should have been going off in the minds of the regulators in the uh in the in europe and they should have been saying to themselves hang on what is it that the fda have seen on visiting this plant that's not obvious to us and then of course it it highlights it exposes the responsibilities of the companies that have duties to license the different manufactured products. And in the case of PIP, which were manufactured in France, the regulator for the CE mark is TUV Rhineland, who are a German company. And rather interestingly, there's an unusual relationship that goes on between the regulator and the manufacturers, which is the...
regulators help the manufacturers obtain the certificate and then the manufacturers pay the regulator for the certificate. And we suspect because that relationship depends on the payments from the manufacturer to the regulator, we feel that that gets in the way of them being entirely... independent and transparent about the way that they're dealing with the products looking for trade licensing in europe but as a consequence of tuv um rhineland providing the ce certificate that gave pip an opportunity to sell and promote the product worldwide so apart from america where it was bad where they were banned um the markets have begun to open up in central and south america enormous market in Europe, the UK being the biggest with 47,000. But typically in France, there are 33,000 women that have been affected. There are massive numbers of women, I think over 40,000 in Venezuela that are affected, thousands in Australia. And all of these women have limited access to help or compensation or any kind of support in having these implants removed because the manufacturer now is not in place and nobody wants to take responsibility. The German product testing firm, Raylan T-UV.
this was the company that was put in place to test this product right now there was a lot of women that were hoping to get compensation from them and some women have had payouts and what I can't understand is how the French courts have now ruled and I guess both of you ladies can comment on this we'll start with you first Tracy but the compensation that they've paid out they've said that there might be a chance that the ladies are going to have to pay this back because they've been found that they're not at fault Yeah, so the case that women brought from overseas, actually, against TUV Rhineland, the regulator, we won, and it had been taken to a magistrate's court, and the magistrate's there.
recognised that many of us from the UK and from places like Colombia were having difficulties in raising the money to have our PIP implants removed. So their order in the decision made by the court was to make sure that women had the finances to pay to get the implants removed. And that's what the majority of women did with that initial payment. TUV, we're unhappy about paying that initial. compensation and made an appeal again at the French court that the appeal court found in the women's favour and it was a historic legal case in fact because generally speaking parties aren't expected to make any settlements until the whole court process has come to an end but in a historic decision the French appeal court judges felt that it was absolutely right and proper that these women should have an opportunity to get these and they're known to be toxic in France to get the toxic PIP implants immediately out of their bodies. Regrettably
at the appeal that TUV Rhineland have made, the appeal court has found in their favour. We don't really understand that because we feel that there's very strong evidence that there was a level of negligence involved in the actions of TUV. But there is a cloud of secrecy around the activities of companies like TUV. And rather interestingly... There are similarities with the VW emissions scam. Again, another TUV regulator. But the issues are really whether or not there is an implied accountability in the roles of the regulators. And at this point, it's all being...
played out in the courts. And even though the decision in the appeal court was not specifically, yes, you can go and chase down these women to repay the money that they've used to replace their implants, I think TUV, which is a large, it's a multinational German company, I think it has put a tremendous amount of pressure on the women that received that payment, the worry about having to pay it back. But it also had an impact on women coming forward who were making the same claims against TUV and hoping for the same preliminary damages in order to remove the PRP implants. What confuses and shocks me, right, is the fact that the UK government have said that these implants aren't dangerous, when there's so many cases of women which clearly show that they are. But, like, how can they say they're not dangerous when we're talking about industrial grade silicone that hasn't been tested on humans? How can they even say that it's not dangerous? Well, I just got a personal opinion on this, but we have discovered that the UK government's principal toxicologist is the former head of research at Syngenta, which is, I think, the largest agrochemical and pesticide company in Europe.
And he's the government toxicologist. And we suspect that he finds it difficult to find anything toxic. But we also know that... There are a lot of conflicts of interest and there's lots of heavy industry lobbying on the issue of toxic chemicals and chemical regulation. And it applies to PIP very specifically because it transpires that we have, in the tests that have been undertaken, it turns out that there are massive concentrations of certain compounds which are well known to be reprotoxic. And that's a particular type of toxicity that means that if a woman is exposed to these chemicals whilst pregnant, there will be...
They're measured, the chemical reactions are measured in parts per million. But in recent times, science has recognized that a delivery of chemicals to a developing fetus doesn't have to take place at parts per million, but can be particularly relevant at parts per trillion. and very much dependent on the moment in time that that delivery of those toxic substances have been made. So, for example, looking back over the thalidomide issues, the health and researchers, medical scientists now know that if a mother was exposed to thalidomide on, say, day 15 of her pregnancy, then certain consequences.
began to manifest. So, you know, if the children had very small arms, the mother could have been exposed on day 14. If there was brain damage, it would have been an exposure on a certain day. So what we're now aware of is the importance of exposures to developing foetus and also the timing of the exposure. And what we've learned about these particular chemicals that are in large concentrations in PIP are that they are also found in personal care products. And personal care products are things like shampoos and conditioners and deodorants.
And the chemical companies have been actively using these chemicals. But what we're finding is that they accumulate. So in a... day women in particular can be exposed to quite high levels of these toxins through several different products. The problem is that for women with PIP they've already got these massive amounts of exposure and then of course we've got the other issue which is the majority of women that are affected are of reproductive age and many of the women are mothers and we feel that this is another reason why our concerns should be taken seriously.
So yeah, let's talk about the fertility issue because one of the chemicals in the implants, day four, has been linked to reduced fertility. So not only is it causing problems for the fetus if you get pregnant, but there's actually infertility issues going on aside from that. Yes, we were very concerned about the issues about breastfeeding and pregnancy with PIP. And one thing became very obvious, you know, if you're pregnant, you cannot undergo surgery. So as a consequence, you know, it was a bit of torture for those women who found out they had PIP and they were pregnant, knowing that they were going to have to go through the pregnancy with the implants ruptured or not, but still in their bodies.
But we were also concerned about this migration of chemicals into breast milk and migrating into the placenta. And the MHRA confirmed that they had done some testing and that the testing had produced results that meant that there was really nothing to worry about. We were fortunate enough to have some... scientific backup and we asked to review the documents and the testing undertaken by the MHRA and once those documents were released we were able to see that they had conducted an experiment on a single sample of breast milk from a breastfeeding mother with ruptured PIP and they had compared it with semi-skimmed supermarket milk and based on the fact that there was a certain level of silicone in the milk from the supermarket container they deduced that there was no risk to children of pregnant mothers.
In our group, because there are a number of women that have been pregnant with PIP, ruptured PIP, and there were still mothers breastfeeding, we asked for volunteers for women to come forward to provide small samples that could be tested by the MHRA so that we weren't relying on, let's call it crap science, just because I can't think of anything else to call it. But we then got in contact with the MHRA and we offered them the volunteers and samples and they sent us a polite letter back rejecting our request. So, regrettably... There's a scientific committee that was set up in the European Union also to monitor and to review the issue of PIP implants. And rather than conduct any particular research or gather any information from the women affected or from doctors or surgeons or paediatricians treating them, they've just decided to go along with the British position and have regurgitated exactly the same results from exactly the same experiment that was conducted by the MHRA.
So it is an area. We did ask UNICEF to provide some help and support for us because we know, you know, women instinctively know that it's not a good thing to have these implants in their bodies ruptured, leaking these chemicals. They know it's not good. And, of course, women wanted answers. And it's another very clear...
example of how desperately let down we've been by a government who doesn't take our concerns or us seriously. You know, at the end of the day, I think having been involved in this campaign now for as long as I have, I do feel that there's a tremendous amount of discrimination against the women that have decided to have breast implants. And yeah, it's worse than regrettable. You know, it's a disgrace. It must be quite hard to move forward with this because of the discrimination involved, Jan.
It's extremely difficult, and it's extremely difficult to deal with an MHRA that has the power and influence to put a single experiment down as factual scientific evidence. And it's very difficult to hold them to account. But we are trying, and most recently we've been to the EU Ombudsman to review the handling. But what we start to realise is the chemical regulation is big. It turns out the medical devices overlap in some way with the new trade-specific partnerships, so that's an area that's...
being dealt with by them too. We've noticed that the medical devices industry isn't keen on stricter regulation and there's always a rather unfortunate argument which is that and the government rely on quite a lot because it is a growing sector. industry sector is that um to make it more palatable what they're doing to to the public is um is telling people that um we have to fast track um new medical devices into the market because it brings hope to suffering patients and it means they don't have to wait for treatments and what it actually is is a way of sidetracking any safety checks any um real analysis of these products um before they're put onto the market and before they're surgically implanted into people's bodies okay so implants ingredients wise it's a some horrific ingredients in aside from silicone because I was always under the impression right that if you've got a silicone implant it contained silicone and nothing else but when the Darren Corning case happened obviously they had a it all come out basically about the contents of their implants there was some neurotoxins in there and some carcinogens which obviously cause cancer how do we know the implants of today don't contain similar ingredients because there seems to be a huge problem in getting access to this information
Yeah, all of what you said is correct. In America, when thousands of women were initiating legal cases against Dow Corning, it became obvious that Dow Corning were deceitful about what they knew were the consequences for women being exposed to chemicals. Interestingly... The main concern chemicals were D4. And at that point, D4 was being used as a catalyst in silicone manufacture. But there were also a number of other, like you say, carcinogens, but also neurotoxins. And the way that the industry has worked around this is that they work with secrecy. It's called commercial sensitivity. And it means that they don't have to make public.
the contents or the ingredients that are used in medical devices. And they've gone one step further. Because a lot of the products that I was talking to you about earlier that contain D4, for an example, it's just an example chemical. Because the chemicals are found in things like shampoo, the product manufacturers have been very keen to get them into supermarket contexts. And in order to do that, they should be properly labelled. So just as our food is labelled, so these products should be labelled. But what the industry has managed to do is negotiate labelling exemptions for all their products that contain these particular chemicals.
consumer you are not seeing exactly the contents of your deodorants or your shampoos because you've found your product in a supermarket and it means that we can't make informed choices nor do we know the levels to which we're being exposed to these chemicals and these are all kept secret you know just like mcdonald's special sauce you know the way that they're manufacturing and it is it's um i think it's a deceitful practice And I think it prevents, it's prevented the authorities finding out about, you know, PIP. And it's also a cloak that protects the other implant manufacturers. And yeah, these things we feel really need to change. I think what the PIP scandal, if you want to call it, has done is actually highlighted a big failure and a lack of regulation with medical devices. I mean, there's a lot of clinics failing to report things as well, isn't there?
Rather shockingly, in Holland, where they obviously know a number of Dutch women have also been affected by this, but in a test undertaken by Dutch media, you know those bags, those orange mesh bags that you find you can buy tangerines in? They scammed the regulator saying that this was a new surgical mesh item that they wished to bring quickly into the market to help with urine prolapses and so on in women. And the scandal was that they did receive approval to put a... langerine bag onto the market to be made available to be surgically implanted into women. That is the state of the medical devices regulation. But as I say, it is a big industry and there's this myth creating machine that medical devices is an important area of innovation and health protection and so on. And these things shouldn't be hindered by red tape. And this is what we're seeing. PIP, metal on metal hips. That was another scandal.
Eshore or Eshore, which are contraceptive devices, which like surgical mesh are being implanted into women's bodies, breaking up and embedding themselves into other organs and being impossible to remove. And the industry is standing by and really doesn't want to, feels that the costs of proper testing. are prohibitive and that the urgency really must come with bringing these potentially life-saving products to the market. But the more investigation you do into the regulation of medical devices, you'll see that it really is the Wild West out there. And that's why the women who are involved in the PIP campaign are doing a really very important job for the rest of the public. Because we have been affected, we can see how others have been affected. And we know now that the MHRA has to do more than it's currently doing and that it's a very important public service that it's undertaking and it shouldn't be manned.
simply by people from pharmaceutical companies or with alternative agendas. The priorities for these organisations always has to be public health and patient priority and putting the patient first. And it's clear that as the NHS is broken up and health is devolved in so many ways, that these things really are very important. And it's important that people that are affected, particularly like women with PIP, that we have to keep fighting and we have to keep questioning. the organisations that have got responsibilities for caring and protecting for our health. Yeah, absolutely. Tracey, what would you say the true financial costs of implants are? If someone's considering it, right? Because your surgeon doesn't say to you, oh, but you might need them replaced. So what is the true financial cost of this, if it doesn't go wrong? For a pit lady, or for just an old implant? Both. When they're increasing the price for all the tissues to clean you out, you'll find that people will be in charge more to remove my pits.
some women that would have half 6,000 pounds to get on top. But then even if they don't go wrong though, there's still a huge cost that people don't nearly realise because even if the implants don't burst, you still can't have them in your body for life, like they're telling people. So there's going to have to be more costs for it for every time you need to change them, right? Yeah. Women are not told that though, are they?
Yeah, exactly. Exactly. So this is what needs to happen. I mean, it seems to be that this industry is so unregulated that people can just say what they want and tell women that are maybe a little bit vulnerable, what they want to hear, and all the problems are going to disappear and they're going to be really happy with the new groups and there's going to be no risks involved. Something needs to change. Something needs to change. Something has to change. But where do we start here?
Like, how can we? If the government's saying, you know, that PIP, the contents of a PIP isn't dangerous, it's fine. Like, what chance do we have? Like, where do we even start? If we had a little book club place, who's going to get out there? The only way people are getting out there is women like myself and teaching them to love themselves and not to have infants. You know, they're dangerous. Absolutely. And it's not just the industry that needs regulating, it's the manufacturers, because let's not forget that...
PIP implied people in charge of quality control of implants. One of them had a cooking diploma. He only had a cooking diploma. And the other one in charge of the lab had previously trained as a pastry chef. I mean, what on earth? Well, let's just go to the show. You don't be allowed to do it. There's no regulations at all, is there? No, it's not. Because they know if anything goes wrong, what's the repercussions for surgeons or anything? If you sue them, they close down and they reopen in another name. And we all had insurance when they put the implants in us.
not only insurance companies and clinics are paying out. So it's like we're banging our head against a big wall and no one's helping. And because no one's helping, it goes down the line of everybody not helping when they're supposed to help. Insurance people are supposed to pay out, you know. Is there any petitions? Has anyone ever done a petition to take to the government? You know, because if they have a petition with over 100,000 signatures, they have to discuss it in Parliament. Yeah, sorry to interrupt. No, go on, John.
We did deliver a petition to 10 Downing Street and we have set up a petition to the Director General of the World Health Organization because PIP was identified as a health scandal and yet it becomes a very political issue and it also becomes very easy to... sidetrack. Anytime we've tried to engage the government in discussions over PIP or any other implants, we frequently see the following day a newspaper headline, say a tabloid headline, referring to the National Hooter Service and how the NHS have provided wannabe...
actresses and celebrities have been getting help from the NHS to have breast augmentation of oversized implants. And what that seems to do is to galvanise public anger towards women and towards women that are having to turn to the NHS because the clinics don't want to take responsibilities. And it just makes it very easy for women to be treated by the public in a way that appears to me at least to be manipulated by the government. You know, it's very hard. I think, for us to get, especially in terms of austerity, our concerns, our health issues, onto the table because of this stigma that's attached to women with breast implants. And it's all worked to the great convenience of the government. So basically, it's a bit of a tricky situation that you're in at the moment. Are there any measures in place to prevent this from happening again, this another PIP scandal? Tracy, do you know? Yeah, of course. Yeah, so it's nothing to happen again. It seems like I'm working on time and time again.
I think it's important to recognise too, especially with regards to things like the... of the chemicals in the implant is we don't really know where women are going to be down the line. And Tracy was explaining to you about her lumps. They're silicone-saturated lymph nodes. And lots of women that have had PIP have been affected in this way. And in my case, I'd had my lymph nodes removed through my cancer surgery. And so whilst I haven't got an accumulation of silicone in my armpits or in my neck, I started to develop lumps all over my body and my elbow and my knees. And the hospital made it very clear that they don't...
These same sorts of lumps can appear in any of the organs. And like Tracy was saying, when you get a lump, especially if those lumps are in your breast, then these are things that we're encouraged to take seriously, go down and see the doctors. But as women are presenting themselves, and they mentioned they have PIP implants, they're expected to go home and live with these lumps, even though nobody knows what it's going to mean for us further down the line. So the campaign objectives for us seem to be fairly clear. One, the regulations are not in place that are needed. There has been a scandal surrounding another brand of implant, which has been recalled. And regrettably, some women...
who had their PIP implants removed, have had the second blood of implants as replacements. So I think it really is time that the regulations are introduced. We can see that there are enormous industry lobbies preventing those regulations being implemented. And we know that not only ourselves, but our children, that all the children that have been PIP exposed and the women need to be monitored. We know that we need a registry and that's for all women with breast implants. And it needs to include all the women that had PIP.
At this point, the government is only proposing a registry that starts from the day that they introduce it, which means 47,000 women affected by PIP are not going to be monitored or registered. So we need proper regulation. We need regulatory changes. For example, a 16-year-old girl, for example, could go to a clinic and receive a breast augmentation surgery, and that clinic doesn't have to have insurance or may not be employing properly insured or qualified surgeons. There is just so many areas that need to be addressed, but for women particularly that have been exposed to PIP.
It is not too late to give them help and support. Many of them still need it. And we need ongoing monitoring. And we also need, this has been a tremendous financial cost for women. And like you say, they were all persuaded that it was a one-off cost. The implants were going to last a lifetime and their happiness was virtually guaranteed. And what the clinics don't tell you is the minute something goes wrong.
You are going to have to pay for it. So the real cost of implants, if you were to have a medical grade implant, for example, may be, you know, £10,000 every 7 to 10 years. So if you have them for, you know, 30 years. There's your £30,000 if everything goes right. And the biggest complication associated with all kinds of breast implant surgery are unhappy results. And what unhappy results mean are you've got one implant somewhere around your neck and the other somewhere around your waist or underneath your arm. Unhappy results are very significant because for insecure women about the shape and their feelings about their bodies, finding out after spending their £5,000 to £10,000 that...
they're unhappy with the results and that they're going to have to pay an enormous amount of money to correct it is a really shocking state of affairs. The other very worrying aspect to all of this is that when the, let's call it the fake science committee of the European Commission, concluded that there was nothing to worry about with PIP, they weren't toxic, they weren't carcinogenic, there was really no evidence to support that they in fact needed to be removed at all. Just goes to show. that uh you know issues of non-compliance need to be addressed you know if something doesn't meet with the regulations it should not be whatever you subsequent there is no process or should be no process to retrospectively provide a certificate of safety for a product those implants have to come out of the body and and i think the um So the costs involved, the health implications, the monitoring, the regulations, all of these things, the safety record for all of these things need to be reviewed. And I'm pretty confident that when we start having the transparency we need, the independence we need, and the standards of science and research that we need for these implants, then I'm pretty certain that either there will be a ban on implanting silicone implants into people's bodies for whatever reason. It may be limited to allow people undergoing certain kinds of reconstructive surgery.
But I think that that's really where we're headed. I think when the truth does eventually emerge, what we will find out is that there is no safety data. And that doesn't mean it hasn't been collected. It means that the data has been collected and there is no evidence of safety. Not this constant, again, another myth by the industry. The use of there is no evidence to suggest harm is not true. It's the way it's being used.
the understanding of what evidence there is and what there isn't. It's actually really worrying because in no other industry, in no other industry, can you spend a massive amount of money like this, be unhappy with the goods in a big way, and then have to front out more cash to correct the problem. If you go to a restaurant and you have a meal and you don't like it, you won't pay for that meal. Right. It is true. Women have been denied their...
Human rights, human rights to dignity, access to treatment, access to monitoring, care for their children. But also, you know, they have rights as consumers, which have been trampled on. And we also have rights as victims of a terrible crime, a shocking crime. You know, every single one, I can guarantee you this, every single woman that has been affected directly by PIP, members of her family, her children and her partners, will all have been traumatised by the consequences of PIP. And don't forget, we're starting from a point that these are women, very often, who are insecure and...
in this particular case, the majority of women now that are left dealing with problems are women that really cannot afford to be forced back into a private, unregulated market for more of the same all over again. How has this whole thing affected you, would you say? I think that's the only way. Yeah, absolutely. It's so good that you've created this PIP Action Group, Jan. It sounds to me like it's actually really genuinely needed badly because it sounds to me like you ladies have literally just been left in the lurch to deal with this with no one really helping you, except you lawyers.
If there's anyone listening that has PIPs in or has been affected by PIPs, they might want to check out what PIP Action is. So can you just tell us, Jan, what PIP Action is about, what the mission is and things? Well, we're a campaigning group. And like Tracy says, we see that there's a need for support for the women that are affected. So there's a lot of support from women that really understand what you might be going through and the horrors. It's also a minefield, you know, with...
knowing about the symptoms and when to approach doctors and hospitals. And really the mental approach to having implants removed is quite important as well. You know, there needs to be support for whatever decisions women take once they've discovered that they've got PIP because we believe very firmly that the implants have got to come out. That's always a start point. And we also know that there's a lot of information that's been held back from us. So information, informing women and providing accurate and correct information is really important as well because there's a lot of disinformation and misinformation.
out there and we've determined that the women and PIP exposed children need to be monitored. We would like to see more testing and we would also like to see the implementation of the regulations and the changes where necessary. The UK set up a cosmetic review in 2013 and the editors and the magazine Cosmopolitan became involved and after a lot of work had been put into make proposals and recommendations for the cosmetic surgery industry in the UK, Cosmopolitan magazine came out and started a campaign to make women aware of the safety implications of implants and also the other issues, you know, which women are encountering because it's not just breast augmentation that are affected by the cosmetic surgery regulations, the fillers and the Botox and so on are also implicated. So what we're concerned with is providing women help and support for dealing with PIP. We're concerned with future health monitoring and access to treatment for women.
and that women are properly compensated for the injuries and the harm that they've suffered. You know, marriages break up. It's difficult when, like Tracy says, when you're constantly ill to hold down a job. You know, when you're struggling with fatigue a lot of the time, it's very difficult to deal with family obligations and responsibilities. And a lot of women are severely out of pocket and finding it difficult to manage. So we need to, in Europe, we need a Europe-wide system to support all consumers when a consumer issue that affects, you know, large numbers.
of people in each country and not having, on top of everything else, to suddenly find lawyers, suddenly looking at facing court issues and having these things drag out for years and years and years. So, yeah, we're very clear that the women are the focus of our concern and proper regulation of breast implants are a concern and the future health and monitoring of the women are our campaign concern. And then, as part of those processes, bringing all those with who we feel strongly and have evidence of. holding them accountable. So we absolutely want to see Jean-Claude Nass being held to account. We don't feel that four years for impacting in such a devastating way on so many hundreds of thousands of women's lives is right. We think that TUV Rhineland, who are issuing license to trade or certificates of health and safety, need to be held to account. And we also need to see, in the UK very specifically, the cosmetic surgery industry.
brought to, you know, straightened out. And we also need to look at the role of the MHRA in protecting the public when it comes to medical devices and pharmaceuticals. And all of these things need to happen. But it all starts off with an attitude that changes towards women. You know, it needs to provide dignity for women and compassion for women and understanding rather than, you know, levels of victim blaming, abandonment and stigmatising and judging women.
for decisions that are very private and are there for them to make for themselves. They're not inviting anybody else or their comments. So it really is about respect for women and women inside that when they are made aware of the dangers, the risks. the difficulties that they may experience, for example, breastfeeding their children. Women will be making more informed decisions. And, you know, you can't doubt, you know, the integrity of mothers and the determination of mothers to make sure that, you know, they maintain a healthy pregnancy. And all of these things now, including, you know, chemicals in cosmetics and in personal care products and how we're being exposed to them and how our children are being exposed to them has got to be a priority for all of us. Yes, absolutely. I agree. Tracy, what would you say to someone who was considering having implants?
What advice would you give them? Knowing what you know. Knowing what I know. And go on. And you can't trust them. So we get implants. I'm not surprised. Because it can change. It can change your life forever. You know. Your career.
What about you, Jan? What advice would you give to someone considering breast implants? Well, for me, I suppose I think about the women that are facing breast cancer surgery and I'd be encouraged to think about a reconstructive procedure following that. And I feel a lot like Tracy. If I knew then what I know now, it wouldn't have been an option for me.
And I wouldn't have taken it up. So I feel that once, you know, most intelligent women will recognize once the information is available to them that this is not, you know, it's not a healthy decision. It's not a healthy decision. But I also feel... because I didn't choose to have breast implant surgery. It was offered to me as part of my treatment for breast cancer. And so I didn't get lots of information about breast implants in general. It was just more focused on life after cancer and after all the surgeries and so on. But I would definitely say to those women that are looking at reconstructive surgery after breast cancer that in my case, and I feel for most of those patients, it would be a mistake. And I think it complicates recovery.
And, you know, for me, my last surgery was in February of this year when my PIP contaminated capsules were removed. I had them removed and then I suffered a massive internal bleed. So I had to go for a second emergency surgery. I needed full blood transfusions and then I had a pulmonary embolism. So like Tracy, you know, I've had a couple of scrapes with my life over PIP implants. You know, I think it's really a bad decision and please don't do it. And if I have to get down on my hands and knees, you know, please don't do it.
it's it's just heartbreaking like just thinking about how many people this is actually affected and is affecting now um i know since i started working on this like what the information i've been putting out has probably scared a couple of people because now considering whether their implants are deadly yeah i think that's an important thing just if um if one of the messages that we send out um through the broadcast is that um It's a really important thing to check your serial numbers. If you have breast implants, then you will have been given some paperwork at the time of your surgery. If you can't find your paperwork, then get in contact with your clinic. But start becoming a little bit more aware of what brand implants you have. Rule out the possibility that you might have PIP. And also be aware that there's now a new medical entity that's been identified since the PIP scandal. And it's a medical condition which is referred to now as Breast Implant Associated, ALCL. And it stands for Allopathic Large Cell Lymphoma.
Most of the figures up until 2010 were being collected in the United States where proper monitoring was going on of medical devices. And they identified just a very small number of women that had been affected. But their data was limited because they had this 16-year period where women were not being, were not offered silicone breast implants as an option. So they were completely banned. So there's a gaping hole in the research of the FDA. But what's becoming more obvious now is that when the PIP alert was sounded, the first French woman had died.
with BIA-ALCL, this breast implant associated ALCL. And since the time of the first report, the numbers have increased substantially of reports of women that now have this form of ALCL. It is treatable. It's a form of blood cancer. and it is treatable but it has to be identified and that's important so if women they obviously if they find lumps or if they have any concerns over the shape of their implants if their implants appear to have deflated if there are any changes at all it's really important to go and get those changes sorted out and um and from that it's also important to understand that one of the risks can be this very um very serious cancer can be treated but if left untreated for long periods then it is potentially fatal and so the real risks of breast implants now we're starting to ask more questions and women are becoming more aware and um and they know they have to approach the doctors if they're having problems, then hopefully we'll start seeing more women seeking treatment, getting treatment, and really rethinking the whole breast implant strategy. Tracy, what advice would you have for someone with implants? See if someone's freaking out right now. What advice would you have?
That would be what I'd like. I wouldn't ignore it because I just do get more sick and out. Listen, ladies, it's been an amazing show. We are out of time, unfortunately. Thank you so much for coming on. If anybody wants to get in contact with you, how can they do it, Jan? Well, we're well represented on social networks. So we are on Twitter and we are on Facebook. PIP Action Campaign. You'll find us there on Facebook. But we also have a sister campaign called Pips Leak, which is our equivalent of Wikipedia with the real ugly truth about PIP implants. And we maintain several blogs. So Pips Leak at Blogspot.
dot co dot uk and our own website pip dot no beg your pardon um pip action campaign or one word at um oh hang on get into that time a day isn't it dot o-r-g i've got a massive baby brain for what is it sorry it's a pipactioncampaign.org fantastic and tracy if somebody wanted to get in touch with you um how can they do that uh the best thing for me on there are not messages when the women have got time to think on their own That's the time when women are at their most down point.
actually reach me on my own Facebook page as well if they need to talk. That's lovely. Thank you so much, ladies. It's been amazing, fantastic information and I just hope that, you know, if someone's considering it, they really do think twice. I mean, I know it's up to an individual, but just, I mean, the information that I've found out from working on this interview is really shocking to the core. So if we can just stop one person from potentially killing themselves, then that'll make me happy, man. Yeah, and also, you know, your baby is about to be bald if it's a little girl. I mean, my daughter as well, the next generation, hopefully they'll be much more wiser and have the knowledge that we do.
And thank you, Jeff, for making awareness and doing an article on PIP. We need all the help. No worries. Well, I wish you ladies all the very best of luck for the future and any campaigns that you want me to push out, just let me know. All right, take care now. See you and the babies. Bye. Thank you. Thanks to both the ladies, Jan and Tracy, for coming on the show and speaking about this. I wish them both the best of luck in moving forward with their mission. It's completely shocked me to the core what I've found out personally by researching for the breast implant awareness special that I've just done. I just can't believe what's going on is being allowed. There's absolutely zero regulations in place and it really needs to change.
Well, we are out of time, but don't forget you can join us next week at 9am and 9pm, repeated Sundays at 4am and 4pm, and Tuesdays at 6am and 6pm. You can listen to this show again on iTunes really soon, plus many of the past shows just visit Knowledge Nation Radio on iTunes and subscribe so you can be up to date with the new shows that are added. In the meantime, you can connect to me at jess.ukhealthradio.com or over at Twitter at gathering underscore minds or on Facebook at facebook.com forward slash gathering of minds. Until next week, take care.