Skip to content
Breech Labour episode artwork

Apr 27, 2017 17 min

Breech Labour

from Take Aurally Hosted by Take Aurally

Dr Jamie Thomas (@mcdreeamie) and Dr Anna Richmond discuss Breech Labour. You can find Take Aurally on both Facebook and Twitter where we will put up links to any guidelines mentioned.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Breech Labour

0:00 17:04
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So downloading and welcome to Take Orally, the podcast from Dream, Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham. In this episode, we'll be discussing breach delivery. However, all guidelines mentioned will be correct at the time of recording. Any guidelines mentioned are correct for Nottingham University Hospitals, NHS Trust. Other trust guidelines may vary. All views and opinions, other speakers own. Hi everyone, it's Jamie, one of the teaching fellows in emergency medicine. And Anna, one of the teaching fellows in obstetrics and gynaecology. So in this podcast, we're going to be talking about breach at term management. I think we already mentioned that when we started in this podcast, that obstinate terms mean different things for different specialties.

A breach presentation for A&E would be somebody saying longer than four hours, with the management getting very unhappy. We're not talking about that, though, are we? No. What does breach mean to you as an obstetrician? So breach to me means that the buttocks, or the bottom of the foetus, basically, is presenting first to the maternal pelvis. So we'd call that a breach presentation. And what does term mean when it comes to a breach presentation? So the definition of term is more than 37 weeks. Probably with respect to breach, you'd start to kind of...

worry about it anything more than 36 weeks um at that stage you start offering some of the management options that we're talking about prior to that um well the more pre-term somebody is the more likely breach presentation is and so you wouldn't worry about it so much if it was like less than 36 weeks so 36 weeks the point of making a decision yeah and the point of offering the um some of the things that we can do to try and change the breech presentation. How is it diagnosed? So mainly on abdominal palpation a lot of these women will just be having routine midwifery led care and at 36 weeks or thereabouts she'd have a routine appointment in the community and on palpation the midwife may suspect that the baby is breech. The mother may kind of say that she feels all of her kicks at the lower part of her abdomen so that may kind of give you a bit of a clue but that kind of palpation of the abdomen will highlight that perhaps there's a problem but then the actual diagnosis would be made by way of an ultrasound scan just to confirm that it is breech presentation.

Are there any causes that we know of for breach? So there are some causes. I've already said the more preterm somebody is, then more likely the baby will be breached. So if someone's going into preterm labour, then it's more likely to be breached than if they go into labour at term for that reason. There could be some things like the placenta is abnormally sighted. So it could just be the placenta is sighted in the uterus in such a position that is not otherwise an issue, but for some reason it's stopping the head coming into the pelvis properly. Or it could be a placenta previa, so the placenta is in the lower part of the uterus covering the cervix, and that obviously stops the head fitting in the pelvis nicely.

There are other causes that the uterus of the woman is an abnormal shape, so that can be a varying degree, like a heart shape or right through to actually a woman having two uteruses. We're getting a very strange look now from Jamie. There's varying degrees in between, basically, of abnormally shaped uterus, uteri, which would mean that the baby doesn't fit properly in that normal shape, and therefore the head doesn't fit in the pelvis properly, and you're more likely to get a breech presentation. But most of the time, we don't really know. There's no absolute cause that can be identified. It's just by chance. But only about 3% to 5% of babies will be breech at term. So it's not desperately common.

And so when we've identified it, what are the management options open to? So there's three things that we'll generally discuss with the woman. The first one is an external covalic version, or an ECV. The second is an elective caesarean section. And the third is a vaginal breach delivery. And generally, in that order, unless the woman has a particular preference that she just wants one of those things straight away.

So what is an ECV then? What takes place? So with an ECV, we are basically externally trying to put pressure on the baby from outside the uterus to encourage the baby to do a forwards or backwards roll. It sounds probably worse than it is actually, so it shouldn't be painful to the mother. If it starts to be really painful during that process, then actually we should stop and say that that's not been successful. Otherwise, yeah, so gentle manipulation on the tummy. We get the breech out of the pelvis and then pressure around.

basically to encourage the baby to turn so the head ends up at the bottom in the maternal pelvis. Beetle gymnastics. Yeah. Benefits to that, I'm guessing, non-surgical? Yeah, so non-surgical, should not be painful, as I said, might be slightly uncomfortable, day case procedure, well, not even a surgery, but it's done as a day, they don't have to stay overnight, is what I mean by that. And if it's successful, then it allows them to have, hopefully, a straightforward vaginal delivery. Yeah. Any risks? The main risk is that of failure, so the success rate is about 50%.

But it depends on various factors like the size of the mother, the size of the baby, how much fluid is around the baby. So like factors that you wouldn't necessarily be able to alter. Yeah, that's the main thing, that it doesn't work. They need to be counselled that there's a 50-50 chance it won't work. Some people, some people do it, some consultants or operators, their success rates will be slightly higher, but overall 50-50. Are there any contraindications where we just can't do ECB? Yeah, so coming back to just actually one of the risks, and that's the main risk, one of the other risks which is possible is that we cause some kind of fetal distress during the procedure, so we have to monitor the baby continuously with the scan.

making sure that we do a CTG, so the monitoring of the fetal heart before and after. It's very unlikely, but it's possible that you then need to do an emergency cesarean section for that reason. Also possible to cause bleeding or cause a placental abruption from the pressure on the abdomen. Again, not very likely to be the case, but might need an emergency cesarean section. Coming on to the contraindications, because of the risk of an abruption, one of the absolute contraindications is if the patient's had some bleeding in the last seven days, then you absolutely wouldn't do an ECV in that case.

Other things are if the patient has another reason why they need a cesarean section, so they've got placenta previa, for example, and you're already going to do a cesarean section, there's absolutely no reason to try and turn the baby. If someone's had a cesarean section before, it's not an absolute contraindication, but maybe a relative one, that there's already a scar on the uterus, so it's just kind of with caution in discussion with the mother. It's like the strength of the uterus basically there. Yeah, so not an absolute, but a relative contraindication. So say you try DCV, it doesn't work, or say your mother in front of you says, you know, I want an elective cesarean then. What are the benefits of doing an elective C-section? So the benefit, if you're only doing a cesarean because the baby is breech, is that you avoid her having a vaginal breech delivery, which will come to kind of some of the risks of that basically in a while. That's really the only benefit.

You're affording her. So the main things with the elective cesarean section, we're talking about the risks, and they're your standard surgical risks, so bleeding, infection, DVT, PE, damage to other structures, bladder, bowel, ureters, and thinking about the long-term consequences in terms of needing repeat elective cesareans potentially in the future, increasing the risk of bleeding, the more cesarean sections that you have, and the potential of there being problems with the placenta being implanted in the wrong part or being adherent abnormally to the scar, again, the more cesareans you have. Risk to the baby, really that of small chance of a fetal laceration, potentially bleeding problems as well. Breathing problems, not bleeding. The baby's not bleeding. Breathing problems in the baby is possible. Okay. Is there a point of a number of C-sections after which you can't have a nautodrival where you can only keep having C-sections? So if you've had two or more caesareans, we'd recommend you at that point to have repeat caesareans. Saying that, I have known women have normal births having had two caesareans in the past. So it's not that it's abnormal. Sorry, it's not that it's impossible. It's just...

the risk of there being a problem with the scar in labour is higher the more caesareans that you have. So when should this elective cesarean take place then? So if it's just a breach and no other reason, then not before 39 weeks. That's because the risk of there being breathing problems in the baby, so the transient tachypnea of the newborn, or TTN, is higher if there's an elective cesarean section before 39 weeks. So if there's no other indication, wait until 39. So about 36 weeks, we've identified the breach, we'd say three weeks' time after 39 weeks, this would be the point we'd be looking in for an elective cesarean section.

Okay. So now on to vaginal breech births. What are the risk factors there? Well, the risk, sorry, of a vaginal breech birth. So the main ones we worry about are the fact that it's not a normal delivery, and there are sometimes things that can happen that mean that you need a skilled member of staff to be able to manage that delivery. And unfortunately, as more and more women now have their breech babies by cesarean...

There's a de-skilling, basically, of the workforce. People are not as good at managing complications associated with breach as perhaps they were 30 years ago. And so women need to understand that there might not be someone there who has all the skills. A vaginal breach birth has kind of become an emergency. It's not really an emergency. It's just that in order to practice the skills that you might need to manage some of those complications, it's done in skills drill sessions that we do with the midwives. But it's not a common occurrence that we see.

these things um there is a risk of uh cord prolapse because if you're when the breach is basically kind of coming down it's not completely a perfect circle plugging the hole and so the cord could slip down and obviously that would become an emergency because the cord is prolapsed and the last thing that could happen that's actually pretty uncommon but we do worry about is head entrapment um the head of the baby is the largest part and in a normal vaginal birth that head would have time to kind of mold and squeeze and fit through the pelvis in a vaginal breech birth that's not the case because the head is the last part of the baby to be delivered. And so you worry that either because the pelvis is inadequate or because, in fact, more commonly the cervix is not completely dilated, the head is entrapped. At that point, if the rest of the baby is delivered, there's a significant risk of hypoxic injury to the baby.

I'm guessing so then if it's a vaginal breech birth, won't be midwife led, there'll be doctors present. Yeah, so if it was known about, it's obviously sometimes it's not diagnosed until right towards the end of labour and you realise that there's a hair buttock sitting there. And then obviously... That doesn't look like a head. Yeah, exactly. But yeah, so you wouldn't recommend this woman to be delivering at home. You'd recommend a hospital delivery where there is staff around that could help if there is complications. To be honest, most of the time, if there's a vaginal breech delivery, they have no complications at all. Our motto is hands off the breech.

So actually, unless there is a problem, you don't do anything. You sit on your hands and allow the baby to basically come down and be born normally. And most babies will actually, you know, it's quite interesting to watch actually, the arms and legs kind of pop out and they manoeuvre themselves and they actually do kind of work themselves out. And the best thing to do in that case is to absolutely do nothing at all. The more you put your hands on the breech, the more it encourages the baby arms to go up in the air and the head to extend and all of those things are likely to, you know, going to cause more problems than good. So most of the time.

Actually, they deliver without any problems, I should add that. If the mother's had a previous vaginal breach and has proven her pelvis, is that reassuring? Yeah, I think so. And even if it's not been a previous vaginal breach delivery, but if it's been any kind of previous vaginal delivery, and then that mother tells you that actually she'd rather have a vaginal breach delivery than a cesarean, then you'd feel more encouraged by that woman because she's already had vaginal births before than perhaps if it was her first time, where we just don't know. Are there any contraindications to vaginal breach?

Really, there's another reason for a caesarean section anyway, which we've already touched upon. So she already needs a caesarean because she's had three caesareans in the past, or she's got percent of previa or something like that. Or it's really a maternal wish, actually. So if the mother doesn't want a virginal breach birth, then that's the biggest contraindication. In your own sort of practice and things, which do women tend to go for?

I think generally we would recommend an ECV first. Just go in that order. In the order we've discussed. Because actually that's not that risky and if it doesn't work we can just go on to the other options anyway so you haven't really lost anything. And then probably elective cesarean, more women are going to go for that than vaginal birth. Because when we're counselling people about the potential risks, obviously women who are having their babies they don't really want to take any kind of potential risks most of the time and so they'll go for that elective cesarean section.

But who knows, I think practice maybe will change over time. We might see actually more women having vaginal breach deliveries, and actually as that happens, more people will obviously become skilled in some of the complications, and so maybe it will become more common. I think it might just be worthwhile adding before we finish why it is like this. Why do we deliver all babies who are breached by cesarean if they can be born normally? And it's all on the back, really, of a trial that happened called the term breach trial, where they found that the early neonatal outcomes were worse in the vaginal breach.

group than the cesarean group so things like so mortality rate and also kind of admission to neonatal units and hypoxic injury was higher in that group but when they did a long-term follow-up between those two groups there was no difference between the vaginal birth group and the cesarean group so that initial kind of immediate neonatal period the outcomes are worse long-term doesn't make any difference And I suppose if you're going for the vaginal breach, because the mother wants vaginal breach, but things aren't progressing as well, you can still go for emergency C-section. Absolutely. The same as you would do, even if the baby was presenting catholic. There's always an option, yeah. What's the Breach Delivery Take Orly podcast? You can find us on both Facebook and Twitter, where we'll put up links to any guidelines mentioned. You can contact us to suggest what you'd like to be covered in future episodes. For more information on education and research opportunities within emergency medicine, acute medicine and major trauma, you can find A New Age Dream on both Facebook and Twitter.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Take Aurally?

This episode is 17 minutes long.

When was this Take Aurally episode published?

This episode was published on April 27, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Take Aurally episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.