Brigitte’s Blow-Up Scenario
from Random Acts of Urbanism Hosted by Brigitte Pellerin
The real campaign starts now. Evan lays out the four scenarios that could each explain how this election ends (fragmentation, sleepwalking, consolidation, and the Lawson shock) and reaches an uncomfortable conclusion: of the four candidates, the one with the lowest probability of winning is Jeff Leiper, because everybody else has already won something. I counter with my blow-up scenario, the one nobody’s talking about because it hasn’t happened yet: tens of thousands of public servants, students, and commuters all converging downtown after Labour Day on a transit system that isn’t ready. Plus two genuinely good policy releases from the challengers, a debate format nobody liked, and the metric that actually matters: 1,150 volunteers and $200,000 are inputs, not conversions. Neil Saravanamutto’s fourth housing option is here. Alex Lawson’s jobs and growth plan is here. The transcript of the episode is below: Brigitte Pellerin (00:01): Hi everyone, hi Evan — how are you? Evan Potter (00:04): Greetings. It’s the end of August. We’re on the way to Labour Day. Brigitte Pellerin (00:07): And it’s the beginning of the real campaign. We have a lot to get to today, so let’s bust right into it. You have a couple of distinct theories about what may happen. Now, we still don’t have the August Liaison poll — unless you’ve seen it. So we’re still running with numbers from several weeks ago. But things are moving, things are happening. And you sent me these four distinct scenarios. How about you run through them, and then I’ll tell you what my blow-up scenario might be. Evan Potter (00:41): So it’s month number four of a long campaign, and there are a number of narratives, or theories of the election. But the first big theory you and I have to discuss is whether this is really a change election. If you look at what we see at the ward level, it can’t be considered one — because twenty-one out of the twenty-two councillors seeking re-election will likely get re-elected. The only question mark is around Allan Hubley, and even he might get re-elected. And we have two open races: Kitchissippi, where Joanne Chianello will almost certainly be elected, and Stittsville. Brigitte Pellerin (01:31): Where there are nine people or so. That one’s wide open. Evan Potter (01:31): So based on the ward level, this is not a change election. We can only consider it one under a single real condition: if there’s a change in mayor. We think Mark Sutcliffe is ahead. We don’t know if he’s ahead by six points, eight points, ten points — we won’t know until we see David Valentin’s public poll, and to my knowledge those numbers haven’t been released yet. Brigitte Pellerin (02:04): No, I haven’t seen them either. I’m really curious. Evan Potter (02:19): So: at the big-picture level, not a change election at the ward level; maybe a change election at the mayoral level. Now let’s look at the four scenarios — the four theories of the case that I see having emerged over the last four months. First: the fragmentation scenario. The entry of Neil Saravanamuttoo into the race fragmented the centre-left coalition that we assume Jeff Leiper was hoping to lead — combined with the fact that Leiper, based on everyone I’ve been talking to, is seen as underwhelming. And as I’ve said before, expectations were much higher for Jeff Leiper than for Alex Lawson or Neil Saravanamuttoo. That’s fair — it’s always relative to your opponents. But the feeling, even within the progressive community, is that Jeff has been underwhelming. They expected more. That’s scenario number one. (03:32) Second: what I’d call sleepwalking to Mark Sutcliffe’s second term. Brigitte Pellerin (03:40): Gross. That’s not a good thing. Evan Potter (03:57): It’s related to fragmentation, but a little different. This is where the centre-left voices in Ottawa don’t row in the same direction — they’re not mobilizing, not coordinating. It’s the collective action problem. Classic. We saw it on Lansdowne 2.0. Jeff Leiper goes one way, Neil Saravanamuttoo goes another, and then other advocacy groups — maybe Horizon — go still another way. Nobody’s rowing in the same direction, and that leaves the lane open for Mark Sutcliffe to get his second term. (04:36) Third: the consolidation scenario. This is where strategic voting comes in — and this goes to the open meeting I attended last night. The theory is that the Leiper ground campaign is so powerful that it has accumulated tens of thousands of votes that aren’t being picked up in the polling. They’re not showing up. But his ground game is so well organized, with infrastructure across all twenty-four wards, that at some point in late September people begin to realize the implications of scenario number one — the fragmentation thesis — and they consolidate around Jeff Leiper. They migrate away from Neil Saravanamuttoo to Jeff Leiper, and Leiper becomes mayor. (05:43) And fourth: the shock scenario — the Lawson shock. Here the theory is that Alex Lawson’s surge, which was noted in July, is not a figment of anybody’s imagination. It’s not a mirage. It’s real, and it gains force throughout September, to the point where Valentin’s September poll has him in the high twenties, closing in on thirty, even before October. In this thesis, Alex Lawson supplants Jeff Leiper and becomes the mayor’s main opponent going into the last three weeks of the race — and perhaps beats the mayor at the end of it. So those are the four theories I’ve seen emerging. And I think we should state quite honestly that Neil Saravanamuttoo and Alex Lawson have already won by losing. They’ve made their case. They’ve got their name recognition. They’ve won. Brigitte Pellerin (06:59): They’ve made their case. People know who they are, and they’re set up for any other election. Evan Potter (07:09): Even if Neil takes ten percent, he’s won. Alex takes twenty-five percent, he’s won. It’s huge. And the mayor wins if he runs a conventional front-runner campaign and gets thirty-five percent. So, sadly for those supporting Jeff Leiper — the person with the least winning probability in this election is Jeff Leiper. It puts a lot of pressure on his campaign. And for those supporting him, they have to hope his infrastructure on the ground is as solid as his campaign manager Stephen Yardy says it is. Brigitte Pellerin (08:04): And thank you — I like this more academic way of looking at things, analyzing it, putting it in little boxes. Evan Potter (08:10): And Brigitte, the dominant narrative is of course scenarios one and two. Brigitte Pellerin (08:22): Well, I was about to say: it looks to me like the Sutcliffe campaign is reading things the way you are. Because the mayor is running what I think is the world’s most boring political campaign. Not doing much of anything. It’s not exciting. There are no balloons, there’s nothing. There’s really nothing going on. Evan Potter (08:35): Because he doesn’t need to. If his internal polling is showing him eight to ten points ahead of his nearest competitor, he just continues to do what he does. He doesn’t have to show up at any community mayoral events. Doesn’t have to do anything. Brigitte Pellerin (08:57): That’s right. Let me talk about my blow-up scenario. My blow-up scenario — and it’s the subject of my next Ottawa Citizen column — is the return to office, and the mess a lot of people are expecting. I don’t know who you hang out with in this city when you go out for drinks with friends, but in my circles there are a lot of people in the federal public service. And whenever you mention return to office, people go — (09:27) All right, let’s thrash this out. And I’m going to say up front that this is a problem that disproportionately affects women. Because — I know it’s a gendered thing to say, but it’s still the reality for a lot of families — the mom is still taking care of more of the administrative things at home. Guys aren’t quite caught up yet, though they’re trying. Anyway, it does affect women more than men. And they’re not t… Get full access to Random Acts of Urbanism by Brigitte Pellerin at randomactsofurbanism.substack.com/subscribe
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.