And what I think is one of the most important facets of constructing urban living shorelines is this ability for them to serve as educational and stewardship tools to connect people with the water in places where a lot of times people have been told to largely be afraid of the water. Hey, podcast listeners. We're about to listen to an interview that Tony did with an expert in living shorelines. But before we did that, I wanted to look at some comments and read them from listeners who've been reaching out to us. I'll start off with an email discussion I had with...
Julie Dunlap, about the title to our episode, quote, Science vs. the Cat Hoarders, unquote. We had too long in exchange to relate here, but the concern was that the title, quote, gives away the position of the podcast host before evidence is presented about the role of cats in wildlife destruction, unquote, and sets science up as a biased position to start with. Julie also recommended we discuss challenges harmonizing multiple uses in public green spaces with conservation goals. In particular, mountain biking in nature reserves and that sort of thing. This is a hot topic in Philadelphia parks and, frankly, a bit of a trigger for Tony and me. So perhaps we will tackle that in the future. Thanks, Julie, for writing us. We also got a great email from Susan Grimbley suggesting we do an episode about urban robins. That sounds neat. And I'll chip in the idea that it would be fun to do one both about American urban robins and European urban robins, two bird species not related to each other at all, but both comfortable living around humans and adapting to cities.
Last, I will mention a note from listener John Paul Peter from Kentucky, who says he particularly likes episodes about outdoor cats and pointed out that many of the cats people tried to adopt from maintained stray populations end up having cat illnesses. In particular, he mentioned feline leukemia or FIV, and ultimately these cats have to be put down. And so these outdoor populations serve as reservoirs for those illnesses. John asked if we've done any episodes about urban bats. We did do one about bat rescue, but I do think, now that he mentions it, that we are overdue for an actual episode about urban bat natural history or ecology. If a listener out there is an urban bat researcher, please drop us a note at urbanwildlifecast.gmail.com. We'd love to get you on the podcast. Thanks again for everybody for writing, and let's get on with the episode.
i'll tell you what hi welcome to this might be the erva wildlife podcast this might be nature's hype man but regardless it's part of the wildlife observer network and i'm here with an old friend of mine uh josh moody is that how you like to be called or is it joshua yeah josh moody uh sometimes people they get professional they use their full name yeah yeah um i don't know what that's relaxed that way i was just laughing because i had to check my phone had to stop the recording briefly because i decided to make banana bread and and josh will laugh because um we've been having some trouble mostly on my all entirely my end about scheduling this because i'm bad at uh remember remembering, I have ADD and I have sometimes bad remembering appointments and especially bad when I don't, when it's such a weird time in society right now where I don't necessarily know what day of the week it is. We had a holiday, so I'm like, Tuesday is...
you know, like I would have worked a full day and then there'd be the next day. And then it was like, no, we'll have off on Monday. And it's, but it's weird to be off because I'm home anyway. So it's strange. And then like, I thought, I thought we were doing this yesterday, but it's today. And then of course, another example of my holiday gets to me, I'm like, oh, I'm going to make banana bread. And I'm like, yeah, I have plenty of time to make it, but I don't have, I had to take it out of the oven, you know, in 55 minutes. So I just had to confirm with the missus that she was getting the banana bread out. Well, if it's a little well done, you can always put a little ice cream on it to help. Yes. And we got them last night, you know, we did the backup plan. Yeah. Have you been doing the Amazon?
um the the prime now from whole foods no it'll make you never want to go to the grocery store again like i go to the grocery store now and i want to i am livid i'm so angry i'm like so frustrated it's just it's so nice to just type what you want in you can really manage your budget yeah the price in the cart and then yeah like there's a little bit of charge but honestly what you save a waste of food makes up for it. But we're here to talk about living shorelines, right? So you're like a pioneer punk rocker in getting academic. I think you were like, at least of our crew, of our generation. So I know Josh from the punk scene. And I think he was like one of the first to actually like go back to school and get academic. You got a PhD, am I correct? Yeah, I got my bachelor's in biology from Temple. I got a master's in ecology from Rutgers. And then my PhD is from Drexel in environmental science.
that is awesome um and you started back you weren't like you you took a little break between like like you didn't you went a little bit later right you weren't oh yeah i took uh i call it my 20 semesters off i went back to school at 28 i started actually ccp and then transferred over to temple from there i did the exact exact same thing um but like in my 30s you know yeah yeah i was close 28 i think that was uh in um uh let's see 22 about 2007 or i'm sorry like 2004 2003 nice i called it my um 14 year rock and roll vacation but it's cool yeah yeah and exhausting vacation though it is it is it's funny when you realize you know you're so against like going like living a normal life the idea of like a 40 hour week um and when the weekends off it's like frightening when you're like a 19 year old punk rocker yeah but then after like you know work in security um until three in the morning and then like you know maybe like having to go right from that to a demo job because you got to make money when the opportunities come to make money you got to do it and you're like you know getting your you know blowing your knee out as a black messenger you're like
Huh. But you know what? I think that that sort of coming from the punk scene really puts you in a good frame of mind for doing environmental work. Because when you think about it, environmental work, there's nothing for certain. There's no replicates. Things are always changing. You constantly have to adapt and deal with situations as they arise. And you've got to think out of the box constantly.
if you're not used to security and things being neat and organized, this, this kind of work won't give you a heart attack right away. Yeah. Amen. And I've told a story before, but my first field gig, I went up to New York city to interview with Robert Rockwell, who we've actually had on this podcast already about working at snow geese up in the Arctic. And he, I was doing this interview with him and he only asked me a little bit about birds. He started asking me more questions about like what I would do for snow, you know, if it's fought, we're working in densest polar bear population in the world.
and there's fog you can't go outside because you can't see the white the giant white predators gonna eat you right and so like what are you gonna do for fogged in for four days like do you like to cook do you play cards and i'm like he wants to know if i can get along if he can get along with me and i said you know what i'm in a band i tour the world i'm stuck in a van with four other guys I know how to get along with people. I'm like, I'm what you call a road dog. And he goes, road dog. I like that. Let's do it. And he took me up there. So it's funny that you bring up the van because when we interview people and we're hiring people, you know, but there's some people that I work with that really focus on the resumes, but the interview for me is the biggest thing. And anyone that I work with who listens to this, I call it, it's the get in the van test. Yeah. Because if you can't sit in a room and get along and engage, and you're not gonna be able to sit in a van with them for like five hours round trip, going to field sites, it may not be a good fit. And so that personality alignment I find is key to having a really good creative.
team for sure and i think yeah it's the total get in the van and you know being what i do um i get asked to go to um schools um for the career days and talk to kids about like do a career mentoring and one thing i always bring up is like because i don't think i see the other people go ahead of me and i'm like they're not saying the thing that they should there's something missed here and that is like you got to present yourself as somebody people can get along with And you got to present yourself like you're interested in the job that you're doing now. Because I feel like so many kids are like, they present themselves like, this is just a way station to get somewhere else. And no one's going to want to hire you for that. No one's going to want to hire you if you don't seem like you're a fun, nice person to get along with.
Yeah, I don't know. It's I think maybe we lucked out and coming from the background we came from, we were so being letting our regular personality come through was so ingrained with us. We didn't really have an option on how necessarily we're going to present ourselves. It was going to kind of come through anyway. So we might have ended up in good positions because we connected with people just naturally the way that we've always connected with people. But I sometimes feel bad for younger people coming up and they're trying to figure out, you know, you know, who should I be in this interview? Who do they want to see? Or, you know, or, you know, what do I want to project?
You know, at least I know when I interview people, I at least try to create an environment where we can sort of, you know, break down the walls a little bit and they end up getting comfortable and just, you can start to see that, you know, but they relax into it. And I find a lot of the times when you work with people, because most of the people I work with are a lot younger than me that, you know, and actually my boss and my mentor, Daniel Krieger's like that too. She just set such a good tone and people became so relaxed that, you know, you could really just get a feel for who each other were. And, you know, once people get comfortable in a situation, I think they really do the best and the things they're most interested in as well. Yeah. Well, speaking of things they're most interested in,
So we're talking about living shorelines and we'll probably go from there, but let's start with that and tell us about your organization and what your main focus is and how it fits into everything. Sure. Well, so I'm the restoration programs manager at Partnership for the Delaware Estuary. And Partnership for the Delaware Estuary is one of the 28 national estuary programs around the country. So we're the estuary program for the Delaware River and Bay. And what that really means is it's the tidal portion that goes from saltwater up to freshwater and the land that drains into that area.
You know, because we're an estuary program, we get a little bit of our funding through the EPA's Clean Water Act. And so we're a clean water organization. All the work that we do in some way relates back to clean water, healthy habitats, strong communities, that kind of thing. And so when I was at Rutgers University, I was working at a shellfish lab there. And the science director of partnership for the Delaware Estuary was interested in bringing this technique called living shorelines, which had been more commonly used down south in the U.S., up into this area.
Now, I was working at a shellfish lab, and my advisor, Danielle, or now my director, Danielle, she's a shellfish ecologist by training as well. And the thoughts that her and Dave Bush, the director of the Haskin Lab, had was, well, for living shorelines, what we really want to do is figure out a way that we can use the local ecology in this area to take some of the applications of living shorelines that have been used and sort of make them our own here. Now, previously, living shorelines, especially down in Maryland and Virginia, was really a particular thing. It was almost like a rock sill along the road and shoreline with a lot of wetland vegetation planted on top of it. So it almost become living shorelines synonymous with a technique, if you will. Now, the idea here, by bringing it up here, is we wanted to see how many different ways we could think about living shorelines. Is it really just a singular technique or is it something a little bit more?
So really the test that we started out with in around 2008 in the Delaware Bay was really looking at the relationship between rib mussels and saltmarsh coregrass, spartanol alterniflora. It's typically a monoculture along most salt marshes. It grows up to the high marsh, a little bit taller down where it's flooded more frequently. And so rib mussels and this grass have a really synergistic relationship. The grass provides a place for the mussels to burrow down in. The mussels being a filter feeder, they pull a lot of nutrients out. Some they keep to build tissue, some they deposit in the ground, which becomes fertilizer for the plant. So you get this kind of positive feedback.
The bigger the plant gets, the more mussels can kind of gather around attached to it. And then the more they fertilize, the bigger the plants get. And as the mussels, using these protein complexes called vessel threads, which are extremely strong, bind to the roots of those plants, they can help to hold shoreline edges together. So the idea was to take this natural sort of mutualistic relationship and use that as the foundation, as the living point to help, you know, curb some of the erosion in the living shoreline application. So, you know, we've worked on that with Rutgers University for a number of years. We have a number of different living shorelines out there.
And what I think we really served as the organization that I work for, a partnership for the Delaware Estuary, sort of like a testing lab. You know, we get these ideas, these research questions. We go out and we try to implement them, learn from them, and pass them on. And now this particular technique of living shoreline has been used by a few different organizations in Delaware and New Jersey. But we typically, we use these in lower energy areas. And, you know, not all areas are the same. As we start to move into these urban areas, these highly energetic areas, big ships are going by. But there's a whole ecology around them. You know, not a single technique is going to work everywhere in every location. So what is our opportunities for living shoreline applications across a variety of diverse habitats, right? And so whereas in Maryland, to sort of loop this back, a living shoreline became a particular type of installation with a particular type of materials oriented in a particular manner in a particular type of location.
to address a particular circumstance, erosion. We in this area, and when I say we, it's, you know, our organization works very closely with the states of Delaware, New Jersey, a lot of the other academic institutions and NGOs in the area such as TNC, Riverfront North Partnership up in Philadelphia. The sort of consensus we came to is that, you know, if a living shoreline's function is to promote life, it's really not about the types of materials that you put in somewhere. For something to be a living shoreline, it needs to be functioning as a living shoreline. So the concept of the living shoreline in this area has started to move away from a specific type of tactic, but more into this idea of function.
something functions as a living shoreline as providing ecological uplift. And now what that does is that opens the door to a whole variety of different tactics that could be considered living shorelines. Because ultimately at the end of the day, living shoreline is an engineered structure. You are taking some materials, you are putting them in a location, you want that to typically attenuate erosion or maybe help build elevation. But at the same time, you want it to promote life. So you put these materials down, they're going to affect the physical conditions, which will affect the biological conditions at the site, which will then feed back. So by thinking of a living shoreline in terms of its functionality, we get away, we open the door for all these different techniques to be considered living shorelines if they're designed with ecological components that can support life.
And how do we know if they are meeting their goals, their ecological goals? How do we know if they're functioning? And this brings it, it really sort of dovetails it with the scientific methods. You need to monitor all of these installations. You need to know ecologically how it's performing before you get anything to the area. And you need to track some metrics that are related to your goals afterwards. And by doing that, we can see if things are functioning as living trends and if they're providing ecological function.
then and they're providing ecological uplift it may not matter the constituents that comprise the structure itself it's really what it's doing now you got to be careful right because you don't want people putting a bunch of potted plants on top of bulkheads and calling it a living shoreline look i got grass growing on this wall you really want to think holistically about the whole ecology in the area and see how this structure is is uh the function and the effects of it are radiating out through the variety of habitats it's placed within but what it does is it allows thinking of it as a function allows us to address the the ecological implications of hard armoring in areas like urban habitats where you it's going to be really hard to do something soft just as the way energy is bouncing around so if we're going to try to build elevation with sea level rise we're going to try to stem erosion keep critical habitats there under certain energetic conditions we're going to need to heavily engineer stuff but if we can make a priority of those designs also enhancement of ecological function while we're doing this then we start to get into a place where we can move forward in these areas and really building out these habitats and creating the proper conditions for them to persist under these under these different areas so
Living shorelines is always a developing field. As I mentioned earlier, we've worked down in the Delaware Bay, more natural habitats. I can talk a little bit about some work we're doing up in the Schuylkill River, across the Delaware River in Camden. There's a group, Riverfront North, who's been doing some work up in Northeast Philadelphia. And what our role, our partnership for the Delaware Restory, how we view our role is to sort of bring together these different groups whose skill sets are needed to create something that's functional. Bring them together, sort of pilot these ideas.
Our organization, one of my roles in it is to develop monitoring plans, collect data, analyze data. So design these experiments, implement them, collect data on them, learn from them, and then help promote the techniques that there's evidence for them working. This is really, really cool stuff you're doing here. And can you walk us through some of the ecosystem services that these are providing? Typical. So we've authored a couple of documents. One is one in Delaware with partners at TNC and New Jersey DEP, and one also in Delaware with the Delaware Living Shorelines Committee. And both of these groups that have put together these documents are groups of diverse stakeholders from public, private, NGO, academic sectors. And what both of these documents do is outline a couple of specific goals, different goals that Living Shorelines can have.
So in terms of ecosystem function, one goal that living trans can always have is erosion control. And now depending on what's being eroded, there's quite a few different functions that could be affected there. You can be thinking about things like carbon sequestration through vegetation proliferation, storage below ground and roots and dead biomass. You can think about habitat creation and persistence for different types of fauna that require certain types of habitat for different life stages. You can think about the intertidal portions of them as helping to support fisheries as nursery habitats for young fish.
You can think about nitrogen cycling, not only through the plants taking nitrogen out of the water, you know, through their production of biomass, but if you incorporate shellfish into living shorelines, which is something our organization does, you know, we have about four or five of us all have backgrounds in shellfish ecology and physiology. Shellfish are a great ecosystem engineer, so they can help build benthic and fauna habitats, which are great for fish foraging. They can help cycle nutrients from the water column down to the benthos, also to the vegetation to remove those from the system, reducing algal blooms. You can think about living shorelines providing... resiliency along coasts by helping to build elevation and trap sediment. So there's a variety of different services that living shorelines can provide. And one of the things that we like to talk about a lot is when we're approached with a location, someone's like, you know, all right, I've got an issue here. And the issue is typically erosion or something that they really want to be there other than the land is disappearing, some type of habit. Now, we're interested in doing something here. We really want to stop this erosion, but, you know, we just don't want to, you know, throw some rock down. What can we do ecologically?
And so what's really important to create a really good functioning living shoreline is to understand the ecological conditions, what currently exists and what is possible to exist in that area, what would be natural to exist there for that specific site. Because once you understand how the site is functioning now and you understand what could be enhanced, you can start setting goals. Now, which are these goals? What do we really need? Flood reduction. We're looking at an elevation-based goal. Are we talking about erosion? We have an erosion control-based goal or a habitat enhancement goal.
But what's nice is once you outline that, then you can start thinking about all those different associated services that come along with it. And a lot of them are going to have to do with nutrient sequestration, habitat proliferation, and especially refuge for all different types of juvenile animals, fish, flora, fauna of different types. So I think living shorelines can meet a bunch of different goals, and typically they meet a variety of them. One living shoreline that we're developing over in Canada, New Jersey, with their municipal utility authority, the wastewater treatment plant. Part of its function, there's going to be freshwater mussel beds there that will help with nutrient reduction. Not only will they help pull nutrients out of the water column, they'll help increase benthic infauna, which will be better fish foraging habitat. The vegetation in and of itself will be nice habitat for birds that come through. So there's the service of providing the habitat for the bird, but then there's also the service for the community, people who like to look at the birds. They can come out and have a place where they can foster their stewardship potential along these shorelines. And actually, to take a little side tangent, that I think is one of the services of living shorelines that constantly is either overlooked or maybe undervalued.
And what I think is one of the most important facets of constructing urban living shorelines is this ability for them to serve as educational and stewardship tools to connect people with the water in places where a lot of times people have been told to largely be afraid of the water, but that it's like a dirty place and you shouldn't go near it. You shouldn't worry about it. And there's a lot of opportunity to foster that stewardship through education, through connection. You know, by increasing these habitats, you give people something to look at, something to learn about. And then, you know, you're an educator, you know, as well as me, once people understand something a little bit.
They start to care about it. Then once they start to care about it, they're sort of interested in protecting it. So a lot of different, a lot of different benefits, you know, spanning a lot of different topics. Yeah. So this is close to home. A lot of what you're saying. I don't know if you, I don't know if you know this about me, probably do, but I actually grew up in Northeast Philadelphia. Yeah. I grew up in Weston Oming and then Mayfair and we would bike down to the, to the river to go fishing. And.
there's, I mean, there, there's no natural, there's like very little natural shoreline on the Delaware and there's very little natural shoreline on the Schuylkill River, right? So, like you said, you go down there and there's just no, you know, it's just a concrete drop off. And, and so in Philadelphia, unfortunately, And Camden as well, which is a city across the river. Remember, not just us listening to this, right? There's going to be people who don't know about Philadelphia. And Camden is kind of like Philly's Gary, Indiana, right? Or like Philly's Compton, right? It's not a suburb. It's a city that's directly across the river from Philadelphia. So it's just as urban as Philadelphia. It just happens to be in New Jersey.
So I guess because we're an old city, we've developed this, our riverbanks have been industrialized and there's very little places you actually go in and enjoy a beautiful view of the river, right? You go down there and it's just concrete. So I love these ideas of these living shorelines providing some aesthetic value, which is not to be understated. So what, how do those, one thing I've always been curious about is when you mentioned birds, I assume it's more like herons and like waiting, like herons and egrets and those, right? Shorebirds need mudflats.
Is there any way to make an artificial mudflat or man-made mudflat? The problem there is because if they're too static, they'll get covered in vegetation. And then it'll be more like herring habitat rather than sherbet habitat. Is that something... possible yeah well i mean i think there's a couple of things there and i think one of the main overarching philosophical discussions that constantly happens and uh around living short on implementation is typically if you're going to build something somewhere you're building it on top of something else right so you're always you're always involved in a habitat trade-off issue pretty much so if you're thinking about okay this marsh has been eroding well now it is a mudflat habitat a mudflat habitat has a lot of ecological service and value to it So one of the things in thinking about appropriate places to put in living shrines is you don't want to end up in a place where you're, you know, the robbing Peter to pay Paul kind of thing. We're going to vastly reduce one habitat in order to promote another one.
But typically, because of the erosion rates in a lot of the areas where this happens, I mean, some places down in Delaware Bay are losing up to like six feet of marsh a year. So you have a lot of times an overwhelming availability of mudflat habitat. And so the small amounts of marsh that you put in aren't really skewing that balance too much. But you do want to be careful because if it is an area that is being heavily utilized by something, you may not want to mess with it, right? Because erosion is also a natural process. Erosion and accretion.
should be happening but they should be happening in some sort of balance a place should be eroding somewhere and a place should be accreting somewhere so it is important you know the first thing to say is definitely it's important to think about the location where you're putting something because you are always converting habitat but it's interesting when you mention like oh could we just build out a mud flat living shoreline see a lot of people associate a living shoreline with vegetation because that was largely you know how what they were used for you were building a marsh on top of something but if we start to think about a living shoreline as a measure of function All we're going to be doing to make it a living shoreline is you are doing something to the area, installing something to create some sort of ecological benefit that could persist. Now, when you think about flooding in an area and you think about water getting into areas, one good way to keep water from getting into areas is to build a hill. You know, it takes a lot of energy for water to go up a hill. It typically would rather spread out than go up. It needs pressure behind it.
So one of the types of things that we've been talking about working with is this idea. So you might build a vegetative portion of your living shoreline, but then out in front of it, you may want to be augmenting the slope, right? You're going to keep it a mudflat habitat. You still want it to be underwater, but you want it to sort of keep water at bay. But that mudflat itself can be part of that living shoreline.
So I think building unvegetated slopes would most certainly be a component. And as we get into, you know, these larger, a lot of the pilot projects that have been done, you know, are pretty small, you know, 80 feet, 150 feet, 200 feet, you know, a lot of proof of concept. But as we start as a region, getting into these bigger, larger designs, which is the direction that we're going in Delaware, New Jersey, for sure, and Pennsylvania starting as well, is what we're going to see as a living shoreline is really, if it's along a greater stretch, is going to be a whole suite of sub-tactments. I think a perfect example of that is right now in Philadelphia, behind the Walmart, along the Delaware River, along four of the piers there, the Delaware River Waterfront Corporation is, you know, involved in redesigning that waterfront there to serve multiple goals, habitat, bird habitat, fish habitat, mussel habitat, and recreational opportunity as well. And when you start to see these bigger ones, they're going to have all these subcomponents, subtidal portions, you know, focusing on SAV and mussels, maybe intertidal portions with this augmented slope that would be good for birds foraging at low tide, as well as vegetative portions.
Now, the Delaware Bay, you know, thinking about red knots and horseshoe crabs and things like that, who prefer sandy habitats. The American Littoral Society down there does a lot of great work doing beach restoration, specifically, you know, targeting, you know, red knot foraging habitat, trying to, you know, enhance that and make it appropriate. And I think all those different goals can easily fall under this umbrella of living shorelines. As long as you can prove it, you've got to be evaluating it, you've got to be looking at it, and you need a goal to track your change against. And if it's functioning and it's supporting life, and they can do that in a myriad of ways, this is a living shoreline to me. So mostly you're doing areas where the natural shoreline has been eroded. Are you doing work where the body of water, the river has been channelized and like huge stretches of Schuylkill are just all concrete. Is there any way to like, I know I see some like floating like structures. Do they, are they considered living shorelines or is there any way to like, you know, I'm thinking like.
shorebirds would not migrating up over Philadelphia. Some of the areas that are protected would be along the Schuylkill or Delaware or East Park Reservoir. But the banks are too steep or concrete. So is there any way to mount something that could provide that kind of habitat? Or is that out of the scope of what we're talking about here? No, no, I think it's within the scope. I think this is a new area. I can talk about two specific projects. In terms of the bulkhead itself, this is sort of a greening up the gray kind of thing. And you run into this with homeowners a lot. Whether people have bulkheads or rocks, things like that, a lot of times people don't want to take them out. But they wouldn't mind converting them into habitat if they can. But also in certain places, it doesn't make any sense to take them out.
Because you have critical infrastructure behind them. You need them to stay there. But what can we do on top of them in front of them? So directly to augment the bulkhead itself, there's actually some people down in Maryland and some people in Delaware now that are working with these sort of Marsh, Oregon type of things. It's almost like, you know how in the backyard of the city, you can hang something on your wall where it's got all the different plans. It's like a biowall. But people are looking at different things like that.
And that's one method. Whether that itself is a living shoreline or more of the just like, you know, putting plants on gray infrastructure, I think would more fall in a second category. But if you're in an intertidal area where the tide does go out, you have this area in front of it and some subtidal area to work it. You can do something. So the Camden County Municipal Utility Authority in Camden, New Jersey, that we're working, we're working with a private firm. We're working with them. And then they contracted a private firm, Stantac, to design this. And we're the ones that are making sure that it's ecologically sound and helping develop habitats. This is a giant 20-foot seawall.
Well, it's about 1,200 feet, and there's nothing in front of it. Some soft mud, some rocks. It's poor foraging habitat. No submerged aquatic vegetation community. You don't really see anything going on there. So this is one of those examples of...
having to potentially use techniques that in and of themselves may not be considered green, but because of their presence, you can get this radiating ecological uplift. So the current design for this location is there would be a series of sort of wave breakwaters set out from this, set out a pretty good distance from this, maybe, I don't know, maybe about 100 feet in front of it. And so what those are going to do, these rock breakwaters, they're going to attenuate shipping waves. Now, why is nothing there? Well, because these giant barges are going by and the energy's hitting these walls, like you say, in the school, and it's just bouncing everywhere.
It's digging out anything that's going to grow on the substrate. It's just creating an extremely inhospitable environment for anything to persist. But you start to deal with that energy first. You put something in to deal with the energy. Now that the energy is attenuated behind it, in the subtitle portion, in the lead of these breakwaters, is perfect mussel habitat. If you install freshwater mussel pens down in this area, that's going to start bringing fish in and things like that. Freshwater mussels are also very well associated with enhanced aquatic vegetation growth. They help it clear the water a little bit. They pass the nutrients on. And now once the energy is reduced and you have this bit of nutrient cycling going on behind it.
You start to see some sediment probably getting trapped back there. The elevation is going to raise a little bit. You can start planting that. And then you start getting an emerging marsh come out there. So it's almost like the succession of habitats. You look at this. The primary problem is going to be the energy. You do something to reduce the energy. And as that gets reduced, you can do something else to build up a sub habitat. And then you can get this ecological succession going on behind it.
And over time, you can start to build up a natural habitat that would be there if the energetic conditions were not in play. And that even though there's a bulkhead behind it, I would consider a living shoreline. You've engineered something, you put it into place. And if the different plant and animal communities are persisting and enhanced as a result of that, you now have a living shoreline. Another example is at Bartram's Gardens in Philadelphia. So partnership with Delaware Estuary, where I work, is in the process of building the world's first mussel hatchery aimed at nutrient mitigation. So typically freshwater mussel hatcheries are, you know.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife runs quite a few of them, and they're there to help propagate threatened and endangered species. But freshwater mussels are one of the most endangered and imperiled animals in America. You know, there's a whole variety of tatsa that are more or less gone that used to be unnatural to this area. But there's still quite a few common species. So at Bartram's, PDE is working with them to build this hatchery. I think we break ground maybe late this year, early next year, to propagate mussels, to put them out, to filter nutrients, to get removed, to help pull nutrients out of the water.
Well, because of that, we're working on a few different things with that. And so they're in one of those areas where they have the natural shoreline, but it's surrounded by all these seawalls, right? The whole river's armored. So what do we do there? Well...
So we're working on a living shoreline there that we're going to start putting in the first components of this summer. The first thing we need to do is we need to see is if we can get the sub-aquatic things, plants and animals, to stay in place. So what we're using is we're using these containers of shell to, again, like a rock breakwater might do, but we're using a little bit more of a natural substrate. I guess rocks are natural, but a little bit more habitat-friendly. Shell has all those little holes and pathways through it that all sorts of little invertebrates and different types of animals can utilize.
But anyway, we're going to subtidally put out a series of test structures to see if we can attenuate the energy, stabilize the bottom. We're going to plant freshwater mussels that we've been producing and growing out from our test hatchery and at a variety of different ponds along with gardens. When we turn in Delaware, we grow these mussels out. We're going to put them out there. Once we can get the subtitle area, a little stabilized, we can get some mussels in there going. Then you start moving land work. But it's all about dealing with the most imminent condition that's causing the most problems and then working in a succession. So at a place like that.
You wouldn't want to throw in a bunch of plants right away because the energy will just overwhelm them. But we start with that major problem. We start to attenuate that. And then once we get the proper conditions for life, we start trying to enhance that life there and give it a little bit of a jumpstart. So that's a place where we're going to be doing a lot of different experiments over the next few years. We're working with Army Corps, National Marine Fisheries Service, Philadelphia Water Department, and obviously the state of Pennsylvania as well. There's going to be a lot of people keeping an eye on this. We're going to be looking at a lot of different types of information and hopefully be using that.
to develop sort of a plan for exactly that type of habitat that you're talking about. What are some techniques we can do here? And what's the mosaic of habitats that could be implemented? And what's the proper order to do that? Because the other thing to remember about a living shoreline is if it's alive, it's not going to be static, right? It's always going to be changing. You're going to have some types of vegetation come and go, you know, some might expand, some habitats might contract. There's going to be a whole lot of changes that could potentially happen as a result of either natural occurrence or, you know, if it's in an urban area, you know, unnatural interference as well.
So part of the key to this is to implement these different types of habitats, put this mosaic together. So, you know, thinking about niche ecology, if these things work together naturally anyway, as borders change, as things shift, there's going to be something there to take over the space if something starts moving out, or if something contracts, you know, something will always be able to move into that area. So thinking about the holistic ecology and these different types of things is sort of key for these really barren habitats, like you're talking about. This is sort of a new area that we're getting into this region. And also, naturally, urban living shorelines are a developing concept.
linear feet do you think or meters for our global audience do you think um your organization or has been installed in this area well how many we've directly installed and that we conduct ongoing research on it's not that much it's like 1500 2000 um it it's not that big because we typically put out these experiments that we track over time now we have our first installation that's still there went out in 2009 so we have installations that are a variety of ages mostly down in the delaware bay and the trip here is more in the brackish water with the salinity somewhere between you know maybe nine and twelve focusing on rib muscles, spartina grass. But this Camden one, the one at Bartram's Garden, we're actually starting some work up by the Fairmount Water Works, putting together a conceptual design this year that'll go out for bid hopefully next year for installation, are really our first foray into the freshwater.
urban prison these are going to be longer because we're kind of at the point where people want to start working with living shorelines a lot more now than they did in 2009 and also also to tell you the truth the regulatory mechanisms are there now to permit these kind of activities that weren't really in place a decade ago i mean part of the problem with bringing a new technique into an area someone's got permanent quite a few people need to need to do it and if there's not the right boxes to check that can be hard to do. That can be kind of a stalemate there. You know, the states of New Jersey, state of Delaware, now the state of Pennsylvania are really interested to have been, you know, fundamental foundational partners in moving this forward. So although the total amount of shoreline that we've done has been pretty small, those are things we've done on our own as research projects. We're now, living shorelines are out of place, where now we're getting into these more collaborative projects. We're starting to think about bigger areas. So I think we're going to see regional numbers jump.
pretty significantly in like the next five years projects singular projects are going to be along the magnitude of like a thousand a thousand feet you know 300 meters you know plus so We're getting close to an hour now. Before we go, can you talk a little bit about climate change and how that affects what you're doing? Because the sea level rise is happening. I assume that some of your projects could be too far underwater, but you also say that they help mitigate the effects of climate change. So could you elaborate on that, please? Yeah, I mean, this idea of persistence over time and under a change in climate is always an ongoing active conversation in terms of living shorelines.
now that we're starting to talk about doing, you know, bigger projects, you know, that is now getting into part of design is this project that we think it's going to be able to trap the sediment. What's the adaptive management plan as water continues to rise? Will this be able to persist? We'll be able to trap enough sediment to be able to keep its elevation. If you're, if you're dealing with an intertidal, if you're dealing with vegetation of any sort, it's going to want to be flooded for some time of the day and it's going to want to be exposed.
So if you're dealing with vegetation at all, you're going to want to make sure that it is at a proper elevation within a tidal data. So if you're dealing with this type of vegetation, will you be able to trap the sediment for the slitting shoreline to grow vertically? And there's a couple of different techniques to do that, or a couple of different considerations. First, is the sediment available? Now, we're lucky. We live in a sediment-rich system. You put your hand three inches down under the water in the Schuylkill or in Delaware, and it's gone. You can't even see it. So there's plenty of sediment out there.
trapping it. That's a whole other issue. This is fast-moving water. You really need to get water to slow down and release the particles in it. So that's where you get into the engineering. Are you creating baffling? Are you creating places to slow this water to give the plants the opportunity to get the trapping? We have the sediment. We have the mechanism to trap. And are those going to be able to persist over time? So a lot of that is going into the design plans now, for sure, in terms of living shorelines being able to persist. And so sometimes, and in some places under certain engineering,
you can get a shoreline to keep pace and just work as a natural marsh. Then the question is, is it now a natural marsh or is it still a living shoreline? That's a philosophical question that we'd love to kind of get down the rabbit hole on. That's sort of up for grabs. But in some places, you may have to do periodic adaptive management. So if you think about a living shoreline like a garden, right? You got a garden in your backyard. You want to grow things. The things can grow here, but sometimes they need a little bit of attention. And so people always thought like seawalls and things like that are great because it's like a set it, forget it. You put it in, you walk away. Cool. So you've done it for a long time, and now they're realizing they're not that way. They need maintenance to it. They need expensive maintenance. So living shoreline should always be monitored. You should be evaluating how they're doing periodically depending on the different stressor.
you may need to go in periodically and do some adaptation. Say it's reached a point where it needs to grow further, but it's not trapping sediment on its own anymore. Maybe you go in and you put a few things in there to help facilitate the trapping. So those are called adaptive management plans. What are we going to do when something starts going haywire? And nowadays, every living shoreline design that gets permitted should have one of those. There should be benchmarks that you're going for, should be monitoring to see how you're tracking to them, and what are you going to do if you don't?
Now, as living insurance are sort of an emerging field, we're one of the groups that advocate for adaptive management plans, monitoring plans. It's not always required, but I think the regulatory agencies, both federal and state, are having the active conversations about what sort of level should be in the statutes and should be required. So adaptive management, living insurance might be able to do it on your own, but you should probably watch them because you may need to go and attend them a little bit. In terms of mitigating the effects of climate change. You know, that's an area of research right now. Like how much carbon storage can we expect per linear foot in different habitats? There's a lot of different groups in the National Ocean Research Reserve System. It's one of those primary examples of the national organization doing this type of research. You know, what sort of carbon sequestration can we expect? We're working on it from the shellfish angle, closing that loop of if nitrogen they're filtering out, how much gets returned to the environment, how much is long-term removed?
So research closing the loops of what we can expect per linear foot or per square meter, however you want to think about it, by different habitat is ongoing. But I think in terms of mitigating climate change. I think more like the actual water level rise. Yeah, I mean. That's literally a physical engineering. You can certainly engineer slopes to keep water out. And if you're building in a place that you're trying to mitigate flooding, you just want to keep your eye on it, make sure if it's trapping sediment and growing with sea level rise and keeping pace, it's good. If it starts falling behind, you might want to get in there and help facilitate trapping a little bit of sediment. So that's going to be an elevation issue or maybe a hydrologic issue. If water's getting in, can't get out, or so much water's coming up in a river, it's pushing its way in. So hydrostatic pressure, that could be an issue too, but we haven't really seen that consideration. One final question that I have.
and you might be the person to answer this, where does the Delaware Bay actually start? Because the Delaware River basically takes a turn in Philly and then just gets wider and wider and wider and wider and wider. And then at some point they call it the bay. Well, if you want to think about two physical conditions where you can draw a line, you can think about salinity. And that's pretty close to the turbidity maximum as well, where the churning, you know, you get the most churning water. But the salinity line is generally around the Delaware Memorial Bridge, based on rainfall each year, you know, drought, things like that. If it's a really dry year, you know, the salt might come up a little further. If it's a really wet year, it might push down a little further too. But I think, I don't know if there's an exact, you know, overall agreed upon answer, but I would probably go with this generally around the salt line and around the Delaware Memorial Bridge.
that's where we tend to see the vegetation really start to change. And when you say salt line, is that going from salt to brackish or from brackish to fresh? Brackish to fresh. So yeah, if we think about the salt grain, you know, obviously down in Lewis, Cape May, right there at the entrance of the bay, we have full salt water and then it decreases coming up. So that would be the place where we can consider the freshwater habitat. So blue crabs, I see blue crabs in Philly, along the river in Philly, even way up in Northeast Philly. So is that like...
Is the salt because of rainfall or what have you come up? Or can they just tolerate a certain level of fresh water? They can tolerate it. We see them in Wilmington, Delaware, a good bit too. I'm now mining my brain trying to remember some of the blue crab talks that I've seen because blue crabs aren't an area of expertise for me. But it is common to see them and it's not due to the salinity of the area. It's part of their migration or part of their movement that has to do with their life cycle and stuff. Cool. Is there anything you want to make sure you say before we end that we might not have covered?
Well, I mean, well, one thing I can mention that's directly urban related is, you know, I mentioned a few projects we're getting started with in Philadelphia and, you know, moving living shorelines up into the urbanized freshwater prism is a place where we're going to have a lot of activity over the next couple of years. One of the things we're really interested in doing is really getting involved with this community stewardship potential of living shrines. I mean, a lot of us involved in this are ecologists and we're working on the ecology and working with engineers on the designs. But this nexus, this environmental justice nexus, the outreach potential, all of that is very high on our radar. And a lot of the models that we developed at PDE are now starting to include community stewardship metrics, look at the potential for living shrine in places. So I'm always happy to hear from people who have an interest in that. We also have a freshwater muscle program that has very strong.
community engagement portion of that program as well, where they like to get involved with educators. And one of the other things we're going to be doing is hopefully over the next year and a half in Pennsylvania, we'll be helping to develop the first PA Living Shorelines Committee. We've won in Delaware. There's basically a group in New Jersey. Now that this work is happening up in Philadelphia and the surrounding areas, we'll be looking to put together a Pennsylvania Living Shoreline Committee, which would comprise a whole suite of different types of practitioners and regulatory agents to keep an open conversation on what the Living Shorelines mean to us here.
How do we see them developing and how can we partner and pair the right people on the right projects to get the most out of it? So it'll really be a think tank with application for on the ground work. So I'll keep you informed when we start doing that. And, you know, anyone who's interested in being a part of any of those things can just get my email address off the partnership for the Delaware Estuary web page and shoot me an email. I wouldn't give a call now. I've been really bad about checking my desk phone with the working home thing, but emails. Well, this might intersect with my actually professional career because I'm hoping so. Yeah. We were talking about getting some muscles on our facility.
in the college creek and yeah well and i gotta tell you another thing tony is that where there is a pretty big gap in the research is uh this overlap of uh bird usage on living shoreline so sarah baboulis who i work closely with on a lot of projects on this living shoreline we're putting in down in the delaware bay we're going to try to implement a program down there where we're doing uh looking at bird use on them as well there's been a couple studies but none of them that i've seen have been real robust we may contact you about that but also up in philadelphia you know when we get this bartram's work going in which will probably be later this summer and i'll keep you in the loop on that as well we've got room in the monitoring plan to look to add additional metrics. So if there's something that...
in terms of birds, we would love to get that in there. And especially if there's a way for like citizen scientists or community groups to look at these too, we can help develop the data sheets, help compile the information and do the analysis for sure. Yeah, well, I mean, I help coordinate breeding bird surveys in Philadelphia green spaces. So we could do targeted ones for that. That'd be great. I could do a lot of it myself. I could also get, you know, organized assistant science response to that question. I think that'd be great. It also sounds like a good PhD program at some point. Could be. I'll tell you what, if people, you know, people coming up in academic environments right now are thinking about going back to grad school.
There is a lot of questions around living shorelines. A lot of ecological questions, a lot of engineering questions, and a lot of community nexus questions. There's a lot of work, a lot of room for all sorts of research to be done around living shorelines. And what I think makes living shorelines work so exciting. It's like I said, it's, you know, at the beginning of this, there's always, you never really know what's going to happen. You're really getting in on the ground floor of these new techniques, these new ways of thinking about ecology and engineering and people all working together. So I would encourage anyone who's going back to school or thinking about some sort of graduate research project, you know, to consider some application relative to living shorelines, because it's an extremely not only ripe area, but it's an area where there's going to be application after you're done. There's a need for it. And it's an area where you'll see that research likely get used. Negative or positive data. Remember, negative data is great data as well.
Well, fantastic. I think that's a great place to end on it. I'm glad we got to connect. I look forward to looking at you in person at some point. Everybody, how can people look at your research? What's the website for your organization? I believe it's partnershipforthedelawareestuary.org. And yes, partnershipforthedelawareestuary.org. And then on that webpage, there's a variety of different dropdown menus and personnel. You can get my, who we are. You can get my contact information under research. You can get information about our wetlands programs or freshwater muscle programs, living shoreline.
uh, programs and also shell recycling. We're involved in shell recycling for use in these projects. So all that information is available there. Fantastic. And for our listeners and viewers, please like subscribe and share on your platform of choice. Uh, please leave us some positive reviews and you can, you can always tweet at us, uh, PMS, um, on our Instagram and, uh, email us at, uh, urban wildlife cast at gmail.com. Thank you, Josh. Look forward to seeing you soon. Um, give my best to your family. Cheers. Yeah. Yeah. Likewise. Thanks for having me. Certainly, man. Thanks.