Skip to content
Buzzfeed, Ford, Transgender and Building Trust episode artwork

Feb 7, 2019 41 min

Buzzfeed, Ford, Transgender and Building Trust

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

First show for 2019 - Peter Fray is joined by a blockbuster panel of editors; Lenore Taylor, Joanne Gray and Helen Trinca.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Buzzfeed, Ford, Transgender and Building Trust

0:00 41:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

The 2026 Chevrolet Equics, awarded the most dependable compact SUV in the US by JD Power, is designed for your everyday. And with available all-wheel drive, you can handle your to-do list with total confidence. Start your bill at Chevrolet.ca. Details at JDPower.com.

The following edition of the Fourth Estate contains offensive language. Climate time forward. In your face columnist, Cameron Time Forward has resigned from the newly merged Fairfax 9 entity, 9 Entertainment, after being cautioned for calling the PM and Fing disgrace in a tweet. But wasn't she employed to be provocative?

Or is the new 9 more purient than the old Fairfax? The press council has censored the Daily Mail and 9.com.au for what it calls and the necessary use of the word transgender in reporting a crime story. Even though the woman involved openly identified as such. Did the website deserve to be censored?

Or is the press council interfering in reporting? And finally, some good news for the media with the Edelman Trust Survey showing a significant uptick in Australians' engagement with news and desire for facts. What can the media do to help this uptick along? Just consider these questions and a lot more we have, I think, one of the most senior and most exciting Fourth Estate panels ever assembled.

Joanne Gray is the managing editor of the Australian Financial Review. She's held a plethora of senior reporting and editing roles far too, long and less for me to talk about now. But she's mainly worked at the Financial Review, but she's been the editor of Boss Magazine and she's been a correspondent in Washington. She's also worked for Bloomberg News in Switzerland and has been the managing editor for Asia, Money in Hong Kong.

Thanks for coming, Jo. Thanks, Peter. Great to be here. Great to have you.

Helen Trinker is also a managing editor. She's the managing editor of the Australian. She too has pretty well done everything pretty well everywhere. She's set up Boss Magazine.

She now edits the deal. She's been a correspondent out of London. She's worked for the West Australian, the AFR, the Cine O'Lingherald and for the past. How long is it at the Oz?

This time around about 11 years. 11 years, yes. And she's also knocked off a few books including a prize for the biography of the Australian author of Melon St John or Cinjon. And finally, our third guest is Lenore Taylor, the editor of the Guardian Australia who's sharp and I'm flinching political reporting has graced the AFR, the Cine O'Lingherald, the Oz and then the Guardian.

Along the way, she's won a couple of Walkley Awards, a couple of all-lin gongs for the press gallery reporting of the year, and author of the book called Shitstorm on the Red Government's Response to the GFC. She's on the phone. Hello, Lenore. Hello, Peter.

Welcome everybody. Before we get stuck into the questions I foreshadowed, I wanted to ask Helen and Jo a quick question about the Banking Royal Commission and that is. The government has promised action on all 76 recommendations and yet was not in favour of the Commission, but neither were parts of the news media. Including the Australian and the AFR.

Quick question. Any regrets? Oh, look, no regrets. It's turned into an amazing new story.

In fact, for us, I think what happened was, you know, we'd heard for many years about trans questions and I think an April followed the mark and I guess we became a bit annured to that. And I think that what the Royal Commission has exposed is clearly a culture in the finance industry of definitely putting profits ahead of customers. And that's really hopefully going to be addressed. I'm not sure if it will be or not.

But the Royal Commission, I think, was extraordinary because whilst we had heard of many of these cases, what they did and Rowena or her colleagues did was really use them to harness emotion and to focus on, bring public attention, the impact on individuals of these kinds of practices. To tell us the human story is exactly which had an enormous impact. As is the job of generous. What about the Australian?

The AUS was not in favour of the Royal Commission. Just in terms of that, I think there are a lot of organisations, obviously, a lot of people who weren't sure whether it would potentially do more damage than good at that point in the sense that this is a very disruptive, potentially disruptive exercise for the banking system and for the whole financial system generally. And of course, I think we have seen some fallout, I suppose, from the Commission already in terms of things like, you know, a whole lot of things have come together obviously to make, for example, credit for homes, you know, harder to get. I suppose my view about it was, and I get to apologise myself in the deal about the fact that I personally had not had any problems with banks, right?

So there's a lot of us, and that's what I suppose is the end result, that mostly have fairly simple straightforward exercises with our banks. We have fairly straightforward things with our superannuation. We're not on the receiving end, we haven't been burnt in a sense. And I also did sort of feel this argument about whether or not it was actually necessary.

As Joah said, they're having scandals and obviously some of our colleagues have done great work in exposing those, and they were out there, many of them were being dealt with. Obviously, as everyone knows, a lot of the material that came before the Commission was necessarily sort of historical in a sense because of the stuff that had happened, some that had already been dealt with. Now, that's not to take away from the huge job that's done, and it's been a scarifying exercise for the banks, and in a sense it's kind of an incredible exercise for all of us looking on and seeing it, because we're seeing in some ways not just a banking system, but big business generally, you know, you could almost argue the whole kind of basis of capitalism sort of being exposed in the sense of saying, okay, this is what happens, you know, how do we manage this? No one's suggesting that we're not going to have banks operating like this, we're not going to sort of move away from the market, you know, all of those things, but how do you work this out?

You know, and I think it's actually sort of a work in progress. I think it was, look, I just think nobody foresaw quite how it was an interesting way for a start that Hayne decided to conduct it, so it was about stories, and Joe used a really interesting word there, because it was about emotion, and I'm not saying that's wrong either, but because it was about emotion, it's had a particular impact in various ways. You know, I personally sort of think that some of the people who appear before the Commission were asked to sort of give testimony about their behaviour and about their bank culture have been, some of them misread it, clearly some of them were caught up particularly in early days on detail, perhaps that you know, that's not, I'm not saying that Commission was wrong, but you can just see the subtleties, it was not a, it was not a forum for subtleties. So no, anyway, so let's say, okay, we'll move on, we might come back to this question, because really it goes to another of our topics which is the question of trust, and very much goes to the Trust.

But anyway, look, let's talk about BuzzFeed and Vice, we've become almost numb to the investors of journalists losing their jobs in so-called legacy media, but last week we heard about jobs being lost in, you know, what's called new startups, although they're not supernip. BuzzFeed and answering over 250 jobs, but it doesn't, those in Australia, and then Vice Media and answering, it costs 10% of its workforce. I guess we all thought that these startups were going to, or were pointing the way to the future of journalism, and what do you make of these cats, Lenore? I think it shows what's happened over the last couple of years in terms of how hard it is to survive on ad revenue alone, no matter what the scale of your venture, the impact, probably of those changes that Facebook made to its algorithm, which really impacted companies that were trying to sort of get viral content going.

But I don't think it means that you can't successfully run a digital news organization. I mean, many organizations are doing that behind a paywall, and going in Australia, we're doing that quite successfully with the reader revenue model where we do both advertising, and revenue that readers get us voluntarily, which is made a profit in Australia where that's where I keep it globally, and traffic is going up. So I think there are different ways of making money, making a sustainable digital media business, but you need to read the market at the time, and those companies were set up when it was believed that you could just get there by advertising scaling, that doesn't seem to be the case anymore. Yeah, no, it's a really, you make a great point.

I mean, I think the other point that's been made about BuzzFeed and bring you two in on this is, you know, it wasn't that they were not making money. It's just that they were not making the amount of money that they thought we were going to do, and so they were running out of runway. I mean, we all held up BuzzFeed, in particular, but also vise for being in a great transition company. They started off, you know, BuzzFeed making cat memes and cat memes and what have you, and then suddenly started doing what could be reported, you know, serious reporting.

What do you make of this? Is it kind of reinforced the kind of the power you need through, I guess, being part of all media in a way? Well, it's not so much, I don't think all media, I think of it's right. I think we have to think about getting our money or the digital area has to get money from the readers, not from the advertisers.

So it's just not going to help in advertising. We all know the reason why there's this massive infantry that's almost infamous, who's going to pay much for that. So it is about a subscription model or some sort of payment model by the users, you know, and the problem with that is, look, I think, you know, I think that one's just about this, something like this, a matter of time, isn't it? The more that everyone gets used to that and the bigger your reach is, I mean, there's a lot of people in the world, and we're finding a lot of people with mobile phones, and we're finding a hell of a lot of people able to, you know, sort of pay at some level, maybe small amounts of money to access sites.

I think there's also what's been going on is a sort of a consolidation, because there's this rush of fabulous everybody, you know, they could get into digital, I suppose. And at varying levels, because of Baro's low. Baro's very low. Yeah, the Baro's low.

But I do think, you know, I believe, like everybody, about a decade ago, that you could do it through advertising. Eventually, you'd get its red advertising. Eventually, you get a model with, say, the legacy print and digital, in our case, like a news call. So a hybrid model.

And you get a hybrid model, and you'll be able to make it work. Well, I think increasingly, everyone gets it, that it's about subs. So, yeah, that's up. So, okay, so, is there a limit to how many subs subscriptions that the air should have?

Well, I guess what I'm trying to get to is, is it's how flexible is that model? I don't think it's flexible. I mean, we can't fiddle with the pricing in a way that sort of does it either also, you know, A, B testing to find out, you know, if we drop the price, would we get the price? I think the focus has to be on creating content that people really, really value.

And so, it's much easier if you're in a financial review situation where you're reporting on business and people can actually take that information and use it to somehow to either make themselves wealthy or more successful or their clients more successful or they can win a deal. So, they can actually use it to make money or somehow advance themselves. And I think, you know, that's a very narrow, I don't know how big that market is, but we're obviously wanting to test that. Well, it's a central question, that wasn't it?

But it's certainly a growing group of subscribers. I mean, we're actually growing at quite a fast clip. As soon as I've said it, actually. Yeah, the other big point here, I think, and I mean, the norm might like coming as well.

So much about brand, you know, brand awareness. When you think about the big global opportunities there are now, and, you know, like New York Times, which in post, we know this story, Financial Times, you know, hugely small, terribly small circulation in times, actually in the UK. I mean, I was staggered years ago to find that it was something like 60,000 or 80,000 or something. Yeah, very minor.

But of course, globally, it's got one of the most brilliant brands. And to be honest, digital opens up the possibility of global numbers in a massive amount. But, you know, how many Australian-based papers can have a global identity? Yeah, we're bringing them all back.

One other thing about that, of course, was that they had seemed to crack the magic code of sponsored content, or whatever they call it. Do you take any learnings from BuzzFeed's, you know, cutbacks on that? Because everyone's tried to tip their toe a little bit in this sort of sponsored content area. Yes, and it's still important, but I think programmatic advertising is becoming increasingly important.

And, you know, as the other two guests have said, content that readers value enough to pay you for it. And so I guess, you know, my experience is that having a model where readers aren't required to pay, you have to inspire them to pay. You have to do something they love enough that they get their credit card out and voluntarily give you some money when they don't have to is quite a discipline. But, you know, it's edging up towards the 40% of our revenue.

We think it'll be half our revenue in the two-cent future. Well, that's it. So you have to know your readers exceedingly well. You really have to know your readers.

You really have to know what subjects inspire them and what they like. And largely they like, you know, solid, old-fashioned, good, need to point. Yeah, yeah. Yeah.

I mean, you know, know your readers and know where, you know, try and find out where you're growing as well, you know, which segments are, you know, are growing and try and cater to that as well. It sounds very simple. It's not. So what segments are growing for the film?

We've got a growing segment in the younger demographic, I guess you would say. Younger rich people. Well, no. That's great.

You know, people, you know, everyone wants to get ahead, you know, be successful. Everyone wants to, I mean, this is, you know, one of Helen's great insights back in 2000 when she created Boss Maker Zain. That, you know, people want to know how to build their careers. They want to know how to deal with people at work.

They want to, they want to hear stories about, you know, people who have made it and their failures and their, you know, mishaps along the way and how they overcame them. So, that's what I think. Let's move on to someone who, I guess, was employed because she had an audience. She knew her audience.

And the name, we came in time forward. But last week, the SMA-CHENET, she resigned after being read from my own biobossies for calling the Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Effing Disgrace. But as I said, isn't that what she was supposed to do? I mean, Chuck bombs.

The nor. You know, you've got a few provocative columnists. I do. So would you sack them if they called the Prime Minister and Effing Disgrace?

I wouldn't, I probably, I would certainly talk a bit about it. I mean, I think there is a question about how your social media policy, which obviously all organisations have, applies to contributors who are so closely associated with your news brand that they're introduced as, you know, the FMH as well, or the Guardians. Yeah. And, you know, saying calling the Prime Minister Effing Disgrace would certainly fall without staff social media policy.

So it would certainly, I think, more in conversation with a contributor who was closely associated with us. I must say, I think from reading that there's some dispute about the, about exactly what went down in that the Health Center, saying that they thought she just got some feedback on a column that she didn't like and she had interpreted as editorial interference. I'm not, you know, I don't quite know exactly what happened, but I do think that, you know, little wide question as to how you have a social media policy for contributors. And of course, and to you, Helen and you Joe as well, you know, in a way, the social media world will live in, Twitter in particular, rewards that sort of, you know, stands.

If you had a columnist who called the Prime Minister of Bloody Disgrace, would they deserve a referendum for that? Well, Bloody is not as, no, but, I think the F word is definitely, definitely the case is, I wouldn't like any of our people on social media to be talking to be using Bloody, to be honest. I don't, I think it's sort of un, it's un-edifying, it's poor language, anyway, for a part of thing else. I think definitely the F word, you know, we, you know, social media policy exactly the same as Eleanor is saying, you know, we, you know, we say to people, you can't do it, you know, you can't use that language because you're using, because you're representing us, you know.

And we wouldn't really, to be honest, have in the print paper, I don't think we'd ever have, we'd not certainly have lots of columnists saying so and so this politician or that is a disgrace, so might. But I mean, we'd probably, as a, you know, sort of an editor of a daily, of a page, you know, the opinion page or something, I'd probably be, I'd say, do you really need to say Bloody, you know, I mean, what's the point, you know, I think it's, you know, I'll call on this or the Australian, you have been warned. Well, I mean, and there is also the question of, you know, it wasn't just one thing, I don't think. No, it was an ongoing, you know.

But I do think Lenore's right. She, you know, she was using the platform and it's, you know, it's a valuable place and we don't necessarily, and I haven't spoken to anyone at the Herald about this, but I think you do have to be cautious about what goes on social media. So before we leave Clementine forward, can I ask, have you noticed any change in the culture of your new, you know, your new entity? Has it become more purian to you?

Absolutely not. You're what you're saying at work? No, I mean, no, there's not really no, I mean, no change that I can, you know, explain. I haven't noticed any difference in the way we do our day to day jobs at all.

And also Peter, Joe would be watching what she says at work all the time as a virtuous. We never use any of those words at work, ever, to anyone. No, we recognize that. No, we recognize that the place is a place.

I mean, I see it seriously, I think it's true of people, the levels of respect are mounted in workplaces these days, it's probably much higher than it was when we all of us went into journalism for 30 years. Absolutely true. And given that we're all on, you know, there's a heavy deadline pressure every single day. People are under very intense pressure and still they behave very civilly, I think, towards each other on a regular basis.

Okay, absolutely. New civilized journalism in the world. You're listening to the Fourth Estate across Australia and the community radio network coming to you from Two S.R. studios in Sydney.

Let's say on controversial subjects, let's talk about transgender. So the Daily Mail and Nine.com.au have been censored by the press council for what it says, irrelevant use of that word in a story reporting that the sister of a prominent footballer have been charged over the death of her boyfriend. And I should add that the charges were later dropped. Just to read the headline in the Daily Mail, major clickbait, of course, transgender sister, comma 31, of football star is charged with a manslaughter over the death of her boyfriend 51 after domestic violence incident that has in Sydney's south.

So I guess the question is, did the press council get it right? Hellen. Actually, I don't think they got it right. I think they were a bit half and half about it too, because I think they said it wasn't like a terminology that wasn't a major problem, but it wasn't particularly relevant.

I think this one was okay. I would say first of all, it's tricky territory, all of these descriptions that we use, and I think that's completely the case that you have to think about it being relevant. I don't want to talk too much about this detail, because this person was completely clear, the charges were dropped and whatever. But I mean, the relevance here, I suppose, goes like this.

Here is a person in a domestic violence issue, which is usually male on female, I suppose, in our culture mainly. It's about strength, it's about physical, often about physical power. And we have a very interesting story here where it's actually a woman who used to be mankilling, allegedly doing something to the partner. And so I think that the fact that that person is transgender is inherently interesting, to be honest, and it's relevant enough to pass the test for me.

I think that a lot of judgment calls all the time in journalism, and there's also another one that operates here, of course, because that headline is incredibly interesting. That story is just incredibly interesting. And it's actually made for a story. I don't define anything wrong with that headline.

It's too long. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that headline, as far as I'm concerned, because it tells the really story, which is in itself, there's many components of it, and it was at the time, obviously, extremely interesting. Now, that's what we're in the industry. We're in the business of the material, this is interesting news.

Now, I completely understand you've got to have judgment calls all the time about how far you go and what descriptive did you use. I think this one, to me, it was okay. There's often times we've obviously changed our views on a lot of this many times in the last 50 years or so, because we no longer refer to people by the colour. There's a lot of stuff like that that has really changed.

We made the point before we went on here about, you know, do we get offended about the mother of three, a whole stack of people, never get offended by that. If you went to the press council and said, I've got no idea if you went to the case, the press council and said, we should not have referred to the new CEO as being a mother of three. I'm not quite sure what the press calls would say. It's become a normative practice to do that.

I don't see it as right. No, no, no. What do you think? I agree that it's a judgment call to use the script is when they're relevant to the story.

I probably think in, I would have made the judgment in this case that it wasn't relevant. We usually use transgender when it's specifically relevant to the story. So, trans people in the Church of England or transgender law rights or, you know, trans in the military. So it's like it's specifically an aspect of the story.

It's essential to the story. It is a judgment call. In this case, I would probably err on the side saying it's not relevant. But like Ellen says, practice on these things changes over time.

And I think certainly the complainants in this case are trying to change practice. Certainly, yes. And that's a whole another story. I guess I have this point now.

I mean, she makes the point. I think it's a good one to make is that perhaps it is relevant in so far as there's a power out. There's a muscle element to it as it were. The woman, the man who became a woman was probably stronger than a woman.

And so therefore maybe the violence aspect is amplified by the fact that the transgender person was formerly a woman. Yeah, I do that to be the long bar. I think it's essentially relevant to the story. Okay.

All right. Joe, what are you? Well, I'm from the position of privilege of never having to write stories about it. I'm actually, I was, I was tending to Helen's opinion, but I think possibly Lenore is, is right.

If it's not directly relevant, maybe it shouldn't be mentioned. And I mean, you know, at a certain point, are we going to get to the point where we even stop referring to gender? I do. Yes.

I mean, you see now some people are bringing their children up in an ungendered way. And, you know, at some point, we might even get to the point where we say is gender even relevant to the story. So which is ridiculous. Anyway, take us down that track.

But I think we're all agreeing that this is an evolving evolving space. I mean, not related in a sense, but it's just a look at how, for instance, we now report suicide completely different than say, even ten years ago. Yeah. And you can only, you know, you can only applaud those sorts of changes.

I think one of the, it is, I think it is extremely tricky. And I think, you know, it's times you can make different decisions about it. I do think that this one, I'm just repeating myself. I think they were particular circumstances now, whether or not when that headline or that story was written, all of those things came into play, they might have been quite slightly unconscious, but it's sort of interesting.

I think it is interesting in a domestic violence situation. You have a woman who used to be a man and they're, you know, involved in that. Domestic violence, ultimately, is just violence. Yeah.

Yeah. So, you know, it is violence. Yeah. Domestic violence.

Yeah. Yeah. So it's physical violence. Yeah.

If you're talking about physical violence, you know, there's, you know, like, unless you do not believe that a man, that males are often absolutely physically stronger than females. And I happen to believe that that is, you know, the case that they are not necessary. But a lot of men of the same dimensions roughly would be a lot more physically powerful, have much more muscle strength. You know, so those are things that are interesting in domestic violence context.

Okay. Well, move on. Well, move on. It's interesting.

I really like to get back to this subject some other time in the future because it's interesting to look at the evolving practices in journalism or not. So let's finish on a happy note, which is the 2018, this year's, this past year's, Edelman Trust Barometer has been released. It was released, the Australian stuff was released today. I was on a panel about it.

And it's shown that there's a small increase in movement in how people trust the media, but a large increase in engagement. And I've to quite the report, engagement with the news surged by 22 points, 40% not only consumed news once a week or more, but they also routinely amplify it. But people are encountering Roblox in the question of facts with 73% still worried about fake news being used as a weapon. Are we, let's start with your job.

Are we surprised by this surge? Well, I think we saw the start of it in the survey last year. People starting to go back to the established media brands. You know, I think we've seen, if anything, a lot of real news in the last year about how much fake news and how damaging fake news, how much fake news, how damaging it has been.

And I think people have become, you know, over the last year, incredibly skeptical about social media and, you know, the Facebooks of the world. And I think, you know, obviously it's a fantastic thing for established brands who spend a lot of money employing professional journalists. Yeah, just on that difference between news media, traditional news media, and social media, I think the gap now is 35 points. Yeah.

I think in terms of the trust. Yeah. So it's an incredible gap. Although, search is actually very close to traditional media.

So this is all good news. How do we keep it going? I think we keep on doing what we've always done really, which is to, in sort of traditional, I suppose, all legacy media or, you know, serious media, to keep on trying to write really good stories, to try to, you know, get to the bottom of issues and to have the resources to do that, to sort of stick to those basics of trying to verify material, you know, to authenticate material. I mean, it's very interesting with the trust factor and the fake news.

A guy from the head of the BBC World Service this week for the media section of the Australian Jamie Angus, and they are doing a huge campaign this year trying to get really looking at fake news video, you know, fake video. And that's an area which I suppose I haven't been really thinking about a lot. Deep fake or something. And it's really, I mean, I think that's interesting because I mean, the capacity, I mean, because one thing of course, the video has an easy sort of thing, well, if it's happened, you know, you see it, you know, it's not a journalist interpreting what's happened.

I've seen this, and as we know, in all sorts of ways that doesn't necessarily the case, but I think it's kind of interesting that that's a new frontier in some ways of fake news. But yeah, no, it's great news for us, but actually not that surprised me because I think the fact that we've got so much capacity, people can access news in so many ways has actually meant that everybody's kind of much more engaged with some, with information in a weird way. And some of it might be completely chunky, which is. People are overloaded with information, so maybe they're coming back to trusted sources.

But how are we going to keep this trust up tick going? I think it's about the relationship we have with our readers, which has changed hugely in recent years. You know, we can engage with our readers below the line. We can respond when they ask in real time when they ask questions about what we've done and why we've done it.

We can take their, you know, like get kicked off or informed when we've made a mistake by readers sometimes. We know who they are. And I think the more transparent we are with readers and the more we engage with them, the more they'll trust us. So, I think that includes sort of showing you're working out sometimes, explaining the process of how you got a story.

It involves being transparent if you make a mistake. It's a whole different relationship, but the more you engage with that relationship, I think the more those readers are going to trust you. Well, we're going to wrap up now, but I do have one question for each of you, and it's the same question. We're heading into an election, as we all know, and there's been a lot of interest in government, what governments can do or should do or shouldn't do for news media.

Given that there is a widespread perception that news media needs to hand, we've had the Senate inquiry last year, we've had the ACCC inquiry into the social platforms. We had things like Judith Nelson, who obviously not government setting up a fund of $100 million. Is there, does the news media need, if this incoming government, the new government, whichever color it might be, in 2019, is there any one thing that it could do to help sustain news media? Maybe I'll start with you, Lenore.

I think making it easier for media companies to set up a BGR, so tax-deductible funds for public interest journalism would be hugely helpful. We actually do that now, but we have a workaround arrangement, which isn't entirely scalable, and doing that would mean that we could look to philanthropy over this period while we're weathering the right disruption as a stabilizer. Tax offset would be helpful. I'm drawn to things the government can do, which are as far removed from any form of direct government handouts or difficult to politicise, because we all know that whatever the government, whenever it's media policy, the debate gets politicised really quickly, and I think when the small public interest publishes fund was set up, that clearly happened.

I would like to go, I think there is a role for government at the moment, because public interest journalism is essential to a democracy, but I would like them to see them do something that just helps us make a sustainable business through the era of transition until we figure out what the future looks like. Okay, right. Helen, what do you want? In terms of big policy decisions, I'll go there so much as thinking, I think what needs to happen is, I believe in public broadcasting, I believe in the private sector, and obviously what I work, and I think that a proper understanding of those entities and those business models, and a mature understanding from government as much as anyone is worth.

I just want to go more practically, but I think the sooner that they get on, this government gets on points of cheer for the ABC and then a new CEO, the better, because I think it's good. I think it's a hugely important part of our new fabric, and it needs to be allowed to get on with what they do as we are, with what we do. Are you allowed to say that for Rupert? To say that the ABC is hugely important, absolutely.

Of course. Although, I mean, they are getting on and doing what they do anyway, and sometimes you wonder, how much do we need the board? That's fighting, Tom. Sorry, I would agree with both of those.

I mean, what I would say is that one of the biggest costs that we face is defamation payouts. I'm sure that the average person has no idea of the number of times we are sued for defamation and how much money we end up paying out to settle cases, even though our stories are correct, and did the public interest. It's very, very hard to prove that. New South Wales is the defamation capital of the world.

If you want to make money, build a pool, build a house, build a mansion. Sue, a media company, New South Wales. It will be fantastic, I think, for public debate, and just in the interest of democratic free speech if we had some reforms to our defamation laws. I think that goes across all the way.

There have been some sort of mega payouts that have been well canvassed and reported in the last year, and some of these are killing actually too. They are capacity to operate. You have to be fair about this. You need defamation laws that do protect people, to some extent.

We have to have provisions anyway, so that people are wrongly accused of things, but I think they are getting a balance right so that we can do what we have to do, which is to try to uncover uncomfortable truths. That's what we are here for. On that note, I think we are going to leave this edition of the Fourth Estate. If I could applaud, which I can, but I very much thank today's guests.

Join a great from a mentioning editor of the AFR. Thank you so much. Thanks, great to be here. Helen Trinker, always wonderful to see you.

Thank you so much. On the phone, Lynette Taylor from The Guardian. Thank you, Lynette. Thank you.

Make sure you subscribe to the Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a few things in between anytime you like. We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us. On Facebook or Twitter, our handle is Fourth Estate AU. My name is Peter Frei, and thank you so much for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on February 7, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.