Skip to content
C.V. Joint (Aust) Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 981 episode artwork

Aug 18, 2022 6 min

C.V. Joint (Aust) Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 981

from Coffee and a Case Note Hosted by James d'Apice

“Get us out, and get a prov liq in!” ___ P, A director and 70% shareholder of a Co sought to have it wound up and a provisional liquidator appointed: [1] - [3] P brought this application shortly after D1 (P’s former spouse, a Dir, and a 20% shareholder) commenced family law litigation: [20] D2, D1’s sibling who owned the remaining 10% of the Co’s issued shares, commenced their own shareholder oppression proceedings: [4], [5] The Co sold car parts, both wholesale and retail: [6] Appointing a prov liq is a drastic step. It requires the Court to consider the prospects of P getting a final winding up order, and whether the balance of convenience favours appointment of a prov liq (including if the Co’s assets are in jeopardy): [12] and [13] Relations between the parties had broken down leaving the Co in deadlock, with police having been called to the Co’s premises a number of times: [16], [18] The Co’s financial position was contested. It appeared to be profitable, though was heavily indebted to its landlord with “precarious” tenure. The Co had very little cash, but it appears P directed the Co’s money into one of its accounts: [20] - [25] The two Ds (in the P’s absence) purported to resolve to increase their salaries slightly. There were also payments of bonuses of $10K per 6 months. The parties were in dispute about the appropriateness of these payments: [26] - [50] Allegations were made of all parties mishandling cash which was properly the Co’s: [51] - [57] The P caused money earned from one of the Co’s eBay stores to be paid into an account under his control, alleging the Ds had previously taken funds without a proper basis, pointing in favour of placing the hands of an independent party: [58] - [69] Further evidence showed P using an account in his own name to pay Co expenses; removing Ds’ oversight from this aspect of the Co’s business: [74] Neither D opposed the winding up of the Co: [83] The Court was satisfied a prov liq should be appointed: [88] The Co was in deadlock, with insecure premises, no sensible basis upon which it might continue to trade, and a real prospect that the Co will be wound up on a final basis pursuant to s461: [89] All this formed a basis for the P’s application succeeding and a prov liq being appointed. ___ Please look for Coffee and a Case Note and James d'Apice on your favourite platform and follow me there!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

C.V. Joint (Aust) Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 981

0:00 6:10

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Coffee and a Case Note?

This episode is 6 minutes long.

When was this Coffee and a Case Note episode published?

This episode was published on August 18, 2022.

Can I download this Coffee and a Case Note episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.