Skip to content
Can Cash Pay PT Actually Scale? episode artwork

Aug 24, 2026 54 min

Can Cash Pay PT Actually Scale?

from PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy Hosted by Jimmy McKay, PT, DPT | Physical Therapy Podcast

What if the future of physical therapy is not just more visits, more units, and more productivity pressure? In this episode of PT Breakfast Club, Tony Maritato, Dave Kittle, and Jimmy McKay start with a productivity benchmark chart comparing outpatient private practice, corporate clinics, cash-based care, hospital outpatient, sports med, and high-volume clinics. That opens up a bigger discussion about what productivity really means in PT. Is 25 visits a day automatically bad? Is one-on-one cash pay automatically better? Or does it all depend on the patient, the payer, the legal model, and the business you are actually building? From there, the conversation turns to whether cash-pay physical therapy can scale. Dave points to Onward and similar performance-based models. Tony pushes back by asking whether that solves a population-level problem or simply serves a smaller group of people who already want the service. Then the crew explores a bigger business idea: can PTs productize their expertise? Jiffy Knee created a branded surgical approach. McKenzie became a global system. Total Motion Release built a recognizable method. So why don’t more physical therapists turn their clinical expertise into branded, licensable programs that other clinics can buy, use, and market? The final stretch gets spicy: Tony’s “best personal trainer vs worst physical therapist” post sparks a debate about education, professional identity, licenses, and whether PTs overestimate the protective power of the degree. The takeaway: knowledge is not proprietary. Value comes from the result, the system, the delivery, and whether people actually want what you are offering.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Can Cash Pay PT Actually Scale?

0:00 54:39
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Broadcasting way too early from three separate Wi-Fi connections, it's PG Breakfast Club with Tony Maritano, Dave Kittle, and Jenny McKay. All right, fresh out of bed after a beer league hockey game. That's Tony Maritato. Tony, you wanted to lead off with this image that I just downloaded from a little group chat. Set us up. What is that? Yeah, so I was looking through, you know, the headlines and what's out there specifically related to private practice and business topics. Productivity is always a big topic. And, you know, there are references for where these numbers come from. But I know you and Larry Benz have been talking about stats. And I can tell you.

I don't know, 15 years ago when we were multiple locations and big administrative team, everything was run on stats. Like that's what we did, you know, percent of arrivals and percent of completed plans of care. And how's everybody doing? Now we don't do any of that stuff, but I figured, Hey, let's talk about some of these numbers. Let's see what is being presented and maybe how accurate it is. All right. So we're looking at PT productivity benchmarks by practice type. Like I feel like too, like a lot of times people will come into like these group chats, these Facebook groups that we're in and say, what's good productivity. And then of course the next question always is what setting are you in? There's a lot of context here in terms of productivity.

So this little chart is showing outpatient private practice, outpatient chain slash corporate, cash-based or concierge, hospital outpatient, sports med, and then a high-volume mill. I wonder if this person's biased, let me just call it high-volume mill. Okay, all right. I'm surprised they didn't lump corporate into high-volume mill. Right. But, you know, this is coming from, like, it's called Proactive Charts. It's basically like an EMR kind of company.

And, you know, they're looking at what are the productivity targets? I think they're pretty, pretty dead on. Like looking at outpatient private practice, 75 to 85% productivity. They do break it down by visit numbers. So they're like eight to 12 visits a day. They're saying this is a typical five day week. So you're assuming eight hours a day.

Three to four billable units per visit, 160 to 200 units. I would tell you that's typical for what I would have expected from my clinical team when we were at multiple locations. Dave, you're in. Any thoughts on that kind of, now it's brick and mortar, one location, people are coming to you. This also has to account for, okay, maybe you schedule 15 and three cancel or no-shows, so you end up doing 12. Dave, what's been your experience with numbers like this?

yeah i mean pretty consistent numbers like this from my first first three years out of school was outpatient ortho in new jersey and then another two years in brooklyn outpatient ortho very similar nothing surprising here and uh actually some clinicians were kind of billing close to like 3.5 to 4 units per visit uh and then there were others that like either didn't care or weren't trained well enough or were not uh reminded often enough or whatever because like there's a lot of folks like sturdy mckee and others that'll always say like physical therapists never overbill like they're so risk averse like they're afraid so like there's some physical therapists that will chronically bill like two or three units per visit and the patient's there for an hour or two it could even be like eight like late stage acl patient and they're there in the clinic for like an hour and a half two hours and they're still only building like two or three units or something so that's obviously on the on the owner or the managers to like coach therapists and retrain them maybe maybe maybe they don't need to be there anymore whatever like you have to be you have to bill for what you actually do uh so i mean but again the numbers overall um pretty pretty consistent from what i've seen how about the third third line cash concierge is that pretty in line with what your people are doing that seems high to what you've said

Yeah, that's definitely high. Dave, if you can't see it, it's six to 10 visits a day, four to six units per visit, but cash is not based on units. So that's kind of messed up. 120 to 180 units a week. It says the big key success factors for cash, extended sessions, premium pricing, low overhead. What would you say your key success factor? Just from hearing Dave talk, I wouldn't say that.

Those are not the success factors. I would say it's ease of scheduling. You come to me. Premium pricing is what allows you to do, what allows the patient to have that. Extended sessions. How long are your sessions typically? Is it an hour or? For us or for Tony? For you, for you, Dave. Yeah, an hour, of course. So it doesn't even matter. It doesn't matter if it's clinic because we're, because what's so funny? Do that an hour, of course. Nothing, nothing. Well, no, because you all, you guys already know. Yeah. But I didn't know if it was like extended if like sometimes people did more.

No, I mean, in the future, like if Ethan, my new therapist is doing like, if he's treating multiple patients at the same time, like if he has an ACL client from like 9 to 10 AM, if they're at the point where they need to do a lot of plyos or late stage, whatever, then like at 10 AM, his next patient's coming into the clinic. And if that first patient from 9 AM needs to do more and they're independent and they don't need a lot of like cues or assistance or oversight or whatever, then he can like go in our private room, treat the 10 AM patient, but the 9 AM patient is still out in the clinic. Maybe, I mean, again, it's a little different because we're not billing insurance and we don't have to worry about like the, I guess like the direct or indirect supervision type of stuff. But in general, all of our clients know. that it's one-on-one for the entire hour. And so as soon as that next client comes in, they're outskies. There's no sit on the bike and just do 30 minutes on your own or whatever kind of thing. Obviously for home visits, it's a lot easier, but I know we're talking about the clinic. And then what have you guys seen? How accurate is that high volume mail? It feels pretty accurate from what I've seen, just people sort of complaining about anyways. Visits per day, 15 to 24 plus, 300 to 420 units a week.

That's consistent for me in two states. And I worked or I shadowed and did rotations in Philadelphia and Pennsylvania. So that's three states in the last 10, 15 years or something like that. So that's pretty consistent for me. I don't know. Yeah, I would agree. There's two issues here. You've got the business model and then you've got the compliance legal aspect. And definitely in models that don't track or aren't subject to the CPT code billing guidelines. So CPT code says one-on-one. It doesn't matter if it's Medicare. You're expected to deliver a billable minute of time to one person. You can't deliver that billable minute to three people.

But if you step outside of that, you look at athletic facilities that have PTs on staff, you look at certain workers' comp situations, you look at other environments, military, you can easily see a therapist doing 25 visits in a day. You're not subject to the same legal limitations as in a typical insurance-based model. And I think the patients do great. Now, of course, are we talking about a brain injury that has multiple complexities, medical instability, and things like that? I was in the clinic yesterday with a new patient. Very complex. For me, very complex case.

I could not possibly do two or three of those at a time. But in a normal situation, person comes in, they've got a little shoulder pain, they don't need my dedicated attention. So we have to put context around this. I don't think 25 in a day is a big deal. I just don't. And the thing is, we go back to what actually happens. I can tell you from 25 years of experience in my clinic, you have a busy block, 10 to 11, man, you're slammed and there's all these people and people are popping in and showing up. But then at two o'clock, you're sitting there staring at each other. I have never met to this day, including myself, when I put myself in the employee role.

I don't appreciate the one hour block of dead time or the cancellation or the no show. All I think about is, man, we were so busy at 10 o'clock. But when you look at the numbers and you say, wait a minute, I got paid for 40 hours. I got paid for a minimum of 160 units of billable time. We lose track of the 10, 15 minutes in the morning. We lose track of the 10 or 15 minutes after the last billable unit. We lose track of the 30 minutes of non-billable lunchtime. Like we lose track as the employee.

of all of the stuff that we're getting paid for that we're not generating revenue for and it feels air quotes feels very hard i hate when people say this feels hard um but we're not generating we're running in mud we're not generating any any kind of benefit for the company the patient the employer or me as the employee where is that disconnect is is it going through school like you're being trained for one thing and then life is a different thing like what does that look like i think that's part of it Yeah, I think that's part of it. I think it's the idealism of, you know, I'm here. Like, again, you go back to, all right, a cash PT who's doing four visits a day. That's awesome. But like, what kind of volume is, how do we deliver a national service at four visits a day with a declining, you know, number of PTs in the profession? You can't. Like, you could be the Rolls-Royce, right? Rolls-Royce doesn't produce as many cars as Honda. But if you want people driving cars, you need volume. You need production. You can't do it in four visits a day with a limited staff.

Why though? Let me just push back. I get what you're saying. It is a smart take. I get it. One example is Jeff Moore and Onward. I think they might have different rates at different locations, but they have, I don't even know. Do you know? There's like 50 or 100 or so, like different affiliate locations, like all over the country. They're growing. What is this? So Jeff Moore, he started Onward. Yeah. So like, and I don't know, it's like a licensing model or like a branding model or something. So he...

The practice owner owns probably most of it. I don't know the numbers, but I'm just going to make it up. The practice owner probably keeps 70, 80% of the income or something and probably has to give the top co, the HQ, some monthly or quarterly royalty fee or whatever, licensing fee for the brand name. They have probably approaching 100, maybe more. And Jeff, I'm sorry, it might be 200. I'm sorry if I'm way understating it if you hear this, but they're probably, I've seen different rates. I think they're around 175 bucks a visit, maybe 190 something a visit at some locations. Maybe they're different based off of rural versus metro and things like that.

That is, and Jeff has said it, he said it on my show and he said it elsewhere on social media. Like he's trying to push that in a way to, I mean, it's already like a national brand, I believe, which is incredible. And like not even 10 years old or something like, or eight or something like that. Dr. Bo is commenting here live. He said 60 clinics in 22 states, which is some really impressive momentum. Tony, maybe that's not national. I mean, 60 in 22 states, that's pretty, I mean, that's halfway to national. It's more than regional maybe. It is absolutely awesome.

I don't even think that would make a dent if we're talking population health, right? If we're talking about getting the musculoskeletal services out to the people who need it, I've run the numbers multiple times, like 300-ish thousand licensed therapists relative to the 330 million Americans. You know, you look at the numbers of how many of those Americans would need or benefit from musculoskeletal health, what's the size of the market. These are drops in the bucket still. And this is where Hinge, Sword, digital platforms are going to come in and pick it up. They're going to take off with it. There's always going to be a place for the little guys like us. And little guy could be 60 kids. But it's just, it's one of those things where we're such a tiny speck on the radar. I think it's easier we disappear than it is that we expand to, you know, the size of McDonald's. That it's easier to do that? It's easier to disappear than expand to McDonald's? We're closer to disappearing versus growing up at McDonald's size? Yes, I think we're closer to disappearing. Okay. So one thing that you said was...

the amount of people across the country that, did you say that wants it or need it? Because there's a very big distinction. Need it, would benefit from it. And I was very specific about that. Yeah. Right. And the people that work with us.

want it and they need it. There's, I mean, I think 90% of people walking on any sidewalk anywhere in the country could benefit from one, just one out-of-pocket physical therapy visit. Call it a tune-up, call it an annual physical body diagnostic, whatever, you know, wrapping paper you want to put on it, movement, balance screen, muscle screen, whatever you want to call it, joint analysis, walking check, gait, whatever, gait posture, stepping protocol, whatever. Yeah, most, I mean, here in New York, Brooklyn, I'm in Manhattan. there's so many people that are like just hobbling around it's like that's a that's an old thing like that's been you've had some you've had some dysfunction for like five or ten or twenty something years right and that person still could benefit from one visit and the difference tony i i agree with you for the most part but it's you're saying we can't grow it big enough for the people that want it or need everyone everyone needs it but they're the people that don't want even the current in-network experience. That's why 90% of people drop off. Maybe there is some disconnect with value in the volume-based clinics and all that. But if you're paying a $20 copay only and you're still dropping off from an in-network plan of care somewhere in the country, and it happens in pretty much every state. So it's not so much that the people don't need it. They absolutely need it. But it's a smaller amount of people that want it and are serious about it or serious about their health and wellness and understand that they want to trade some amount of dollars for that value or they don't see the value. I mean, there's many things here.

Yeah. Yeah. I just think it's one of those things we don't have enough capacity within the system, especially if somebody wants to keep doing one hour sessions or longer. There's plenty of individuals just in the system right now that could do 10 minutes and do just as well as if they got an hour. You know, but nobody is moving the needle in that direction. Nobody is expanding on a very limited basis. Like in some skill nursing, they're going to more group interventions. I think even that like, and, and, you know, with what Onward has done and people within that organization, I do think they're moving into because it's an athletic population and active population. They are moving a little bit away from the one-on-one and they're, they're doing group sessions and it's more looking like a CrossFit, you know, class in some cases than traditional physical therapy. Um, but this opens the door to what Dave's specialty is talking about private equity, moving in and talking about.

bringing in funding, bringing in business models. I don't think they've said, and I remember Zach Long and Jeff talking about Onward when they were just starting, I think they bootstrapped the whole thing. I don't think they brought in private equity or got funding, but there's definitely opportunities for something like that in the space. We see companies that do. Dave, why don't you bring us up to speed on some of that? Well, I remember, I think we talked about it briefly here at least a year or two ago. If not, it was myself and Jeff on my show.

The way that they got all their affiliates to open up locations of Onward Physical Therapy, almost all of them came through Jeff Moore's continuing education course, which was the ICE Institute of Clinical Excellence. And they would know, they found out who are the top tier physical therapists, who are the therapists that are serious, that ask very discerning questions. And the ones that are really, they care about the craft and building their skills. And they're not necessarily someone who just does all the courses through ICE just to do them, but they would find. people that were like the top of the crop of the attendees of these courses to then open up onward locations and then jeff said uh so eventually like jeff used to teach a lot of those courses then eventually he got other instructors so then he would he would tap on the instructors and say hey um you know you had jimmy mckay in this course you know he reached out about well and i'm just making this up wanting to open up like an upstate new york onward location whatever and jeff would be interfacing with the instructors to find hey hey mr mrs instructor how how was jimmy in like how did he interact with the other therapists was he respectful what did he show up on time did he sleep

during the course that you know so that that in itself is like an incredible pipeline to find owners and affiliates to then open up owner physical therapy um i mean i really i really want to almost like i don't say like put fun together i think we could do like acquisition or partnership by partnership but i want to i want to continue to seek partnerships or acquisitions of out-of-network self-pay practice owners starting in new york city i'm working on a couple things here but i think jeff moore i'm not you're probably not going to sell it you're probably not going to sell it but but that could be a great rebrand for all the other practices that uh we potentially partner with and have a bigger footprint because he's already got like a kind of like a regional national name and in terms of private equity like that would that could be one play where you you just you try to just package up all of the other practice owners like me that are doing either concierge like home visits or the one-on-one visits in outpatient practices just like onward is already doing and they're pretty much like 45 minutes to 60 minute visits per visit um 45 to 60 minute sessions each visit uh so it's it's very similar so what was what was saying about frank frank benedetto which i'm sure you guys know he's got his honey badger project similar too

I'm a fan of Frank. I've chatted with him. I never spoke with him. I've messaged him. I've messaged him a bunch. But he's teaching therapists how to create digital courses and how to sell. I think he's changed that, though. I think he did that. I think he... Well, he used to poo-poo a lot on outpatient mills because he had a practice that he sold. And then he was poo-pooing my model, doing home visits and one-on-one visits, the way that Tony kind of poo-poos it here, which is totally fine. Let's go backwards. So two questions. What does Onward offer?

And then what would you offer in terms of absorbing? Like, so what it looks like? I've never heard of Onward. I don't know how I missed this, but I have not heard of Onward. But this is good. I don't have any expectations. So is it similar to like the Hilton model where you buy sort of looks like you buy the name, but then you're also getting the infrastructure too, is my guess. But on the website, it doesn't sort of explain, which is probably good. You're not going to show off everything. But like, what would you expect in a way? If you were like, I want to open an Onward in New York City, what would you expect from that stuff besides just the logo and the website? Well, I know for sure that Jeff helps. And Jeff, if I have any of this wrong, please correct me online or whatever.

um when i've spoken to him before he was saying that you know hey we're looking here at this state or this city or this metro He knows square footage pricing on every major metro. He can literally tell you off the cuff, off the back of his hand. So he'll help you. So, Jimmy, I was joking. I know you're not going to open one, but if you were opening an Onward in upstate New York, you could call Jeff. He would help you with finding locations, with the build-out, what are the products that they use. Obviously, you have to have certain branding colors and that whole scheme. EMR, whatever order. Yeah, it's all the back end. All the EMR stuff, they probably have their own custom unless they use Jane. I don't know what they use, but you would have someone like Jeff and his team.

like at your side shoulder to shoulder or like or digitally but like there to support you on how to not get screwed over on signing a lease how to negotiate leases how to find a great spot in location how to they're actually they're actually not they're not huge on like marketing because they're focused on skills right so like the skills and results and that's what gets a lot of word of mouth uh but there's a ton on the back end plus the branding and the signage and all that type of stuff so there's a lot of things that you would benefit from compared to if you just started from scratch and you just wanted to do every little thing on your own and you wanted to just make you know mckay physical therapy like you're gonna have just way more like yeah you'll yes you'll own 100 of it But then you also have 100% of the challenges, the headaches, kind of like learning everything from scratch and not starting on like first or second phase. It's kind of like what they offer.

So this is interesting. And I want to be very selective because I don't know that I can trust the information that Gemini is giving me back. So just the high picture, it says how the model works. It's targeting solo PTs or two PT teams. It's saying they're usually subleasing space out of a CrossFit box or fitness studio. The stack, they provide unified local SEO, website architecture, branding, marketing, community of performance forward clinicians. Cost structure, historically, it's been a licensing or consulting setup.

That's what they were calling it. I'm not going to say the percentage this says, but it says they take a percentage of revenue as a royalty cut back to the parent company alongside with initial buy-in or setup costs. There was some legal questions in the state of Washington where they were trying to say that they were non-compliant, that it should have been a franchise, not a licensing agreement. Pros and cons, instant authority, turnkey tech solution with SEO, community and mentorship. That's the main thing. But it looks like they were using a licensing or consulting agreement, not technically a franchise. So can we just double down or just review that? I believe this model, still that model, it doesn't matter if it's onward or someone else, like doing one-on-one visits, brick and mortar, almost any zip code, I believe, can charge at the least $100 a visit out of pocket, completely out of pocket, or 150 or 175. Tony, you're saying that cannot scale across the entire country. Is that what you're saying?

I think it depends on how it's done. I think, you know, and this has been brought up in the groups a hundred times. Like, yes, I think you could do as a professional consultant, I reach out to an attorney, it's a $300 fee. You know, am I going to, is it $300 three times a week for 12 weeks for a nuisance problem that isn't really a big deal? No, that's not scalable. That's, that's not a McDonald's kind of, you know.

hits every country across the world um are there enough people in the society that are willing to pay 150 300 even 500 for like a one-time professional consultation yeah i think individuals can do that it's not a population solution so in the conversation if we're saying individuals can we build a business and be successful in 2026 yes are we going to save the planet with physical therapy interventions no so we're not going to save the population with the current model though tony right right right who cares who cares right so like the current model in network where people are paying for premiums and they got a 10, 20, $50 copay. We already know the stats that 90% of people drop off of their plan to care, which means they, of course they need it, but they just don't want it or they don't see the value or the therapist are too busy or whatever. Like there's so many factors, but people don't want it at scale.

So, and also, like I said a million times, I know you said today already, again, that Hinge Health and Sword Health will take over some of that. People don't want, they're not going to want that either. Like I'm saying, they don't want that either. Like there's some people that benefit from it. Okay. And they like it, but at scale, the same type of person that is like, all right, I drive one time to physical therapy and it was a 20 or $50 copay. And then they drop off after two to one or two visits or three visits or whatever. That person, it's really hard to say that person. It's really hard to help that person. It's really hard to help that person out of chronic back pain or chronic pain or.

headaches or bad posture or whatever like they're making their own decisions on their own health and wellness they're not investing the time and effort maybe they were never guided or taught about the value of that maybe they have you know past trauma and demons that don't allow them to focus on their health and wellness and there are so many people like that unfortunately in the country and maybe across the world so like our type of service offering maybe can't scale as well or as easily as mcdonald's because we everyone needs to eat uh but not everyone wants or everyone needs what we do but not everyone wants what we do to the level that people want an easy big mac or fries that's so readily available in any country that you go to yeah Going down this road a little deeper, though, let me ask you guys this. We know people, shoot, his name, Total Motion Release Tom. Tom D'Alonzo Baker. Yeah, so he's got this huge network of people that he's educated, he's trained, you're part of that, you understand what he does.

I've always thought like, we've seen the franchise model. We've seen the licensing model. Is there an opportunity within the profession to go one level deeper and be curious what Jimmy thinks where somebody like Tom created total motion release? Somebody like me, I would create a total knee specific, uh, branded program that has, you know, name recognition that has the social media reach that has all of these things. And then, uh, an individual practice owner or a small group, or they would basically buy the licensing for my branded total knee program. Tom's branded total motion release.

Our responsibilities would be to continue to build brand recognition, continue to build reach, and so that a clinic, just like a clinic, would buy a physical piece of equipment, they would buy a branded program like this, bring it into the clinic as a revenue driver. Do you guys think... there's opportunity for that. And the reason why I ask is because does that open the door for individual therapists to be like, I'm never going to grow a $10 million PT practice, but maybe I could just grow my personal brand, turn it into a productized service, and then sell that to other practices or venture-backed companies that are looking to scale faster and bigger. What do you guys think about that as an opportunity? What do you think, Jimmy? I mean, it's possible. I think the opportunity, the ROI is huge. I think the number of times that will happen is smaller, right? The home runs are big. It'll just be fewer home runs. I actually didn't think you were going that way. I thought...

Dave, what do you think? Let me flesh out the second idea that I had. I don't have any problem with it. I think that's totally fine. Actually, I screenshotted something yesterday. Let me see if I can pull it up. I was going to share with you guys. I got hit with an Instagram ad, and it was a female physical therapist. I forget her name, but it was like TheraX Shoulder. Her whole Instagram is a digital product. I guess I don't have the screenshot. Give me an example of what you're thinking about. Would it be what Dave's describing? What's the tennis elbow woman? But she's not selling it to other people. She's like, you see me, telehealth. I'm tennis elbow. I'm super good at it. I can treat it from here.

That's all I do. And then that's what she is. She just owns tennis elbow. Is that what you're thinking? Or are you thinking like, I'm a therapist somewhere else and I'm just going to buy into this shoulder program and then I sell it to my patient. So I'll give you a surgical example that exists right now. So the Jeffini.

The Jiffy Knee, it's a branded surgical procedure. They protect the intellectual property. They protect the name. It's not that different from other minimally invasive sub-vastus approaches to total knee replacement. But they have built this thing where now they bring surgeons in, they train them on the Jiffy Knee process and do all of this stuff. We've got a surgeon south of us in the Cincinnati area, one north of us in Dayton. They're the only ones in this area who are allowed to do it, who are doing it. And patients, consumers are actively seeking this out.

Because they have name recognition. Everything is in a box. Now the surgeon isn't creatively thinking of, how do I do this procedure? Everything has been done. It's been taught. So you're just packaging this protocol effectively with a name and marketing material around it to sell more knee replacements. But they're Jiffy knee replacements. They're just not knee replacements. So I'm on their website. So if I'm a person who needs, something's wonky with my knee, right? I trip over them by Googling it or someone tells me about it. And then, of course, I look them up by state.

But Jiffiny doesn't own a portion of their practice. It's just they get a cut of whatever comes through the door, through that Jiffiny door. Yeah, I'm not sure. I mean, you're bought in a little bit because you got to get certified. That's going to pay for itself in a couple of knees, right? Yeah, basically what they did was they built a marketing machine that the orthopedic surgeon buys. They buy the marketing machine. They put it into their surgical center. And that marketing machine is just sucking people out of the general population to get their knee replaced. Yeah, I don't know. Like, does this translate to PT? Because I can't.

go get a Prime Day deal on scalpels and do it myself. But I feel like what we sell is different. And although there are people out there doing this right now. I think what Tom did was he was like, you don't work the painful side. You work the non-painful side. That's so out of the box. It doesn't make sense. Why would this work? But then you've got all of these testimonials and all of these clinicians on board. That is enough to make a consumer who is sitting there at home being like, I did therapy. I did this. I did nothing worked. I'm going to go buy that. And it adds the price premium to it because it's branded and, you know, there's more authority behind it. So.

so how does someone so is total motion release and jiffy are they like the same model just for different things is that what you're saying no he i don't think he's gone down this route he's just sticking he's he sells like ceus as a virtual ceo okay he's still just kind of teaching selling the education but in in the world that i'm thinking he would sell the name total motion release he would allow therapists to market the name total motion release for potentially for a fee for a licensing agreement whatever um he's got his his database of providers and i'm sure he sends people to to there who have taken his course A thousand bucks or three payoffs. And by the way, Tony Motion Release works really well if you're a physical therapist. You should check it out and I get nothing from it. So I'm outside of this. I'm outside of this model right now, Tony. I'm not going to get anything from it, but Tom's a great guy and this absolutely works. Yeah, he's got incredible testimonials. People that I know, like, trust. I've sent patients to therapists who do it because I don't do it. I've paid for one of my therapists to go through it. That therapist isn't with us. He relocated. And also I find it interesting that Tom hasn't raised that price. That price was $1,000 like 15 years ago. Really? Interesting.

Trying to reach more people. Maybe. So one great therapist could create one great system that could then scale across the country, basically. Well, like McKenzie, right? So that started in New Zealand or whatever. Yeah, that's a great example.

Start in New Zealand? That's an expensive course. Why don't we have hundreds of those? Every therapist thinks they're amazing. Every therapist thinks they have unique protocols and unique approaches and they don't want people stealing their methods. I feel like it's feudal Japan and samurais are not teaching other people how they kill each other because it's so unique to them. But seriously, why haven't we seen more individual therapists turning these into full-fledged businesses? Is it because we can switch to a topic? Is it because of...

Like I'm selling me and not the result. Like I couldn't tell you who owns the car dealership that I drive by five times a week that I bought my last car from. And that person's name's on the door, but they don't market that. They market brand. More specifically, they market the car. Even more specifically, they market what you're going to do with the car. So is that the reason? It's like, well, I'm the magic. I have my name on the door. I'm Dr. Blah, blah, blah. Is that the reason we can't let it go? Because then we can pivot into this idea. I think we've got enough time to at least dig into it, which is when Tony wants to get interaction, he posts something like.

give me the best trainer and the worst PT, which is, which is better. Right. And then people lose their minds because they people comment, comment, comment, comment. I even love that one comment. I'll find, I'll bring it up. It's like, I've rewritten my posts seven times and I can't post it because it sounds rude. And I'm like, yeah, like she can't let it go. She can't recognize that she can't let the identity go. But, uh, is that it? Is that why this hasn't been created is because I'm the man, you can't scale me. You can't scale Jim McKay. I'm the magic. I'm the magic baby.

Well, I also part of that, like, all right, so Tony, you said there's how many 300 or 330 something thousand PTs in the country? What's the number? Yeah, something like that. Around 300K. And then how many approximately, how many practice owners do you think there are? The numbers I always see are about 40,000 private practices. No, but I mean, but owners though, right? So some owners own multiple locations. So do you think each owner is like 10? 27,000. Practice owners? I think so. So that would be, that would be 10% of the total physical therapist workforce that become private practice owners.

So you're asking how come more therapists don't do like productize a service or, you know, make their system and productize their system. I think we see some of it and it's probably going to be similar to that number, which would be 10% of the amount of 10% of the therapists. of the 300,000 therapists become practice owners. So of the staff physical therapists, maybe five or 10% of them might step up and make like, like Emma and is like the elbow queen or whatever, or Tom Delonzo Baker and make his, this type of a system. So I can't, I can't imagine it being, I mean, 5%, 5% of 300,000 therapists is 15,000 therapists. So I can't imagine, I mean, maybe there's that many, but it's probably even less than that because maybe a lot of the therapists get into our world and they're like, they're just looking for a job with the base pay or the base salary and health insurance benefits. And to go and do the thing you're talking about, Tony takes, you know, a lot of entrepreneurial chops and effort and failure. And you know, that.

yeah a lot of risk a lot of risk and time and effort so um not everyone signed up for that because they signed up for a stable healthcare job with a base salary and insurance and a safety net and all that Yeah, it's been 25 years and I still try to fit a round peg into a square hole. I still try to make and mold everyone into what I am and what I think is important and valuable. I don't know how to get away from that, but I think when I do get away from that, I'll probably just disappear from the profession. Truthfully, that's the only thing that keeps me in the profession is the desire to change people's ideas. But I have no right to do that. So what are you going to say, Jimmy? I'm going to say one day we're going to wake up and like his Facebook groups are just going to be gone. His YouTube channel will just be down. His email won't work. He's going to be Kaiser Soze.

We've seen it happen. Rob, right? Rob Biney. Rob Biney just disappeared. At some point, you just get so sick of it, you just walk away. Yeah. You just can't. Yeah. Tony, don't do that to us. We'll track you down in Ohio. Seriously. That's right. All right. So here's the post. And I've re-read. I don't understand why we do this. I've re-read this real quick. I've re-read this post just because sometimes I do post something and I don't pay enough attention. I've re-read the post and I don't disagree with the post. I mean, I think I conveyed what I'm trying to say, but clearly it struck a little bit of a nerve and I think it's an insecurity thing. Correct.

I mean, I was a personal trainer for a long time before I became a physical therapist. I don't think I was any better once I got the PT degree. Jimmy went down the road in this thread, which is what I agree with. What you learn in physical therapy school has virtually no impact on the rest of your career. You learn all the good stuff working with people. You learn from the people you surround yourself with. A great personal trainer can do everything a great physical therapist can do. I would argue there's just as many bad physical therapists as there are bad personal trainers. But everybody in this thread went immediately to a personal training as a weekend certification.

neglecting all of the amazing personal trainers that have bachelor's degrees, master's degrees, that continue to research and learn and study and do all of this stuff that far exceeds what a lot of physical therapists do. You could tear apart most of these arguments with a butter knife. I like Michael. I'm not taking a shot at Michael. But he's like, the difference is the education bar none. You can't compare the medical knowledge of a personal trainer.

How do you know? How do you, what if a personal trainer reads every book that's available on his train ride to work every single day for 30? No, what you're saying is I sat there for three years and did this thing. And I know that there were a thousand people that applied for 30 seats. Lots of people are out. I'm in, therefore I'm valuable. And I understand there, there's the thing. I earned this. You can't take it away from me and just read books to get this knowledge. Yes, you can. You can. And then you say, well, the only way you learn the real stuff is by working with patients.

What if a trainer is hustling and working with patients every single day and they're watching the videos that our colleagues create ad nauseum at scale and they're learning faster? The only differentiator is the letters after your name and your license. And as Tony pointed out, and it made me feel a little lightheaded. This was six, eight months ago. We were like, the license actually limits you more than it allows you to do. The only thing it really allows you to do is bill insurance. You're in the system and it actually limits what you're allowed to do. Now you have to, you are beholden to a scope of practice where we've said, what is the purpose of a scope of practice to protect the consumer? Like, really?

Is that it? Does it do that? Right? So I think the reason these threads sort of devolve is psychology, not anatomy, not physiology, not business, not communications, psychology and personal identity. And I think for context, like I did everything different backwards. I was that personal trainer working in physical therapy clinics. I was associated with great therapists and they would do something. I'd be like, well, why are you doing that? And I'd go home and I'd research what the science was behind what they were doing. I learned the anatomy. I understood the mechanics of everything. Like you're taking a smart person and it doesn't matter whether they have the degree or not. A smart person is going to find the information. What school theoretically does is it teaches you how to learn. You don't have to be spoon fed in the DPT degree.

It might be the reason I get better at cycling. I have access to bikes and roads and hills. I get better at cycling when I sign up for a race and get a group to cycle with and meet with them three times a week. That's it, right? I'm obligated by myself internally, socially, to show up. School just says you got to show up five days a week for three years. That's why you're better. But if someone's motivated and does it, I'm very sorry. The knowledge is not proprietary. It just ain't.

Yeah, yeah. So my point in that, and that kind of relates into the other stuff. If we are moving into a world, business world, where reimbursement continues to decline, which I imagine it's going to, cost of the DPT degree is going to continue to increase, which I imagine it's going to, we're looking for new tools that we can bring into our arsenal. The unlicensed professional who has the same brain in their head that I have, who has the same learning capacity, who has the same, they come into an onsite environment where we can teach them. And in my experience, truthfully, unlicensed professionals are far more eager to learn from me or whoever the therapist is than a licensed professional. Because usually when I hire a PT with a degree.

They want to do it their way. Yeah, and that's fine. They've earned that right to do it their way. But if I want to teach somebody a different way or expand ideas and, you know, I'm going to hire somebody that's not a PT and I can teach them everything that I want them to do within the culture of the business and within what we're doing. I think that's expandable. I think that I have access to far more people with good personalities and, you know, that I can bring in if I don't have to worry about licensing. And if I'm not getting paid for the insurance reimbursement anyway, there's no reason that I have to stick to that.

And PTs are able to delegate to non-PTs, teach them, coach them, caregivers, whatever you want to call them, as long as we're not billing insurance. Correct. You know, so now this is back to the scalability. This is a scalable model. All I have to do is build a good business that satisfies the consumer, delivers the value they are expecting. And I could probably do it for less than the $50 copay like Dave referenced earlier in the call. Correct. And you can charge more for it. This brings me back to like my podcast episode four. I could have stopped there.

Eric Mara said the three things you need to be great. He said he was answering for a sports physical therapist, but this applies to any supplies. He said his three A's available. You got to, you have to be where the person is when they need to be open, right? Affable. If you're a jackass and I have a choice between you and a non-jackass, I'm going to pick the non-jackass. You got to be, I got to want to work with you. And then his last A was adequate, adequate. But the people who have the personal identity wrapped around the letters after their name, which is ironic. We're talking about it now because if you're on LinkedIn, everybody's getting their certifications. Now the results for OCS, SCS, NCS, they all came out. I got a diatribe on that for a hot second. But if you're wrapping yourself up there, your third A is not, it's not available, adequate and available, affable and adequate. It's available, affable and awesome.

Look at me. I separated myself. I think I have a post coming out later today that highlights there's two times of the year that like OCS and NCS and all those letters get mentioned. It's the day the results for the current class come out. And that was yesterday. And everyone's saying, I'm thrilled. I'm proud to announce. And you should be. You study more and you learn something.

The second day of the year, these words pop up the most is when they have to recertify 10 years from now. And then all you hear is this did nothing for me. I got no extra money. I've got to pay to recertify, which my post questions. You knew this was the case. You've looked around. You've solved everything. You don't get any more money. I don't care about the money. I care about my patients. And then something happens in 10 years where like people, they age like milk. It just sours completely. And 10 years later, people like this is stupid.

This is bull crap. You all got sold a bill of goods. And I'm like, my man, it wasn't just fine print. It was in the headline. Their ego took a hit because they realized that there was no ROI or other than, I mean, maybe some, but like not, it's not going to get you a pay raise. And then they post online. They're mad. They're like, I have to pay to recertify. You should be paying me. Right. So, um, yeah. So there's like a little bit of like a buyer's divorce 10 years later. Yup. And it's so funny to like paying for this and I've got to prove that I'm good. Who are you? I'm like, guys, no, nothing changed this. If there's anything in like most education is like, trust me, it doesn't.

change quickly. This was the same a decade ago when you bought in. You changed. Or I should say some things that you wanted to change didn't change and you're mad about it. And I get it. But the same token, read the fine print. Yeah. All right. Let's do parting shots. Oh, man. I'll start. So the challenge of productizing your own service is no different than any other endeavor. No different than starting a course, starting a practice, starting any other type of gig. I hope more therapists do it. I hope that folks will follow what Tony has done and expand on that and create the next McKenzie, create the next motion release.

Get out of your own head, get in front of people. And I agree with Tony's kind of overall theme, which is like, you got to get it out there. You can help more therapists, you can help more people, more patients. But the crux is, would they want it? And you're not going to know if they want it until you offer something and you say it's this much money and let's do that exchange. And then you may or may not have a business.

Will Boyd is here. Thank you, Will. He shared a video, a Hormozy video with us that I want to talk about next week. Yes, yes, yes. They started Concierge. They have brick and mortar. They've raised their prices multiple times. They're still not earning a profit. Wow. And so I tell you, as much as I hear all the complaints about affordability and nobody makes money and how do we buy a house, every time I watch the Hormozy videos and webinars and stuff, there are so many people in the seven-figure range with just random businesses.

um the money is all over the place it's just understanding a couple simple principles of you know exchanging value that's it jimmy uh i would say there's probably more ways to make a living the way you want to do than there are to make a living the normal the easy way this the the opposite of what chris corner if you guys look him up he would call them boring businesses right there's there's ways to do this The mistake I think we make is we try to say, well, how would I scale this to 50 states and 4,000 people on day one? First of all, see if you want to do it, right? Pick your heart. I mean, I feel like if we ranked all of our parting shots, I think I have like three that I just cycle through, but I say them in different ways. Choose your own heart. Make sure you understand what business you're in and ask yourself that. But like, there really is more opportunity there is than there is this opportunity, in my opinion. And nothing says you can't do both. I give this talk all the time where I say, go get a nine to five job, get someone to pay you for 40 hours, turn your brain off, do whatever you want there, and then do stuff on the side that satisfies an itch. I've always done that.

As out of the box as Jimmy McKay is, I'm not. I'm using air quotes there on a podcast. I've always had like, I'll take the nine to five and then five o'clock on Friday, I'll fly somewhere and do a weird thing. That makes me feel good. I feel safe, but I scratch the itch. You can do that too. It doesn't need to just be any of the things that we mentioned today. It's your version. All right, let's make sure we talk about Will's video next week. Enjoy your weekend. We're back on Tuesday. That's it. We're out. Boys, what the hell are you doing? Follow Tony Merritt. And hey, here's a reminder. None of this was for advice. This was for entertainment only. Our lawyers say that counts. Thanks, Keegan.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy?

This episode is 54 minutes long.

When was this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode published?

This episode was published on August 24, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.