You're listening to the Money Web SAFM market update podcast. With the fuel price set to come down at midnight tonight across all grades of petroleum, diesel and other... We're going to be taking a closer look at the fuel conversation and taking a look at the latest conversations that took place at the Fuels Industry Association of South Africa's recent gathering. We're going to explore the impact of refining and importing on the South African fuel conversation and more importantly on South African fuel prices. And joined on the line by Executive for Insights at Africa International Advisors, Henry Gilfillan, to take a look at this and see what to make of it. Henry, lovely having you on the show as always. Thanks so much for taking the time. Is there a significant enough case to be made for...
either importing or refining and the impact that either has on the fuel prices. I mean, certainly if the recent fuel price increases or anything to go by as a result of the tensions in the Middle East, one would probably not be on the side of importing as much as perhaps before. Yeah, thank you, Jimmy. Thank you for the opportunity and good afternoon to you and your listeners. I think the essential question is, you know, will us restoring and bringing back our refining industry that once, you know, was a good deal larger than it is today, bringing that back make any difference to the price you and I pay at the pump? And I think the challenge that we have and, you know...
We all would love to see lower fuel prices, firstly. And I think, secondly, we'd all love to see greater investment in South Africa that creates jobs and brings economic growth. The problem that you have is there's a lot more to the fuel price than just the actual act of refining. And, in fact, in the numbers that we showed today at the FIASA webinar, the actual refining, if you look at the cost of a litre of petrol... at the pump, the actual cost of the refining component, if you're lucky, makes somewhere between 10% or 20% of the overall cost. The rest is all sitting either in the crude oil price or in the various taxes and levies that get added on the actual fuel price. So the actual refining margin is a really small portion of the overall cost of fuel. And then you've got to ask yourself the question, well, even in that 10% or 20% that sits within the refinery, will investing in a new refinery in South Africa actually change those costs? And I think that's quite a complicated question with a number of challenges.
Henry, but let's take a look at the downstream impact and the value chain impacts of having refining capacity in South Africa. Yes, the fuel price that we import in terms of the crude price we import is out of our control. But at the moment, when there is a global crisis such as this, other countries that are refining the fuels are able to then add that premium from the base cost that they acquire it at. Surely we would then be able to eliminate that premium to some degree. And it would also allow us as a country to hold stock reserves of crude, knowing that we have the capacity to refine them.
I mean, I think there's two issues that you raised. So the one is, you know, the actual value add of having a refinery in a country. And there's undoubtedly, you know, some value that gets added. But I think, again, you've got to look at the overall market dynamics globally. And the problem that you have is it's an industry that is changing quite dramatically. Firstly, there's a lot of uncertainty as to the long-term outlook for demand for liquid fuels. We're seeing a big penetration of electric vehicles. So, you know, the actual offtake of the product is beginning to look a little bit more uncertain. You know, that's the first dynamic. The second dynamic is that...
The refineries that are being built these days are significant scale refineries. You're talking some of the refineries being built in India, just completed in India, a million barrels per day sort of number, which exceeds our total domestic market. And the problem with that sort of industry is refineries at that scale are able to outcompete much smaller refineries. South Africa's largest refinery historically was in the 140,000, 150,000 barrel per day range. And just your costs per unit are just too high to compete against these mega refineries. So the question is, if you want to add that value in country, can you do that competitively? And I think what we were raising is that there are
of significant challenges that South Africa would face in doing that, you know, to actually be able to add that value. And then the second part of your question is really around storage. And you're right, it is, you know, storing crude oil is, you know, we have that storage capacity already built, but you can store refined products as well. And, you know, that has some complexities to it. And at the moment, the challenge that I think South Africa has is not so much a lack of refining capacities, but actually the storage of the final product in situ. So I think while points you raise or the questions you raise are valid, I think the answer is a lot more complex as to whether we can actually do this competitive in a way that adds value as opposed to destroying value for the country.
Speaking of adding value to the country, Henry, should we be pursuing the conversations around synthetic fuels and refining of synthetic fuels more actively as South Africa? South Africa is one of the most unique countries in that we have the ability to process coal to synthetic fuels as evidenced by Sasol. We also have the ability to process natural gas to synthetic fuels. Should we be pursuing those as potential alternatives given that the country is able to pursue those and that might reduce our reliance on crude, at least from our own perspective? Yeah, I mean, I'd frame the question a little differently. And I'll get to your question about coal-to-liquids and gas-to-liquids now. But South Africa has two other opportunities that would make us a lot less dependent, in fact, potentially make us an exporter of transportation fuels. The one is we have the opportunity to explore and produce oil in South Africa. We've seen Namibia making huge strides just north of our border in producing oil. And those resources may well be sitting south of the border in South Africa. So that is one option, definitely a lot cheaper than potentially building more coal-to-liquids. And then the second option that we have is the advent and...
rapid growth in electric mobility, where we have the opportunity to produce the electricity locally, distribute it, and develop an electric vehicle fleet, which we've seen happen in Europe to a very large extent. So those two levers can also be pulled. And I think to answer your question directly around coal to liquids and gas to liquids, the challenge we have at the moment, we don't have domestic gas, firstly. And then secondly, around coal to liquids, it's a very expensive technology with huge investments required up front. It was enabled in the pre-94 days, really, because the apartheid government needed energy security. But it's a very expensive option to do. If it was cheaper, you would see a lot more coal to liquids plants being built. So I think there are other options that we must pursue very, very definitely to improve our resilience in terms of exploring for oil.
in South Africa and also looking at options such as growing our electric mobility a lot quicker. The fuel challenges that confront South Africa might not be going away anytime soon, but South Africa does have alternatives it can pursue if we are looking to improve our resilience in this regard. We'll have to leave the conversation on that particular note. Henry Gilfillan, the Executive for Insights at Africa International Advisors, joining us to take a look at the refining conversation, the fuel importation conversation and how South Africa can build its own resilience. You've been listening to another MoneyWeb SAFM market update podcast, uploaded weekdays at 7pm.
For more MoneyWeb podcasts, go to moneyweb.co.za or the app and follow MoneyWeb News for daily updates.