Skip to content
Can The Media Do Better On Palestine? episode artwork

May 20, 2021 40 min

Can The Media Do Better On Palestine?

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week an important discussion about how the media has covered the Israel and Gaza conflict and does the media need to change its coverage. Monica Attard speaks with Sophie McNeil and Hugh Riminton.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Can The Media Do Better On Palestine?

0:00 40:45
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and direct your device across the globe by podcast. I'm Mike Atard. Well, as the calls for a ceasefire between Israel and Palestine grow internationally, we turn this week to how the media in Australia has covered the ongoing death and destruction there.

Many in the media think the way our newsrooms cover this issue has helped lead to a distorted picture of the crisis and they wanted to change. At the time of recording, over 680 journalists and others had signed an open letter calling for a new way and a major pushback on the traditional way the media has covered Palestine. In this edition, we ask is our media guilty of both side-arism on this issue? Or is this simply an issue the Australian media is ill-equipped to cover because of its complexity and our distance from it?

To discuss these important issues, we're joined by two very qualified and experienced journalists. Sophie McNeil is a former ABC foreign correspondent. She's covered the Middle East extensively, including Gaza. She's also the author of We Can't Say We Didn't Know and She Now Works for Human Rights Watch.

Hugh Riminton is the National Affairs Editor for 10 News First. He's also worked at CNN in Hong Kong from where he reported on Asia, including China. Welcome to your both. Sophie, I'll start with you.

You've reported from Gaza and you've seen this conflict from the ground. Is Australian media in your mind covering this latest outbreak of conflict will for an Australian audience? No, I don't think they are. I think what's happened is that people are really paralyzed by fear.

They cover this conflict unlike any other stories. They know how controversial it is. They get scared. They told it to conflict so you don't understand.

So they just shy away and it's really disappointing that this is on office for many years. When I was there in the middle, I was really strongly back by the agency. I had a brilliant foreign editor at the time who really looked after me and the whole organization backed me when I came under attack. But I think other people saw how I was treated.

I had a member of parliament take out ads and defaminated, criticized me in a newspaper. It was really stressful, really stressful. I was more than 10 years in the region. I was really confident calling things out for what they were.

And yet it was still incredibly stressful. I think journalists watch that. They get fearful. And they just avoid.

That's a hard issue, unfortunately. So in your mind, the problem right now lies with the reporters rather than with editors? No, I think it actually mainly rests on editors because they also know how many times reporters have gone to editors when they get pushed back. I know that from having covered this story.

That when I pitched something on Israel Palestine, it was treated differently to any other story. And it's got to end. It really clouds the public. So if you can just interrupt there when you say treated differently, talk us through that.

What does that look like? You pitch a story to you? Yeah, so there's hesitation. There's, oh, you know, okay, but who are you talking to?

And there's there is a level of editorial involvement in a story on Israel Palestine that you cannot compare to any other story. I covered Yemen. I covered ISIS. I covered China.

Unlike any other story I've ever covered, that the hesitation and the concern and going out of the way to make sure both sides, you know, no other stories treated in that way, no other conflict is treated in that way. And that harms the public's understanding of this story and harms the coverage in a really damaging way. Okay, so just to be clear, you're saying that hesitation is not in covering it at all, but in the manner in which it's covered so that they're insisting that it be... No, God, no, even covering it at all.

Can we be bothered with dealing with the complaints? And have we, are we sure we're going to get the right voices so that we don't get any seem to be fair? And yeah, it's whether to even cover it at all? And then how that coverage happens if it's actually even commissioned?

Okay, now here what's your take on the Australian media's coverage thus far of this latest outbreak of conflict? What is interesting to listen to Sophie, who I enormously respect as a reporter and I respect an decision to go and now work for Human Rights Watch, you know, to use a voice in a different way, the notion that we're not covering the story or avoiding the story in day-to-day terms, we don't like in normal times we don't. But in this period that we're in at the moment, in the last, you know, nearly two weeks, it has been covered. It's been either the lead story or certainly high in the first break in all the stories that network 10 has been carrying, you know, so who I would work for.

And you, I'm not saying, you know, of course we're covering this war, I'm talking about the day-to-day that doesn't get covered. So normal times, of course it was going to, you know, lead commercial news. But it's the day-to-day on Israel Palestine that people avoid. And I've seen tense coverage of this conflict and I think sometimes it's even better than the ABCs actually, more willing to say, to call things out for what they are.

Thank you. Well, I just see it as being, I see it as being reporting. And so when you talk about the both sides issues of it, I think if you simply report what's in front of this and the course of this current conflict, then people can see that there is a, you know, there is a total difference in the death toll, you know, the destruction, the ruination of infrastructure within Gaza compared with what's happening on the other side, you just simply report it and people can filter out from that their own, you know, their own sense that this is, you know, as I described it in one of the stories this week, it's a David and Goliath battle. I mean, this time, you know, it is Israel that is the Goliath and as it has been now for many years.

So, you know, to me, there are two issues and I think Sophie's pointing it up there a little bit is when it flares up into the point of being a war, it has our attention. What we're not seeing is the day-to-day processes, we don't get lost in the weeds as we might see it in, for example, the political collapse and paralysis that's happened within Israel, you know, series of elections, this kind of, this period in which there's no clear democratic resolution to their political problems. And then in the middle of it comes a war which is to some degree political convenient to Benjamin Netanyahu. We don't go into the business of the politics of the paralysis of the politics, if you like, within particularly Gaza, but also on the West Bank.

We don't go and do those stories towards a general Australian audience. Our audience is fundamentally suburban Australia. You know, they've got other concerns and if people have particularly interested in those things, they can go to more specialist outlets to go and have a look at it. Well, that actually brings me to the next point though.

I mean, do you think that in a conflict like this, which has gone on for so long, there's been, you know, since 87 over 14,000 people have died in this conflict, 87% of those deaths have been on the Palestinian side. Do you think that we've become both as an audience and as journalists that we've kind of become a little bit desensitized to it? I think, you know, there's this whole kind of approach of the museum, you know, more of the saying what's different, what's different. So it's always really hard to convince your editors, but this is significant, you know, this latest route of House Demolition, or, you know, there were four kids shocked this Friday in a demonstration.

How's it different to last week? Yes, it's really hard to keep up, you know, any interest in the daily grind of what is, you know, an military occupation in the West Bank, you know, it's been going on for more than 50 years, hasn't gotten worse than worse than worse. So how do you capture that at the daily story, you know, and two points out, yeah, like it is, it's very difficult for Australian organizations to put, you know, that level of detailing to their daily reporting, because it isn't the headline stuff, you know, it's that, that, that daily, the daily humiliation, so the daily, you know, human rights violations that we see, that gets to the point we are today, you know, and this is, I mean, it's a problem of all views, isn't it? That suddenly the focus is on, you know, it's all on the last week, rather than the decades that got off to where we are.

And I think that's what human rights, what you're trying to do now is change the discourse, change the language, to try and capture that daily grind of occupation and human rights abuse, and what we're saying is that Israel is guilty of committing the crime against humanity of apartheid. And that is a powerful word to use. And by using that word, we're saying that's the level of abuse, that's where it's gotten to, and that, you know, this should change how we refer to the Israeli government and the conflict there. So language is very important here, and we specifically, you know, come out and said this after years of research, this report we put out three weeks ago, years and years and years of putting into collecting all that evidence.

So that's one way of trying to change the discourse and capture that daily grind, so it doesn't make the headlines. So here, would your editors, A, allow you, if you were so inclined to cover the day to day grind, that leads up to these outbreaks of conflict that actually kill people. And secondly, would they allow you to use the word apartheid? Well, so two questions, and the first one is I don't think you can cover it unless you're on the ground.

And we're not on the ground. We don't keep a middle east office, none of the commercial broadcasters keep that. I spend a lot of time going in and out of the middle east, I have done for 25 years, I took my daughter on a trip when she was 13 there just a couple of years ago, late 2019, because I wanted her to be aware of what was going on. We stayed in Jerusalem, we visited the West Bank, we went across to Jordan and so on.

And that was just a rapid fire sort of education for her. Great idea as to how that goes. But I do think it's, there's plenty of agency, what vision comes in every day out of the middle east. Do we form that up into stories?

I think you need to be on the ground. And what's really disappointing is that Australians outlet have close to many offices there. So fair fact, you should have a correspondent based in Jerusalem. The Australian is to have a correspondent based there.

So we're really not getting as much coverage as we used to. Well, indeed, in fact, the ABC had a correspondent in Jerusalem and one in Beirut. So within a couple hundred kilometers of each other, you had two correspondents, although they were covering a wide field as you know, better than most. So if you so, so that business of reporting what's going, if I just put a counterfactual in that, I think some people might argue that it is the most over reported parts of the conflict zones in the world, because we're not expending as much effort at airtime on what might be happening, for example, in Myanmar, or in, you know, we can't get into see what's really going on with the Uighurs in Western China.

We, you know, so that there are sort of calamities of events going on in the world that are getting substantially ignored. The Middle East gets covered in its highly contested space. And the argument about, you know, just keeps going on what's new in this, et cetera. This is the central tragedy of the Middle East, is that the conflicts have no path to resolution.

There is a theoretical path that's been laid down. It's been it's been laid out again by Tor Wenner's land is it the special coordinator of the UN, you know, in the talks and the UN sessions and security council sessions have been taking place in recent days. It still goes down to a viable two-state solution with Jerusalem as a capital for both the Palestinians and for the Jews, the state of Israel. You know, but there are, you know, I was there in 96 when the Oslo process basically collapsed finally with the election of Bibi Netanyahu.

And, you know, back then it seemed as if there might be a path to peace, but there hasn't been one in 25 years. Okay. So you know, does the way the media covers this story make any difference in the end? If there's no resolution, there's no prospect for resolution?

Well, I think, sorry, sorry, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I was going to say that what's fascinating, I think, this course is slowly changing in the US, for example. And I think it's social media.

You know, I think Palestinians are increasingly getting their version of events and video or, you know, what's happening on the ground out through social media. And I think it's really interesting to see that, you know, it wasn't really, thanks to any reporting, but it was more, you know, individuals telling their stories and that you can't, you know, matter that, you know, all the pressure on journalists and how you report this story and the pressure we all know that the Israeli lobby does put on don't let you know, experience it very much myself. That doesn't, you know, impact people's social media accounts, things that go viral. So that's something that they can't control.

And that's really interesting. I think we're not replacing the impact of that now as it is, of course, is slowly changing. Okay, here, what do you think? Well, I think social media, like all social media is there to present a point.

And that's fine. It's good to see voices amplified in that way. A reporter's job is not simply to be social media, reporter's job and theory is to provide some analysis, analysis context and so on. There is no question that life, particularly in Gaza is a hopeless proposition, almost hopeless.

I don't want to put them into that cage of hopelessness. But there is that the fundamentals haven't changed in decades in generations. And you don't see a path to that changing. And that creates this terrible frustration.

And then these periodic explosions of violence to take place, which always ends with more hammering of the infrastructure within Gaza. You know, the UN has been in charge of pouring billions of dollars in since the last big confrontation in 2014 to try and rebuild infrastructure in Gaza. Much of that has been destroyed by the slightest effort. Much of it was winnowed away in corruption and graft as well.

No doubt. Some of it we're told was went into, a lot of the reinforced concrete went into the tunnel systems that have now been hammered. That was a mass tunnel system. So, you know, there's a sense of long-term hopelessness and that is not good.

It's not good for the Palestinian people. It's not good for humanity in general. There has to be ultimately a path out of this. But no one is moving towards that path.

And just very quickly, on the question of the word apartheid, I don't like the word apartheid applied to this. I understand why it might be used. You know, I reported on South Africa, as many reporters do. I heavily involved in the commitment of my life as a journalist was heavily involved in reporting the apartheid regime going way back to the very early 1980s.

And I kind of feel as if every appalling circumstance kind of deserves its own name. The thing to do is that apartheid now is a crime on international law. If not just saying it's like South Africa. Apartheid after the horror of apartheid in South Africa, the international legal system defined apartheid as a crime, a crime against humanity.

And so, that's what we're saying. We're saying that the evidence on the ground meets that threshold of apartheid as defined under the Rome statute. So, it's not just saying it's like South Africa. It is a...

Now, because of that horror there, there's maybe this crime that we're saying. Well, I don't... There's no question. It doesn't matter, particularly what the word is.

There is no question that the building of settlements on occupied territory in the West Bank is a crime against humanity. It's certainly a crime against the Palestinian people. And the deepest offense related to that is that it removes... With every passing week, month, year, it removes the prospect of it coming to a point of peace.

So, essentially, it is locking in a disastrous outcome for everyone. And everyone's position on this in the Israeli... If you look at Israel, the move that existed in Israel in the early 1990s, with Bibi Netanyahu, as initially seen when he first emerged as a kind of a right-wing, not to be taken too seriously type of guy, super-glib. The whole country has moved towards him over the subsequent 25 years.

Obviously, he's not... His political standing has been damaged by corruption, by a whole bunch of other things. But in terms of the overall view, it has moved into a more bellicose, more unforgiving position. And equally, you've got Hamas.

There's nothing in Hamas' charter or in its intentions that say that it's there as a willing partner to peace. The people of Gaza are not being offered elections to sort out what they want out of this process, free and fair elections. So, those are also issues that can't be... I could be accused of both sides of them here, but that's exactly the truth of it.

So, there are different sides. There are stories, and you can't tell the story, without reflecting on what are the internal pressures on each of these two warring parties and their populations, and how does that play out in the overall strategic school with it? Okay, can I just take you both now to this open letter that's been signed by journalists, media workers, writers, commentators, some 680 of them, and it's directed to editors and publishers demanding of them that they make space for Palestinian perspectives and that they avoid both side-arism and they respect the rights of journalists to have a view and be able to publicly express solidarity with the Palestinians. So, I guess my question is, are these sensible demands and goals when you're covering a conflict like this, or are they really just missing the whole point of the media, particularly on that last point, having journalists being able to publicly express solidarity with the Palestinians, which sounds very, very much like picking aside?

Hugh? Well, I've seen that later and I wouldn't sign it. Part of that is because my life in journalism, I'm not a petition signer. I think that we do have a role, if we have any role that's left to us, it is actually to try to, you know, that business of both side-arism is being a negative thing.

In fact, you know, there's never going to be any resolution. You know, go back to Sunzoo, it's about no your enemy and know yourself. You've got to see both or all sides. You need to report what's going on and journalism has a role in that.

I do think that there's a line between being a reporter and being an activist and reporters do a valuable role as reporters, activists do a valuable role as being an activist. And I think it is highly commendable to see someone like Sophie go from being a reporter to being a century human rights activist, to being a voice to putting a flag down on the ground and saying, I am now for human rights. This is where I see the problems. This is how I'm going to devote my life.

One of my most, my colleague, Steve Levitt, who was a cameraman that I worked with who introduced me to and took me around places in Africa, northern Uganda and southern Sudan and those civil wars, et cetera, in the 1990s, later went on to work for World Vision. I applaud him for that. There's a guy called Larry Lester, who now runs Humans Without Borders in the Middle East, which is involved in getting Palestinian, sick Palestinians, so not war zone injured, but people have got ordinary things needing dialysis for kidneys, et cetera, cancer treatments, and is involved in bringing Palestinians to Israeli hospitals for better treatment by an Australian outfit called Project Rosanna. He was a journalist.

It is good for journalists to become activists. They see stuff. It's good to get fired up and do it. But at that point, you're not a reporter.

And I think that activist is good. Reporter is good. There is a church in state between the two. Sophie, does avoiding both sides of the main that you've got to pick aside?

Oh, absolutely not. What we want is we want this conflict to be covered like any other. And when I was covering Syria, did I go out of my way to give the person dropping the bombs, the deployment of you, or when I covered Yemen, did I go out of my way to get that one of you? What I'm saying is it needs to be covered like any other conflict.

And yes, you need to look at that story that day and cover it as it should be covered. A six-year-old Israeli child was told by a rocket a few days ago. Yes, the death hole in the other, but that story was that today's story. Because that victim that day, what I'm saying is that you have to pick each day for as it is and cover it like every other conflict.

Whereas right now in newsroom is your Palestine, people get nervous, people are full of fear and trepidation about complaints about pressure from the Israeli lobby and they cover it differently. I know that they're very clear. I know that they're very clear. But when a petition says that it wants a journalist to be able to publicly express solidarity with the Palestinians, that feels to me like it's just strikingly dangerously close to asking journalists to pick your side.

Yeah, I think that there are a lot of problems with that. And I think as Middle East correspondent for the ABC, I would certainly not have signed that letter. I think what that letter reflects is a deep concern that exists because everybody knows about the pressures, play for journalists over this particular story, right? And then they know about the fear and the trepidation.

So I think this petition reflects really accurate concern. There should be more debate about how much attention is given to the lobby and how our editors engage with those people because they don't know another story. So why is this one any different? So we're not saying, I'm not saying that you should prioritize anyone for it except for who's suffering on that day.

That's who I want to be prioritized. And I want the truth and the fact to be called out. And just be like our language, which is a point of it's an illegal occupation of the West Bank. It's a little bit irreligious.

It's a little bit illuminous, it's a little bit occupied. All that kind of language that we get too scared to use. But that's the fact, what we are calling for it human rights, what is the fact and the truth to be prioritized and those who are suffering. And I feel that often you don't get to see that sometimes in the coverage of Israel Palestine.

Okay, so sorry, I forgot one. Well, and also we just cover it in a vacuum, like we can't understand how much this point. So what we're saying is that it's not about just the last few weeks, it's about death A.T.R. of the people who have no civil rights.

Right. So I think it's really interesting in the way that Black Lives Matter meets who in a bit struggle of the Palestinians is one of equality. Right. And that's how we're saying it should be seen.

It shouldn't be seen as this, this vacuum of this conflict today, what's happening in Gaza, it needs to be seen within the context of the people who for more than 50 years have been living under a military occupation and have no rights. And that's where we're trying to focus the conversation now as a human rights group. Okay, now I want to take you both back briefly to the role of a reporter, particularly when they're covering conflict and having had the experience myself. I think it's very, very difficult to detach yourself and avoid getting too involved with the story that you're covering.

First of all, I'd like to ask both of you, have you been in a situation where you have found it really, really difficult to detach? And does that, has that ever led you into a situation where your reportage reflects that attachment in a kind of objectively dangerous way? You look, I think so. And I completely sympathetic with Sophie when she says, you know, if you're there with people who are dying at a particular time, that is the story, you know, the fact of children, the stuff that Sophie reported out of Yemen in particular, see it on the mind.

It's a terrible, terrible circumstances of children dying totally unnecessarily. And I've seen the same things in the Civil War in Sudan and South Sudan in the 1990s. And when you're there with those people, when you're in a bomb shelter or when you're, you know, you're reporting their circumstance. And you're quite right.

You're not, you're not making dialing up, you know, if you had a number, you're not dialing up the guy who's ordering the bombs to come in and saying, look, I'm just down here, you know, once you're inside of what's going on right now, because, because in a sense, that's not necessary to telling a story. I don't think, unless you're taking a total eagle view over everything that they did in the course in the middle of a conflict, you know, you can be sufficiently detached as to not tell the story that's in front of you. And so is there a danger in that? Yes, it's an ancient danger of reporting, I suppose.

But there's no question that you need to show one of the things. I'm reading the biography of Marie Colvin, the great war correspondent who was killed in Syria at the moment. And, you know, she spent so much of her time, she said she was interested in humanity in extremists in war, what happens, what it looks like. And I relate to that, I think that your job at certain times is to be there in the weeds with the people who are suffering and say, this is what is happening to these people now.

And that is part of your duty. And Sophie, do you think it's too big an ask of a journalist to remain detached, particularly in covering conflict? I mean, personally, I don't know, what do you think? I mean, I think that's what can be wrong with journalism these days.

The idea that you should be this detached robot, you know, you're dealing with human beings, their light, you know, their face, you have to get close and personal. I think that's the best journalism. It's not saying you're not accurate, but you're not reporting the fact that you're not verifying everything and double checking it. That doesn't make that redundant.

I mean, I think you have to get close, you know, you have to be right there with them and find out how they feel. And I think too often we have in journalism education, I think it's become too academic, you know, this idea of the detached reporter being, you know, totally objective. No, objective is like, I'm an unachimilian. I'm a woman.

I'm a mother. Like I'm not, you know, I am not some robot who's going to just, you know, stand there and kind of try and act detached. No, I think people want up close personal reporting because that's all the audience is the same. You know, they say, they, they, I think if you react the way any normal person looks, you know, like I've been in a situation like she was talking about Yemen coverage in an emergency room in Yemen where the starving, you know, little boy won't won't get into the intensive care because no one's got 20 bucks to pay it.

So I paid it, you know, because did I overstep the line, you know, you know, was I not objective? Was that going to harm my reporting? No, I was just reacting as a human, you know, and I think people appreciate that in reporting. I think it's silly to try and pretend you can be some kind of objective robot who doesn't react in a way that most of us would if we were in that situation.

So here, what do you think? Do you think that the, you know, the ethical codes by which we've all grown up as reporters where it's demanded of us that we remain detached, so we remain the cool observers that we remain objective, do they serve us well in in war zones when we're in those situations? Well, it's interesting. There's nothing actually in the code of ethics that says we have to remain cool, lead detached.

It says that we should, you know, be striver accuracy, of course, and fairness and disclosure of all essential facts and don't give disnoting emphasis. And I think that's all fair. I think I've never felt, in fact, ethically troubled reporting on any war zone or conflict zone reporting on what's on the ground. It's never troubling me.

And it also felt that one of the key things you do as a journalist, as opposed to say academics and politicians and the diplomatic corps and all that kind of stuff, is that you are allowed to go on the ground and see what's happening on the ground. And that's why journalists often bell the cat when things are going wrong. Or when plainly leaders are feeding the world bullshit, is you say, no, have a look at this. This is what I saw today.

How does this fit with the narrative that's coming up? So you do challenge power and you do challenge those things by the mere fact of what's on the ground of your reportage. So, you know, I've often felt that journalism is one of the most ethical things you can do as a foreign reporter. You know, if people are constrained by that, you know, I understand that if you say go to North Korea, it is perceived and understood that you're not going to be reporting for, you know, that you're under those constraints.

But that's understood by your audience and you go to warn your audience of what's going on. I've never been to North Korea, so I don't know. But everywhere else I've been in China, you know, in Saddam Hussein's Iraq, under the apartheid regime in South Africa, when it was still driven by the whites, you know, I've always felt that your job is to get to what is the truth on the ground. And that's often embarrassing to power.

And you take your chops as you go. And just a small thing I'll work soficets. And I realize the difference between working for commercial media and working for public media is that public media has complaint processes, just in commercial media as well. But the structure of the complaint process and public media, because it's public money that is funding the outlet, it may be that as Sophie calls it, the Israel lobby will focus more of its attention on the ABC than maybe something as insignificant and hard to influence as a commercial outfit like Channel 10.

You know, I've in my reporting from a distance on the latest war in in the Middle East, you know, there've been grumbles from individuals and a few complaints and all that kind of stuff. But but I haven't had any formal approaches or complaints at all. And you know, I've had some messages of thanks from people who aligned with the Palestinian cause, but I don't think I've done anything to cozy up. You simply report what you think is going on to the best of your ability.

Okay. And Sophie, can I end up by asking you, and I'll put this question to both of you, but but somebody who's now standing outside of journalism, but having been in its belly in a very, very dramatic way covering conflict for all the years that you have, what do you think feel as journalism looks like? Standing up to pressure, prioritizing the truth, the facts, the evidence, and coming to a conclusion and being confident in that you were there, you saw it, you're calling it out for what it is. And you know, there's all that noise that will come at you and hope it's this and that all of that and take this into account and the complaints and all this and holding your ground and saying, this is what's happening, you know, and that's, it's obvious, right?

But on the story of Israel, Palestine, it's not always obvious. And it's true what he was saying, you know, the commercials don't get it anywhere near as much as the and what I'm asking for Australian journalists to do is to not shy away from the story that they told it's so complex. I'm asking them to treat it like any other story, you know, you wouldn't sit down and meet with lovely groups around back to those with other stories. So don't, with this one, treat it like any other story where you're focusing on the facts and the evidence and that you, as that expert, he put that time in and he's on the ground and spoken the people and waited all up that you can make the call of what the story is.

So I'm saying it'd be great. That's my call in my art. Okay, Hugh, I imagine that you'd agree with much of that, but the final leg in Sophie's description is come to a conclusion. Is that something that you agree with?

Well, sometimes on stories that I've done, I've said, this is just one person's perspective in this wider war. You know, so, you know, I've reported, I remember reporting, for example, I was out on patrol with an American patrol in Baghdad during the surge came under fire with all this sort of business going on. And then afterwards, I interviewed him and he said the war was a waste of time, basically. He said, we got to be the place worse than we came here and the people who have supported us will then feel the rough as he pronounced it.

And he was dead accurate. He was a sergeant who'd been in there for four years by that stage for most of four years. And it was exactly against the official line that was coming out of the United States about how well the war was going and so on. And I just said, look, this is one guy's perspective, but he's earned the right to have it.

And it doesn't matter. You can say that in any, you know, you don't have to claim that the experience of anybody inside a war, even though it's even a village that are being bombed, you report that. And you acknowledge that it's just one part of a war. So you can do that.

What's fearless journalism? I still think it is getting on the ground and having editors willing to put people into the risk when budgets are tightening, we know that they are. But it's having a go to find out for yourself what's going on in the report, which you see. That's great.

Thank you very, very much on that note. I think we'll say goodbye. Thank you both Sophie McNeil and Hugh Remington. That was a fantastic discussion.

And I hope we have you both back on Fourth Estate very soon. Great to talk. Thanks, my God. Thank you.

Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Thank you both. And on that note, I'd like to thank you Sophie McNeil and Hugh Remington for your time. And thanks for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SCR and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network.

Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, thanks to them for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media, politics and everything in between. We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is Fourth Estate AU.

Thanks to my producer Anthony Dockroal, as always. My name's Monica Atard, and thank you for listening. I say for Ontario. I mean, some more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen.

It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to wear me when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario.

For all of us. Learn how at ontario.ca. Safer Ontario. Pay for by the Government of Ontario.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 40 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on May 20, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.