Can We Write a Better Script Than Chris Stuckman?

Chris Stuckmann has been talking about movies on youtube for almost 15 years, and he has finally put his money where his mouth is and mad his own movie. Shelby Oaks is a loveletter to all of Chris Stuckmann's favorite movies and genres, but is there enough of his own ideas in there to make it his own story? Does 15 years of reviewing movies make you a good filmmaker?