Skip to content
Can you Pre-Launch TOO Early? episode artwork

Jan 18, 2026 33 min

Can you Pre-Launch TOO Early?

from ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! Hosted by Tyler James

Last year, there was an increased focus on pre-launch, with Kickstarter making a number of platform changes enabling creators to get their pre-launch pages up earlier and with less friction, and make visible the conversion power of pre-launch followers. As a result, many creators are bumping up their pre-launch plans. However, is there such a thing as pre-launching too early? Tyler shares some indicators that there might be... Let's discuss.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Can you Pre-Launch TOO Early?

0:00 33:51
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

All right, comic crowdfunders, you're going to want to listen to this one before you go live with that pre-launch page. Comics Launch Session 547. Can you pre-launch too early? Today's session is brought to you by Comic Impressions, a US-based comic and graphic novel printer specializing in both small digital and large offset print runs. Go to ComicImpressions.com to submit a quote or request a free printing sample and use discount code CL05 to get 5% off your entire order. Hello friends, Tyler James is here with you and this is another episode of the Comics Launch Podcast and on today's episode we are going to talk about pre-launch, pre-launch followers, and...

Can you actually pre-launch too early? This is a topic and pre-launch has been a subject of several recent, semi-recent episodes of the Comics Launch podcast. And pre-launch has sort of gotten a renewed life, even though from the very beginning of this show, we talked about how important it is that you have to put the crowd before the funding. But pre-launch has definitely been a topic that I know a lot of veteran creators are thinking more about and just trying to find new ways to build a buzz so that their launch does not begin with crickets. And so I'm hoping on this episode.

that we can dive in and talk a little bit about this because in the past, I think I've leaned into the concept that the longer the runway that you have, the faster the takeoff and that the seeds for a very big and successful launch are often planted months, if not years in advance. And all of that is still true, but I do want to share some interesting data that I've seen recently. And it's anecdotal for sure, but I think it may shine some light on some things and give some things for you to keep in mind as you do your planning. We in the comics launch community try to be data driven as best we can while at the same time. focusing on doing work that lights us up and putting really cool creative projects out there. So we have to balance it all.

Before I do do that, oh, I did want to just say that I do have a Kickstarter that's live for a book that I wrote. Epic numbers one through five is live on Kickstarter. You can check that out at comictribe.com forward slash epic five, which will redirect you over to the Kickstarter. Epic is my fun tale. It's kind of like a palate cleanser compared to all of the darker, heavier, scarier, creepier, bloodier stuff that Comics Tribe is usually known for. It is about as far away from sync as you can get, while I think still maintaining the kind of quality that Comics Tribe is known for. But Epic is sort of, it was my palate cleanser.

that I would write after I would sort of work on either like a really twisted, dark superhero tale for the Red 10 or Oxymoron and working on that series. But Epic was the flip side, the light side, the bright side, the here's everything we love about the superhero comics medium, just unabashedly, earnestly excited about telling stories with people in capes punching each other. And the twist of it is kind of like a way to re-explore our high school years with a kind of a comedic twist. So Epic, if you've never heard of it, never heard me talk about it. He is a teenage superhero, gets incredible powers.

but his powers turn off whenever he's around people he's attracted to. So in this particular episode, we're finally pitting him face-to-face against what will be his nemesis, the sinister Sinstress, who also just happens to be, of course, the sort of mean girl, the chief mean girl, most popular girl in school, class president, et cetera, at his school. But she leads a double life, much like our protagonist, Eric, does as a Sinstress. And so she has a whole scheme in place, and it's all leading up to... the big high school homecoming dance that we've been sort of leading up to. And so this is a fun issue. It's 28 pages of sequentials. There's a economical way. If you've missed any of the epic adventures over time, you can get all caught up with either the trade or we do still have some single issue packages available. And it's just, it's a breath of fresh air writing this series. It successfully resurrected by Kickstarter. I think the campaign, you know, to bring it back, which was, I think, I don't know, 18 months ago or around there, but that it did really well for us. We were really excited with how that.

did. And then some big life events came up for my artist and co-creator Matt Zolman. But man, he has put things back together, is back drawing just about every day, and is making nice strides into the next issue. And this particular issue looks great. We also have an awesome cover by Fico Osio, who is now crushing it on Batman and Robin for DC Comics. And he worked on several of the issues of Epic when Matt stepped away for a time. So I hope you'll check it out if you like superhero comics, if you want to see some heroes in caves punching.

each other if you want to see some high school hijinks come to life in sequential pages epic is just that but so let's talk about the topic today which is pre-launch and can you pre-launch too early now the seeds of this came about because inside one of my comics launch pro groups a creator shared his metrics from his Kickstarter dashboard. Now you may remember that last year Kickstarter kind of silently rolled out a subtle update to their follower conversion metrics reporting.

where it broke out pre-launch followers from live campaign followers, basically. And it also still showed your overall follower conversion rate. And again, just in case you're new to this world, a follower is someone who hits notify me about this project or remind me about this project, but is not yet a backer. Followers can then become backers once they back the project, and that would count as a converted follower. Now, what...

many folks noticed as soon as they rolled out this update was that there was actually a very big discrepancy between pre-launch followers conversion rates and post-launch followers conversion rate. In fact, for pretty consistently when I looked at commerce drive projects, our pre-launch followers were backing and converting at four to five times more likely than followers that did not follow the campaign beforehand. So followers that came through and discovered the campaign while it was live. So, and let me just, I can give you examples on some previous projects that I shared. So the conversion rate on my last Kickstarter project.

was the sync Halloween special. And we had an overall, a 50% conversion rate. So 299 converted followers out of 595 projected followers, 63% conversion rate for pre-launch followers, and just a 17% conversion rate for post-launch followers. You'll remember, and please, if you haven't listened to them, go back. There's some great episodes on pre-launch strategies. I tried some new strategies in 2025 that I will be carrying forward in 2026 and beyond. So definitely check out those because those numbers are really good.

I think that follower conversion rate was one of the better follower conversion rates that we've ever had for Sync, and a lot went into that. And so I don't want you to miss that. However, this creator that shared in the group basically shared his data, and he had about four days left to go in his campaign, I believe. His project was converting at about 14%, 41 converted followers, 290 project followers. And it appeared that this creator did not put a lot into prelaunch. He only had 25 prelaunch followers, but they were only converting at about 28%. So that's still pretty low for prelaunch follower conversions. And then his post-launch follower conversions was about 13%. Now, this particular creator mailed his Kickstarter page. Great project image, compelling premise, really good value for what he was offering. And so a lot of interest, but it was still, you know, these are relatively low project follower numbers with four days to go. And so this creator was wondering, you know, hey, I've consistently converted 30 to 35.

percent more followers across his past campaigns. And so is there another 40 backers out there based on those numbers that I should be expecting? And what ended up turning out is there were. And while I think his conversion rate ended up quite low at about 22%, this still ended up being one of his most successful Kickstarter campaigns, if not his most successful and his most back campaign and everything. I noticed after launching Epic that I was kind of seeing similar things and that the conversion rates was significantly lower for this latest Epic launch than the last sync launch that I did, for example. So just to give you some numbers here, like right now, Epic has 347 project followers, 81% converted, 23% overall conversion rate.

Of our pre-launch followers, we had 208 pre-launch followers and only 69 have converted so far. So that's a conversion rate of 33%. And in terms of post-launch followers, 139 and only 12 have converted. So that's 9%. So in one regards, I'm still seeing that pre-launch followers are worth, in this case, about a little more than three, three and a half percent times more than what a post-launch follower is worth.

That 33% conversion rate is far, far lower than the 63% conversion rate that we were able to do for sync. And so what explains that? Because I'll be honest, and I definitely talked a lot last year about how, hey, you know, knowing these numbers, realizing the value of your pre-launch followers, that can justify investing more in pre-launch advertising and other things like that. But, you know, if instead of 60% conversion or 70% conversion, in some cases you're getting 33% conversion or, and after a couple of days. it was significantly worse, then that might throw things off. Now, I also will say we are just three and a half days into launch for Epic. And I will expect that our ultimate conversion rate numbers will be significantly higher for our pre-launch followers. And perhaps we'll bump up for our post-launch followers as well. Epic, the last time we launched, we actually kind of, our launch for this one pretty much mirrored our launch for last one. And so we kind of, it was not a massive come out. It was sort of like a slow and steady adding.

backers, you know, a few backers every day. And the last launch ended up, you know, over 400 backers. I'm not sure if we're going to get that again. I think there was a certain amount of energy and excitement about bringing the series back after a long time. And we had a lot of people just jumping on board are really well and low priced catch up tiers and things like that. So there might be some other reasons why we don't sort of hit what we hit last time. Also, some of it is just, you know, what we're going to put into it in terms of promotion and other things. But one of the things that I have noticed, and one of the things that Kickstarter did last year was that they decoupled being

100% ready to launch and having your project approved from the ability to launch pre-launch pages. In fact, now you can just put in the most basic information and you can get a pre-launch page up and running. And you can have that pre-launch page up and running months, if not years in advance of when you actually do pull the trigger and launch. And as a result, many creators are doing that. Many creators are saying, hey, here's my 2026 projects and I am going to upload all of my projects to Kickstarter. We'll just set up the pre-launch pages. Now we have them and we can promote them just all year long. And that is potentially a strategy.

However, the one thing that I'm going to caution you and that I may be seeing with Epic, and again, all of the data is not in just yet, but that was something that I did with Epic. Epic, it's kind of funny. If you look at my Kickstarter dashboard, Kickstarter, and this is kind of a quirk of Kickstarter, but if you go and you log into Kickstarter and you look at your projects. Kickstarter actually lists your projects, not in the order that you launched them, but in the order that you started setting up the project. So my Epic one through five Kickstarter campaign isn't even in my top one, two, three, four projects. When I click on my profile at the Kickstarter button, I have to hit the view all and then scroll down because I started setting up the Epic project and I launched the pre-launch page for Epic. But after that, I think we launched Oxymoron Killing Time and Sync and Sync.

1 through 15, and sync City of Killers, and Grogor and Shanks number one, and my comic book crowdfunding planner, and sync Halloween special number one. So like five or six projects actually launched before Epic, even though I started setting it up and launching the Kickstarter page. And again, a lot of that just had to do with family and life stuff coming up that meant that the issue sort of had to get, the art on the issue had to put on the shelf for a longer than anticipated time. You know, when I'd set it up, I thought we were a month or two out from launching, and that didn't end up happening. But what ended up happening is I started doing some...

pretty active promotion for the pre-launch page for Epic. I even included like a, hey, go sign up for the pre-launch page included with one of our rewards. And so like there's a QR code that people could scan and that brought in a lot of people and I would promote it, you know, sporadically. over the sort of year plus that the pre-launch page was live. And as a result, even before I knew exactly when we were going to finally pull the trigger on this campaign, I had about 132 pre-launch followers on that epic list. Once, it was only a couple of weeks ago that I actually locked in and just said, okay, you know, we're doing it. It's going to be, we're going to launch it on the 14th, or sorry, the 13th of January. It's going to run until the end of January, the 31st of January, and we're locking and loading. Let's go. And I put like another solid week of

prelaunch promotion into it and was able from that to gain another hundred or so prelaunch followers. But what I am speculating, again, the data is something that I am looking at, is that a big reason why my prelaunch follower conversion rate is sort of missing the mark a little bit is that a lot of those prelaunch followers had probably been prelaunch followers for... potentially a year plus, right? They might be people that back the Kickstarter camp, the last Kickstarter campaign hit pre-launch and then haven't thought of or heard of or about Epic since. And man, that is something to keep in mind and something to keep in mind if you're going to have one of these super long runways. And so I think that's what's going on here with Epic. Again, I am not terribly concerned about it because...

The good news about a Kickstarter campaign is it's a campaign. And, you know, I still have 15 days to make sure that all of those previously warm people can get warmed up and get a nice invite to come join us. And then also to attract plenty of new people and do my best to convert those. And so I'm going to be thinking about that. But after the break, I'm just going to give some strategies to.

avoid the issue of, hey, people are jumping on your pre-launch and then they don't hear from you for months and then the project launches. But instead of pre-launch being a excitement and something that you're building towards, building towards, building towards, it's just like the launch comes and there's some disconnect. That's probably something that you're going to want to avoid with your launches and something that, unfortunately, this particular epic launch, I probably could have done a better job on that. But we'll talk about it after the break. In a moment, I'm going to give you today's comics launcher. But first, we need to thank our sponsor.

Comic Impressions team is set up to offer easy Kickstarter fulfillment for a low per package fee, which has saved me time and money and has been a lifesaver for some overseas Kickstarter creators who've relied on Comic Impressions to handle U.S. Kickstarter fulfillment. Comic Impressions also prints with top-of-the-line presses and offers some of the most popular specialty printing options. Foil stamping, spot UV, foil covers, and more. Now, I'm a big print quality snob, and while they can do offset printing, their digitally printed books are some of the best I've ever flipped through. But don't take my word for it. What I want you to do is go right now to comicimpressions.com forward slash samples and request a free sample pack that includes all of their paper stock options as well as some actual comics and graphic novels that they've printed.

that show off their digital and offset printing capabilities. I know you're going to be impressed. And if you're interested in getting a printing quote on your next project, they have a new online estimator at ComicImpressions.com that will help you ballpark your print quote. And as a featured Comics Launch sponsor, if you use discount code CL05 at checkout, you'll get an additional 5% off your order with Comic Impressions. If you're a comic creator, you need a reliable printer in your corner, and that's why I recommend ComicImpressions.com. Your Comics Launcher procession 547 is what are the prerequisites you want to have in place before you're ready to confidently start the pre-launch process.

All right, we're back. And I guess the big thing that I want you to take away from this episode is that prelaunch is a momentum game. And while Kickstarter now makes it easy for us to start an open prelaunch at any time, I'm probably going to recommend that we as creators be conscientious and thoughtful about when we activate that prelaunch page and to make sure at bare minimum that we have a momentum plan in place. so that we don't lose our pre-launch followers who, again, are among our most likely to convert. We don't want to lose their interest along the way or have them forget about us once pre-launch is activated. We want that list to actually be really, really warm. And so when I think back to what we did successfully with the Sync Halloween launch is we actually used the new pre-launch updates feature that Kickstarter offered so that our pre-launch followers were actually hearing from us about this specific project.

several times before we launched with Epic did not really use that feature again. Also the sync Halloween launch, the launch was impending. I think we launched within two months or so of launching that pre-launch page. It may have been a little bit more, but we were also, the launch was building. We were running some pre-launch ads as well. So there was some visibility for this project. We had a special VIP offer that was, we're getting people bought into the project in the lead up to it.

Another thing that I think really did help with Sync Halloween is that it was a launch that was timed to correspond with the season. We were going to launch in October. Obviously, October is Halloween's month. And so people were already leaning into projects like that. We also did have a VIP upgrade offer. So something else that our backers could do or to get or a special bonus that they could access beforehand. And I think, you know, I've reported that those people that took those VIP actions, they were by far and away our highest converting cohort, you know, over 70%, I think, ended up redeeming their prelaunch status.

And then we also did, for the first time, incorporate a pre-launch follower goal strategy that worked hand-in-hand nicely with our pre-launch updates, such that there was a reason for following, there was a reason for being a pre-launch follower, and there was a reason that our pre-launch followers could root for and had an incentive to share to get more pre-launch followers in the door. And that was sort of our pre-launch follower strategy. And I think I talked about that in previous episodes. Pre-launch, it had a lot of momentum to it. The people on that pre-launch list were hearing from us regularly. There was stuff going on even before the campaign launched. And unfortunately with Epic, I was not able to recreate that. There was a long gap between launches with a bunch of other projects going on. I definitely did not give this project as much of a...

emphasis of push in terms of time and resources and ads, investment, et cetera. And it was also sort of timed, not really with any particular season in mind. It was mostly time for visibility. So we get this book launched before some other big fulfillment projects get underway. And I did incorporate one pre-launch follower goal, but we did not really use our pre-launch updates and definitely could have used those more. And again, some of that had to do with visibility about when the project would and could be ready to launch. So these are some things that I just want you to consider and that there might be a case to make, especially if you're going to be

trying to use the pre-launch follower count as an important metric to figure out your plans, know that a longer runway might mean that those pre-launch followers, especially if you are not building that momentum and keeping that momentum specifically geared towards this launch, that follower conversion rate might not be as high as it would be if those pre-launch followers came in in the near-term weeks before your campaign goes live. So that's just something I want you to consider. Again, I do think all of the metrics that Kickstarter's rolled out have been a real improvement and definitely help. increased visibility. I do appreciate that they give us numbers and data that we can work with to help us tell a story and try to figure some things out. And I also do believe that decoupling pre-launch pages and launching those with having to have a campaign already complete and reviewed and approved, I think that was a good strategy.

At the same time, know that that necessarily means that there's a lot more pre-launch pages up. And if you are just relying on people discovering those pre-launch pages and then sticking with you for weeks, months, or in some cases, years, and then expecting those pre-launch followers to convert the same way someone that came on board and you've been nurturing and really getting excited specifically for this launch, I wouldn't expect those to convert the same way. So I want you to take that and do with it what you will. But these are some things that I'm thinking about going into 2026, and I hope this was helpful. Thank you so much for listening. Let me walk with you to take another step forward towards your next successful comics launch.

Looking for something new? These projects just launched on Kickstarter. Hello, Comics Launch. This is Abby, creator of Old Souls, live on Kickstarter. Old Souls is a story about a romance in the Old West between two women, after one of them, an injured outlaw, takes refuge in the other's barn, and suites her to let her stay. They have to continually make the decision between the comfort of loneliness and the danger of love. If you're a fan of westerns or romance, then you should check out Old Souls on Kickstarter today. Hello, Comics Launch. This is Jamie from Thunder Zone Comics letting you know that our new Kickstarter is now live. We have new issues of Weirdo, Marshall Strong, Big House Blues, Supercross, and the debut of Sumo Boy.

Additionally, we have catch-up tiers and add-ons if you missed out on any of our previous releases. If you are a fan of kick-ass indie superhero comics, then please check out Thunder Zone Comics Returns on Kickstarter today. Hello, Comics Launch. My name is Jazz Blair, and I'm the writer and artist of Red Hill, a comic which is now live on Kickstarter. What is Red Hill? It's a city where no magic can enter or leave, and all of the drama, politics, and rich world-building that comes along with it. But at its heart, it's about Copal Cavalier. She is charged with care of her newborn niece after her sister suddenly dies of a strange magical illness. Fearing she'll succumb to the same fate, Copal decides to travel to Red Hill to find the baby's father.

If you like weird D&D lore, the political intrigue of Star Trek Deep Space Nine, or the gallows humor of Disco Elysium, I think you'll have a fantastic time reading my comics. Hey, Comics Launch. Thanks for the invite, guys. I joined your Spotify podcast today. I had a few sessions on there, some great information. So anyway, I just want to give you a shout out. My name's Paul. I'm the creator of The Vessel of Sorrel, The Thorn. It's an eight-part global comic. It took me just under a year to write. It's fully scripted. I'm now getting it illustrated. It's launched on Kickstarter. It's about eight relics that are buried across the Earth. They were placed on the Earth billions of years ago before any life form was on this planet.

and basically they play havoc amongst the world. They play havoc with Sorrel Fong as she finds one of them. Farber had already found one. I can't say too much. It will ruin the plot, but it ties into today's stories. It ties into today's society of the President of the United States.

COVID, the UFO landings, more importantly, the powerful CEOs of certain companies in this world. And it dates around about 2019. So get involved. They will be launched. They come with LED relics as well that are tied into the story. The relics light up of an eye. Hi, Comics Launch. It's Gary Scott Beatty with Cyclopean gods and eldritch monsters in the complete gods of Azern, the first complete printed collection of my strange horror webcomic.

Inspired by 70s B-movies, creepy magazine, early Vertigo comics, and the strange cosmic horror of H.P. Lovecraft, readers have found Gods of Azern amazing, stunning, and creepy. Don't miss this Kickstarter exclusive, the complete Gods of Azern, now at strangehorror.com. Hey, Comics Launch, this is Zane, creator of Surf's Dangerous Days, live on Kickstarter. Surf's Dangerous Days is a story about a queer superhero fighting through both villains and the struggles of a daily life.

If you're a fan of the superhero genre or Marvel Comics or just want to see a new take on that kind of thing, then you should check out Surf's Dangerous Days number one on Kickstarter today. Hello Comics Launch, this is Jamie, creator of Hage no Yakusoku, Steel Promise, live now on Kickstarter. Steel Promise is an anime-inspired high school drama that blends emotional storytelling, friendship, romance, and intense robotic combat, following students who risk everything to chase their dreams and keep the promises that define them. If you're a fan of anime-style comics, emotional character-driven stories, or series like My Hero Academia and Gundam, you should check out Hage no Yakusoku, Steel Promise on Kickstarter today.

Are you a Comics Launch listener with a project that's launched or about to launch on Kickstarter? Tell us about it at comicslaunch.com forward slash voicemail, and we might just feature it on our show. So in this free guide, you're going to find nine proven strategies to level up your next launch. Whether you're a first-time creator or a savvy crowdfunding vet, I guarantee you'll find something of value in this guide. So what are you waiting for?

To get your free copy right now, go to comicslaunch.com forward slash funded. You've been listening to Comics Launch with Tyler James. Go to comicslaunch.com for show notes, free resources, and to connect with me. Thank you so much for listening, and I can't wait to see what you launch.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond!?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode published?

This episode was published on January 18, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.