Skip to content
Case Files Part 2: Tracking Down Siobhan McGuinness's Killer episode artwork

Feb 8, 2021 15 min

Case Files Part 2: Tracking Down Siobhan McGuinness's Killer

from Montana Murder Mysteries Hosted by NonStop Local

In our newest 'Montana Murder Mysteries' podcast, Evening Anchor Angela Marshall takes a look deeper into the case files of Richard William Davis-- the man now known to have killed five-year-old Siobhan McGuinness of Missoula back in 1974. After 47 years, advancements in DNA identification technology gave cold case investigators the help that they needed to finally hone in on their suspect. But they soon learned that his "evil" acts may go beyond this one tragedy. In the conversation with Lane, Angela found out that Davis may be connected to even more murders, including the disappearance of a young woman in 1973 and a trio of deaths in the 70's known as 'The Alphabet Murders.' "Case Files Part 2: Tracking Down Siobhan McGuinness's Killer" is available now wherever you get your podcasts and here:

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Case Files Part 2: Tracking Down Siobhan McGuinness's Killer

0:00 15:31
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Carbon monoxide. You can't see it. You can't smell it. And without an alarm, you may not know it's there. Install carbon monoxide alarms on every level of your home and test them monthly. The more you know, the safer you'll be. Learn more at embridgegas.com slash safety. It doesn't erase the pain of what happened.

It's a difficult situation, but you hope it answers some of the questions, not satisfactorily, because you're like, there's a why. There really is no why other than this man was evil. And the evil acts of Richard Davis, the man now known to have killed five-year-old Siobhan McGinnis in 1974, may go beyond this one tragedy. He may be connected to even more murders in the 1970s, including a trio of deaths called the Alphabet Murders. Welcome to part two of Case Files tracking down Siobhan McGinnis' killer. I'm your host for this Montana Murder Mysteries podcast, Angela Marshall, and it's brought to you by The Advocates.

Montana Burner Mysteries is brought to you by The Advocates. Your accident wasn't your fault, so don't deal with it on your own. The Advocates will handle paperwork and deal with the insurance company so you can rest and get better. Been nervous to work with an attorney? Then work with an advocate instead. The Advocates are available 24-7 online at MontanaAdvocates.com. I recently met via Zoom with Susan Lane, a retired federal agent who is now a member of the Cold Case Squad for the Missoula County Sheriff's Office. She spoke to me in detail about how forensic genetic genealogy, commonly referred to as familial DNA testing, allowed authorities to hone in on the murder of Siobhan McGinnis.

But let's try this other guy kind of as our next go-to. And that was Richard Davis. Richard William Davis. According to an article in the Arkansas Democrat Gazette, Richard William Davis was born on November 7th, 1941 in Gallatin, Pennsylvania to Ray and Letty Shelley Davis. He grew up with one sister.

Beginning in his late teens, Davis was always on the move. He moved to Bath, New York, and started building a house in 1966 on Mill Route Road, according to a press release from the Village of Bath Police Department. But he didn't settle down there. According to a poster from the FBI's Violent Criminal Apprehension Program, or VICAP, Davis lived in Pennsylvania in the early 1960s, South Dakota in the late 60s, back in New York until the late 70s, and Arkansas beginning in the late 80s. Richard was married. He had two wives. His first wife, they were missionaries in South Dakota. And so in her obituary, it talked about that they had been missionaries during this time frame, that they had lived in Bath, New York, and then they had moved from Bath, New York down to Arkansas. He had been born in Pennsylvania. So we were looking at kind of those areas. Along with being a missionary on the Sioux reservation, Davis also worked in the mines in South Dakota.

He also worked as a security guard at a winery bar in New York, drove a school bus in Alaska, worked again as a security guard for the Arkansas School for the Deaf and Blind, drove truck, and even volunteered at Big Brothers Big Sisters. And his travels took him all over the country, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Washington, and Wyoming. Davis passed away at the age of 70 on August 24, 2012, in Cabot, Arkansas. His obituary noted, quote, he was a loving husband, father, and grandfather. It also said, quote, he enjoyed the outdoors and loved caring for animals.

born-again Christian who believed in the word of faith and he was ready to be with Jesus. Lane tells me once Davis had been identified as a suspect, the cold case squad passed the torch to the Missoula Police Department detectives assigned to the case and they, with members of the FBI, boarded a plane to Arkansas in early October 2020 where Davis' family was living to find out more about him and to find any evidence that could connect him to Siobhan's murder. So Richard Davis died in 2012 and he was cremated. And so it's not like we could exhume him and do a one-to-one match. So they went and they said, you know, do you have any, do you have a hairbrush or a pipe he smoked or something that might have his DNA? And there was nothing. And so did a reference sample of various family members, relatives of his to be able to compare kind of almost like a reverse paternity, if you will. And so to be able to say, how is this person compare? If you look at our DNA sample of the perpetrator as the paternity, if you will, is there a relationship there? And there was. And so kind of at that point, it was 99.9% positive that this is the right guy.

Here you are. You find out that you have your suspect. You had mentioned it's a 99.9% match. I mean, what is going through your head? What do you think is going through the minds of your colleagues when after almost five decades, we have a suspect in this crime? Your spidey sense of saying, look here. And when it was confirmed, it was just, you know, just kind of compose myself. And then it really is a big switch because then you start thinking about.

It's a completely different mode. This is we have a suspect. We have to contact the family. We have to do a further interview. We have to do a press conference. We have to, you know, it's like it's it's like as if the case is fresh again. But while this case was top of mind for her, fellow law enforcement officers and the family of Siobhan McGinnis, she says the family of Richard Davis never even once considered him a murderer. Going back to Arkansas to talk to the family who are victims as well in the case. So it's as far as this is just traumatized. This man.

did this horrible crime. And the fact that your father, your uncle, your husband, your brother, whoever is this monster, is pretty traumatic for everyone involved. Still, in Lane's words, they were, quote, very helpful people who wanted to do whatever they could to solve this case. You know, again, the numbers of Richard Davis, they certainly could have turned you away, but they were extremely helpful, extremely helpful in this situation. When you come armed with, this is a crime that we've not been able to solve through normal means and normal processes, and we need to bring some, we need to resolve this, that people are very willing. And in this case, the family of the perpetrator was, they were horrified by it, horrified by the idea. It was a relative of theirs and wanted to do anything that they could to help.

One missing piece of the puzzle? What brought Davis to Montana? Lane says he was living in the state of New York at the time. And in talking with family members and sifting through old photos, they remembered him taking cross-country road trips often to look for work. And law enforcement theorized it's on one of these cross-country road trips out West that Davis made contact with Siobhan McGinnis. Remember the green Cadillac spotted by a witness at the time of Siobhan's murder? The one with New York license plates? Davis had been driving a green Cadillac back then. And then we shifted our focus to what else was this guy doing? And what else was he up to?

Because this is the one case, and then just as the investigator, you know you don't go from zero to the abduction, sexual assault, and murder of a child as your first crime. So we just thought there was other things out there that we needed to pull every thread to see what else he might have been up to. They wanted to find out if Davis could be connected to other crimes, other kidnappings, other sexual assaults, or even other murders. Lane says they uncovered an incident in June of 1973 out of Bath, New York, where Davis had been living. So this was about eight months before the murder of Siobhan McGinnis. A mother reported to the local Village of Bath Police Department that a man had tried to coerce her eight-year-old daughter into his truck, Parkner Hadfields, which is a cash-and-carry type store located on Gansford Street. Now, after looking at the police report uncovered by local investigator Colin Taft, Lane says that suspect was Richard Davis. Davis was questioned by an officer.

according to the report. Because he says, I like to give small children rides home. And so we were all like, ugh. Davis was never charged. In March of 1976, now this is two years after Siobhan's murder, Davis was arrested in the town of Bath for endangering the welfare of a child. Police Chief Chad Mullen wrote in a press release, Davis, quote, pled guilty and was fined $25. That same press release went on to say, quote, due to the age of the incidences and the purging of records over the years, it is believed that Mr. Davis was involved in picking up several young teenage runaways whom he would then take back to his house. Lane had also been researching missing persons cases in the areas where Davis was known to have lived. One name that came to her attention, Barbara Jean Alexovich.

Barbara J. Aleksevich disappeared from Bath, New York on the night of October 3, 1973. Adding this case to the timeline, this was nearly four months to the day Siobhan disappeared. Barbara was 24 years old. In the hours leading up to her disappearance, she was said to be having drinks at the local Elks Lodge with her husband, according to unidentifiedwiki.org. Now, for unknown reasons, she decided to leave the lodge early and walk home, but the hazel-eyed brunette was never seen or heard from again.

What's interesting to note, the Elks Lodge from where Barbara was last seen is located on Gansvert Street, that same street where Davis was suspected of child abduction just a few months prior. And so she's walking home. She would have walked right by where this truck had been parked four months later. But still, this is, you know, there's a hunting ground and she never made it home. But they've never found her body. So there's no DNA. There's nothing to compare it to.

But that didn't stop local authorities from pinpointing Davis as their lead suspect in this cold case. In fact, on the day after the Missoula Police Department held their press conference, bringing Siobhan's killer to light, the Village of Bath Police Department held their own press conference. Here's Police Chief Chad Mullen on October 27th of last year. The Village of Bath Police Department is reopening the missing persons case of Barbara Alaskovich dating back to October 3rd of 1973. The reopening of this case is predominantly stemming from a cold case homicide investigation in Missoula County, Montana. Investigator Taft with the Bath Village Police Department was recently contacted by Susan Lane of the Missoula County Cold Case Unit. Investigator Taft was notified of a DNA match from a male that lived in Bath, New York at the time of the homicide their department is investigating.

The male is identified as Richard W. Davis, born November 7th of 1941. It is the intent of our police department to move forward with any and all new leads in the missing persons case of Barbara Leskovich, which is presumed a homicide. Chief Mullen went on to say, without the work of the FBI's forensic genetic genealogy team, Mr. Davis would never have been tied to Siobhan's murder, and in turn, named as a suspect in Barbara's homicide.

Well, since the FBI's VICAP has issued flyers on Richard William Davis to law enforcement jurisdictions all across the country. The hope is this information will help these other agencies look into Davis as a potential suspect and solve their own cold cases that have been buried for decades. A trio of child killings out of Rochester, New York between 1971 and 1973, known as the alphabet murders or the double initial murders. It was three little girls who were abducted, sexually assaulted and murdered in Rochester, New York. And at that time.

Rochester, New York was one of the areas that Richard Davis was working. All three victims were girls between the ages of 10 and 11, and their last names began with the same letter as their first names. Cameron Colon, Wanda Walkowitz, and Michelle Mainza. Each girl had been sexually assaulted, and each girl had been murdered by strangulation. And one by one, their bodies were dumped in a town near Rochester that began with the same letter as their names. All this information collected by Wikipedia.

Well, today, the case of the Alphabet murders remains open and unsolved. But Lane tells me she did advise local law enforcement there on ways to get grant funding to do forensic genetic genealogy testing on the victims and to see if the deaths of these young girls are in any way connected to Richard William Davis. And as our conversation continued, Lane brought to my attention several other cold cases that might come to light in which Davis is being looked at as a potential suspect. She tells me her hope is that technology today will help unlock the secrets to these cold cases and reveal more about the double life of Richard Davis kept hidden for so long. It doesn't erase the pain of what happened. It's a difficult situation, but you hope it answers some of the questions. Not satisfactorily, because you're like, there's a why. There really is no why, other than this man was evil.

We thank you for listening to Montana Murder Mysteries. Your efforts have helped us reach 100,000 downloads. Now, if you like our show, remember to make sure to subscribe and share it with your friends. And while you're there, don't forget to rate our show and leave us a review. And if there is a case that you would like us to cover, feel free to reach out to us on our professional Facebook pages, my co-host Blake Simonson and I, or by going to MontanaRightNow.com, clicking on the Feature tab, and then clicking on Montana Murder Mysteries. You'll be able to check out previous episodes, complete with pictures and maps unique to each case. And you'll be able to find a button to send us tips and story suggestions.

Montana Murder Mysteries is researched and written by Blake Simonson and myself and produced by Jill Lissar. We'll see you next week.

4 MT Heads The MT Heads Montana based friends talk about everything from personal, local, and international events and issue's. Admittedly not professionals in any of these areas, just real people talking about real things. Explicit Murder in Miami iHeartPodcasts In the 1980s crime journalist Phil Stanford dove into the decadent and dangerous world of Miami just as the city was becoming the cocaine- and murder- capital of the United States. His path would place him in the crosshairs of a federal investigation focusing on a mysterious and controversial drug smuggling pilot who claimed to be an operative of the American government- all while flaunting his extensive illicit activity. Murder in Miami traces the connection between the murder of a missing Miami private investigator to the sprawling roots of an international money laundering scheme as Stanford tries to make sense of his role in a surreal story of spies, smugglers, killers and corruption. All reaching to the highest levels on both sides of the law. Explicit Suspect Convictions Kast Media Barton McNeil discovers his 3-year-old daughter's lifeless body in her bed the morning after breaking up with his girlfriend. McNeil insists that she was murdered by his former girlfriend after pointing to a cut screen in the bedroom window. Police agree a murder has been committed, but arrest him. Explicit Atlanta Monster iHeartPodcasts and Tenderfoot TV From the producers of Up and Vanished, Tenderfoot TV and iHeartPodcasts present, 'Atlanta Monster.' This true crime podcast tells the story of one of the city’s darkest secrets, The Atlanta Child Murders. Nearly 40 years after these horrific crimes, many questions still remain. Host Payne Lindsey aims to find truth and provide closure, reexamining the disappearance and murder of over 25 African American children and young adults. Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Montana Murder Mysteries?

This episode is 15 minutes long.

When was this Montana Murder Mysteries episode published?

This episode was published on February 8, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Montana Murder Mysteries episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.