Skip to content
Catholicism In The Hobbit with Joseph Pearce episode artwork

Jul 27, 2015 59 min

Catholicism In The Hobbit with Joseph Pearce

from Center for Evangelical Catholicism Hosted by Center for Evangelical Catholicism

Author Joseph Pearce goes through the Catholic themes in J.R.R. Tolkien's the Hobbit.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Catholicism In The Hobbit with Joseph Pearce

0:00 59:57
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Anyway, we're lucky enough to have Professor Joseph Pierce back with us again tonight. He was with us back in the beginning of December when he talked about Alexander Solson-Eason, when he could actually, it was a fabulous talk which if you didn't hear I recommend going back and listening to either on the St. Mary's website or on iTunes. But anyway, he actually during that talk he was able to do something that Padre Pio was famous for and that was by location and that he was here and on EWTan at the exact same time.

I don't know how that was possible. But anyway, Professor Pierce is English born writer who lives now in Simpsonville. He's also a writer in residence with Thomas Moore College up in New Hampshire and also teaches up there in the humanities. He used to have a similar position down with Avi Maria in Florida.

And anyway, he's written I believe 16 or 17 different books last time. He didn't even remember how many. And on a multitude of different topics in particular literary converts is his. And biography is but he also has books of verse.

I mean, and they're all fabulous. I've read almost all of them and highly recommend them, which he will be selling at the end of the talk and more than happy design. So stick around and get your copy of whatever you like. So anyway, now I'm going to turn over to Professor Pierce and welcome him back.

Good evening. Good evening. It's good to be back. I like speaking at St Mary's because I'm going to leave home at 5.30.

I'll be home in time for bed. I'm not happy to go anywhere near an airport. It's wonderful. So it's good to be here.

And this evening I'm going to be going to talk about the Catholicism of the Hobbit. Could I begin by asking for a show of hands all of, if you have read the Hobbit, please raise your hands. OK, if you've seen the movie, please raise your hands. OK, if you've read all the rings, please raise your hands.

OK, if you've seen the movie, please raise your hands. OK, if you've done all four, raise your hands. All right, so basically we've got a pretty knowledgeable audience here, so I have to make sure that I know what I'm talking about. Before we get to the Catholicism of the Hobbit, I want to just begin by talking about the Lord of the Rings very briefly, for maybe about five or ten minutes, and then we'll get into the Hobbit.

Because although the Hobbit was written first, knowing what Tolkien did with the Lord of the Rings, and I'm talking said about the Lord of the Rings, is a good introduction into the Hobbit. Well, Tolkien said, and I'm quoting him in word for word here about the Lord of the Rings, the Lord of the Rings is, of course, a fundamentally religious and Catholic work. OK, so the Lord of the Rings is a fundamentally religious and Catholic work, the words of the author of the work itself, and let's not forget that little sub-claws in there, of course. In other words, it should really be a no surprise to anyone.

Also, on another occasion in one of his letters, he wrote about a scale of significance with regard to his relationship as author and the Lord of the Rings as work. And he talked about the insignificant factors, the more significant factors, and the really significant factors. Amongst the more significant factors was he said his love of languages, which is clearly a major ingredient in the Lord of the Rings. Above that, he says, is the fact that I was born in the Shire in a pre-mechanical age, which I could say more about than I'm going to resist the temptation to do.

Although there is going to be a Q&A session, so if I raise questions I don't answer, that's the time to raise the question again and I'll answer them. But then at the very top of this scale of significance, the more important and the really significant factors at the very top of the scale is, and I'm quoting, talking word for word here, the fact that I am a Christian, which can be deduced from my stories and in fact a Roman Catholic. Alright, so there we have talking's own word about the Lord of the Rings being a fundamentally religious and Catholic work. I do give a talk very regularly and frequently on the Catholicism, the Lord of the Rings, and it's a different talk, and it just doesn't time to give two talks.

I can't by locate, but I can't give two talks at once, that's the problem. So basically the main arguments of the Catholicism Lord of the Rings will have to wait for another occasion, or first of the commercial blakes in the talk. You can obviously buy the talks or the series or the various things I've done showing the Catholicism Lord of the Rings that's available at the back there. But I just don't just give one fact about the Lord of the Rings, which I think is the key that unlocks the rest of the work, the rest of it follows on from that, because say much more.

And that's the date on which the ring is destroyed. Now we have a knowledgeable audience here, so someone's going to tell me, please put your hand up if you know on what date the ring was destroyed. I knew you'd know, I want to give someone else a chance, and you know as well. Yeah.

Master 25th, thank you. So several people knew the answer. Now when I give this talk at secular universities, well the Catholicism Lord of the Rings, and the secular university, I call it the Unlocking Lord of the Rings, so that they get non-believers in. And when you mention Master 25th, the non-believers look completely and that they perplex and be mused and be fuddled.

They do it about many things in life. What on earth is Master 25th? So at secular universities, one thing they do know is the facts of life. So you say, well what happened nine months after Master 25th?

April, May, June, July, August. December the 25th. Santa Claus comes down the chimney. All right, even the secular universities, they know that it's Christmas, and that's the date on which Jesus was born.

Nine months before that is the feast of the enunciation. And that date is more important than Christmas. In fact, don't think that I'm a hematic, but my one complaint against the Catholic Church, that's an interesting thing to say, Catholic parish, isn't it? My one complaint against the Catholic Church is that, Master 25th, the feast of the non-seations is not a holy day of obligation, because clearly it should be, because life begins a conception, not at birth.

The word became flesh on Master 25th, not on December 25th. God became man on Master 25th, not on December 25th. So, the feast of non-seations is hugely important. And what many people don't know, even Catholics, is that the date of the crucifixion was also Master 25th.

Of course, we celebrate good Friday as a moveable feast, but the actual event of the crucifixion happened on one particular date in history. And that date was Master 25th. That's according to the tradition of the Church, which would be passed down from the witnesses. And I think we can be fairly sure that the Blessed Virgin Mary remembered the date on which I was crucified.

I remember the date on which my father died, and it was in far less dramatic circumstances. And I'm sure that Saint John remembered the date on which Christ was crucified, and that the other witnesses, the other Mary's, and he gave all the apostles that ran away, and still know what day happened. So, it passed down from that time the date of the crucifixion, the same date as the enunciation. Now, of course, this makes Master 25th the most important date by far in the Christian calendar.

This is the date on which Tolkien has the ring destroyed. Now, what the incarnation, the enunciation, and the crucifixion, the death and later resurrection of God Christ have, were taken together, is the power to redeem us from sin. And especially from original sin. The original sin is, as theologians will tell you, the one sin to rule them all, and in the darkness bind them.

And the one sin and the one ring are destroyed on the same day, which makes the power of the ring synonymous with sin itself. The carrying of the ring is like the carrying of the cross. The wearing of the ring is the committing of sin. When we put the ring on, it's an act of sin.

If we put the ring on habitually, we become addicted to our sin. In freely choosing evil, we lose our freedom by becoming addicts to the sin itself, enslaved by sin. And one of the most brilliant portraits of the human soul anywhere in world literature is the picture of Gollum, the shriveling of the personhood. Once the person has become addicted to sin, to the ring.

When they want nothing but the ring, when the ring is all that they care for, when they will betray everyone and everything in order to possess it. Well, when you get that situation, you don't possess it. It possesses you. One of the great paradoxes of life at the heart of the Lord of the Rings is that the thing possesses the possessor.

And from that, we could talk about all sorts of other characters, but that's the other tool. I've got my Lord of the Rings note to put one side now. We went to the Hobbit. The Hobbit was written before the Lord of the Rings, published in 1937.

The Lord of the Rings was originally commissioned as a follow-up to the Hobbit, but it sort of grew up and grew out and fold and grew inside and became its own thing. The Hobbit is a children's book. But I'm currently reading The Chronicles of Narnia with our five-year-old daughter. And anybody would know that great literature, even if it's purportedly for children, is for children of all ages.

And as we know from the gospel, unless we can see through the eyes of a child, we will not get to the kingdom of heaven. We have to remain childlike without falling into the childishness of sin. So the Hobbit is a children's book, but it has many, many profound meanings in it. And we could have guessed as much.

It says fundamentally religious and Catholic, of course, as the Lord of the Rings. And we shouldn't be surprised by this because in an academic lecture that Tolkien gave, which is later published under the title of On Fairy Stories, he said that fairy stories hold up a mirror to man. In other words, they show us ourselves. Now, if something shows us ourselves, it's not a scapist, it's not fantasy, it's reality, it's realism.

So in the Hobbit, we are shown ourselves. But there's a question that begs itself, because if it holds up a mirror to man, which it does, the obvious question is, what is man? And that's a question we need to know and ask and answer before we're going to be able to understand the Hobbit. Because for Tolkien, we're not merely homo sapiens.

Now, let's make one thing clear. The word homo sapiens, by the way, the term homo sapiens was a name given to us by us. It's a product of the Enlightenment. Never trust any body who claims that he is the enlightened one and that everybody else is in the dark ages.

The Arrogance of the Enlightenment is betrayed by the name it gives itself. We are enlightened. And the whole history of humanity up to us has been ignorance and bigotry and darkness. Where's the Enlightenment that calls us homo sapiens?

The Enlightenment also calls itself the Age of Reason. And again, the arrogance of it, as if no one had the power of reason before they came along just a few hundred years ago. You can forget about Socrates and Plato and Aristotle and Saint Augustine and some Thomas Aquinas and the great philosophers and the great theologians and the great writers, because they were not living in the Age of Reason. They were living in the dark ages before the Enlightenment or the Age of Reason.

So it's these arrogant people that look down upon the whole history and the whole of humanity that call us homo sapiens. And the ignorance actually is illustrated by the very name itself. Because the word sapiens means wise. And the Enlightenment doesn't mean wise, it means clever.

And there's a huge difference between cleverness and wisdom. In fact, I forgot to make my book up, but I'll get it in the moment when I need it. And I'm talking in the Hobbit, has a great deal to say about the difference between cleverness and wisdom. Because what the modern man means about homo sapiens is it'll be basically a little bit smarter than the monkeys.

Nothing to do with wisdom, it's to do with the fact that we walk on two legs, not four, and we're a little bit more developed than the chimpanzee. There's nothing to do with wisdom. Nothing to do with sapiens, the Latin for wisdom. But for a Christian, we're not part of this rationalist understanding of humanity.

And all do we think that we are homo sapiens, because wisdom is something that you have to learn and acquire through life. And of us are born and wise. Wisdom is not what defines us as people. Some of us may acquire it.

Many of us won't. It isn't something that unites us as being a characteristic of all of us. So in our homo sapiens, what a Christian believes we are, and now we begin to see where the Hobbit comes in, we are homo viatore. We're a man on a journey, a travelling man.

The whole purpose of our life, and it's the only purpose worth worrying about, is to get to heaven. And that's a quest, and a dangerous and perilous ones, with dragons on the way. And there's no guarantee we'll get there. And if we don't act virtuously, we won't get there.

So the mirror to man that's being held up in the Hobbit, and Lord of the Rings, is a mirror of homo viatore, man on a journey. And now we begin to see how Bilbo's journey in the Hobbit, have you seen as a mirror of our journey in life. So I want to talk about three key ingredients of the Hobbit, because it's something to summarise them now, and then there's a bit more detail. In one sense, Bilbo's journey is a rite of passage, from ignorance to wisdom.

He doesn't begin as homo sapiens, but perhaps he is homo sapiens or Hobbits sapiens, whatever the appropriate Latin phrase for a wise Hobbit would be. And a rite of passage from sin to virtue. The second key meaning of the Hobbit can be found in what might be termed a mystical meditation on divine providence, and the relationship between grace and free will. And the third is a moral commentary on Matthew 6 verse 21, where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.

Okay, so let's now look at the story. The story begins of course with Bilbo being very reluctant to go on an adventure. Ventures are horrible, inconvenient, and perhaps dangerous things. Why would he leave the comfort of his Hobbit hole to go on an adventure?

Chesterton said that an adventure is made in inconvenience properly conceived. Bilbo does not have that Chestertonian spirit at the beginning of the book. It's an inconvenience to be avoided at all costs. This is what he got on an adventure.

At the beginning of the book, he's a creature of comfort, addicted to the creature comforts. He has everything he wants around him he doesn't need to go anywhere else. Of course Gandalf says the reason he should go on the adventure is it will be profitable to him. Of course Gandalf, who is wise, does not mean profit purely in terms of gold.

That he has something to gain from the adventure which transcends mere treasure. Another aspect of the Hobbit is the recurrence of the word luck. What is luck in the Hobbit? Is it blind fortune?

Is it like throwing the dice or tossing a core coin? Are we at the mercy of blind and mercy this fate of fortune? What does luck mean something else? Well, the word luck, I mentioned once giving this talk, I think it was at home school in conferencing Massachusetts if I remember correctly, but the word luck can lucky.

He's mentioned an awful lot in the Hobbit. I said I'm not quite yet enough of a Tolkien nerd to go through the Hobbit and count how many times the word luck and a lot of luck came up in the Hobbit. Thankfully, there were a couple of family of Tolkien nerds in the audience. And that night they went home and they duly went through the Hobbit, and next day they gave me this very useful chart.

I won't read the whole thing to you, I'll give you a feel. It's headed a luck in invertebrates and it's derivatives mentioned in the Hobbit. And there's a column, chapter, page, Pavadof, line, the speaker who says it, and the term used. So, for instance, in chapter one, page 24, Pavadof, line four, Thorvyn says luckily.

And go down to chapter nine, I go to the random here. Chapter nine, page 186, Pavadof, line four, the narrator says luckily. So, anyway, the term used luckily, luckily, luckily, luckily, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky. So, the summary at the bottom is the luck is mentioned in the Hobbit at least 36 times.

This is not an exhaustive list. What do you want to start with? They should be. But we tried to find as much as we could.

The addition of the Hobbit used was printed by Del Vay Books Inc in 2012, all page under set for a corresponding to that printing. And I have the names of the people concerned, but I think they're talking nerdishness deserves to be kept a secret. But we've got the point. Now I think my general word for it, that luck and luck is used an awful lot.

We now know it's used at least 36 times by all sorts of people. But what is luck in the Hobbit? Is it merely blind chance? Well, let's take a couple of examples.

Perhaps one of the most famous things in the Hobbit is the famous Riddling game. The game of riddles between Frodo and Gollum in the depths of the Misty Mountains there. And it's a high stakes Riddling game, far higher stakes than the poker game you're going to see on TV. Because the loser gets eaten.

I don't think even Las Vegas stooped to those levels yet. We certainly make the poker game interesting. So of course Frodo is a little bit nervous. Can't really afford to lose this game, it will be his last ever game of riddles.

And eventually Gollum asks him a riddle and he can't think of the answer against a panic. And Gollum, instead of showing the good cardinal virtue of patience, senses victory and senses his supper. And he climbs out of the boat, puts his foot in the water. And in so doing, scares a fish.

He jumps out of the water and lands on Bilbo's lap. That's what's called Clue. And the very lucky one. Because then Bilbo's out, fish!

The answer's fish! Which indeed it was. That's lucky. But see, the luck is connected to freedom of choice and free will and human action.

And the consequences of that. Because if Gollum had shown the patience, if Gollum had behaved virtuously and stayed in his boat and had stepped into the water. The fish would have let out Bilbo would not have got the clue and he would have been supper. And this point, by the way, Tolkien's pretty explicit about this point in The Lord of the Rings.

Theoden says, off Duff Evil will Evil Mar. And because Tolkien wants us to get the point a couple of pages later, Gandow says, off and does evil hurt itself. Now, if something's together, he sort of hammers it home. It's not all that subtle sometimes.

In other words, evil is self-destructive. Sin is self-destructive. And here we see how Gollum is defeated on the very brink of victory by his own sinfulness. The same thing happens later.

He asks Bilbo another question. And this might not be able to know the answer, and he is panicking. And his panic is brought to levels of hysteria by the sound of Gollum again, not showing patience or temperance and advancing on Bilbo to kill him. And Bilbo and his panic want to shout out, give me more time.

But because he's petrified, his mouth is dry, and he can't formulate a whole sentence. So he blurts out time, which is the answer to the riddle. But again, it is Gollum's evil action that defeats Gollum from victory and saves Bilbo. Of course, that's the via negativity, if you like.

That's the reverse side of it. Throughout The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, we also see how virtuous action has positive consequences. But there has been cleverness and wisdom, one moment please, in The Hobbit. We are told by the narrator that goblins are cruel, wicked and bad-hearted, and that they make no beautiful things but many clever ones.

And he continues, it is not unlikely that they invented some of the machines that have since troubled the world, especially the ingenious devices for killing large numbers of people at once, for wheels and engines and explosions always delighted them. And also not working with their own hands more than they could help. But in those days and those world parts, they have not advanced as it is called so far. Now the interesting thing about that, of course, part of the fact that we see that orcs are clever, evil people can be clever, that or fit law was clever, Joseph Stalin was clever, because he was just cleverness and wisdom.

But the interesting thing there is the orcs actually, if you notice, step out of the story. It's not unlikely, we're told, that they invented some of the machines in our world, particularly ingenious devices for killing large numbers of people at once. The phrase more recently used for that is weapons of mass destruction. That we don't have to look very far to find the orc, that in our world, as are many, many golems.

This is showing a mirror to man, remember. But other parallels between the hobbit and the Lord of the Rings is Gandalf's role. In both books, Gandalf disappears in the crucial moment and comes back again later. And this is really a case of Gandalf flying the nest.

So it's little nestlings, his young ones, going to learn to fly. So Gandalf leads to just the right moment. Telling them, of course, whatever you do, do not leave the narrow path. Obvious analogy with the gospel.

Stick to the narrow path. In fact, the words emphasize so much again by talking, in the words of Gandalf, they're in capital letters. It cannot be stressed enough. But of course, they don't.

They get a bit hungry. And they leave the narrow path and get themselves into all sorts of trouble. Another parallel between the hobbit and the Lord of the Rings is the return of the king. The following Oakenshield, of course, is the true king under the mountain, who returns the lonely mountain to claim his own.

The reclaimed his kingdom and its treasure. Because no one is going to pretend that Thor in Oakenshield is as noble as Aragon, the antique good and bad kings. But the point is that the true kings return is important in both books. There are songs sung about it in both books.

And the true king has a right to his return. I could say much more about that. When I give the Lord of the Rings talk, I talk about the Arthurian dimension, the once and future king, King Arthur, the Jacobite dimension, the exile Catholic king, who's exile to England, who's the king over the water, for which we await the return. All of this, and of course, and most importantly, particularly in Amadorn's kingship, a shadow or foreshadow of the kingship of Christ and the second coming.

Another king written in the hobbit is summed up actually by some words from Sam in the Lord of the Rings, above all shadows, where it's the sun. And in the Lord of the Rings, that's shown in several ways, my favorite, which I'm going to take at the Lord of the Rings, Diaggression, because I think this really sums it up. Sam and Frodo are heading towards Mordor, and they come to the crossroads. And at the crossroads, there's a statue of the king.

The statue of the king of an old ancient king. The statue of the king is a symbol of civilization, civilization being understood as humanity being creative and turning towards the light, and creatively it gets from God. Human society living virtuously should we say, and in wisdom. But this statue has been desecrated and destroyed and vandalized by a horde of orcs.

The head of the statue has been hewn off, decapitated, in the place of the head is a roughly hewn ugly stone, placed on the shoulders of the king with the red eye of Sauron, dwarfed on it crudely, and there's orcish graffiti all over the statue. Now, we don't want to know what orcs write in their graffiti. That is one good reason for being thankful that we can't speak orcish. But this work of beauty, this work of civilization has been destroyed.

And it seems to be a symbol of the triumph of evil. And yet the very last light of the sun, breaking through the trees, illumines the head of the king which has been rolled away several yards. And it's as if the sun, although it's not talked about explicitly in the book, as if the sun itself, the light of the sun has placed a halo of sanctity and blessing around the head of the king. But more than that, once the light has shone on the head of the king, they notice stone crop growing around the king's head.

Stone crop, as you may know, tiny little golden flowers that grow on rock. And more than that, there's a creeping plant, crawls along the ground towards the head of the king, winds itself around the king with beautiful white flowers. And Frodo says, see Sam, the king has a crown again. They cannot conquer forever.

And here we see super nature, God, miraculously blessing nature, and showing how nature is united with super nature, with God in the war against evil. It's a miracle of grace that they see in that vision. But more than that, I could say much more about Tolkien's philosophy of creativity, it's not the place for it. But Tolkien believed that at the top of the hierarchy of creation is the creator, God.

Below that is creation, that which is made directly by God from nothing, ex-nehalo. Below that is sub creation, things made by us using the creative gifts that God has given to us. A sub creation could be to the glory of God and for the use of man, both of which are good. There's nothing wrong with building a house, just like yourself dying of the cold or putting some clothes on.

But there's a certain way in which God actually magnifies man's sub creation so that it even perfects God's own creation. Yes, we can't make anything as beautiful as a sunset or one of God's creatures, animals. But let's take for instance the statue in the Lord of the Rings here. Let's assume it's made from marble.

The marble had been under the ground for millions of years. No one's seeing it. Yes, it's beautiful. It's just made by God, but no one sees it.

And then by human, subterfated gifts, we quarry that piece of stone, that piece of marble. We give it to a gifted sculptor who turns it into a beautiful statue of a king and raise it to the glory of God. And then the force of evil will come along and attempt to destroy it. And here God himself with his creation is blessing that work of sub creation.

And talking down to the understanding of evil is profoundly Christian. Evil has no being of its own. It's merely the absence of the good. All goodness comes from God.

All light comes from God, which is why evil is always described in the Lord of the Rings in the Hobbit as being the shadow, the land of shadow, or a cell one as the dark lord. But we have a family Christian understanding of evil. And let's now move on to dragons as we move towards the end of the talk. I want to make sure I leave time for questions.

Now dragons are not merely large animals like a dinosaur. If a tiger were to come into this room now, it would be a little bit scared quite rightly. But it would be scared because it could kill us. It would be a danger to our flesh.

But a dragon on the other hand is demonic. When you see depictions of Michael, Michael is slaying the dragon or the serpent. You see some jaw is slaying the dragon. And dragons eat people.

But they particularly like maidens. Because it's not human flesh that they crave. It's the pollution of the human spirit. The devouring is a deflowering.

They want to corrupt. So we're not surprised that Smau has a problem. And Smau's of course is possessed by his possessions. He's a slave to his possessions.

He's not happy. He doesn't leave his lair in case someone steals a trinket from his horde of tens of thousands of trinkets, none of which he can use. But all of which according to Tolkien, he knows the market value of. Again, another example of the dragon leaping out of the storm.

We can't really imagine Smau's reading the Wall Street Journal for the late smart prices. But Tolkien's drawing parallels here between the dragons and certain real people in the real world. He also says that the angular dragons are having something stolen from them. It's a bit like people we know that may own something for years and forget that they own it.

Yet at the moment they lose it, they're in an apoplexy of rage. So they're dragons in our world. So Smau has the dragon sickness. By the way, the whole light thing, you mentioned the link to the hobby.

I'll do that very quickly. It's a way or a finger of sunlight that points to the key, to the door in the lonely mountain. As it was prophesied, would be the case that the sun itself, the finger of God touching the door will show where the door is. They couldn't find it by their own powers.

They did that supernatural intervention. And also Smau has destroyed because in his pride, he rolls over to show Bilbo his wonderful armor of gold that's impenetrable. Nobody can possibly destroy me. But he has an Achilles' heel.

There's nothing in the Achilles' head. It's an Achilles' heart. Because there's a hole in the armor right above his heart, somewhat providentially, or luckily if you prefer. But what happens is when he's coming flying over in his rage to destroy Lake Town, it's the light of the moon, which again is a reflection of the light of the sun, which again is a reflection of the light of God.

The points towards the dragon and this beautiful gold and silver, all traded by God, all beautiful, reflects back the beauty of the light, where there's a black hole about Smau's heart. Darkness, the absence of light, evil. And it's in that black hole that the arrow finds itself, Smau gets destroyed. Above all shadows, rides the sun and the moon, and the God of sun and moon.

Okay, it's the finish then. The dragon sickness. Clearly Smau has the dragon sickness. But who else has the dragon sickness?

Yes. Thorin Okenshield. Thank you. Thorin Okenshield certainly had the dragon sickness.

He becomes possessed by his possessions so much so that he almost kills Bilbo his friend. He gets his love for his friend and his neighbours, makes enemies with nearly everybody because he's possessed by his possessions. He has the dragon sickness. Thank you.

Thorin Okenshield. Anyone else? Sorry? Well, golem actually has the dragon sickness much more in the Lord of the Rings than he does in the Hobbit.

I mean, he does have it, but if you don't really see the power of the ring in the Hobbit, it sort of, that ring becomes evident in the later work. The dragon sickness fulfills the same function in the Hobbit that the ring does in the Lord of the Rings, and golem, it's not really a central figure. He's all, yeah. The mayor of Lake Town, thank you very much.

The mayor of Lake Town also has the dragon sickness. What he does, of course, is steal the treasure from his own people and goes off into the desert and dies of starvation. Because you can't eat gold. And again, talking actually tells us that.

He reminds us of these basic facts, these Midas lessons. All right, anybody else has the dragon sickness? Yeah. The king of Merpwood?

Yes, the king of Merpwood has the dragon sickness. He also raises an army pretty quickly to go and get his share of the treasure. Anyone else? Bilbo briefly.

Okay, thank you. I was waiting for the word Bilbo. Before we get to Bilbo, let's talk about the other, you must not forget, in the role of honour of those who had the dragon sickness. The wonderful satchel baggens is.

Because when they come into the story at the end, of course, they are sending off all of Bilbo's possessions and measuring his hobbit hole to move in. And they're very disappointed that he's returned. Yes, but we mustn't forget Bilbo Baggens. Bilbo Baggens has the dragon sickness at the beginning of the story.

He's possessed by his possessions. And in fact, the actual parallel is pretty obvious. Bilbo and the dragon both live under a hill. Bilbo's address is under hill.

The dragon, of course, is under the lonely mountain. The only difference between the hill that Bilbo lives under and the hill that smelt his under is one of scale. And yes, there is a very bad pun in there if you think about it. No, that doesn't have sat scales.

But the point is that he's possessed in his own way as in his hobbit fashion by his possessions. The purpose of the journey is to overcome the dragon sickness, to be healed from the dragon sickness, to grow in virtue, so he's no longer addicted to the creature comforts, to the selfishness, which is the root of all evil. So the journey, like our journey in life, again, Bilbo's journey, parallel is our journey, is that we have to embrace suffering, embrace the adventure of life, including the dangers and the suffering, to lay down our lives for our friends, which Bilbo does on several occasions, growing in virtue every time in the process, in order to overcome our addiction to sin. So, how does the hobbit end?

Well, what's happening with Bilbo returns home. By the way, the question of luck, right towards the end of the last page of the book on the return journey home, the handout says to Bilbo, you don't think all of your adventures are managed by merely luck, do you? Because of course they weren't. And Bilbo in his humility smiles and says, thank goodness, indeed, thank goodness.

Who is goodness? God is goodness. But so what's happening when Bilbo returns home? What's actually physically happening in the story?

What's literally happening with Bilbo returns home? Yeah. The sat-full-baggins are selling all of his possessions, except for the ones they want to keep themselves, of course. And why are they selling off all his possessions?

Anyway? Not well, why do they think they're allowed to sell his possessions? Because they think he's dead. And I want to be reminded one of your great American wits, Mark Twain, allegedly read his own epitaph in the newspaper.

I want to do that. I want my ambitions in life, is to read my own epitaph in the newspaper. And he wrote to the editor saying, Dister, reports of my death are greatly exaggerated. And I can imagine Bilbo returning home and saying exactly the same thing, much of the annoyance that sat-full-baggins.

In fact, we're told that most of them are very upset that Bilbo's returned from the dead. And some of them refuse to accept he's really alive even though they see him in the flesh. And again, there's an analogy there to the words of the gospel. Now if they were not believed, the miracles that they're seeing says Christ, they will not believe even if one returned from the dead, one rose from the dead.

Bilbo rises from the dead, he comes back, he's resurrected and they won't believe he's alive because they'd rather have his possessions than him. So what we see at the end here is that Bilbo starts with dragon sickness through a life of virtue and suffering. In laying down his life for his friends, no greater love has any man says Christ. He dies to himself.

And in dying to himself, he's resurrected. Ultimately the Hobbit encapsulates one of the great paradoxes of the gospel, that we have to lose our life in order to find it. We must die in order to live. We must die in order to love.

I'm going to go off on a long tangent here, but the modern world has got love all wrong. Love is not a feeling. I love you because you make me feel good. I mean you don't make me feel good anymore.

I find someone else to love. Love is not a feeling. Love is an action. Ultimately love is a commandment.

Love the Lord thy God. Love thy neighbor. Love thy enemy. However hard that might be.

It may not make you feel good. In order to love, we have to give ourselves to the other. We have to die to ourselves. We must die in order to live.

We must die in order to love. In the Hobbit, Bill by learns how to love. He learns how to live. And the most important thing of all, he learns how to live happily ever after.

Thank you so much. Okay, maybe five or ten minutes for questions if you have them. Are there any questions? I'm going to stand you all into silence.

Sorry? The question I skipped at the beginning. I'm not going to remember it either. Then I might have been that important.

Oh yes, okay. Well, Tolkien in that scale of significance about the importance of his relationship as author to the Lord of the Rings had again the more important factors was his love of languages. And the most important was the fact he's a Catholic and a Christian. He can be deduced from his stories.

But just below that, between the more important and the really significant, the least significant is the fact that I was born in the Shire in a pre-mechanical age. Now the point is Tolkien, that's not true. Now I'm not talking about a liar, but it's not true. Because Tolkien was born in 1892.

And anybody who knows anything about history knows anything about the Industrial Revolution about 150 years earlier than that. He was born in South Africa and quite clearly the Shire is meant to be Anglo-Saxon, Rustic, so he wasn't born in the Shire. He wasn't born in a pre-mechanical age. But what he's getting at, and I speak with him in my own shoulder so I can really relate to it, is that after his father died when he was very young and his mother became a Catholic and then had both her sons received to the church at the same time as sort of cradle converts if you like, that after that the family were plunged into penury because the little bit of help they were getting, of course the father dying unexpectedly when she had two young boys threw them into poverty, but they got some help from their families, her family and her husband's family.

But when she became a Catholic, that help was ended, cut off. The family were basically thrown into penury. Tolkien was convinced that he wrote on two occasions that his mother was a martyr for the Catholic faith. But because of that poverty, they lived for a while in Birmingham.

Birmingham in England was the second, I think, the second largest city in England after London. But it was a village, 150 years earlier. It became a city because of the industrial revolution. They lived in the middle of the city with a railway going out the back, to those days, of course, of steam, smoke and noise.

There were factory chimneys inside of the house, so it was noisy and smelly and polluted. That is not the shire in a pre-mechanical age. But Tolkien also lived for a while in his childhood in a little village in Worcester, called Serhol. He had a pond, he could play in, a tree, he could climb, an old fashioned mill that animated his imagination.

This was the shire. And the shire was more powerful because he knew Mordor. He saw the belching factories and the noise and the smell and the pollution of the big city where you couldn't see the countryside, you couldn't see wildlife. But he also experienced the village and the wildlife.

And it was the contrast between the two, which makes the experience of the shire as a child so powerful. But strictly speaking, the phrase is not accurate. Okay. Any other questions?

Yes. Who are the orcs? Who are the orcs? Who are the orcs?

Well, I mean, it was widely believed when the Lord of the Rings was published at the time of the Cold War, and of course the Second World War had recently happened, fascism was in recent past, communism was all very much around. And of course, George Orwell had recently published a 1984 on Animal Farm, CS Lewis, that he had a strength also to touch upon these issues of totalitarianism. So many people thought that the Lord of the Rings was also addressing these issues. And it's easily done because, you know, Sauron, the red eye, Saruman, the white hand, which after the fall of Isengard has read on his fingertips.

So you could, and then of course the shire of his England, but Tolkien would have spurned such reductionism. He said that the Lord of the Rings was an allegory of atomic power. And he wrote back, replied to the correspondent and said, no, but it is an allegory of power, particularly power usurped for domination. So there is that political aspect to it, but he says in the same letter, but more important than that, it's an allegory of death and immortality, which takes the whole thing up beyond politics to the level of philosophy and theology, which is why Tolkien says that all of the rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic world.

Because at its deepest level, it works on the level of theology, not on the level of politics, but it doesn't mean there's not political applicability, talking about applicability, and of course the work can be applied in all sorts of ways. There's another hand up. Okay, yeah. Of course, of course, which is why you're not doing Tolkien justice if you're saying that Lord of the Rings is merely a political allegory of contemporary times.

Tolkien was rooted in language, in the history of language. He spoke Old English, translated by a wolf. He spoke Old Norse, Greek, Latin. So he was rooted linguistically, he was also rooted historically as a Catholic, and he was also a traditionalist.

And one thing about tradition is it slows things down, healthfully. You can talk about political philosophy in terms of human society being a car, that progresses the gas pedal, the steering wheel is wisdom, and tradition is the brakes. We're living in a society now that's throwing away the steering wheel and refuses to use the brakes, and they wonder why we can be heading for disaster. Landscape with dragons, Michael Obrin's book.

It's a very big topic, and not quite frankly I can do justice to this evening. It's much safer to remain on safe ground, because we do live in a landscape with dragons. But what we can't do is, and this is a mistake in the other direction, we can obviously avoid allowing our children to read poisonous stuff. Most poisonous stuff is not actually stuff you read, it's stuff you see.

So I would actually first encourage people to skip with the television period. That's the first step you can do if you want to navigate your children with a landscape with dragons. Reading is less perilous, but you can also be perilous. But the other ever, the other extreme of error is to try to shield their children so much that you are trying to hide from them the fact that dragons exist.

Very stories always have dragons and evil witches and treachery and poison, because the real world has dragons and evil witches and treachery and poison. And so we need to, our children do have to be introduced to the reality of evil, as well as the course of the supremacy of virtue, from the earlier stage. We can't avoid the landscape with dragons in itself. We have to be careful that we're not allowed to be devoured by dragons because of the things we introduced them to.

But I think most of those are visual and not actually the things that you read for the most part. We have five seconds to ask another question, or I'm going to... Okay, thanks very much. And if you hang around and buy some books, that would be great.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Center for Evangelical Catholicism?

This episode is 59 minutes long.

When was this Center for Evangelical Catholicism episode published?

This episode was published on July 27, 2015.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Center for Evangelical Catholicism episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.