Skip to content
Chapter 28: Economic Ideas (Part 3: The Classics) episode artwork

Sep 3, 2019 36 min

Chapter 28: Economic Ideas (Part 3: The Classics)

from The Industrial Revolutions Hosted by Dave Broker

Please consider becoming a supporter on Patreon. Your support helps pay for the audio hosting service, the website, research materials, and other costs of delivering the podcast. Plus there are special perks available only to Patreon supporters, including footnotes, book reviews, special recognition, and more.Visit https://www.patreon.com/indrevpod today. Thank you!This week we discuss the so-called “Classical” school of economics, and the various ideas about capitalism, free trade, and labor during that period. In particular, we’ll be discussing the lives and works of Jean-Baptiste Say, David Ricardo, John Stuart Mill, the guys who influenced them, and the guys they influenced in turn.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Chapter 28: Economic Ideas (Part 3: The Classics)

0:00 36:19
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey, this is Dave. For this week's episode, I'm not going to run any ads, but before we get started, I do have a request. Please take a moment today to go to patreon.com slash indrevpod. That link will also be in the episode notes for this episode.

What is Patreon, you ask? Patreon is an online platform for fans of creators like me to patron their work. You see, it does cost money to deliver this podcast. There is the audio hosting service, the website, research materials, etc., none of which are free.

But if you enjoy this podcast, please consider becoming a patron. What do you get out of it? Well, everyone who signs up for as little as $1 per month gets access to the footnotes I compile for each episode. What I do is I add the footnotes to the script and then email them to all the Patreon supporters each week.

For example, in last week's script, I added a footnote to the section about John Law and how he had to convince the Prince Regent of France, the Duke of Arion, to support his scheme for the Louisiana Territory. And as part of that effort, Law named the new city in the territory after the Prince Regent. I can't fit every interesting factoid into each episode, so that's where the footnotes come in handy. I think you'll enjoy them.

Higher patronage levels come with additional perks. For $2 per month, you'll also get a monthly book review from me. I'm excited to tell you about some of my favorite books from this research process. For $3 per month, you'll also get monthly recognition in the episodes and in the e-newsletter.

For $5 per month, you'll get all those perks plus a free t-shirt. And for $10 per month, you'll get everything else mentioned, plus a direct line to me as an official advisor of the podcast. And surprise, yes, from time to time. And these are just the perks now.

I'll probably add some more perks to each level later on, possibly an ad-free stream, for example. I'm open to other suggestions, too. So please check out the Patreon page, patreon.com.com slash intrevpod. Thank you.

The era of classical economics can really be broken down into two periods. The first began with the publication of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, which we covered in Chapter 10, and continued through the end of the Napoleonic Wars, almost 40 years later. The second period covers the 30-plus years between the end of the Napoleonic Wars and the end of the first Industrial Revolution. Following Smith, there was a general sense of optimism about the economy and the future.

The middle classes of both Great Britain and the continent sensed a rising tide of industrialization and an expansion of political rights. And Smith's fellow philosophers and early economists shared that optimism. There was Antoine de Colasse de Condoséc, who wrote about the possibilities of continuous scientific progress. William Godwin, who, while much more radical than these other guys, wrote about the perfect ability of humankind.

And Friedrich Söden and Johann Friedrich Colasse, who expanded on and refined Smith's ideas. There were also some pessimists, our old friend Thomas Malthus comes to mind. As well as James Maitland Lauderdale, who was one of the first to note that machines could do more than help workers become more productive, they could also just replace workers. Lauderdale's theory of value stood in stark contrast to Smith's.

Value wasn't just derived from labor, it also came from capital and land, too. But no other economist of this period stood out, like Jean-Baptiste Se. Born into a Protestant merchant family in Lyon in 1767, Se was sent to England as a teenager, the study as a trade apprentice in the London area. He returned France in 1786 and spent a few years working in life insurance, and then as a journalist.

During the height of the French Revolution, he served as a secretary to the Jacobin Finance Minister, Étine Clavier. But after his boss committed suicide following the fall of the Gerondins, Se took over as editor of La Decade, a philosophical, literary, and political journal. It was during those years he began importing the ideas of Adam Smith to the continent. Then from 1800 to 1804, Se took up a post in Napoleon's consular government and dived deep into writing his economic philosophy.

In particular, he published his treatise on political economy. But when Napoleon took over his emperor, Se had had enough, and instead he went into the private sector. With this career move, he imported British textile and manufacturing ideas to set up a new cotton-spinning mill at Aushie Le Hizin, where he employed as many as 500 workers, mostly women and children. After the fall of Napoleon, Se briefly went back to the UK to study the developments of the Industrial Revolution there, before coming back to France and taking over as chair of Industrial Economy at the Conservatory of Arts and Crafts for 13 years.

He then took over a professorship teaching political economy at the College of France, where he spent the rest of his life. These experiences were unique among economists of this era, and they no doubt had a profound influence on his views. Se was the quintessential bourgeois liberal of the age, favoring radical political reform and a free-market capitalist economy. He was a big supporter of Smith's work, although, like the French physiocrats, a generation before him, Se differed from Smith in two important ways.

Number one, he didn't think all value was derived from labor. He agreed with Lauderdale that value was also derived from capital and land. He called these the three types of productive service. Number two, his views of government and markets were much more laissez-faire than Smith's work.

Among other things, Se understood the law of supply and demand, and probably explained it better than any previous economist. He also formulated an important theory of entrepreneurship. In fact, Se is the guy who coined the term entrepreneur. Basically, the entrepreneur is the person who looks at the demand up there for a certain good, calculates the cost of his production, and then determines whether or not it makes economic sense for him to produce that good and deliver it to the market.

This feeds into the most important of his ideas, which is known to us as Se's law, from his treatise of political economy. He says, quote, inherent in supply is the wherewithal for its own consumption. Or as John Maynard Keynes later explained it, supply creates its own demand. Now, this was, and remains today, a fairly controversial idea.

Se is essentially claiming that there cannot be excess supply in the market. If it's produced, it will be consumed. To explain, he says that a merchant who receives an income doesn't keep an excess of his money. He's going to spend that money, maybe on food or clothing, or on capital investments for his business.

And while that's not strictly true, especially in the short run, it is generally true in the long run. So he expands on the idea, as he puts it, quote, products are paid for with products. He's arguing that, in a free, laissez-faire market, all things come back to an efficient equilibrium. Smith believed that self-interest would generally serve the public interest, but he didn't believe that was an absolute truth, as he sought capitalists and especially bankers were capable of economically destructive greed.

But Se's optimism defined the age. With liberty, political, and economic, mankind could be at its most virtuous and most productive. But the good times didn't last forever. After the defeat of Napoleon, the economic contractions in Britain and the following panic of 1825 signaled not all was well.

Smith and Se and others may have been optimistic about economic modernization, but now it was becoming clear that transition wouldn't be entirely positive. There would be new kinds of hardships, new challenges for policymakers, and new intellectual battles that he fought. And on that battlefield, the new study of economics would be on the front line. This is the Industrial Revolutions, Chapter 28, Economic Ideas, Part 3, The Classics.

Now during the Napoleonic Wars, trade between the United Kingdom and the continent had largely been cut off, but with the emperors' defeat at Waterloo, Britain would be able to start importing grains from Europe again, and sure enough, grain prices fell. Now, if you were a laborer, this was great. You wouldn't have to pay as much to get fed. And if you were a manufacturer, this was great, because your workers wouldn't come to you asking for a race in order to afford bread.

But if you were a landowner, lower grain prices were a problem. The crops produced on your lands would fetch lower prices, meaning the rents you collected from your tenants would be lower. You'd be making less money. Well, that landed gentry, still dominated parliament.

And in 1815, they passed the Corn Law, keeping prices artificially high. In 1822, they also passed a new importation act, which is that height hair of sun grain imports. Collectively, these Corn Laws came to dominate parliamentary debate in the early 19th century, as one of the key issues dividing liberal industrialists from conservative aristocrats. Okay, a time out for my fellow American listeners, corn does not mean the same thing in Europe as it means to us.

That's what you might call maize. Corn to them means cereal grains, wheat, barley, malt, rye, etc. Anyway, among the members of parliament who opposed the Corn Laws was the investor, turned economist, turned politician David Ricardo. Born in 1772, Ricardo was the third son in a Jewish immigrant family from the Netherlands.

His father was a banker, and when David was 14 years old, they went into business together, making a fortune in the stock market. At age 21, David married a Quaker woman named Priscilla Ann Wilkinson, and for marrying outside their religions, both families disowned them. They became Unitarians instead, and Ricardo remained a member of the London Stock Exchange where he continued amassing a fortune. Then in 1799, he read The Wealth of Nations, and over the next decade, he became obsessed with economic theory, reading as much as he could.

In 1810, he wrote his first economic essay, criticizing the country's bulliness to policies. But it was the Corn Laws, flying directly in the face of Smith's free trade ideas that really set him off. The year the Corn Law was passed, Ricardo wrote a pamphlet expanding on Malthus' theory of differential rent to argue against the bill. Then in 1817, he published his most important work, The Principles of Political Economy and Taxation.

The year after he bought a seat in Parliament, because you could do those things in those days, to represent the Irish Rotten Burrow of Port Arlington. We'll talk about Rotten Burrows some other time, I promise. And while the means with which he took office were, hmm, corrupt, Ricardo was a genuine voice for political and economic reform. Being just about the only person in Parliament who understood economics, he was also fairly popular there, with his fellow members, who sought him out to explain these complex issues to them in a straightforward way.

But he only got to serve a few years in Parliament, before his untimely death from an ear infection in 1823, at the age of 51. He wouldn't live to see the Corn Laws repealed, nor would he live to see his ideas come to dominate the field of economics in ways he never could have expected. Arguing against the Corn Laws, Ricardo reasoned that the country only had so much land for cultivation. If tariffs inhibit the importation of grains, it means more of the national income would go to agriculture, and by extension to the gentry.

These landowners will continue to pay their workers subsistence level wages and capture the rest. But what are they going to do with that money? There's not much reinvesting you can do when you own land. You could buy more land, but that won't increase the total stock of land cultivated in the country, that just means the land cultivated would change hands.

Meanwhile, industry suffers because industrialists would have to pay their workers more and more to accommodate rising food prices. This would fall, and it's the industrialists who can actually grow production and the economy with profits, unlike the landowners. Ricardo argued it would be better to repeal the Corn Laws, open up free trade with the rest of the world, import cheap grains from other countries, and drive down grain prices in the UK. While that'll suck a bit for landowners, it will mean greater profits for industrialists who can, in turn, reinvest those profits into increasingly efficient means of production.

Then, they could sell the goods produced for the UK's trade partners, cement the country status as workshop of the world, and have enough cash rolling in so nobody ever worries about the price of food ever again. Now, this opened up a lot of other avenues of economic thought for Ricardo, in part because it opened up several lines of debate with his rival economist, though close personal friend, Thomas Malthus. Malthus argued that the Corn Laws were acceptable because the landowner's rents and workers' wages get spent, feeding back into the economy, whereas the manufacturer's profits just keep building up in the accumulation of money. But as Ricardo was able to rebut, savings and investment are one in the same.

Tapping says law. He notes that there cannot be an excess of money. Even if you're not purchasing fixed capital like machines, you're going to put your profits into circulating capital. You're going to buy stocks, or bonds, or even dump the cash into a savings account where it'll earn interest.

And then it will be used to fund other endeavors elsewhere in the economy. My decision to save results in my neighbor's decision to spend. While this might sound fairly obvious today, it was a bit of a breakthrough in explaining what constitutes the national income and how an economy can grow. Their debate also spurred Ricardo to develop a theory of profits and wages, so explosive that it left divisions in economic thought still felt to this day.

Like Malthus, Ricardo believed that in the long run, the working class would never be able to earn much more than subsistence-level wages. This equilibrium for unskilled labor is known as the Iron Law of Wages. Now, this part of Ricardo's theory is generally ignored today, as we know it's not true. But the rest of the theory is pretty interesting.

Ricardo noted that when a good is sold, the money earned from it goes to two places. First to wages, that is paying the workers who produced it, and second to profits, amassed by the industrialist. As wages are driven up, profits will necessarily fall. To some extent, new technologies can help increase the profits, but Ricardo feared that would usually be in the form of machines that replace workers rather than help the workers increase their productivity.

Ricardo also believed in Smith's labor theory of value, that all value is derived from labor. I mean, yeah, machines can help create value, but who built the machines? People doing labor. Where did they get the raw materials to build said machines?

From people doing labor. Then he expanded on this concept, writing, quote, the value of a commodity, or the quantity of any other commodity for which it will exchange, depends on the relative quantity of labor, which is necessary for its production, and not on the greater or less compensation which is paid for that labor. Did you get that? Not on the greater or less compensation which is paid for that labor.

In other words, profits only exist because workers aren't getting compensated the full amount of the value they create. Almost from the get-go, this idea took on a new name. The exploitation of labor. Now, there's a lot I'm not telling you about Ricardo's theories, and in fact, a lot of the other stuff he wrote about is either irrelevant to us today, or has been discredited, or so refined that it need not be mentioned.

He did not believe in the business cycle, for example, that the economy could grow and crash periodically, a belief that the Panic of 1825, two years after his death, proved wrong. But for his insights on free trade, capital accumulation, and wages and profits, Ricardo became the single most influential economist of the 19th century, and he spawned three distinct schools of economic thought. First, was the so-called Ricardians, including James Mill, John Ramsey McCulloch, and William Wewell. These guys loved Ricardo, promoted his work, and expanded on it.

The great Robert Torrance can also arguably be included in this camp, since his theories and methods were so similar to Ricardo's, although he did reach some very different conclusions. Second, was the Ricardian Socialists, who saw in Ricardo's writings the reasoning for an anti-industrialist philosophy, namely when it came to the exploitation of labor. They included William Thompson, John Gray, John Francis Bray, Charles Hall, Thomas Hodgkin, and arguably the somewhat fascinating character, Piercy Ravenstone. And finally, there were the anti-Recardians, guys like Samuel Bailey, Massa William Sr., Samuel Reed, George Paulitz Scrope, and Samuel Monteford Longfield.

Principally, they were opposed to Ricardo's labor theory, and they went to great lengths to undermine it. In their works, they also got hauntingly close to uncovering another economic concept, diminishing marginal utility. But that's for another time. After the wealth of nations, economics took a rather smithing orthodoxy for a long time.

Say for a few guys like Malthus, it was a pretty classic liberal philosophy. But after Ricardo, economics became fractured. A variety of socialists and neoclassicalists would duke it out over the next, well now, almost two centuries. Among other things, these guys would all have to deal with the fallout of the Panic of 1825 and subsequent economic meltdowns, and how they responded to these meltdowns differed, but that the meltdowns were happening at all provided the socialists the evidence they needed to rise and influence in the 1830s and 40s.

In the long run, capitalists were getting rich while their workers were getting nowhere, while in the short run, economic anxiety was common, with occasional bouts of misery. But one man would try to keep the peace by synthesizing many of the new ideas into a comprehensive and honest economic philosophy. Let's back up a few years. Adam Smith wasn't the only moral philosopher interested in economics.

Among others would be one of Smith's friends and correspondence. Jeremy Bentham. Now, if you don't know much about him, I mean, you should research him if you don't. You should remember his brother, Samuel Bentham, from Chapter 13, the factory system.

Samuel was the naval officer, who worked with Mark Isambard Brunel to launch the high-tech blockmills at the Portsmouth Dockyards. More importantly, though, Jeremy Bentham is known for his work advancing a new moral philosophy, called utilitarianism. According to the opening lines of his 1780 book, an introduction to the principles of morals and legislation, human beings are driven by their desire to increase utility. A word he uses to describe, quote, that property of any object whereby it tends to produce benefit, advantage, pleasure, good, or happiness, or to prevent, quote, mischief, pain, evil, or unhappiness to the party whose interest is considered.

While difficult, perhaps to measure, utility serves as a quantifiable metric for good. And very simply, the goal of policymakers and others should be to create the greatest amount of utility possible for the greatest number of people. And while it certainly has its drawbacks, this is a very practical moral philosophy, free from religious overtone or tradition, which can be readily adapted anywhere. This philosophy also spoke to the spirit of the age, the Industrial Revolution, in which industrialists were trying to maximize everything, for their good, and by extension they believed, for the nation and world at large.

Among Bentham's many students was the industrialist Robert Owen, a sort of socialist-minded capitalist, who we still need to talk about. Another was his secretary, a brilliant philosopher and political economist in his own right, James Mill. James Mill was a big believer in free trade, and Ricardo's defense of free trade in particular, and he added some clarity to a major concept Ricardo had worked on in that defense. Quote, If two countries can both of them produce two commodities, corn, for example, and cloth, but not both commodities, with the same comparative facility, the two countries will find their advantage in confining themselves each to one of the commodities, bartering for the other.

He then goes on a rather lengthy explanation of how many hours it would take to produce each commodity in Poland versus England. This explanation of comparative advantage is still used in economics classes today. I've sat through them, and maybe you have too. Among the things Jeremy Bentham and James Mill did together was experiment with the education of James's son after he was born in 1806.

Bentham wanted to see if they could turn him into a genius by subjecting him to a rigorous upbringing. He was taught to read Greek by age 3, Latin by age 8, and to compose poetry and understand advanced theories of mathematics before he was a teenager. To these ends, he would not be allowed to associate with other children, save for his siblings, since they might slow down his development. Now, the boy would grow up with some, uh, issues, by age 19 he had a nervous breakdown.

But he did go on to become one of the greatest philosophers of the 19th century. He would also be the last true leader in the Classical School of Economics, John Stuart Mill. An avid utilitarian, like his father and Bentham, J.S. Mill believed strongly in creating a just society that produced the greatest good for the greatest number.

By his teenage years, he had also become enmeshed in the works of their economist friends, the late Adam Smith and David Ricardo. In fact, Ricardo and the Mills would go on walks together to discuss political economy. When it came to his political philosophy, especially in the book on liberty, Mill is bold and on point. His economic philosophy, meanwhile, has been described as trying to please everyone to the point of irrelevance.

He described it as harmonization and a constant effort to quote, construct bridges and clear roads in the works of his predecessors. I for one very much think it's time the world revisit Mill, especially his 1848 book, Principles of Political Economy. For one thing, he wanted to harmonize the utilitarian philosophy with the liberal economics of the Classical Era. The laws of production, developed by Smith, say and Ricardo, didn't line up with the laws of distribution.

As Mill put it, quote, the rules by which distribution are determined are what the opinions and feelings of the ruling portion of the community make them, and are very different in different ages and countries, and might be still more different if mankind so choose, end quote. So if society wished to, I don't know, favor principles of equality, it could rearrange distribution of income along those lines. Now, that's not to say he was a socialist, he made sure to make that very clear, but he was certainly sympathetic to socialism, and even more so, to trade unionism. Nevertheless, he stuck to the traditional confines of the classical school.

Among the things that raised eyebrows among his lefty friends, Mill developed an important labor wage curve. Essentially, he argued that the demand for labor is what it is, and the supply of labor determines the price of it, the wages. If you take steps to increase wages outside that market system, such as through collective bargaining or by setting a minimum wage, what it will do is increase unemployment. More workers will enter the labor market seeking that heightened wage, yet there will be fewer opportunities available to them because some employers won't want to pay the higher wages, and they'll leave the market.

Now, in practice, this model isn't perfect. I mean, wages are sticky, right? Don't worry, we'll get to Keynes all the time. But in broad strokes, yeah, lifting wages reduces job opportunities.

Mill caught a lot of flack for this, and so he fine-tuned the theory in later years. But perhaps more importantly, Mill also developed an interesting theory of value. Again, differentiating himself from Ricardo, Mill argues that while all value is derived from labor, value also depends on capital. The means of production and the jobs associated with them require not only wages going to workers, but also profits going to their employers.

I, Dave Broker, am sure I can make a screw, but not without some training on a machine, like the lathes built by Henry Modsley. Oh sure, those machines were built by workers in a factory, and the iron ore steel for the machines were molded by workers in a foundry, and the iron ore for them was dug out by workers in mine. So yeah, all value is derived from labor. But as a matter of practicality, someone had to pay to build a foundry.

Someone had to pay to build the factory, and someone had to pay to get the lathe, and if no one is making a profit, then no one has the money to pay for any of that stuff. This was such a profound concept that even Karl Marx found it necessary to account for it in his theory of labor exploitation in Das Kapital. But according to Mill, workers do not have a right to the whole of what they produce because it is not only their labor which contributes to the creation of value, but also the abstinence of some pay so that capital can accumulate. What's amazing about this is just a hundred years earlier, this wouldn't have been such a big deal.

Over the 1750s, most workers owned their own tools, operating out of their own little shops. But by the 1840s, that had changed. Industrialization and capitalism had produced a new status quo for production, and it seemed to be causing as much pain and frustration as it was material well-being. As you've probably noticed by now, the field of economics has been gravitating more and more towards socialism as we go.

And by the time Mill wrote his works on political economy, at the end of the first Industrial Revolution, several socialist thinkers, and even distinct schools of socialism were gaining ground. In fact, the most famous, and perhaps most radical among them, Marx would publish his Communist Manifesto the same year as Mill's principles of political economy. But we're going to leave the socialists for another time. Instead, we're going to keep discussing the growth of capitalism.

And we're going to talk about one particular family, who accumulated previously unthinkable amounts of capital, and used it to spread industrial growth across the globe. The family, which is perhaps more responsible than any other, for the making of the modern world. The Rothschilds. Next week on the Industrial Revolutions.

Hey, we are really close to 100 ratings on Apple Podcasts. If you use Apple Podcasts but haven't rated this podcast yet, please do. And even more importantly, please write a short review. It helps more people discover the Industrial Revolutions.

I'll appreciate you so much for it that I might just read your review in the next episode. Thanks as always.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Industrial Revolutions?

This episode is 36 minutes long.

When was this The Industrial Revolutions episode published?

This episode was published on September 3, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Industrial Revolutions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.