Reese's knows a thing or two about great combinations. Chocolate and peanut butter, obviously, but there's more than one way to Reese's. From indulgent Reese's pick-ups with Caramel, to crunchy Reese's pieces and Reese's miniatures, there's a delicious Reese's for every mood. It's the same combo you love just with more ways to enjoy it.
So whether you're snacking, sharing, or just treating yourself, nothing else is Reese's. Hello and welcome to For The State, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from Touristia in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Euro Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the Globe via podcast, I'm Anthony Dockwell. In our first show for 2023, we are looking at a subject that has been on many people's minds, especially if you work in a location that uses words like journalism.
That subject is AI, and in particular, chat GPT. As chat GPT has become more valuable for people to try, the results have caused the alarm bells all over the world. If chat GPT can write long-form copy in model styles and an extended many humans would struggle to achieve, our journalists are about to go the way of the blacksmith. Or are we about to embark on a new era where journalists are set free from some of the more mundane and time-consuming parts of their job?
To discuss this and more, we are joined by two humans, well qualified to take us through what is shaping to be the biggest revolution since the personal computer or the invention of the internet. Dr. Sacha Morotaurus is a senior lecturer at UTS, and in a previous life was a feature writer for the Sydney Morninghold. Sacha is the author of Net Privacy, How We Can Be Free in an Age of Surveillance.
And Charlie Lewis is the tips and merma editor at Crykey. He also presents SpinCycle on Triple R in Melbourne. Dr. Sacha Morotaurus and Charlie Lewis, welcome to For The State.
Thank you, Danny. Look, we've also seen the demonstrations, and I'm guessing you both have had time now to try out chat GPT for yourself. Are we on the cusp of a revolution? Oh, Jay, I don't know.
That's kind of an impossible question, isn't it? I think obviously there's a lot going on. There's a lot of substantial that's going on, and meanwhile there's a lot that's just hype that's going on. So it's really hard to pull those two apart.
You know, we've had some really interesting big stuff, particularly with chat GPT late last year, you know, building on GPT-3 in 2020, I think it was. So this is a hugely forward Microsoft has made it, you know, many billion dollar investment in the revolution. I don't know. I will tell, but it's only it feels like a bit of a moment, doesn't it?
Yeah, I'm Charlie. What do you think? I suppose, I mean, to the extent that there's a revolutionary element to this, it is one that's probably been ongoing for a bit for a while. We've had obviously a lot of hugely forwards in a official intelligence over the last year, not just in areas like chat GPT and tech space, but obviously across areas like surveillance.
If you can go back to 1996 and have a computer beating a Grandmaster of chess. So I mean, to some extent, you know, this is a process that is sort of quite a long way into its, it's quite a long way along the line. I think, you know, obviously in terms of the concerns that we'll go into about something like chat GPT, perhaps as I said, it's almost impossible to say how soon this, whether there'll be any kind of major cliff moment where it's obvious before and after moment coming. Yeah, I'm interested to see what you both felt about this.
Like I had a very strong reaction when I started filling around with chat GPT. It was not just scary in its ability, but it was also humbling as it shows what we think, something that makes us special. A lot of what we think makes us special is actually just mechanical assemblage and reducible to algorithms. Have humans just been taken down a pig?
Very true. I had something of a similar reaction. I didn't spend too much time on it and I don't want to help train me. I wasn't too much.
So, you know, I have my concerns with a number of reasons I'm still getting into. But yeah, I was actually strangely impressed with the quality of the content of produced and it's not making anything right? I mean, it's just, it's just not copying and pasting, but it's just like scanning the whole internet and redoitating bits. So with that in mind, yeah, I was pretty impressed.
So I typed in a couple of exam questions that I'd set in the second semester for some lore exam and the responses were surprisingly good. They're about the role of a particular type of ethics, virtue ethics, the lawyers and how does that sit with their professional codes of conduct? So basically how do people theories align, go with it and compliment what they have to do professionally under their codes of conduct? Yeah, and the answers were surprising.
What marks did you give it? Yeah, well, to be honest, I would give those answers good marks. You know, and I have to say very good marks. And the reason I think is, is because there is good stuff on the internet about that, about that sort of general question.
So, chap JPT uses data collected up to about mid 2021. The question that I just told you about is a very general question. There's been well answered online. I mentioned there's a bit of a consensus online where there seems to be, and the short answer is yes, lawyers do need to supplement their professional codes of conduct with ethical theory, including virtue ethics.
That to me is a good answer. The only way answer perhaps not is a very good answer, the sound answer. And chap JPT just articulated in a way that was about 300 words. It was very logical.
It kind of set out the key issues. It gave a definition of virtue with definition of professional codes of conduct. So, just what you kind of take to student to do it. So, yeah, it was definitely quite impressive.
Okay, well, let's jump into the big one. We'll artificial intelligence like chap JPT replace human journalists as editors turn to the technology for content creation and curation in the media industry. Charlie, you can jump in first on this one. I mean, I think in the setup, as I understand it now, I mean, I don't think so, or at least not 100% not on mass because it doesn't know anything.
It has no expertise as such. It just scans the internet and collects that into an article or an argument. And I do think, I mean, it's interesting, a lot of the, I was interested to hear something that you thought that the quality of writing was really good. So, the stuff I've seen, it's been possible, but I haven't seen much that's really, you know, I think a mumbrillated in an experiment where they try to get some mimic various kind of hyper-vile Australian journalists like Virginia Trian and I own Jones and people like that.
And I wasn't actually that impressed with like say, it's force of language, with its ability to forceally and memorably kind of perform an argument. I do agree that it definitely was able to put arguments together in a sort of clear and logical sense. I suppose that in some ways are still just as much an attack on what journalists are supposed to be able to do. But in terms of, yeah, but going forward, you have to say that of course that gets more and more sophisticated.
And of course it's not just chat GPT, it's not just that, it's obviously, you know, Google search and Microsoft being both pretty good AI chatbots for their search engines to help kind of summarize and deliver kind of summaries of the information you're searching for. So that's going to be another sort of filter between the human being and the information that they get. So it is very worrying in that regard. In response to, yeah, I don't think it will be good.
And what I've seen isn't good in terms of writing the style of, of, of data, or whoever we're talking about. But, you know, that sort of clear, logical writing, that was, that was what I thought was quite impressive. But we're faced journalists, certainly not the short term. And, you know, we've come across a number of examples of inaccuracies, you know, and they've got down inaccuracies.
There are problems with the content of producers if we're measuring biocuracies, right? And we know that in Google's own primary materials. So, you know, that's an issue for journalists. And yet we know that there are companies that are already using it and have communities using GPT as well as other AI, which is content in the short term, I think, the break.
You know, Australia is one of the first to come out to say that. And some other companies have made similar comments that they will be exploring, you know, looking into it. So what exactly that means? I'm not sure.
I'm not sure. How much content they're going to allow. Obviously there are certain journalistic skills that the AI cannot replicate. I mean, you can't show up where it's not one of the most difficult questions.
It's a, you know, it can't make moral judgments in the same way as a human being can. And I think, and that's very important. But that's only important if you really give, if you really care about a kind of a certain quality of journalism, human quality of journalism. If you're only worried about content, then it can absolutely replace your workforce.
This technology is only going to get better. In the case of chat GPT, there's a new version coming out soon. And, you know, it's already a soundingly good in limited ways. But let's assume that it does get better.
You know, humans are expensive. We get sick. We take holidays. We don't answer work emails when we're sleeping.
We also want to get paid more every year. If, if you were editors trying to cut costs, wouldn't you reach out to this technology? Hence how can a mercenary on right now? How much I value people.
Look, Charlie was raising this point about, you know, all the things that journalists do when it's not just the truth that their ethical judgments wrapped up in there. To me, what's important, you know, I went with the Senate to make your transition and, you know, we're involved in, say, the media firing code and various aspects of journalism and regulation about journalism. And so we put up against this issue of what is journalism all the time and what makes it valuable. And so to me, what makes journalism valuable is, well, not all journalism is valuable, right?
What makes journalism valuable is the stuff about it that's in the public interest. And what makes it valuable is the fact that people are taking into account ethics and making decisions in the pursuit of accuracy and fairness and balance all these traditional journalistic qualities. Now, AI can't do that. AI has no idea about the concept of objectivity, which admittedly is a really contested concept.
Right? It's a really healthy, I think, debate going on in journalism about what is objectivity mean? We still value it, we still pursue it. What role does advocacy journalism have?
Right? There's a really important question about what the role of journalism should be. Where does AI come in? It doesn't.
It just regurgitates content, it falls with the net and regurgitates what's already out there. So I guess to use AI like this, in journalism can work, from my point of view, but it needs to work with significant human oversight, you know, and with people and with editors. So to your question about, you know, if I were an editor, would I just employ AI? Well, no, because I do think fundamentally that's something that people do and can do and make a decision.
But I might employ it in a certain way to supplement what happens in the newsroom. You know, perhaps it can do certain types of preliminary reports, you know, whether that's just financial figures or whether or whatever it is that compliments what humans do. And then what human journalists do will actually be the more sophisticated analysis and certain kind of pieces and all sorts of other genres and picture writing. You know, it doesn't love a beautifully well-crafted feature.
So yeah, that would be my position as well. Charlie? I think I just completely agree with that, Sashron. Is that it's extended as useful as a, as a, as a research tool, and then that could potentially be useful for a newsroom, but it does have to be done with a huge amount of human oversight.
And also I'm equally inamored with and I think it's a dying art anyway, which is really lovely. It is a kind of human prose focused feature running already, but dying art is taking an Australian and AI is in a position to kind of take over that. Yeah, so it looks like we've got a consensus here that some jobs are definitely in trouble. Like if you were doing cut and paste journalism at the Daily Mail or producing listicles at Buzzfeed, you probably not in a safe position, but quality journalism, investigative journalism sounds like it's actually quite secure.
So in that setting, is AI actually a useful tool rather than a threat? I would hope so. Yeah, I'd hope so. It's going to take a few years to play out, but yeah, hopefully it can be a useful tool for journalism.
You know, in the way that various aspects of technology have already become, you know, the international consortium of investigative journalists has an office here at BTS and the local faculty, and they have done such amazing work, you know, with the Panama Papers and all their other investigations, and that was all possible because of digital technology and all the connections they could make with journalists all around the world, you know, something like the Panama Papers, I think it was 17 countries, you know, something journalists, and all these newsrooms collaborating over a year or more, and working with this massive drive of documents that was leaked from the law firm in Panama, you know, that is all made possible by tech. That couldn't have happened in the old days. It was digital tech and communications that made that possible. In the same way, I think, you know, AI now will probably open up new doors for some types of journalism, perhaps maybe even ones we can't really foresee.
But yeah, I do come back to that point that I think it's, you know, you said this is something you use, you put it well when you said that it's about quality or investigative journalism, but seeing like CHAPTBT is the first thing I just need to do with it, and we're talking about, you know, maybe more mundane tasks, you know, we're talking about rip-off journalism. That's not something that I want to say provided anyway, but yeah, that could be too prepared by AI. And I think that does get to a little bit the fact that there's more than one threat to quality journalism in the kind of political world now. It's not, I mean, we mentioned BuzzFeed.
They, for quite a while, did do quite very good political journalism, and of course, financial considerations kind of goes out. That wasn't AI that ever was going to threaten that kind of journalism. I mean, one of the interesting things I read about this is that, you know, when the Industrial Revolution came along, it was difficult jobs that were got replaced. So, you know, heavy jobs, technology came in and made and took those jobs away.
Here we are looking at something that's going to take away the lower end, the lower skill jobs we're talking about, the less experienced, the less important part of journalism is under threat. But, you know, everyone has to start somewhere. Many journalists have started BuzzFeed as we know who have now gone on to amazing things. It does seem that there's a, even if investigative journalism, high quality journalists are safe, it does seem to be baking and a problem for the industry.
Yeah, well, I've seen that doesn't come to pass the way you described it. I think there are always the jobs that the jobs that the journalists need to do in their first years and then, you know, those kind of roles where you can't keep teaching, write a new story of 400 words, the teachers you had to do. And I don't know, maybe the AI can play a role in that training as well. You know, maybe those early years will be partly AI working together with young journalists.
You know, there might be some sort of role to AI for training purposes. I don't know. One of the things about journalism that people don't really understand is that the copy comes last. You know, you get a lead, you make editorial judgements, you search out the story, you do a lot of hard work, you get your facts, you check your facts, you verify your sources, then you write your copy.
And the facts is a really important part of journalism. Chat JPT, like all AI chatbots, has been shown to have a pretty checkered record when it comes to facts. It's normally factual, but at the same time, it's been shown quite often to make stuff up. In the, in the AI field, it's called an hallucination where the bot just feels a gap in with something, it's just sourced from somewhere else.
So, Sasha, how wide should we be about the accuracy of his chatbots and their tendency to hallucinate? It's really concerning. You know, accuracy is, you know, it's just absolutely one of your chief imperatives of the journalists. You know, you need to be accurate.
And if you're not, then what are you doing? You know, you have to be accurate. You don't want to deceive your audience. You don't want to be truthful with them.
So it is concerning that AI, which just throws the web and then will spit out what the web has on it, will necessarily give us a lot that is not true. And it won't signal what's true and what isn't. It's just all mixed together. And this word of hallucination that you use describes when you produce a something that's coherent and plausible, and it happens to know, and look at it deeper, it turns out to be totally untrue.
So this is, it's really concerning. One of my favorite journalists that I used to work at the Sydney Morning Herald, some time ago I was telling a little bit of time in reporting state politics, and there was the chief of the Bureau at the time. I don't even have the paper for a few months. I was really sort of a sponge and just absorbing how he was working.
And he was really good journalist and more always get really good stories. Watching him work, he would spend all day just, you know, sort of going around talking to people, listening, thinking, sitting in to the parliamentary sessions. He would write the story really quickly. Only got quite a few mistakes in the grammatical mistakes and that sort of thing.
And the subs would have to work some of the paragraphs around. But he just waited until the last possible, you know, you know, pissing off a lot of the subs and others. But he would get a really good story because he got everything, you know, he could see the picture. And so that's a completely different way.
To me, that was excellent journalism. You know, like he got a grammar on sometimes, but he got the picture right. And then there were checks and balances to fix up the grammar and, you know, that sort of stuff. Whereas the guy is working in, it has a completely different methodology.
It just, it looks at what's out there. And then it kind of draws on that to make it coherent, slab of text. Yeah, I think it's a different sort of, I tell you. Yes, absolutely.
I think you can always tell the difference. And I think also it goes sort of tangent from that also kind of proselysis like this kind of, it's like another very bad trend in journalism, which is kind of not the death, but the kind of eroding of expertise and beats and areas that people have some personal expertise on that they reported on for a long time. Obviously, as we said before, an AI doesn't know anything. It doesn't remember things happening.
It doesn't have context in that same way. It doesn't assess those things based on that context and that knowledge it already has. It just draws and sits out what appears to be on the face of it a coherent and plausible answer. On that point, one of the most interesting things I read was from David Chalmers, who's an Australian philosopher, and he's a philosopher of mine, so you know, he stands there thinking about consciousness.
And these things, and he, he wrote in 2020 when a JPT-3 came out, he said, look, does this thing have consciousness? Well, you know, I could say, I could possibly answer yes, but I could possibly answer yes, but it doesn't have understanding. You know, so that's where it still is, that is the kind of key difference that this day is. There's no understanding on that level.
But it fakes understanding at a level that is astounding at the same time. Why do you make expertise? It actually makes a mockery of expertise because like, you've got it writing an answer to a legal question. It can write about last night's episode of Marited First Sight.
It can write some Java code and you can get it the right movie script and anything in between. Expertise becomes almost nonsense. Well, yes or no, because obviously it's still relying on information that has been put into the public domain, often by hopefully experts. Obviously, it's not just consulting experts, that's the real issue with it.
But it doesn't make it, I suppose, in a way, that kind of reinforces why the expertise is so important, because that's a big part of assessing the credibility and the usefulness of the information that you're interrogating. Sorry. That's a very important point. And it is something that we should dwell on that these bots are relying on human input and human generation facts and material.
And this is where things can get very murky, that if humans stop producing as much of this stuff, and the web becomes largely produced by AI, where are we? I'm going into, obviously, a philosophical area where I'm guessing no one has an answer, but these are very important questions. Humans are still very much part of this whole equation. I guess we're debating about where we do we stay in that equation or do we take a step back?
Absolutely. If we just rely on this AI from this point forward, then we've got a full stop on where we go as a civilization. And that's because it's all just looking at what's there on the web already. If you want to have new research and new journalism, the topic of today, we need people like Kate McQuine, one of the other wonderful investors in journalists, and all the other great feature writers that we have to do something new to make us think in fresh ways to reveal something that we didn't know before.
That's a powerful thing that journalists, among some other people, can do. When you were saying before about the Industrial Revolution and how that kind of removed all the difficult jobs, and it is funny, and quite a bit of a calling thing to reflect on, that it's like, yeah, tech was supposed to make our lives easier and give us more time to work on higher pursuits, and now it's just making sure that painters can't get jobs and writers are going to become opposite. Let's turn to chat GPT's politics. Officially, it has no political views and does not engage with politics, but on a whole range of issues, it's been shown to be pro-environment and left-leaning, or that is how it has been perceived.
The alt-right has been complaining that this particular chatbot has woke. But is it woke or is it just a case of something that Stephen Colbert observed many, many years ago that reality has a well-known liberal bias? Charlie? I don't know if I'll go that far.
What I would say is that the makers of the chatp G have very open about that it has these moderation filters that steer away from certain potentially dodgy topics. So there was a recent piece in the data graph whipping up a little bit of a culture war front on this one, which is saying that it's a biased and woke, and it would refuse, for example, to write a poem, an ode of praising George Bell. It said he's faced the most serious accusations and it wouldn't be appropriate to do that, and that was taken to be evidence that it was left-leaning and woke. The thing about those moderation is that it's well-documented in all AI that if you don't put filters like that in, you very soon start dealing with a racist, basically, when they scan all of social media and all of it.
There was studies done by John Hawking University and the Georgia Institute of Technology a year or two ago, and they basically tested these virtual AI robots and asked them to do things like scan blocks of people's faces and put to the criminal in a box. You can probably guess the answer it always went with, it was always a black man's face. So if you don't put these things in, it starts to absorb, again, it goes back to what chat PT does. It takes all of the internet and there's a lot of very nasty stuff on the internet, so it absorbs all the prejudices that are making to that process.
Now, whether sometimes that does give you slightly absurd outcomes, it's not again or there really, but that was designed, I suppose, to counteract very well-known biases in the other direction that happens if you don't put those in. It actually does raise, just I'll go on so much longer, but it does raise another kind of real concern about something like AI taking a lot of young journalists, jobs, young journalists in particular, is that it again accelerates, I think, quite a bad trait, a long-term trait in Australian journalism in particular, which is the lack of diversity. It means that you are now getting a circle of the white male university educated, middle-aged bias of mainstream Australian journalism. I don't think anyone would say that I'm overstating that.
That is now being circled back into the process so that if you were producing it, producing AI based on that content, you then maintain that voice. And the AI process, kind of by preventing younger and more diverse voices getting involved, kind of again, continues that spiral. Yeah, I think that's a really important point, Charlie. I think about journalism and public interest journalism and ethics of journalism, at that point just keeps coming back to me.
It kind of stronger and stronger sense that the way to make journalism ecosystem healthier and better and more in the public interest is to improve the diversity. Make journalism more effective about what Australia is in terms of indigenous terms of class, such as your economic background and so on. And in Australia, sure things have been getting better, but they're not right, and it means to be better. And as a problem, we get to this AI, we get stuck where we are, we get reflected back to us what already exists instead of kind of working forward towards a better journalism ecosystem.
And to your early point about choices and about wokeness, and about what is kind of being given as content by AI, there are always decisions that need to be made in terms of, once we accept the basic premise that, okay, there are some things we don't want to use to train this AI. And I think that's a very fairly elementary and simple position. It's a good position to take, right? It's really important that we don't give it really hateful, really racist, really sexist, really problematic content because it's socially destructive.
We can just put this to the side and say, no, no, we're not going to let the AI train quite that stuff. We're not going to have it scanned. But once we've made that decision that some content is going to be off limits for it to scan, don't become very hard inside, okay, what is, also, what isn't? Like, that's always tricky.
And, you know, whether the people who have programmed this have got it right, I don't know. I certainly don't know. But these choices need to be made. One interesting kind of side note here is that, you know, there are a whole number of ethical issues to do with this.
One is, how was this AI trained? And I have read about some of the employers we employed in countries and places, including Africa, paid very little, and were exposed also to content, including very traumatic content, as in the same, that's something that we need to keep away from this AI as we train it. So, you know, sometimes some of the hidden kind of issues going to the training of the AI, the making of it, that I think we should be thinking about too. You shouldn't be able to get people to kind of get exploited along the way.
Yeah, and a little bit strikes me, you know, as always we get sidetracked by something that isn't the real issue. So, it's not a real issue that this chat might once say, racist slurs, and that, you know, it won't engage in culture wars. But the fact that it also locks off politics and won't have political views, in a sense, makes it kind of useless to the realm of journalism, because even if you're, you know, working in a media organisation, that's trying to be fair and balanced about the news, the news is political. Politics is the news.
So, it does seem that in this particular instance that they might actually be making this particular chatbot useless to the media. I mean, what do you think about that? Yeah, and that's an interesting one. Again, I suppose it does come down to what you want to use it for.
And that's, again, what at the moment is kind of slightly clunky about the writing that sometimes is produced by a chatbot like this, is that it does a lot of the kind of essay sort of caveats or something would argue it's this and some people would argue it's that. I mean, yeah, you're right. I mean, that does really come down to a bit of a fundamental question about what journalism is for, what the role it's supposed to play for its consumers is. I, for one, am quite comfortable with a publication within reason, the publication having an obvious political framework within which it operates and that's how it's a new separate interrogates, it's a more conservative or a more left-wing view.
I've got no problem with that as long as that is upfront. And usually, if you read anything for long enough, you'll be able to pick up it anyway. So, I suppose in terms of, and as you say, even in the process of saying, I want this to be a completely apolitical platform, you are making a political judgment by what you define as apolitical. So, it's sort of, it's not useless.
It's probably kind of impossible to probably put in place. Okay. Well, look, let's end talking about education and journalism. Sasha, you know, journalism schools preparing their students to work with AI?
Too early to tell, I'd say. I haven't had many conversations with my colleagues about that. I spend, you know, I live physically in the law faculties, I'm on a couch too. So, Lauren, I certainly have a lot of conversations, informal conversations with colleagues about JBT, just in terms of education.
You know, as I said before, about, you know, it's ability to generate essays or exams and so that sort of thing. You know, that's something we really need to think about. And part of that is really worrying and part of that is really good because, you know, we need as educators to keep, you know, you can't just sort of, you know, keep doing things the way you can do them because that's how you can do them. And there are real problems.
I have real issues with grading students and also grading writing. Kind of enterprise anyway. So, look, I think, you know, in some ways it's kind of where the AI comes along and shapes up the way we do things. Some extent.
As to what's happening in the journalism schools, specifically, I think I think I'm going to take a bit of time. But, you know, it's actually days, I need to have more conversations with my colleagues there still to work out what's going to happen. But they won't be able to ignore it. So, a lot of the chat at the moment is about cheating and it's about, you know, people using AI to cheat.
Is anyone talking about students working with AI together? Because that's what's probably going to happen when they go into the workplace. Yes, that's a really good point. And I spoke with Fred on Twitter yesterday.
I'd give the person about her number, who was just talking about my head. And she was talking everyone through how she has dealt with JPT in the classroom. And hers was a writing course, I think, you know, not specific journalism, but more writing. You know, they did exercise with chat to continue.
They talked about how it works, what it's doing stuff, what it might be used for productively, what it should definitely not be used for, you know, what's ethical, what's unethical. So, I think, you know, my approach as a teacher, as a tertiary teacher, you know, my approach tends to be open about this. It's not a 10 chat to be doesn't exist. You know, this part of me that doesn't want to tell people that story that I told that the upset about how good that example is, right?
But there's definitely a part of me that doesn't want anyone to know that that happened. But, you know, then the other part of me tends to win and it's like, no, let's have that conversation with still people. I can do it. It's actually quite powerful.
And so we all need to think together about it. Okay, what does that mean to education? What does that mean for assessments for cheating? And then what will it mean for the journalism industry?
What we were talking about before? You know, how can we use this technology and whatever it's a grows into in a way that, you know, that in riches is all. And that sounds like a kind of tripe, please, shaking the state. But that's what we want.
We want this technology to make our lives better. Dr. Sacha Molotaurus and Charlie Lewis, thanks for being on Forf Estate. And thanks for listening to the program.
This edition was recorded at the studios of Tumrissiya and heard across the country from the community radio network. Forf Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support. And make sure you subscribe to Forf Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between.
We'll be back for more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter and handle It's Forf Estate AU. This program was produced by myself with a little bit of help from Chat GPT. I'm Anthony Drockle. Thanks for listening.