Support for the show comes from Odoo. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in. An all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs. Best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com slash propg. That's O-D-O-O dot com slash propg.
I'm Anna Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Chloe Mal. We talk all about her taking on the top job at Vogue, finding her personal style, and her favorite lunch order in the iconic Condé Nast cafeteria. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers.
How much more would you get done with a personal assistant in your pocket? Life's too short to be like manually filing insurance claims and like being on hold waiting for like the lab tests that the doctor did. Like, I don't know, I feel like it's allowing me to show up in ways that I've always wished I could show up. I just am so strapped for time. What we gain and give up when AI agents enter the picture. That's this week on Explain It To Me. Listen to new episodes Sundays wherever you get your podcasts.
I just think that it's super interesting at a macro level that these two countries, because of trade and strategic alignment, have come closer and closer. And it's sort of Kissinger's nightmare, right? We're living in a kind of reverse 1970s where Russia and China are getting close together rather than the US getting closer to both Russia and China individually. Welcome to China Decode. I'm Alice Han. And I'm James King. In today's episode of China Decode, we're discussing the future of a gas pipeline between Russia and China, China's massive sell-off of US treasuries, and the world's first commercially approved brain chip. All right, let's get right into it. Russian leader Vladimir Putin visited China just days.
after President Trump left his own bilateral summit in the country. A centerpiece of the agenda was the long-stalled Power of Siberia 2 pipeline, a proposed 1,615-mile pipeline that would carry up to 40 billion cubic meters of natural gas annually from Russia into the industrial heartlands of China. So far, no deal has been announced post-summit, but a spokesperson says a general understanding between the two leaders was reached. James, this obviously happened right after Trump's own trip to China. We knew this from the get-go. Obviously, the two leaders, Putin and Xi, have a very strong relationship that dates back decades. This is Putin's 25th visit, which is hard to...
I believe, to the country. No other leader at the world stage has met with Xi Jinping as many times as Putin and vice versa. What was your readout on the meeting between these two leaders? And why, more importantly, has this gas pipeline, which should be strategic to both sides, been stalling? Yeah, I'll come to the gas pipeline in a minute. It's a monster. It's a huge deal. But I think, you know, the big picture here is that what we're seeing is the axis of authoritarianism in action. This kind of bromance between Putin and Xi is really striking. And I've been looking at the fact that since Russia's invasion of Ukraine,
we've seen these two big powers draw together much, much more closely. That includes diplomatically, economically, but also militarily. And that's why it really matters for the world. I would say, actually, that the sort of closeness that we've seen between Russia and China since the Russian invasion of Ukraine is probably the most consequential geopolitical shift that we've seen in the world over the last decade. I mean, I know there are several competitors for that title, but this one is really big. On the one hand, we have a superpower, China. On the other, a big power, Russia.
Their combined population is about 1.55 billion people, vast territories. It's the second and the ninth largest economy. And both of these countries are nuclear weapons powers. So... You know, this is really important. For the US, I think it's particularly key because China used to be a rival, perhaps an adversary of the US, but now China and Russia together makes a much bigger adversary to the US. And China and Russia have not attempted to hide their opposition to the US. As you mentioned, just a few days after President Trump left, Xi and Putin were warning that a global return to, quote, the law of the jungle would be a risk for the world. And this is a clear...
reference to the US attack on Iran and Venezuela. So this is an axis of authoritarianism in my view, and it's clearly oppositional to the United States. For Europe, obviously, this has been a major problem. I mean, Russia casts such a long shadow over Europe in terms of its economic politics, as well as its military threat, that China and Russia together creates a much more formidable player for Europe to conjure with. And now I get back to the power of Siberia 2 pipeline, because the key glue in the Russia-China relationship is effectively hydrocarbons. And among hydrocarbons, natural gas is probably the most important. We've seen Russia and China build the power of Siberia 1 pipeline. That's taking natural gas from Russia.
to China. But this power of Siberia 2 pipeline, if it is built, would be 2,600 kilometers long, cost up to 34 billion US dollars to build. It's an absolute monster. And what it would mean is that China would be the customer of up to 50% of Russia's exports of natural gas. That's equivalent to what Russia was exporting to Europe before the Ukraine war. But now the exports to Europe have sharply declined.
And so we can see in these pipeline politics, the real shift in orientation of Russia from a Europe facing power before the invasion of Ukraine to what is now the case, it is now a China facing power. So that's why this power Siberia pipeline, I think is so crucial. It shows the fundamental geopolitical shift of one of the most important European and Asian powers. That's Russia away from Europe and towards China. But what did you make of it, Alice? What did you make of the big bromance between Xi and Putin in Beijing?
Well, it was clear as soon as Putin landed that he's very well-liked in China. He was greeted by the foreign minister Wang Yi as opposed to the vice president Han Zheng, and they were very cordial with each other. He had a very confident gait as he came down the tarmac when he landed. And it's clear that this relationship between Putin and Xi... is a personality-driven one. They clearly have, I think, a deep affection and respect for each other. But going beyond that is the amount of trade coupling that has happened between Russia and China since the Ukraine war began. So trade between China and Russia has basically doubled from 2020 to 2024. That is, to your point, mainly driven by hydrocarbons, oil, and gas. China increased its imports, even this year, of Russian oil by 35%, and total trade is up nearly 20%. And more importantly, Russia is China's largest single source, I mean, country-wise, of crude oil. It's about 20% of its crude oil imports.
In a period in which we've seen China being on the chopping block in terms of de-risking and decoupling, it seems like we've seen something in the reverse strain, which is a coupling between Russia and China on the trade front. And we haven't mentioned on technology as well. You know, we see in the data a lot of Chinese exports of semiconductors, of autos, of trucks, of drones going into Russia or drone components, even though technically these should not be allowed based on the sanctions regime in place. But right now, I think the thing that is really stalling the pipeline, and I'm curious to get your thoughts on this, is about pricing. It seems like at the strategic level, the leaders love each other. The relationship is great. But what is holding this pipeline back, which is going to be considerable in terms of the energy flows of gas from Russia to China, is the fact that the two sides can't agree on who's going to foot most of the bill. So according to some reports, China is reportedly looking for pricing that is about half of what the Russians are expecting in terms of the power of Siberia too. And I think this is somewhat stalled because ultimately the two sides can't really agree on pricing. It remains to be seen if there's enough pressure to get this going because of what's happening in the Middle East. But right now...
As someone who looks at the China energy situation, it seems like the Chinese went into the conflict in Iran long in terms of supply of LNG, of gas. Their reserves have not been as depleted as their crude oil reserves. So maybe in the short term, there isn't an impetus to really push this pipeline forward. We shall see. I just think that it's super interesting at a macro level that these two countries, because of trade and strategic alignment, have come closer and closer. And it's sort of Kissinger's nightmare, right? We're living in a kind of reverse 1970s where Russia and China are getting close together rather than the US getting closer to both Russia and China individually.
Yes, so right, Alison. I think price is one of those things that always tells the true story, isn't it? The truth of this relationship is that although people talk about it as the Chinese government once wrote, a no-limits partnership between China and Russia, the truth is that under the surface, there is considerable tension. There always has been, there is right now, and in my view, there is likely to be for the foreseeable future. And the way the Chinese are driving such a hard bargain over the price of the natural gas that it would import from Russia, it really speaks to the tensions in the relationship. China knows it's got...
Russia over a barrel. Because of the way that Europe has slashed its hydrocarbon imports from Russia since Russia invaded Ukraine, China is about the only big market that Russia can export this natural gas to. And that means the Chinese know that they can afford to tell the Russians to cut the price and cut it really substantially. And I think it's quite interesting that neither side was able to agree a price, and therefore the future of the power of Siberia to this huge pipeline itself, well, it's not approved yet. I guess we all think that it will get approved. Somehow the two sides will agree on a price, but we have to keep on watching for that. Okay, we'll be back with more after a quick break. Stay with us.
Support for the show comes from BetterHelp. If you've thought about trying therapy with our long-term partner, BetterHelp, insurance options may now be available nationwide with an average copay for eligible members of just $23 per session. October 10th is World Mental Health Day, but that doesn't mean your brain got the memo. Stress can show up unannounced and overstay its welcome. That's why mental health ought to be a part of your everyday life. Therapy isn't just for the big life choices. It can also help you with the small things that are taking up way too much space in your brain. That conversation with an ex, that work situation that maybe you could have handled better, that subtle relationship dynamic with your parents that you can't put your finger on, but it always sets you off.
These things add up and it helps to be able to sort through them with a licensed professional. If you've been waiting to start therapy, BetterHelp works with more than 125 health plan networks and eligible members have an average copay of just $23 per session with insurance. Don't have insurance or don't live in the United States? You can still get 10% off your first month. Visit betterhealth.com slash prop G to explore your payment options. That's betterhelp.com slash prop G.
So nothing slips through the cracks. back it up vanta delivers a 526 roi over three years and pays for itself in just three months over 16 000 fast-growing companies like ramp rider and harvey save time and resources while scaling fast with vanta learn more at vanta.com slash prop g and get a thousand dollars off that's vanta.com slash prop g for a thousand dollars off And they have options for nearly every budget.
It helps you save time with built-in automated tools, offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. You can even get direct access to certified HR experts. It's quick and simple to switch to Gusto. Just transfer your existing data to get up and running fast. Plus, don't pay a cent until you run your first payroll. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash prop G and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash prop G. One more time, gusto.com slash prop G.
Welcome back. The war in Iran triggered a global sell-off of U.S. Treasuries starting in March, and China was no exception to those joining the off-rep. The sell-off is motivated by the need to liquidate reserves of the U.S. dollar to help defend against the energy shock that began with the Middle East conflict. The yield on the 30-year U.S. Treasury note is now at 5.2%, the highest level since pre-global financial crisis levels in 2007. James, I know this is a bit of a wonkish topic, but ultimately, you know, telling people out there the bond market matters more than the stock market, which is why...
Trump last year was motivated by Treasury yields soaring rather than stock market tanking and had to move back on his liberation tariffs. And, you know, I think this is such an important piece to note because at the end of the day, the 30-year Treasury, and the U.S. is a global reserve currency, so this is an extremely important thing, not just for the U.S., but also for the world. The 30-year is an important signal of inflation, growth expectations. It's also things that mortgages in the U.S. are pegged at. You know, it can't be understated how important the 30-year yield is and the curve of the U.S. Treasury.
Right now, it's crazy that we're north of 5%. We haven't seen these levels since 2007. For some people who are screaming recession, this is yet another indicator that we are fast approaching that, driven by the energy shock from the Middle East. Alice, are you saying effectively that the US borrowing costs when it issues these long bonds have increased because China is buying fewer of these bonds than it used to in the past? Is that the dynamic here?
Well, we can go into the minutiae of the data in just a bit, but I think this is a global phenomenon. You know, late last year, we saw gold asset holdings in FX reserves globally among central banks surpassed, this is the first time since the 1990s, surpassed U.S. denominated treasury holdings. So we saw that close to $4 trillion of gold held by not just PBOC, but other central banks around the world because people were not so sure about, A, the debt sustainability of the U.S. We've got public debt to GDP in the U.S. now north of 120%.
and rising and unclear about the U.S.'s role as the world number one, the world hegemon. And so there are recurring questions. You get this at a lot of panels, I'm sure, that you and I get invited to about whether or not China will overtake the U.S. in terms of reserve status. But we're starting to really get, I think, consternation amongst central banks around the world about the debt sustainability of the U.S. and the strength and reserve currency status of the dollar. And certainly, I think what has happened even more since the conflict in the Middle East erupted.
is that you're seeing a lot of central banks now trying to sell down UST bills to get cash to buy as much oil as they can and at whatever price because we're so supply constrained. That, I think, is a global phenomenon, but certainly we are starting to see... in the last year or so that China has been selling down some of its treasury holdings, at least what's publicly available in the data set. Still about 50% of the FX reserves at around $3 trillion are in US bonds. But I've seen noticeably since the Russia-Ukraine war broke out, since we started to see FX sanctions on Russia in 2022, that China has been diversifying on the margin by increasing its currency exposure to other currencies, but also its exposure to gold and commodities. But how do you see this?
Very interesting, yeah. I mean, China's big problem has always been that it has a huge trade surplus. Every year, I mean, last year, it was a record in history, I believe, certainly for peacetime, 1.2 trillion US dollars. And it's got to put those dollar earnings somewhere. So it puts them in its foreign currency reserves. They're also held in different packets, in state-owned banks, et cetera. But just for simplicity's sake, they go into the foreign currency reserves. And then China has the question, how do they invest such an enormous amount of money in dollar-denominated assets somewhere around the world? That's the key problem that they have. And so in the past, their answer was, well,
We'll buy U.S. Treasuries because there is enough U.S. Treasuries. We can sink trillions into the U.S. Treasury market. But as you say, according to the U.S. government data, it looks like China has been selling down its holdings of Treasuries quite substantially over the last few years. And this does tend to raise questions over the sustainability of the dollar's dominance over the financial system. I wouldn't put it any more categorically than that. I would just say that.
It raises questions. I'm not making any bold predictions here. These are very complicated flows. The other thing I'd like to point to is the possibility that the selling down of US treasuries by China over the last few years is primarily a data function. It's primarily what the US government data is showing. And it might not fully reflect what's happening in actuality because I think there's a number of leading scholars out there, including Brad Setzer. And he is saying that China buys a lot of US treasury bonds.
through Belgium. But we just don't know how big that portion is because it's not transparently reported. So I think we have to have a little bit of a caveat on how deep the selldown of US treasuries by China has been. But I think it's a fascinating topic, Alice. And I really believe that if we look at the renminbi versus the US dollar over the next five years and their relative strength in the global economy, we're going to see many interesting trends. Yeah. And just to backtrack a little bit.
I love Brad Setz's work. He's one of the best when it comes to balance sheets, trade balances, capital account balances. And he mentions that it's not just Europe through Belgium. It's also potentially Canada and Cayman Islands. There's some of these shadow holdings in these other custodial banks, which hold these T-bills that are not reflected in the public data set, to your point, James, in Chinese PBOC FX reserves. But I think what is useful to point out about...
the relevance of FX reserves to currency, to trade, to geopolitics, is the fact that, you know, in the past, I would say really before COVID in particular, you saw China really build up an FX war chest, so to speak. You know, they had large holdings, even larger than today, you know, probably closer to four trillion at its peak. And the idea was that you would sell CNY to buy more FX foreign. currency holdings so that you could depreciate or devalue your currency relative to the dollar, relative to other currencies. And that's relevant because historically they've weaponized the FX reserves in order to achieve a degree of currency devaluation. Now we're seeing a currency appreciation, which I think is a regime shift that I've noticed in the last year or so. And part of that, I think, is largely driven by dollar weakening against pretty much all the currencies. And FX reserves are now pretty stabilized in general. They're not as much manipulating in the FX reserve market. But I've seen a willingness to let the CNY appreciate against the dollar. And I think that that has been an interesting shift. Do you think that that is driven by?
the geopolitics of the relationship or driven by China's different model when it comes to its currency in the export domain? I think it's driven by both. And I think it's a very important trend. I wouldn't want to overstate it, but I would say the Chinese renminbi is likely to appreciate gradually over a period of a number of years. I mean, I don't know, three, four, five, six years, something like that. And I think the reasons for that are, first of all, geopolitical. China's very...
cognizant of the fact that Europeans, countries, and the US are constantly blaming China for its enormous trade surplus. And it realizes that it needs to allow its currency to appreciate in order to buy more from abroad and maybe take a little bit of the pressure off in terms of the competitiveness of its exports. So I think that's a crucial trend here. Okay, let's take one last quick break. Stay with us.
Support for the show comes from Athena. Client calls in the morning, school pickup in the afternoon, a quick errand on the way home, and then hours spent in the home office after dinner. If any of that sounds familiar, then you could use more than an extra hour in your day. You need Athena. Athena matches you with a dedicated full-time executive assistant, a real person, not software. This person can handle your inbox, your calendar, your travel, as well as the household stuff that quietly eats your week, such as appointments, errands, and gift shopping. Your executive assistant is vetted from the top 1% of applicants and backed by SOC 2-level security reinforced with AI tools so they get better at supporting you over time instead of just checking boxes. Athena clients get back 15-plus hours a week on average, and one small business owner said having their EA directly led to an extra $200,000 in revenue.
Go to athena.com slash propg right now and get matched with your EA. That's athena.com slash propg. Give yourself back a few hours this week and go to athena.com slash propg and see who they pair you with this month. Support for the show comes from Yahoo Scout. Life comes with plenty of big questions, especially when you're taking your first steps into adulthood.
When those questions get complicated, you want more than a quick answer. You want reliable information without spending hours searching for it. That's where Yahoo Scout comes in. Yahoo Scout is an AI-powered answer engine built to help you navigate life's big decisions, from comparing job offers and planning a trip to learning to manage your finances and so much more. Instead of simply spitting out an answer, Yahoo Scout helps you understand your options, weigh the trade-offs, and see the sources behind the information with simple visual answers. I have been using Yahoo's personal finance page as my homepage or starting page from the internet for 20 years. I like Yahoo Scout. I like the user interface, and I like the way it organizes the answers. You can navigate life a little easier by visiting scout.com.
Are you tired of hearing about business, tech, and finance from the bros? We are the Tiger Sisters, a top business podcast with the Vox Media Podcast Network. Tiger Sisters releases every Monday and we decode money, power, and love. And who doesn't love all those things? We are the internet's Wall Street and Silicon Valley big sisters. Tune in every Monday for late night sister talk meets boardroom strategy. Check out Tiger Sisters on YouTube, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to the Tiger Fam.
Welcome back to yet another technological breakthrough that's causing a stir in China and around the world. The country just became the first to approve a brain chip for commercial use, an implant embedded into the brain to help people with spinal cord injuries. The brain computer interface is made by the Shanghai-based company Neuracool Medical Technology, which for context... is a possible rival to Elon Musk's Neuralink startup. James, we're already living in the future. The images of this are phenomenal. What is your take on this? How successful can they be? And should we be worried about Elon Musk's Neuralink? Well, I mean, Alice, honestly, every now and again, a story comes along that is truly mind-blowing. And without using hyperbole, I really think this is in that category. This is sci-fi made manifest. I was just looking back at the movies to see...
how many times this theme has cropped up in the movies, i.e. somebody having their brain wired up to an electric pulse or to have a chip in their brain. There was a 1995 film in which the Keanu Reeves character had an overloaded brain implant that was used to smuggle highly confidential information to megacorporations. But if we go back to 1962, there was a film, a movie, in which a mad scientist keeps his wife's severed head alive by wiring it up to an electric current. I mean, that's rather gruesome, but we're not talking about that here. But we are talking about something truly...
amazing, which is a coin-sized chip, which is in this case called Neo, that is inserted inside the skull, just on top of the brain membrane, and it's used to help people with spinal cord injuries. So basically, it picks up brain impulses, and then it translates them into a way that can be understood by a computer, and then it's used to, for instance, power... a robotic glove so that the person with the brain injury or the spinal cord injury is able to grasp objects and manipulate this robotic hand. So effectively, in one sentence, what it does is this chip reads the thoughts of the patient. So the patient thinks, pick that thing up, that thing that's on the table, pick it up now. And this chip will read that thought and send a signal to the robotic arm that will pick the thing up. I mean, this is just...
quite extraordinary. And the other thing about this is, which is almost equally extraordinary, I think, is that the Chinese government is taking this very seriously. It's not taking it as some sort of woo-woo technology that might exist at some point in the future. Oh, no. This is identified as a national strategic priority, this business of brain-computer interface. And it just shows, I think, how forward-looking China's government is on its scientific agenda. The Chinese government has unveiled a 17-step roadmap.
to establish a global lead in the brain-computer interface industry by 2030. And added to that, it's allocated 1.7 billion US dollars to an industry fund to help finance breakthroughs in this regard. So one of the applications that is being developed at the moment by a company called Neuro Excess is something that has successfully turned thoughts into real-time speech in Mandarin Chinese. So in other words... Somebody with a brain injury or some kind of other impediment, they can't speak what they're thinking. This new technology will read their thoughts and allow a computer to speak their words or to write their words. I just think we've crossed the matrix here, Alice. We are into totally new territory. What do you think? That's really fascinating to me is the whole approval process between China versus the US. Part of the reason that the Chinese have pulled ahead.
is that they've just got faster approval timings, right? So Elon Musk's Neuralink is the closest to commercializing in the U.S., but it's still in clinical trials with around 21 participants as of this January. There are some other companies in the mix as well. But the U.S. FDA, it seems, they've been cautious about the approval for these brain chip interfaces.
And they rejected Neuralink's application in 2022. But Chinese approval agencies have just been faster to commercialize this because they're really trying to build an ecosystem, a research talent data collection ecosystem around this. What are some of the drawbacks, do you think, of the Chinese methodology of this? And how feasible is it for China to start exporting this to other markets in 5, 10 years' time? That's a great question. I mean, I think, you know, the first point is that it shows, I believe anyway, that China is much less squeamish or you might say sensitive about approving this type of technology. So this was approved for commercial use in China in March by the National Medical Products Administration. That's a government body. And it's the world's first. It's the world's first.
commercial approval for brain-computer interface. Second thing to say, I think, is that China's doing quite a lot of this real biotech research at the frontier. We've mentioned in, I think, a couple of previous episodes about a small company in Shenzhen that is trying to find ways to increase human longevity by significant amounts. I don't want to sort of throw out hyperbolic statements, but over 100 years as a regular feature. And this is also not regarded by the Chinese government as in any way eccentric. And we were talking earlier a little bit about Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
There was this hot mic moment when Vladimir Putin was last visiting Beijing in which he and Xi Jinping were having a conversation about how people might one day live to be 150 years old. And at the time, everyone thought, wow, you know, this is really out there as a conversation between two of the world's most powerful people. But no, it's not out there. This is... you know, the logical conclusion that one might draw, certainly in a sort of fairly lighthearted conversation from research that is currently underway in China. So I think to me, this is the big takeaway from this, is that China is pushing back the frontiers and it's putting money and administrative heft behind all of these very new technologies. I love that point you ended on, James. It's longevity science meets geopolitics. You know, maybe we'll go, in the not too distant future, we'll have all these elderly leaders with brain chip interfaces. All right, James, you know what time it is. It's prediction time. As you peer into the future, what do you see?
I think I'm just going to stick with this brain-computer interface and say that we will see a few more licenses for similar neurotech. That's the general phrase for what we're talking about, neurotech. In other words, technology linked to the brain. I think we are going to see several new licenses over the next two or three years. And I imagine that NeuroAccess, the one that I mentioned, is turning thoughts into either speech or written words. We'll get a license maybe this year, maybe next year, but it won't be that long.
So my prediction is twofold. It's mainly about macro and finance. On the macro front, some of the April data you may have seen at James on industrial output, manufacturing investment even, as a subset of fixed asset investment, looked pretty weak. I suspect that going into Q2, we'll see a weak momentum in the economy. We might see quarterly GDP growth closer to 4.5% in the second quarter of this year as China gets hit, not just by the rising costs to inputs from energy prices, but also in terms of external demand starting to cool as well for Chinese manufactured goods. And then the second part of it is...
I don't think this is getting enough attention. There's trillions of fixed-term deposits that were used during the COVID pandemic by Chinese households that basically will start to unwind this year. These are five-year term deposits. Now, everyday Chinese people need to chase higher yields because some of these deposits now only offer about 2% yield versus the 5% that they offered back in 2022. So I think we'll see a lot of domestic flows into potentially the stock market, into wealth management products as Chinese households try to find more yield in an environment that is really uncertain.
All right, that's all for this episode. Thank you for listening to China Decode. This is a production of Prof G Media. Make sure to follow us wherever you get your podcasts so you don't miss an episode. Talk to you again next week.