Skip to content
Chris Masters On Taking Down A Giant episode artwork

Jun 9, 2023 39 min

Chris Masters On Taking Down A Giant

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

In this week's episode, Chris Masters talks to Monica Attard about the stunning victory he and Nick McKenzie had over Ben Roberts-Smith. In what was one of the biggest and most expensive defamation cases in recent memory we get Chris's insights and methods on taking down a myth. Produced by Anthony Dockrill

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Chris Masters On Taking Down A Giant

0:00 39:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Monica Atard. Well, Thursday last week was a landmark defamation ruling which reverberated around the country.

Federal court judge Anthony Besanco threw out Ben Robert Smith's defamation case against the age, the Sydney Morning Herald and the Canberra Times. It was a stunning victory, also vindication for the nine papers for backing their journalists in what was a titanic battle. Apart from the truth, the other big winner was public interest journalism. While the win was remarkable in many ways, a number of serious questions still need to be answered.

Why did it take seven years to reach this point and how could crimes of this nature be perpetrated by Australian soldiers and supported by not just powerful forces in the establishment, but also by large sections of the media and will make investigative journalism easier to do? To talk about this, I'm delighted to have one of the country's best and most respected journalists with us today. Chris Masters is a multi-walkly award-winning journalist. His 1987 four corners of the moonlight state led to the Fitzgerald inquiry into corruption in Queensland and ultimately brought down the then Biocipedes in government.

He is the author of Jonestown and unauthorised biography of Alan Jones. And it was his work, along with that of Nick McKenzie, who wrote the series of stories with him, which led to the downfall of Ben Robert Smith. Chris Masters, welcome back to Fourth Estate. Can you just begin by telling us how you first came to question the myths around Ben Robert Smith, because it certainly was a lot of a lot attached to his name.

That's right. I mean, the most decorated living Australian soldier. I had a few delis with him in the past. I actually wrote positively about it in the book that I had written in 2012 called Uncommen Soldier.

As a result of that book being published, and probably the words I said, a couple of people said to me, I think you might not have got that quite right. And I didn't take too much notice of it, because one thing you do know, which you work with, special forces soldiers, in particular, is they're like a wolf pack. People carry on about mateship being the strong bond that forges the Australian soldier. Well, there are a lot of anti-mates too.

And there's a lot of animosity. And so I didn't take a huge amount of notice, but it built, as I was working on another book about special forces. It wasn't so much that people were saying to me that he was a walk criminal. Indeed, I think they really didn't want that territory.

But they were saying that they thought he was unworthy of the recognition of Australia's most famous soldier and wearing Australia's most prominent medal. Let's just take it back to the beginning though. So I'll unwind you a little bit. So the book that you're referring to is a book that you wrote that came out of the period that you were embedded with the with the ADS in Afghanistan?

Yes, I was there in 2007. I was there again in 2010. I was there again in 2011 with special forces. In 2012, a book was published called Uncommon Soldier.

But by that stage, of course, I'd opened some doors in the special forces community. I'm the only reporter to have embedded with them. They're very secretive and they're very anti-media. So I was in an unusual position.

And I probably felt that I had enough to write a book about the special forces mission in Afghanistan. So that began around about 2013. And it was finally published in 2017. And it was on that embedment in 2011.

I think that you're saying that you began to hear things about Ben Roberts-Miff. But that was in the realm of a supposed rumor in regard to his behavior towards his colleagues. Yes, it wasn't about war crimes. It was about how they thought he was a bully.

They thought he wasn't a particularly good soldier. They used to say things like, is the Lance Armstrong a bit of a phony. And I didn't take a lot of notice about this because I heard similar things being said of a great many other soldiers. There's a lot of rivalry.

The yes, yes, it's like the wolf pack of soldiering. And they're very competitive. They're very alpha. So it wasn't unusual to hear that sort of stuff.

It wasn't really until 2017, as I was in the final stages of getting my book done. And of course, the Breton & Worry was underway by then that some of these whispers began to merge into rumor, began to merge into the prospect of credible evidence. And that was when you then contacted Nick McKenzie? How did that relationship come about?

Well, I was in touch with Ben Roberts-Miff before then. There was a few questions I had to put to Ben because there was a significant discrepancy in an account of combat action in 2006 that I became aware of. And he'd said something in a take to the one memorial that I knew was disputed by other people that was on his patrol. And I felt I had to reconcile that.

So I had an interview with Emi he got very cross. And I think that was a turning point because he didn't act like a man with nothing to hide. I mean, if he's simply said to me, look, Chris, everybody in a combat zone tends to have a different view of what occurs. I know that.

So then, okay, those guys think differently, but that's what happens. It might have gone away, but it didn't. He got really cross and fenders through me and sent angry legal letters to the soldiers. He presumed to have been talking to me.

I had a book about to come out. He threatened to sue the publisher, Alan and Unwin. He tried to change his evidence at the Australian War Memorial. So do you like?

I mean, I felt always felt that he drew the battle line. So I didn't. I mean, they would want to get into a battle with a six foot seven Victoria cross recipient. And that stage Nick became involved.

Because I'm not employed by anybody. I felt that this was a very big story. It needed some strong support. And I'd known Nick for a long time.

We'd worked together before when it was requested that some extraction of the book be published. I got Nick onto that. And the relationship was forged, if you like, reforged because we'd worked together many times. And it went from there.

And I suppose Nick would have given that he's been working in investment, giving journalism himself quite a long time. He would have been reasonably sure that his employer was prepared to stand by the both of you. Well, both of us have been involved in litigation too. We're probably between us.

We've been sued by just everybody. And you get hardened to that. You don't want to be sued. But you cannot be coward either.

The worst censorship in journalism is self-censorship. And it was awful being sued because it just takes you away from your job. It takes so much longer the amount of effort that's required to actually pull the facts together to shape a newspaper article or television pieces. Nothing compared with what is required to defend it in accord of laws.

But look, we had each other. That was really important. I'd been through these things on my own in the past. I wasn't employed by anybody.

He had the resources of fair faxes. It was then and known as it became later behind him. And because he was fully employed, he really became the driving force of the story from about 2018 onwards. I mean, we stayed on it together.

And I think both of us say that we couldn't have done it without each other. But he did power of work. But you're byline. Suppressimably, you had some insurance, some coverage in the event that there was a suit.

Yes. Well, we were sued. August 2018, after the first series of articles were published, we were sued. No, in the preceding months, we didn't really have publishable evidence.

In 2017, we'd heard a lot of rumors. We had some documentation. We knew of schisms. We knew of complaints about Robert Smith.

And we actually, well, I knew of the alleged cliff kicking incident where he allegedly was participated in the murder of an Afghan village called Ali Jan. I'd known about that in 2017, but I didn't know it as fact. What I had was uncorroborated, he'll say. In the beginning of 2018, I spoke with a different soldier who confirmed to me for the first time that he had witnessed Ben Robert Smith involved in the execution of a different Afghan.

A little bit after that, Nick found some crucial evidence. We first bought a sense of corroboration. One of the things that helped prove the Afghan allegation, and if you like, the Darwin cliff kick allegation, and if you like, prove first of all to us, we have to believe our own work first. And we believed it when Nick got in touch with somebody in the United States who unprompted, gave firsthand evidence of that alleged cliff kick.

And that corresponded with what we then knew, the villages from Darwin, and what some of our unknown sources in West Australia were saying. So, you've got to say to yourself, there can't be a conspiracy here from three corners of the globe. I think that evidence was compelling to us. I'm sure it was later compelling also to the Breton inquiry and, of course, to Justice Bessenko.

Because of course, I mean, one of the parts of investment, give the journalism, I suppose, is that you hear something and it remains in the realm of gossip or words, just to claim something up there in the ether, finding the people who have been witnesses, finding the people who actually know what has occurred. It is such a very difficult process, particularly when you're operating in this kind of environment where you're looking at a war that's taking place on the other side of the world, where people are scattered around the globe. That has a huge undertaking, isn't it? Yes, it was almost mission impossible in a way.

We couldn't get back to Afghanistan. It's too dangerous. You can't really speak to the illiterate villages. It's not as if they're on the phone.

The Special Forces community in Australia is notoriously secretive and very, very anti-media. I mean, it was very, very fortunate for me that I had spent time embedded with Special Forces in Afghanistan. I had come to know some of the soldiers and built a level of trust. It's funny because, in our job, people think that the purest journalism occurs outside the tent and the inset side the tent, you let around by the nose.

But really, being inside the tent was what made the difference because the soldiers knew me. They trusted me enough. I think they felt that their internal elevation of concerns and complaints about Robert Smith had gone absolutely nowhere. So it was time to invite the classic precincts of the Fourth Estate.

Let's talk a little bit about that whole issue of being embedded because it does have such a bad name in journalism, as you say. I recall you being criticized for that period of time when you were embedded as well. Obviously, though, is some benefit in that. You've already outlined the trust factor that people will learn to trust you.

I'm wondering, though, whether it changed your view of the way Australian soldiering happens. Often people think that if you were embedded, then you come out with a very, very positive view or a very assertive view of the way those personnel operate. For you, was it that? Well, you have to accept that if you're protected by the soldiers, if you're in a dangerous environment, then you're going to get close to them and you're going to have enormous respect for them and your own objectivity will be challenged.

I think that the criticism of the embedded reporter was always unfair because journalism is about good judgment. And it's not as if I couldn't make a good judgment about the facts. I didn't think that the reporter working inside the tent was any better or worse off than the reporter working outside the tent. I mean, it's not as if the Taliban wouldn't tell your lies as well as defense media officials.

It's after the journalists to work it out themselves. I mean, that's the job. It's not being told stuff. It's about figuring it out.

And a typical of journalists to accuse journalists of just sort of being on the drip, when that's how 90% of the industry works. I mean, sporting reporters rely on contact with the sports clubs. The industry relies on press releases. We've then got to do our own job to fundamentally get to the truth.

And I thought, ironically, it was because of my access as an embedded reporter that opened that door. And I was just about to ask you about that because what would happen then if you were embedded and you come across information such as you did come across with Ben Roberts-Mitz that it's quite damning or has a potential to be damning. And yet you are kind of right there in the belly of the force. What do you do?

How do you behave? What's your reaction to those around you? Well, that's of course exactly what happened. I always said from the beginning, look, you know, full well that I'm a journalist first.

And if I see something that's in the public interest that you don't want me to report, then I will report it as much as I had signed a deal of agreement that prevented me from disclosing national security information. I always thought that was fair enough. Human life is more important than a good story. I don't think any of us thought that I would ever come across anything like that.

I don't think that many of the people I was working with, either thought that war crimes were going on or had any real knowledge of them. As my knowledge base grew and I began to submit more and more material to the Defense Department, some of it very, very unflattering, I was of course worried that they were going to try to find a way to stop me publishing it. And I would say to them, and the deal was, of course, that they had no editorial control over what I was writing. They had inputs for sure, but it would be my call at the end of the day.

And so this material continued to go in chapter by chapter by chapter. I didn't get any kick back at all. And it really surprised me actually. I was waiting for it, but it didn't really happen.

Now, I don't know to this day for sure why that didn't happen, but you have to stand back from the whole frackar and say, well, the Defense Force did call on the special investigator that the ADF was actually initiated by Defense. Jeff Sengel, when was the Special Operations Commander, he obviously, and I know this, you know, he came to a view, as I came to a view, around about 2015, 2016, that there was a bit of a smell there. And he wanted to do something about it. So he commissioned Sam Cromford to look into it.

They saw that, yes, that it was a bit more than rumor there. They went to the Chig the Army at the time. General Campbell and said, we think there should be an inquiry to this. And so the Bergen inquiry was initiated.

I wasn't the only one who wanted to get to the bottom of things. So Chris, you know, did that period of being embedded and then subsequently investigating with Nick McKenzie, the whole Ben Roberts-Smith story, did that change, has it changed your view of the way Australia does soldiering? Well, I always liked the idea of courageous restraint. I admired the soldiers in Afghanistan.

I saw this up close from myself, who would patrol with a view of protecting innocent villagers from a predatory Taliban and doing so with their fingers off the trigger, that significant risk to themselves. I think I had a kind of a romantic notion that Australian soldiers coming from a society that values toughness and fairness, a decent behavior, that they were well suited to this really difficult environment. And much of what I saw working with conventional forces, you know, reinforced those views. And at the time, thinking about 2010, 2011, 2012, you know, the Americans were suffering all sorts of disgrace because of revelations of what had happened at Abu Ghraib.

Canadian Special Forces had disbanded earlier after the Somalia issue. And so, you know, war brings out the worst in people, as well as the best in people. It was never so naive, it's not to believe that Australian soldiers could do bad things. But I didn't really have any evidence of it.

I didn't really see it happening. But when I became aware of it, it's not as if to say, I thought, no, that can't be. Did you think that Australian soldiers were above all of that at the time? Well, I couldn't think that.

No, I thought that the training was good, the leadership was good, and essentially the core of them were above that. But you're always going to get rogues. It's very, very difficult. When you think about it, who can you get to do this kind of work?

And sometimes some of the soldiers I met, I thought were just as easily placed in a biker gang. You know, it's a pretty rough culture. A lot of them aren't particularly well educated, not in the conventions of civil society anyway. They're very, very well educated in their own craft.

But there was one occasion in Afghanistan I heard about where one of the soldiers unfilled a Nazi flag. And, you know, that shocked me, as I'm sure it shocks you to hear that. And we don't think that Australian soldiers could embrace Nazism. I'm not going to make excuses for that person.

But I was told when they were challenged about it afterwards, you know, he really didn't know much at all about modern history. He didn't really know much about World War II and, you know, the Holocaust, he just thought it was cool. But that's just kind of foolishness, right? It doesn't go foolishness.

Yes, you see a lot of that. You know, you saw it in our own trial. You saw the SAS partying at the Fat Lady's arms and somebody wearing a Ku Klux Klan outfit. You know, they're boys on the beer who can be way, way, way over the top.

There's a lot of misogyny in the ADS. And a lot of it is inexcusable. Also cultural, given that it's mostly male and they're away in theatre quite a lot doing horrible things. Back to the Ben Roberts' story.

So, you know, basically, as soon as you went about telling the story of his actions, which you had at that point verified you had corroboration in Afghanistan, you were attacked by several sections of the media. Did that shock you at all? Or did you expect that to happen? It shocked me to agree.

I mean, I expect there to be some fraternal relationship in media. We'd all do a difficult job. At the end of the day, we all basically worked for the public. I thought that everybody would know how hard this work was for Nick and I.

And it would cut us a little bit of slack on that basis. Quite the opposite. You know, we were just seen as competition. A lot of the attacks on us were low, low attacks had generated death threats to both of us.

I felt that what happened was that we were so in front in the reporting. You know, we had so many strong connections into that community that the other side didn't have that they tried to catch up essentially by going on the drip, you know, being fed material from our opponents and just taking a classic contrary approach. What's worst about it is when you know that they must know that what they're reporting is wrong. I know that they were warned ahead of time that Masters and Mackenzie had pretty good information, but they continued to attack us right and left.

And then I do the classic reverse verdict, of course, as the Breton inquiry approaches and it becomes clear that they're on the wrong trim and that those evil journalists, Fairfax, are probably reporting factually and this is how Breton is going to find. They suddenly do a U-turn and hope that nobody notices. That didn't stop them from being coming back for another nibble. Did it post a brooding?

Oh, no, that's right. There were a couple of reverse ferrets. That's what they called it in their industry. You know, when you disown everything, you reported beforehand and change direction entirely, but never acknowledged that you were formally wrong.

No, they attacked us again as they continue to do. Again and again as it turns out. Again and again. And I mean, what I say is, look, after a while, I think, oh gosh, you work in the same industry as me, half of us are married to one another.

You've got to respect other journalists and you know sometimes the job is really difficult and when the editor tells you that you should do the story this way, when you know it's the opposite, I mean, what do you do if you're 30-year-old? There aren't that many jobs around. So I had some degree of sympathy for them, but on the other hand, I think, well, you're not doing journalism anymore. You're just doing propaganda and the worst of them, they're not doing the job, which is speaking to Mr.

Power. They're actually doing the opposite. So much of the competitive reporting on Ben-Lobbert Smith actually came from the Power Groups that really opposed the exposition of war crimes. You're referring there to elements of the establishment, particularly the defence force establishment that supports the kind of myth-making and doesn't want to see that disturbed.

It's more in the diaspora, I think, somewhat more in the political community. Actually, I still have some regard for the core values of the ADF and I said before that they did commission for Bergen inquiry and they have done something towards protecting the soldiers who have actually spoken out. I think that soldiering can't survive on myth. The soldiers are the first to know that it will get them killed.

So they need to know, they need to have an honest appreciation of their own capacity. I think that is true. It's the diaspora, it's the romantics, it was the nonsense of Brad Brendan Nelson, the director of the Australian War Memorial for God's sake, Kerry Stokes, the chairman of the War Memorial, who wanted to hang on to that romantic and, as it turned out, idiotic view that our soldiers are something like Seven Foot Tawlan and Bullet Proof Heroes in the form of Ben-Robert Smith. So how do you think Stokes is, you know, sealing?

We've only heard so little from him since the judgment. Do you think that he may have changed his mind about Ben-Robert Smith? I just couldn't answer that. I used to wonder whether he would change his mind because I felt that we had learned so much.

And surely he knows somewhat what we know. The other thing is, I genuinely believe he is a defender of the Australian soldier and he's very proud of the Perth-based regiment. He's done a lot for them. But why was he supporting Ben-Robert Smith and not the soldiers who had the moral courage to tell a very difficult truth?

Okay. I want to ask you as well about the impact you think this might have on the continuation of the University of Give Journalism in Australia, which has been so terribly hard for so many people for so long because of the current state of the defamation laws, which had been undergoing reform, but the reform has been slow and, you know, not hugely significant. A lot of the commentary around his case as it relates to journalism is that it will result in investigating journalism becoming easier to do, less fraud with the fear that the story and the major investment that goes into these kinds of investigations will be for nothing. Do you think that it's the case?

Do you think it will become that proprietors and editors will become less fearful of allowing the investment to take place? I think it is a watershed case and I think it will have an impact. I can't really see that investigative journalism gets a lot easier in that it's still cost a huge amount of money. It's money that the industry doesn't really have.

Extraordinary. Can you imagine the ABC spending $20 million defending one of its reporters? It simply couldn't afford it. And also, the toll on Nick and I was huge.

You know, you shouldn't be joining the industry to undergo this sort of torture and torment. Five years, you're continuing to do your work, but at the same time waking up every day, having this hanging over your head, the consequences are just catastrophic, and also to the people who help us them try ourselves. But don't think that it isn't a horrible, horrible worry every day. So I can't see that investigative journalism is going to be significantly encouraged, encouraged to a degree.

And I think really good that Australian public get a bit of a look at what we do and how we do it and how hard it is and maybe improve their respect for the general craft of journalism. I mean, if we don't do this work, who will? I had got a bit of feedback that's encouraging me on that front. I suppose the greatest encouragement is in the fact that if there are other Ben Roberts Smiths out there who think, yep, I'm going to take on Fairfax, I'm going to take on nine, and I'm going to make a fortune and I'm going to get these top shelf lawyers.

It doesn't matter that I don't have the truth on my side. I've got an enormous amount of power on my side. I don't think there'll be quite so many of them anymore. Presumably the new defence, the new public interest defence will lessen that possibility as well.

Right? Yeah, I mean, none of this really wanted to get sued in the first place and no publish it as either because even the first letter you get is not just intimidating, but it's also expensive. It's going to encourage them to think, you know, it's going to end up costing hundreds of thousands of dollars to fight this. Should we settle?

They might well say, even if they know they're absolutely right, that there'll be some kind of pressure to settle. And that happens only too often. Just on this defamation issue, I do think it's interesting. You talked about waking up in the last five years and with this thing hanging over your head.

And this is Chris Masters, who's been sued. I don't know how many times you've been through the courts on defamation, as long as I've known you, and quite possibly a lot longer than that. So you're no stranger to defamation cases. So when you heard that Ben Roberts Smith was suing, what did you think?

What was the immediate thought? Well, look, I mean, I hated it. I've had been sued a lot of times. It's caused me a huge amount of heartache.

It's made me think it's just not worth it. The amount of time and effort, the trouble you take to do this journalism, it's just not worth it. It's just morally and mentally exhausting. You tend to have to continue to do your other work as well.

It can feel very, very lonely. I regard journalism as a vocation. I think that if you see it as a profession, as I do, with professional responsibilities, one of those responsibilities is to take risks. And if you're an investigative reporter with the privilege to do more than what the Daily Reporter can do, then also you've got to take on the stories that you don't really want to do.

That was my test for what it's worth. I used to say every time I started on a news story, I'd think to myself, what's the story I least want to do? And I remember, for example, doing the story in Alan Jones and thinking, oh, my, this will cause me so much trouble if I take on somebody in my own industry and challenge their power base. But it was important.

And I think Nick McKenzie and many of my colleagues think much the same. Chris, I'll ask you a question about the defences that that nine ran, which was the truth defence. Why the truth defence and not the others that were available to you? Well, truth is actually the hard one to win, but I'm glad we pleaded truth because it was confrontational.

We were actually saying to the other side, no, no, okay, we know it's hard. We know the courts aren't necessarily favourable to journalists in the media, but we're going to plead truth. We believed these allegations were true. We just spoke into enough people who provided sort of compelling evidence.

So I think that might have set them back on their heels a bit. And I'm really proud and glad that we were able to ultimately plead truth. We're not in the Queensland case on the moonlight state in 1987 and were sued many times. Over 13 years, my death by 1000 courts, we didn't plead truth.

We pleaded qualified privilege, which is closer to the public interest defence that's now being promulgated. And essentially in qualified privilege, you basically have to demonstrate that you're operating faithfully, responsibly and in the public interest. And when you think about it, the bar in those days was so high. I mean, here at my alleging that there's institutional corruption in Queensland police force that goes right up into the high realms of government.

You know, they've got all of the power. It was also about the criminal underworld and drugs trafficking and organised crime. You know, again, they've got the police have got all the information there. How can a journalist challenge what they know?

But it took so long. That's one of the reasons it took so long was because it essentially became an attack on me and my methodology. And it was one of the reasons that I felt so defeated because, you know, if you like, I was the defendant because we were pleading that we were pleading qualified privilege in stating that I had operated responsibly. There's another reason I was so pleased that we ran the truth defence in this one because it actually took the focus away from Nick McKenzie and I.

The focus instead on was whether these things happened rather than, you know, whether Nick and I had operated responsibly as it happened. Neither of us had to give evidence. And that might be a relief at one level. I'm not really sure what I think about that though, because there were plenty of times when I was sitting there in court.

And, you know, there were attacks on my character and credibility where I really felt like standing up and saying, hang on a minute. How can I have my say? And if public interest defence have been available, how do you think it might have fed under that one on this story? I think we would have fed well, but I still think we would have done better.

We obviously did do. That was the truth defence. So it doesn't really come into play. But yes, this matter was significantly in the public interest.

There was a good reason for the media to get involved because it was clear that complaints and concerns that had been raised by soldiers hadn't really gone anywhere. It's true that the Inspector General's inquiry was underway. So it's not as if there was no action at all. But there's also a sort of a public education factor to this too.

I think Australians have learned a lot about our military conduct and learned a lot about the conduct of our soldiers abroad. I think it's been useful at arranging levels. One of the lessons that you want our defence force, our political class and our media to take from what you and Nick McKenzie have just gone through and from that judgement. I would like to think that if they were going to work with journalists, they should think about working with the ones who have a record forgetting it right, not the ones who are on their side.

That's the trouble. There are so many alliances, so many deals done. One of the reasons that the ABC remains a valuable national institution is it's so much harder to do a deal with it. I would like to think that they recognise that journalism is important.

The fourth estate is important. But if we don't do this work, who's going to do it? And I know that I said that was the final question, but I do have one more. And that is in relation to Ben Roberts, specifically in the aftermath of the judgement.

He not only still has his medals, he's a major exhibition at the National Women's Memorial and Canberra. Do you think that for starters, the exhibition should be remade to be about his war crimes? Is that taking it too far? Given the different levels of burden that you face in a civil jurisdiction facing a defamation trial and a criminal court, if it were to come to that?

I remember having a conversation with the former director of the Women's Memorial, Brendan Nelson, around about ANZAC Day 2017, after the Centenary of ANZAC in 2015. And Brendan was well known for his well chosen words. And I said, maybe you should think about beginning to find some words that actually explain that war brings out the worst and it's not only the best in this, that the Inspector General's inquiry is underway and it's likely to find some embarrassing facts about Australian soldiering. It ought to be put into perspective.

The one memorial when it was instituted initially by the historian, he led the process, Charles Bain. He was a journalist. He believed in telling the truth. The one memorial should be an institute that honors the truth.

And part of that truth is about the ugly face of war. I think it's I'd like to think that the one memorial could accommodate the truth about how Ben Robert Smith, if they can continue to run displays around him. Chris, thank you so much for talking to Fourth Estate. Really appreciate your time and I hope you get some risk from all this very soon.

Thanks a lot, Maika. And on that note, I'd like to thank Chris Masters for being on Fourth Estate. And thanks for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of two SCR and heard across the country on the community radio network.

Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast, absolutely. You can hear us talk about media, politics and everything in between.

We'll be back with more next week. But in the meantime, please stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to my producer, Anthony.org.

I'm Maika Atard and thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on June 9, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.