Skip to content
Code Red Podcast with Stephen Moore episode artwork

May 27, 2020 30 min

Code Red Podcast with Stephen Moore

from CODE RED Hosted by Secure America Now

This week we were happy to have Author and Economist Stephen Moore on the Code Red Podcast. As an economic advisor to President Trump, Moore is a member of the task force to reopen America and a leading voice for re-opening the United States economy and getting the American people back to work. Moore is also a co-founder of the Committee to Unleash Prosperity, a group of top U.S. economists dedicated to unleashing America's true economic potential.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Code Red Podcast with Stephen Moore

0:00 30:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I've heard some say we're not going to open up until 2021. I mean, you can't function as a society if you don't have businesses, if you don't have production, if you don't have workers. We all starve to death if that happens. I mean, at some point, you just run out of things on the shelves of the stores. It will be like the old Soviet Union, Alan, if that happens. You're listening to Code Red with Secure America Now, the largest national security grassroots army.

Today, our Code Red podcast guest is economist Stephen Moore, a member of President Trump's task force to reopen America and a founder of the Committee to Unleash Prosperity. Steve, can you give us an overview of the state of the American economy and what are the dangers if we fail to open up? Hi, Alan. Great to be with you. Thanks so much for having me on the Code Red call.

Look, I mean, the state of the American economy right now is that obviously we can't function as a society and we can't have any growth or increase in employment and get people back on the job until we allow the economy to reopen. And what's happened over the last two or three weeks is that you're starting to see this crazy picture emerge where red states across America with Republican governors are opening up their economy in a safe and effective way in states like Texas and Tennessee and Florida and Georgia, South Carolina, Iowa, Nebraska, Utah, Idaho. Those states are open for business again. It's going slow, but they're. They have restaurants and businesses open again, stores are open. And then you've got these states like New York and New Jersey and Connecticut, my home state of Illinois and Michigan and California and Washington state that remain closed. So it's not entirely true, but it's mostly true that Republican states, red states are opening up and blue states are saying shut down. And that is creating a real geographical dispersity. So the southern states are going to get up and running and the mountain states are going to get up and running. And meanwhile, the coastal areas like the Northeast and the West Coast are very, they're going to have a very slow recovery.

Last week, the mayor of Los Angeles declared that Los Angeles would not reopen until the end of July. When you were asked about that, you described it as lunatic. Can you explain your reaction to the extended closure? Well, it'll destroy the great city of Los Angeles, the city of angels, which has always been a very prosperous place for 75 years and has been one of the growth cities in America and a dynamic place with immigrant businesses and huge increases in population. And I think it'll destroy the city. I don't think Los Angeles, it'll take.

decades for Los Angeles to recover if they keep their economy shut down for another two or three months. It makes no sense. You'll have tumbleweeds down Sunset Boulevard. You will have riot. I think you'll see rioting in the streets if they continue to try to keep Los Angeles in their homes. People are already going stir crazy and businesses will fail. Stores will fail. Shopping centers will fail. It will be catastrophic, Alan, for the city of Los Angeles to keep shut through.

I think right now he's talking about the end of July or early August before they open up. So that can't happen. I think you're going to have a lot of citizens revolts against that. And hopefully the mayor will come to his senses. But you've got a lot of Democratic mayors around the country that are talking about keeping things shut down until the beginning of the fall. Or I've heard some say we're not going to open up until 2021. I mean, you can't function as a society if you don't have businesses, if you don't have production, if you don't have workers. We all starve to death if that happens. I mean, at some point, you just run out of things on the shelves at the stores. It will be like the old Soviet Union, Alan, if that happens.

One of the... phenomenon that you just touched on, which I'd like you to comment on, is that there are people coming out into the streets, going to state capitals, demonstrating, saying, open up. We can't live this way. We need to support our families, et cetera. And the mainstream media, by and large, has tried to depict these people as radicals, as fascists, as they pick any negative term on the right that you can think of.

And they're trying to poo-hoo those people and shunt them aside. I was on a phone call with you a couple of days ago about opening up America, and you mentioned that you had been contacted by people across the country. Can you share with us some of the sentiments that you're hearing from people across this country? Well, the disparagement of these people is very troubling to me because these are just concerned Americans. They're patriotic Americans. They want to get back to work. They want America to work. And they are concerned not just about their jobs, Alan, but this started right before Easter weekend. Remember where the government was basically telling people they would put them in jail if they dared attend a church service or some service where even if they were going to social distance, that was not allowed. And as you know, religious freedom is one of the bulwarks of our...

constitutional protections in the First Amendment, the right of religious liberty. And so it was people of faith. It was people who are kind of libertarian-leaning, like me, who just felt like the government was trampling on their rights. A lot of the people were business owners, Ellen, that run stores or run small businesses that were going to fail if they couldn't get revenues and customers in their door. And so the idea, the left was basically so antagonistic to these people, saying they don't even have a right to protest.

Now, a lot of people protest about things I don't agree with, but I would defend to the death their right to protest. I mean, that's a fundamental American right to have the right of assembly, a peaceful assembly, and to have your grievances against government told. But the left basically said these are racist. These are people who are trying to kill people. They are all with Confederate flags and carrying guns. Now, look, if you get rallies, you know, you have hundreds of these rallies. You're talking about tens and tens of thousands of people who came to these.

you're going to get some bad apples at any kind of, you know, people, no, people shouldn't be waving the competitive flag and people, I don't think it's appropriate for people to bring guns to these things. I even told people, don't wear a Make America Great Again mega hat. Not because I don't like Donald Trump. I do love Donald Trump. But I said, if you're trying to persuade people, you don't want to antagonize them. And so, but I think those protesters, Alan, were quite effective. I think they really did change the debate. And I don't think it's mere coincidence that by these thousands of patriotic Americans who are concerned about the future of our country by taking it to the streets in a peaceful way.

I think really changed a lot of attitudes. And now we are seeing America open up too slowly, but at least we're starting to open up. I agree with you in terms of the long-term threat to our democracy with the demonizing of people who are expressing points of view that the news media doesn't agree with, that certain elected officials don't agree with. We've also seen a situation that even medical professionals have been taken down from platforms like YouTube because anyone who speaks against continuing the lockdown, they're trying to stifle those people.

And that's a very, very troubling thing to me and to the people who are going to listen to this podcast. One of the things that has become an issue, and I think it's going to continue to be an issue, is that Governor Newsom from California and Governor Cuomo and their other governors are determined to get the federal government to bail out their states in exchange for, I would guess, opening up their economy. I'm not sure about the second half of it, but they are making the demand. in terms of getting bailed out. What is the attitude of you and your group about bailing out what can be described as blue states?

Well, first of all, we have to stop spending money now. We've already spent $3 trillion, Alan, on all of these bailout programs and relief packages. And $3 trillion is enough. So we've already spent and borrowed $3 trillion. My line and the line of our group is stop the spending. You've done plenty of spending. I think, and Arthur Laffer agrees, that it's probably on the balance been negative for the economy, not positive. As you know, Alan, you and I have known each other a long time. I mean, government spending does not stimulate anything but government. It doesn't stimulate any kind of connectivity. And so this idea that somehow we're going to...

get the economy up and running by growing government is economics turned on its head. What we need to do is stop the spending and certainly not bail out blue states. I'm from a blue state. I'm from Illinois. And we have $50 billion pension deficits. We've known that for 25 years. And now Nancy Pelosi is opportunistically using this in a very cynical way.

this crisis, this health emergency, to spend money on things that have nothing to do with the pandemic. I mean, they've got in that latest bill, they've got money for the National Endowment for the Arts, environmental justice funds, bailouts of the Illinois pension plan. You know, what is this about? Isn't it supposed to be about helping people that have been disadvantaged by the crisis? Isn't it about, you know, dealing with the health issues? How in the world is, you know, giving a grant to the National Endowment for the Arts, how does that have anything to do with the pandemic? And so I do think there's a backlash, Alan. I think even some of my liberal friends think, you know, what is she doing? How dare she use a health emergency?

to advance a liberal agenda. That should be done through the normal process of debate. And she's always lost those debates, so they're using the crisis. And I do think we have to stop the spending right now, not a dime more. We can't even afford the spending that they've already allocated. And by the way, it hasn't been very smart. We're now paying people in 31 states more money to stay unemployed than to get a job.

As my friend Melanie Phillips said, the world has been turned over on its head. One of the flashpoints in terms of strategies and when we deal with opening up or locking or keeping the lockdown going is our schools. We have in New York, the governor has said that he's not sure if the schools will be able to open up in September. And I mean, all the literature I have read and I know people are reading a great deal, listening a great deal. about this virus, one of the things that we hear repeatedly is that children are not the main target. Matter of fact, they are rare targets of this virus. What do you make of this school, in a sense, shutdown mentality, and how would you answer those governors who are set on that policy?

Well, you're actually understating the case, Alan. There's been virtually no deaths of people under the age of 20. In fact, I've been telling my kids who are in their teens and early 20s, I'm like, you probably do want to contract coronavirus. That's how you get immunity. And I mean, seriously, I mean, people under the age of 25 are not at risk, period. I mean, you're probably more likely, if you're under 25, to get killed by...

crossing the street than dying from coronavirus. This is an old person's disease. It's a disease that very negatively affects people with emphysema, with diabetes, with Alzheimer's, with heart disease. Those are people we have done a terrible job of keeping safe. You're there in the New York area where you've seen the abysmal job that Governor Cuomo has done in terms of keeping people safe in nursing homes. I find it sad and also comical that Democrats around the country are saying, Andre Cuomo, he's the one we should run as our standard bearer. Don't Biden put Cuomo up. Cuomo? He's been the worst governor in America in terms of handling the crisis. So anyway, I think that...

We should never have shut down the schools in the first place. But now that we know way more about coronavirus than we did three months ago, it would be very crazy to keep kids from going to school this summer and this fall. And by the way, if you do that, the problem with keeping the schools shut is people can't go to work. And I have two people work for me that can't go to work if the kids can't go to school. They don't have anybody to watch their seven and eight year old kids. So that has a negative effect on the economy and the well-being of our kids. And so we should not allow that. We have to open up the schools in August and September.

Your committee to unleash prosperity was founded recently. And can you tell us what your strategy is to help bring about reopening America and how people can become part of the committee's activities? Well, first of all, thank you for asking. And first of all, one of our activities that's been really very popular is we put out a newsletter every morning called the prosperity hotline, which is really. Giving people, you can read it in five minutes, it's just four or five bullet points every morning about what's really happening with this crisis. Because, Alan, the media treatment of this and the way the media has scared the hell out of people has been shameful. And they're not giving people the real facts. And so it has been fake news. And so we're trying to give people the real statistics and data. And it's very consumable. It's very easy to understand about what's really happening around the country. And people want to get that, by the way. You can just go to the Committee to Unleash Prosperity website and you can sign up and it's free. Are you getting that, Alan, by the way? I am. It is an invaluable tool of...

Understanding what's really going on. Whoever is doing your daily briefings should be commended because you, in fact, look at America, give us real facts, not made up stuff. And also what's going on around the world, because there is a lot of positive movement, actually, like countries like Switzerland opening up a month earlier than they thought because the virus is not as dangerous. I learned about that through your newsletter. So we will, when we promote this podcast, we will also include information on how people can get it.

Yeah, and it's free. And thank you for saying that. By the way, it's mostly John funds handiwork. You know, John, he and I worked together for 10 years at The Wall Street Journal. He's a great reporter and others are involved in it. And so anyway, anyone wants it, it's free. But our basic three or four priorities right now.

Alan, our number one, get the economy up and running everywhere in the country. It's long overdue. I happen to think that we shouldn't have shut down our economy in the first place. We should have kept our nursing home safe and we should have kept our businesses safe, but we didn't need to shut down our $20 trillion economy. I think that will go down in history as one of the greatest mistakes in our nation's history. But we are where we are. We have to start reopening in a safe way, number one. Number two, we cannot keep spending money in the trillions of dollars like we have or we're going to bankrupt our country. Number three, we believe the best way to help workers and businesses is to suspend the payroll tax for the rest of the year that we give every worker in America, you and me and everyone listening to this show, a 7.5% increase in their paychecks each year.

week so that would provide uh more of an incentive for people to get back uh into the into the workforce and would also provide a seven half percent reduction in the uh in the cost of for employers to hire workers so it'll be very pro-work very pro-hiring and then finally we would like to see a liability shield against lawsuits for employers because, Alan, I've talked to hundreds of employers and just a small sample, but they all say, look, unless I feel like I can be protected from these lawsuits where someone gets sick on the job and then all of a sudden you get slapped with a four or five million lawsuit, they won't come back, they won't open up their businesses. So we have to provide at least for another nine months or so this kind of liability lawsuit so these vulture trial lawyers can't shut down our businesses. The president decided to stop funding going to the World Health Organization.

The lockdown crowd and the left-wing media attacked him for doing that. What do you think about that particular decision? And what do you think about the role of China has been in this pandemic? Well, I think the World Health Organization has fumbled this from the start. They have been a mouthpiece for China. And by the way, we know China has been the sinister character in all of this in terms of hiding from the rest of the world the severity of this pandemic and its contagiousness and its lethality. So I think that Donald Trump was absolutely right to pull us out of WHO. But we also need to, in my opinion, have sanctions or reparation payments from China to the United States for all of the damage they have caused because China was clearly the...

agent of this German warfare, whether they did it intentionally. And I actually don't think they did it intentionally. I think it was just incompetence by the Beijing government. Who would have ever thought a communist regime would be incompetent? But it doesn't really matter whether they did it intentionally or not. They need to pay us for the damage they've inflicted on us through their negligence.

that you thought that the lockdown was in fact the mistake to begin with. Recently, Dennis Prager wrote a column called the worldwide lockdown may be the greatest mistake in history. Do you want to talk a little bit more about why you think lockdown strategy was wrong? Do you agree with Prager that this is a historically significant event? Yeah, look, I know I'm in a minority opinion. I bet a lot of the people even listening to your Red Alert probably don't agree with me. But I think we'll know the facts much greater as months go on. And I do think a year from now, two, five years from now, people will look back and say, what the hell were they thinking? First of all, it just starts with this. You can't shut down an economy, period. End of argument. You can't do that. You impoverish your own people. You make them so poor that the cure becomes worse than the disease. So we knew back two months ago, Alan, we knew from other countries that this was a disease that mostly affects older people. We knew that it affected people who have other kinds of health problems.

We also knew, by the way, from history, we've known this for 500 years, that pandemics are urban diseases. We should have shut down New York. We should have shut down Detroit, New Orleans, Chicago. There were about 12 or 14 urban areas that account for about 95% of the deaths, right? Because that's where pandemics are spread, in areas where you have high population density. There was no reason to shut down Nebraska or Idaho or Sheboygan, Wisconsin, or even places in upstate New York didn't need to be shut down. And so what I'm saying is we could have, at one-tenth the cost, kept people safer by...

you know, keeping in quarantine the people who were very much at risk, but allowing the rest of our life to go on. And if we had done that, I think we could have saved literally, literally trillions of dollars, not just in the United States, but worldwide, maybe tens of trillions of dollars. And by the way, think of all the human misery and human suffering that are associated with the massive reduction in wealth and incomes and jobs that people have. You're going to see starvation in Africa. You're going to see in the United States, you already see this, you know, people in food lines, the Salvation Army trucks, because they've lost their jobs. And by the way, for liberals to say, oh, gee, you don't, all you care about is greed and profits. It's ridiculous. No.

I believe that the people who are being most hurt here are not people who are rich. I mean, rich people probably suffered a loss in income, but their lifestyle is not going to be changed. It's the people at the bottom of the income ladder. It's the middle class folks who are really suffering. And they are in great danger of negative health effects from being isolated, from losing their jobs. So I really don't even think it's a close call. I think that the cost of this have been orders of magnitude higher than the benefits. And I'm not saying we should just let life go on as it was. I'm saying we should have been smart and surgical.

about where we were devoting our national resources to keep people safe and the irony is we spent all this money we lost trillions of dollars and then you have like things like the nursing home scandal there in new york where thousands of people died because of government stupidity you know your newsletter uh one of the things that uh you highlight today but you've done it uh previously as well is the it appears to be i will call them games that are being played with the number of deaths that are attributable to the virus And Dr. Birx, she actually last week criticized the CDC, the Center for Disease Control, for overstating the number of deaths. And I believe the governor, a Democratic governor of Colorado, has also challenged those numbers and come up with fresh numbers in his state, which, of course, decreased by, I think, close to 25 percent the number of deaths attributed to the virus.

Are you as concerned as I am about an agency like the CDC not being an agency that you can trust during a pandemic? Well, of course I am. And the CDC, by the way, that's an agency that we've given $10 billion a year to for the last 25 years. It's a very well-funded $10 billion, not $10 million, $10 billion of funding. The reason we have a Center for Disease Control is to keep people safe during a pandemic and to try to mitigate pandemics. And what we find out is that if you look at their website over the last three or four years, they were involved in climate change issues, LGBTQ issues, all these kind of fashionable social issues that had nothing to do with preventing a pandemic. And so lo and behold, we have one of these once every 20-year pandemics, and the CDC is completely unprepared for it. Remember, they have the testing kits.

work remember that alan well that yeah yeah that incompetence by the cdc probably cost us hundreds of billions of dollars think of we wouldn't have had to shut down our economy probably if the CDC had not fallen down on the job. By the way, I don't understand people say, oh, I really trust government now more than before. It's like, how can you trust government more? This crisis was a result of the incompetence of our government officials. And what has been really frustrating as this has been going along is we're not getting information from our government about what's really happening. I mean, Korea was issuing better data about what was happening with coronavirus than our own US government was. They didn't tell people what the age profile was. They didn't tell people you were more likely to die of coronavirus if you were over the age of 80 than if you're under the age of 40.

You know, those kinds of things are important details. They didn't tell us where it was happening, why it was happening, how it was happening, who was getting sick. And I think we need much more transparency in our numbers. And you are right. There's no question that they have inflated the number of deaths because a lot of the people who have died.

had what's called comorbidity. They had other diseases like emphysema or diabetes or were in nursing homes where the average life expectancy in a nursing home during normal times is six months. So when someone's in a nursing home, they are going to die. And look, nobody wants to see someone die early. But when someone's 88 years old, that's a lot less tragic when they die than when someone's eight years old. And this was not something that affected young people. And yet the government never told us that.

You know, one of the countries that succeeded in fighting off the pandemic without destroying itself, its economy in itself, is Taiwan, which is a mere 80 miles from mainland China. And as you said, they focus their resources on those most vulnerable. And I think this might be the first time in history where we are quarantining the healthy rather than quarantining those who are sick or most in danger. It's mind boggling ridiculous. Steve, I want to thank you for sharing your views and also for fighting this extremely important battle. Is there any parting thoughts that you would like us to have?

Yeah, I'll end on an optimistic note, Alan. I do think that because we've had so many states open up, and this week, we're starting to see a lot of states open up their business and so on. I think that it's going to be a very terrible summer. We're not going to sugarcoat this. We're going to have 20% unemployment for several months now because of the dumb decisions that our government has made. But I do think by the end of the summer, we're going to start to see some semblance of recovery. And then I think things are going to be picking up in the fall. It's going to take many, many months to recover from this. But I think we are now, I can finally start to see a light at the end of the tunnel. And that's a very encouraging thing.

That is a great note to end on, Steve. As this battle continues, if you ever want to come and talk to our Secure America Now audience, please just let me know. We'd love to have you back. I look forward to that, and I look forward to seeing people in person. I'm kind of tired of doing these podcasts and streaming.

So do we. Let's bring the end of Zoom. Anyway, thank you very much. Thank you.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of CODE RED?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this CODE RED episode published?

This episode was published on May 27, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this CODE RED episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.