College funding is a crisis which often fails to make headlines

The government’s record on education funding is particularly woeful in respect of colleges, says Anne Murdoch, college leadership adviser at the Association of School and College Leaders.Pay erosion, teacher shortages and insufficiency of government funding have had a calamitous impact on schools in England and have triggered the current industrial dispute .But what often fails to make headlines is the damage caused by these same pressures on the nation’s colleges and the effect of this on beleaguered workforces and the many thousands of young people in this vital sector.The current funding position for colleges, less, in real terms, than it was 10 years ago, is simply not good enough for them to recruit and retain teachers.So far, Education Secretary Gillian Keegan has not addressed these problems, just as she refuses to compromise over the government’s widely criticised plans for post-16 qualifications reform.COLLEGE FUNDINGCollege funding over the past decade or so has been nothing short of bleak.Analysis by the Institute for Fiscal Studies says that between 2010 to 2020, spending per student aged 16–18 fell by 14% in real terms.Even with additional funding announced by the government in the 2019 and 2021 spending reviews, college spending per pupil in 2024–25 will still be around 5% below 2010 levels.Furthermore, there was no extra funding announced in the 2022 Autumn Statement to help colleges cope with larger-than-expected cost increases.COLLEGE TEACHER PAY GAPIn March, the Institute for Fiscal Studies published a report on college teacher pay.It found that, even though school teachers’ pay is falling in real terms, the disparity between school and college teachers’ pay has continued to grow.Between 2010–11 and 2022–23, the median salary for a school teacher has fallen by 14%, while the median salary for a college teacher has fallen by 19%.The gap in median salary between school and college teachers is now over £7,000 and, depending on the outcome of the current school teachers’ dispute, could become even wider.None of this is to undermine the challenges faced by schools. Teachers in all areas of education deserve better pay. But it does illustrate that the arguments being made about pay and funding apply just as strongly to the college sector.RECLASSIFICATION OF COLLEGESThe Office for National Statistics reclassification of colleges to the public sector in January was an ideal opportunity for the government to improve the funding and pay for colleges.Instead, it failed even to address the inequalities around VAT for colleges and bought in rules to make it more difficult for colleges to take out loans. Colleges cannot now take out new loans without permission. Some colleges are now having to pay for advisors to negotiate with the government over loans, reducing cash levels even further.THE CASE FOR POST-16 AND SKILLSThe Department for Education’s plan to withdraw funding from tried and tested Applied General Qualifications, such as BTECs, before there is sufficient time for the evaluation and rollout of T-levels, is causing further difficulties for colleges when the numbers taking T-levels are still low.The House of Commons Education Select Committee said in a recent report that rushing ahead with reforms to post-16 qualifications risks leaving young people stranded without suitable qualification pathways and worsening worker shortages in key sectors.The report echoes many of the concerns raised by ASCL and other supporters of the #Protect Student Choice campaign. It urges the DfE to place a moratorium on the withdrawal of funding for AGQs until there is robust evidence that T-levels are demonstrably more effective at helping students’ progress, meeting industry needs and promoting social mobility.The committee found that withdrawing funding for many AGQs prematurely risks restricting student choice and narrowing progression opportunities. This, in turn, could lead to an increase in the number of young peo...