This is an iHeartPuckist, guaranteed human. I know it's got the nation talking. A lot of issues now are emerging, as it relates to this case called the Cornell 7. Now, one thing that did emerge from yesterday, which has got a lot of people angry, is one of the Cornell University frat brothers that emerged at the center of this explosive charge of gang rape in this girl, has now battling back with his own lawsuit, claiming that he was too wasted to consent to sex, and claiming that he was the victim. I know that has angered many, and a lot of people on the front lines of this case.
Now, we have one other part of the story that's come out, more than a thousand protesters furious, marching on Cornell University's campus, in support of the woman, allegedly gang raped in a fraternity, demanding the resignation of the school's president. There are a lot of other things that are emerging in this case that are making it very, very problematic, not the least of which is LaTisha James, appointed by Kathy Hochl, the governor, to be the lead on this. The problem is LaTisha James has already come out with an opinion in this case, and she is on the side of this Jane Doe, this alleged victim in this case, saying her heart goes out to the victim. Here's what she said.
So let me just say my heart goes out to the victim, the survivor, and I stand with her, and all individuals who unfortunately have been the victims of sexual assault. And my job is to ensure that the rights of students, and that the rights of survivors, and that all individuals on campuses, all throughout the state of New York are safe. Now, LaTisha James is not the only New York political that has involved herself. AOC has commented on the Cornell rape case, quote, seven men, Lord a woman into a frat house, drugged her, gang raped her for seven hours. And, you know, again, part of this then goes to the issue of tainting a jury pool, because this is making big news, not only in New York, but all over the country.
Listen. Just about two years ago, seven men, drugged and gang raped a 20 year old woman. They lured her in to a fraternity house. They drugged her with ketamine. They then posted to a group chat that she was incapacitated.
And seven men took turns, gang raping her for seven hours. What always bothers me in this case now, you know, from what I'm reading and the comments and the conduct of kids at what's supposed to be an Ivy League institution or repulsive to me all across the board, especially the kids in this frat house. What I'm urging most people to do is what we always do on the show. And that is don't rush the judgment. David Shown, former council president Trump, civil liberties attorney, Brian Claypool, veteran trial attorney here to discuss this.
David will start with you. I think that it's case closed on the issue of LaTisha James. She shouldn't be involved in the case. I don't know what to think overall. I just find the conduct of so many involved in this repugnant.
But I think this is happening too often in too many college campuses, but that's my own personal opinion. What are your thoughts? Yeah, there's no question about any of that. I think maybe the most important thing you've said, which you've been true to your entire career, is that we have to keep an open mind. And that's where the LaTisha James factor has no business in this case.
I mean, she has her own checkered past. But beyond that, she's already said, what the victims forced to endure is horrific, unacceptable, we stand with you. These are folks who have not been charged criminally. Case closed clear in New York, it's especially agreed for a prosecutor to make these kind of comments when the people haven't been charged. 1989 case, matter of death of manners.
U.S. vs. Smith 2013. So that's problematic. All right, we don't know what happened.
If you listen to the DA and the original complaint that the young woman made, he said that she never said she was drunk, she never said she didn't give consent, and so on, a very different story from the civil complaint. On the other hand, the civil complaint is very detailed. What you've said is 100% accurate that the text are terrible, the conduct is terrible, one way or the other, even with consent. But let me just close this important thing to remember. On the question of consent, consent is a defense to rape.
And it can still be under 130.10 for the season one of New York, in law. It's still an affirmative defense. If the person has no reason to believe that the other party wasn't capable. So what the law says 130.05 is incapable of giving consent. If you're physically helpless or mentally incapacitated, which means unconscious, unable to communicate, your uncleaness could be asleep, or if somebody slipped your Mickey, something like that.
According to the statement, she gave to the DA originally, at least brought forth that statement. She wasn't in those conditions. And the idea that she was lured into a meeting with one or two of the boys doesn't appear to mesh with the facts, but none of us was there. So we don't know. And you're right, keep an open mind.
All right, let's get your take on this. And these alleged text messages of this Jane Doe to members of the frat house, both before and after the event, how problematic would that be in trying to get a guilty verdict in a court of law? Hey, Sean, great to be back with you. That's a great question. The starting point here is, and by the way, I've represented a lot of sexual assault victims over the years, especially in civil cases.
And now what I would do, Sean, is I try to generate evidence and then advocate for a criminal prosecution, right? But I will tell you firsthand, that I have in many cases where there has not been a criminal prosecution, yet there's a civil case standing, why? Because these cases almost always resolve based on credibility, right? It's what she said versus the Cornell seven said, right? So why is that important?
Because you always need to have what's called for operating evidence, right? Something in addition to just what she says, and they said, what do I mean by that? Let's look at her behavior after all this happened. A lot of people would think that if somebody has been raped, for example, they go into the ER of their hospital and they get what's called a rape treatment kit. If she had done that, and then there's some evidence of maybe abrasions in her vaginal area, or bruising on her body, that certainly would help promote a possible criminal prosecution, right?
What else? Disclosures, those are text messages. This investigation should be done more copious, and what do I mean by that? You've got to be looking at who she was messaging, who the frat brothers are messaging. Because what you usually find, Sean, is within a couple of weeks of something happening like this, that there are some types of admissions.
For example, she might have texted her sorority sister, a family member, maybe even a therapist, and maybe the frat brothers are texting their buddies, and maybe they're saying something incriminating. We've got to do a deep dive and find out whether there were any types of disclosures like that. But the last thing I want to say too, is like with Dave saying, Sean, I'm telling you, there's a voluntary intoxication loophole law in place in New York, and that's not the fault of us. That's the fault of the house. The New York house has been sitting on this law for six years, to eliminate it.
What that means is she can't argue if there's an indictment, and trial, she cannot argue that I was stoned. I was too intoxicated to consent. She can't argue that unless she could prove somebody forced her to take the alcohol and drugs. Well, I mean, it seems like, if you go by the things that were told or said in these text messages, David Shown, it seems like there might have been a consensual part of this, and then you have this mass napchat that goes out to these fraternity brothers. And at that point, things take a turn dramatically for the worse, and it speaks horribly to the character, I think, of these kids that are in this fraternity.
Am I wrong on that? No, I think you're 100% right. That's the way one would read this case, trying to reconcile with what she said to the DA, and what she reportedly said to the DA. And the fact that we have so far, there's some suggestion she consented to a threesome at some point according to the DA, she said she was physically attracted to one of them, and her drunken curiosity led her to agree to the other. But yes, there's no reason to believe that she consented to seven or eight people, whatever it is, having sex with her.
But again, we weren't there, we don't know. We're gonna have to look at all of the evidence. I think the case could turn on the text messages. These are horrible text messages among these punks at the fraternity saying, I don't need to repeat what they say, it's in the complaint. These are terrible kinds of things.
So much of this stuff starts at home. Who raised these kids to be like this, and who doesn't monitor them? But I think one of the reasons, the civil suit is filed, I think it's very strong likelihood. Cornell will settle. Cornell, it looks terrible at a couple of the boys, right in F.A.
So now you have people demonstrating so on as if they know the facts, and they don't. But that kind of things brings pressure on Cornell. Cornell is coming off having this Hassan Piker on campus recently with saying horrible anti-American things, anti-Semitic. Oh, they were chanting not once, but a couple of times from the river to the sea at the event you're talking about. Exactly.
Well, I mean, if you were to look at this case and the fact that what investigators knew and were presented with at the time, what should their actions have been in your view? I think the investigators did what they thought was appropriate. There's a suggestion, there should have been an independent investigation by the DA, maybe two months reliance on the Cornell police. Maybe there's an inherent interest in college police in shutting things down and not having a lot of publicity. I think that's the most legitimate complaint.
It wasn't a bigger outside investigation. On the other hand, if you believe what the DA and the local police say, there was no reason for that, based on the young woman's own statements at the time. Apparently her friends told her to go to the police. She did that and based on her own statements. Unfortunately, these cases were both ways.
Brian is right. There are many victims of sexual assault criminal cases they're never brought. Maybe should have been, but he can prevail in the civil case. On the other hand, there are many false accusations out there. I represent one of them right now, a young man falsely accused in a rape case.
It's horrible, the damage it does on both sides. All right, quick break. We'll have more with David Schone, Brian Claypool on the other side than we'll get to your calls. The 80941 Sean, our number as we continue. Are you ready to get out of the media spin room?
Well, you've come to the right place. This is the Sean Hannity show. All right, I'll find moments with David Schone, Brian Claypool, this case is spiraling out of control. Everyone thinks that they have cracked the case and solved all the details of it.
We don't know all the details yet. We're doing what we always do on the show. We're not rushing to judgment. We're talking about the Cornell 7 case. We'll get to your calls coming up.
80941 Sean is our number. I mean, this is just hard. I think for a lot of people to wrap their heads around. And I'm watching, in one sense, it's reminiscent to the Duke lacrosse players. Should they have hired these dancers or strippers to come to their house?
No, they shouldn't have. Many of them left early. They were able to prove their innocence. But there was this massive rush to judgment. Brian, I'm beginning to sense that the public and commentators and news organizations and people with political agendas are moving quickly in that direction.
Yes, Sean, no question by and look, I have a single dad. I've got a daughter, the victim's age, right? I'm emotional about it. But what we all have to do is try to do what you said at the beginning of the show and what Dave's talking about. We need to have a detailed investigation, right?
We can't rush to judgment because sometimes, Sean, people like what these kids do at the front, it's important, right? But unfortunately, sometimes what people do this in moral, right, clearly immoral what they did. I was thinking about my daughter. She's there. I hope she would never be there.
But does that amount to whether it is illegal? And that's really what we have to be looking at here. And that's where you've got to be looking at the behavior of everybody after you've got to apply the law, Sean. That's what I think a lot of people are missing. My AOC comes out and says, oh, these guys getting raped her.
It doesn't look good, right? It's awful behavior. But when you look at the law that's existing in New York, right now, if you're the prosecutor, if I'm the prosecutor, you're a prosecutor, you should be just looking at one thing. And that is, will I be able to get a guilty verdict beyond a reasonable doubt in a criminal court? The question for LaTisha James is not, I feel bad for her.
We all feel bad for her, right? I do. You do. Dave does. But that's not the lens that you've got to be looking at.
What's the existing law, right? It's not favorable to rape victims in New York. And then what is the evidence that you plug in there? And can you get a guilty verdict? You can't be promoting a political agenda in a criminal court in an alleged gang rape case.
I'm just saying to my audience, there's too much we don't know about this case to come to any conclusion, except that the behavior, especially these kids in this frat house, were repugnant and awful and horrible. And I think too much of this type of behavior is going on on college drug use, alcohol use. It's like the 60s free love sex everywhere. And it's gone to mainstream. And this is it on steroids and human growth hormone.
I do hope that justice is ultimately served in this case. But I would urge people to withhold that judgment until we know all the facts in this case. But it is horrible on the surface for sure. Thank you both. Appreciate it, Clay.
Thank you, David. Thank you. Every Canadian deserves a place to call home. That's why we created Build Canada Homes. We're using new technology to build more efficiently, unlocking government land to build in more places, and cutting red tape to get more projects started.
We're building more affordable homes faster because a more affordable Canada is a stronger Canada. Learn more at Canada.ca slash building homes, a message from the government of Canada. You can't always get what you want, but you can get Sean Hannity online at Hannity.com. All right, Mark is next. Mark is in Massachusetts.
Mark, how are you? What did you think of the law that was signed by your governor, Governor Healy, that allows abortion up to the moment of birth? And why hasn't that been a bigger issue in the state of Massachusetts where you live? No, Massachusetts has become like Vermont, like Oregon, like Washington State. It's, you know, it's completely blue.
It's a nice thing. It sounds like it's midnight blue, but whatever. You know, between the mayor of Boston and the governor, you know, there's no difference between here, again, Oregon, Washington, California. They're all off their rockers. And the main reason I put a call in Sean is that, you know, the No King's concert?
Yeah. I pulled up some of the riders on the performers, bands like the Eagles and Bruce Springsteen, and the Foo Fighters, Madonna, and what they ask for before they do a performance. And they make the White House look like, you know, a blow-up folks home. I mean, you're talking about their, what's called the writer, which is what they want in their green room. Yeah, it's, for example, Madonna wants her dressing room to be draped in custom fabric, centered with lilies and white roses.
And she requests that her rooms for her children be furnished with identical pieces from her home to provide a seamless transition. Bruce Springsteen, he needs, and I can only get pieces of this stuff, he needs 21 dressing room coaches, and all 16 foot tall plants to create a right backstage environment, and he must have homemade chicken soup, heavy in the broth, and two 99 cent bags of rolled gold pretzels with zero substitutes.
And there must be a massage therapist and a nail, acrylic nail specialist on standby at all times. I could go on and on. I think we get the point, blue collar, Bruce is anything but blue collar, right? And what he was charging on his last tour was astronomical. If you wanted to buy tickets to go to a Bruce Springsteen concert, so, you know, I think he's just a phony liberal.
And, you know, none of these people mattered to me, to be very blunt. If they were gonna have an impact on the political process, the Donald Trump would not have been elected in 2024 because they were all coming out strongly against him. And the people will make their own decision. But, you know, whether or not they have some impact on the minds of some people, I don't know, but it didn't show up in 24. I'm hoping it doesn't show up this midterm year.
And, you know, but like all of us, they have freedom of speech, they can do what they want. I choose not to go to, I would never go to a No Kings concert, a Donna concert, a Springsteen concert. I have no interest in them. You know, people that are heavily political that perform, I have no interest in them at all. You know, I can't believe Madonna got away with, you know, I think an awful lot about blowing up the White House, nothing ever happened to her.
You know, we're Johnny Dept talking about, when's the last time an actor assassinated a president? But, you know, these are the times we're living in. Mark, appreciate your van, 800, 941, Sean, if you want to be a part of the program. Gary is in St. Gary, how are you?
Glad you called Sir. Hi, sir. How are you today? I'm good. Hang in there. What's going on?
The question I ask you is if it's frowned upon to stand outside of voting spaces and pay people to vote for particular groups. Why does the Democrats and the radical socialists throw out things and when they get elected, these things happen and now we have individuals that are on government subsidies, that all they do is live off that, keep voting for the party to keep them living. Look, the true story and history of socialism, stateism, communism, totalitarianism is always the same. You get these grand promises, you know, all of your anxiety in the world is going to be taken away.
Everything is going to be catered to you and guaranteed by your government. I'm Donnie recently described what socialism is, the government's role in providing every service, everything that people will need in the course of their lives. It's one problem. It's been tried. It's been tried over and over again.
It's been called many names. It's taken on many forms, many manifestations. You know, the current form is just called something different, but it is what it is, collectivism, communism, socialism, but guaranteed babysitters for date nine for mom and dad and guaranteed daycare and guaranteed health care and guaranteed government jobs and guaranteed government salaries and guaranteed government healthy food and health care and everything in between. And the problem is it's when you add it all up what they're promising, it's $212 trillion, we can't afford it. And the second thing is every time it's been tried, it's failed and those promises are never fulfilled.
And you end up, you know, when all said and done with more poverty, a loss of freedom. And then you have given and empowered all of these people that then become more oppressive and more oppressive and more oppressive and usually end up enriching themselves and not the people. So, you know, the most honest form of government is one that relies on a belief that rights come from God and governments instituted by men to protect the rights that are given them. And then there's something called liberty and freedom. And with liberty and freedom, you know, you then get to make your own decisions about your own life.
What I like to encourage everybody on this program to do is to take this gift of liberty and freedom and use it to find the God-given talent, find a way to make money, provide for yourself, provide for your family. And don't ever believe any government promise that they're gonna provide any government service. I would tell young people especially, don't think that social security is gonna be there for you when you retire, I'd say the odds are high that it's not gonna be. Even for older people at some point, I think they're gonna mean-stested, I think they're gonna cut benefits back because it's headed towards insolvency. Medicare, you know, we've learned nothing.
The government fraud, waste, abuse, I mean, it is rampant. They don't run anything well. They can't even run the post office well. So, it's frustrating to me that the government that has ruined schools, the government that can provide law and order and safety and security in many places in this country, the government that raided the Social Security Lockbox, the government that gave you Obamacare and that broke every promise of Obamacare is now promising everything's gonna be handled and taken care of and we're just gonna confiscate, if you empower us, steal this group of people's money and give it to you. And I guess that's appealing to some people, it's not appealing to me.
What's appealing to me is that I am the master of my own destiny and that I wanna find the reason that God put me on this earth and I wanna work hard and I wanna provide for my own family. And I think you get a sense of personal satisfaction, confidence that comes with that that's incalculable. I hope that answers your question. Let's say hi to Bill in New Jersey, Bill, how are you? Good, how you doing, Sean?
I'm good, what's going on? Well, the one reason I called it to talk about the communism, back before the Soviet Union collapsed, I went into the Soviet Union but before I did that, I was in France, pointing out a picture for food and they brought me something I didn't like. So I had a little pit stop, so I decided I wanted to go to Germany. I go to Germany, I wanna go to Berlin. In order to go to Berlin, I needed a visa to get to Berlin to go through East Germany.
So I get into Berlin, which is West Berlin, it's the middle of East Germany and there's all these deserters, they're Soviet deserters and they're trying to exchange their money at the exchange. They couldn't do it, so their money was worthless. So what we did is we bought their money seven to one so they could eat and then we literally got in the car, drove through Checkpoint Charlie, made a right instead of a left and went into the Soviet Union deeper. And because we had that little passport, I mean, not passport because I had the little visa stamp on there, they would stop at the Checkpoint and we did act all happy and they let us go, right? So anyway, when we got to these towns, the towns had giant monuments that said, to the end of fascism in seven languages and the stores were empty.
This one town had this store with electronic stuff in it, right? And the electronic stuff was behind glass and everybody was walking through like children looking at it, wishing they could get it. I bought some of it, it was bubble gum machine garbage, right? And the people were very nice, but they had absolutely nothing. They couldn't even afford soap.
So by the time I was in that store buying that stuff, I was gagging, I let them know it. I had to get out of there because I couldn't stand being around all the people that smelled so bad, but out in the street, it didn't matter. But what I thought of myself at that point is, this reminds me of the Democratic Party and their Communist housing they put in from the 30s through the 60s in America. And every American should be stuck here for a week so they can see what communism is. And the truth is, it will never work.
And that's with the poor countries, because those countries had nothing. The Russians stole everything from them. The people were very nice, but they were like little children wandering and stuff, you know, just seeing that garbage behind the glass, and they couldn't have something that they want someday, and they couldn't even afford it. You know, and it was the best experience I could say that I could have had in the late 80s. Because...
Well, let me say this to back up what you're saying. I have met people that lived in the former Soviet block countries, former Soviet Union, people that have made the perilous journey from Cuba to America and have been fortunate to live here. Many of them live in South Florida and Miami that I've met, and I've been there, I've broadcast from that community, the Cuban American community, they're wonderful people. And they will all tell you the same thing. It is hell.
And that every promise made was never kept, and they lived in poverty. And the government was so oppressive that, you know, they ruined the lives of so many. Never mind how many lives were stolen. Last century alone, you know, China, Mao, Stalin, Russia, Hitler, Mussolini, Poggio, Japan, pole-pot, the killing fields, over 100 million souls are dead, in the name of some ism. I can't even believe that this is where this country is now, that you have people advocating, making the same promises historically that have been made, that will never be fulfilled, and people are buying it.
And it's up to us to prevent them from getting power. And that's gonna happen in 28 days. You get to determine the outcome, meaning you collectively in this audience. And I hope you choose wisely. And Hannity, the busiest man in media, right here for you three hours a day, bringing you information that no one else will.
Lock it and leave it. It is the Sean Hannity Show. All right, that's gonna wrap things up for today. Hannity tonight, nine Eastern on the Fox News Channel. We are loaded up.
We've got the great one, Mark Levin, Jim Jordan, Jack Smith, How Deep of Political and Legal Trouble is Ian. Brianna Lyman, Tommy, Larry, Jason Chaffetz, Satan DVR tonight, Hannity on Fox. We'll see you tonight back here tomorrow. Thank you for making the show possible.