Costume or Uniform
from The Paul Truesdell Podcast Hosted by Paul Grant Truesdell, JD., AIF, CLU, ChFC
Costume or Uniform When a chief executive dresses like a rock star, look harder at the books. Most people who have worked for a living have sized someone up by what they wore into the room. Those of us at or near retirement have been doing it for forty or fifty years, at job interviews, loan closings, board meetings, and funerals. This is a conversation between you and me about what a chief executive's clothes can tell you about the company you own. It isn't about fashion. It's about signals, and it matters to anyone with a retirement account, because Nvidia sits inside nearly every index fund in America, whether the owner chose it or not. A Search Nobody Planned On Thursday, November twelfth, Nvidia announced that Jensen Huang had resigned. He co-founded the company in 1993, in a Denny's restaurant in San Jose, California, and he was the sole chief executive it ever had, thirty-three years in the job. The board named its chief financial officer, Colette Kress, as interim chief executive, named the first board chair in the company's history, and said it would consider both internal and external candidates for the permanent job. I've always believed you should dress for the job you want, so if they're taking outside applications, consider this my new look. Here's what happened, in brief. In late October, The New York Times reported that American intelligence agencies believe a Chinese citizen named Alice Huang, no relation to him, had grown close to him while gathering information for Beijing. On November eighth he admitted to an affair. On Wednesday the Times reported a second relationship, with a senior executive who reported directly to him. The board met late into the night, and by Thursday morning he was gone. It was hard-hitting, investigative reporting, and it moved faster than the board did. Hours after the resignation, Reuters reported a third relationship, with another Nvidia employee. China denies the spying allegations, and so far nobody has been charged with a crime. The money and the spying deserve their own conversation, and they'll get one. Today I want to talk with you about the jacket. What a Signal Is Worth Economists have a name for what clothes do in business. They call it signaling theory, and it grew out of work by the economist Michael Spence, who shared the Nobel Prize in economics in 2001 for it. The academic setting is a condition called information asymmetry, which means one side of a deal knows a great deal more than the other. In plain terms, when you know less than the person across the table, you look for clues, and the person across the table knows you're looking. A college diploma is a signal to an employer. A marble lobby is a signal to a bank depositor. A uniform is a signal too. The trouble is that some signals are expensive to fake and some are cheap. An audited balance sheet, signed by an outside accounting firm that can be sued if it's wrong, is expensive to fake. A black turtleneck costs a few hundred dollars. The economists call the first kind a costly signal and the second kind cheap talk. Keep those two ideas in your pocket, because every story I'm about to tell you turns on the difference. Three Founders and Their Uniforms Let's go back to Steve Jobs. For most of his second run at Apple he wore the same outfit: a black mock turtleneck made for him by a Japanese designer, blue jeans, and gray New Balance sneakers. According to his authorized biography, he kept roughly a hundred of those turtlenecks in his closet. Here's the part that matters. Jobs had already built the Apple II, the Macintosh, and the iPod before the turtleneck became famous. The results came first, and the uniform came second. Mark Zuckerberg went with a gray T-shirt and a hooded sweatshirt. In May 2012, when Facebook was pitching its first public stock offering to Wall Street investors, he showed up to the meetings in the hoodie, and a well-known stock analyst said publicly that it signaled immaturity. Zuckerberg's own explanation, given at a public question-and-answer session a couple of years later, was that he wanted to make as few decisions as possible. Then there's Jensen Huang and the black leather jacket. Keynote after keynote, product launch after product launch, the jacket became as much a trademark as the green Nvidia logo. It gave him a prominence few executives ever reach, and crowds of developers greeted him with the kind of over-the-moon enthusiasm usually reserved for rock stars. If you think about it, all three were channeling the same message. I'm hip, I'm cool, I don't need a suit and tie or a long-sleeve dress shirt, and I don't need your approval. That message plays well on a stage. It plays less well in a boardroom, where somebody is supposed to be watching the store. A Turtleneck and a Borrowed Voice Now let's look at Elizabeth Holmes. She dropped out of Stanford at nineteen to found a company called Theranos, which claimed it could run a long list of medical tests from a few drops of blood out of a fingertip. She wore the black turtleneck, and she wore it on purpose. She was openly channeling Steve Jobs and selling herself as the next one. She borrowed something else, too. During the Obama years, a speech fashion spread among young women in this country, a low, creaky way of talking that linguists call vocal fry. It was common enough in public radio that a Minnesota Public Radio news blog joked about an epidemic. In 2014, a team of researchers from Duke University and the University of Miami found that young women who spoke that way were judged less competent, less trustworthy, and less hirable. Holmes took the low register further, to a deep baritone. Here's something most people probably haven't seen: former colleagues, and John Carreyrou, the Wall Street Journal reporter who exposed the company, said the voice was put on, and that she occasionally slipped back into a higher, natural voice when she forgot. Looking back, it seems ludicrous, and it worked for years. What she built around herself was a who's who. The Theranos board included two former secretaries of state, Henry Kissinger and George Shultz; two former secretaries of defense, William Perry and James Mattis, who was a retired Marine general at the time; two former United States senators, Sam Nunn and Bill Frist; a retired Navy admiral, Gary Roughead; and a former chief executive of Wells Fargo, Richard Kovacevich. That may not be surprising, given how persuasive she was. What is surprising, and a concern, is how few people on that board had ever run a medical laboratory. The company was valued at roughly nine billion dollars at its peak. In January 2022 a federal jury convicted Holmes on four counts of fraud, and she was sentenced to more than eleven years in prison. The uniform, the voice, and the famous names were all signals, and every one of them was cheap. The costly signal, a laboratory test that worked, was the one she could not produce. When the Suits Changed Places I'm not saying Jensen Huang is Elizabeth Holmes. Nvidia makes real chips that real customers line up to buy, and Theranos made promises. What the two share is the costume, the founder who becomes the brand, and a board that defers to the brand. For a picture of what happens when business people stop knowing how to dress, let's go back to January 10, 2000. That morning, America Online announced it would buy Time Warner, in what was then the largest merger in history. Time Warner was the old establishment: Time magazine, Warner Brothers, HBO, CNN. AOL was the internet company that mailed free trial discs to every house in America. Everyone expected the internet people to show up looking casual. Instead, Steve Case of AOL came in a suit and tie and turned out to be the best-dressed man on the stage. Gerald Levin, the chairman of Time Warner, wore khakis, an open-collar shirt, and a sports coat, and he opened ...
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.